final version - Columbia University

@CBD5796 ^ MCG 1C9BD=39FKU @C=3; @b>3>3F7^R57=3X 6:PS9_BD9©U803F76D5K=3X [©M42S5K=A@b6D5KM=
UD574T>SF7^![©MF7FK9[6:57=3X@FK@CBDXC9
6:M ;35 9©B8UD9?[©FK@CUDU857JA[©@b6:57M= 6c@bU21 U 5KU =3MC6 F75d1b9©F7^!6:M 2H9?@CU UD0S[©[©9UDU GI03F @bUT@§4¤MBD9
MCG:1C9BD=39FKU
@b>3>3BDM@C[cPU-A5K= ¥ P357[cP?>3BD57MB 1 =3M ¥ FK9;3X9 MCG]@ >3@CB86D5K[©0SFE@CB 1C9©B8=39©F ¢U B89©FK9 b@C=3[©9 X0S5K;39U
;357BD9©[6:9;
¡
576DUV5K=3[FK03U85KM=_57=_6:P396:BD@C5K=S5K=3XU896
U803XX9U86 6:PA@b66DP39 1C9©B8=39©F¤¥ 9©5KXCP 6DUN@bUDUD57X=39;T2L^¤@C=DR C £4T96:P3MR; 4 @^
%Z03BBD9©U803F76DUN@bFKUDM
¢¤[03F76"6:M 57=L6:9©B8>3BD96 ¡¡ £ > `HL> - 5 6Z57U [©F79@CB"6:PA@ 6@ F7M ¥ ¥ 9©57XPL64T@ ^ 9[6 6:M$4T57UDU85K=3X ;A@b6:@
5KU4¤MBD9
6-6DPA@b69-39¦C9©= ¥ PS9©= U8M4¤9$U 6:B803[6D03BD9$;A@b6:@ 57UV=3MC6">3B89©UD9=L6 -H@C= /P!R [©M4 235K=A@ 6:5KMC= MCG
UD0SXX9©U
5K=3U80 ¢¤[©579©=L66:BD@C5K=S5K=3X";A@b6:@ ¡ N P 03U8-RFK@CBDXC9©B ;A@b6c@-UD96DU%4T57XPL6]2H9©=S9J36GIB8M4 ¥N95KXPL6D9©;
6:57=3XZ@b=3;
¥ PS9©=6:PS9©BD9N5KU]U80 ¢¤[©579©=L6%;A@b6:@-6:M BD9©F75E@C2SF7^9U86:574 @ 6:9 1C9©B8=39©F ¥N95KXPL6:U¦¡e F 6:9BD=A@L/
[©MC4235K=3@b6:57M=
9F7^$- ¥N94¤5KXPL6VXCBDM03>_4 03F76D5K>3F79-6c@bU21 U"@C=3;?;A@b6:@CUD96:UW6:M 4¤MBD9 BD9©F75E@C2SF7^¤9©U 6:5K4T@b6D9Z@ UD57=3XFK9
6:5
MCG 6:P39 ¥ 9©57XPL6:U"M='1C9©B8=39©F7U ¢ ©C9©23@CB:@- }b~~ #2 ¤ ¡
UD96D6D5K=3X
=L^ 94T>357BD57[@CF"U86D03;S^ =39[©9©U8U:@CB85KF ^ FK9©@ 9©U?U8M4T9§Q 039U86D5KM=3U?03=3@C=3U ¥ 9©B89©; I M=S9§[©M03F7;
e
b@CB85K96 ^ MCG"4¤M1;35 JA[@ 6:5KMC=3U9-9 4R6:9©=SUD5KMC=3UTMCB @C;3;35 6:57M=A@CF 9041>H9©BD574T9=L6:U 6:M @C;S; 6DM
5K4T@CX57=39T@
GIMC03B ¥N9";39©U8[©B85K2H9©;T@C2 M C9 ¡ N P39UD9 57=3[©F703;39.-GIMB%904S@C4¤>3FK9.- 5K= 9U86:57XL@b6D5K=3X;35 9BD9= 6 6 ^R> 9U
6:PS9
@FK@CBDX9BW= 0342H9©B MCG 1C9BD=39FKU8-H4¤MR;357G ^R5K=SXa6:PS9 /QP!R.BD9X03FE@bBD5dc©@b6:57M= >A@bB:@C4¤96D9©B9-1U8^RU86D9©4/
MB
M03FK;TFK5Z1C9©F ^2H9-4¤MB89"57=SGIMB84 @b6D5 C9W6:PA@C=¤MC6DP39©B8U9- ¥N9-2 9FK5K9 9 6:PA@ 6 MC03B >SBD5K4T@CB ^4¤9©UDUD@CX9
¥
5K=A@CB 6:57[©03FK@CB [@CU895-6:PS9 UD5Zc©9TMCGW6:PS9 4 @bBDX57=!;SM19U=3MC6a[©MB8BD9FE@b6D9 ¥ 9©FKF
03B86DP39©B84TMCBD95-O5K=!6:P357U
576DP?M>S6:574 @bF X9=39©BD@CFK5Zc@b6D5KM= >H9©B GIMBD4T@C=3[9 ¡
¥
576DPBD9UD>H9©[66DM >3B8MC6:95K=[FE@CU8UD57J3[@b6D5KM=U-H576-5KU-> 9BDPA@b>3UZ=3MC6ZUD03B8>3BD57UD5K=SXT6:P3@b6U86DBD03[6:03B89
¡
039©=3[9@C=S; U 6:BD0S[6:0SBD9$4T57XPL6V2 9 b@CF70A@C23F79 ¡
UD9Q
P39NF7M ¥N9BO>H9©B GIMBD4T@C=3[9 MCG16:P39 ¥ 9©5KXCP 6D9©; 9BD574T9= 6DU
03=3[cP3@C=3X9; ¡ 03B 6:P39BV9041>H9©BD574T9=L6:U ¥NMC03FK;?4¤MBD9Z>SBD9©[5KU89©F7^ ;39J3=39$6DP39UD5 6:0A@ 6:5KMC=3UW5K= ¥ PS5K[cP