final version - Columbia University

` % 6:9©B84|@bFKM=3X-6:P357U>A@b6DPU- ¥ 9VFKMRM$1GIMB>3B8MC6:95K=3U]6DPA@b6@bBD9V@CU8UD57X=39©; 6DM 6:PA@ 66:9BD4 @b=3;
9@b[cP
6:M @b= ^TMCGd6DPA@b6N6D9©B84 ¢UN[cP357FK;3B89©= ¡ ¡ 9 [M=3U85K;39BN6:PA@ 6WUD0S[cPSBDMC6D9©5K=SUN4¤5KXPL6 2 9->3BDM>H9©B8F7^
=3MC6
6DM "-@C=3;+UDM ¥ 9 FE@b2 9F 6:PSMUD9 >SBDMC6D9©5K=SU @CU 80S=3[©9B86c@b5K= ¡ 5K=A@CF7F7^5-]@CF7F >SBDMC6D9©5K=SU
@CU8UD5KXC=39©;
=3Mb6 M=A@b6DP?GIB8M4 6:M 6:P39 B8M1MC6"@bBD9FE@b2 9FK9©;3FK9UG @CB 9041[©99©;3U$6:P39¤= 0342H9©B MCG
MB
6:5 C9%904S@C4¤>3FK9U ¡ MBd9£¢¤[©579©=3[^$- ¥N9B:@b=3;3M4¤F7^ UD9©F79©[6]@VU80323UD96]MbG16DP39=39©XL@ 6:5 C9904S@C4¤>3FK9U
>HMUD5
6DU @ U 6:BD57=3X@bU @ 9©[6:MB MCGV[©MC03=L6:U MbG @CFKF%>HMU8UD5K2SFK9¤UD0323U 6:B85K=3XUaMCG @?J419©; F79©=3XC6DP
BD9>3BD9UD9=
¡ N P39 4¤5KUD4T@b6D[cP)1b9©B8=39©FX9=39©BD@CFK5Zc©9©U 03>HM=§6:PS9¤U8> 9[6DBD034 1b9©BD=S9©F 2 ^5K=3[BD9©4¤9©=L6D5K=3X3-sGIMCB
¡
M2SUD9©B9; ¡ / FK9=3XC6:P_U 6:B85K=3X O ¡ / 4¤9©B S0-16DP39 [©MB8BD9UD>HM=3;357=3X [©M0S= 6-@CU ¥ 9©F7Fd@CUW6DP39[©M0S= 6DU
9@b[cP
¡ / 4¤9©B8U"6DPA@b6-;35 9©B GIBDMC46DP39 MC23UD9B 9; ¡ / 4¤9©B 2L^@ 6 4¤MU86¨% 4¤5KUD4T@b6D[cP39©U¦¡ \ = 6:P357U
MCG@bFKF
MB21]- ¥N9"03UD9-@ 4T57UD4T@b6:[cP U8> 9[6:B8034&1C9BD=39F¤¥ 5 6:P ¡ ¦ # @b=3; % ¦ ¡ N P39"J3=A@CFA4¤5KUD4T@b6D[cP
¥
9[6DMB PA@CU }C~£¢ ¦ C~ © ~~~ 235K=3U¦¡ N P39 4T57UD4T@b6:[cP_U8> 9[6DBD034 [©@C>S6D03BD9U"U89©Q 039=3[©9
UD>H9©[6:B8034
^5-N@C=S; PA@CU 2H9©9= UDP3M ¥ = 6:M+>3B8M 157;39 XCM1MR; >H9©B8GIMCBD4T@C=3[©9 5K= [FE@CU8UD5 G ^157=3X+/ % \
UD574T57FE@CB8576
9B8G @C4¤5KF75K9©U ¢ £d9UDFK57996-@CF ¡Z- }b~~ ¤ ¡
UD0S>
=3UDMbG @CB @CU @1C9BD=39FWGI03=3[6D5KM=+;S9JA=39U¤6DP39_UD574T57FE@CB8576 ^§2H96 ¥ 9©9= >A@b5KBDU MCG"M2 ¤89©[6:U8- 6:PS9
\
>SFE@C[9 6DM 2H9©X57= ;S9JA=357=3X @ >3B8MC6:95K=A@bBD5KU8M= @CFKXMCBD576DP34¤U ¡ R @C=L^ UD03[cP @CF7XMB8576:PS4TU 9 4S57U869-"57=3[©F703;357=3X a
}
B89©4T@C5K=S5K=3X ` %¢6:9BD4¤U9-]5 ¡9 ¡Z- 6:P39¤FK9©@bGW=SM1;39U MCGN6:P39¤BD94 @C57=35K=SXH9©[57JA[TMCGN6DP39
P357U¤>SBDMR[©9©;S03BD9_^R5K9FK;39; @6DMC6c@CFNMCG `:% 6:9BD4¤U I } ¤ 4¤MFK9[©03FK@CB GI03=3[6:57M=+6:9©B84TU8- }}
N
UDM 6:P3@b6V6:P39 BD@b6:57M MCG]>HMU8576:5 9U 6DM =39©XL@ 6:5 C9©U 5KUVMC=390/ 6:M./ M=39 ¡
¢¡¡ ¡£ !#¢¡ $
M BD9>3BD9UD9= 6 >3BDMb6:9©57= U89©Q 039=3[©9U9- ¥ 9!03UD9!6:P39 4¤5KUD4T@b6D[cP 1b9©BD=S9©F ¢ £d9©U8FK579!96 @CF ¡^- }C~~ ¤ ¡
N
P357U 1b9©B8=39©FpX9=39©BD@CFK5Zc©9©UV0S> M=?6:PS9$U85K4¤>3FK9B9-1UD>H9©[6DBD034 1b9©B8=39©F ¢ £p9UDF75K996-@CF ¡Z- }C~~L}¥¤ - ¥ PS5K[cP
N