final version - Columbia University

6:9 " GC~ ¢U U:@ ¥ 6:P39@b; 9= 6WMCGs6:PS9Z> 9BD[9©>S6DBDM=_@bFKXMB8576DP34 ¢ §"MU89©= 23FK@b6D69- " G " ¤ - ¥ P357[cP ¥N@CU
FE@
UD574T>3F757JA9; 4¤M1;39F MCG 6:PS9=39©03B8M= ¡ N P39 >H9©BD[9©>S6DBDM= ¥N@CU UD9©9=@CUVP3@ R57=3X XBD9©@b6 > Mb6:9©=L6D5E@CF
@
RH9©B 6 ¢ " ¤- " " ¤ U8P3M ¥N9; 576:U 6:PS9©MB896:57[@CF"FK574T5 6c@b6D5KM=SU ¡ YZ9[@C;39U
03=L6:57F
6:9©B8-]6:PS9_BD9©U89@CB8[cP [©M4¤403=35 6 ^!BD9©U8> MC=3;39©; ¥ 576DP O @bB86:5 JA[©5K@CF S=3903B:@CF =396 ¥ MBM1RUbOIe 6 6"U S -
FE@
6D5E@CF7F7^ > 9BD[9©>S6DBDM=3U [©@CUD[©@C;39©;j5K=L6DM§403F76D5KFK@ ^C9©B$=396 ¥ MBM1RU¦¡ \%BDMXB89©U8U ¥W@CU U8FKM ¥¢03=L6:5KF
9©U8UD9=
GIMCB ¥N@CBD; =S96 ¥ MB21 U_@C=S; 6:P39 2A@C[ 1 >3B8M>A@CXL@ 6:5KMC= 6:BD@C5K=S5K=3X!@CF7XMBD5 6:P34 ¢ ¡ 9©B82 MU8- " ¤ # ¤
GI9©9;/
9©BD9 ;357UD[M C9©B89©; ¡ N P39UD9 6:9©[cPS=35KQ 039U ¥ 9©B89T>HM>303FK@CBD5Zc©9;§5K=6:PS9¤9©@CBDF ^ " B~ ¢U ¢ § 034¤9©F7PA@CB86
¥
¡^- " B¥¤ ¡"e 6:6-UZU 6:5KF7FpUD0 9©B89©;§UD9 9B:@CF>SBDM23F79©4¤U9-H9¦C9©= ¥ 576DP2A@C[ 1 >3B8M>A@CX@b6:57M= ¡ N P39
96Z@CF
¥ 9©BD9 ;A@ 6c@ B89©>3B89©UD9=L6c@b6D5KM=U- [cP3M5K[9MCG =396 ¥NMBM1 6DM> MCFKMXC^5- =SM=/ [M= 9 4
>3B85K4T@CB8^?>3B8M23F79©4¤U
=SM=/ XCFKM2A@bF SVM>S6:574T5Zc@b6D5KM=@- @C=S;!M C9©B8JS6D6:57=3X ¡ N PSM03XP =3903B:@CF%=S96 ¥ MB21 Ua@CBD9 U 6:5KF7F]57=§03UD9.-
O
>SBDM23F79©4¤U];3BD@ ¥ = GIB8M4 4 @C=L^$JA9©F7;3U9-CUD03[cP¤@CU2S5KMF7MXC^ ¢UD9©9 6"M23F795- }b~~ # ¤ -b6D904R6
[©FK@CUDU857JA[©@b6:57M=
¢YZ034 @b5KU9- "H" B ¤ -S5K4T@CX9 B89©[MX=35 6:5KMC= ¢!%ZUD0S=A@ 96-@CF ¡^- "H" ¤ ¤ -3@C=S;A@CB 6:9;_2 ^
MCGOQ
6:9[cP3=35KQ 039 ¢P @C>3=S5d1]- "H" B ¤ ¡R 03[cP MCGV6DP39_@C>S> 9©@CFNMCGV6DP39?/P7R [©M4¤9©UaGIBDM4 576DU B89©F^/
6:PS9
9F7^ UD574T>3F79[©MC= C904!M>16:5K4¤5dc©@b6:57M= ¢ M ^R; @C=3;P @C=3;39= 2 9BDXP39.- }C~~ ¤ - ¥ PS5K[cP!2A@CFE@b=3[©9U
@b6D5
57=3[©F703;39@ XB89@b6D9©B b@CBD5796 ^ MCG]>SBDM23F79©4¤U ¡ N PS9©UD9$904R6D9©=3U85KM=3U"5K=S[©FK0S;39 6:PS9a@b235KF7576 ^ 6:M >H9©B /
6:M
¢YZB803[ 1C9BW96W@CF ¡^- "H" ¤-S/R[cP MFd1bM>SGp96V@CF ¡Z- ""H" ¤ -140SF76:5 / [FE@CU8U%[©FE@bUDUD5 JA[@ 6:5KMC=
GIMB84¢B89©XB89©U8UD5KMC=
¡ 9U86:MC=_@C=3; ¡ @b621 5K=3U8- "H" B ¤ -LGI9@b6D03BD9"UD9FK9©[6:57M= ¢ ¡ 9©U86DM= 96W@CF ¡Z- }b~~+ ¤ -R@C=3;T6DB:@C=SUD;303[6:57M=
¢
¡Z- "H" B - ©CML@b[cP35K4¤U9- ""H"- MF7FKM2H9©B 6 96a@CF ¡^- }C~~HG¥¤ - ¥ 576DP35K=§6DP39 /QP!R
¢`$@C4¤4¤9©BD4T@C=§96@CF
~
6 -A;30S9 6DM [^R[©F79©U"MCG]57BDBD@b6:57M=A@CFH9041032H9©BD@C=3[©9$GIMFKF7M ¥N9;_2 ^?M C9©BD[MBDB89©[6:5KMC= ¡
b@CBD579©;?>A@CU
P39 J39©FK;aMCGAe \ PA@C;a>3BDM4¤5KU89©;$XBD9©@b6OBD9©U803F76DU9- ¥ P35K[cP=S9¦9BUD99©4¤9©; 6DM-4T@b6D9©BD5K@CFK5Zc©9 ¡ N P39
N
6:PS9©5KBV>SBDM23F79©4¤UV[@C4¤9FE@bBDX9F7^¤6:P3B8M03XP357=3=35K=SXUMCG
FKMU8UVMCG 6:P39 [©FK@CUDU857JA9B ¥ 576DP 5 6:UV9041>H9©[6:9©; X9©=S9©B:@bFK5dc©@b6:57M= ¡
6:PS9$94T>S5KBD57[@CF
MC>303FE@bBD576 ^-MCGR6:P39 /P7R - BD9UD9©@CBD[cP39BDUOPA@ 9 UDM03XCP 6p6DM"9 4R6:9©=S; 576DUd;3M4T@C5K=
§-@bFKFK579©;Z2L^Z6DP39>
M>S6D5K4¤5dc©@b6:57M= ¡>%Z6DP39©B8UVPA@ 9 904R6D9©=3;39;§/P7R UV6:M U 6:BD0S[6:0SBD9©;