final version - Columbia University

9-[M C9©B6:P39 9= 6D5KB89 GI9©@CUD5723FK9VU8>A@C[9 ¡ ¡ 9";S5KUD[M 9©B89©;¤6:PA@b6 @U86:@C=3;A@bBD; /3R %)@CF7XMB8576:PS4 [©@C=
¥
@C57F36:M$BD9@b[cP_@C= MC>S6:574 @5K=¤BD9©@CUDMC=A@C23F79"6D5K4¤95- ;3039 6:Ma=3M=/ UD4¤M1MC6DP3=39UDU MCGs6:PS9-FK@b6:9= 6 RfaY
G
¤89[6D5 9.- @C=3; ¥ 9>3BDM R5K;39 @ U8MFK0S6D5KM=TGIMBN6:P3@b6V>3B8M23FK94 ¡]e U"@BD9UD03F 6 MCGp6:P39UD9$@C; b@C=3[9©U8-
M2
9_@CBD9T@C23F79¤6DM >3B8M 157;39T6DP39TJ3BDU86 5K4¤>3FK94T9=L6c@b6D5KM=§MCG /3R %GIMB$FE@b6D9©=L6Rba Y >SBDM23F79©4¤U ¡
¥
P39 U8MCG 6 ¥N@CBD9 57U ¥ B857686:9©= 5K= £¢¤¢ @C=3; 57Ua57= M$1b9©;+GIBDM4 MC03BR e N £de UDMCG 6 ¥N@CBD9 03UD57=3X
N
57= 6D9©B G @C[©9 ¡ 6:PS9*Rba¡
9$5K=L6DBDMR;303[©9;H9©=3;39=L6MCG36DP39 5K=3>3016O6DM 2H9 [FE@CU8UD57J39©;U-C@C=3;a6DP 03U
N
K0E5E`HL?5>¦¥ ¡ ¡ 9T5K=L6:B8M1;30S[©9 ;39> 9=3;39=3[©9?MCGV6DP39 [©MC4235K=3@b6:57M= ¥ 9©57XPL6:UMC= 6:P39T5K=3>3016
@CB89
?@HL?K0E 5E `HL?5>¦¥_[©M42S5K=A@b6D5KM=+MbG 1b9©BD=S9©FKU ¢ £p9 ¥ 5KU8- ©C9©23@CB:@-N@C=3; 6-M2SFK95-
UD>3@C[©9.-W[©B89@b6D5K=3X!@
2 ¤ ¡ N P357U =39¦¥ 6D9©[cP3=S5KQ 039 57U 5K=L6:9BD9©U 6:57=3X?2 9[@C03U89 5 6 5KU [@C>3@C23FK9 MCGNUDMF R5K=3X?>3B8M23FK94TU
}C~~C
9?03U80A@CF7F7^ 2 99©= 2 96D6D9©B 6:PA@b=+90415KU 6:5K=SX6:9©[cPS=35KQ 039U9- ¥ 5 6:P3MC0S6 6:P39_=S9©9©; GIMB>3@CB86D5K[©0SFE@CB
PA@
MCG 6:PS9a@bFKXMB8576DP34 ¡
6:0S=35K=3X
9¤[©MC=3;303[6:9©;+U89¦C9©B:@bF 94T>357BD57[@CFU 6:03;S5K9©U$03U85K=3X 1C9BD=39FN[©MC4235K=3@b6:57M=U-d5K=S[©FK0S;35K=3X?M=S9
¡
9 41> 9BD5K4¤9©=L6DU ¢ £d9¦¥ 57U9- ©C9©2A@CBD@- @C=3; 6-M23F795- }b~~ [ ¤ 6:PA@ 6 5KFKF703U86DB:@b6D9©U$6:PA@b6¤F79@CB8=35K=3X
UD96¤MCG
¥N95KXPL6:U R5K@ MC>S6:574T5Zc@b6D5KM=¤5KUV=3Mb6 @CF ¥N@^RU"U803>H9©BD57MBW6:M 0SUD5K=SXT@U85K4¤>3FK9
1C9BD=39Fp[©M42S5K=A@b6D5KM=
¥ 9©5KXCP 6D9©;![©M4 235K=A@ 6:5KMC= ¡ N P35KUZU 6:03;1^§5KUZ>3@CB86D5K[©0SFE@CB8F7^3B:@b[6:5 6:57M=39©B8UZ;30396DM
03=
6:574T9S0S6:9 6DP39 [M42357=A@b6D5KM= ¥N95KXPL6DU GIMBTFK@CBDXC9 ;A@ 6c@ U896:U?@b=3;
6:PS9
6DM 9B8GIMB84h6:PS9¤MC>S6:574T5Zc@b6D5KM= ¡ \ =
;3039
9041> 9BD574T9= 6DU9- 6:P39§0S= ¥ 9©57XPL6:9; [M42357=A@b6:57M= ¥N@CU_MCG 6D9©= @CU XCM1MR; @CU?@C= MC>S6:574T5Zc©9©;
M03B
¡ ¡ 9 ;357UD[©0SUDU?UDM4¤9§[@bUD9©U?57= ¥ PS5K[cP ¥N9!M23U89©B9©;)@C= @C; b@C=L6c@bX9GIMB 6:PS9
[©MC4235K=3@b6:57M=
B
6:9©=L67RfaY 4T5 416D03BD9$MCG ` @C03U8UD5E@b=3U 03U85K=3X @ 4TMCBD9 9FK9XL@C=L6-GIMCBD403FK@b6:57M=3BDMC23FK94 ¡
FE@
9V@CFKU8MZ;357UD[©M C9©B%@C=S; 9041>3FK57[@b6D9NU89¦9B:@CFS[@CU89©U6:P3@b6 ¥ 9©BD9VMC4T5 6D6:9;aGIB8M4 ©C9©2A@CBD@ ¢}b~~ #L@ ¤ -CU8M
¡
904157U86:57=3X 6D9©[cP3=357Q 039©U [©@C=3=3MC6UDMF 95- @CU 5KFKF703U86DB:@b6D9©; 5K= U ^1=L6DP396D5K[_;A@b6:@ 9041>H9©B85K4¤9©=L6:U¦¡
6:P3@b6
P 03UG @CB8-9©4¤>35KB85K[©@CF%BD9UD03F 6:U ¥ 5 6:Pe6 / C M= [M4T4¤M= 2 9=3[cP34T@CB21 U @C=3; BD9@bFN>3B8M23FK94TU
N