29.03.2013 Views

WP 5 Analysis of present IWRM practices - Brahmatwinn

WP 5 Analysis of present IWRM practices - Brahmatwinn

WP 5 Analysis of present IWRM practices - Brahmatwinn

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

This is the major reason why a trans-boundary water management does not exist in the Brahmaputra<br />

river basin.<br />

Comparison <strong>of</strong> selected macro-scale river basins Danube and Brahmaputra<br />

Issue Danube Brahmaputra<br />

Population Approx. 14 mio. Approx. 100 mio.<br />

Basin area 77.000 km 2 >500.000 km 2<br />

River structure Strongly human modified Natural river course<br />

floods Due to snow melt and precipitation Due to snow melt, precipitation and<br />

GLOFs<br />

droughts - In non-monsoon period<br />

Water quality Drinking water is strictly controlled Pollution problems, particularly in<br />

India (e.g. Arsen)<br />

Transboundary<br />

water<br />

management<br />

ICPDR as superior authority Only bilateral agreements<br />

Communication Good, in ICPDR re<strong>present</strong>atives <strong>of</strong> all<br />

riparian states close cooperating<br />

<strong>IWRM</strong> In progress (in form <strong>of</strong><br />

implementation <strong>of</strong> EU WFD)<br />

Coverage climate/<br />

discharge stations<br />

Good density for monitoring and<br />

projection, long time series since<br />

1900<br />

6<br />

Worst, high conflict potential between<br />

up- and downstream countries<br />

Has not yet started<br />

Poor coverage, especially in Tibet,<br />

limited data access (classified)<br />

Sanitary services Good coverage Poor coverage, particularly in rural<br />

areas and in respect to canalization<br />

and treatment, drinking water supply<br />

good in Bhutan, very poor in India<br />

Mayor water users 1. Public water supply<br />

2. Industrial water use<br />

3. Hydropower<br />

River linking<br />

projects<br />

Main- Danube channel to avoid<br />

water scarcity in northern Bavaria,<br />

well organized<br />

1. Agricultural water use<br />

2. Hydropower<br />

3. Public water supply<br />

Different water diversion plans within<br />

the countries (e.g. India and Tibet)<br />

without considering doubts and<br />

worries by neighbor states<br />

In brief overview both basins have a history in trans-boundary issues and disputes, but <strong>IWRM</strong> in the<br />

past has developed differently:

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!