24.10.2014 Views

My PhD thesis - Condensed Matter Theory - Imperial College London

My PhD thesis - Condensed Matter Theory - Imperial College London

My PhD thesis - Condensed Matter Theory - Imperial College London

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

CHAPTER 4.<br />

ERRORS IN QMC SIMULATIONS<br />

The Ewald interaction v E is the correct interaction to use for the Hartree energy, 6<br />

but not for the exchange-correlation energy. The reason for this is that the entire<br />

exchange-correlation hole (a total charge deficit of one electron) is contained within<br />

the simulation cell; there should be no images of the exchange-correlation hole.<br />

The Ewald interaction, which includes the effects of image charges, is therefore<br />

inappropriate for the calculation of U XC .<br />

4.2 Fixed-node errors<br />

After many time steps, the walkers in a conventional DMC simulation are distributed<br />

according to the fixed-node density Ψ T Ψ FN<br />

0 rather than the desired density Ψ T Ψ 0 .<br />

Any fixed-node estimate of the ground-state energy must be variational: E FN<br />

0 ≥<br />

E 0 . The equality holds only when the nodes are exact; while this may be achievable<br />

for a one-electron system, it is almost impossible in many-electron calculations.<br />

An indication of the difficulty in correctly guessing the nodal surface is the high<br />

dimensionality of that surface: (Nd − 1), for a system of N electrons moving in d<br />

dimensions. It is not possible to deduce the nodal surface from the condition that<br />

the wave function be zero when two electrons coincide: this defines a surface of only<br />

(N − 1)d dimensions.<br />

The fixed-node approximation is uncontrolled; the size of the error it introduces<br />

cannot be calculated analytically. It is not surprising that a great deal of time and<br />

effort has been devoted to overcoming this problem, with limited success.<br />

The release-node algorithm of Ceperley and Alder [12] uses separate populations<br />

of positive and negative walkers which are allowed to cross the nodes of the trial<br />

wave function. The problem with this method is that both walker populations grow<br />

geometrically in time, leading to exponentially-increasing statistical fluctuations;<br />

the method becomes a race to obtain convergence to the ground state before the<br />

6 Although the Hartree energy defined by equation (4.24) depends on the value of ξ, the total<br />

energy does not, because of the corresponding terms in the ion-ion energy. The exchange-correlation<br />

energy defined by the same equation does not depend on ξ.<br />

65

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!