Evaluation of Entry into Ice cream Business - BRAC University ...
Evaluation of Entry into Ice cream Business - BRAC University ...
Evaluation of Entry into Ice cream Business - BRAC University ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
“<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong><br />
<strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Unilever<br />
Bangladesh Limited”<br />
Submitted to<br />
Sharmin Shabnam Rahman<br />
Lecturer<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong> <strong>Business</strong> School<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong> <strong>University</strong><br />
Submitted by<br />
Md. Robin Miah<br />
Id# 06204032<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong> <strong>University</strong><br />
Date: 02-09-2010
September 2, 2010<br />
SHARMIN SHABNAM RAHMAN<br />
Lecture<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong> <strong>Business</strong> School<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong> <strong>University</strong><br />
Subject: Submission <strong>of</strong> Internship Report<br />
Dear Madam,<br />
This is to inform you that I am submitting the internship project report titled “<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />
<strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Unilever Bangladesh Limited” upon completion <strong>of</strong> my<br />
formal internship attachment period from May 06, 2010 to July 06, 2010 with Unilever<br />
Bangladesh Limited.<br />
I would like to thank you and show my gratitude for your support and guidance that you<br />
provided me during the preparation <strong>of</strong> this report. Without your help it would have been<br />
impossible for me to prepare this report. I would like also show my gratitude to my Company<br />
supervisor MD. Risalat Siddique, Brand Manager, UBL for his support during my internship<br />
period.<br />
I have tried to discuss all the relevant points <strong>of</strong> a feasibility study while keeping consistency with<br />
Unilever Bangladesh Limited’s information confidentiality policy.<br />
I would be glad to clarify any discrepancy that may arise or any clarification that you may<br />
require regarding my project and report.<br />
Sincerely,<br />
________________________<br />
MD. ROBIN MIAH<br />
ID#06204032<br />
<strong>BRAC</strong> <strong>University</strong>
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT<br />
I would like to show my sincere gratitude to Sharmin Shabnam Rahman, lecturer, <strong>BRAC</strong> <strong>University</strong>,<br />
and my Academic Internship Supervisor; for her constant supervision and guidance have been <strong>of</strong><br />
extreme help to me. I am also thankful for all the times I consulted her and she answered with the<br />
utmost patience and perseverance.<br />
I am thankful to Mr. Tanzeen Ferdous, Senior Brand Manager, Brands & Development, Unilever<br />
Bangladesh Limited, for entrusting me with such an important project and allowing me scope to work<br />
independently, providing all required supports.<br />
I am also grateful to Mr. Muhammad Risalat Siddique, Brand Manager, Unilever Bangladesh<br />
Limited and my Company Internship Supervisor, for his relentless support during each stage <strong>of</strong><br />
research and work. He supervised and corrected me during the entire research process.<br />
Last but no the least, I would like to thank Mr. Hamdan Kabeer, Brand Manager for Lipton, Unilever<br />
Bangladesh Limited for helping me in developing the construct <strong>of</strong> this report and providing me detail<br />
regarding Operating Methods for Foods <strong>of</strong> Unilever PLC.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited<br />
I
Executive Summary<br />
Unilever Bangladesh Limited (UBL) is a household name virtually for every Bangladeshi national.<br />
Being a multi-national, no other company has achieved this level <strong>of</strong> success. It is regarded as one <strong>of</strong><br />
the most reputed multi-cultural companies <strong>of</strong> the world. With its history <strong>of</strong> over 70 years globally, UBL,<br />
an operating and Brand building company <strong>of</strong> Unilever Group has predominantly served the<br />
Bangladeshi market with mainly Home and Personal Care (HPC) FMCG products for last 47 years<br />
with limited presence in the food business with Lipton tea. With dominant brands in HPC like Lux,<br />
Lifebuoy, Wheel and Pond’s, growing brands like Sunsilk, Clear and rising stars like Rexona and<br />
Dove’, the company now wants to check its possibilities in the foods category which globally is the<br />
largest business <strong>of</strong> Unilever (54% <strong>of</strong> total portfolio). With this intention in mind, the authorities <strong>of</strong> UBL<br />
in Brands & Development Department assigned the project “<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong><br />
<strong>Business</strong> for Unilever Bangladesh Limited”. This research was designated to be mainly qualitative<br />
in nature and to build on earlier researches done by UBL.<br />
To assess the feasibility <strong>of</strong> entering <strong>into</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> business, I combined primary sources like<br />
consumer and trade visits, and secondary sources like earlier research reports to understand market<br />
construct, market characteristics, and target consumer groups <strong>of</strong> the ice <strong>cream</strong> industry. Based on the<br />
collected data, and then assessed the entry prospect for UBL in this industry.<br />
<strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> industry <strong>of</strong> Bangladesh is estimated to have a size <strong>of</strong> BDT 220 Crore where BDT 131 Crore<br />
belongs to branded segment (BDT 121 Crore Common Format <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> that is distributed through<br />
retail and BDT 9.8 Crore in the boutique segment) and BDT 79 Crore is in the unbranded low qualitylow<br />
price segment. The industry is currently growing at a rate <strong>of</strong> 19%. The research excluded<br />
unbranded segment from discussion as global quality mandate <strong>of</strong> Unilever prohibits UBL from<br />
competing in that market.<br />
Branded common format is dominated by Igloo with more than 51% share with followers like Kwality<br />
and Polar where Milk Vita and Savoy are minnows. Boutique segment is competed by Club Gelato<br />
(20% share), MövenPick, Andrsen’s (3 outlets) and Gelateria Igloo (3 outlets). These three have<br />
around 17% share.<br />
The market is characterised by low competitive rivalry where Dhaka still contributes to more than 61%<br />
<strong>of</strong> total country’s sales. This is due to issues regarding electricity and requirement <strong>of</strong> cold distribution<br />
chain by the industry. There are still huge untapped areas <strong>of</strong> the country. However, the industry is<br />
extremely capital intensive and there are lots <strong>of</strong> entry barriers. Only manufacturers with large capital<br />
can invest and thus there has been no big player in the common format segment since Kwlaity (1999).<br />
Products or <strong>of</strong> quite high quality in the Bangladeshi market but price is still out <strong>of</strong> reach <strong>of</strong> rural and<br />
lower SEC people who belong to low disposable monthly income group. Distribution is mainly done<br />
through refrigerated trucks alongside use <strong>of</strong> carts in the country. Boutique format players serve at<br />
their premises, ice <strong>cream</strong> and other dessert items to <strong>of</strong>fset seasonality <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> sales. Promotion<br />
in the common format is mainly in newspapers and billboards along with trade based consumer<br />
promotions and trader schemes.<br />
Consumers <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> are mainly Urban kids in the age group <strong>of</strong> 5-14 who mainly consume normal<br />
sticks, cups, cones innovative fillers and water ice <strong>cream</strong>s; there is urban youth in the age group <strong>of</strong><br />
15-24 who consume premium and extrusion sticks and cones and urban mothers in the age group <strong>of</strong><br />
25-35 who are the decision makers for kids and family ice <strong>cream</strong> purchases. The consumers can be<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited<br />
II
segmented based on their desired satisfactions from ice <strong>cream</strong> occasion, portrayed personality traits<br />
<strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> bands and the occasions when they consume ice <strong>cream</strong>. Analysis shows there is scope<br />
for market development and penetration in the country. There is also scope for ice <strong>cream</strong>s that are<br />
health conscious and nutritional in the industry.<br />
Looking at the scenario <strong>of</strong> the Bangladeshi market, UBL is suggested to enter the industry in a grand<br />
way with tentative initial investment <strong>of</strong> BDT 45 Crore in manufacturing facility, cold distribution channel<br />
development and placing branded freezers at retail outlets. Expected brand is Wall’s, the regional ice<br />
<strong>cream</strong> brand <strong>of</strong> Unilever. Company is also suggested to enter in the boutique segment with<br />
Ben&Jerry’s the premium boutique brand <strong>of</strong> Unilever. Products should be differentiated and nutritional<br />
with the price range at par or higher than common format players and lower than the boutique format.<br />
Extensive promotion would be required and thus presence in television as ice <strong>cream</strong> is a brand that<br />
requires continuous innovation and hype around the brand.<br />
Expected outcome <strong>of</strong> the entry is to have sales <strong>of</strong> BDT 11 Crore with a market share <strong>of</strong> 10% in the<br />
first year. However, for the first three years company would have negative net pr<strong>of</strong>it and is expected<br />
to make a net pr<strong>of</strong>it <strong>of</strong> BDT 2.5 Crore with a gross slaes <strong>of</strong> BDT 38 Crore in the fifth year <strong>of</strong> business.<br />
Thus, Unilever can benefit from entering in this industry if they enter in a grand way. Obviously<br />
company has to balance the investment issues for the industry and also acquire necessary resource<br />
for ice <strong>cream</strong> as traditionally UBL is an HPC company. If they can address these issues tactfully they<br />
can do well leveraging their existing brand image.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited<br />
III
Table <strong>of</strong> Contents<br />
Topic Detail Pg. No<br />
1.0 Introduction<br />
1.1 Background <strong>of</strong> the Report 1<br />
1.2 Objectives 1<br />
1.3 Scope 2<br />
1.4 Methodology 2<br />
1.4.1 Primary Research 2<br />
1.4.2 Secondary Research 3<br />
1.5 Limitation 4<br />
2.0 Background <strong>of</strong> the Organization 5<br />
2.1 Global Unilever Group 5<br />
2.1.1 Home and Personal Care Divisions 5<br />
2.1.2 Foods Division 6<br />
2.2 History <strong>of</strong> Unilever 6<br />
2.2.1 Soap and Margarine Origins 6<br />
2.2.2 Surviving the Great Depression 7<br />
2.2.3 Post-war Era: Adapting to New Markets and Technology 7<br />
2.2.4 Restructuring and Major Acquisitions 7<br />
2.2.5 Twenty First Century Unilever 7<br />
2.2.6 Unilever <strong>of</strong> Today 8<br />
2.3 Unilever Bangladesh Limited (UBL) 8<br />
2.3.1 Manufacturing Facilities 9<br />
2.3.2 Employees 9<br />
2.3.3 Product Categories and Brands 9<br />
2.3.4 Brand Launches by Year 10<br />
2.3.5 Corporate Mission 11<br />
2.3.6 Corporate Social Responsibility 11<br />
2.3.7 Corporate Governance 11<br />
2.3.8 Organizational Structure 12<br />
2.3.9 Brands and Development Department 12<br />
3.0 Global <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Industry 15<br />
3.1 Overview 15<br />
3.2 Unilever <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> 15<br />
3.3 Regional <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> and Unilever 16<br />
3.3.1 <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Consumption 16<br />
3.3.2 India <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> and Unilever 16<br />
4.0 Bangladesh <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Industry 17<br />
4.1 Industry Construct 17<br />
4.1.1 Branded Market 17<br />
4.1.2 Unbranded Market 18<br />
4.2 Historical Progress <strong>of</strong> the Industry 18<br />
5.0 Market & Competition Analysis 20<br />
5.1 Market Description 20<br />
5.1.1 Market Characteristics <strong>of</strong> the Common Format Segment 20<br />
A. Market size 20<br />
B. Competitive rivalry in the Market 20<br />
C. Market Sales and Growth Rate 22<br />
D. Market Share and Size <strong>of</strong> the rivals 22<br />
E. Geographic Sales Orientation 23<br />
F. Seasonality <strong>of</strong> Sales 23<br />
G. Distribution/ Servicing System 24<br />
H. Technology and Innovation 26<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited<br />
IV
I. Production Capacity 26<br />
J. Products and Pricing 27<br />
K. Firms as Price Setters 28<br />
L. Promotion 28<br />
M. Players in the Common Format Segment 30<br />
5.1.2 Market Characteristics <strong>of</strong> the Boutique Segment 35<br />
A. Detail <strong>of</strong> Operation 36<br />
B. Players in the Boutique Segment 37<br />
5.2 Price Comparison <strong>of</strong> Common and Boutique Segments 41<br />
6.0 Consumer Analysis 42<br />
6.1 Target Group <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> 42<br />
6.1.1 Geographic Group 42<br />
6.1.2 Target Age Group 42<br />
6.1.3 Target SEC and DMFI Group 43<br />
6.2 <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> in Consumer Lifestyle 43<br />
6.3 Highlights <strong>of</strong> Purchase Habit <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> 44<br />
6.3.1 Common Habits across Target Groups 44<br />
6.3.2 Habits <strong>of</strong> Kids 45<br />
6.3.3 Habits <strong>of</strong> Youth 45<br />
6.3.4 Habits <strong>of</strong> Mothers 45<br />
6.4 Barriers to <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Consumption 45<br />
6.4.1 Emotional Barriers 45<br />
6.4.2 Functional Barriers 45<br />
6.5 Research Findings 46<br />
6.5.1 Relevant Occasions in Daily Lives <strong>of</strong> Consumers 46<br />
6.5.2 Frequency <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Consumption 47<br />
6.5.3 Market Character: Relevant Occasions vs. Frequency <strong>of</strong> Consumption 48<br />
6.5.4 Consumer Satisfaction from <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Occasions 50<br />
7.0 Industry Attractiveness and <strong>Entry</strong> Prospects 52<br />
7.1 Driving Forces <strong>of</strong> Growth 52<br />
7.1.2 Trade and Infrastructural Level 52<br />
7.1.3 Consumer Level 52<br />
7.2 Prospects <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> 53<br />
8.0 <strong>Entry</strong> Strategy for Unilever 54<br />
8.1 Suggested <strong>Entry</strong> Areas for UBL 54<br />
8.2 Products 54<br />
8.3 Placement 55<br />
8.4 Price 55<br />
8.5 Promotion 55<br />
8.6 Scope <strong>of</strong> Opportunity 55<br />
8.6.1 Geographic Contribution 56<br />
8.6.2 UBL objectives 56<br />
8.7 Critical Success Factors 56<br />
9.0 <strong>Business</strong> Projection 57<br />
9.1 Basic Assumptions 57<br />
10.0 Conclusion 58<br />
References<br />
List <strong>of</strong> Tables<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited<br />
V
Detail<br />
Page<br />
No.<br />
Table 1: Detail <strong>of</strong> Trade Visit 2<br />
Table 2: Detail <strong>of</strong> Consumer Research 3<br />
Table 3: Third-Party Factories <strong>of</strong> UBL 9<br />
Table 4: UBL Categories and Brands 10<br />
Table 5: History <strong>of</strong> Brand Launch 10<br />
Table 6: Unilever’s Global <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> 15<br />
Table 7: Per Capita <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Consumption <strong>of</strong> Countries 16<br />
Table 8: Glimpse <strong>of</strong> India <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> 16<br />
Table 9: Market Sales and Growth Rate <strong>of</strong> Branded Common Format Market 22<br />
Table 10: Volume Based Market Size 22<br />
Table 11: Market Share <strong>of</strong> Competitors 23<br />
Table 12: Seasonality <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Sales 24<br />
Table 13: Distribution Method <strong>of</strong> Market Players 24<br />
Table 14: Production Capacity <strong>of</strong> Current Market Players 26<br />
Table 15: <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Serve types 27<br />
Table 16: Rank <strong>of</strong> SKUs 27<br />
Table 17: Rank <strong>of</strong> Flavours 27<br />
Table 18: Volume Share <strong>of</strong> Different Serve Types 27<br />
Table 19: Products <strong>of</strong> Igloo 30<br />
Table 20: Igloo Facilities and Logistics 32<br />
Table 21: Strengths and Weaknesses <strong>of</strong> Competition 35<br />
Table 22: Players and Shares in Boutique Segment 36<br />
Table 23: Detail <strong>of</strong> Club Gelato 38<br />
Table 24: Detail <strong>of</strong> MövenPick <strong>of</strong> Switzerland 39<br />
Table 25: Detail <strong>of</strong> Andersen’s <strong>of</strong> Denmark 40<br />
Table 26: Detail <strong>of</strong> Gelateria Igloo 41<br />
Table 27: Comparative Price Analysis 41<br />
Table 28: Relevant Occasions in Consumers’ Lives 46<br />
Table 29: % <strong>of</strong> Variance Explained by Consumer Clusters 55<br />
Table 30: Requirements & Product Attributes Desired by Consumer Clusters 50<br />
Table 31: Value and Volume Based Scope <strong>of</strong> Opportunity for UBL 55<br />
Table 32: Assumptions for <strong>Business</strong> Projection 58<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited<br />
VI
List <strong>of</strong> Figures<br />
Detail<br />
Page<br />
No.<br />
Figure 1: Unilever’s <strong>Business</strong> Areas and Sales Contribution 5<br />
Figure 2: Unilever’s Governing Structure 12<br />
Figure 3: Departments and Leadership Team <strong>of</strong> UBL 12<br />
Figure 4: Organogram for Brands and Development Department 14<br />
Figure 5: Unilever <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Portfolio 15<br />
Figure 6: Market Construct <strong>of</strong> Bangladesh <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Industry 17<br />
Figure 7: Geographic Sales Orientation 23<br />
Figure 8: Serve Types and Pricing 28<br />
Figure 9: Igloo Supply Chain 31<br />
Figure 10: Distribution Process <strong>of</strong> Igloo 31<br />
Figure 11: Target Group wise Consumption Pattern 42<br />
Figure 12: <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> in Consumer Life style 43<br />
Figure 13: Frequency <strong>of</strong> Occurrence <strong>of</strong> Occasions 47<br />
Figure 14: Frequency <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Consumption 48<br />
Figure 15: Relevance <strong>of</strong> Occasion-Frequency <strong>of</strong> Consumption Mapping 49<br />
Figure 16: Required Market Strategy for Bangladesh 49<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited<br />
VII
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited<br />
VIII
1.0 INTRODUCTION<br />
This section presents the background <strong>of</strong> the report, “<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong><br />
for Unilever Bangladesh Limited” and outlines its objectives, scope, methodology <strong>of</strong> project<br />
completion and report preparation used in its formation, and limitations <strong>of</strong> the report.<br />
1.1 Background <strong>of</strong> the Report<br />
This project was assigned as part <strong>of</strong> the Internship Program <strong>of</strong> Institute <strong>of</strong> <strong>BRAC</strong> <strong>University</strong> upon<br />
completion <strong>of</strong> four year BBA graduation program. In accordance with the specifications <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Program, the author has completed the 12-week period <strong>of</strong> the internship at an organization, Unilever<br />
Bangladesh Limited (UBL).<br />
The project was completed and report was prepared under kind supervision <strong>of</strong> Academic supervisor,<br />
Sharmin Shabnam Rahman, Lecturer, <strong>BRAC</strong> <strong>University</strong> and Official supervisor, Muhammad Risalat<br />
Siddique, Brand Manager, UBL. The project, on which this report is based, was assigned as a job<br />
responsibility <strong>of</strong> me my self.<br />
1.2 Objectives<br />
Broad Objective:<br />
Main objective <strong>of</strong> the project was to evaluate feasibility <strong>of</strong> entering <strong>into</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> business for UBL.<br />
To achieve this broad objective, some specific objectives were accomplished. These are outlined<br />
below.<br />
Specific Objective:<br />
� Identify current global ice <strong>cream</strong> business situation and view <strong>of</strong> Unilever towards Asian region.<br />
� Identify ice <strong>cream</strong> industry construct <strong>of</strong> Bangladesh and its parameters and characteristics.<br />
� Analyze sales, financing, marketing, and supply chain issues <strong>of</strong> branded ice <strong>cream</strong> segment.<br />
� Analyze current market players <strong>of</strong> the branded segment.<br />
� Analyze consumers <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> in detail.<br />
� Assess industry attractiveness and entry prospects for UBL.<br />
� Suggest entry strategy for UBL.<br />
� Estimate tentative five year business projection for UBL in ice <strong>cream</strong> business.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 1
1.3 Scope<br />
Scope <strong>of</strong> research for the project has been limited to Dhaka and outskirts <strong>of</strong> Dhaka only. As <strong>of</strong><br />
current market situation, ice <strong>cream</strong> is primarily an urban product (due to electricity issues <strong>of</strong> the<br />
country) and Dhaka contributes more than 50% <strong>of</strong> the market and all the major marketing activities<br />
are concentrated in Dhaka and thus this scope does not limit overall understanding <strong>of</strong> the market.<br />
The report puts emphasis on branded ice <strong>cream</strong> segment and takes a cursory glimpse <strong>of</strong> the<br />
unorganized unbranded segment. While carrying out the competitor analysis, all the existent branded<br />
segment players and only the major players in the premium boutique segment have been analyzed.<br />
Special emphasis has been placed on market leaders and their marketing strategies while formulating<br />
the entry strategy for UBL.<br />
1.4 Methodology<br />
Both primary and secondary research sources were used to complete the analysis. Primary research<br />
was mainly qualitative and was used to understand the ice <strong>cream</strong> industry first-hand and validate the<br />
information collected from secondary sources. Details <strong>of</strong> both methodologies are provided below.<br />
1.4.1 Primary Research:<br />
Trade Visit:<br />
� During market visit, a total <strong>of</strong> 60 shops were visited with formal questionnaires in different areas <strong>of</strong><br />
Dhaka city. Areas were selected based on SEC orientation <strong>of</strong> different areas. The areas were:<br />
Zone<br />
Gulshan, Dhanmondi,<br />
Uttara<br />
Kamalapur, Mirpur,<br />
Mohammadpur,<br />
Lalmatia<br />
Malibagh, Rampura,<br />
Khilgaon, Shantinagar<br />
Azimpur, Lalbag, New<br />
Market, Dhaka<br />
<strong>University</strong>, Sadarghat<br />
Table 1: Detail <strong>of</strong> Trade Visit<br />
Major SEC<br />
Orientation<br />
SEC A++<br />
SEC A<br />
SEC A & B<br />
SEC B & C<br />
Channels Visited (All Zones)<br />
1. Urban General Stores (UGS)<br />
2. Urban Neighbourhood Grocer<br />
(UNG)<br />
3. Premium General Store (PGS)/<br />
SMMT<br />
4. Modern Trade (MT)<br />
5. Confectionary/ Bakery<br />
6. Fast Food shops<br />
� 10 (6 Igloo and 4 Kwality) cart sellers were interviewed to understand cart distribution and selling<br />
method.<br />
� 4 highest performing boutique players (Club Gelato, MövenPick <strong>of</strong> Switzerland, Andersen’s <strong>of</strong><br />
Denmark and Gelateria Igloo) were formally interviewed to understand the boutique segment.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 2
Consumer Visit:<br />
To understand consumer perception about ice <strong>cream</strong> and current industry, focus target groups <strong>of</strong> ice<br />
<strong>cream</strong> were identified and group discussions were conducted with them. The groups were:<br />
� Urban kids in the age group <strong>of</strong> 5-14:<br />
� Informal discussions with 10 kids regarding their perception <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> and how their<br />
parents influence their ice <strong>cream</strong> consumption.<br />
� Urban youth in the age group <strong>of</strong> 15-24<br />
� Two group discussions were conducted students <strong>of</strong> IBA and NSU, each consisting <strong>of</strong> 10<br />
members.<br />
� Urban mothers in the age group <strong>of</strong> 25-35<br />
� Two group discussions were conducted with mothers at Green Herald Int’l School and Rifles<br />
Public School.<br />
1.4.2 Secondary Research:<br />
Secondary research sources provided useful insight <strong>into</strong> background and upcoming issues <strong>of</strong> global<br />
and Bangladesh ice <strong>cream</strong> industry. These were used as information source and then cross validated<br />
against each other and using primary research.<br />
Internal sources:<br />
Unilever’s internal sources that contributed to the research were:<br />
� Unilever global web archive.<br />
� Unilever <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Academy web site.<br />
� Unilever Pakistan Ltd, Consumer & Market Insight (CMI) Division.<br />
� Unilever Bangladesh Ltd archive.<br />
External sources:<br />
External sources that contributed were:<br />
� AC Nielsen, Bangladesh.<br />
� Market Research Information from India.<br />
� Market Intelligence from Bangladesh.<br />
� Company web sites <strong>of</strong> competitors.<br />
� Earlier reports on the <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> industry <strong>of</strong> Bangladesh.<br />
� The Internet.<br />
1.5 Limitation<br />
This study had few limitations that restricted the research analysis. They are outlined below.<br />
� By policy, UBL does not disclose any financial, research, production or sales data to any entity<br />
outside the company. Because <strong>of</strong> this policy, it has not been possible to include the data and<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 3
other information used to estimate different financials and work out the entry strategy for UBL in<br />
this report. This is especially true in case <strong>of</strong> the business projection section, where information on<br />
the exact size <strong>of</strong> the target group, market share for the initial years, distributor and trade margins,<br />
supply chain costs, etc. have been omitted. Much <strong>of</strong> the data provided has been modified to<br />
maintain confidentiality.<br />
� First <strong>of</strong> all, convenience sampling was used for research and this warranted for some biasness in<br />
input from traders and consumers <strong>of</strong> qualitative study.<br />
� All the market competitors are private companies and thus amount <strong>of</strong> available public information<br />
is few. Also, no research or advertising agency formally tracks the industry. In many cases recent<br />
concrete data was not available and estimations had to be made.<br />
� Research was conducted only in Dhaka even though ice <strong>cream</strong> consumption habits and<br />
distribution issues (e.g. electricity) in other areas <strong>of</strong> the country can vary in future with proper<br />
expansion <strong>of</strong> the ice <strong>cream</strong> industry beyond capital and metro cities.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 4
2.0 BACKGROUND OF THE ORGANIZATION<br />
2.1 Global Unilever Group<br />
Unilever is one <strong>of</strong> the world’s leading suppliers <strong>of</strong> fast-moving-consumer-goods (FMCG), with 400<br />
brands spanning 14 categories <strong>of</strong> Home, Personal Care and Foods products. In fact, 150 million times<br />
a day people use Unilever products at key moments <strong>of</strong> their day. Unilever employs more than 206,000<br />
people in 150 countries and had worldwide revenue <strong>of</strong> just over US$47 billion or BDT 3290 billion in<br />
2009.<br />
Unilever has two parent companies - Unilever NV and Unilever PLC. Unilever N.V is a public limited<br />
company registered in the Netherlands and Unilever PLC is a public limited company registered in<br />
England and Wales. The two parent companies, NV and PLC, together with their group companies,<br />
operate as a single economic entity (the Unilever Group, also referred to as Unilever) with the same<br />
board <strong>of</strong> directors. Unilever's corporate centres are in London and Rotterdam.<br />
Unilever’s brand portfolio includes worldwide favourites: Lipton, Knorr, Dove, Axe and Vaseline. Their<br />
portfolio is diverse in response to the varying needs <strong>of</strong> their customers across the globe. Unilever<br />
<strong>of</strong>fers world-class brands, many <strong>of</strong> which are customized for local markets. Unilever invests €1 billion<br />
or BDT 94.4 billion every year in cutting edge research and development and has five laboratories<br />
around the world that explore new thinking and techniques to help develop their products. The<br />
following figure shows the portfolio <strong>of</strong> categories Unilever operates in:<br />
Figure 1: Unilever’s <strong>Business</strong> Areas and Sales Contribution<br />
The following are some recent highlights from Unilever’s three global divisions - Foods, Home Care<br />
and Personal Care:<br />
2.1.1 Home and Personal Care Divisions:<br />
� Lux became the first mass-marketed soap when it launched in 1924. Today it achieves annual<br />
global sales <strong>of</strong> over €1 billion<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 5
� Unilever’s oral care brands Mentadent, Pepsodent and Signal have teamed up with the world's<br />
largest dental federation, the FDI, representing 750 000 dentists around the world<br />
� First launched in France in 1983,Unilever’s leading male grooming brand, Axe, now gives men<br />
the edge in the mating game in over 60 countries<br />
� Hindustan Lever has launched a Surf Excel Quick Wash, with a low foaming formulation, reducing<br />
the amount <strong>of</strong> water needed for rinsing by up to two buckets per wash<br />
� Recent breakthroughs at Rexona include Rexona Crystal, a deodorant that eliminates unsightly<br />
white deposits on dark garments.<br />
2.1.2 Foods Division:<br />
� Unilever is the world's leading ice <strong>cream</strong> producer, with brands such as Algida and Wall's in<br />
Europe, and Ben & Jerry's in the United States.<br />
� Unilever is the largest seller <strong>of</strong> packet tea in the world through the Lipton brand.<br />
� The acquisition <strong>of</strong> Bestfoods in 2000 brought Unilever leadership in the culinary category. Knorr is<br />
now their biggest brand, with €2.3 billion sales in over 100 countries and a product range covering<br />
soups, bouillons, sauces, noodles and complete meals.<br />
� Becel/Flora pro.activ products have been recognized as the most significant advancement in the<br />
dietary management <strong>of</strong> cholesterol in 40 years.<br />
2.2 History <strong>of</strong> Unilever<br />
2.2.1 Soap and Margarine Origins:<br />
The Anglo-Dutch Group, Unilever, was created in 1930 when the British soap-maker Lever Brothers<br />
merged with the Dutch margarine producer, Margarine Unie. At the time, an international merger was<br />
an unusual move. However, the owners <strong>of</strong> the two companies could see that bringing together<br />
complementary businesses with strong global networks would create new opportunities. The<br />
companies were competing for the same raw materials, both were involved in large-scale marketing <strong>of</strong><br />
household products and both used similar distribution channels.<br />
Lever Brothers was founded in 1885 by William Hesketh Lever with his brother James. The company<br />
produced Sunlight, the world's first packaged, branded laundry soap. Sunlight was a revolutionary<br />
product that helped popularize cleanliness and hygiene in Victorian England. Its purpose was 'to<br />
make cleanliness commonplace; to lessen work for women; to foster health and contribute to personal<br />
attractiveness, that life may be more enjoyable and rewarding for the people who use our products.'<br />
In 1930, Lever chose Margarine Unie as a merger partner. Margarine Unie, a Dutch company had<br />
grown through mergers with other margarine companies in the 1920s. The logic for the Anglo-Dutch<br />
merger was clear: animal fats were the raw materials for both margarine and soap.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 6
2.2.2 Surviving the Great Depression:<br />
The Great Depression struck not long after the new company was formed. As prices and pr<strong>of</strong>its<br />
around the world threatened to collapse, Unilever had to act quickly to build up an efficient system <strong>of</strong><br />
control. But it was not until the end <strong>of</strong> World War II that Unilever began to recognize the important<br />
relationship between marketing and research. In the meantime, Unilever expanded its U.S. operations<br />
through two important acquisitions: Thomas J. Lipton Company, manufacturer <strong>of</strong> tea and the<br />
Pepsodent brand <strong>of</strong> toothpaste.<br />
2.2.3 Post-war Era: Adapting to New Markets and Technology:<br />
Unilever's greatest achievements between 1945 and 1965 were its adaptation to new markets and<br />
technology. Unilever's strategy was to acquire companies in new areas, particularly food and<br />
chemical manufacturers. Among the post-war acquisitions were U.K. frozen foods maker Birds Eye<br />
(1957) and U.S. ice <strong>cream</strong> novelty maker Good Humour (1961). The advent <strong>of</strong> the European<br />
Economic Community, or Common Market, also created new opportunities for Unilever.<br />
2.2.4 Restructuring and Major Acquisitions<br />
In the 1980s Unilever undertook a massive restructuring. The company sold most <strong>of</strong> its service and<br />
ancillary businesses, such as transport, packaging, advertising, and other services that were readily<br />
available on the market, and went on a buying spree, snapping up some 80 companies between 1984<br />
and 1988. Specifically, Unilever's core businesses were detergents, foods, toiletries, and specialty<br />
chemicals.<br />
2.2.5 Twenty First Century Unilever:<br />
Unilever's fastest growing market in the early 1990s was in Asia. Asian sales <strong>of</strong> personal products,<br />
detergent, and packaged foods were growing more than twice as fast as sales in the United States<br />
and Europe. Unilever continued to make acquisitions in the mid-1990s, completing more than 100<br />
purchases between 1992 and 1996, more than half <strong>of</strong> which were in foods. In 1993 Unilever gained<br />
the number one position in the U.S. ice <strong>cream</strong> market through the completion <strong>of</strong> two acquisitions. One<br />
the largest acquisitions <strong>of</strong> this period was the 1996 takeover <strong>of</strong> Chicago-based Helene Curtis<br />
Industries Inc., manufacturer and marketer <strong>of</strong> personal care products, primarily shampoo and<br />
conditioners, hand and body lotions, and deodorants and antiperspirants.<br />
Unilever ended the 20th century with the launch <strong>of</strong> Path to Growth, a five-year strategic plan that<br />
included a focus on top brands within core market sectors and an emphasis on growth within<br />
developing countries. In the face <strong>of</strong> considerable competitive pressures in various markets around the<br />
world – particularly from Procter & Gamble, the company announced that it would eliminate about<br />
1,200 <strong>of</strong> its brands to focus on around 400 regionally or globally powerful brands.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 7
2.2.6 Unilever <strong>of</strong> Today:<br />
Unilever is truly a ‘multi-local’ multinational with operating companies and factories on every continent.<br />
They have a portfolio <strong>of</strong> brands that are popular across the globe - as well as regional products and<br />
local varieties <strong>of</strong> famous-name goods. This diversity comes from two <strong>of</strong> their key strengths:<br />
� Strong roots in local markets and first-hand knowledge <strong>of</strong> local cultures<br />
� World-class business expertise applied internationally to serve consumers everywhere<br />
Unilever recently completed the five-year Vitality company initiative in which it began to converge the<br />
marketing <strong>of</strong> disparate arms <strong>of</strong> their business, including personal care, dieting, and consumables <strong>into</strong><br />
an umbrella function. More than ever, Unilever brands are helping people 'feel good, look good and<br />
get more out <strong>of</strong> life' – a sentiment close to William Lever's heart over a hundred years ago.<br />
2.3 Unilever Bangladesh Limited (UBL)<br />
Lever Brothers Bangladesh established its manufacturing facility in 1964 at Kalurghat in Chittagong.<br />
Productions started <strong>of</strong>f with Lux and Lifebuoy soap. After meeting the local demand, the surplus<br />
production was shipped to Pakistan. It was after independence that Lever Brothers Bangladesh Ltd<br />
was constituted with Unilever owning 60.75% shares and the Government <strong>of</strong> Bangladesh owning the<br />
remaining 39.25% shares. In 2004, Lever Brothers was renamed Unilever Bangladesh Limited in<br />
order to align their corporate identity and logo with the global Unilever.<br />
By tapping <strong>into</strong> the vast know-how base <strong>of</strong> the parent company - Unilever, Lever Brothers was able to<br />
make their products available to the consumers at an affordable price. In the last decade, Unilever<br />
has consistently been achieving double-digit growth in Bangladesh, with an annual turnover reaching<br />
at BDT 1 billion in 2006. Unilever procures 40% <strong>of</strong> its inputs from local sources and spends about<br />
BDT 150 crores annually in Bangladesh for promotional activities, including advertisements, for its<br />
products.<br />
Its current <strong>of</strong>fices are located in:<br />
Factory: Unilever Bangladesh Limited<br />
51 Kalurghat Heavy Industrial Area<br />
P. O. Box # 125<br />
Chittagong – 4000<br />
Bangladesh<br />
Corporate Office: Unilever Bangladesh Limited<br />
ZN Tower<br />
Plot No. 2, SW (1)<br />
Road No. 8<br />
Gulshan – 1<br />
Dhaka – 1212<br />
Bangladesh<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 8
2.3.1 Manufacturing Facilities:<br />
The company has a Soap Manufacturing factory and a Personal Products Factory located in<br />
Chittagong. The factory has to adhere strictly to four important policies:<br />
� Quality Policy<br />
� Occupational Health and Safety Policy<br />
� Environmental Policy<br />
� Quality & Consumer Safety Policy<br />
� Total Productive Maintenance Policy<br />
Besides these, there is a tea packaging operation in Chittagong and four manufacturing units in<br />
Dhaka, which are owned and run by third parties exclusively dedicated to Unilever Bangladesh.<br />
The following are the details <strong>of</strong> these third party operations:<br />
ARC Surfactants<br />
91, Tongi Industrial Area, Gazipur<br />
Progati Soap Factory<br />
Tongi Industrial Area, Gazipur<br />
SMAH Limited<br />
96, Tongi Industrial Area, Gazipur<br />
Third-Party Factory Brand<br />
SMAH Limited<br />
115-116, BSIC Industrial Estate, Konabari, Gazipur<br />
2.3.2 Employees:<br />
Table 3: Third-Party Factories <strong>of</strong> UBL<br />
Wheel Washing Powder ,<br />
Surf Excel<br />
Lifebuoy Soap – 70gm<br />
Wheel Washing Powder<br />
Pond’s Talcum Powder<br />
Unilever operations in Bangladesh provide employment to over 10,000 people directly and through its<br />
dedicated suppliers, distributors and service providers. Ninety-nine percent <strong>of</strong> UBL employees are<br />
locals.<br />
2.3.3 Product Categories and Brands:<br />
In Bangladesh, Unilever <strong>of</strong>fers consumer brands which spans across three categories which are as<br />
follow:<br />
� Home care, which in turn is divided <strong>into</strong>:<br />
� Fabric cleaning<br />
� Household care<br />
� Personal care, which in turn is divided <strong>into</strong>:<br />
� Skin Cleansing<br />
� Skin Care<br />
� Oral Care<br />
� Hair Care<br />
� Foods<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 9
There are currently 14 brands across the above-mentioned categories:<br />
Category Brands<br />
Skin Cleansing Lux, Lifebuoy and Dove<br />
Skin Care Fair and Lovely , Rexona and Ponds’<br />
Oral Care Pepsodent and Close Up<br />
Hair Care Sunsilk, Dove and Clear<br />
Fabric Cleaning Wheel, Surf Excel<br />
Household Care Vim<br />
Foods Lipton Taaza<br />
Table 4: UBL Categories and Brands<br />
Leveraging their global network and combining it with local consumer insight, Unilever Bangladesh<br />
has introduced relevant innovative products throughout the years. This has led to the development <strong>of</strong><br />
products in categories such as Detergent powders, Dish wash Bar, Face wash and Deodorants, thus<br />
enriching the lives <strong>of</strong> Bangladeshis. The following table illustrates the way UBL has continuously<br />
introduced new brands and even more so in the last decade.<br />
2.3.4 Brand Launches by Year:<br />
2.3.5 Corporate Mission:<br />
Year Brands<br />
1964 Lifebuoy<br />
1964 Lux<br />
1972 Wheel Laundry Soap<br />
1982 Sunsilk<br />
1987 Close Up<br />
1987 Vim<br />
1989 Clear<br />
1988 Fair & Lovely<br />
1990 Lipton Yellow Label<br />
1991 Ponds'<br />
1991 Pepsodent<br />
1992 Taaza<br />
1993 Surf Excel<br />
1997 Wheel Washing Powder<br />
2002 Clinic<br />
2002 Rexona<br />
2003 Vim Bar<br />
2003 Pepsodent Tooth Powder<br />
Table 5: History <strong>of</strong> Brand Launch<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 10
Unilever states its mission as follows:<br />
“Our mission is to add Vitality to life. We meet everyday needs for nutrition, hygiene and personal care<br />
with brands that help people look good, feel good and get more out <strong>of</strong> life.”<br />
Its goals are:<br />
� To manufacture high-standard products<br />
� Promoting products to the highest extent<br />
� Producing large volume to achieve production cost economies<br />
� Enabling quality products to be sold out at obtainable prices<br />
2.3.6 Corporate Social Responsibility:<br />
Unilever Bangladesh supports community development through various initiatives.<br />
� The Fair and Lovely Foundation undertakes various projects throughout the country to empower<br />
women with access to information and resources in the areas <strong>of</strong> Education, Career and<br />
Enterprise. Workshops for rural women teaching them business and vocational skills like pickle<br />
making , poultry farming, etc. have been held and Projects on IT education for women will also be<br />
implemented through this Foundation<br />
� Unilever Bangladesh has sponsored the modernization <strong>of</strong> existing surgical facilities and the<br />
setting up <strong>of</strong> a modern operation theatre and intensive care unit at the Maa Shishu O General<br />
hospital in Chittagong, which significantly enhanced access to modern health care for the<br />
underprivileged people <strong>of</strong> the city<br />
� Unilever is the main sponsor <strong>of</strong> the Lifebuoy Friendship Hospital bringing health care to<br />
thousands <strong>of</strong> underprivileged riverine population in the country<br />
� UBL also sponsors students from various education institutes in Chittagong as well as members<br />
<strong>of</strong> the British Council Library and provided scholarships to meritorious students.<br />
2.3.7 Corporate Governance:<br />
Unilever's highest executive body is called the Unilever Executive (UEX). It is led by the Group Chief<br />
Executive (GCE), Patrick Cescau. The UEX define the top level organisation structure and manage<br />
trade<strong>of</strong>fs within the corporate portfolio. They are accountable for all aspects <strong>of</strong> company operations,<br />
managing business performance and overall pr<strong>of</strong>it responsibility for the Group.<br />
The Unilever Executive is also responsible for defining and shaping the culture, leadership capabilities<br />
and behaviour needed to deliver Unilever’s corporate strategy. They have responsibility for all internal<br />
communications and some aspects <strong>of</strong> external communications (customers, suppliers, pr<strong>of</strong>essional<br />
bodies, media and investor relations). They are responsible for managing corporate risk and<br />
reputation.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 11
Figure 2: Unilever’s Governing Structure<br />
The Category Presidents for Foods and Home and Personal Care are responsible for Category<br />
strategies, brand development and innovation. The Regional Presidents are responsible for managing<br />
the business, deploying brands and innovations effectively and winning with customers. They are<br />
supported by the Finance and HR functions.<br />
2.3.8 Organizational Structure:<br />
Unilever Bangladesh is headed by a Chief Executive Officer, Mr. Rakesh Mohan, in Bangladesh.<br />
There are five departments headed by five individual directors. Presently the company has the<br />
following departments at its corporate headquarters:<br />
Brands &<br />
Development<br />
K.S.M. Minhaz<br />
Supply Chain<br />
Imran Momin<br />
CEO<br />
& Chairman<br />
Rakesh Mohan<br />
Finance IT<br />
& Legal<br />
Mahatabuddin<br />
Ahmed<br />
Customer<br />
Development<br />
Mizanur Rashid<br />
Figure 3: Departments and Leadership Team <strong>of</strong> UBL<br />
2.3.9 Brands and Development Department:<br />
This department has five parts working together. These are:<br />
� Brands<br />
� Development<br />
� Consumer and Market Insight (CMI)<br />
� Media<br />
� Activation<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 12<br />
Human<br />
Resources<br />
Jerry Jose
This department is responsible for nurturing a brand towards market leadership and <strong>of</strong>fering<br />
consumers with innovation and novelty in brands. With a deep consumer insight, the Brand Managers<br />
look after the brands on a daily basis: planning and organizing activities that boost their image and<br />
increase their exposure. The Brands Team has been expanded to Brands and Development, thus<br />
providing the opportunity <strong>of</strong> increased coordination between the Marketing and Development Team<br />
and to ensure a successful innovation process at Unilever. The Development team is responsible for<br />
developing cost-effective formulations and packaging for the products and developing and improving<br />
the processes involved in their manufacture.<br />
However, Bangladesh still remains a Brand-Building country while Development generally takes place<br />
at regional level. Brand Developing countries are responsible for the brand category strategy,<br />
identifying new consumer and technology opportunities, product formulation and packaging design<br />
and communication strategy. The critical role <strong>of</strong> Brand Building is to lead the specific country category<br />
and brand operations team to create, execute and evaluate the insight-led Category Building Plan and<br />
Brand Marketing Plans created by Brand Development. Development at local levels takes place in the<br />
form <strong>of</strong> packaging innovations and minor product modifications to fit local consumer needs and<br />
production methods.<br />
Marketing information is crucial for UBL and the company decisions are based to a large extent on the<br />
accuracy and timeliness <strong>of</strong> such information. Consumer and Market Insight (CMI) team ensure that<br />
data are collected cost effectively to provide consumer information to aid the company to attain a<br />
competitive advantage. This helps to achieve a proactive understanding <strong>of</strong> the Bangladeshi<br />
consumer. The CMI team carries out various market and consumer research through external<br />
research agencies such as Sirius and AC Nielson and also coordinates with regional CMI team to<br />
gather category research done globally.<br />
Brand activation is the core marketing process through which a brand is brought to life through a<br />
variety <strong>of</strong> brand experiences. The activation team builds a brand by creating a physical or emotional<br />
space in the consumers’ lives that enables the brand to interact in a meaningful way. These activation<br />
programs drive purchase and preference by building consistent, long term relationships with<br />
consumers. The responsibility <strong>of</strong> the media team is to buy media space, settle the different media<br />
packages for each brand and coordinate various partnerships and events with media partners.<br />
The Organogram on the following page depicts the different positions in Brands, Development, Media,<br />
Activation and CMI.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 13
Product Group<br />
Manager<br />
Fair & Lovely<br />
Marketing Manager<br />
Colour, Oral &<br />
Pond’s<br />
Product Group<br />
Manager Pepsodent<br />
Senior Brand<br />
Manager Pond’s<br />
Senior Brand<br />
Manager -<br />
Lifebuoy<br />
Product Group<br />
Manager<br />
Hair Care<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 14<br />
Chairman & Managing Director<br />
Brands & Development Director<br />
Company CMI<br />
Manager<br />
Marketing Manager<br />
Skin cleansing, fabric<br />
Wash & Household & Head <strong>of</strong><br />
CMI<br />
Senior Brand<br />
Manager Wheel<br />
Co. Media Manager/<br />
Product Group Manager<br />
Lux<br />
Activation Planning &<br />
Media Operations<br />
Manager<br />
Figure 4: Organogram for Brands and Development Department<br />
Company Activation<br />
Manager & Senior Brand<br />
Manager – Tea<br />
Company Development<br />
Manager<br />
Packaging<br />
Development<br />
Manager<br />
Product<br />
Development<br />
Manager<br />
* Company Media Manager reports to BDD for media related issues<br />
while has a double reporting line to MM for Lux related issues
3.1 Overview<br />
3.0 GLOBAL ICE CREAM INDUSTRY<br />
Global <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> industry is estimated at 43 Billion Euros 1 ($54 Billion) at the end <strong>of</strong> 2009. Unilever<br />
business is currently at 4.7 billion Euros ($6.04 Billion). Nestle’ outpaced Unilever with recent<br />
acquisition <strong>of</strong> U.S. Company Dreyer's Grand <strong>Ice</strong> Cream Holdings Inc and became world’s largest ice<br />
<strong>cream</strong> manufacturer with 28% market share compared to that <strong>of</strong> 17.6% Unilever share.<br />
3.2 Unilever <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong><br />
Unilever <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> business under the umbrella name <strong>of</strong> “Heart” brand (also known as Wall’s,<br />
Algida, Ola etc in different countries) has been one <strong>of</strong> the most successful businesses in the food<br />
category. As <strong>of</strong> 2009, Unilever ice <strong>cream</strong> sales stands as following.<br />
Region 2007 2008 2009<br />
Europe 2315 2,392 2,455<br />
North America 1,269 1,283 1,298<br />
Asia 444 506 576<br />
Latin America 408 430 452<br />
Total (Mln. Euros) 4,412 4,611 4,781<br />
Table 6: Unilever’s Global <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong><br />
Current market standing based on Underlying Sales Growth (USG) and Market share for Unilever in<br />
Asia is excellent and market is currently growing at a very high rate compared other three regions.<br />
Market is not saturated and many untapped countries like Bangladesh can provide more growth from<br />
this region. Unilever Portfolio under “Heart” or “Wall’s” brand looks as follows:<br />
Magnum<br />
Magnum Cornetto Carte d'Or Carte d'Or<br />
Light<br />
Figure 5: Unilever <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Portfolio<br />
Breyers<br />
CarbSmart<br />
Solero Ben&Jerry’s<br />
Among these Magnum is Premium Extrusion stick, Cornetto is Cone, Solero is fruit based and<br />
Ben&Jerry’s is super premium ice <strong>cream</strong> that is sold through dedicated boutiques. Others are filled<br />
SKUs. In recent times there have been additions <strong>of</strong> sub-brands like Frusi and Moos.<br />
1 Source: Reuters (Global AC Nielsen study)<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 15
3.3 Regional <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> and Unilever<br />
3.3.1 <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Consumption:<br />
World ice <strong>cream</strong> consumption data shows scopes and opportunities for Unilever in this category. Per<br />
capita consumption (PCC) <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> in the South Asian region is pretty low with 0.1 litres per year.<br />
Bangladesh PCC is also estimated to be similar where people consume ice <strong>cream</strong> less than once a<br />
month as can be seen from the following chart 2 .<br />
Country Per Capita Consumption<br />
Volume<br />
(ltrs/yr)<br />
Value<br />
(Euros/yr)<br />
Consumption<br />
Pattern<br />
Australia 18.0 48.0 > 8 times / month<br />
Hong Kong 2.4 11.0<br />
Singapore 2.4 11.9<br />
Malaysia 1.6 3.0<br />
Thailand 1.5 1.8<br />
China 1.0 1.1<br />
Philippines 0.8 1.5<br />
Pakistan 0.4 0.4<br />
Indonesia 0.2 0.4<br />
India 0.1 0.1<br />
Table 7: Per Capita <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Consumption <strong>of</strong> Countries<br />
2 -3 times /<br />
month<br />
< 1 once / month<br />
This represents the challenge for the category in this region to be: “To Grow the Category &<br />
Increase Market Share”.<br />
3.3.2 India <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> and Unilever:<br />
Overall <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> industry in India is as follows:<br />
Detail<br />
Total<br />
Market Impulse<br />
Take<br />
Home Artisan<br />
Value (Cr BDT) 1687 56% 34% 10%<br />
Volume (‘000 Ltrs) 75407 54.5% 40.2% 5.3%<br />
CAGR (Volume) 11% 10.43% 11.33% 12.63%<br />
CAGR (Value) 13.52% 13.19% 13.91% 14.02%<br />
Gross Pr<strong>of</strong>it 49.9% 48.20% 51% 55%<br />
Table 8: Glimpse <strong>of</strong> India <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong><br />
This market data has been considered to understand a similar but evolved market. In the Indian<br />
market, Kwality Wall’s (a merger between Unilever and Kwality) with its mother brand and two sub<br />
brands Cornetto and Max has 16.19% market share in the market. However recent strategic change<br />
towards focused distribution and marketing approach in six major cities (Mumbai, Delhi, Calcutta,<br />
Chennai, Hyderabad and Bangalore) that contribute to two thirds <strong>of</strong> total Unilever sales has provided<br />
Unilever recent success in the category in India.<br />
2 Source: Unilever Pakistan Ltd. CMI<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 16
4.1 Industry Construct<br />
4.0 BANGLADESH ICE CREAM INDUSTRY<br />
The ice <strong>cream</strong> industry <strong>of</strong> Bangladesh is a growing one. With an estimated market size <strong>of</strong> BDT 220 Cr<br />
in 2009, the market can be subdivided broadly <strong>into</strong> branded and unbranded categories.<br />
Common<br />
[BDT 121 Cr]<br />
Branded<br />
[BDT 131 Cr]<br />
4.1.1 Branded Market:<br />
Boutique<br />
[BDT 9.8 Cr]<br />
Total Market<br />
[BDT 220 Cr]<br />
Figure 6: Market Construct <strong>of</strong> Bangladesh <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Industry<br />
Unbranded<br />
[BDT 79 Cr]<br />
Around 20,000 local manufacturers<br />
The branded market segment is around BDT 131 Cr with players in both common/ conventional ice<br />
<strong>cream</strong> format (BDT 121 Cr) and boutique format which is still very small in size (BDT 9.8 Cr).<br />
Common Format:<br />
Common format ice <strong>cream</strong>s are generally produced and packed in factory. These are distributed and<br />
sold through retail channels/ carts to the shoppers. Products can be single serving like stick and<br />
cones or multiple serving like containers. Moreover, single serving can either be water based where<br />
only water and flavours are mixed or <strong>cream</strong> based where milk <strong>cream</strong> and flavours are mixed.<br />
Branded common format ice <strong>cream</strong> industry has only five players in the market. They are Igloo, Polar,<br />
Kwality, Savoy and Milk Vita. Igloo is currently the market leader. Polar stayed market leader for 10<br />
years (’86-‘96) in their initial days and Kwality challenged and took Polar’s second position in recent<br />
times. However, Igloo bounced back every time they faced challenge. Milk Vita came in the market<br />
with proper dairy ice <strong>cream</strong> but failed to create an impact as their core business is not ice <strong>cream</strong>.<br />
Boutique Format:<br />
Boutique format ice <strong>cream</strong>s are sold through dedicated outlets where there is seating facility for<br />
consumers. They can see the products/ flavours open in freezers and can choose directly. Also<br />
consumers can decide what type <strong>of</strong> packing to use e.g. cup, cones or containers and based on the<br />
consumers decision product is either served for consumption at the premises or take away.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 17
Boutique format has seen an upsurge from year 2000 with introduction <strong>of</strong> premium, franchise and<br />
imported ice <strong>cream</strong>s. This segment is driven by Dhaka and Chittagong based players. Club Gelato,<br />
MövenPick, Andersen’s, Gelateria Igloo, Baskin31Robbins and Sub Zero are the major players in the<br />
segment. Among these, Gelateria Igloo and Sub Zero are run by common format players Igloo and<br />
Kwality respectively.<br />
4.1.2 Unbranded Market:<br />
The unbranded market basically is constituted with around 20,000 local small producers that do not<br />
use any brand leverage and compete in the market based on significant lower price in the range <strong>of</strong><br />
BDT 1-5.<br />
Market size <strong>of</strong> this segment is significantly high with BDT 79 Cr. These producers are mainly rural and<br />
suburb based where concentration <strong>of</strong> SEC C and lower SECs are high. They mainly produce water<br />
ice <strong>cream</strong> sticks or in colloquial terms “Baarfi”. These are made with saccharine and colours. They<br />
also produce small amount <strong>of</strong> milk based kulfi. These ice <strong>cream</strong>s are very unhygienic and <strong>of</strong> low<br />
quality.<br />
4.2 Historical Progress <strong>of</strong> the Industry<br />
� Before 1964: <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> market dominated by unorganized unbranded approach.<br />
� 1964: Igloo started large scale organized approach under K Rahman & Co. Ltd.<br />
� 1965: Igloo opened up the first ice-<strong>cream</strong> parlour in Dhaka.<br />
� 1971: Igloo was nationalized by the government <strong>of</strong> Bangladesh after liberation.<br />
� 1972: In June Igloo was handed over to Bangladesh Sugar & Food Industries Corporation.<br />
� 1983: Abdul Monem Ltd. acquired Igloo under privatization policy.<br />
� 1986: Polar started operation; introduced food grade plastic based packaging. They immediately<br />
became market leader with extensive campaign.<br />
� 1988: Dolce Vita Gelato, one <strong>of</strong> the dedicated boutique operator brought premium ice <strong>cream</strong>.<br />
� Early 1990s: Rainbow and Snow White started extensive operation in the boutique segment.<br />
� Late 1990s: American S<strong>of</strong>t <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> started promoting the s<strong>of</strong>t ice <strong>cream</strong> format.<br />
� 1995: Savoy was introduced but failed due to product quality though in suburban areas they<br />
grabbed share with low price.<br />
� 1996: In September, Igloo organized a massive marketing campaign<br />
� Introduced the first straight line extrusion ice-<strong>cream</strong> in the market<br />
� They initiated a massive campaign and became market leader after 10 years<br />
� 1997: In February, Igloo took a devastating decision to increase price for the cup line<br />
� Igloo not only incurred substantial financial loss but also lost the hard earned market<br />
share. The question <strong>of</strong> sustaining became a central issue.<br />
� In summer, Price <strong>of</strong> 11 items were revised and communicated as special discount.<br />
� This instantly pushed them to the number one position.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 18
� 1999: Kwality ice-<strong>cream</strong> entered the market<br />
� 2000: <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>of</strong> the premium boutique operators like Club Gelato, MövenPick and<br />
Baskin31Robbins.<br />
� 2002: Kwality launched an extensive campaign and started to capture the ice-<strong>cream</strong> outlets <strong>of</strong> the<br />
city by providing freezers.<br />
� 2004: Kwality’s number <strong>of</strong> freezers exceeded Polar’s and moved to second position.<br />
� 2005 onwards: Igloo leads the market and there is immense competition among Polar and<br />
Kwality for the coveted 2nd spot.<br />
Historical progress <strong>of</strong> this industry is <strong>of</strong> great importance. Bangladesh ice <strong>cream</strong> industry has<br />
traditionally been exposed to high quality products for a long time. Igloo initiated the progress <strong>of</strong><br />
boutique segment (1965) but it lost its way over time. The segment picked up once again in the recent<br />
years. Also high quality products and innovations in the common format segment have created an<br />
appreciation for continuous innovation and better products in the minds <strong>of</strong> the consumers. Consumers<br />
in Bangladesh see ice <strong>cream</strong> as a fun product which requires novelty and quality coupled with<br />
continuous hype around the brand. This is why we see Kwality and Polar could create early impacts<br />
with their entry <strong>into</strong> the industry as they came up with innovations in product or packaging and<br />
arranged massive marketing campaigns during their launches. Igloo had to minimize their effects with<br />
similar campaigns to hold on to their position.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 19
5.1 Market Description<br />
5.0 MARKET & COMPETITION ANALYSIS<br />
Bangladesh ice-<strong>cream</strong> industry is growing. With increasing market demand, size <strong>of</strong> the industry is<br />
growing but due to entry barriers <strong>of</strong> lengthy and complex production process and high investment few<br />
companies enter this business. Although local companies in the branded segment have captured<br />
most <strong>of</strong> the market share, small unbranded local companies own a huge market to themselves.<br />
Where branded ice <strong>cream</strong> consumers look for innovation and quality, unbranded users outside metro<br />
cities are currently inclined towards low price low quality products. This creates an opportunity for<br />
further market development on the hygiene and health platform. On the other hand, the boutique<br />
industry is doing quite well with their approach towards ice <strong>cream</strong> as a dessert item along with service<br />
<strong>of</strong> other snacks like cakes and c<strong>of</strong>fee at their premises which help them reduce seasonality effects <strong>of</strong><br />
ice <strong>cream</strong>.<br />
With a complicated scenario in the market, to analyze the industry condition and understand the<br />
competitive realities, details <strong>of</strong> market characteristics and players <strong>of</strong> both common and boutique<br />
segments are explained in following sections. However, unbranded segment is excluded from<br />
discussion as Unilever’s portfolio does not match the characteristics and price level <strong>of</strong> this category.<br />
5.1.1 Market Characteristics <strong>of</strong> the Common Format Segment:<br />
A. Market size:<br />
Due to promotion, innovation and exposure to different cultures the consumption <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> has<br />
increased. As a result the total market size is expanding. At present the local companies in the<br />
common format segment have a huge market <strong>of</strong> about BDT 121 Cr. This market is 16 times larger<br />
than the boutique segment and nearly doubles the unbranded segment. Over the years, the size<br />
increase <strong>of</strong> the industry shows the prospect <strong>of</strong> converting unbranded unhygienic ice <strong>cream</strong> consumers<br />
<strong>into</strong> branded ice <strong>cream</strong> consumers. However, price level still remains a big problem for the branded<br />
category as petty unbranded ice <strong>cream</strong> companies with a price range <strong>of</strong> Tk.1 to Tk.5 have a total<br />
market size <strong>of</strong> BDT 79 Cr which shows a hint <strong>of</strong> high price sensitivity in lower SEC consumers.<br />
Overall market size <strong>of</strong> 220 Cr indicates that most <strong>of</strong> the people in the country are exposed to ice<br />
<strong>cream</strong> or some kinds <strong>of</strong> derivatives <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> like “Baarfi”, however, they probably cannot afford<br />
higher priced icy fruit sticks (BDT 6-10) available in the branded segment.<br />
B. Competitive rivalry in the Market:<br />
Competition is not very intense among the existing five companies because the number <strong>of</strong> operators<br />
is very small considering the total population. Also, complexities <strong>of</strong> production and distribution process<br />
and other entry barriers are stopping new companies from entering the industry.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 20
Igloo is confident about its unbeatable first position, but there is competition among other companies<br />
such as Polar and Kwality for the 2 nd position. However, in current market, no operator is showing<br />
much aggressive and visible activity towards growth. It is expected that recent announcement<br />
regarding introduction <strong>of</strong> ISIS diabetic ice <strong>cream</strong> by Polar in partnership with DANONE would again<br />
create some hype in the market.<br />
Reasons behind existing level <strong>of</strong> rivalry among competitors can be attributed to following reasons:<br />
� The ice <strong>cream</strong> industry has few sellers because there is economy <strong>of</strong> scale through large-scale<br />
production. The larger firms have a cost advantage over smaller firms; they can produce more<br />
cheaply- making it hard for small firms to survive.<br />
� Market is bigger than capability <strong>of</strong> current players and can accommodate them without much<br />
trouble. This is because PCC <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> in the country is still pretty low.<br />
� This market has substantial amount <strong>of</strong> “barriers to entry”, making it difficult for a large number <strong>of</strong><br />
competitors to enter the market. The cost <strong>of</strong> setting up a new plant in this industry is quite high.<br />
The cost <strong>of</strong> entry works as an entry barrier.<br />
� To get people to try new product, the potential entrant will have to run a big competitive<br />
advertising or massive promotional campaign, which is expensive. The prevailing companies<br />
created barriers in entry for potential rivals by using extensive advertising and product<br />
differentiation earlier which has its effects till now. Another fact is that product awareness and<br />
brand loyalty to the existing firms make it expensive for potential rivals to enter.<br />
� To further elaborate present competitive reality <strong>of</strong> the industry the five competitive forces are<br />
discussed below:<br />
� The rivalry among the competing sellers is weak as market is yet to develop more.<br />
� With various entry barriers not many new companies are attempting to enter this industry.<br />
� As there are no direct substitute products to ice-<strong>cream</strong>, the companies don’t face any<br />
competition from other industries.<br />
� As the number <strong>of</strong> suppliers is very low and, the companies especially Igloo as the best<br />
product enjoys high bargaining power or leverage over rivals. But some <strong>of</strong> the companies<br />
such as Savoy are concentrating on increasing pr<strong>of</strong>it margin <strong>of</strong> the retailers for securing a<br />
more prominent position in the market.<br />
� Mainly consumers or buyers decide the pricing. Keeping in mind the various buying power<br />
<strong>of</strong> people, the companies decide the price <strong>of</strong> each items. Price <strong>of</strong> the Items that have the<br />
most market demand is kept low so that they are in the reach <strong>of</strong> the general customers.<br />
By lowering the price some companies such as Savoy are trying to maintain a competitive<br />
edge.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 21
C. Market Sales and Growth Rate:<br />
Sales information <strong>of</strong> the five existing companies for the current years shows the following trend.<br />
Company<br />
Name<br />
2007 2008 2009<br />
Total Market 113.07 121.20 131.22<br />
Igloo 57.85 60.86 64.25<br />
Polar 16.8 18.35 20.19<br />
Kwality 30.6 33.5 37.4<br />
Savoy 3.88 4.15 4.58<br />
Milk Vita 3.94 4.34 4.88<br />
Table 9: Market Sales and Growth Rate <strong>of</strong> Branded Common Format Market<br />
Volume based market size shows the following scenario prevailing in the Bangladesh market in 2009.<br />
Company Single Vol Multi. Vol Total Vol<br />
Name<br />
Total<br />
('000 Ltrs) ('000 Ltrs) ('000 Ltrs)<br />
Market 3275.9 4296.7 7573<br />
Igloo 1676.0 2198.3 3874<br />
Polar 486.7 638.4 1125<br />
Kwality 886.5 1162.8 2049<br />
Savoy 112.4 147.4 260<br />
Milk Vita 114.1 149.7 264<br />
Table 10: Volume Based Market Size<br />
The total volume <strong>of</strong> the branded common format ice <strong>cream</strong> industry is 7500 Tons <strong>of</strong> which more than<br />
50% belongs to Igloo, followed by Kwality with 27%.<br />
D. Market Share and Size <strong>of</strong> the rivals:<br />
Market share data for all the local companies show a trend where Igloo is the biggest ice-<strong>cream</strong><br />
company dominating with a huge market share. Although even 1-2 years ago there was intense<br />
competition between Kwality and Polar but now it seems that Kwality is 2 nd largest ice-<strong>cream</strong><br />
manufacturing company in Bangladesh. Polar is in the 3 rd position with Savoy and Milk Vita trailing in<br />
the market. Market share percentage over the years is presented in the following table.<br />
Company<br />
Name<br />
2007 2008 2009<br />
Igloo 50% 50.31% 51.16%<br />
Kwality 25.6% 26.66% 27.06%<br />
Polar 17% 16.1% 14.85%<br />
Milk Vita 3.4% 3.32% 3.48%<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 22
E. Geographic Sales Orientation:<br />
Savoy 3.9% 3.65% 3.43%<br />
Table 11: Market Share <strong>of</strong> Competitors<br />
<strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> still continues to be a city-oriented product and its demand is comparatively low in the rural<br />
areas. Reasons behind this are electricity problem outside urban areas and purchasing power <strong>of</strong><br />
people. Geographic sales orientation <strong>of</strong> the common format ice <strong>cream</strong> industry is provided below.<br />
4.80% 2.50% 5.90%<br />
6.90%<br />
18.90%<br />
Dhaka Chittagong Khulna Comilla Barisal Others<br />
Figure 7: Geographic Sales Orientation<br />
Dhaka still is the largest contributor in the ice <strong>cream</strong> segment. Nevertheless, over the years this trend<br />
is shifting. Areas outside Dhaka are also growing making Dhaka’s share lower by small percentage.<br />
As urban markets are the major contributors, companies design their products keeping in mind the<br />
tastes and styles <strong>of</strong> the urban consumers. Compared to the other companies Igloo is the most<br />
expensive in the common format segment, so they target only city based customers who have the<br />
purchasing power. Although other companies such as Savoy are <strong>of</strong>fering low priced product, even<br />
their main target is urban people due to nation wide electricity problem.<br />
F. Seasonality <strong>of</strong> Sales:<br />
<strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> industries in warmer part <strong>of</strong> the world are highly seasonal. Same is true with Bangladesh.<br />
According to secondary data sources sales seasonality looks as follows:<br />
61%<br />
Period Name Months Contribution<br />
Super-Peak April, May, June 46%<br />
Peak March, July, August 36%<br />
Off-Peak February, September, October, November 15%<br />
Super Off-Peak December, January 3%<br />
Table 12: Seasonality <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Sales<br />
This data was validated through interviews with retailers during market visit. According to them more<br />
than 75% sales <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> came in the hot months. Another insight that could be identified was<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 23
various festivals and programmes provide scope for higher volume <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> sales. According to<br />
companies where only 10-15% sales occurs in the winter season, same amount <strong>of</strong> sales occurs<br />
during festivals like the two Eids and Nobobarsha.<br />
G. Distribution/ Servicing System:<br />
Mainly common format ice-<strong>cream</strong> is distributed in two methods that are directly to retail shops and<br />
through hawkers with ice <strong>cream</strong> carts/ trolleys.<br />
The various channels <strong>of</strong> retail shops other than cart that serve as distribution outlets for <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong><br />
are:<br />
7. Urban General Stores (UGS)<br />
8. Urban Neighbourhood Grocer (UNG)<br />
9. Premium General Store (PGS)/ SMMT<br />
10. Confectionary/ Bakery<br />
11. Modern Trade (MT)<br />
12. Fast Food shops (Recently some fast food shops keep branded ice <strong>cream</strong> cabinets)<br />
Distribution details <strong>of</strong> all the companies are provided below. However, detail <strong>of</strong> Milk Vita is not<br />
available as they are mainly milk producer and they have no dedicated ice <strong>cream</strong> cabinet for retail<br />
stores and currently they are not distributing ice <strong>cream</strong> in Dhaka city.<br />
Company<br />
Distribution<br />
Method Frequency<br />
No. <strong>of</strong><br />
Cabinets<br />
No. <strong>of</strong><br />
Carts<br />
Igloo Distributor/ Cart 2 to 3 times a week 4000 100<br />
Kwality Distributor/ Cart 1 to 2 times a week 1050 20<br />
Polar Distributor/ Cart 1 to 2 times a week 800 50<br />
Savoy Company 1 to 2 times a fortnight 176 -<br />
Milk-Vita - - - -<br />
Table 13: Distribution Method <strong>of</strong> Market Players<br />
Distribution Process: Distribution process through both methods is described below.<br />
Retail Distribution: The general distribution that is followed by companies is that distributor sends<br />
large refrigerated trucks dedicated to specific territories. These trucks are accompanied by small<br />
refrigerated vans. Main road side shops are served directly from the large truck and shops that are<br />
inside small streets are served by the small vans.<br />
Order and delivery are done on the same day. The strategy followed is that <strong>of</strong> replenishment. If the<br />
branded freezer <strong>of</strong> the company is empty, they simply fill it up according to requirement <strong>of</strong> different<br />
SKUs as the delivery people see fit. However, shopkeepers have to buy full cartons (usually 24 pieces<br />
in a carton) <strong>of</strong> single serve ice <strong>cream</strong>; they cannot buy in pieces.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 24
Among the retail shops, there are about equal numbers <strong>of</strong> branded and unbranded freezers. This is a<br />
normal scene in Dhaka where all shopkeepers require freezer to keep other cold products. However,<br />
basic distribution policy is that, if a shop has branded cabinet <strong>of</strong> a company, they cannot keep<br />
competitor ice <strong>cream</strong> in that cabinet. Thus, penetration can be made possible in shops where<br />
unbranded freezers are available.<br />
General branded freezer contract policy with Igloo and Polar is that traders have to pay BDT 5000 to<br />
take a freezer. Maintenance <strong>of</strong> branded freezers is responsibility <strong>of</strong> the company but electricity bill is<br />
paid by shopkeeper. However, Polar is not currently giving any new freezer. Kwality gave away their<br />
freezers for free; however, they ensured safety <strong>of</strong> their freezers by checking background <strong>of</strong> the<br />
shopkeepers.<br />
Cart sellers: Cart sellers collect required amount <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> from nearby distribution house or<br />
company showroom (Igloo has one showroom in Panthapath) on a daily basis. They also have to buy<br />
cartons <strong>of</strong> products, not pieces. Kwality carts collect their ice <strong>cream</strong> from factory (Tejgaon) or nearby<br />
distribution house. Cart sellers contribute around BDT 3000 sales in a day and generally sell at BDT<br />
1-2 higher than set price <strong>of</strong> each product.<br />
The cart sellers generally keep at least a two-day stock so that they can meet sudden upsurge in daily<br />
demand <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> or if they get the opportunity to sell at parties, programs or any open air event<br />
(Wedding at community centres or outside cultural programs at auditoriums). If cart sellers need<br />
replenishment <strong>of</strong> stock, they even take service more than once in a day either revisiting showroom/<br />
house or they call up company delivery people to serve them at their location if there is opportunity for<br />
selling more ice <strong>cream</strong>.<br />
Policy regarding Damaged <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong>: All the ice <strong>cream</strong> producers have very good relationship with<br />
the shopkeepers. If the retailers have refrigeration problem, company takes ice <strong>cream</strong> back until the<br />
problem is fixed, whether it is stored in branded freezer or not. Also if any ice <strong>cream</strong> gets damaged or<br />
there is bacterial formation, company takes them back. Usual return time varies from 15-30 days. For<br />
large sellers however, they take less time.<br />
Payment Method for <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Purchase: All the companies give credit <strong>of</strong> around one month to<br />
large volume contributing retail sellers and try to maintain good relationship with them. This trend is<br />
seen in all channels. Also all the SMMTs and MTs are given credit <strong>of</strong> one month and payment is<br />
made by cheque. Other small shopkeepers have to purchase with cash. However, according to<br />
shopkeepers Igloo is currently trying to cut down on credit sales as they believe there is a consumer<br />
pull for their brand. Companies like Polar and Kwality also give special commission to large sellers.<br />
Polar gives 5% commission on every bill.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 25
H. Technology and Innovation:<br />
Technological advancement in the ice <strong>cream</strong> industry has been very rapid. Starting with stick mould<br />
and filler ice <strong>cream</strong> production, the companies have come a long way. Assessing the consumer<br />
choice and demand the companies are introducing new products very <strong>of</strong>ten. Improved and new<br />
technology is used for faster production and better quality. Igloo is trying to meet the international<br />
standards and launching products such as Sundae, Cornelli, and Nuggets. Other companies are also<br />
introducing new flavours suitable for their target segments. Igloo has both the ISO and the HACCP<br />
certifications. These were awarded in the year 2003 due to their relentless pursuit <strong>of</strong> quality and<br />
innovation. In September 1996, Igloo introduced the 3D Mould line and straight line extrusion<br />
technology for the first time in the subcontinent. Basically, with Igloo’s pursuit, all the modern<br />
technologies and quality innovations are available in the market.<br />
I. Production Capacity:<br />
Current production capacity <strong>of</strong> the major players in the common format ice <strong>cream</strong> segment is<br />
estimated to be as follows:<br />
Name<br />
Capacity<br />
(Ltrs/ day)<br />
Total<br />
Production<br />
('000 Ltrs)<br />
Required<br />
Capacity (at 300<br />
production days )<br />
Estimated unutilized<br />
capacity (Ltrs/ day)<br />
Igloo 22000 3874.33 12914 9086<br />
Polar 6500 1125.13 3750 2750<br />
Kwality 12100 2049.34 6831 5269<br />
Savoy 1560 259.85 866 694<br />
Milk Vita 1330 263.87 880 450<br />
Table 14: Production Capacity <strong>of</strong> Current Market Players<br />
From the table we can see that all the ice <strong>cream</strong> manufacturers are operating with unutilized capacity.<br />
However, one point to be noted is that different ice <strong>cream</strong> SKUs require different amount <strong>of</strong> item to be<br />
produced. Exact machine production capacity at litre per day does not represent the accurate<br />
scenario. Nevertheless, it can be safely assumed that all the manufacturers have unused machine<br />
capacity at their premises. Moreover, the larger players like Polar and Kwality have new technology<br />
available at their premises. Kwality bought second hand machines from Thailand but both Igloo and<br />
Polar bought their’s from Italy and Denmark.<br />
J. Products and Pricing:<br />
Products: The products in the ice-<strong>cream</strong> market are differentiated. A few firms dominate the market,<br />
but an endless variety <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong>s are <strong>of</strong>fered to the consumers. Igloo pioneers all major<br />
innovations in the market. The products that are available in the market can be classified <strong>into</strong> single<br />
serving and multiple serving groups. Which are then categorized based on functional attributes/<br />
designs. These are:<br />
Single Stick Normal mould, 3D mould, extrusion<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 26
serving<br />
Multiple<br />
Cup and Sundae Flat cup, long cup<br />
Cone Normal cone (vanilla, strawberry etc), premium cone (Ripple)<br />
Innovative Fillers Snowball, Animal shaped containers, sandwich, nuggets etc<br />
Container 0.5 ltr, 1 ltr and 2 ltr containers<br />
serving Family Pack Assorted packs, cakes, shahi kulfi etc<br />
Table 15: <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Serve types<br />
Among all the products available in the market, most selling SKU for all the companies is Choc-bar<br />
stick and highest selling flavour is Vanilla. Following are the ranks <strong>of</strong> most selling SKUs and flavours.<br />
SKU Name Rank<br />
Choc-bar (70 ml) 1<br />
Vanilla Cup (100 ml) 2<br />
Vanilla Box (0.5 and 1 Ltr) 3<br />
Lemon Lolly (70 ml) 4<br />
Normal Cone 5<br />
Flavour Rank<br />
Vanilla 1<br />
Chocolate 2<br />
Strawberry 3<br />
Ripple 4<br />
Mango 5<br />
Table 16: Rank <strong>of</strong> SKUs Table 17: Rank <strong>of</strong> Flavours<br />
Choc-bar is one <strong>of</strong> the earliest vanilla based chocolate coated SKU that has dominated the market<br />
strongly over the years. Shopkeepers could not provide an exact percentage on SKU based sales<br />
contribution. Most <strong>of</strong> them ranked the SKUs and flavours according to sequence shown in the above<br />
table. Also, according to newspapers and secondary sources Vanilla is the most selling flavour with<br />
60% sales contribution. According to secondary sources percentage sales contribution <strong>of</strong> various<br />
types <strong>of</strong> SKUs in the common format segment are as follows:<br />
Type <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong><br />
Value<br />
Share<br />
Volume<br />
Share<br />
Impulse dairy ice <strong>cream</strong> 51.4% 44.3%<br />
Impulse water ice <strong>cream</strong> 11.2% 13.8%<br />
Take-home dairy ice <strong>cream</strong> 37.4% 41.9%<br />
Table 18: Volume Share <strong>of</strong> Different Serve Types<br />
Impulse dairy ice <strong>cream</strong> provides more value share as price per litre is higher than take home multiple<br />
serving ice <strong>cream</strong>s. Impulse water ice <strong>cream</strong> shows a similar trend as <strong>of</strong> take home ice <strong>cream</strong>.<br />
Pricing: Product pictures and price ranges <strong>of</strong> each category are provided below.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 27
Stick<br />
Cup<br />
&<br />
Sundae<br />
Normal Cup Sundae Premium Cup<br />
Price Tk.12 Tk.20 Tk.25<br />
Cone<br />
Normal Premium<br />
Price Tk.20 Tk.25<br />
Container<br />
Normal <strong>Ice</strong> Fruit Normal Cream 3D Mould Premium Extrusion<br />
Price Tk.10 Tk.15 Tk.15 Tk.20<br />
Normal Premium<br />
Price/Ltr. Tk.100 Tk.175<br />
Innovative<br />
Fillers<br />
Normal Premium<br />
Price Tk.20 Tk.25<br />
Family<br />
Packs<br />
Kulfi Cake Mixed Pack<br />
Price/Ltr. Tk.150 Tk 175 Tk 190<br />
Figure 8: Serve Types and Pricing<br />
Single<br />
Serving<br />
Multiple<br />
Serving<br />
As it can be seen from the above chart, all impulse ice <strong>cream</strong>s are priced within the range <strong>of</strong> BDT 10<br />
to 25. Other take home multiple servings are priced within the range <strong>of</strong> BDT 50 (0.5 Litres) to BDT<br />
220 (2 Litres). Another noticeable factor in price is that there are both normal and premium flavours in<br />
all types <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong>s.<br />
K. Firms as Price Setters:<br />
The firms have capability to affect the market price to be low as pr<strong>of</strong>it margin is very high. If Igloo<br />
reduces the price <strong>of</strong> an item below the prevailing price level in order to increase its sales, its<br />
competitors will fear that their customers will go away from them to buy Igloo products. To retain their<br />
customers they will be forced to match the price cut <strong>of</strong> Igloo. Historically this has been proven to be<br />
true. However, due to price sensitivity, companies cannot drastically increase price even if they<br />
provide higher quality <strong>of</strong> product. It was seen in 1997 when Igloo increased price <strong>of</strong> 11 SKUs and<br />
faced drastic sales fall during that time. It shows that the industry might welcome overall industry price<br />
increase but not individual company price increase.<br />
L. Promotion:<br />
The promotion scenario in the industry is not quite organized as <strong>of</strong> now. Even proper data regarding<br />
promotional expenditure is not available from research sources. The reason being, there is not much<br />
consumer related activity seen in the market. After Kwality’s introduction in the market in 1999, Igloo<br />
went on with massive Television promotion <strong>of</strong> their new products that were available at that time.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 28
However, in current times there is no TVC running from any company. Companies promote their<br />
launches mainly through billboards and newspaper promotions which is currently the most used<br />
source <strong>of</strong> consumer promotion. Some promotional activities that were done by the companies over<br />
the years are listed below.<br />
Consumer Promotions:<br />
1. Larger players like Igloo and Kwality goes on with campaigns like “Gift on stick” where various<br />
prizes’ names are written on the sticks and consumers can get them.<br />
a. Igloo ran a program on their launch <strong>of</strong> Macho variant where gift varied from cricket<br />
bat to personal computer.<br />
b. Igloo had a program in 2006 where gifts on sticks varied from Bangkok visit to<br />
sunglass.<br />
c. Igloo ran one campaign in 2007 where gold bars were given on purchasing Choc-bar.<br />
d. Kwality ran a similar program in 2008 where gifts varied from wrist watches to<br />
motorcycle.<br />
2. Some companies ran consumer TTS and gift programs where company products were given<br />
free.<br />
a. Igloo had a program in 2006 where Igloo butter was given free on purchasing Igloo<br />
ice <strong>cream</strong> cake.<br />
b. Kwality ran a program in 2008 where one SKU was given as gift with another SKU<br />
randomly.<br />
c. “Cone <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> at your Home” program was run by Igloo in 2002 where six cone<br />
biscuits were given free with purchase <strong>of</strong> one litre ice <strong>cream</strong>.<br />
3. Media placement is another form <strong>of</strong> placement done by larger companies.<br />
a. Igloo purchased “Glimpse <strong>into</strong> World Cup Result” space in daily newspapers during<br />
World Cup Football 2002.<br />
4. One interesting program is done by only Igloo in Bangladesh. They did it in June 2006. The<br />
program was “Igloo <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Festival” with main attractions <strong>of</strong> “Get as much ice <strong>cream</strong> as<br />
you want for BDT 200”, “Get a Fantasy Kingdom <strong>Entry</strong> ticket with each <strong>Entry</strong> Coupon”, “Lucky<br />
Draw” and “Celebrity Adda”.<br />
Trade Promotions:<br />
5. Trade promotions are mainly given to “Highest retail purchasers” and also based on time<br />
bound trade schemes where various slabs <strong>of</strong> purchase amount are mentioned for different<br />
prizes.<br />
a. Igloo takes their highest purchasers to visit countries like Singapore and Thailand.<br />
b. Savoy has a purchase slab scheme where first prize is table fan.<br />
c. Polar gives special sales commission to their highest purchasers (around 5%).<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 29
M. Players in the Common Format Segment:<br />
Branded common format ice <strong>cream</strong> segment is constituted <strong>of</strong> five players only. Among them Igloo is<br />
the largest player and Milk Vita is the smallest. The following sections detail the basic company detail<br />
<strong>of</strong> all the companies with special emphasis on Igloo, the market leader.<br />
Igloo:<br />
The pioneering ice-<strong>cream</strong> company in Bangladesh started its operation in 1964 in Chittagong under K<br />
Rahman & Co. Limited (KRC) with a small factory inside Coca Cola bottling factory <strong>of</strong> KRC. After the<br />
independence <strong>of</strong> Bangladesh in 1971 Igloo was taken over by the government <strong>of</strong> Bangladesh. Later in<br />
1983, Abdul Monem Limited purchased the entire production setup <strong>of</strong> KRC Limited including Coca-<br />
Cola bottling plant and Igloo ice-<strong>cream</strong> factory. After taking full charge <strong>of</strong> Igloo ice-<strong>cream</strong> by Abdul<br />
Monem Limited the manufacturing operations continued in Chittagong till 1990. Although, Dhaka<br />
fetched the maximum share <strong>of</strong> the total revenue, the distribution cost increased tremendously in the<br />
process <strong>of</strong> meeting the demand <strong>of</strong> Dhaka city. To cope with the distribution problem and handle Polar<br />
threat, Abdul Monem Limited transferred the factory to Dhaka, changed the ice-<strong>cream</strong> packaging from<br />
the conventional paper to plastic and expanded their market and distribution operation. The new<br />
factory <strong>of</strong> Igloo was setup at Shyampur, Narayanganj and was nine kilometres away from the<br />
Motijheel <strong>of</strong>fice. The company apart from catering the capital city started to expand its operations in<br />
Comilla (1991), Khulna (1992), and North Bengal (1993). These markets were served directly from<br />
Dhaka since the storage facilities were not developed till then. The company is now the market leader<br />
since 1997 with clear market share victory over others with sweeping 51% share. It is to be noted that<br />
Igloo is also a player in the boutique segment with three parlours (2 in Dhaka and 1 in Chittagong).<br />
Product Range: Igloo <strong>of</strong>fers the widest choice <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong>, more than any other competitor in the<br />
market. Igloo is <strong>of</strong>fering a total <strong>of</strong> fifty items, including normal premium and novelty cup, stick and<br />
family pack items. Igloo has thirty flavours, more than anyone else in the industry and is continuously<br />
launching new and innovative delicacies.<br />
Igloo ice-<strong>cream</strong> can be classified in six groups. They are:<br />
Stick Macho, Choc-bar, Mini Choc, Clown, Mega, Shell n core, Lolly<br />
Cone Cornelli 2 in one, Cornelli classic<br />
Cup Shahi kulfi, Vanilla, Strawberry, Mango, Snow ball<br />
Container Vanilla, Strawberry, Mango, Chocolate, C<strong>of</strong>fee, Diet Vanilla, Tutti<br />
Frutti, Ripple, Pralin, Pistachio<br />
Innovative Nuggets, Sandwich<br />
Family Ripple cake, Party time, Shahi Kulfi<br />
Table 19: Products <strong>of</strong> Igloo<br />
Single serve stick, cups and cone items are easy to carry around and convenient to eat which makes<br />
it most sold. The core target segment <strong>of</strong> ice-<strong>cream</strong> is 6-24 years and this generation is always on the<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 30
move and thus prefers independent cone, stick or cup items. As Igloo initiated the concept <strong>of</strong> ice-<br />
<strong>cream</strong> as a family product, they <strong>of</strong>fer some items to be enjoyed with the whole family.<br />
Quality and Innovation: Igloo is committed to maintaining the highest quality standard, through its<br />
continuous R&D activities. The major ingredients, raw materials and packing materials are procured<br />
from the best European sources. Strict quality control is done at every stage <strong>of</strong> the manufacturing<br />
process, from procurement <strong>of</strong> material, mixing, material flow, ice <strong>cream</strong> making, packaging, storing (at<br />
main warehouse), distributing and market shelving, by the Quality Control Department. Current supply<br />
chain for various materials <strong>of</strong> Igloo is as follows:<br />
Australia<br />
(Milk Powder)<br />
Denmark<br />
(Ingredients,<br />
emulsifiers &<br />
stabilizers)<br />
Figure 9: Igloo Supply Chain<br />
China, Denmark,<br />
Singapore &<br />
Thailand<br />
(Food grade<br />
packing materials)<br />
China & UAE<br />
(Food grade<br />
sticks)<br />
Distribution Network: Their distribution network is stretched all over the country with a long fleet <strong>of</strong><br />
refrigerated vans. Firstly, the ice <strong>cream</strong> products are stored at the central warehouse <strong>of</strong> the factory,<br />
and from there they are distributed through the haulage vehicle to the operational centres located in<br />
Dhaka, Chittagong, Comilla, Rajshahi, Barisal, Bogra, Rangpur and Khulna. Strictest cold chain<br />
maintenance during the distribution and selling <strong>of</strong> the ice <strong>cream</strong>s is ensured. Their distribution process<br />
is as follows:<br />
Manufacture Stored at -24c Transported by<br />
Refrigerated trucks at -<br />
Retail outlets<br />
(Deep freezers)<br />
Refrigerated<br />
vehicles<br />
(Distributors)<br />
Figure 10: Distribution Process <strong>of</strong> Igloo<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 31<br />
Reaches &<br />
Preserved in<br />
Eight regional stores
Trolley Operation: Igloo also operates through trolleys for extending its reach to consumers at the<br />
furthest points. The trolleys are operated near schools, alleys, streets, parks etc. and play rhythmic<br />
music to attract the consumers. These are very colourfully decorated with Igloo umbrella and the<br />
puller wears specific uniforms. Igloo was the first in introducing and operating these trolleys in<br />
Bangladesh for any Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG). Igloo has around 125 trolleys operating<br />
throughout the country. Individual trolleys are provided with a regular supply <strong>of</strong> igloo ice <strong>cream</strong>s.<br />
Marketing: The marketing commitment <strong>of</strong> Igloo is based on the relationship with its customers and<br />
consumer by not only manufacturing the highest quality product but also delivering the product by<br />
maintaining this quality. To satisfy the ever-changing needs <strong>of</strong> the customer, Igloo has regularly<br />
launched new ice <strong>cream</strong>s and introduced new flavours. And this commitment has positioned Igloo as<br />
the market-leading brand by gaining the consumers trust with the positioning as: “A WORLD OF<br />
GREAT TASTE”.<br />
Facilities and Logistics at a glance: As <strong>of</strong> 2009, following are the facilities and logistics enjoyed by<br />
the company.<br />
Kwality:<br />
Factory location Dhaka<br />
Production Lines 4<br />
Packages<br />
Stick, Cup, Family pack, Others (Nuggets<br />
and sandwich)<br />
� Mark-Italy<br />
Machine suppliers<br />
�<br />
�<br />
Tetra Pak(Hoyer)-Denmark<br />
Sabore, Denmark<br />
� Hass- Austria<br />
� Freemark 1100, Italy<br />
Machine models<br />
� FM 3000, FM 6000, Italy<br />
� SL600, Denmark<br />
Cone baking Hass- Austria<br />
Chocolate making Macentyre-UK<br />
Coverage Nationwide<br />
Operational centre 10<br />
Total market vehicles 30<br />
Distribution channel Direct/through appointed distributors<br />
Outlet service 7500<br />
Injected deep freezers 4000<br />
Trolley operations 125<br />
Warehouse no 8<br />
Table 20: Igloo Facilities and Logistics<br />
Kwality is currently the second largest ice <strong>cream</strong> manufacturer <strong>of</strong> the country. The mother company<br />
for the Kwality brand is Sanowara Drinks & Beverages Ltd, a sister concern <strong>of</strong> Sanowara Group. The<br />
company is famous for powdered milk brands Red Cow and Diploma in Bangladesh. The drinks and<br />
beverage concern <strong>of</strong> Sanowara made an entry <strong>into</strong> the market in 1997 with “Yes” brand drinking water<br />
and launched the ice <strong>cream</strong> brand in 1999. With heavy communication and novelty products it<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 32
successfully removed Polar from the second place with a current market share <strong>of</strong> 27%. The company<br />
also operates in the boutique segment with two parlours in Dhaka and Chittagong.<br />
Kwality ice <strong>cream</strong> factory is situated in Chittagong with a floor space <strong>of</strong> 35,000 sft and fully automated<br />
machinery/ wrapping/ mix machinery equipments from Italy having capacity <strong>of</strong> around 20,000 litres <strong>of</strong><br />
ice <strong>cream</strong> per shift. The ice <strong>cream</strong> factory employs 140 people. The company is ISO 9001-2000<br />
certified.<br />
Kwality was the first true competitor for Igloo products with some major innovation in product design<br />
and communication but their quality is perceived to be lower in the minds <strong>of</strong> the consumers and they<br />
do not have extrusion ice <strong>cream</strong>. The product prices are also similar to that <strong>of</strong> Igloo but they charge a<br />
bit lower than Igloo in premium multiple servings. However, during market visits it was seen that<br />
shops that keep only Kwality or Igloo and Kwality both, they can sell Kwality too although the sales<br />
amount is lower than that <strong>of</strong> Igloo. People who look for Igloo, shopkeepers give them that directly but<br />
if they get a chance and Kwality ice <strong>cream</strong> stock is high, they also push Kwality to dry the stock out.<br />
This gives an indication that market is larger than what the current players are capable <strong>of</strong> serving<br />
even in Dhaka.<br />
Kwality follows a similar distribution model like Igloo but distribution frequency is lower and amount <strong>of</strong><br />
cart sellers is limited to 25 and they operate only in Dhaka.<br />
Polar:<br />
Once a giant in the industry, Dhaka <strong>Ice</strong> Cream Industries Ltd. introduced the first hygienically packed<br />
ice <strong>cream</strong> in Bangladesh in 1987 and the brand name "Polar" was thus born. In the early days, the<br />
company started ice <strong>cream</strong> business with a wide range <strong>of</strong> products and a variety <strong>of</strong> flavours in Dhaka<br />
city. In 1988, the company started its distribution in the city <strong>of</strong> Chittagong, then Bogra, and continued<br />
to cover more cities. Presently, Polar ice <strong>cream</strong> is available throughout Bangladesh. The company<br />
today trails in the market with 15% market share in the common format segment. Recently, Polar has<br />
announced launch <strong>of</strong> ISIS diabetic ice <strong>cream</strong> with support from DANONE to turn around in the market.<br />
The company has its head <strong>of</strong>fice, as well as a modern, large-scale industrial plant in Dhaka. Polar ice<br />
<strong>cream</strong> is made with Danish expertise, using Danish equipment and technology. The production<br />
activities and quality control measures are supervised and managed by Danish experts. Polar <strong>of</strong>fers a<br />
wide range <strong>of</strong> delicious flavours and tastes made by ingredients imported from Europe.<br />
Dhaka <strong>Ice</strong> Cream at present has 3 cold stores in Dhaka, Chittagong and Bogra, in Bangladesh. From<br />
Dhaka cold store, they distribute ice <strong>cream</strong>s in Mymensingh, Tangail, Jamalpur, Sherpur, Kishoreganj,<br />
Netrakona, Comilla, Narsingdi, Barisal, Madaripur, Agaeljhara, Faridpur, Magura, Chuadanga,<br />
Jessore, Satkhira, Khulna, Pirojpur and Sylhet through their distributors. In case <strong>of</strong> long distance<br />
delivery points, the company uses auto cooling freezer van.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 33
In Dhaka city, they distribute ice <strong>cream</strong>s directly to retail stores in freezer vans. Besides that, they<br />
have several distributors at different points <strong>of</strong> the city. Distributors cover their individual areas where<br />
company is not able to supply directly in their freezer vans. Similar model is followed by the company<br />
to distribute ice <strong>cream</strong> from their other cold storages through out the country. For storing and selling<br />
ice <strong>cream</strong>s in retail stores, the company like the other players arranges a deep freezer with the Polar<br />
logo and canopy light box.<br />
In addition to this distribution, the company also undertakes home delivery <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong>s for special<br />
occasions.<br />
Savoy:<br />
Savoy <strong>Ice</strong>-<strong>cream</strong> brand is owned by Sena Kalyan Sangstha (SKS) Group <strong>of</strong> industries. It started its<br />
journey in March 1995 with a factory in Tejgaon, Dhaka. Yearly turnover is estimated at BDT 3.88<br />
crores with a market share <strong>of</strong> roughly 3.5%.<br />
The factory has been established with Sonali Bank finance at 60:40 equity ratio. The total production<br />
capacity <strong>of</strong> the factory has been estimated at 2400 litres <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ice</strong>-<strong>cream</strong> per day. Total land area <strong>of</strong> the<br />
factory premise is 1.16 Bigha with 8,000 sft area covered with a total project cost <strong>of</strong> BDT 1.44. The<br />
factory employs 73 people.<br />
Product ranges <strong>of</strong> the company include all the basic designs and flavours <strong>of</strong> the industry. However,<br />
the company has not been much <strong>of</strong> an innovator in the industry. Their product quality is substantially<br />
low than that <strong>of</strong> other players and they price their products at 10-15% lower than the other<br />
competitors. The company imports raw materials mainly from Europe. The general raw materials are<br />
Euro <strong>cream</strong>, Skimmed Milk Powder, Cocoa Powder and Flavour (Vanilla, Mango and Strawberry),<br />
Colour (Yellow, Red, Chocolate and Green), Ripple Sauce, Cheney Fruit, Palm Kernel Oil,<br />
Anhydrous, Butter Oil (Ghee) and Sugar etc.<br />
Milk Vita:<br />
Milk Vita is one <strong>of</strong> the most famous brand names in Bangladesh for its liquid dairy milk. Owned by<br />
Bangladesh Milk Producers’ Co-operative Union Limited (BMPCUL), the company came in the market<br />
with proper dairy milk ice <strong>cream</strong> in form <strong>of</strong> cups and choc-bar. With a production capacity <strong>of</strong> around<br />
1600 litres per day, the company is trailing in the market place with 3% market share.<br />
Although the Milk Vita Choc-bar was perceived to be extremely tasty by consumers, they probably<br />
could not do well due price competition. Currently they do not even distribute ice <strong>cream</strong> in Dhaka.<br />
However, their presence is seen in outskirts <strong>of</strong> Dhaka and other nearby towns.<br />
If the current market situation prevails, Milk Vita would lose their remaining market share and other<br />
companies would benefit, especially Igloo. However, one <strong>of</strong> the advantages <strong>of</strong> Milk Vita remains to be<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 34
their nation wide milk supply network. They have skimmed milk powder production plant that Igloo<br />
does not have. Thus, they can combat the seasonality <strong>of</strong> milk supply that Igloo with its huge<br />
requirement <strong>of</strong> milk cannot.<br />
Strengths and Weaknesses <strong>of</strong> Competitors:<br />
Company Strengths Weaknesses<br />
Igloo<br />
Kwality<br />
Polar<br />
Savoy<br />
Milk Vita<br />
� Strong brand image<br />
� High product quality<br />
� Highest no. <strong>of</strong> variety<br />
� Strong distribution network<br />
� Highest visibility<br />
� Strong promotion<br />
� High production capacity<br />
� Presence <strong>of</strong> extrusion ice <strong>cream</strong><br />
� Product variety<br />
� Strong promotion<br />
� Free freezer distributed<br />
� Presence in all price segments<br />
� High production capacity<br />
� Free freezer<br />
� Quality perceived to be high<br />
compared to Kwality<br />
� Items are generally a bit pricy<br />
� Igloo does not give free freezers like<br />
other companies.<br />
� Reluctant in recent times regarding<br />
innovation<br />
� Local sourcing <strong>of</strong> liquid milk does not<br />
meet demand<br />
� Failure to use ERP technology,<br />
slowing decision making<br />
� Weak distribution<br />
� Lower exposure<br />
� low amount <strong>of</strong> carts in operation<br />
� Discoloured freezers<br />
� Lower exposure<br />
� Low product variety<br />
� Unused capacity<br />
� Price is lower � Discoloured freezers<br />
� Low product variety<br />
� Weak distribution<br />
� Small amount <strong>of</strong> freezers<br />
� Low production capacity<br />
� Quality is good due to dairy <strong>cream</strong><br />
� Brand leverage from Milk Vita milk<br />
Table 21: Strengths and Weaknesses <strong>of</strong> Competition<br />
5.1.2 Market Characteristics <strong>of</strong> the Boutique Segment:<br />
� Low exposure<br />
� Low variety<br />
With a small market <strong>of</strong> BDT 9.8 Cr and 5.67% share in the branded ice <strong>cream</strong> market, the boutique<br />
segment is currently an increasing segment in the ice <strong>cream</strong> industry. Boutique segment’s history<br />
dates back to 1960s when Igloo launched boutiques in Dhaka to save distribution cost and promote a<br />
culture <strong>of</strong> “ice <strong>cream</strong> eating out”. In later years, boutiques lost their glamour and retail common format<br />
segment picked up growth. However, with Dolce Vita in the late ‘80s, craze for Italian Artisan ice<br />
<strong>cream</strong> was recreated in the market. Although Dolce Vita is failing in recent times, emergence <strong>of</strong><br />
MövenPick and Club Gelato in 2000 has uplifted the segment once again. Current growth rate <strong>of</strong> the<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 35
segment can be estimated to be approx. 20-22% (higher than the common format segment).<br />
Following are the basic detail <strong>of</strong> all the major players in the segment with their estimated sales 3 .<br />
A. Detail <strong>of</strong> Operation:<br />
Players Outlet #<br />
Sales<br />
(Cr Taka) Share<br />
Club Gelato 1 1.36 19.9%<br />
MövenPick 1 1.19 17.4%<br />
Andersen’s 3 1.19 17.4%<br />
Gelateria Igloo 3 1.19 17.4%<br />
Sub Zero (Kwality) 2 0.51 7.5%<br />
Baskin Robbins 1 0.15 2.2%<br />
Dolce Vita 1 0.17 2.5%<br />
American S<strong>of</strong>t 1 0.09 1.2%<br />
Rainbow 1 0.09 1.2%<br />
Others (<strong>of</strong>f site) 0.89 13.0%<br />
Total Market 6.82<br />
Table 22: Players and Shares in Boutique Segment<br />
General operational procedure followed by all the operators is as follows:<br />
� Operating method: There is a variation in operational method among the large operators.<br />
� Club Gelato uses kitchen at own premise where imported ingredients and local milk (daily<br />
special service from Milk Vita) are used to make ice <strong>cream</strong>.<br />
� MövenPick directly imports ice <strong>cream</strong> from Switzerland.<br />
� Andersen’s, Gelateria Igloo and Sub Zero produce ice <strong>cream</strong> at their factory with a mix <strong>of</strong><br />
imported and local ingredients.<br />
� Products: Around 30-35 flavours <strong>of</strong> artisan dairy ice <strong>cream</strong> are served at the premises.<br />
� Most sold flavours are Vanilla, Ferrero Rocher, Butterscotch, Chocolate, Caramel etc<br />
� Other Products: Larger players also serve ice <strong>cream</strong> desserts (milk shakes, ice cappuccino etc),<br />
pastries and other desserts with normal c<strong>of</strong>fee and tea facility at their premises.<br />
� Boutiques fight ice <strong>cream</strong> seasonality with the other products sales during <strong>of</strong>f-peak ice <strong>cream</strong><br />
seasons. Usually ice <strong>cream</strong> and other products contribute at 60:40 ratio in summer and during<br />
winter and <strong>of</strong>f-peak seasons the ratio reverses.<br />
� Pricing: Usually the prices <strong>of</strong> products in this segment are 3-4 times higher than that <strong>of</strong> the<br />
common format segment.<br />
� Prices do not vary with flavours. Variation depends on serve style (Cone/ tub) and use <strong>of</strong><br />
toppings and other ingredients (Chocolate sauce/ nut/ fruits) etc.<br />
� Usual margin charged is around 50-60% over production cost. Similar margin is charged for<br />
other products like c<strong>of</strong>fee, ice cappuccino etc.<br />
3 Yearly sales is estimated based on company’s approximate daily sales collected during interview<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 36
� Target Group: Most <strong>of</strong> the consumers belong to SEC A and higher SEC A with DMFI <strong>of</strong> at least<br />
BDT 20,000.<br />
� Foreign delegates and resident foreigners also visit these boutiques.<br />
� Main purposes <strong>of</strong> visits in the boutiques are:<br />
• Youth: hangout with friends and having ice <strong>cream</strong> and ice <strong>cream</strong> derivatives<br />
• Family: Family night out or eat out at a restaurant and then having dessert<br />
• Foreigners: Having dessert after dinner<br />
� Rush time at boutiques are: Afternoon 2-4 pm and at night 9-11 pm.<br />
� Offsite sales: Most <strong>of</strong> the large operators also sell <strong>of</strong>fsite. They have small freezers for <strong>of</strong>f-site.<br />
� Club Gelato and MövenPick serves ice <strong>cream</strong> at high society parties and programmes.<br />
� MövenPick also has kiosks in known hotels like Sheraton.<br />
� Promotion: No mass promotion is done by any <strong>of</strong> the companies. Word <strong>of</strong> mouth is the most<br />
important source <strong>of</strong> promotion. Posters and banners outside the premise and occasional<br />
newspaper advertisements are used to communicate special <strong>of</strong>fers.<br />
� Growth Drivers: Market growth is driven by image, innovation, quality, decoration <strong>of</strong> facility,<br />
environment and special <strong>of</strong>fers.<br />
� Club Gelato has the image <strong>of</strong> selling true Italian dairy ice <strong>cream</strong> with an excellent hangout<br />
environment.<br />
� MövenPick imports ice <strong>cream</strong> directly from Switzerland and is perceived to be <strong>of</strong> high quality.<br />
� Andersen’s operates with the image <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> from Denmark<br />
� Gelateria Igloo (from Igloo) and Sub Zero (from Kwality) could not establish the premium<br />
artisan ice <strong>cream</strong> image.<br />
B. Players in the Boutique Segment:<br />
There are very few players who have significant impact in the boutique segment. Detailed information<br />
<strong>of</strong> all the major boutique segment players is provided below.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 37
Club Gelato:<br />
Basic Company Information<br />
� Location: Banani, Road# 11 (Planning for a second one in Dhanmondi)<br />
� Established in: 2001<br />
� Seating Capacity: 48<br />
� Area: 1250 sft (including kitchen)<br />
� Owner: Mr. Jahangir Alam (Bangladesh)<br />
� <strong>Business</strong> Type: Joint business partnership with Singapore<br />
� Staff: 15 people (6 in the kitchen)<br />
� Production capacity: 150 litres per day<br />
Product Related Information<br />
� Product: Italian style parlour scoop ice <strong>cream</strong>, fruit juice, c<strong>of</strong>fee and pastries<br />
� Flavours: Around 32 flavours available<br />
� Most selling: Ferraro Rocher, Vanilla, Pistachio<br />
� Innovations: New variants and ingredients are communicated by their Italian supplier and Club<br />
Gelato decides what to take from them.<br />
� Serve type: Cup, Cone, Glasses, Box for take away<br />
Consumer Pr<strong>of</strong>ile<br />
� Primary: Teenagers and Young Adults (18-30) & Diplomats<br />
� Secondary: Family consumers for eat out<br />
� Income Group: High income customers; tentatively from SEC A and higher SEC A<br />
� Geographic Area: Diversified<br />
� Rush time: 8-10 pm<br />
Sales and Price Information<br />
� Sales: BDT 50,000 (60% <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong>, 40% other desserts) daily in summer. In winter however, other<br />
products sell more and thus they keep total sales at the same level.<br />
� Price: 750 per litre for any flavour.<br />
� Sales Volume: 50-60 litres per day<br />
Supply Chain/ Placement Information<br />
� Milk: Local sourcing from Milk Vita (40/50 litres per day)<br />
� Chocolates & Flavours: Belgium, France, Germany<br />
� Transportation: Mainly air (They can afford it due to high margin)<br />
� Contribution <strong>of</strong> various materials: Flavours (30%), Milk (20%), other parts are water and air<br />
Promotional Materials<br />
� Materials used are near premises POS materials for promoting the parlour only.<br />
Table 23: Detail <strong>of</strong> Club Gelato<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 38
MövenPick <strong>of</strong> Switzerland:<br />
Basic Company Information<br />
� Location: Gulshan<br />
� Established in: 2000<br />
� Seating Capacity: 55<br />
� Owner: Mr. Arif Mahmud<br />
� <strong>Business</strong> Type: Franchise <strong>of</strong> International MövenPick<br />
� Storage Capacity in Shop: 150 litres<br />
Product Related Information<br />
� Product: Imported MövenPick ice <strong>cream</strong>s, c<strong>of</strong>fee, chicken sandwich and Frappe<br />
� Flavours: Around 30 to 35 flavours available<br />
� Most selling: Swiss Chocolate, caramel, Vanilla Dream, Espresso, Strawberry<br />
� Innovations: New variants are communicated by their franchiser and they decide on flavours that<br />
they want.<br />
� Serve type: Cup, Cone, Glasses, Box for take away<br />
Consumer Pr<strong>of</strong>ile<br />
� Primary: Teenagers and Young Adults (18-30) (70%) & Diplomats<br />
� Secondary: Family consumers for eat out<br />
� Income Group: High income customers; tentatively from SEC A<br />
� Geographic Area: Concentrated in Gulshan and nearby areas.<br />
� Rush time: Afternoon- Young Adult, 10 to 11 pm Foreigners<br />
� *the company also serves at parties and has freezers in known hotels where their ice <strong>cream</strong>s are<br />
served.<br />
Sales and Price Information<br />
� Sales: BDT 35-40,000 daily in summer.<br />
� Price: 640 per litre for any flavour.<br />
� Sales Volume: 55-60 litres per day<br />
Supply Chain/ Placement Information<br />
� Transportation: Imported finished goods by ship.<br />
� Ship travel time: 19 days<br />
� Port clearance: 10 days<br />
� Safety Cushion: Extra 10 days<br />
Promotional Materials<br />
� Materials used are near premises POS materials for promoting the parlour only.<br />
Table 24: Detail <strong>of</strong> MövenPick <strong>of</strong> Switzerland<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 39
Andersen’s <strong>of</strong> Denmark:<br />
Basic Company Information<br />
� Location: Gulshan, (2 others in Uttara, Dhanmondi)<br />
� Established in: 2001<br />
� Seating Capacity: 48<br />
� Owner: United Group<br />
� <strong>Business</strong> Type: Franchise <strong>of</strong> Australian company Andersen’s <strong>of</strong> Denmark<br />
� Production: Tongi Factory <strong>of</strong> United Group<br />
� Production capacity: 2000 litres per day in factory<br />
� Storage Capacity in Shop: 150 litres<br />
Product Related Information<br />
� Product: Danish parlour scoop ice <strong>cream</strong>, and c<strong>of</strong>fee<br />
� Flavours: Around 30 to 35 flavours available<br />
� Most selling: Strawberry, Butter Scotch, Green<br />
� Innovations: New variants and ingredients are communicated by their franchiser and they decide<br />
on flavours that they want.<br />
� Serve type: Cup, Cone, Glasses, Box for take away<br />
Consumer Pr<strong>of</strong>ile<br />
� Primary: Teenagers and Young Adults (18-30) (70%) & Diplomats<br />
� Secondary: Family consumers for eat out<br />
� Income Group: High income customers; tentatively from SEC A<br />
� Geographic Area: Concentrated in Gulshan and nearby areas.<br />
� Rush time: 8 to 10 pm<br />
Sales and Price Information<br />
� Sales: BDT 10-12,000 daily in summer.<br />
� Price: 460 per litre for any flavour.<br />
� Sales Volume: 40-50 litres per day<br />
Supply Chain/ Placement Information<br />
� Milk: 20/25 kg packs are imported<br />
� Chocolates & Flavours: Imported<br />
� Butte paper: Local sourcing<br />
� Transportation: Ship<br />
Promotional Materials<br />
� Materials used are near premises POS materials for promoting the parlour only.<br />
Table 25: Detail <strong>of</strong> Andersen’s <strong>of</strong> Denmark<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 40
Gelateria Igloo:<br />
Basic Company Information<br />
� Location: Banani, Kemal Ataturk Avenue (Two others in GEC Mor, Chittagong and Naya Paltan)<br />
� Established in: 2000<br />
� Seating Capacity: 20<br />
� Production: From Igloo factory in Shyampur, Narayanganj<br />
Product Related Information<br />
� Product: Parlour scoop ice <strong>cream</strong> and c<strong>of</strong>fee only<br />
� Flavours: Around 30 flavours available<br />
� Most selling: Vanilla, Strawberry, Chocolate, Pistachio, Butter Scotch, Tutti Fruity<br />
� Serve type: Cup, Cone, Glasses, Box for take away<br />
Consumer Pr<strong>of</strong>ile<br />
� Primary: Teenagers and Young Adults (18-30)<br />
� Secondary: Family consumers for eat out<br />
� Income Group: High income customers; tentatively from SEC A and B<br />
� Geographic Area: Diversified<br />
� Rush Time: afternoon and evening<br />
Sales and Price Information<br />
� Sales: BDT 8,000 to 10,000 daily in summer. Nearly one fourth in winter.<br />
� Price: Varies but 350 per litre <strong>of</strong> vanilla<br />
� POS materials at the premises.<br />
Promotional Materials<br />
Table 26: Detail <strong>of</strong> Gelateria Igloo<br />
5.2 Price Comparison <strong>of</strong> Common and Boutique Segments:<br />
Price ranges <strong>of</strong> both common format and boutique segment cannot exactly be pin pointed as products<br />
do not follow common structure and variations occur with use <strong>of</strong> toppings, mixing <strong>of</strong> flavours and use<br />
<strong>of</strong> coatings. However, a price comparison has been made among the brands based on their price <strong>of</strong><br />
per litre <strong>of</strong> vanilla flavoured ice <strong>cream</strong> in the market. It appears to be as following:<br />
Company Price/ Litre Vanilla<br />
Club Gelato 750<br />
MövenPick 640<br />
Andersen’s 460<br />
Dolce Vita 440<br />
Igloo 100<br />
Kwality 100<br />
Polar 100<br />
Milk-Vita 90<br />
Savoy 85<br />
Table 27: Comparative Price Analysis<br />
As it can be seen, there is price gap within the range <strong>of</strong> BDT 100-400. <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> kiosks and small<br />
scooping boutiques can operate within that range.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 41
6.1 Target Group <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong><br />
6.0 CONSUMER ANALYSIS<br />
Who are the consumers <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong>? This question does not have a clear answer. <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> is a<br />
food for all. It is the only food consumed by a human being at less than 0 degree centigrade<br />
temperature and people <strong>of</strong> all ages feel indulged to have it. However, we can determine focus target<br />
groups for both branded common format and artisan boutique ice <strong>cream</strong>. Group discussions and<br />
market visits were done to get insight <strong>into</strong> the consumers along side resources form secondary<br />
sources. Age based target group is common for both segments but variation among the groups occur<br />
mainly based on SEC and DMFI classification.<br />
6.1.1 Geographic Group:<br />
Branded ice <strong>cream</strong> remains an urban product till date. Geographically branded ice <strong>cream</strong> has reached<br />
urban and semi urban areas up to Thana Head Quarter levels. <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> has reached areas where<br />
electricity is available. Small artisan players are available in places where large branded players have<br />
no distribution.<br />
6.1.2 Target Age Group:<br />
Age wise grouping <strong>of</strong> target consumers is as follows:<br />
� Urban kids in the age group <strong>of</strong> 5-14<br />
� They mainly consume normal sticks, cups, cones innovative fillers and water ice <strong>cream</strong>s.<br />
� Urban youth in the age group <strong>of</strong> 15-24<br />
� They consume premium and extrusion sticks and cones.<br />
� Urban mothers in the age group <strong>of</strong> 25-35<br />
� They determine the family purchases. Even when the father purchases ice <strong>cream</strong>, decision is<br />
taken by them.<br />
Consumption pattern <strong>of</strong> various age groups are depicted in the following chart.<br />
<strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> consumption pattern<br />
20%<br />
50%<br />
30%<br />
05 to 14 yrs 15 to 24 yrs 25 to 35 yrs<br />
Figure 11: Target Group wise Consumption Pattern<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 42
6.1.3 Target SEC and DMFI Group:<br />
Common Format:<br />
SEC A and B is the target group for common format ice <strong>cream</strong>. However, with rapid increase in price<br />
level over the years, has made it a “hard to consume” product for SEC B consumers who belong to<br />
lower DMFI group.<br />
Boutique Format:<br />
Boutique format’s higher margin and high price range makes it an exclusively SEC A ice <strong>cream</strong>.<br />
People belonging to upper and upper middle class have access to the mediocre boutiques and only<br />
higher upper class can have premium ice <strong>cream</strong>s like Club Gelato and MövenPick.<br />
Another unique target group for boutique format are the foreigners who live in Bangladesh. These<br />
people tend to visit the parlours to have ice <strong>cream</strong> as dessert especially after dinner.<br />
6.2 <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> in Consumer Lifestyle<br />
Context<br />
� Fun & Excitement<br />
� Social Togetherness<br />
� Indulgence<br />
� Affection for children<br />
� Boredom relief<br />
� Pacifier/ Reward<br />
When<br />
� Post Dinner<br />
� School Time<br />
� Summers<br />
<strong>Ice</strong> Cream is<br />
best<br />
enjoyed in<br />
shared company<br />
Figure 12: <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> in Consumer Life style<br />
Social Setting<br />
� Friends<br />
� Family<br />
� Companion/ Spouse<br />
� Guests<br />
Where<br />
� Treat / Celebration<br />
� Holidays<br />
� Hangout<br />
This simple overview <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> in consumer lifestyle was determined based on in-depth research<br />
analysis <strong>of</strong> UBL and validated through qualitative group discussions by the author. However, detail <strong>of</strong><br />
in-depth research is provided in a later section <strong>of</strong> this chapter.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 43
6.3 Highlights <strong>of</strong> Purchase Habit <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong><br />
6.3.1 Common Habits across Target Groups:<br />
There are some common habits that were identified in earlier researches and group discussions with<br />
consumers. Common habits mean the consumer approach towards ice <strong>cream</strong> that is seen across all<br />
target groups e.g. kids, youth and adult purchasers. These are outlined below.<br />
� <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> is mainly seen as a dessert or a snack. Impulse ice <strong>cream</strong> is seen as a quick snack<br />
that is consumed when it is in sight. Visibility plays a big role here. Regarding family packs,<br />
people see it as a post-food dessert.<br />
� <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> purchase is commonly a planned event. When the contexts arise, people generally<br />
take a bit <strong>of</strong> time to decide whether or not to have ice <strong>cream</strong> or when they want to go to a<br />
boutique they make due considerations regarding which boutique to visit.<br />
� <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> purchase decision is taken based on favourite flavour. People tend to try out new<br />
variants and flavours when they first see it. They compare the taste with earlier experience and<br />
when they purchase later they choose the flavour they have liked most.<br />
� For In-Home segment decision is mostly taken on the flavour. Generally people come up with<br />
different flavours <strong>of</strong> choice and most voted flavour is chosen.<br />
� People become aware <strong>of</strong> new variants or flavours mainly through word-<strong>of</strong>-mouth. Advertisement<br />
(new launches, special <strong>of</strong>fers and festivals) in newspaper is another source <strong>of</strong> awareness.<br />
� People are currently indifferent towards the price level <strong>of</strong> premium flavours. However, some feel<br />
that price <strong>of</strong> Choc-bar, or water ice <strong>cream</strong>s (lolly) is a bit much. If less, they would have consumed<br />
more. Some also feel that companies should come up with branded ice <strong>cream</strong> in the price range<br />
<strong>of</strong> BDT 5-8.<br />
� <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> is purchased from nearby shops. If required brand and flavour is not available, 2-3<br />
shops will be visited and then available flavour will be selected even if the required one is not<br />
found. This is done mainly not to ruin the mood for ice <strong>cream</strong>.<br />
� People are very open to try new brands and flavours especially if it comes from a credible source.<br />
They would try new flavours and if they are satisfied with the taste, they would repeat purchase.<br />
� Regarding boutique visits, people feel that boutiques need to have a proper environment, enough<br />
flavours and other snacks.<br />
� While visiting boutique with family or companion, they want variation in flavours, so that they<br />
would order different flavours and taste each other’s ice <strong>cream</strong>. It is seen as a sign <strong>of</strong><br />
togetherness.<br />
� Frequency <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> purchase varies among people. It depends on peer pressure, collective<br />
family decision, summer heat and attitude towards “ice <strong>cream</strong>” itself as a product.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 44
6.3.2 Habits <strong>of</strong> Kids:<br />
� Kids choose ice <strong>cream</strong> flavours by the look <strong>of</strong> the product (generally pictures shown in POS<br />
materials and carts). They love colour and designs <strong>of</strong> the products let it be a common format or a<br />
boutique ice <strong>cream</strong>.<br />
� Kids (when in house) would go with the housemaid to the nearby shop, choose the flavour they<br />
want (within range <strong>of</strong> the amount given to the maid) and buy it.<br />
� When with parents, they would take the product they like even if the price is lower than some<br />
other product. However, mothers play a role in this decision. They would want their children not to<br />
choose too high priced a product or coloured products.<br />
6.3.3 Habits <strong>of</strong> Youth:<br />
� Young people are the main consumer <strong>of</strong> impulse ice <strong>cream</strong>. They also are one <strong>of</strong> the major<br />
consumers in the boutique segment.<br />
� Young people love to try out new products that come <strong>into</strong> the market. Another side <strong>of</strong> the coin is<br />
that, they are not very loyal to a brand or a flavour and tend to switch a lot.<br />
� Regarding boutique visits, young people go to boutiques to have an “ice <strong>cream</strong> hang out” with<br />
peer groups. They would stay there for a longer period <strong>of</strong> time while they have their ice <strong>cream</strong>.<br />
� Some times young people make milk shakes and other ice <strong>cream</strong> based desserts.<br />
6.3.4 Habits <strong>of</strong> Mothers:<br />
� Mothers worry about their children’s health and they prefer “vanilla” type <strong>of</strong> brands. However,<br />
when price constraint occurs, they go for water ice <strong>cream</strong>s for their children. They try to convince<br />
their kid’s purchase decision.<br />
� Regarding family purchase, mother’s decision is sometimes prioritized by the whole family.<br />
6.4 Barriers to <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Consumption<br />
6.4.1 Emotional Barriers:<br />
� Overindulge (close to sinful)<br />
� Undisciplined (no control)<br />
� Childish (licking)<br />
� Artificial Image<br />
6.4.2 Functional Barriers:<br />
� People <strong>of</strong> SEC B feel that ice <strong>cream</strong> is an expensive dessert (If less expensive would consume<br />
more <strong>of</strong>ten).<br />
� It leads to cold / cough - especially in winter / rainy season.<br />
� It contains artificial additives / preservatives<br />
� It is very high in calories that lead to fattening.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 45
� It does not quench “thirst”.<br />
� Less convenient (portable, immediate eat)<br />
� Messy / Dripping<br />
6.5 Research Findings<br />
The highlights regarding purchase habits, triggers and barriers <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> consumption provide a<br />
glimpse <strong>into</strong> the consumer world <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> industry. However, UBL CMI conducted a formal<br />
research exclusively on ice <strong>cream</strong> consumers to identify:<br />
� Occasions <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong><br />
� Frequency <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> consumption<br />
� Expectations from ice <strong>cream</strong> occasions<br />
� Personalities that they desire from ice <strong>cream</strong><br />
6.5.1 Relevant Occasions in Daily Lives <strong>of</strong> Consumers:<br />
Research question regarding “usual occasions <strong>of</strong> life that occurred most frequently in day-to-<br />
day lives <strong>of</strong> the respondents” generated the following replies.<br />
Occasion<br />
% <strong>of</strong> Respondents<br />
saying "Yes"<br />
Watching TV 93<br />
Normal Dinner At Home 91<br />
Normal Lunch At Home 89<br />
At Home, While Reading/Music/Surfing 86<br />
Informal Family Get Together 85<br />
Out Of Home, Hanging Out With Friends 84<br />
Out Shopping 84<br />
Mid-Afternoon Break At Home 83<br />
At Home By Myself During The Day 82<br />
Special Dinner At Home 82<br />
Informal Dinner Out Of Home 82<br />
Normal Lunch Out Of Home 82<br />
Leisure Walk 79<br />
Coming Home From Work/School 78<br />
Special Dinner Out Of Home 78<br />
Celebration 78<br />
A Night In With Friends 77<br />
At Home By Myself In The Evening 77<br />
Special Lunch Out Of Home 76<br />
Mid-Afternoon Break Out Of Home 75<br />
Special Lunch At Home 73<br />
Day out with Partner 72<br />
Midmorning Break 70<br />
At Breakfast 68<br />
Family Day Out 68<br />
During Work Or At School 65<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 46
Travelling To/From Work/School 65<br />
At The Cinema 61<br />
Special Event 56<br />
Clubbing/ At A Party 50<br />
Post Gym/Sports 48<br />
Table 28: Relevant Occasions in Consumers’ Lives<br />
Respondents were then asked to mention “frequency <strong>of</strong> occurrence <strong>of</strong> the identified occasions”.<br />
The identified replies are as follows:<br />
Post gym/sports<br />
Special event<br />
Family day out<br />
Special lunch out <strong>of</strong> home<br />
Special dinner at home<br />
A night in w ith friends<br />
Mid-afternoon break out <strong>of</strong> home<br />
Leisure w alk<br />
Out <strong>of</strong> home, hanging out w ith friends<br />
Mid-afternoon break at home<br />
Day out w ith Partner/ Spouse<br />
Traveling to/from w ork/school<br />
Coming home from w ork/school<br />
normal lunch at home<br />
Normal dinner at home<br />
Daily 2-3 Times A Week Weekly 2-3 Times A Month<br />
Once A Month Every 2-3 Months Less Often Never<br />
Figure 13: Frequency <strong>of</strong> Occurrence <strong>of</strong> Occasions<br />
This shows that “Normal dinner at home, Watching TV, Normal Lunch At Home, At Home, While<br />
Reading/Music/Surfing, Coming Home From Work/School, During Work Or At School,<br />
Travelling To/From Work/School, Midmorning Break, Day Out With Partner/ Spouse, At Home<br />
By Myself During The Day” are the most frequent daily rituals <strong>of</strong> busy lives <strong>of</strong> consumers.<br />
6.5.2 Frequency <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Consumption:<br />
Respondents were asked to mention “consumption pattern <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> during the identified<br />
occasion” on a scale <strong>of</strong> 1-5 depicting frequencies like “(5) always, (4) most <strong>of</strong> the times, (3) about<br />
half <strong>of</strong> the times, (2) sometimes, (1) never/ do not know”. The responses are depicted in the<br />
following table.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 47
50 48 43 41 39 37<br />
48 30 30 29 27 26 23 27 25 22 20 20 20 19 20<br />
26<br />
22 17 13 17<br />
22 22<br />
34 37<br />
40 37 41 39 40 46 38 39 44 46 47 46 45 37 45 41 46 41 37<br />
46 38<br />
4 4 4 4 7 4 5 4 4 6 5 5 5 5 5 5 6 6 7 5 6 6 6 5 7 7 5 9<br />
6 7 7 7 9 9 9 10 11 10 10 16<br />
11 11 10 12 10 11 11 10 10 11 13 11 14 13 13<br />
12 14<br />
11 12 14 11 13 12 16 18 15 19 18 15 18 21 18 17 17 17 19 18 17 18 20 17 21 30 21<br />
22<br />
30 34 34 25<br />
Midmorning break<br />
While clubbing, at a<br />
At the cinema<br />
Special event<br />
Normal lunch out <strong>of</strong><br />
A night in with friends<br />
Normal dinner at<br />
Informal dinner out <strong>of</strong><br />
Always most <strong>of</strong> the times About half <strong>of</strong> the times Sometimes never/do not know<br />
At home by myself<br />
At home by myself in<br />
Figure 14: Frequency <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Consumption<br />
As it can be seen “Day out with Spouse, Special lunch at home, Special dinner at home,<br />
Watching TV, Family day out, Celebration” are the occasions where most frequently ice <strong>cream</strong> is<br />
consumed.<br />
6.5.3 Market Character: Mapping Relevant Occasions vs. Frequency <strong>of</strong><br />
Consumption<br />
If we plot frequency <strong>of</strong> consumption on the X-axis <strong>of</strong> a chart and relevance <strong>of</strong> occasion occurrence on<br />
the Y-axis taking the above mentioned values as cut-<strong>of</strong>f values we get four quadrants in the chart<br />
depicting four market scenarios that any ice <strong>cream</strong> manufacturer in Bangladesh market might<br />
encounter given the current market situation. This market segmentation is based on frequency <strong>of</strong> ice<br />
<strong>cream</strong> consumption in daily occasions <strong>of</strong> consumer lives.<br />
The segments are:<br />
� OPPORTUNITY MARKET: High Relevant Occasions-Low <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Frequency<br />
� QUESTION MARKET: Less Relevant Occasions-Low <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Frequency<br />
� HIGH FREQUENCY MARKET: Relevant Occasions-High <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Frequency<br />
� CAPTIVE MARKET: Less Relevant Occasions-High <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> Frequency<br />
The chart looks as follows:<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 48<br />
Out shopping<br />
Special lunch at<br />
Day out with Spouse<br />
Watching TV
Figure 15: Relevance <strong>of</strong> Occasion-Frequency <strong>of</strong> Consumption Mapping<br />
As it can be seen from the above chart, Bangladesh Market still lies in the Opportunity and Question<br />
market zone with a pull towards High frequency and Captive Market zones. This is evident from<br />
market data as penetration <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> still remains at Thana headquarters levels. Also, this explains<br />
the high market growth rate <strong>of</strong> 17% as market is yet under developed and branded quality ice <strong>cream</strong><br />
has yet not reached all levels <strong>of</strong> consumers, especially rural level that constitutes around 75% <strong>of</strong><br />
Bangladeshi market.<br />
From the above analysis, we can establish that target <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> manufacturers should be to<br />
penetrate more <strong>into</strong> the Bangladeshi market to create higher frequency <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> consumption.<br />
The following chart shows the strategies to follow for ice <strong>cream</strong> manufacturers.<br />
Figure 16: Required Market Strategy for Bangladesh<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 49
As, relevance <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> consumption occasions can hardly be controlled by marketers, their<br />
endeavour should be to create more “emotional and functional” attachment to ice <strong>cream</strong> in less<br />
frequent occasions through “market development” strategy to earn share from overall food<br />
expenditure <strong>of</strong> consumers and at the same time make them consume more ice <strong>cream</strong> in highly<br />
relevant occasions through “penetration” strategy.<br />
6.5.4 Consumers’ Emotional Requirements and Product Attributes:<br />
All consumers under these clusters also identify the emotional requirements and the significant<br />
product attributes they seek from their current preferred and future desired ice <strong>cream</strong>s. These are<br />
provided below.<br />
Cluster<br />
Emotional/ Functional<br />
Requirement Product Attributes<br />
Enjoyment Flavour/ Variety � Combination <strong>of</strong> different flavours<br />
� Combination <strong>of</strong> different textures<br />
� Very sweet<br />
� With wafer or biscuit<br />
� With chocolate<br />
� Of a well known brand<br />
Socially Involved Spoonable/ Rich � Very <strong>cream</strong>y<br />
� Only natural ingredients<br />
� No mess<br />
Care Size/ Creaminess � Big<br />
� Rich, full taste<br />
� Smooth<br />
� Value for money<br />
� No mess<br />
Unwind & Escape Economy � Crunchy<br />
� Economic<br />
� Of a well known brand<br />
� Nutritious<br />
Balanced Convenience Health Conscious � Of a well known brand<br />
� Nutritious<br />
� Milk based<br />
� Low sugar<br />
� Low carbohydrates<br />
� Filling<br />
Active Self-Grooming Fruit/ Vitamins � Healthy<br />
� Fruit based<br />
� Low fat<br />
� Liquid or drinkable<br />
� Nutritious<br />
� Of a well known brand<br />
Confidence Drinkable/ Light � Low calories<br />
� Light on the stomach<br />
� Chewy or gooey<br />
� Not so sweet<br />
� Natural appearance<br />
Sensual Appeal or image � No artificial additives<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 50
� Natural appearance<br />
� Melting slowly<br />
� Attractive packaging<br />
� High quality ingredients<br />
� Of a well known brand<br />
Table 29: Requirements & Product Attributes Desired by Consumer Clusters<br />
Of these findings we see that the identified highlighted barriers to ice <strong>cream</strong> consumption are pretty<br />
evident among the consumers. Mostly people want products <strong>of</strong> a reliable source or a well known<br />
brand, low calories, quality ingredients, value for money/ economic type.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 51
7.0 INDUSTRY ATTRACTIVENESS AND ENTRY PROSPECTS<br />
7.1 Driving Forces <strong>of</strong> Growth<br />
As identified in the earlier sections, there are several driving forces behind the growth <strong>of</strong> ice-<strong>cream</strong><br />
industry in Bangladesh.<br />
7.1.2 Trade and Infrastructural Level:<br />
� As a result <strong>of</strong> globalization newer varieties have been introduced to the local products. Many<br />
foreign companies are also coming as franchise so there has been increased competition and<br />
these boutiques are setting higher standards for the local producers.<br />
� The present market growth rate is 18-19% which is being influenced by larger players like Igloo<br />
who are expanding their distribution nation wide with expansion <strong>of</strong> national electricity grid.<br />
� With entry <strong>of</strong> Modern Trade and recent organized business approach <strong>of</strong> retailers has made it<br />
possible for ice <strong>cream</strong> manufacturers to penetrate <strong>into</strong> shops even without providing them with<br />
branded freezers.<br />
� Weather change has increased “summer” season in our country, which has reduced negative<br />
seasonal impact on ice <strong>cream</strong>.<br />
� Large companies like Igloo have taken global learning <strong>of</strong> using carts as an effective tool <strong>of</strong><br />
availability and visibility for ice <strong>cream</strong>.<br />
� New and improved technologies are being used in the production process. This technological<br />
advancement has improved quality, increased speed <strong>of</strong> production and made the process more<br />
cost effective.<br />
7.1.3 Consumer Level:<br />
� Only a few years back rich people could afford the luxury <strong>of</strong> having ice-<strong>cream</strong> but now it has<br />
become a common product for everybody. <strong>Ice</strong>-<strong>cream</strong> companies are producing different products<br />
with a wide price range for consumers <strong>of</strong> every class and status.<br />
� Nowadays companies are doing promotional campaigns more frequently; the customers get to<br />
know about the product which makes it easier for them to buy the best one.<br />
� The improved standard <strong>of</strong> life and more modernized lifestyle <strong>of</strong> people is an important reason for<br />
the increased consumption thus growth <strong>of</strong> the ice-<strong>cream</strong> industry.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 52
7.2 Prospects <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong><br />
The ice-<strong>cream</strong> industry <strong>of</strong> Bangladesh is an attractive one for the investors because there is a huge<br />
market but number <strong>of</strong> producers is very small. The major reasons behind industry attractiveness are<br />
as follows:<br />
� The industry’s current growth potential is very high with opportunity for market development.<br />
� The competition currently permits adequate pr<strong>of</strong>itability and the competitive forces are becoming<br />
stronger with time.<br />
� Boutique segment is at a very high growth stage but no operator is currently operating with a mid<br />
price range <strong>of</strong> BDT 100-400. <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> kiosks and small scooping boutiques can operate within<br />
that range.<br />
� Current industry driving forces are favourable for the future industry pr<strong>of</strong>itability.<br />
� Globally oriented consumers look for variety in ice <strong>cream</strong> that is currently not available. Latest<br />
innovations came in the market in 2002. People would welcome new variety and flavours.<br />
� There is a gap in the market for balanced convenience through ice <strong>cream</strong> where consumers can<br />
get nutritional benefits for ice <strong>cream</strong>. Also, emotional attachment to ice <strong>cream</strong> could further be<br />
improvised in promotional campaigns.<br />
� There is high scope for market penetration and development to increase frequency <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong><br />
consumption.<br />
� Level <strong>of</strong> risk or uncertainty is very low in ice-<strong>cream</strong> industry because the consumer market is so<br />
huge, any product with a standard quality and careful pricing will be able to make significant pr<strong>of</strong>it.<br />
� As for geographic reach <strong>of</strong> the industry, 60% market is still in Dhaka. There is scope <strong>of</strong> expansion<br />
and a new entrant can easily capture market share within Dhaka using carts even if they do not<br />
want nation wide cold chain distribution.<br />
� The production process is very complex and capital requirements are also high. So before going<br />
<strong>into</strong> production any company should know about their capabilities and weaknesses and then start<br />
the business or else they might suffer huge loss at a certain level.<br />
� Unilever can acquire the required resource and use existing multi-national multi-cultural expertise<br />
to enter the market in a grand way.<br />
� With high probability <strong>of</strong> entry from DANONE with more products like the ISIS diabetic ice <strong>cream</strong>,<br />
Unilever should consider entering in this industry as soon as possible.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 53
8.0 ENTRY STRATEGY FOR UNILEVER<br />
While describing the suggested entry strategy for UBL, certain issues have been kept confidential and<br />
some issues have been touched but not explained to keep consistency with UBL confidentiality policy.<br />
8.1 Suggested <strong>Entry</strong> Areas for UBL<br />
� Boutique segment <strong>of</strong> the Bangladesh ice <strong>cream</strong> is only 5% <strong>of</strong> the branded market. UBL needs to<br />
pursue a larger scope to make the entry viable.<br />
� UBL cannot fight with unbranded segment as global product quality mandate <strong>of</strong> Unilever does not<br />
allow UBL to fight in low price-low quality segment.<br />
� Recommend entry should be in the common format segment with both single and multiple<br />
servings and in the boutique segment with a different brand name (if possible BEN & JERRY’S).<br />
� UBL should build up state-<strong>of</strong>-art modern factory for manufacturing and establish cold chain<br />
facilities initially focusing on metro cities.<br />
� Investment issues are required to be addressed for building factory and cold chain and capital<br />
requirement needs to be identified for that purpose 4 .<br />
� UBL may have boutiques for driving image/ selective top-end <strong>of</strong>fering.<br />
� Kiosks can be setup near universities and shopping malls.<br />
� Boutiques should be concentrated in Dhaka and Chittagong.<br />
� <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> for boutiques and kiosks would be produced in factory as institutional packs <strong>of</strong> 9-10<br />
litres.<br />
8.2 Products<br />
� As a Brand Building country in global Unilever operating framework UBL is entitled only to bring<br />
products developed by the Brand Development countries.<br />
� Unilever should focus on serving products that have nutritional benefits (already available<br />
globally) along with usual satisfactions <strong>of</strong> sensual pleasure, functional attributes etc.<br />
� Current existent players especially Igloo and Kwality have extensively copied global and<br />
regionally available Unilever products e.g. Cornelli is same as Wall’s Cornetto, Vinetta is similar to<br />
Vienetta, Mega is similar to Magnum etc. UBL needs to differentiate these to consumers on the<br />
“taste the original” platform where global quality is focused regarding the products.<br />
� UBL should also bring regionally famous brands like Moo or Max to create image differentiation.<br />
� Magnum or Moo should be used as premium end ice <strong>cream</strong> to generate more pr<strong>of</strong>it margin.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 54
8.3 Placement<br />
� Distribution focus should be in Dhaka for entry as Dhaka contributes more than 60% <strong>of</strong> total ice<br />
<strong>cream</strong> sales in the country.<br />
� Company may use carts as distribution method. They serve as good source <strong>of</strong> visibility and<br />
availability. It would help in increasing impulse purchase.<br />
� At least 1500 outlets in Dhaka and Chittagong needs to be actively served using dedicated<br />
branded refrigerators to generate sales.<br />
� 50 carts should operate in Dhaka and Chittagong.<br />
8.4 Price<br />
� UBL products should be priced at par with Igloo pricing for the common format ice <strong>cream</strong>s.<br />
� UBL can bring in premium single-serve SKUS for the higher economic classes in the price<br />
range <strong>of</strong> BDT 60-80.<br />
� Smaller SKUs (small lolly stick) can be introduced in the price range <strong>of</strong> BDT 10-15.<br />
� In the boutique segment UBL should price products above the semi-premium segment (Gelateria<br />
Igloo, Sub Zero or Andersen’s) but lower than that <strong>of</strong> Club Gelato or MövenPick.<br />
8.5 Promotion<br />
� UBL would require strong marketing campaign (As high as 50% <strong>of</strong> sales) to have a grand entry in<br />
the market.<br />
� Presence in the television media would be <strong>of</strong> utmost importance. More than 50% <strong>of</strong><br />
promotional expense should be made here initially. Gradually it can be reduced.<br />
� Newspaper would serve as the second most important option.<br />
� Billboards should also be used.<br />
� Activations (similar to Lux Channel i Super Star or Igloo Festival) should be done to generate<br />
trial.<br />
8.6 Scope <strong>of</strong> Opportunity<br />
Value Volume<br />
(BDT Cr) (Tons)<br />
Market 131 7835<br />
Common 121 7600<br />
Boutique 9.8 235<br />
Table 30: Value and Volume Based Scope <strong>of</strong> Opportunity for UBL<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 55
8.6.1 Geographic Contribution:<br />
� Dhaka (61%)<br />
� Chittagong (19%)<br />
� Sylhet (10%)<br />
8.6.2 UBL objectives:<br />
Common Format <strong>Ice</strong> Creams:<br />
� Target: 10% Market share in 1st year operation<br />
� Value: BDT 11 Cr<br />
� Production capacity required: 2.1 Tons/ day<br />
� Freezer Placement: 1500 freezers<br />
� Cart operation: At least 50 carts<br />
Boutiques:<br />
� Target: Further develop the market<br />
� Focus: Dhaka, Chittagong and Sylhet Metro<br />
� Franchise: At least 20 franchisee operations nation wide in divisional towns<br />
� Pricing: Below imported parlours; above common formats with around BDT 400 per Litre.<br />
8.7 Critical Success Factors<br />
� UBL is considered as a high pr<strong>of</strong>ile company in Bangladesh and thus they cannot operate in the<br />
market only with common products like choc-bars and cups. They must have premium products<br />
(these require extrusion line) also to carry their brand image. Otherwise UBL would not be able to<br />
charge usual premium over competition products.<br />
� Launch <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> would require huge promotional and activation support in order to gain<br />
customers from Igloo. People want novelty regarding ice <strong>cream</strong> and UBL have to let them know<br />
about their products and create hype.<br />
� Cart should be used as a source <strong>of</strong> distribution. Recent successes <strong>of</strong> Unilever companies like<br />
Indonesia shows that carts can generate more sales and can be used as source <strong>of</strong> visibility in the<br />
minds <strong>of</strong> both retail traders and consumers. Carts can also provide incremental sales to the<br />
company.<br />
� UBL have to create a strong cold chain for ice <strong>cream</strong> (initially in Dhaka and Chittagong) to ensure<br />
quality products for consumers.<br />
� UBL have to build capacity very rapidly to meet consumer demand if the launch is successful.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 56
9.1 Basic Assumptions<br />
9.0 BUSINESS PROJECTION<br />
<strong>Business</strong> projection for ice <strong>cream</strong> business was made based on a conservative approach. UBL would<br />
require spending significantly on production capacity and factory dedicated to ice <strong>cream</strong>. Thus, to<br />
analyse business possibilities <strong>of</strong> ice <strong>cream</strong> certain assumptions were made and collected data were<br />
used. These are:<br />
� Production equipments and cabinets would cost approximately BDT 55 crores.<br />
� Production equipments : 45%<br />
� Packaging Equipments : 15%<br />
� Storage Facility : 20%<br />
� Branded Freezers : 10%<br />
� Distribution Investment : 10% (Distributors would also invest themselves)<br />
� <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> factory with a floor size <strong>of</strong> 20000 sqft would cost BDT 25 crores.<br />
� Objective is to capture 10% market share in Dhaka and Chittagong in the first year.<br />
� <strong>Business</strong> would grow by 50% in year 2 and 3; 30% in year 4 and 25% in year 5.<br />
� Weighted price per litre is BDT 170 according to volume share <strong>of</strong> single serve ice <strong>cream</strong>, multiple<br />
serve ice <strong>cream</strong> and boutique ice <strong>cream</strong>.<br />
� Other financial assumptions were also made. List <strong>of</strong> them are provided below but amount has<br />
been removed for confidentiality issues.<br />
Assumptions<br />
Trade Margin<br />
Distributor's Margin<br />
Duty/VAT Rate<br />
Trade Terms Expense % <strong>of</strong> NPS<br />
Trade Terms Expense % <strong>of</strong> NSV<br />
Advertising &Promotion % <strong>of</strong> NPS<br />
Indirects (Salaries, Wages etc) %<br />
Trading Tax %<br />
Table 31: Assumptions for <strong>Business</strong> Projection<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 57
10.0 CONCLUSION<br />
<strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> has good prospect in Bangladesh. It is still a growing market with opportunities for big new<br />
entrants. With the barriers <strong>of</strong> entry, UBL needs to consider its priorities. UBL being an HPC company<br />
traditionally needs to acquire expertise in cold chain distribution and has to invest a lot <strong>of</strong> money to rip<br />
the benefits <strong>of</strong> the industry. However, to initiate company can take regional support and acquire<br />
resource expertise. The company should enter the business as soon as possible since there is<br />
potential threat from DANONE to introduce more ice <strong>cream</strong>s after ISIS diabetic ice <strong>cream</strong> and also<br />
with potential <strong>of</strong> the industry arch rival Nestle’ might consider entering <strong>into</strong> the industry too.<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 58
Web References:<br />
References<br />
1. www.unilever.com<br />
2. www.unilever.com.bd<br />
3. www.hll.com<br />
4. www.unilever.com.pk<br />
5. www.thedailystar.com - Life Style Magazine,<br />
6. www.reuters.co.uk<br />
<strong>Evaluation</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Entry</strong> <strong>into</strong> <strong>Ice</strong> <strong>cream</strong> <strong>Business</strong> for Bangladesh Limited 59