A BRIEF REPORT - Goa Legislative Assembly

A BRIEF REPORT 

THE BUSINESS TRANSACTED DURING THE 

~ECQND SESSION 

TBEFOURTH LEGISLATIVE AksEMBLY 

TBE SIlATE OF GOA

A BRIEF REPORT 

THE BUSINESS T~NSACTED DURZNG THE 

SECOND SESSION (JUNE-JULY-AUGUST), 2004 

! 

THE FQURTH LEGISLATIYE ASSEMBLY 

I 

TJm FATE OF GOA

This booklet contains brief information on the business transacted by 

the Fourth Legislative Ass I bly of the State of Goa during the Second Session 

(J~ne-Juiy-A~gust), 2oo4T 

ASSEMBLY HALL 

PORVORIM- GOA 

28 DECEMBER, 2004. 

S. A. NARVEKAR 

SECRETARY, LEGISLATURE

TABLE OF CONTENTS 

1. Brief Report of the Second Session (June-July-August), 2004 

of the Fourth Legislative Assembly of the State of Goa 

2. Statement No. 1 - Dates of Meetings. 

3. Statement No. 2 - Attendance of Members. 

4. Statement No. 3 -1 Percentage of Attendance of Members. 

i 

5. Statement No. 4 -I Szlmmary of Business transacted during the 

I Second Session of June-July-August, 2004 of the I/ 

I Fourth Legislative Assembly of the State of Goa. 1 

11 

6. Statement No. 5 - , Financial Business. 

! ii I 

7. Statement No. 6 - I Supplementary Demands. 

I 1 

8. Statement No. 7 - 1 Statistical information regarding Government Bills. ; i 

9. Statement No. 8 - 1 Announcernnet of Assent to Bills. Ill1 

I 

10. Statement No. 9 - ~ornination of Members on the Panel of Presiding 

(~embers. 

I 

11. Statement No. 10 - Private Members' Resolutions. 

12. Statement No. 1 1 - /Calling Attention Notices (Under Rule 63). 

I 

13. Statement No. 12 - List of Papers laid on the Table of the House. 

I 

14. Statement No. 13 - Departmentwise statistical information of 

Starred Questions. 

15. Statement No. 14 - Departmentwise statistical information of 

Unstarred Questions. 

I 

16. Statement No. 15 - eresentation of Reports. 

i 

17. Statement No. 16 - Adjournment Motions 

1 

18. Statement No. 17 - Zero Hour Mentions. 

1

A Brief Report of the Second Session (June-July-August), 2004 

of the Fourth Legislative Assembly of theistate of Goa. 

The Second Session (June - July - August), 2004 of the Fourth 

Legislative Assembly of the State of Goa commenced at the Assembly Hall, 

Porvorim on Monday the 28th June, 2004 and had twentysix sittings. The 

House was adjourned sine-die on the 2nd August, 2004 and later prorogued 

on 6th August, 2004. The total time taken for the business of the sittings was 

97 hours and 08 minutes. 

I 

MOTIONS FOR CONDOLENCES 

P 1 

Motions for Condolences 1 n passing away of'the following personalities 

were moved:- 

i) Shri Felicio Cardozo, Pillars of Konkani movement a Freedom 

Fighter and lournaljt who passed away on 17th May, 2004. 

i) Fr.,Freddy J. da Pillars of Konlcani movement Founder, 

Publisher and 

the Konkani magazine. 

1 

FreedomFighters, g 

ih) SIShri Krishnanath bhat, Sitaram Naik, Pumshottam Dattaram 

Kavlekar, Gopi Ma1 ankar, Dinanath Yende, Luis Teresa, Andnt 

Pawaskar, Murlidh r Rane and Dinanath Dhamaskar all the 

t sons of soils who sacrificed for the liberation 

of Goa, Daman & D' 

t 

from the Portuguese yoke. 

iv) Shri Prabhakar ~ n 

.F 

~ , a l noted ' economist, businessman, Author, 

Writter and Philanthr pist. 

V) Dr. Shrikant Jichkar (IAS and IPS), Journalist, great scholar,Ex- 

MLA (Maharashtra), Ex-MP and Minister of State for Home Affairs 

(Maharashtra) who phsed away on 2nd June, 2004. 

I 

I 

vi) Dr. J. F. Martins, a Reedom lighter and Veteran Politician and 

Social Worker.

-2- 

MOTION FOR CONGRATULATION 

The House congratulated Dr. Manmohansingh, for being sworn in as a 

Prime Minister of the Country. 

FINANCIAL BUSINESS 

General Discussion and Voting on 85 Demands for Grants (including 

three Charged Demands) for the year 2004-2005 took place for 15 days i.e. 

on7,8,12,13,14,15,19,20,21,22,26,27,28,29th July and 2nd August, 2004 and 

passed the connected Goa Appropriation (No.2) Bill on 2nd August, 2004. 

SUPPLEMENTARY DEMANDS FOR GRANTS 

The Second Batch of Vo e on Account 2004-2005 was presented, 

discussed and passed on 28th Ju h ,2004. Thirty Supplementary Demands for 

Grants for the year 2004 -20055( irst Batch) were presented to the House on 

29th July,2004 and discussed and passed on 2nd August, 2004. 

I 

(V ide p tatement No. 6) 

4 

Apart from Appropriation N0.2) Bill, -2004, 11 Bills were introduced 

during the Session. One Bill intr duced during the earlier Session and 10 Bills 

C 

introduced during the Session w re considered and passed. 

( Vide Statement No. 7 ) 

- *. 

Governor's assent to 13 Biks (12 bills considered and passed during its 

earlier Session and 1 bill passed during the current Session) by the House was 

announced in the House. 

-1,; ;: : ,:3_:t$t;;=+, 

.4 

I 

BERS ON THE PANEL 

Four Members were 

the year 2004 - 2005. 

on the Panel of Presiding Members for

(Vide Statement No. 9) 

PRIVATE MEMBERS' RESOLUTIONS 

2,9,16,23 and 30 July were allotted for Private Members' Business. 107 

notices were received, 104 notices were admitted, 8 were adopted, 11 were 

withdrawn, 6 notices did not come for discussion as the Members were absent 

and 79 notices were lapsed on prorogation. 

( %de Statement No. 10 ) 

CALLING ATTENTION NOTICES (Under Rule 63) 

13 notices were received , 2 were admitted and discussed. 

I 

( Vide Statement No. 1 1 ) 

i - 

PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE OF THE HOUSE 

I 

Forty Papers were lai on the Table of the House during the Session. 

de Statement No. 12 ) 

STARRED AFD UNSTARRED QUESTIONS 

Notices of 1281 starred Questions and 550 Unstarred Questions were 

received. 

I 

Questions 

Starred Uns tarred Total 

Received I 1281 550 1831 

Disallowed 127 62 189 

Starred Questions admitted as 

Unstarred 173 .... 173 

Consolidated I 95 40 135 

I 

I 

Admitted 

! 862 611 1473 

Replied 

1 

126 7 133 

Laid on the Table 

1 

I 

I 

722 580 1302 

Postponed I 14 22 3 6

( Vide Statement No. 13 and 14 ) 

PKESENTATION OF REPORTS 

Second and Third Report (2004) of the Business Advisory Committee 

and Fifty Eighth, Fifty Ninth and Sixtieth Report of the Public Accounts 

Committee were presented to the House. 

( Vide Statement No. 15) 

ADJOURNMENT MOTIONS (Under Rule 68) 

4 notices of the Adjournment Motions were received, 3 were disallowed 

and 1 was admitted for discussion during the Session. 

(Vide Stqtement No. 16) 

Forty two notices of Zero 

during the Session. 

mentions were received and discussed 

( Vide Statement No. 17 ) 

I 

SIATI&NTNO. 1 

DATES 4~ MEETINGS 

I 

Sr. No. i .ate of Meeting Time of Meeting Total period 

'i 

F& To Hours Minutes 

7.35 P.M. 

4.34 P.M. 4 

7.10 P.M. 

3.35 P.M. 

4.14 P.M. 1 

5.05 PW. 

4.30 E.M. 4 

6.3 P.M. 

5.a P.M. 2 

235 P.M. 

5.07 P.M. 0 

3.40 P.M. 

2.40 P.M. 0 

3.15 P.M.

2.30 P.M. 2.42 P.M. 

3.35 P.M. 3.41 P.M. 

2.30 P.M. 4.30 P.M. 

5.00 P.M. 6.30 P.M. 

6.45 P.M. 6.48 P.M. 

2.30 P.M. 4.07 P.M. 

2.30 P.M. 4.30 P.M. 

5.00 P.M. 10.25 P.M. 

1 2.30 P.M. 4.30 P.M. 

5.00 P.M. 7.30 P.M. 

2.30 P.M. 4.30 P.M. 

5.00 P.M. 8.50 P.M. 

2.30 P.M. 4.30 P.M. 

5.05 P.M. 8.25 P.M. 

2.30 P.M. 4.00 P.M. 

2.30 P.M. 4.35 P.M. 

5.05 P.M. 9.17 P.M. 

1 2.30 P.M. 4.30 P.M. 

5.06 P.M. 6.46 P.M. 

I 2.30 P.M. 4.28 P.M. 

5.05 P.M. 8.15 P.M. 

1 2.30 P.M. 4.32 P.M. 

j 5.07 P.M. 8.20 P.M. 

2.30 P.M. 4.06 P.M. 

( 2.30 P.M. 3.40 P.M. 

1 3.55 P.M. 

I ;::: 

4.30 P.M. 

9.08 P.M. 

E: 4.30 P.M. 

I 5.04 P.M. 7.22 P.M. 

2.30 P.M. 4.31 P.M. 

5.05 P.M. 8.39 P.M. 

2.30 P.M. 4.30 P.M. 

5.16 P.M. 6.30 P.M. 

2.30 P.M. 4.42 P.M. 

2.30 P.M. 4.26 P.M. 

5.12 P.M. 10.12 P.M. 

TOTAL : 97 08

STATEMENT NO. 2 

Attendance of Members (excluding Speaker, Dy. Speaker, Ministers 

and Leader of Opposition) 

Date Present Absent

STATEMEMT No. 3 

PERCENTAGE OF ATTENDANCE OF MEMBERS 

Percentage of attendance of eaeh Member of the Legislative Assembly 

(excluding Speaker, Dy. Speaker, Ministers and Leader of Opposition) 

S1. No. Name of the Member No. of days Percentage 

Attended 

the session 

1 

1 Shri ~axmikadt Parsekar 25 

2 Shri Sadanand Shet 26 

3 Shri Rajesh P tnekar 26 

4 Shri Rajendra plekar 26 

5 Shri Damodar paik 25 

6 Shri Vasudev $aonkar 26 

7 Shri Vijay Pai f;hot 25 

8 Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu 26 

I 

9 Shri Agnelo Fymandes 26 

10 . Shri Dayanand Narvekar 25 

11 Smt. Victoria ernandes 26 

f 

12 Shri Harish Pr bhu Zantye 26 

13 ShriRaviNai , 26 

14 Shri Subhash S$irodkar 12 

15 Shri Giovanni Karl Vaz 24 

B 

16 Shri Aleixo ~e I ueira 

23 

17 Shri Francis Si veria 26 

18 Shri Francisco lsardinha 26 

19 Sbri Luizinho aleiro 

26 

20 Shri Joaquim qlemao 

9 

26 

21 Shri Chandrakant Kavlekar 23 

22 Shri Isidore Femandes . 24 . 

23 Dr. Wilfred D'Souza 26 

24 Shri Pacheco Grancis Xavier 25 96% 

"25 Shri Vnay ~en$ulkar 18 69 % 

* Shri Vinay 

1 

has resigned as a Cabinet Minister with effect 

from 6th July, 2004.

SUMMARY OF BUSINESS TRANSACTED BY THE GOA 

LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY DURING THE SECOND 

SESSION OF JUNE-JULY-AUGUST, 2004 

MONDAY 28 JUNE, 2004 

The Second Session of the Fourth Legislative Assembly of the State of 

Goa commenced at the Assembly Hall, Porvorim at 2.30 p.m. on Monday 28 

June, 2004. Shri Vishwas Satarkar, Speaker was in the Chair, (Second Session 

of the Fourth Legislative Assembly &as summoned on 27 May, 2004). 

\ 

I. NATIONAL ANTHEM 

The National Anthem was recited by the Members. 

/ 

11. QUESTIONS 

(i) Shri Manohar Parrikar, the Chief Minister asked for postponement 

of Starred Question Nos. 1,10 and Unstarred Question No. 9 for 

answer on 7/7/2004. I 

(ii) Shri Matanhy Saldanha, 'Minister for Tourism, Sports & Youth 

Affairs made corrections 10 Starred Question No. 2. 

(iii) Two postponed Starred Qdestions and Five Starred Questions were 

replied orally. 

(iv) Thirty five Starred Questions were not reached and transferred to 

Unstarred list. 1 

(v) Tho postponed unstarreh Questions and twenty two Unstarred 

1 Questions were laid on thb Table. 

the notice of adjournment motion 

Deshprabhu for suspending 

abuse and misuse of the 

Goa as reported on Indian

RULING 

I have received a notice dated 27.6.2004 of Adjournment Motion for 

suspending the Question Hour for serious charges and abuse and misuse 

of the highest constitutional office in the State of Goa as reported on 

Indian Express dated 27/6/2004 by the off~ce of the Governor. The 

signatories are Shri. Luizinho Faleiro and Shri. Jitendra Deshprabhu. The 

Adjournment Motion confines to the aspect related to the office of the 

Governor. As per item (vi) of sub-rule 2 of Rule 278 of the Rules of 

Procedure and Conduct of Business of the Goa Legislative Assembly, 

the discussion shall ndt reflect upon the conduct of the Governor. 

I 

I would like to quote Kaul and Shakdhar vide page 512 

" It has been held by the Speaker from time to time that the following 

I 

matters could not be raised by way of Adjournment Motion: 

Conduct of the Presideint or any action taken by him 

I 

Conduct of the ~ovedor of a State" and 

Conduct of the Speaker or an order passed by the Speaker 

Further as per Kaul an4 Shakdhar vide page 503, " Press reports unless 

admitted by Government cannot be accepted as authoritative for the 

purpose of an adjoumrbent motion'.. 

Secondly the matter rail ed in the adjournment motion is required to be of 

a specific matter of recent 

P 

occurrence. The notice does not speak about 

the specific issues to bh taken-up and besides the matter is not of recent 

occurrence. I therefore feel that matter raised in the notice does not 

warrant the disturbanck of the regular Business of the House and take 

UP- 

I therefore, disallow the notice for Adjournment Motion. 

Owing to pandemonium in the House, the Speaker adjourned the 

House again at 3:40 The House reassembled at 4:35 p.m. 

IV. MOTION FOR CONGRATULATON 

SIShri Dayanand G. Narvekar and Pratapsingh Rane (Leader of the 

Opposition) moved the following motion:

'"This House congratulates Dr. Manmohansingh, for being sworn in as a 

Prime Minister of the Country." 

Ten Members spoke on the motion and the motion was adopted 

unanimously. 

V 

MOTION FOR CONDOLENCE 

Shri Manohar Parrikar, Chief Mbiste'r and Shri Dayanand G. Narvekar 

moved the following Motion: 

"l'his House condoles theuntb#Ay and tragic death of Goa's two towering 

pillars of Konkani movement, reedomFighter and Journalist Shri Felicio 

1 

Cardozo and Fr. Freddy J. da Costa, Founder, Publisher and Editor of 

Gulab the Konkani Magazine n a road mishap at Haveri, near Hubli on 

hearfelt condolences to the bereaved 

17 May, 2004 and offer our 

families. " 

I 

Eight Members spoke on the motion and the motion was adopted 

unanimously. 

(1) Shri Vinay Tendulkar, ~idister for Forest laid a copy of the Goa 

Co-operative Societies Rules, 

I 

2003. 

I 

nu' 

(2) Shri Dayanand Mandrekar, e Minister for Agriculture laid a copy of 

the Ninth Annual Report o Goa State Horticultural Corporation Ltd. 

for the year 2001-2002. 

(3) Shri Atanasio Monserate, Minister for Town and Country Planning 

laid on the Table the following: 

(i) Order No.7/4/98/STE/DIW/Part-U1084 dated 04/02/2004 notifying 

the dates of festive occasions in the calendar year (2004-2005) for 

relaxation. 

i 

I 

(ii) Notification NO.LS/MI~C/~~~ Wart II/1166 dated 23/02/2004 

made to the Governments Directions 

I/589 dated 31 July, 2002 published in 

I No.21 dated 22 August, 2002.

(5) Corrigendum No.7/4/98/STE/DIR/Part-V123 1 dated 11/03/2004 

issued to the Government Order No.7/4/98/STE/DIR/Part-111084 

dated 4/2/2004, pertaining to Noise Pollution (Regulation and Control) 

Rules, 2000. 

VII. ASSENT TO BILLS 

Secretary reported assent of the Governor to the following 12 Bills passed 

by the Fourth Legislative Assembly of the State of Goa. 

(1) The Goa Appro riation Bill, 2004. 

(2) The Goa Appr f priation (Vote on Account) Bill, 2004. 

(3) The Goa Children's 

I 

(Amendment) Bill, 2004. 

(4) The Goa Medic 

I 

Practitioners Bill, 2004. 

P 

(5) The Goa Civil Oourts (Amendment) Bill, 2004. 

(6) The Goa Labour 

I 

Welfare Fund (Amendment) Bill, 2004. 

(7) The Goa Educa kn ~evelo~ment corporation (~mendment) ill, 2004. 

(8) The City of Pan 3 ji Corporation (Amendment) Bill, 2004. 

(9) The Goa Public ' ealth Amendment) Bill, 2004. 

B ( 

(10) The Goa Sales Tax (Amendment) Bill, 2004. 

-'(11) The Goa sales J ~ax and Luxury Tax (Settlement of Arrears by 

Hoteliers) Bill, 2004. 

(12) The Goa Tax on Luxuries (Amendment) Bill, 2004. 

I 

VIII. BUSINESS ADVISORY COMMITTEE REPORT 

, 

Shri Francis D'SOUZ~, the Minister for Legislative Affairs presented to 

the ~ousc the ~econh Report (2004) of the Business Advisory Coinmittee 

and moved the fo~ohing motion: 

1 % 

'This House do agJre with the Second Report (2004) of the Business 

Advisory Committee". 

Motion was put to vote and adopted. 

'IX. PRESENTATION OF THE SECOND BATCH OF VOTE ON 

ACCOUNT FOR A FURTHER PART OF THE FINANCIAL 

YEAR 2004-2005.x 

Shri Manohar Pqar, the Chief Minister presented a statement of 1, 

the Second Batch of yote on Account for a further part of the financial 

!, 

year 2004-2005. i /I 

11

X. DISCUSSIQN AND VOTING OF THE SECOND BATCH OF 

VOTE ON .ACCOUNT (2004-2005). 

Shri Manohar Parrikar, the Chief Minister moved for the vote of the 

House the Second Batch of Vote on Account (2004-2005). 

XI. GOVERNMENT BILL 

(A) INTRODUCTUION 

The following Bill was introduced. 

i 

Bill N0.16 of 2004 - 

I 

The G a Appropriation (Vote on Account) Bill, 

2004. 

(B) CONSIDERATION ~ N PASSING D 

Shri Manohar Parrikar, the Minister moved that the Bill No. 16 of 

2004 - The Goa on Account) Bill, 2004 be taken 

into consideration. . 

The ~ otTn for 

Four members took part in de debate: 

Clauses 2,3, and 

vote and adopted. 

'i 

"-a 

was put to vote and adopted. 

preamble and title were put to 

'

1. Shri Pratapsingh Rane moved the following amendments to the motion 

of Thanks. 

a) '%but regret that there is no mention in .the Address about the 

Hausing facilities for the poor." 

b) "but regret that there is no mention in the Address about the 

failure to establish the proper law and order in the State." 

2. SIShri Jitendra Deshprabhu, Ravi S. Naik and Aleixo Sequeira moved 

the following amehdments to the motion of Thanks. 

a) "but regret dat there is no mention in the Address about the 

failure of thd Government to give Central and State benefits to 

the ~cheduklcastes living in urban and ~ural areas of the State 

and also failure to implement reservation policy and preemployment 

scheme to them." 

I 

b) "but regret that there is no mention in the Address about the 

failure of the bovemment to extend benefits of Central subsidies 

t 

and loan sch mes introduced by Union ~~hculture Ministry as 

well as State level subsidy schemes." 

c) "but regret that there is no mention in the Address about the 

to bring about the effective changes 

State." bandharas." 

d) "but regret that there is no mention in the Address about the 

failure of theiGovernment to protect Environment and Ecology 

of the State." 

I 

e) "but regret at there is no mention in the Address about the 

4 

failure of the Government to give benefits to persons below 

I 

poverty line $y way of correct and truthful revision." 

there is no mention in the Address about the 

Government for the lack of transparency in 

of tenders of various projects." 

g) "but regret th4t there is no mention in the Address about thefailure 

of the Gove/rnment to give necessary importance in the 

agricultural sector. "

ia& iii: Q-4 

h) "but regret that there is no mention in the Address about the 

failure of the Government to extend the power subsidy to the 

farmers as well as failure to provide modern infrastructure to 

cultivators and farmers." 

i) "but regret that there is no mention in t+e Address about the 

failure of the Government to implement irrigation schemes for 

Agriculture and Horticulture." 

j) "but regret that there is no mention in the Address about the 

failure of the Government to save valuable lands by not repairing 

I 

of bunds and 

k) "but regret that there L no mention in the Address about the 

failure of the ~ ovedent to protect the fishing community to 

obtain their livelihood.'7 I 

1) "but regret that there is no mention in the Address about the 

failure of the ~ ovedent in giving quality power in the State." 

I 

m) "but regret that there Cs no mention in the Address about the 

to maintain Law and Order in the 

I 

n) "but regret that there bs no mention in the Addnss about the 

failure of the ~ove-It in quality Health Services to 

the people of Goa." 1 

) "but regret that no mention in the Address about the 

failure of the 

to provide the Tillari Water to the 

fanning community fob irrigation." 

%.,:cL 

p). 'but regret that 

'"'zf~a'pmf&ure of the 

.'. I 

s* .tiL*&$.4 

no mention in the Address about the 

to attract industries in the State." 

that there is no mention in the Address about the 

e Government to bring discipline in the Co-operative 

no mention in the Address about the 

nt to improve quality of education at all

-15- 

s) "but regret that there is no mention in the Address about the 

failure of the Government to iiplement effectively all beneficial 

schemes of various Departments." 

t) "but regret that there is-no mention in the Address about the 

failure of the Government to improve Sanitation and Garbage 

disposals." 

u) "but regret that there is no mention in the Address about the 

failure of the Government to improve rural housing and rural 

employment ." 

I 

- 

, 

3. Shri Dayanand G. ~ hekar moved the following amendments to the 

motion of Thanks. 

l 

a) , "but regret thak there is no mention in the Address about the 

rising crimes, hders, rape, dacoity and theft cases in Goa." 

b) "but regret thi there is no mentionk the Address about the 

rising unemplopment in the State of Goa." 

I 

' C) "but regret thd there is no mention in the Address about the 

rising cost of living in the State of Goa vis-h-vis tax burdens to 

1 

common/poor people." 

d) "but regret th there is no mention in the Address about the 

proposed ali2 ent of national highway from Pednem to 

Canacona." P" 

e) "but regret that there is no mention in the Address about the 

suffering of people due to unplanned development of cities/ 

/villages and attempts of Government to include more village 

areas in P.D.A against the wishes of people." 

f) "but regret that there is no mention in the Address about the 

number of suidides, accidents taking place every day." 

i 

g) "but regret that there is no mention in the Address about the 

Tdlari higatioh project..' 

I 

The amendrnebts were proposed.

I. QUESTIONS 

TUESDAY 29 JUNE, 2004 

(i) Shri. Digamber Karnat, the Minister for Pawer asked for postponement 

aff'tarred Question No. 1 for reply on 13/7/2004. 

(ii) 4 Starred Questions were replied orally. 

(iii) 35 Starred Questions were not reached and transferred to Unstarred 

list. 

(iv) 1 postponed Urntarred Questions and 19 Unstarred Questions were 

laid on the Table of the House. 

11. ZERO HOUR MENTION / 

Shri Isidore Femandes made a hention about fhe Arabian Sea which has 

started eroding into the ma:inlaAd, thereby causing considerable damage . 

to plant and property in ~oinguihim constituency. 

I 

Shri Manohar Parrikar, chief h#.nister moved the following: 

at freedom fighters S1Shri 

Dattaram Kavlekar, Gopi 

s Teresa, Anant Pawaskar, Muralidhar 

ghters who passed away 

ons of the soils have sacrificed 

from the Portuguese yoke and 

condolences to their bereaved 

and the motion was adopted 

nister laid on the Table the 

ort 2000-2001 and Action Taken Report 

the Report of National Human Rights 

earances for International 

Ordinance No. 1 of 2004).

(2) Shri Ramrao Dessai, Minister for Social Welfare laid a copy of the 

Audit Reports and Accounts pertaining to the Goa State Commission 

for Backward Classes of the following years: 

(i) Audit Report and Accounts from April 1,1994 to March 3 1,1995 

(1994-95) and from April 1,1998 to March 3 1,1999 (1998-99) 

(ii) Audit Report and Accounts from April 1,1999 to March 3 1,2000 

(1999-2000) 

(iii) Audit Report and Accounts from April 1,2000 to March 3 1,2001 

(2000-200 1) 

V. PRESENTATION /IF REPORTS 

I 

Shri Pratapsingh ~ 4e, Chairman of the Committee on Public Accounts 

presented the Fifty Eighth, Fifty Ninth and Sixtieth Report of the Public 

Accounts 'Committe ' . 

'i 

VI. DISCUSSION ON MOTION OF THANKS (second day) 

, Fuxther discussion on emotion of lXanks to the Address of the Governor 

moved by Shri L +ant Parsekar-and seconded by Shri Rajendra 

Arlekar on 28 June, 004. 

Five members partic'pated / in the debate. 

WEI!NESDAY 

I 30 JUNE, 2004 

I. QUESTIONS 1 

I 

. (i) Shri Ramkrishna Jhhavlikar, the Minister for PWD, made correction 

to Starred Questiok No. 20 

I 

I 


I 

I 


1 

list. 

(iv) 18 Unstarred Ques ons were laid on the Table of the House. 

P

11. ZERO HOUR MENTION 

-18- 

Shri Giovanni Karl Vaz made a mention about the misuse of the 

Multipurpose Hall built by the Government in Momugao Constituency. 

Owing to pandemonium in the House, the Speaker adjourned the House 

at 3:35 p.m. The House reassenibled at 4:05 p.m 

111. RULING BY THE SPEAKER 

Hon. Speaker gave a ruling disallowing the Congratulatory Motions tabled 

by SIShri Dayankd G. Narvekar and Sadanand Shet congratulating Rt. 

Rev. Filipe Ned Ferrao, on his taking over as Archbishop of Goa and 

Daman and Shri Narendra Mdharaj (Nanij Baba) on conferring him 

Dharmacharya by Adya ~hankhcharya, respectively7 -- .. 

I 

RULING 

i 

I have received the following Congratulatory Motion under Rule 125 (1) 

of the Rules of Procedure ~d 

I 

Conduct of the House of the Goa 

Legislative ~ ssebbl~ from S%. D. G. Narvekar, MLA. 

as Archbishop of 

the East Indies 

proud by being the 

great responsibility 

this State. He is a 

and ~elgium. " 

Ferrao, onhis taking over 

of the East and patriarch of 

Paul 11, who has done Goa 

at a very young age thereby taking a 

er of guiding the Catholic population of 

theologianhaving studied in Rome 

I have also received another Cod ratulatory Motionunder the same Rule 

as givenbelow by Shri. Sadanyd 

B 

M. Shet,MLA. 

"This House congratulates s+. Narendra Mharaj {Nanij Baba) on 

conferring him DHARMACHPLRYA by Adya Shankaracharaya. Shri. 

Narendra Maharaj has done gredt job to uplift the Hindu community. At 

young age great responsibility is left on his shoulders. Shti. Narendra 

Maharaj has made Goa proud oh conferring DHARMACHARAYA as 

his follow6@"& spread in Goa om ~ern6rn.b Canacona." 

b 

ession I dad received me Motion under Rule 125 

enty Shri. Narvekar.1~7hichI had disallowed 

I

These motions relate to religious aspects and may not be of general 

public interest. Therefore being a sensitive issue I directed my Secretariat 

to find out whether such Motions were taken-up by this August House in 

the past. However, the records do not show that such Motions were 

taken in the past, especially after attaining Statehood. 

As there is no precedent I felt that we should not take-up such Motions 

in the House so as to maintain secular concept. 

Therefore, by invoking inherent power, I have disallowed both these notices 

so as to rule out any precedent for future. 


again at 4:15 p.m. The qouse reassembled at 500 p.m. 

As the Member was absent the motion was not moved. 

"This House ~ondolek the death of renowned social worker Shri M. S. 

Prabhu who expired on 

I 

May 12,2004, he was in the forefront in earlier 

Political era and his contribution 

I 

to various social organizations has been 

hot~worthy, and c0nv4~ the heartfelt sympathies to the bereaved family." 

V. PAPERS LAID ON ITHE TABLE 

- -. 

Shri Ramrao Dessaij the Minister for ~ndustrks,' Art aid Culture dd 

Social Welfare laid a copy of the Audit Repo'rt' of the Goa Khadi and 

Industries Board for the year 2001-2002. 

VI. DISCUSSION AND VOTING ON MOTION OF 

(Third day) 

I 

moved by Shri 

Arlekaron 28 

Parsekar and seconded by Shri Ra~endra 

Rane, Jitendra Deshprabhu, Ravi Naik, 

otion of Thanks

The Motion of Thanks moved by Shri Laximikant Parsekar to the Address 

of the Governor was put to vote and adopted. 

I. QUESTIONS 

THURSDAY 1 JULY, 2004 ' 

(i) Shri panduraAg Madkaikar, the Minister fdr Transport made 

correction to Starred Question No. 4. 



,. Est. 

(iv) Replies to 9 Unstarred Qhestions were laid on the Table of the 

House. 

11. ZERO HOUR MENTIONS 

1. Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu dade a mention about inferior and non 

consurnabl6 grains distributed to people below poverty line by various 

nstituency and other parts of Goa." 

I . fair price shops in Pernem C I 

I i 

P 

---2: ~hri ~ijendra Aelekar mad4 a mention about the increase of fatal 

accidental deaths on roads i due ce . 

III. MOTION FO 

.'. . 

LENCE 

*.. S/Shri M and Shri Dayanand G. 

Narvekar moved th~ 

,,. This House condoles the death of Shri Prabhakar Angle q noted 

$2 C 

economist, busbkisman and philanthropist; was the presiden€:of Goa 

Chamber of Commerce and 1ndbstry from 1989 to 1991 ;%2~;esident 

,:;:,:of Kala Acadesy ;,pas Memder of the. Governing Council -anp the 

, ; 

;i,i@p~uti~e 130qdpf m a cad em^; authoredpo books on Goaqecanomy 

entitled "Goa Concepts & ~iscbncepts"and "Goa: Economic .Re.view" .- 

besides wrote several articles and columns in newspapers and magazines; 

'.," 7&*act5ve p&ifcip&it& cultural activities!& convey its sympathies to 

,-e~c- &a 

.' ,:a ,&e bereave&f&&$jti ' 

. . 5 .I,=, 

ir.. ... - 

~;jj &-i I - 

j . 5 t : 

Eleven Members spoye on the moticiii'ahd'the motion was adopted 

unanimously. 1 - , 

I 

. , , :I ; ':-fp-: ,,

-21 - 

IV. PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE 

Shri Matanhy Saldanha, the Minister for Tourism laid on the Table a ID 

copy of the 21st Annual Report of the Goa Tourism Development - 

~or~orition Ltd. for the year 2002-2003. 

I 

4 

V. ASSENT TO BILL , 

Secretary reported the assent of the Governor to the Goa Appropriation 

(Vote on ~Lcount) (~0.2) Bill, 2004 passed by the Fourth Legislative 

Assembly. 

1i 

1- 

VI. GENERAL ON THE BUDGET FOR THE STATE 1 

i 

I 

Three members took dart in the debate. 

1 

&DAY 2 JULY, 22004 

I 

t 

I. QUESTIONS I 

(i) Shri. Francis D'so&~, the Minister for Law, asked for postponement 

of stalled ~uestiod NO. 13 for reply on last week of ~uly, 2004 

(ii) 

6 Starred QuestioJ were replied orally. 


list. 

I 

(iv) Replies to 6 Unstded QYCS~~O~S were laid on the Table 

11. ZERO HOUR ME 

I 

House. 

Shri Dayanand G. Nhekar made a mention about.the collapsing of 

Hillock at Bogda, SO~OITO' this threatening the lives bf the peopie. 

111. MOTION FOR CbNIpIoLENcE 

,% e 1, 

1: 

:- , - 

SIShri Francis D' Soya, Damodar Naik and Rajendra Arlekar moved 

the following: 1 

I

"Tnis House condoles the sudden accidental death of Dr. Shrikant Jichkar, 

Journalist, great scholar with maximum number of academic degrzes 

whereby his name 'appeared in the Limca Book of World Record, who 

held every possible position in the Political life like MLA, MP, Minister of 

State for Home Affairs (Maharashtra) and in bureaucratic field as IAS 

and IPS Officer who devoted his life towards helping the tribal people 

near Himalayan terrain died on the 2nd June, 2004 in a road accident and 

this House expresses its heartfelt condolences and convey the deep sense 

of sorrow and sympathy to the bereaved family." 

Eight members spoke on the motion and the motion was adopted 

unanimously. 

IV. PRIVATE MEMBERS' RES~LUTIONS: 

I 

1. Shri Chandrakant ~avlekar Awed the following: 

I 

"This House urges upon the G4vernment to construct a minor Irrigation 

Dam at Maina in ~ue~emi~irla Village Panchayat in Quepem 

constituency for the benefit of ke people of ~ aina ~aurem ~irla viage 

Panchay ats. " 

Three members took part in the debate. 

The resolution was withdrawn by the leave of the House. 

I 

2. Shri Aleixo Sequeira moved d e following Resolution duly amended: 

I 

"i" 

I - 

"This House strongly reco I ends the Government to cover the 

cases with congenital defects under medical scheme for the parents upto 

Rs.3,50,000/- per am-" 1 

I 

Four members took part in the debate. 

I 


vernment may take early steps to 

the lines of such schools in 

a Pradesh), Bhopal (Madhya

-23- 

I a 

Pradesh), Calcutta (West Bengal), Joapur (Rajasthan) and Gujarat and - 

if necessary, relevant legislation may be passed to bring in excellence in 

qualitive legal education to satisfy the needs of judiciary and the legal 

8 

profession, as the students passing out from these institutions are picked j 

up by the corporate sector, private business houses on payment of high ' > 

salaries." $ 

 

1 - 

Two members took part in the debate. , 

The resolution was qithdrawn by the leave of the House. 

I 

4. Dr. Wilfred D'souza 1 moved the following:- 

I 

"This House resolve that the Government allocates special areas in and 

around Municipal areas 

i 

where scrap can be collected and disposed off 

to prevent developmtnt of multiple locations for such activity." 

I 

Four members took ;art in the debate. 

. The resolution was Jithdrawn by the leave of the House. 

5. Shri Dayanand G. ~arvekar moved the fallowing:- 

I 

I 

"This House strongl$ recommends the Government to construct a byepass 

road from Salvddor do Mundo to Olaulim-Pompurba in Bardez in 

order to avoid congetion." 

Two members took 

7 

/ art in the debate. 


MONDAY 5 JULY, 2004 

I. QUESTION 

1 

I 

(i) Shri Manohar ~arkkar, the-Chief Minister made correction to Starred 

Question Nos. 2,128 & Unstarred Question No. 28 and asked for 

postponement of / Starred Question Nos. 6, 17, 19 and Unstarred 

Question Nos. 31 ,and 35. 

I

Shri Rajendra Arlekar, requested to suspend the Question hour and 

to take up the Calling Attention. 


at 2:35 p.m. 

The House reassembled at 3:05p.m. Owing tc~ continued pandemonium 

in the House, the Speaker adjourned the House again at 3:07p.m. 

The House reassembled at 3:35 p.m. Owing to conhnued pandemonium 

in the House, the Speaker again adjourned the ~ o hat e 3:40 'p.m. for 

the day. 

Owing to such pandemonium replies to Starred Questions for the day 

were deemed as laid on the ~abl( and replies to Uqstqrred Questions 

were laid on the Table. 

I TUESDAY 6 'my, 2004 

I . , 

I. RULING BY THE SPEAYR , ., * . 

Hon. Speaker gave a ruling didlowing the notigeof adjournment motion 

tabled by SIShri Luizinho ~ale$o, ~iten&'rie&p'rdb%u, ~&sh'~ant~e, 

Francisco Sardinha and Smt Fernqdes for suspension of Question 

Hour and the other 

dohsk tb ifisdigke urgent matter 

regarding 

I ' 

-' . v 

RULING 

2 . :/,r 

I have received a notice for 

, discuss urgent matter 

1 issues which were 

2004. The Adjournment ~otiok seeks t&e~yg~gp+&~& Question Hour 

and the other Business of the to takeup &e related discussion. 

The signatories of the said 

'S;7*&t&. L-&Fdeiro,Jitendra 

Deshprabhu, Harish 

9, 

Fernmdes . 

.;; 

-

I further rule as follows: 

-25- 

As per the list of Business General Discussion on the Budget has been 

slated for today . Members have got ample opportunities to discuss the 

related issues during the discussion of Budget wherein they can also 

expect the replies today itself. 

As per sub Rule 6 of Rule 70 the Motion shall not anticipate a matter, 

which has been previously fixed for consideration. In such circumstances 

such Motions are not normally admitted. If you want to censure the 

Government there are ample of opportunities available to you to raise 

such issues through other forums. The Business is already been fixed in 

consultation with the Business Advisory Committee and the 

recommendations of the Busitiess Advisory Committee allocating the 

time for the Business das already been approved by this August House. 

I 

As per Rule 268 of de Rules of Procedure the Financial Business is 

required to be dispos off by giving priority. I am there.fore bound by 

this Rule. 

I would like to quote Speaker's Ruling, Shri. Shivraj V. Patil who was 

in the chair of Lok then in the year 1996-97 which was reported in 

the journal of parliarnebtary Momation June 96VolumXLII as follows: 

I 

"Adjourment motionk are not normally allowed during the budget 

discussion or during/ the discussion on the Motion of Thanks on 

President's Address as members have sufficient opportunity to 

- focus the attention of the House to AY matter during that 

discussion" 

4 

I therefore, disallow e notice. 

Owing to continued pandebonium in the House, the Speaker adjourned 

the House at 2:40 p.m. 

The House reassembled at 3:10 p.m. Owing to continued pandemonium 

in the House, the once again adjourned the House at 3:15 

p.m. for the day. 

Owing to such 

replies to Starred Questions for the day 

were deemed as laid on the Table and replies to Unstarred Questions 

were laid on the Table.

WEDNESDAY 7 JULY, 2004 

I. QUESTIONS 

(i) Shri Rarnkrishna Dhavalikar, the Minister for PWD made correction 

to Starred Question No. 24 and asked for postponement of Starred 

Question Nos. 1,21 for reply on 28/7/2004. 

(ii) 

34 Starred Questions and 14 Unstarred Questions laid on theTable of 

the House. 

Hon. Speaker gave a ruling disylowing the notice of adjournment motion 

tabled by SIShri Joaquim Alemao, Karl Vaz, Harish Zantye, Dayanand 

Narvekar, Luizinho Faleiro, hgnelo Fernandes, Pratapsingh R. Rane 

and Smt Victoria Fernandes fbr suspension of Question Hour and the 

other Business of the House tb discuss the acts of Criminal trespass, 

rioting, destruction of private Aroperty, assault, arson and vandalism by 

I 

the BJP Government represented by the Cabinet Ministers, Member of 

Legislatiwe Assembly etc. committed 

I 

at Mapusa. 

, 

I 

RYLING 

I have received a notice dated dth ~ ul~, 2004 of Adjournment Motion for 

suspending Question-Hour bd the other Business of the House to 

discuss the acts of Criminal trespass, rioting, destruction of private 

property, assault, arson and van alismby the BJP Government represented 

4 

by the Cabinet Ministers, Member of Legislative Assembly etc. committed 

at Mapusa. The signatories to fhis motion areis1 Shri. Joaquim Alemao, 

Karl Vaz, Harish Zantye, ~a~a$and ~arvekar! Luizinho Faleiro, Agnelo 

Fernandes, Pratapsigh R. ~ ane and Smt. Victoria Fernandes. 

I 

At the out set I would like td inform the Members that if they are 

interested in discussing the matter they may raise the same through 

Calling Attention Motion. It 1s unfomnate that I have received 3 

Adjournment Motions within 7/working days. As regards to this notice of 

the motion, I feel the notice is not in the concise form of Motion and 

therefore, it is not in compliance with the Rules.

I had already ruled in my earlier rulings that such motions shall not 

anticipate a matter, which has been previously fixed for consideration as 

envisaged under Rule 70 (6) of the Rules of Procedure. As per Bulletin 

issued by this Secretariat the Demands on Home is listed for 15th July, 

2004 for discussion and voting during which this issue can be discussed 

threadbare by the Members. The relevant Bulletin has already been 

circulated to the members. 

I have also cited in my earlier Rulings about the Ruling givenby the then 

Speaker Shri. Shivraj Patil in 1996-97 wherein: 

"~djo-ent motions are not normally allowed during the budget 

discussion orduring thk discussion on the Motion of Thanks on President's 

Address as members sufficient opportunity to focus the attention of 

the House to any 

that discu~sion'~ 

I 

I therefore disallow 4e notice of Adjournment Motion for suspending 

the Question hour an other business of the House. 

4 

Owing to pandemoniu& in the House, the Speaker adjourned the 

House at 2:42 p.m. 

The House reassembled 3:35 p.m. Owing to such pandemonium 

replies to Starred ~uestibns for the day were deemed as laid on the 

Table and replies to Uns-d Questions were laid on the Table. 

(1) .Dr. Suresh Amonk , the Minister for Health laid on the Tablea copy 

of the Goa Factorie f (Tenth Amendment) Rules, 2004. 

(2) Shri Manohar the Chief Minister laid on the Table a copy of 

the Gaa Forest Development Corporation 

Ltd. for the year 2002-2003. 

I 

N. DISCUSSION ANDIVOTING ON DEMANDS FOR- GRANTS 

FOR TJ3E FEAR 2004;2005. 

The following Demands were moved: 

Demand No.2 General Adm. & Coardinadon 

Demand ~ o.6 - ~lectiqn Office

Demand No.8 - Treasury & Accounts Administration, North Goa 

Demand No.9 - Treasury & Accounts Administration, South Goa 

Cut Motins to Demand Nos. 2,8 and 9 were not moved by the members. 

No members took part in the debate. 

In the midst of uproarious scene, the estimates of voted expenditure in 

respect of Demand Nos.2,6,8,9 were put to vote and granted. 

THURSDAY^ 8 JULY, 2004 

I 

I. , QUESTIONS 

(i) Shti Pandwang ~adkaikar, t$e Minister for Transport made correction 

to Starred Question No. 13. / 

(ii) 7 Starred Questions were reghied orally. 

(iii) 28 Starred Questions were not reached and transfend to Unstarred 

list. 

e 

(iv) 26 Unstarred Questi~ns wer laid on the Table of the House. 

11. RULING BY THE SPEAYR 

Hon. Speaker gave a ruling to th,e I notice of adjounment motion tabled by 

Shri Pratapsingh R. Rane for the involvement of two Ministers viz,-the 

Ministers Shri Francis D 'SO~Z~ and Shri Dayanand Mandrekar in 

I 

vandalism and in terrorizing people in Mapusa 'tijriattacking with a mob 

the Hotel of thecongressman Shri Mathew.. Braganza and criminally 

trespassing into the hotel and destroying propefty, near Cine Alankar 

who need to be prosecuted forisuch criminal acts which are unheard of 

in the political history of Goa, ;and the Hon. speaker announced that he 

would take up discussion at 6:30 p.m. for one &our after hishing the 

discussion and voting on Demands. 

;: ; < + < $ j&": "> 2 .*, ' 

RULING ..-. 

I *. . * 

I have receive 9 notice of ~bjournment Motion dated 8th July, 2004 

of Procedure and- ond duct cif ~uine& of the 

Shri. P. R. Rane-,Lqa$er of ,Opposition 

of urgent ~@p&ce:

"The involvement of two Ministers viz, the Ministers Shri. Francis D'souzi 

and Shri. Day anand Mandrekar in vandalism and in terrorizing people ir 

Mapusa by attacking with a mob the Hotel of the Congressman Shri 

Mathew Braganza and c-ally trespassing into the hotel and destroying 

property near Cine Alankar who need to be prosecuted for such criminal 

acts which are unheard of in the political history of Goa". 

In fact I have already given my ruling on similar subject yesterday. 

Therefore I decline to admit the said notice since I have already decided 

on the said subjecd. 

I 

As per Kaul and Shakdhar page 667 the following is relevant: 

"The general rule regarding motions is that a motion must not raise a 

question substantially identical with one on which the House has already 

given a decision inlthe same session." 

Further Rule 37 (6)' provides that it shall not repeat in the same session 

in substance questions already answered or to which an answer Qs 

been refused. 

However, considering the urgency of the matter I am reidy to convert 

this motion into Shdrt duration under Rule 64 of the Rules of procedure, 

if the Members agrhes. We can take-up the discussion at 6.30 p.m. far 

one hour after finishing discussion and voting on Demands. Discussiop 

on Demands will have to be stopped at 6.00 p.m. so that Ministers would 

be able to reply by 6.30 p.m.. 

111. PAPERS LAID OT THE TABLE 

I 

Dr. Suresh Amonkar, the Minister for Health laid on the Table the 

following: 

I 

4 

(i) Notification No. 1 19191-PHD dated 24-1-2003, empowering Director 

of Food & Drugs Admn. Under clause (vi) of section 2 of the 

Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954 (central Act 37 of 1954) to 

exercise all the pokers and perform tbc duties of the Food (Health) 

Authority under the said Act for the entire State of Goa, published in 

Official Gazette, Extraordinary No.2 Series 11, No.43 dated 24.1.2003.

(ii) Order No.DFDA/PFAA-1211981533 dated 24: 1.2003 prohibiting the 

sale of Gutka and Pan Masala containing tobacco or not 

containingtobacco by whatever name called, published in the Official 

Gazette,Extraordinary No.2, Series I, No.43 dated 24.1.2003. 

(iii) Order No.DFDA/PFAA- 121/98/568 dated 7-4-2003, prohibiting the 

sale of articles of food, such as food articles tobacco and/or extract 

thereof, with any kind of flavours including cardamom, menthol, and/ 

or any kind of sweeteners including sugar, glycerine, glucose, andlor 

aromatic herbs and spices including dry fruits, silver leaves, saffron 

mulethi, sabnernusa and lime, hl or any of them, published in Official 

Gazette, ~xtraordinh ~0.2, jeries II, No. 1 dated 7/4/2003. 

(iv) Notification No. 10/9/9 

No. l0/9/9 1-I/PHD 

the Officers to be 

Administration 

Extraordinary 

dated. 29-5-2003, and Notification 

19h2/2004 regarding appointment of 

Authority, in chqe of the Health 

published in Official Gazette, 

30bii2003 and Official Gazette 

(v) Notification No. 

dated 31-7-200i, empowering the 

Magistrate First Class, to try 

& Cdsmetics ~ ct, 1940, 

in t$e Official Gazette 

(vi) Notification NO. 13/53/87 -M/HD dated 31R/2W3:3 regarding Goa 

Narcotic Drugs and Psychot pic Substancesr @mendment), Rules 

2003 pblished in the 0 fficialkette, Series Ii &. 18 dated 3 1.7.2003

IV. CALLING ATTENTION 

Shri Dayanand G. Narvekar called the attention of the Chief Minister t 

the following matter of urgent public importance: 

"apprehension and anxiety in the minds of the parents in general an 

student community in particular who have answered their examinatio 

XI1 standard of open schools, due to leakage of question papers, 

which re-examination was called during the 2nd week of June, 2004 an 

the result of the said examination is expected during the month of Augu 

2004 and that the colleges are not giving them admissions as hundreds 

and who were seeking 

absence of proper direction 

Education 

students may loose their valu 

academic year, the Government intends to take in the matter." 

The reply to the C 

2004. 

was postponed to Monday 12 Jul 

Y GOVERNMENT ILL (INTRODUCTION) 

ii 

The following Bill das introduced: 

Bill No. 19 of 2004 4 fhe heoa Barge Tax (Amendment) Bill, 2004. 1 

VI.' D~SCUSSION A 

1 

~ VOTING D ON DEMANDS FOR GRANTS 

FOR THE YEAR 2004-2005 

The following Dem nds were moved. 

I 

i 

- Factories & Boilers 

Seven niembers too part in the debate. 

Shri Atanasio the.Minister for Town & Country Planning 

Minister for Labour in charge of Demands 

replied to the debate1 

Owing to pandemo 'um in the House the Speaker adjourned the House 

at 6;30 p.m. "t 

I 

- > 

I 

The House resumed its sitting at 6:45. In the midst of uproarious scene 

the estimates of voted expenditure in respect to Demand Nos.52,54,59,60 

- ~ 

were put to vote and granted. 

I 

I (

~ 

I 

FRIDAY 9 JULY, 2004 

I. QUESTIONS 

(i) 1 Starred Question was replied orally. 

(ii) 22 Starred Questions were not reached and transferred to Unstarred 

list. 

(iii) Replies to 12 Unstarred Questions were laid on the Table of the House. 

Owing to pandemonium in the Housp, the Speaker adjourned the House 

I 

at 257 p.m. 

i 

The House resumed its sitting at3:45 p.m. Two Members namely Shri 

Jitendra Deshprabhu and ~hri ~uihinho Faleiro were ordend to withdraw 

from the House for their disorde iy conduct and the members withdrew 

'i 

forthwith. The Opposition Members staged a walk out. 

I - 

11. PRIVATE MEMBERS' RES~LUTIONS 

I 

1. Smt. Victoria Ferns the mover of the following Resolution was 

not present in the House. i 

"This House strongly reco-ends the Government that the areas 

already acquired by the ~ ovehent for be purpose of widening of 

roads should be demarcated +ediately to avoid encroachments over 

such areas." 

I 

2. Shri Dayanand G. ~arvekar tie mover of the following Resolution 

was not present in the ~ouse! 

"This House strongly reco 1 ends the Government to set up Urban 

Health Centre at Porvorim in order to cater to the needs of the people 

residing at Porvorim and surrunding areas." 

I 

3. ~hri 1sidore Fernandes the mover of the following Resolution was not 

I 

present in the House. 

I 

f;:,'

-33- 

4. Shri Darnodar Naik moved the following Resolution: 

"Whereas it is noticed that the number of deaths in Margao City and 

the surrounding areas are increasing day by day due to accidents, 

drowning etc. and due to the police formalities which take longer time, 

till then bodies are required to be kept in the morgue of Hospicio 

Hospital, Margao which is not adequate to accommodate more number 

of dead bodies since only one out of three units has been functioning 

at present in this hospital, therefore this House strongly recommends 

the Government to construct a morgue at every PHC in Salcete taluka 

to cater to the qeeds of such contingencies." 

I 

Two members took part in the debate. Shri Surcsh Amonkar, the 

Minister for ~ ehth replied. 

I 

The resolution ;as withdrawn by the leave of the House 

I 

5. Dr. Wilfred ~'sdLza moved the following- 

"This House sb 

\ 

ongly resolves that the Department of Power 

- . (Electricity) draw/;up a comprehensive scheme for ktallhg undergmund 

, cable system for distribution of power pafticplarly invillages with large 

number of cocod t tnw to avoid inconvenience to the people due to 

i-' 

frequent breakdo n in power supply." 

Shri Manohar Parrikar, the Chief 

The resolution 

by the leave of tbe House. 

12 JULY, 2004 

., 

I. QUESTIONS t 

(i) Shri Manohar ~ahkar, the Chief Minister, made correcfions to 

t 

' Unstarred Question ~ 0.~21 and asked for post$onement of Starred 

' 

I 

~uebtion NOS. 16 to ttie next Session and ko. 38 for reply on 26/7/04 

and - Unstarred 4estion Nos. 34 & 35 to the next Session.


(iii) 33 Starred Questions were not reached and transferred tounstarred 

list. 

(iv) Replies to 34 Unstmed Questions were laid on the Table of the 

House. 


Shri Harish N. P. Zantye made a mention about the news item which 

appeared in Tarun Bharat on1 2-7-2004 regarding death of late Shri 

Digambar Krishna Govekar. I 

111. CALLING ATTENTION / 

I 

Further discusion on the 

Narvekar on 8 July, 

was called to the 

general and 

moved by Shri Dayanand 

of the Chief Minister 

their valuable academic year, 

the matter. 

Shri Manohar Parrikar, Chi 

action Government intends to take in 

IV. GOVERNMENT BILL- 

1 

P 

ON AND PASSING 

Shri Manohar Panikar, the C .ef hnister moved that the Bill No. 19 

of 2004 - The Goa Barge Tax (Amendment) Bill, 2004 be taken into 

consideration. 

l 

a-=- 

.Lv+%.,+. - 

I 

e mot~oqfo ~Gideration bf the Bill was put to vote and adopted. 

ses 1 ,2,*$@Je, pearmble and title were put to vote and adopted. 

motion for p&s& .a 

of .thee BBP wk poi to vote and adopted. 

> , 

= a I

V. DISCUSSION AND VOTING ON DEMANDS FOR GRANTS 1 

FOR THE YEAR 2004-2005 1 

I" 

jl 


! 

Y 

Demand No.43 - Art & Culture Demand No.57 - Social Welfare 

1 

Demand No.55 - Municipal Administration 

Demand No.76 - Electricity 1 

Demand No.83 - Mines 

I 1 

I 

The Cut Motions to bmand Nos. 55,76, 83 were moved by SIShri 

Pratapsingh R. Rane (Leader of Opposition), Aleixo Sequeira, Isidore 

Fernandes and Smt J&toria Fernandes, MLAs. 

The Cut Motions to Demand Nos.43,55,76 were moved by Shri Dayanqd 

I 

G. Narvekar, MLA. 1 

I 

Twenty members took part in the Debate. 1 

SIShri Ramrao ~essad the Minister for Social Welfare and Digambar 

Kamat, the Minister fdr Power in charge of the Demands repliedrtb the 

debate. 1 

. 

I 

The cut motions inrespect of Demand Nos. 43,55,76,83 were put to vote 

and defeated. 

l 

The estimates of ioted expenditure in respect of Demand 

1 

Nos.43,55,57,76,83 put to vote and granted. I 

VI. GOVERNMENT 

CONSIDERATION AND PASSING 

Shri Manohar Parrikar, the Chief Minister moved that the Bill No. 11 of 

2004 - The Goa ~oopkrative Society (Amendment) Bill, 2004 be taken 

into consideration. 

The motion for considIration of the Bill was put to vote and adopted. 

Clauses 1 to 10, pre&le 

and title were put to vote and adopted. 

The motion for passhi of the Bill was put to vote and adopted. 

1 

1

I. QUESTIONS 

TUESDAY 13 JULY, 2004 

(i) Shri Ramrao Hesai, the Minister for Industries, asked for postponement 

of Starred Question No.30 for reply on 20 -7-2004. 

(ii) Shri Digamber Kamat, the Minister for Power, asked for postponement 

of Starred Question No.7 for reply on 27-7-2004. 

(iii) 1 postponed Starred Question and 8 Starred Questions were replied 

orally 

(iv) 30 Starred Questions were not reached and transferred erally to 

Unstarred list. 

I 

(v) Replies to 25 Unstarred ($estions were laid on the Table of the 

House. 

I 


1. Shri Dayanand G. ~arvekarl made a mention about the unscientific 

manner in which the hillock ib Porvorim is being cut. 

2. Shri Luizinho Faleiro made aimention about the harassment meted out 

< ; . 

to MIS. New MillenniumBa/kers Cake Shops in Goa. 

111: DISCUSSION AND VOTI pb G ON DEMANDS FOR GRANTS 

FOR THE YEAR 2004-2004. 

The following Demands were doved: 

I 

Demand No. 11 - Excise 1 

Demand No. 12 - Sales & Entertainment Tax 

Demand No. 14 - ~oa'sadan ' 

Demand No.15 - Collectorate, North Goa 

Demand No.16 - Collectorate, South Goa 

The Cut-MvJions to Demand /Nos. 11,12,14,15 were moved by Shri 

~a~anand % ~arvekar, MLA.1 

The Cut Motions to Demand d0.14 were moved by SIShri Pratapsingh 

R. Ram (Leadk~f~~~ositionj, Isidore Femandes, Aleixo Sequeira and 

I 

Smt %ctoria Fem+&s, MLAs. 

Thirteen members toas;pprt 4 the Debate. 

I

I_- 

Shri Manohar Parrikar, Chief Minister replied to the debate. 

F 

The cut motions in respect of Demand Nos. 11,12,14,15 were put to vot 

and defeated. 

e l 

The estimates of voted expenditure in respect of Deman 1 

Nos.11,12,14,15,16 were put to vote and granted. 

k 

5 

WEDNESDAY 14 JU.LY, 2004 

r > 

I. QUESTIONS I \ 

(i) Shri Ramkrisba Dhavalikar, the Minister for PWD, made correction 

to Starred 4estions No. 22 

I 

(6) Shd ano oh ad ~z~aonkar, the Minister for Panchayat made correction 

to Stvred Quhtion 31. 

\ 

(ii) 9 Starred Qubstions were replied orally. 

(iy) 24 Starred Qkestions were not reached and tranfered to Unstarred 

list. 

I I 

(v) Replies to 26 Unstarred Questions were laid on the Table of the gouse. 


I 

1. Shri Joaquim Alemao made a mention that motorized canoe have 1 

breached the b ed pe.od 

. of fishing as specified by the Gave-ent. 1, \ 

t 

1 I 

2. Smt. Victoria Fe andes made a mention that the mining rejects dumped 

in the forest are I is canied by rivulets to the paddy fields, causing 

huge losses. 

iY 

111. PAPERS LAID 0, THE TABLE 

1. Shri Manohar ~Arrika, the Chief Minister laid od the ~adie the I 

fonowing: 

I ' 

!I 

(i) Notification No.SilSn003-Fin (R&C) dated 20.1.2004, exempting 

whole of the tax payable under theGoa tax on Entry of Goods 

I

Act, 2000 (Goa Act 14 of 2000) on entry of "ethanol" in to a local 

area for being doped in petrol, published in the Official Gazette, 

Extraordinary, Series I1 No.43 dt. 22.1.2004. 

(ii) NotificationNo.5/3/2004-Fin (R&C) dated 17.5.2004, exempting 

the tax payable under the Goa Tax on Entry of Goods Act, 2000 

(Goa Act 14 of 2000) in respect of machinery, equipment and 

other material required for use in research and development work 

by Railways, upon their entry into any local area within the State 

of Goa, for a period of one year with effect from February 5, 

2004. 

1 

( i) Notification 

amending the 

Tax Act, 1964 (Act 4 of 

returns by the registered 

Rs.50001- and/or total 

I No.52 dated 30.3.2004. 

substituting the limit for filing the 

whose sales tax liability exceeds 

Rs.20 lakhs during previous 

No.2) Series 

i THE YEAR 2004-2005 . i 

1 The following Demands were 

Demand No.68 - Forest 

i I 

The Cut Motions to Demand 

G. Narvekar,MLA.

Shri Dayanand Mandrekar, the Minister for Agriculture and Shri Mano 

Parrikar, the Chief Minister replied to the debate. 

The cut motions in respect of Demand Nos. 64,65,71 were put to vo 

and defeated. 

The estimates of voted expenditure in respect of Demand Nos.64,65,68, 

were put to vote and granted. 

THURSDAY 15 JULY, 2004 

I. QUESTIONS / 

I i 

(i) Shri ~andurane Madkaikar, the Minster for Transport asked 

postponement df Starred Question No. 5 and Unstarred Question N 

19 to reply on 29-7-2004. 

(i) Dr Suresh ~mobar, Minister for Health made corrections to Starre 

Question No. 28. 

(ii) 12 Starred Questions 

i 

were replied orally. 

I 

i 

I 

' (iii) 24 Starred ~uestions were not reached and transterred to Unstarre 

list. 

I ! 

(iv) Replies to 29 Unstarred 

I 

Questions were laid on the Table of the Hous 

I 

11. CALLING ATTANTION 

i 

Shri Luizinho Faleiro called the attention of the Minister for Fisheries t 

the anger and desiair in the minds of the people of Goa on account of 

illegal fishing by lelected few motorized canoes and boats inspite o 

Government of 1ndka7s uniform ban imposed from 18 June to 15 Augus 

2004 on the West coast of India for protection of ecology and environrnen 

and the total apathb and negligence on the part the Government and 

the steps taken by he Government in this regard. 

Six members took part in the debate. 

Shri Rarnkrishna Dbavalikar, MiDster for Fisheries replied to the debate 

I 1 

I

I1 DISCUSSION AND VOTING ON DEMANDS FOR GRANTS 

FOR THE YEAR 2004-2005 

I 

I 


Demand No. 17 - Police 

Demand No. 18 - Jails 

Demand No.23 - Home 

Demand No.24 - Goa Public Men's Corruption Investigation and Enquiries 

%emand No.25 - Home Guards & Civil Defence 

Demand No.26 - Fire and Emerd ncy Services 

i" 

The Cut Motions to Demand Nos 7 & 23 were movedby Shri Dayanand 

G. Narvekar, MLA. 

The Cut Motions to Demand 

Pratapsingh R. Rane (Leader 

S. Naik and Agnelo Fernandes, 

& 23 were moved by S/Shri 

Harish N.P. Zantye, Ravi 

Fourteen mtembers took part 

Shri Manohar Parrikar, the 

The cut motions in respect 

and defeated. 

Tie ,es$imates of voted ex 

NOS. 17,1823,2+25,26 were put 

i-. 

replied to the debate. 

. Noq11,18,23 

- were put to vote 

of Demand 

Bill,


I. QUESTIONS 

(i) 4 Starred Questions were replied orally. 

(ii) 19 Starred Questions were not reached and transferred to ~nstarrecl 

list. 

(Z) Replies to 12 Unstarred Questions were laid on the Table of the 

House. 


. 

1. Shri Darnodar Naik made a mention about the order of High Court 

about a ban on the elling of idols of Ganapati made out of plaster of 

paris. 

2. Smt. %ctoria Fernandes made a mention about the Hepatitis-E due to 

consumption of water supplied by the private tankers, from well water, 

which is not properly checked by the Health Department in Panaji and 

sufrounding areas. , 

I 

3. Shri Luizinho Faleiko and Shri Giovanni Karl Vaz made a mention 

about the issue of ficsh notices by the Mormugao Municipal Council 

to the residents of daina, Vasco to more than 200 people for vacating 

within 10 days of the receipt of the notices as reported on all the 

i 

papers during the monsoon season thereby putting the people into 

hardships and difficklties. 

I 

111. PRIVATE MEMsEks' RESOLUTIONS 

I 

1. Shri Jitendra ~esh~kabhu moved the following:- 

I 

"This ~ouse unanihusly resolves the Government that the children 

of ex-servicemen with Goan origin seeking admission in Goa Medical 

College and other t chnical institutions be given preference over, non 

4 

Goan ex-servicemen children by amending the relevant mles suitably 

on line for reservation in case of OBC/ST/SC/FF/PH and other special 

categories." 

, 

'


The resolution was adopted unanimously. 

2. Shri Agnelo Fernandes moved the following:- 

"This House strongly recommends the Government to establish a Fire 

Station in Calangute Constituency at the earliest in view of the touristic 

importance of the area. 

Two members took part in the debate. 


3. Dr. Wilfred D'souza moved the following:- 

"This House str~ngly resolvks to request the Government to give grants 

for promotion of the ~onkAni language and literature in the Roman 

script taking into consideradion that a large number of Goans use this 

I 

script in contributing to journals, newspapers, magazines and books in 

this script." 

I 

I 

Two members took part in ;the debate. 

The resolution as amended 1 with the following text was adopted 

un&ously. ! 

the Government to give 

and literature in the 

number of Goans 

newspapers, magazines and 

4. Shri Darnodar Naikmoved the following:- 

"Whereas it has been obseked that the various selling agencies fmm 

outside Goa organize codrcial exhibitions at various important places 

in Goa particularly during t$e festival seasons without any restrictions 

from the local bodies, therefore this House recommends the 

Government to regulate dhe holding of such exhibitions so that 

substantial revenue could de earned by Government." 



I

5. Shri Francis M. Silveira the mover of the following resolution was not 

present in the House: 

"Whereas it is noticed that though Goa being a touristic State, it lacks 

entertainment facilities such as Golf courses, marina facilities, Casinos 

etc.therefo~5 this House strongly recommends the Government to 

promote such facilities by providing soft loans to private parties and 

permit them to obtain licenses for casinos in order to attract high 

spending international tourists for which licenses for casino operations 

may be extended to 3 stars residential facilities." 

I. QUESTIONS 


(i) Shri ~anohar ~&r, the Chief Minister asked for postponement of 

Starred Question Nbs.4,19,26,29,36 to the next session and Urntarred 

(ii) 

Question NOS. 10,151~17 and 19 and made coi~ctions to Starred Question 

No. 5 

I 

1 

3 Starred Questiod were replied orally. 

I 

(iii) 

I 

(v) Replies to 1 postpo, 

were laid on the Table of the House. 

1 

29 Starred Questipns were not reached and transferred to Unstarred 

list. 

ed Unstarred Question and 28 Unstamd Questions 


I 

Shri Agneb ~ernandhs made a mention about running of ilkgal bars and 

tavernas by foreignec in Candolim and Calangute. 

I 

In. PAPERS tA3D 04 ''THE TABLE 

I 

Shri Mancrhar the Chief Mniskr laid on the Table a copy a$ 

h a 1 Acmmts for the year 2001-2002 and 

State IE&&&xicW Development Capration

IV. DISCUSSION AND VOTING ON DEMANDS FOR GRANTS 



Demand No. 31 - Panchayats ' 

Demand No. 70 - -Civil Supplies 

Demand No. 13 - Transport 

Demand No. 33 - Revenue 

Demand No. 07 - Settlement & Land Records 

Demand No. 77 - River Navigation 

Demand No. 67 - Ports ~dmidstration 

The Cut Motions to Demand kos.13,31,33 &77 were &edby 

Dayqeand G. Narvekar. 1 

I 

Shri 

The Cut Motions to Demand was moved by SIShri Pratapsingh 

R. Rane(Leader of Jitendra Deshprabhu,MLA. 

Twentytwo members took 

SIShri ~ kohar ~z~aonkar, 

~adkaikar, the ~ini+er for 

for Captain of Ports in 

1 

in the Debate. 

for Panchayati Raj , Pandurang 

S aldanha, the Minister 

The cut motions in 

vote and defeated. 

: Nos.7,13,31,33,70,77,6 

v. GOVERNMENT BIL 

(A) INTRODUCTION

(B) CONSIDERATION AND PASSING 

j; 

I 

Shri Manohar Parikar, the Chief Minister moved that the Bill No.21 of; 

2004 - The Goa Entertainment Tax (Amendment) Bill, 2004 be take4 

into consideration. 

I 

The motion for consideration of the Bill was put to vote and adopted. 

i 

1 

I 

Clauses 1,2, preamble and title were put to vote and adopted. i ! 

The motion for passing of the Bill was put to vote and adopted. 

I 

I 

I. QUESTIONS , 

20 JULY, 2004 

I 

(i) Shri. Atanasio Mdnserrate, the Minister for Town & Country Planning j 

made corrections to Starred Question No. 3 

I 

i 

I 

(G) Shri Digamber Kbat, the ~inister for power asked for postponement of Starred Questiyn Nos. 7,23 to next session and Unstarred Question 1 

' 

'Nos. 12,19 and 21 for reply on 27-7-2004. 

I 

($1 1 postponed Stded Question and 5 Starred Question were replied 

orally. 

1 

(iv) 30 Starred Que: dns were nor reached and transferred to Unstarred 

list. I 1 

(v) Replies to 22 Unstarred Question were laid on the Table of the House. 


I 

1. Shri Dayanand G.; Narvekar made a mention abht the erection of 

electric poles at various places by Power Grid CorporationDepartment. 

2. Shri Rajesh Pabekar made a mention about the severe leakage of 

chemical, which took place in Bicholim on 29 Jun 2004 at Industrial I 

Estate Bicholim, b+longing to MIS Venus Grand Oaanic Factory. 

1

I 

3. Shii Agnelo Fernandes made a mention about the increase in dmwning 

deaths of tourist in the coastal belt, thereby giving a bad name to the 

State of Goa. 

%II. PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE 

1. Shri Manlohar P&ar, the Chief Minister laid on the Table the 

following: 

(i) The Government Guarantee to the S anjivani Sahakari Sakhar 

Karkhana Ltd., Dayanand agar, for availing cash credit facilities 

b 

to the tune of Rs. 1625.00 l p from the Goa State Co-operative 

I 

l 

Bank Ltd., Panaji sanctioned under Order No.62-94-2002/TS/RCS 

dated 7.11.2003. 

I 

(ii) 

The Government ~uarantle to the Sanjivani Sahakari Sakhar 

Karkhana Ltd., Dayanand agar, for availing cash credit facilities 

to the tune of Rs.2500.00 !MI 1 s from the Goa State Co-operative 

Bank Ltd., Panaji, under Order No.62-94-2002/TS/RCS 

dated 31.12.2003. 

(iii) Office Order No.62-94-2 F€'S/;RCS dated 4.6.2004, revoking of 

Government Gmtee 

l&ts providedtothe Sanjivani 

Sahakari Sakhar ~arldiada Ud., +ayanand ~ a ~ vide a r Order 

No.62-94-2002/TS/RCS d 31.12-2003 

'forobtaining cash credit 

facilities from the Goa Co-operalive 3mk hd., Panaji with 

~>,*,""+

The cut motions to Demand Nos. 20, 22 & 32 were moved by Sht 

Dayanand G. Narvekar, MLA. 

Nine members took part in the Debate: 

Shri Manohar Parrikar, the Chief Minister replied to the debate. 

I 

The cut motions inrespect of Demand Nos. 20,22 & 32 were put to votc ' 

and defeated. I : 

The estimates of voted expenditure in respect of Demand Nos. 20,22 

30,32 were put to vote and granted. 

QUESTIONS 

I 


(i) Shri Ramlucishna Dhavalikar, the Minister for PWD asked for 

postponement of unstaned Question No. 33 to next,Session. 

Lii) .Shri Manohar Azgaonkar, the Minister for Panchayat made corrections 

to Starred ~uestihn No. 6 

, 

(g) 8 starred Questioy were replied orally. 

(iv) 26 Starred Questions were not reached and transferred to Unstarred / 

list. 

I 

I 

(v) ~e~lies to 36 unshed Questions were laid on the Table of the House. 

I 


1 

I 

1. ShriSadanand Shet made a mention about the narrow road at =vim 

from playground to Tivim chapel which has become an accident prone / 

zone. 

1 

2. Shri Francisco Sardinha made a mention about St Jose Areal road I 

which has completely deteriorated, as all the vehicles going from 1 

Sanvordem, Quepem and Sanguem are go* via St Jose Areal road. 

I 

t 

I 

I 

I 

I 

1

I 

I 

11. DISCUSSION AND VOTING ON DEMANDS FOR GRANTS 



Demand No.47 - Goa Medical College 

Demand No.48 - Health Services 

Demand No.49 - Institute of Psychiatry and Human Behaviour 

Demand No.51 - Goa Dental College 

Demand No.53 - Foods & Drugs Administration 

The Cut~Motions to Demand N~S. 47 & 48 were moved by SIShri 

Pratapsingh R. Rane (Leader of pposition), Jitendra Deshprabhu and 

Dayanand G. Narvekar,MLAs. 

Eighteen members took part in the/ Debate. 

Dr. Suresh Amonkar, Minister for Health replied to the debate. 

The cut motions in respect of ~ehand Nos. 47 & 48 were put to vote 

and defeated. 

The estim'ates of voted expenditure in respect of Demand 

Nos.47,48,49,51&53 were put to iote and granted. 

THURSDAY 26 JULY, 2004 

. QUESTIONS ! 

i (i) Dr Suresb Amonkar, the Minist' r for Health asked for postponement 

/ of Starred Question No.9 for rep P y on 29-7-2004 and made corrections 

/ to Stamd Question No. 22 hdan life. 

1 I 

r (ii) Shri Pandurang Madkaikar, the Minister for Revenue asked for 

I postponement of Starred 26 to reply on 29-7-2004. 

ii. 

i.'. . 

i 6) 

5 Starred Questions were 

s were not Leached and tr


1 

I 

1. Shri Harish N. P. Zantye made a mention about the private tour 1 

operators are not visiting Mayem lake, Mulgao (Vanadevi Temple), I 

Sanquelim (Dattatraya Temple), Harvalem waterfalls and Narve , 

(Saptkoteshwar Temple) which are declared as touristic spots by the 

Government of Gos. 

2. Shri Luizinho Faleiro made a mention about acquisition of fertile land 

by the Government at Margao and Quepem by the State Urban 1 

Development Agency located at adjacent to the NH 17 at the entrance 

to the city of ~argao for the purpose of setting up the proposed 

Kalagram. 

I 

3. Shri Luizinho Faleiro made a mention about students community and 

specially the residents of'Madel who have been spearheading an 1 

agitation against the sound, air and water pollution created by certain 1 

miscreants in the area thereby creating health hazard and the threat of I 

epidemics due to open pits which are filled with sewerage waste posing 

' a'serious threat to human life. 

I 

4. Snd Luizinho Faleiro made a mention about the plight and suffering of ( 

the Truck owners due to police harassment for not allowing them to 1 

take their unloaded1 trucks to their residential places. 

I 

I 

111. PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE 

. . I 

1. Shri Manohar Parrikar, the Chief Minister laid on the Table a copy of 1 

statement of ~uarbtee given by the Government for the loan etc. 

raised by statutory Corporations, Local Bodies and other financial 

hlstitutioIls. 

I 

2. Shri Ramarao Dessai, the Minister for Industries laid on the Table a 

copy of the 23rd h ual Report 2002-2003 of the Goa Handicrafts 1 

Rwd and Small Scale hdustries Development Corpbration Ltd. 

I 

I

IV. DISCUSSION AND VOTING ON DEMANDS FOR GRANTS 



Demand No.34 - School Education 

Demand No.35 - Higher Education 

Demand No.36 - Technical Education 

Demand No.37.- Government Polytechnic, Panaji 

Demand No.3 8 - Government Polytechnic, Bicholim 

Demand No.39 - Government Polytechnic, Curchorem 

Demand No.40 - Goa College of Engineering 

Demand No.41- Goa Architec e College 

Demand No.44 - Goa College 

F 

f Art 

Demand No.50 - Goa College 

94f Pharmacy 

The Cut Motions to Demand bos. 34 & 35 were moved by SIShri 

Opposition), Jitendra Deshprabhu and 

Day anand G. 

Twelve members took part in 

Shri Manohar Parrikar, Chief Minister replied to the debate. 

I 

The cut motions in respect of $emand Nos. 34 & 35 were put to vote 

and defeated. 1 

I 

The estimates of voted eljpenditure in respect of Demand 

~0~.34,35,36,37,38,39,40,41:4b & 50 were put to vote and granted. 

I 

V. GOVERNMENT BILL 

! 

CONSIDERATION AND PASSING 

*"4 . 

- Sbri ~ a r l . h ~ 

Madkakar, th Minister for ~ rans~oi moved that the 

2004 - The Goa Motor Vehicles Tax (henbent) Bill, 

2004 be taken into consideration. 

. .8ill$~&~~pf 

ei 

I 


and title were put to vote and adopted 

the Bill was put to vote and adopted. 

* - 

-:-%& 

..eT&z


I 

I. QUESTIONS 

(i) 7 Starred Questions were replied orally. 

(ii) 14 Starred Questions were not reached and transferred to Unstarr 

list. 

(iii) Replies to 19 Unstarred Questions were laid on the Table of the HOUI 


1. Smt. %ctoria Fefnandes made a mention about the bus owners fro 

the route passing through Ribandar-Panaji road are floating tl 

Government instructions given in the Notification No.2315tPIS-Cri 

/MAGI2004 datejd 17-2-2004 whereinit is declared that the road fro] 

Tamba House to Ribandar Patto junction as "NO STOPPING" ( 

"STANDING ZONE". 

, 2. Smt Victoria Femandes made a mention about the students whos 

either ad born in ~ obut a stayed in Union Territory of Darna 

and Diu due to delinking from Goa in 1987 after Statehood do not ge 

eligibility for seats reservedunder the below category who have studie 

for last ten years in union tory of Darnan and Diu and passed XI 

std science CBSE Board, New Delhi from schoolslcolleges located i, 

union ~enitory df ~arnan and Diu for admission for the Medical Pos 

MBBS or ~n~ideerin~ in the current academic year 2004-2005 a 

there is no ~edjcal or Engineering Colleges in Union Territory o 

Daman and Diu. 

3. Shri Luizinho FFiro made a mention about eighteen employees o 

I 

Goa Constructioh, Housing and Finance Corporation Ltd., who are 

retrenched by the! Government of Goa and presently unemployed fo~ 

2 H years wherdin the Government had given assurance that the) 

would be rehabiliated in other ~ovemment ~e~artments wherein the 

posts are being filled by depriving these 18 employees of gainful, 

employment. 1 I 

I 

I 

i 

I

-52- 

11. PRIVATE MEMBERS' RESOLUTIONS 

1. Shri Sadanand M. Shet moved the following: 

"This House strongly recommends the Government to develop the old 

road from Revora Church to Pirna border in order to avoid traffic 

congestion on the main road Pirna-Mapusa via Nadora." 


The Resolution was withdrawn by the Gave of the House 

I 

2. Shri Aleixo Sequeira moved the fdllowing: 

1 

"This House strongly recommends the Government to exempt all the 

institutions working for the bendpt of the handicapped children from 

collecting any fees and levies by y e local bodies such as Municipalities 

and Panchayats." 

I 


1 The resoldtion as amended with the following text was adopted 

unanimously. 

I 

I 

i "This House strongly recommends the Government to exempt all the 

1 institutions working for the bdpefit of the destitutes, aged persons, 

orphahages and handicapped children fromcollecting any fees and levies 

by the local bodies%such as ~unidi~alities and Panchayats." 

I 

3. ~Shri Agnelo Femandes moved d following: 

"This House strongly recommends the Government to set up a Police 

sub-station/out pst at candolimid ~alangute constituency as the existing 

I 

. ~oli=e~~~t&o$o~t post being ve far and considering the fact that the 

crime rates;;ge, increasing day b 

mo mem6~bfrfook park in the 

-

"This House strongly recommends the Government to set up a Police1 , 

station at Candolim in Calangute Constituency as the existing Police ~t , 

Stationlout post being very far and considering the fact that the crime 

rates are increasing day by day." 

4. Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu moved the following: 

"This House strongly recommends the government to construct a mini ' I 

indoor sports hall in Pernem Municipal area to cater to the needs of the 1. 

youth of Pernem." 


The resolution was/ withdrawn by the leave of the House 

I 

5. Shri Isidore Fernanbes moved the following: 

"This ~ouse urges ipon the ~overnment to declare the high incidence of 

acute kidney failure! in ~anacona ~alukas an epidemic, so as to expedite 

the matter and also1 for assistance fmm foreign agencies to pinpoint the 

root cause of this 4sease that is affectmg hundreds of people from this 

region." I I 

' Three members tobk part in the debate. 

i 

The resolution as amended with the following text was adopted 

unanimously. 

I 

I 

"'Ihis ~ouse urges ipon the Government that in view of the high incidence 

of acute kidney fa$ure in Canacona Taluka to take assistance from all 

agencies to pinpoint the root Zause of this disease that is affecting hundreds 

of people from thid region 

I 


I 

I. QUESTIONS ' 

i 

(i) Shri Manohar tanikar, the Chief Minister asked for postpbnement 

Starred Question No.6 and Unstarred Question Nos.4,14,23,25,32,33 

and 36 to next Session. 

' 

I 

.

(ii) 

1 postponed Starred Question and 4 Starred Questions were replied 

orally. 

(iii) 32 Starred Questions were not reached and transferred to Unstaned 

list. 

(iv) Replies to 42 Unstarred Questions were laid on the Table of the House. 


Shri Ramrao Desai, the Minister for Industries laid on the Table a copy 

of the Annual Report and Annual Administrative Report for the year 

2001-2002 of the Goa Industriq Development Corporation. 

Immediately after em and NO.^ 1 was moved, the pandemoniumoccuoed 

in the House. The Speaker adjburned the House at 3:40 p.m. TI& House 

I 

' 

reassembled at 355 p.m. and $he Demands were moved. 

I ' I 

. . 

, .i 

The following Demands were .. : 

Demand No .21- Public WorFs 

Demand No.45 - Archives & bchaeology 

Nos.74 & 46 were

Shri Filipe Neri Rodrigues, Minister for Water Resources and Shri 

Ramkrishna Dhavalikar, Minister for P. W.D. in charge of the Demands ,: . 3 

replied to the debate. , 

The cut motions in respect of Demand Nos. 21,46,66, & 74 were put to 1. 

vote and defeated. 

The estimates of voted expenditure in respect of Demand ' 1 

Nos.21,45,46,66,74 & 80 were put to vote and granted. 

i. 

1 

,-DAY 27 JULY, 2004 

I 


1 

(i) Shri Ramrao DCsai, the Minister for Industries asked for postponement 

of Starred Quistion No.6 for reply to the next session and made 

corrections to Starred Question Nos. 11,20 and Unstarred Questions 

No.40. \ I 

, (li) Shri DigamberlKamat, the Minister for Power asked for postponement 

of Unstamed hestions No. 18 for reply to the next session and made 

corrections to Postponed Starred Question 7. 

I 

(33) 1 postponed tarred Question and 4 Starred Questions w e 

replied I 

I 

(iv) 37 Starred destions were not reached and transferred toUnstarred 

list. 

I 

i 

(v) Replies to 52 fJmtarrexI Questions were laid on the Table of the House. 

I \ 

1. Shri ~ a~andd G. Nawekar made a mention about the flooding of 

agricultural lkd, near Podwal-Poira bridge, due to dump* of rmrd by 

the contractor 

I 

of the Jnkstmcture Development Corporation without 

acq-g lanb mmd.

I 

2. Shri Harish N. P. Zantye made a mention about the food grains (rice) 

of 4 tons and 100 kg supplied by the Civil Supplies ~e~artment to the 

Village Panchayat of Karapur-Sarvan, Bicholim Taluka, meant for 

RDA works has Not reached the beneficiaries and the said rice has 

been lifted from the Civil Supplies godown and misappropriated out 

and out. An FIR has already been lodged on 12-6-2004 in this 

connection at the BicholimPolice Station. 

3. Shri Luizinho Faleiro made a mention about the evasion of excise of 

crores of rupees by fraudulent manufacturing fake brands of liquor, 

storing duplicatelabels and caps of various brands of Indian and Foreign 

liquor as reported in The Navhind Times dated 24-7-2004. 

111. DISCUSSION AND VOTING ON DEMANDS FOR GRANTS 


I 


I 

. Demand No. 19 - Industries, Trade and Commerce 

Demand No.72 - Science, ~echnolo~~ and Environment 

Demand No.73 - State Electiin Commission 

Demand No.75 - Planning, stktistics & Evaluation 

I 

Demand No.79 - Goa ~azettker 

I 

I 

The Cut Motion to Demand $0.19 was moved by SIShri Dayanand G. 

Narvekar, Pratapsingh R. Rane (Leader of Opposition), Isidore Femandes, 

Aleixo Sequeira and Smt vidtoria Fernandes, MLAs. 

The Cut Motion to Demand No.72 was moved by S/Shri Dayanand G. 

Narvekar, Pratapsingh R. ~ &(Leader e of Opposition), Luizinho Faleiro 

and Agnelo Femandes, MLA~. 

I 

I Nine members took part id the Debate: 

. 

i 

. 

Shri Atanasio Modsenate, for Environment and Shri Ramrao 

Dessai, Minister Manohar P&ar, Chief Minister 

in charge of the Demands r#plied to the debate.

I 

The cut motions in respect of Demand Nos. 19 & 72 were put to vot ; 

and defeated. 

The estimates of voted expenditure in respect of Demand Nos. 19,72,73,7: 

& 79 were put to vote and granted. 

1 

I. QUESTIONS 


I I 

t 

i. 

(i) 2 postponed Starred Questions and 4 Starred Questions were repliec 

orally. 1 

(ii) 

30 Stamd Questions were not reached and transferred to Unstarre4 

list. 

I I 

($1 lXeplies to 25(Unstarred Questions were laid on the Table of the House.. 

I 

11. ZERO HOURi MENTIONS 

1. Shri Giovanni Karl Vaz made a mention about the workers, officers: 

. and managerslof Western Shipyard Ltd., situated at ~ omu~ao ~arbouri 

for being served termination notices to the officers and managers in 

I 1 

view of the slqw downby workers in the yard due to non-payment of 

salaries in time and arrears as per their settlement before the Assistant 

Labour cornniissioner. 

1 I 

2. Shri Dayanang G. Narvekar made a mention about the unrest in the 

ranks of Junioi Engineer (Degree holders) of Electricity Department 

for not redesi 

I 

ating Junior Engineer and Technical Assistant and 

thereby blocking 

P 

their promotion in the department names like~WD 

and other dep@ents. 

It I 

I 

I 


I 

Shri Manohar Padcar, the Chief Minister laid on the Table the following: 

1. A copy of the Audited Report of Annual Accounts of the 

EconomicDeve opment Corporation Ltd., for the year 2001-2002. 

5

-58- 

2. A copy of the Notification of the Goa Preservation of Trees 

(Amendment) Rules, 2003. 

V. DISCUSSION AND VOTING ON DEMANDS FOR GRANTS 



Demand No. 6 1 - Craftsman Training 

Demand No.78 - Tourism 

Demand No.42 - Sports 

Demand No.69 - Youth Affairs 

The Cut Motions to Demand No.78 was moved by s/s~& Agnelo 

Fernandes, Pratapsingh R. Rane (Leader of Opposition), Isidore 

Femandes and Dayanand G. ~arjkkar, MLAs. 

The Cut Motions to Demand No.42 was moved by S/Shri Day&&d 6. 

Narvekar and Jitendra Deshprabhu,MLAs. 

i 

Fifteen members took part in the Debate. 

r 

: Shri Francis D'Souza, the ~inijter for Craftsman Tralning abd Shri 

Matanhy Saldanha, the Minister fpr Tourism, Sports "& Ydd M%rs in 

charge of the Demands replied to1 the debate. 

The cut motions in respect of Demand Nos.78 & 42 were.ptb 

, 

defeated. 1 -- P 

1 

.' , * 

;tnd 

(ii) Shri Pandurang Madkaikar, the Minister for Transports mac 

corrections to Starred Question No. 5 and Unstarred Question No. ; 

(i) 3 postponed Starred Questions were replied orally. 1 

(iv) 18 Starred Questions were not reached and transferred to Unstarrc 

list. 

(v) Replies to 1 postponed Unstarred Question and 35 Unstarred Questio~ 

were laid on the Table of the House 


I 

1. Shri ~ajendra Arlekar made a mention about the issue of evictic 

notices to ihe residents and traders of Vasco, the tenants in tl 

Momugao bunicipal Council premises, even when discussion wi 

going on wip the Government-to sort out the matter. 

I 

7 

2. Smt. Victo 'la Fernandes made a mention about the use of helmets k 

the two-whgeler riders. 

I 

P 

3. Shri Ravi S. aik made a mention about the dumping of waste materii 

, . and rejects qy M/s Mohit Steel Factory, Kundaim Industrial Estate i 

the plot of Marcaim communidade in survey no.508/0 which is on th 

hillock, giv+g rise to health hazard to the habitants staying below th 

hill. 

I 

III. PRESENTA ION OF SUPPLEMENTARY DEMANDS FOI 

GRANTS F& THE YEAR 2004-2005 (FIRST BATCH). 

~hri Manohar &rr&ar, the Chief Minister presented the Supplementar 

Demands for Grants for the year 2004-2005 (First Batch). 

I 

IV. DISCUSSIOP/ AND VOTING ON DEMANDS FOR GRANT; 


TIE following Demands were moved: 

Demand No.56 

Demand No.58 

- Information & Publicity 

- Women and Child Development

Demand No.63 - Raj ya Sainik Board 

Demand No.29 - Public Grievances 

Demand No.27 - Official Language 

The Cut Motions to Demand Nos.56 & 58 were moved by SIShri 

Pratapsingh R. Rane (Lader of Opposition), Isidore Fernandes and Agnelo 

Fernandes. 

Six members took part in the Debate: 

Shri Manohar Parrikar, the Chief Minister replied to the debate. 

The cut motions in respect of Demand Nos. 56 & 58 were put to vote 

and defeated. 

1 

The estimates of voted expenditure in respect of Demand Nos.56,58,63,29 

& 27 were put to vote and granted. 

I 

V. GOVERNMENT BILL. I 

INTRODUCTION 1 

The following Bill was introduced: 

Bill No.22 of 2004 - The Goa 

(Special Rights) (Amendment) 

1 

I 


I. QUESTIONS i 

- 

I 

(i) Shri Francis D7Soura, the hinister for 

postponement of Starred ~uedtion NO. 13 dri 

and fixed to reply on 30.7.2(/04 was fu 

next Session. 

I 

(ii) Shri Manohar Parrikar, the Chjef Minister 

Unstarred Question No.6 to the next Ses 

embers of the Legislative &se@ly 

5 

> -

( i) 5 Starred Questions were replied -orally. 

( i) 14 Starred Questions were not reached and transferred to Unstarred 

list. 

(v) Replies to 6 Unstarred Questions were laid on the Table of the House. 

i 

1 


1. Shri Aleixo Sequeira made a mention about the anxiety in the minds . 

1 

of traders and businessmen from Goa due to the reports on the ,' 

introduction of the VAT system. 

2. Shri Luizinho Fdleiro made a mention about the registered and 

recognized occupational Health Physicians who are post-graduates, 

holding Diplomas @ occupation and Industrial Health and are authorized 

to issue medical f$icss. 

I 

miZD- 

3. Smt. Victoria Fe des made a mention about the illegal development 

coming up at Bambolim, Nauxirn and St. Cruz thereby blocking the 

access to the beach by the builders; also the illegal cutting of hills and 

J 

trees would resulq in a man made catastrophe. 

I 

4. .Smt.-ctoria made a mention about the anxiety in the minds 

construction of Patea Cantor 

and the closure of the sluice gates 

there is need of putting up a pipe or 

1. Shri ~handrakantl~avlekar the mover of the following resolution was 

not present in the House: 

"This House 

areas." 

upon the Government to construct a bus stand for 

of the people of Quepem and surrounding 

2. Shri Agnelo ~ernbdes moved the following: 

I 

'This House strodgly recommends the Government to ensure that the 

grounded ship "kver Princess" is removed at the earliest without 

causing any po~uhon.''

Seven members took part in the debate. 


3. Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu moved the following: 

"Whereas it is noticed that though Goa being a touristic State, it lacks 

entertainment facilities such as Golf courses, marina facilities, slot 

machines etc., therefore this House strongly recommends the 

Government to promote such facilities without discrimination to permit 

them to obtain licenses in order to attract high spending international 

tourists for which licensqs may be extended to 3 stars residential 

I 

facilities." 

I 

I 

Four members took part i/n the debate. 

I 

The resolution was w wn by the leave of the ~ouse." 

4. Shri Darnodar Naik the Aover of the following resolution was not 

present in the House: i 

courses in Ban 

and Goa Bhavan in ~dunbai, ther

MONDAY 2 AUGUST, 2004 

b 


(i) Shri Manohar Parrikar, the Chief Minister asked for postponement of 

Unstarred Questions Nos.11,17,20 & 27 to the next Session. 

(ii) 5 postponed Starred Questions were replied orally. 

1 

(5) 27 Starred Questions were not reached and transferred to Unstarred 

list. 

I 

I 

(iv) Replies to 2 postponed Unstarred Questions and 26 Unstarred 

Questions were laid on the Table of the House. 


I 

I 

1. Smt Victoria Femanhes made a mention about the shortage of water 

supply to Cacra village in St. Cruz Constituency. 

I 

4 

2. Smt Victoria Feman es made a mention about the illegal sale of liquor 

and alarming large-scale adulteration in bars and tavernas in the city. 

I 

4. Shri Francisco ~ardhha made a mention about the issue of Circular 

dated 21-7-04 that $aches will have to put 200 how of remedial 

teaching in a year inl~i~her Secondary aided Schools. 

1 

5. Shri Luizinho Faleirb made a mention again about the registered and 

recognized Occupadonal He* Physicians who are post graduates, 

I 

holding Diplomas in occupation and Industrial Health and are authorized 

to issue medical fitacss. 

I 

Shri Manohar ~arrikad~ Chief Minister moved under Rule 306 of the 

Rules of Procedure h Conduct of Business of the Goa Legislative 

Assembly for Suspen "% ion of Rule 129(2) regarding notice period of 

I

A - 

Government Bills and proviso to Rule 141 in respect of the period of 

circulation of copies of Bills listed for the day, fromtheir operation on the 

day. 

The motion was put to vote and adopted. 

IV. 

MOTION OF CONDOLENCE 

Shri Luizinho Faleiro moved the following Motion: 

"This House condoles the death of Dr. J. E Martins, a Freedom Fighter, 

Veteran Politician and a social worker of Goa and conveys its heartfelt 

sympathies to the bereaved family. 

Four members spoke on thk motion and the motion was adopted 

unanimously. ! 

V. PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE 

(1) Shri Manohar Panikar, t$e Chief Minister laid on the Table the 

following: 

(a) A copy of the Annual pport for the year 2002-2003 of the Goa 

University. 

I 

@) A copy of the Annual Administration ~ e~ort of the Government 

of Goa for the year 2013-2004. 

1 

(2) Shri Pandurang ~adkaikah the Minister for Transport laid an th 

Table a copy of the Audit/ Reports for the financial year 2000-01, 

2001-02 and 2002-03 of thk Kadamba Transport Corporation Ltd. 

(3) ShriFilipe Nery Rodrigues the Minister for Water Resources laid on 

the Table a copy of the ~ ~hted Report of the Goa Tlllari higation 

Development Corporation for the year 2000-2001. 

I 

Sbri Manohar kin&&, the 

(2004) of the usi in& Advis 

motion: 

. , :- 

d 

&ief Minister presented the Third Report 

b 

ry Committee and moved the following

"This House do agree with the Third Report (2004) of the Business 

Advisory Committee." 

The motion was put to vote and adopted. 

VII. BREACH OF PRIVILEGE 

Shri Pratapsingh R. Rane raised a Breach of Privilege and Contempt of. 

the House under Rule 76 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of 

Business of the Goa Legislative Assembly against the Editor, Publisher 

and Reporter of Daily Gomantak %mes for having published the decision 

of Business Aavisory Committee held on 29-7-2004 under the caption 

"Congressmen uppet diith Rane's move" in the Daily dated 2-8-2004, 

before presentation of the report to the House. 

VIII. DISCUSSION AND VOTING ON DEMANDS FOR GRANTS 

FOR THE YE~R 

2004-2005. 

I 

The following Deyands were moved: 

' 

Demand No.1 - ~ebislature Secretariat 

Demand No.3 - ~istrict & Session Court, North Goa 

Demand No.4 - District 

I 

& Session Court, South Goa 

Demand No.5 - ~rdsecution 

Demand No. 10 - ~ btar~ Services 

Demand No.28 - Awnistrative Tribunal 

Dehd No.62 - ~ d w 

Demand No. 82 --1nfbrmation ~echnol~~ 

I 

Charged Expendihq - Raj Bhavan ma is cuss ion only) 

Charged ~x~enditure - Debt Services (Discussion only) , 

charged ~x~enditnrel Goa Public Service Commission@iscussion only) 

I 

The Cut Motions to Demand Nos.62 ifk 82 were moved by Shri 

Pratapsingh R. Rane Leader of Opposition). 

Five members took dart in the Debate: 

Shri Manohat Parrikar, Chief Minister replied to the debate. 

1 i 

1 

I 

i 

II 

,

The cut motions in respect of Demand Nos. 62 & 82 were put to vote 

and defeated.. 

The estimates of voted expenditure in respect of Demand 

Nos. 1,3,4,5,10,28,62 & 82 were put to vote and granted. 

X. 4PPROPRIATION BILL 

1 (A) INTRODUCTION 

i' 

The following Bill was introduced: 

Bill No. 17 of 2004 - The Goa Appropriation (No.2) Bill, 2004. 


1 

Shri Manohar Parrikar, the Chief Minister moved that the Bill No. 17 of 

2004 - The Goa Appropriation (No.2) Bill, 2004 be taken into 


I 

Twelve members took part in the bebate. 

I 

I 1 

1 The motion was put to vote and adopted. 

Clauses 1 to 3, Schedule, preamble and title were put to vote and adopted. 

The moth for passing of the Bill bas put to vote and adopted: 

I 

: DISCUSSION ON THE FIRS^ BATCH OF s 

DEMANDS FOR GRANTS FOR THE 

1 Discussion on the First Batch of Suppleme 

1 for the year 2004-2005. 

!I. APPROPRIATION BILL 

(A) INTRODUCTION 

The following Bill was introduced 

Bill No. 18 of 2004~The Goa Apppri 

I 

I


Shri Manohar Parrikar, the Chief Minister moved that the Goa 

Appropriation (No.3) Bill, 2004 be takeninto consideration. 


I 

I 

Clauses 1 to 3, Schedule, preamble and title were put to vote and adopted. 


I 

XII. GOVERNMENT /BILLS 

The following Bills Lere introduced: 

I 

(1) The Contract ~zbour (Regulation and Abolition) (Goa Amendment 

Bill,2004. 

I 

(2) The Goa Sales Tp (Amendment) Bill, 2004. 

1 

'(3) ' The Goa Salary, Allowances and Pension of Members of the Legislative 

Assembly (~meddment) Bill, 2004. 

(4) The Goa Salarieq 

I 

and Allowances of the Speaker and Deputy Speaker 

(Amendment) Bq1,2004. 

(5) The Goa Salaries 

2004. 

and Allowances of the Ministers (Amendment) Bill, 

(1) Shri Manohar P Minister moved that the Bill No. 22 

of the Legislative Assembly (Special 

be taken into consideration. 

The motion for cthsideration of the Bill was put to vote and adopted. 

I 

, Clauses 1,2, prea/nble and title were put to vote and adopted. . 

The motion for pissing of the Bill was put to vote and adopted. 

I

(2) Shri Manohar Parrikar, the Chief Minister moved that the Bill No.28 

of 2004 - The Goa Sales Tax (Amendment) Bill, 2004 be taken into 


The motion for consideration of the Bill was put to vote and adopted 

Clauses 1,2,3, preamble and title were put to vote and adopted. 


(3) Shri Manohar Parrikar, the Chief Minister moved that the Bill No.25 

of 2004 - The Goa Salary, Allowances and Pension of Members of 

the Legislative Assembly (Amendment) Bill, 2004 be taken into 


The motion for consideration of the Bill was put to vote and adopted 

Clauses 1 to 27, Schedule, preamble and title were put to vote and 

adopted. 

I 


I 1 

(4) ~hri ~&ohar ~arrikar, the ~hiief Minister moved that the ill NO. 26 

of 2004 -The Goa Salaries and flowances I of the Speaker and Deputy 

Speaker (Amendment) Bill, 20b4 be taken into consideration. 

The motion for consideration o~f the Bill was put to vote and adopted 

I 

Clauses 1 to 4, preamble and title were put to vote and adopted. 


(5) Shri Manohar Parrikar, the chief ~inister 

27 

of 2004 - The Goa Salaries and Allowances of the Ministers 

(Amendment) Bill, 2004 be taken into consideration. 

The motion for consideration 01 the Bill was put to vote and adopted 

Clauses W,3 to 7, preamble $d title were pit to vote and adopted. 

moved that th& Bill ~ b . 

The motion%r passing of the ill was put to vote and adopted. 

I

XIII. NOMINATION OF MEMBERS ON THE PANEL OF 

PRESIDING MEMBERS/COMMITTEES OF THE HOUSE. 

The Speaker has nominated the following members to various panell 

Committees shown under for the term 2004-2005 with effect from the 2nd 

August, 2004. 

S1. Name of 

Committee 

Name of Members 

WSmt/Dr. 

Name of Chairman 

1. PANEL OF 

PRESIDING 

MEMBERS 

2. ESTIMATES 

COMMITTEE 

3. COMMIl-TEE ON 

GOVERNMENT 

ASSURANCES 

4. COMMITI'EE ON 

PETITIONS 

5. COMMITTEE ON 

DELEGATED 

LEGISLATION 

Rajendra Arlekar 

Jitendra Deshprabhu 

Laximikant Parsekar 

yctoria Fernandes 

I 

Vinay Tendulkar 

%ctoria Fernandes 

Uaximikant Parsekar 

hicky Pacheco 

dgnelo Fernandes 

yjay Pai Khot 

qamodar Naik 

dayanand Narvekar 

ldajesh Patnekar 

$cky Pacheco . 

Iqidore Fernandes 

qarl Vaz 

yjay Pai Khot 

Vasudev Gaonkar 

I 

~'axirnikant Parseka 

I 

Joaquim Alernao 

Narl Vaz 

Vijay Pai Khot 

TZYEEwa 

Dlamodar Naik 

Ravi Naik 

Luizinho Faleiro 

Jifendra Deshprabhu 


Dayanand Narvekar 

Laximikant Parsekar 

Ravi Naik

-70- 

S1. Name of Name of Members Name of Chairman 

Committee 

Shri/Sm5fl>r. 

Wilfred De Souza 


Harish Zantye 


6. COMMITTEE OF Deputy Speaker Deputy Speaker 

PRIVILEGES %ctoria Femandes 


Rajesh Patnekar 

%jay Pai Khot 

Aleixo Sequeira 

Chandrakant Kavlekar 

I 

7. LIBRARY Rajendr 

\ 

1 Arlekar 

COMMITTEE Vasudev Gaonkar 

Francis S ' veira 

Joaquim Alemao 

I 

8. COMMITTEE Wilfred De Souza 

I 

ON PUBLIC Aleixo S queira 

UNDERTAKINGS Subhash hirodkar 

Sadanan ; Shet 

Agnelo 

4 

emandes 


Darnodarj Naik 

I 

9. BUDGET 

COMMITTEE 

Francisco Sardinha 

VmaY ~endulkar 

%ctoria Femandes 

ama add Naik 

Agnelo qemandes 

Sadanand Shet 

Isidore ~ Lmdcs 

Rajesh datnikar 

Micky ~bcheco 

,.; Wilfred Souza 

Rajendrai Arlekar 

Vasudev gaonkar 

. - I ' . 



Francisco S ardinha

Speakerhas further appointed 3 Sub-Codttees consisting of 4 Members 

each to emne 

the Budgets of various Govt. Departments. 

S1. Nameof Name of Members Name of Chairman 

committee 

SMSmt/Dr. 

Sub-committee I 

1. Francisco S ardinha Francisco S ardinha 

2. Rajendra Arlekar 

3. Vasudev Gaonkar 

4: Victoria Fernandes 

Sub-committee I1 

1. Wilfred De Souza I Wilfred De Souza 

2. Micky Pacheco I 

3. Sadanand Shet I 

4. Agnelo Fernandes I 

Sub-committee I11 ! 

1. Damodar Naik Damodar Naik 

2. ~ma~~endulkar 

1 

3. Isidore Fernandes 1 

4. Shri Rajesh ~atne$ar 

ACCOUNTS 

COMMI'ITEE 

10. PUBLIC 

i 

I 

/ 

Luizirih~FaleirO 

Jitendra Deshprabhu 

Pratapsingh R. Rane Pratapsingh R. Rane 

Damodar Naik 


I Wilfred De Souza 

I Sadanand Shet 

11. RULES 

COMMITTEE 

1 Speaker Speaker 

1 Dy. Speaker 

/ Law Minister 

1 Pratapsingh Rane 

1 Harish Zantye 

, Chandrakant Kavlekar 

I Rajendra Arlekar 

i 

L 

I 

I

- 

S1. Name of Name of Members Name of Chairman 

Committee 

Shri/Smt/Dr. 

12. BUSINESS Speaker Speaker 

ADVISORY Dy. Speaker 

COMMITTEE Chief Minister 

Law Minister 

Leader of Opposition 


Laximilcant Parsekar 

I 

Speaker made valedictory rdmarks on the conclusion of the Second 

Session, 2004. 

1 

I 

XV. NATIONAL ANTHEM i 

National P Lnthern was sun4 recited by the Members. 

(HOUSE ADJOURNED S DIE ON 2 AUGUST, !004). 

L

Demands for Grants for the Year 2004-2005(First Batch) 

Total No. of Demands No. of Demands discussed No. of Demands Remarks 

moved 

Guilotined ' 

- - 

82 DemandNo. 1 

-- 

Legislature Secretariat 

Raj Bhavan 

(Cha-Wd) 

DemandNo. 2 

Demand No. 3 

DemandNo. 4 

Demand No. 5 

' DemandNo.6 

DemandNo. 7 

DemandNo. 8 

Demand No. 9 

DemandNo. 10 

DemandNo. 11 

DemandNo. 12 

DemandNo. 13 

General Adm. & 

, Coordination 

District & Session 

1 Cod, North Goa 

1 

/ District & Session 

Caurt, South Goa 

Prosecution 

' Electionoffice 

Settlement &land 

I Records 

I 

' Treasury & Accounts 

Adra, North Goa. 

1 Treasury & Accounts 

I Adra7 SouthGoa. 

1 Debt Services (Charged) 

Notary Services 

Excise 

1 Sales &Entertainment Tax 

Transport 

GcaPublic Service 

Commission-


moved 

Guilotined 

DemandNo. 14 

DemandNo. 15 

DemandNo. 16 

Goa Sadan 

Collectorate, North 

Goa 

Collectorate, South 

Goa 

DernandNo. 17 Police 

I 

1 

DenzandNo.18 Jails i 

DemandNo. 19 

DemandNo. 20 

Industries, T lade 

"i 

and Commerce 

r 

Printing & st ' tionery 

DemandNo. 21 Public Works 

I 

DemandNo. 22 Viglance 1 

I 

DemandNo. 23 Horn i I 

DemandNo. 24 

DemandNo. 25 

DemandNo. 26 

DemandNo. 2 

DemandNo. 28 

Goa Public Men's 

Corruption- &vestigation 

and ~n~uires 

I 

~ome ~uardi & 

civil~efenc! 

I 

FireBiEmerg ncy 

services 

I 

DernandNo. 29

Total No. of Demands Yo. of Demands discussed No. of Demands Remark 

moved 

Guilotined 

1 2 3 . 4 5 t 

1 

DemandNo. 30 Lotteries 

DemandNo. 3 1 

DernandNo. 32 

Panchayats 

Finance 

f 

DemandNo. 33 Revenue 

I 

DemandNo. 34 

I 

School Education 

DemandNo. 35 1 Higher Education 

DemandNo.36 1 Technical 

, Education 

DemandNo. 37 

DemandNo. 38 

DemandNo. 39 

DemandNo. 40 

I Government 

I Polytechnic 

/ Panaji. 

I Government 

Polytechnic, Bicholim 

I 

/ Govemment 

1 Polytechnic, Curchorem 

GoaCollege of 

Engineering 

DemandNo. 41 

DemandNo. 42 

DemandNo. 43 

Goa Architecture 

College 

DemandNo. 44 1 Goa College of 

i Art 

I 

I 

DemandNo. 45 I Archives and 

l Archaeology

Total No. of Demands . No. of Demands discussed . No. of Demands, Remarks 

moved 

Guilotined 

1 2 - 3 4 5 

DemandNo. 46 

Museum 

DemandNo. 47 

DemandNo. 48 

DemandNo. 49 

DemandNo. 50 

DemandNo. 51 

GoaMedical College 

Health Services 

Institute of Psychiatry 

&Human Behaviour 

~ ocolleg+ a of 

Pharmacy i 

GoaDental 

8 

DemandNo. 52 

DernandNo.53 

DemandNo. 54 

DemandNo. 55 

DemandNo. 56 

DemandNo. 57 

1 DemandNo. 58 

DemandNo. 59 

Demand No. 60 

Labour 

Foods & dugs 

~dmmistrTon 

Town & ctuntry 

Planning 1 

Municipal 


Information & 

Publicity 

Social Welfare 

1 

Women & Child 

Develop~ent 

I 

Factories k~oilers 

I 

~ 1 0 ~ 

DemandNo. 61

Total No. of Demands No. of Demands discussed No. of Demands R e d 

moved 

Guilotined 

1 2 3 4* 

5 

DemandNo. 63 

DemandNo. 64 

DemandNo. 65 

DemandNo.66 

DemandNo. 67 

DemandNo. 68 

RajyaSaiIllkBoard 

Agriculture 

Animal Husbandry 

&Veterinary 

Fisheries 

, 

Pdrts I Administration 

~hrests 

DemandNo. 70 

divil 

I supplies 

, DemandNo. 71 @o-operation 

I 

DemandNo. 72 

(cience, Technology & 

~nvk-onment 

DemandNo. 73 StateElectionCommission 

r DemandNo. 74 Water Resources 

I 

- 

DemandNo. 75 

DemandNo. 76 

DemandNo. 77 

DemandNo. 78 

planning, Statistics 

&Evaluation . 

Electricity 

RiverNavigation 

Tourism 

DemandNo. 79 lGc3Gazetteer 

DemandNo. 80 

1 ~ e~al ~etrology 

I 

DemandNo. 82 1 Infcrmation Technology 

DemandNo.83 

I 

I 

Mines 

I

Demands for Supplementary Grants for the Year 2004-2005 (First Batch) 

I Total No. of Demands No. of Demands discussed No. of Demands Remarks 

moved 

Guilotiued 

' 1 2 3 4 5 

I 

28 DemandNo. 1 Legislature Secretariat 

Raj Bhavan 

(Charged) 

DemandNo.2 

General Adm. & 

Coordination 

DemandNo. 5 

Prosecution 

DemandNo. 6 Election 0kce 

Dest ~erci$s (Charged) 

DemandNo. 13 Transport 1 

DemandNo. 14 

Demand No. 19 

~oa~adani 

I 

I 

Indus tries,i Trade 

andcoy 

DemandNo. 21 public walks .< 

DemandNo. 23 

DemandNo. 26 

ire & Emergency 

Services 1 

DemandNo. 31 

DemandNo. 33 

Revenue 

DernandNo. 34 

DemandNo. 35 

DemandNo. 40


moved 

Guilotined 

1 2 3 4 5 

DemandNo. 47 

GoaMedical Cosege 

DemandNo. 48 

DemandNo. 49 

Demand No. 52 

Demand No. 54 

DemandNo. 56 

DemandNo. 58 

Health Services 

Institute of Psychatry 

&Human Behaviour 

, Labour 

i 

I 

,Town and Country 

\Planning 

I 

pformation &Publicity 

, _- 

pomen &child 

Development 

I 

DemandNo. 65 

DemandNo. 68 

DemandNo. 70 

DemandNo. 77 

DemandNo. 78 


$Veterinary Services 

~prests 

I 

~lvil~u~~lies 

I 

I 

dver ~avi~ation 

\ 

I 

Tourism

i 

i 

Statistical Information of Government Bils 1 

Sr. Title of the Bill Name of Date of Clause by Date of 

No. Minister Introduction Clause Passing 

Readkog 

1 2 3 4 5 6 

, 

1 BillNo. 11 of 2004-The Minister for 16.2.2004 12.7.2004 12.7.2004 / 

Goa Cooperative Societies codperation . 

(Adra)Blll2004 I 1 

I 

1 

2 Bill No. 16 of 2004-The Chief 28.6.2004 28.6.2004 28.6.2004 

Goa Appropriation (Vote Mi$ster 

on Account) ( No. 2) 

4 

Bill, 2004. 

1 

I 

3 BillNo. 19 of 2004-The def 8.7.2004 12.7.2004 12.7.2004 

GoaBargeTax Amendment Mihster 

Bill, 2004. 1 

4 Bill No. 20 of2004-The Mibster for 199.2004 22.72004 22.7.2004 

GoaMotor Vehcle Tax Trqnsport 

I 

I (Amendment) Bill, 2004. 

i 

1 5 BillNo.21of2004-The Chef 19.7.2004 19.7.2004 19.7.2004 

GoaEntertainment Tax mster 

(Amendment) Bi11,2004. 1 

6 BillNo. 22 of2004 -The dister for 297.204 2.8.2004 2.8.2004 

Goa Members of the Lab 

..Legislative Assembly 1 I 

' (SpecialRghts) 

(Amendrnent)Bill, 2004. ' 

I 

2.8.2004 2.8.2004 2.8.2004 

I 

ster 2.8.2004 2.8.2004 2.8.2004

- 

Sr . Title of the Bill Name of Date of Clause by Date of 

No. Minister Introduction Clause Passing 

-6 

1 2 3 4 5 6 

9 Bill No. 23 of 2004 -The Minister for 2.8.2004 

Contract Labour megulation Labour 

and Abolition) (Goa 

Amendment) Bill, 2004. 

- 7 

: 

7 

a 

10 BillNo. 25 of 2004 -The Minister for 

Goa Salary, Allowances Legislative 

and Pension of Members I Affairs 

of the Legislative Assembly 

Blll,2004. 

11 BillNo. 26 of 2004-The Minister for 

Goa Salaries and Legislative 

Allowances of the Speaker Affairs 

and Deputy Speaker 

(Amenent) Bill, 2004 1 

12 Bill No. 27 of 2004 - 2.82004 2.8.2004 2.8.2~ 

Goa Salaries and 

~ilowances of Mmiste 

(Amendment) Bill,2004. 

13 2.8.2004 2.8.2004 2.8.2004 

GoaSales Tax (Amen

STATEMENTNo.8 

ANNOUNCEMENT OF ASSENT TOBELS 

: Sr. No. Title of Bill Act Number Date of Whether assented 

by the 

PresidentIGovernor 

i 

1. The Go Appropriation Bill, Act 1 of 2004 28-6-2004 Governor 

2004. 

i 2. The Goa Appropriation Act 2 of 2004 28-6-2004 Governor 

(Vote on Account) Bill, 

i m. 

i 

3. TheGoaChldren's Act 12 of 200428-6-2004 Governor 

1 

I 

I 


I 

i 4. TheGoaMedical ~ctl9 of 2004 28-6-2004 Governor 

I 

Practitionen Bill, 2004. 

I 

5. The GoaCivil Courts Act 5 of 2004 28-6-2004 Governor 


6. The Goa Labour Welfare AC~ 6 of 2004 25-6-2031 Governor 

Fund (Amendment) Bill, 1 

m. I 

7. The Goa Education AC~ 11 of 200428-6-2004 Governor 

' . (Amendment) Bill, 2004. 

8. The City of Panaji ~ c8 of t 2004 286-2004 

Corporation (Amendment) I 

Bill,2004. 

9. The Goa Public Health

STAMENT No. 9 

Nomination of Members on Panel of Presiding Members 

Sr. No. Name of the Member Date of Nomination 

1. Shn Raj endra Arlekar 02-08-2004 

2. Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu -do - 

I 

4. Smt. VictyriaFemandes -do - 

I 

* ' 

statement/ of Private Members' ~esolutions 

! 

I 

1. Number of days Illotted for the discussion 

2. Number of ~oti4es of Resolutions received 107 

Number of ~otides withdrawn by the Members 

1 

Number of Reso htions not admittedldisallowed 

Number of Reso utions balloted 

Number of Resolutions Lapsed on prorogation 

Number of Resobutions passed 

I 

Number of Res lutions defeated . 

Number of Res lutions withdrawn by leave of house 

Members absen in the House 

1 

umber of ~esdlutions admitted 

0 

3 

25 

79 

8 

Nil 

11 

6 

104

I 

STATENENTNo.11 

Calling Attention (Notices under Rule 63) 

No.of No.of Noticels No.of No. of Name Subject Date on 

Noticels disallowed Noticels Noticels of which the 

Received lapsedl Consolidat- Admitt- Member 

matter was 

withdrawn -ed -ed 

. discussed 

13 6 2 1. ShnD. G Leakage of 8-7-2004 

I Narvekar Question 

paper in the 

I 

I 

I 

I 

open 

University 

in XII 

Examination 

I 

2. Shri Luizinho Illegal fishing 15-7-2004 

1 Faleiro by selected 

few Motorized 

I

STATEMENTNO. 12 

4 

List of Papers aid on the Table 

- 

S1. No. Subject Laid by Date 

1. The GoaCo-operative Societies ~ules, -3. Minister for Forest 28.61301 

n 

2 The Ninth Annual Report of Goa State mnister for 28.6.2004 ! 

Horticultural Corporation Ltd. for the year 

2001-2002. I 

I 

Agriculture 

3. The ~ oscheme a for i-edate~elief Minister for Town 28.6.2004 

(Second Amendment) ules, 2004. & Country Planning 

F 

i 

4. The OrderNo. 714/98/STE/DIR/Part-I/1084 Wnister for Town 28.6.2004 

dated 04/02/2004 noping the dates of & Country Planning 

festive occasions in e calendar year 

(2004-2005). 

3 

 

5. ANotificatimNo. LShISCl1915Part 

, 1~1166 dated2310212d04publishing the 

Amendments made to the Governments 

Directions No.LS/MIS/C/1915/96/Part I/ 

1589 dated 31 July, 2002 published in the 

~fficial~azktte, ~erieL INo.21 dated22 

August, 2002. 

Minister for Town 28.6.2004 

& Country Planning 

6. A Minister for Town 28.6.2004 

& country Planning 

Rules, 2000 

t' 

7. The Annual Report 2 0-2001 and Action Chief Minister 29.6.2004 

Taken Report propos d to be taken Report 

of National Human Rights Commission. 

I 

, 8. A copy of the Goa (1sSue of Single Point Chief Minister 29.6.2004 

Clearances for International FilmFestival) 

ordinance, 2004 (~r+ance~o. 1 of 2004)

i 

~ 

Sr. No. Subject Laid by Date 

9. The Audit Report and Accounts from April Minister for Social 29.6.W 

l,1994toMarch31,1995(1994-95)andfrom Welfare 

April 1,1998 toMarch3 1,1999 (1998-99) 

pertaining to Goa State Commission for 

Backward Classes. 

10. The Audt Report and Accounts from April Minister for Social 29.6.2004 

1,1999 toMarch31,2000 (1999-2q00) . Welfare 


Backward Classes 

I 

11. The Audit Report and Accounts from April Minister for Social 29.6.2004 

1,2000e March3 1,2001 (2000-2+1) Welfare 


BackwardClasses. 

, I 

12. The Audit Report of the Goa 9d1 

and Minister for 30.6.204 

Village Industries Board for theyear Industries, Art & 

2001-m Culture and Social 

Welfare 

13. The 2lst annual Report of the ~ dTourism a Minister for Tourism 1.7.2004 

Development Corporation Ltd. for the 

year2002-2003 

I 

I 

14. The Goa Factories (Tenth Amendment) Minister for Health 7.7.2004 

Rules, 2004 

15. The Annual Accounts of the GCJ Forest Chief Minister 7.7.2004 

Development Corporation Ltd. fo the 

year, 2002-2003 

;I I 

16. TheNotificaionNo. lOl9191-PHd dated Minister for Health 8.7.2004 

24-1-2003, empowering Director f Food & 

Drugs Admn. Under clause (vi) df section 2 

of the Prevention of Food ~dultdration Act, 

1954 (Central Act 37 of 1954) toekerciseall 

the powers and perform the 

Food (Health) Authority 

for the entire State of 

official ~azette, ~xtraordinary~h.2 series 11, 

~0.43dated24.1.2003: . - 1 

1


17. The Order No.DFDA/PFAA-1211981533 Minister for Health 8.7.2004 1 

dated 24.1.2003 prohibiting the sale of ~Gtka 

and Pan Masala containing tobacco or not 

containing tobacco by whatever name 

called, published in the Official Gazette, 

ExtraordinaryNo.2, Series I, No.43 dated 

24.1.2003. I 

18. The OrderNo.DFDA/PFAA-1211981568 Minister for Health 8.7.2004 

dated7.4.2003 dated7- 2003,prohibiting 

4- 

the sale of articles of food, such as food 

articles tobacco andor Lxtract thereof, 

with any kind of flavo ' s including 

cardamom, menthol, 2 d/or any kind of 

sweeteners including sLgar, glycerine, ' 

glucose, andor aromadic herbs and spices 

including dry fruits, silt er leaves, saffron' 

mulethi, sabnernusa 

r 

d lime, all or any of 

"1 

, them, publishedinofficial Gazette, 

ExtraordinaryNo.2, ~&es 11, No. 1 

I 

dated 7/4/2003. 

I 

19: The NotificationNo. 1019191-WHD dated Minister for Health 8.7.2004 

29-5-2003, and~otific#on~o. 1019191-11 

IPHD (Part) dated 19/2(2004regarding 

appointment of the Of licers to be the Local 

(Health) Authority, in E harge of the Health 

Admnistration in the kal areas, published 

in~fficial~azette, ~x@dmary series II 

No.9 dated301512003 andofficial Gazette 

~xtraordinary series Il! ~0.47 dated 

24m004. 

3 1/7/2003, 

First Class, to try offcpxs under the 

Section 36-A of the Drugs & Cosmetics 

Act, 1940, within their respective 

jurisdiction, publishGin the Official Gazette 

Series IINo.21 dated211812003. 

Minister for Health 8.7.2004

Sr. No. . Subject Laid by Date. 

21. The Notification No. 13153187-I/PHD dated Minister for Health . 8.72334 

3 1/7/2001, regarding GoaNarcoticDrugs 

and Psychotropic Substances (Amendment), 

Rules 2003 publishedin the Official Gazette, 

Series I,No.18 dated3 1.7.2003 

22. The NotificationNo. 13153187-I/PHD dated Mmister for Health 8.7.2004 

27/2/2004, regarding appointments of 

Ayurvedic Physician attached to Asilo 

. .. 

Hospital, Mapusa wider the Directorate 

of Health Services, as the Licensing 

Authorityo for the purposes of part XVI 

of the Rules 152 of the Drugs & cosmetic 

2711 112003.


26. The NotificationNo.5/8/2003-Fin @&C) (38) ' Chef Minister 14.7.2004 

dated 29.3.2004, amending the TABLE in sub 

rule 2 of Rule 13 of the Goa Sales Tax Act, 

1964 (Act 4 of 1964) substituting thelimit for 

filing the returns by the registered dealer 

whose sales taxliability exceeds Rs.50001- 

andlor total turnover exceeds Rs.20 lakhs 

during previous year, published in the 

Official Gazette (Extraordinary No.2) 

Series INo.52 dated30.3.2004. 

27. The Audited Report bf 1st and 2nd Annual Chief Minister 19.7.2004 

~cmunts for tihe hey eat 2001-2002 and 

2002-2003 of the ~ ostate a ~nfrastructure 

Development CorporhtionLimited. 

28. The ~overnment ~ukrantee to the Sanjivani Chef Minister 20.7.2004 

~ahakari ~akharKar$analtd., ~a~anand 

lTS/RCS dated7.11.2003. 

1 . 

29. The Governmefit Guarantee to the Sanjivani Chief Minister 20.7.2004 

~ahakari ~akhar Karhana~td., ~a~anand 

Nagar, for availing cjsh credit facilities to 

the tune of Rs.2500.00 lakhs fromthe Goa 

~tate~o-~~erative~hk~td., Panaji, 

sanctionedunder0rd~~o.62-94-2002 

/rS/RCSdated31.12.2003. 

I 

30. TheOfficeOrderNo.62-94-2002~S/RCS Chief Minister 20.7.2004 

dated 4.6.2004, revoking of Government 

Guarantee of Rs.2500.00lakhs provided to 

the Sanjivani Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana 

Ltd., Dayanand Nagar vide Order 

No.62-94-2002/TS/RCS dated3 1.12.2003 

for obtaining cash credit facilities from the 

Goa State Co-operative BankLtd., Panaji 

withimmediateeffect.1

I Sr. No. Subiect Laid by Date 

I 

31. The statement of Guarantee given by the Chief Minister 22.7.2004 

Government for the loan etc., raised by 

Statutory Corporations, Local Bodes and 

other financial institutions . 

32. The 23rd Annual Report, Profit and Loss Minister for 22.7.2004 

Accounts & balance Sheets along with the Industries 

Audit Report for theYear2002-2003 of the 

GoaHandcrafts Rural and Small Scale 

Industries Development Corporati Ltd. 

I 

I 33. The Annual Report and Annual 1 Minister for 26.7.2004 

Administrative Report for the year/ Industries 

2001-2002 of theGoa, Daman andDiu 

~ndustrial ~evelo~ment corporati&, ~anaji. 

I 

34. The Audted Report of Annual ALounts Chef Muuster 28.7.2004 

of the Econornic Development ~o)-poration 

Ltd., fortheye&2001-2002. 1 

! 

Chief Minister 28.7.2~04 

2003 in the Official 

No. 5) Series INo. 15 dated 

36. The Annual Report for they 

of the Goa University. 

al Administratio

STATEMENT No. 13 

Statistical information of Starred Question of Second Session, 2004 

' 

Airport 4 - 2 1 - 1 1 - 

Agriculture 30 1 2 3 - 3 2 1 

AnimalHusbandry $7 1 - 7 - 19 1 18 

Arckves 17 - - - - 7 - 7 

Art & Culture 1 4 1 5 - - 8 - 8 

Administrative 13 - - - - 3 1 2 

Reforms 

I 

Captain of ports 

l5 

1 - 1 - 3 - 3 

Civil supplies 1 4 2 1 2 - 9 2 7 

Co-operation 4 - - - 8 3 5 

Craftsmantraining k2 - 2 - - 10 2 8 

I 

Education 66 13 9 2 - 41 - 40 

I 

1 1 

Environment I p 1 1 - - 7 - 7 - 1 

Election 4 4 - - - 

Finance 75 15 6 10 1 41 4 35 2 2 

Fisheries 7 1 - - - 6 1 5 

Factories &Boiler 4 - - 1 - 3 - 3 

Forest 28 1 - 1 4 - 21 11 10 - 1 

General 1 8 3 2 1 - 1 2 1 8 3 - 


Health 3 14 9 - 53 13 39 1 - 

Home 9 1 2 1 0 3 34 4 3 0 

I 

Housing 1fl - , I - - 8 1 7 - 1 

Industries 2 2 3 - 21 2 1 8 1 - 

InformationPub. 2 4 9 - 7 3 4 

InformationTech. 1 - 2 - - 12 - 1 2

z 1 

a 

-2 3 

4 % 0 

8 a g CI ol 

Departments a 4 

2 

2 

s s g 

& . a 6 

" j d s 

'u 

- 1 - 

/ 

LabourBrEmployment 14 2 4 1 - 6 1 5 - 1 

Legal Metrology 3 - 1 - - 2 - 2 

law &Judlciary 7 1 - 6 1 4 1 - 

I 

Non conventional 3 - - ~ - 3 - 3 

Ener 

Mines 1 2 3 1 2 - 6 - 6 

Panchayatl Raj 5 9 7 5 6 3 7 7 3 - 4 

Personnel 24 2 3 4 - 15 1 1 1 3 - 

Public Grivences 1 - - - - 1 - 1 

Power 131 9 23 2 - XI 13 76 1 1 

Provedon a 5 1 1 - - 3 - 3 

Puhlic Works 141 5 21 8 - 103 19 84 

I . 

Revenue 61 7 101.3 - 40 7 33 

River Na\rigation 8 - - 1 2 1 5 1 4 

Ru~ilDcvelopient 19 3 4 1 L - 11 - 11 

cience amcl Techno 1 - - - - 1 - 1 

23 4 . 1 3 - 15 2 1 3 

15 3 2 : - 1 22 2 20 

5 3 7 2 3 - 3 9 3 3 6 

13 3 10 

24 2 4


Statistical information of Unstarred Question of Second Session, 2004 

a 

3 

> a - 

.M 

Departments 

0 

- 

3 

Aqort 

Agriculture 


Adm. Reforms 

Archives 

Art & Culture 

Captain of ports 

Civil supplies 

Co-operation 

Craftsman training ' 

Education 

Election 

Environment 

Finance 

Fisheries 

Factories &Boilers 

Forest 

General 


Health 31 3 1 4 3 - 3 9 - 3 7 2 - 

Home 31 8 10 3 - 30 1 2 7 2 - 

Housing 3 - 1 - - 4 - 4 - - 

Industries 1 4 2 2 1 - 1 2 - 1 2 - 1 

Information Pub. 13 4 1 - 13 - 13 - 2 

Information Tech. 3 11 2 - - 4 - 4 - -

a 

'Q 

$ 'Q 

Q * 

.A g a * * a 

0 

5 3 . g $ e I 8 

g e , $ 

S P G , 

Departments ' 8 a % 3 

g 

a g g 

s . z g g g $ 8 

o , a u u S z 

Labour 6 1 4 - - 9 - 9 - - 

Legal Metrology - 1 - - 1 - 1 - - 

law 1 - - 1 - - - - - 

Mines 6 1 1 - - 6 - 6 - - 

Non conventional Ener 1 - - - - 1 - 1 - - 

Official Language Cell 1 - -I - - 1 - 1 - - 

Panchayati Raj 3 2 4 5 ! - - 31 - 31 - 2 

Personnel 28 6 3 1 5 - 2 0 - 15 5 - 

Power 44 4 P/ 1 - 67 3 64 - 1 

1 

Protocol 2 - _I - - 2 - 2 - - 

1 

Provedoria 4 1 1 / - - 4 - 4 - - 

Pnnting & St& 1 - -I - - 1 - 1 - - 

Public Works 36 2 211 1 - 52 - 51 1 2 

Revenue 3 1 0 1 1 - 2 0 - a 0 - 1 

-I - 

River Navigation 2 - - 2 - 2 - - 

RuralDevelopment 4 - 4 - - 8 - 8 - - 

Science and Techno 1 - - - - 1 - 1 - - 

Social Welfare 17 4 1 2 - 11 - 11 - 1 

Sports 1 3 - 2 - - 1 5 - 1 5 - - 

Tourism 1 4 3 2 1 - 1 2 - 1 2 - - 

Town andcountry pla 7 - 4 - - 7 - 7 - - 

2 3 2 4 1 2 4 1 2 3 - - 

1 1 4 1 - 2 4 - 2 3 1 - 

- 1 1 - 3 2 1 - - 

- 16 - 16 - - 

a


PRESENTATION OF REPORT 

S1. No. Name of the Report Date of Presented by 

Presantation 

1. Second Report (2004) of the 28-6-2004 ShriFrancis D'Souza 

Business Advisory 

Wnister for Legislative 

Committee. 

Affairs. 

2 Fifty Eighth, Fif y Nine and 29-6-2004 Shri Pratapsingh Rane 

Sixtieth report of the Public 

Chairman of the 

Accounts Committee. 

Committee onpublic 

Accounts. 

3. ThirdReport (2004) of the 2-8-2004 Shn Manohar Parrikar 

Business Advisory/ 

Chief Minister 

CoAmmittee. 

I

-96- 

STATEMENTNO. 16 

Adjournment Motion (Under Rule 68) 

, No.of No.of 

-- 

No.of Subject Name of Member Date on 

Notices Notices Notices which 

received disallowed1 admitted 

matter is 

/withdrawn 

discussed 

4 3 1 1. For suspension of ShriLuizmhoFaleiro, Disallowed 

of Question Hour and Jitendra 

for discussion on Deshprabhu 

serious charges 

and abuse and 

misuse of the 

highest constitu- 

-tional office in 

the State of Goa. 

I 

2. For ension ion of SlShriLuizinho Disallowed 

the Question Hour Faleiro, 

and thL other Jitendra Deshprabhu, 

Business of the Harish N. P. Zantye, 

Francisco Sardinha 

and Smt. Victoria 

Femandes . 

3. For suspension of SIShri. Joaquim - 

the hes st ion Hour Alemao, 

and other other 

~usiness of the 

~ouse for 

&scu(sion on 

the a

No. of No.of No. of Subject Nqne of Member Date on 

Notices Notices Notices which 

received disallowed! admitted 

matter is 

/withdrawn 

discussed 

I 

I 

I 

and vandalism by 

the B JP Government 

represented by 

Cabinet Ministers, 

M.L.A. etc 

committedat 

Mapusa. 

4. For suspension of ShriP. R. Rane, 

I Question Hour waderof 

1 for discussion on Opposition). 

I the involvement 

I of and in terrorizing 

people in Mapusa 

by attacking with 

amob. 

I 

Disolowed

-98- 


ZERO HOUR MENTIONS 

2nd Session 2004 

Sr. No. Date Name of the Member Subject 

1. 29-06-2004 Shn Isidore Fernandes The Arabian Sea wbch has started 

eroding into the mainland, thereby 

causing considerable damage to 

plant and property in Poinguinim 

I 

Constituency. 

2. 30-06-2004 Vaz M~sus of themultipurposeHal1 built 

by the Government in Mormugao 

Constituency. 

3. 01-07-2004 Shri Jitendra Deshprabhu The inferior and non-consumable 

grains distributed to People below 

poverty line by various fair pnce 

shops in Pernem Constituency and 

. . 

other parts of Goa. 

4. 01-07-2004 The increase of fatal accidental 

deaths on roads in the State of Goa 

due to cattle menace. 

5. 02-07-2004 Shn Dayanand arvekar The collapsing of hillock at Bogda, 

Socorro thus threatening thelives of 

the people. 

6. 12-07-2004' Shri Harish N. P. Zantye The news item whch appeared in 

Tarun Bharat on 2-7-2004 regarding 

death of lateShri Disambar Krishna 

Govekar. . 

Day anand Narvekar The unscientific manner in which 

the hillock in Pworimis being cut. 

, 

I 

8. 13-07-2004 S 1 

-


9. 14-07-2004 Shri JoaquimAlemao The motorized canoed have \ 

breached the banned period of. 

fishing as specified by the 

Government. 

The mining rejects dumped in the 

forest area is carried.by rivulets to 

the paddy fields, causing huge 

losses. 

Shri Darnodar Naik 

The, order of High Court about a 

ban on t he selling of idols of 

Ganapati made out of plaster of 

paris. 

Hepatitis-E due to consumption of 

water supplied by the private l 

tankers, from well water, whch is 

not propertly checked by the 

Health Department in Panaji and 

4 

surrounding areas. 

S LuizinhoFaleiroand 

.. 

1 

The issue of fresh notices by the 

S Giovanni Karl Vaz Mormugao Municipal Council to the 

residents of Baina, Vasco to more 

than 200 people for vacating within 

10 days of the receipt of the notices 

as reported on all the papers during 

the monsoon season thereby putting 

I 

the people into hardships and 

difficulties. 

14. 19-07-2004 ~hri Agnelo Fernandes Running of illegal bars and taverns 

1 by foreigners in Candolim and 

Calangute. 

15. 2047-2004 ~4 ~a~anand ~arvekar Erection of electric poles at various 

I 

places by Power Grid Corporation1 

I 

I 

/Department. 

I 

I

Sr. No. Date Name of the Member . Subject 

16. 20-07-2004 Shn Rajesh Patnekar The2.severe leakage of chemical, 

which took place in Bicholimon 29 

June, 2004 at Industrial Estate 

Bicholim, belonging to MIS Venus 

Grand Organic factory. 

17. 2047-2004 Shn Agnelo Fernandes The increase in drowning deaths of 

tourist in the coastal belt, thereby 

I giving a bad name to the State of 

I Goa 

1 

18. 21-07-2004 Shn Sadanand Shet The narrow road at Tivim, from 

I playground to Tivim Chapel which 

has become an accident prone zone. 

19. 21-07-2004 Shri Francisco Sardinha 

I 

St. Jose Areal road which has 

completely deteriorated, as all the 

I vehicles going from Sanvordem, 

I 

Quepemand Sanguemaregoing via 

St. Jose Areal road. 

I 

- , 

XI. Z-07-204 Shri Harish N. P. dantye The private to& operators are not 

I 

visiting Mayem Lake, Mulgao 

(Vanadevi Temple), Sanquelim 

i 

(Dattatraya Temple), Harvalem 

waterfalls andNarve (Saptkoteshwar 

I 

Temple) which are declared as 

touristic spots by the Government 

1 

~ 

of Goa. 

21. 22-07-2004 

I 

ShnLuizmhoFaleiro Acquisition of fertile land by the 

Government at Margao andQuepem 

by the State Urban Development 

Agency located at adjacent to the 

NH 17 at th& entrance tothe city of 

Margao for the purpose of setting


22. 22-07-2004 Sbri Luizinho Faleiro Students community and specially 

the residents of Made1 who have 

been spearheading an agitation 

against the sound, air and water 

pollution created by certain 

misceants in the area thereby 

creatinghealthhazard and the threat 

of epidemics due to open pits which 

are filled withsewerage waste posing 

a serious threat to human life. 

23. 22-07-2004 Shn LuizirboFaleiro Theplight and suffering ofthe Truck 

I 

I 

owners due to policeharassment for 

not allowing them to take their 

unloaded trucks to their residential 

places. 

24. 23-07-2004 Srnt.VictoriaFemandes The bus owners frcm the route 

passing through Ribandar-Panaji 

road are flouting the Government 

instruction given 111 the Notification - 

No. 2315JPI.S-CT/MAG/2004dated 

17-2-2004 wherein it is declared that 

the road from Tanlba House to 

Ribandrv Patto junction as "NO 

STOPPING" OR "STANDING 

1 ZONE". 

25. 23-07-2004 Smt. ~ictorik~em;u1des The students whose either parents 

are born in Goa but stayed in Union 

Territory of Driniatn rmd Diu due to 

de-linking tiom Goa in 1987 after 

I 

I 

I 

I 

I 

Statehood do not gel ellgihility for 

seats reserved unclrr the below 

czkgory who lime sti~ci~ed for last 

Lcli years in Ullloli Territory of 

Damnn mld Dlu :uld passed XI! std 

-aerier CBSEBoard, NewDelhi kern 

scf~ools/colleges located In union 

Territory of Dmrm and Diu for 

admission for the Medical Post 

MBBS or Engineering in the current 

acridemic yeat-2004-2005 as there is 

noMedical or Engineering Colleges 

in Union Temtory of Darnan and 

Diu.

I 

8. No. Date Name of the Member Subject 

4 

Shrl Lulzl~lhoFaleirc> 

I 

1 

Eighteen employees of Goa 

construction, Housing and Finance 

Corporation Ltd., who areretrenched 

hy the Government of Goa and 

presently unemployed for 2"2 years 

\vl~ereln the Government had given 

assur:lnce that they would be 

rehab11 ltated in other Government 

Dep:irtmen ts wherein the posts are 

helng I'illed by depriving these 18 

enipioyees of gainful employment. 

27. 27-07-2CQl Shn ~:i~:::icu~d Nnmekar The flooding of agricultural land, 

I 

nex Podwd-Poira bridge, due to 

I 

dunlping of mud by the contractor of 

the Infrastructure Development 

i 

I 

Coqmrahon without acquiring land 

around. 

~ 

~ 

28. 27-07-%04 Shri llmsii N. P. Zoil,ye The food gains (rice) of 4 tons aid 

1 

100 kgs supplied by the Civil 

Sai;plies Department to the Village 

! 13snch.~y;~t of Karapur-Sarvm,, 

1 

3 ichol :I ,I T:iluka, meant for RDAI 

\~crrk~ has not reached- 

I 

beilzftcixies and the said rick* 

been lilted from the Civil &@&$ 

godown and misappropriated &t 

an out. An FIRhas mbeea 

lodged on 12-6-2004 in this 

connection at the Richolim Police 

I 

Station. 

I 

1 

29. 27-07-u)04 

3 

Sl d LuizmnhoFdeiro 

i 

The evusioli of excise of crores of 

n~pres by li:iudulent manufacturing 

i':~ke brands of liquor, storing 

~lui3lic-rite labels andcaps of various 

hr ,.~d.s of Indian andForeignliquor 

.is rrportrd in The Navhind Times 

r 

drited24-72004. 

I 

I 

-

Sr.No. Date Name of the Member Subject 

30. 28-07-2004 Giovanni Karl Vaz The workers, officers andmanagers 

of Western Shipyard Ltd., situated 

at Margao Harbour for being served 

termination notices to the officers 

and managers in view of the slow 

down by w&rs in the yard due to 

non-payment of salaries in time and 

I 

arrears as per their settlement before 

I 

the AssistantLabour Commissioner. 

31. 28-07-2004 ShriDayanaqdNarvekar The unrest in the ranks of Junior 

I 

Engineer (Degree holders) of 

Electricity Department for nor redesignating 

Junior Engineer and 

Technical Assistant and thereby 

blocking their promotional names 

I 

like PWD and other departments. 

32. 29-07-2004 ShriRajen&{Arlekar The issue of evictim notices to the 

residents and traders of Vasco, the 

tenants in theMormugao Municipal 

Council premises, even when 

discussion was going on with the 

Government to sort out the matter. 

33. 29-07-2004 Smt.VictoriaFemrindes The use of helmets by the two- 

I 

I wheeler riders. 

34. 29-07-2004 Shri Ravi S. ~kik 

I 

The dumping of wastematerid and 

rejects by MIS Moht Steel Factory, 

KundaimIndustrial Estatein the plot 

of Marcaimcommunidade in Survey 

No. 50810 which is no the hillock, 

givingrise to health to thehabitants 

staying below the hill. 

35. 3007-2004 Shri Aleixo Squeira The anxiety in Qe minds of traders 

1 and businessma from Goa due to 

the reports on the introduction of 

I 

tfae VAT system. 

I

I 


Giovanni Karl Vaz 

I 

The workers, officers andmanagers 

of Western Shipyard Ltd., situated 

at Margao Harbour forbeing served 

termination notices to the officers 

and managers in view of the slow 

down by work%rs in the yard due to 

non-payment of salaries in time and 

arrears as per their settlementbefore 

the Assjstant Labour Commissioner. 

~hri~a~an&d~arvekar The unrest in the ranks of Junior 

Engineer (Degree holders) of 

, Electricity Department for nor re- 

designating Junior Engineer and 

I 

Technical Assistant and thereby 

1 

blocking their promotional names 

i 

like PWD and other departments. 

~hri~a~endrk~rleka The issue of evictim notices to the 

residents and traders of Vasco, the 

tenants in theMormugao Municipal 

I 

I 

I 

I 

Council premises, even when 

discussion was going on with the 

Government to sort out the matter. 

Smt.~ictoribernahdes 'me use of helmets by the twowheeler 

riders. 

I 

ShriRavi S. kaik The dumping of wastematerid and 

rejects by MIS Mobit Steel Factory, 

I 

KundaimIndustrial Estatein theplot 

of Marcaimcomrnunidadein Survey 

No. 50810 which is no the h~llock, 

givingrise tohealth to thehabitants 

staying below the hill. 

Shri Aleixosequeira The anxiety in t& minds of traders 

and business~llen from Goa due to 

the reports on the introduction of 

the VAT system. 

I


- - 

Shri LuizmhoFaleiro 

Smt. VictoriaFernandes 

The registered and recognized 

OccupationalHealthPhysicians who 

are post-graduates, holding 

Diplomas in occupation and 

Industrial Health and are authorized 

to issue medical fitness. 

The illegal development coming up 

at Bambolim, Nauxim and Si. Cruz 

thereby blocking the access to the 

beachby thebuilders; also theillegal 

cutting of hills andtrees wouldresult 

in a man made catastrophe. 

~mt.,~ictoria~emandes The anxiety in t he minds of farmers 

and saltpan owners due to the 

1 construction of Patea Cantor Bundh 

I near Four Pillars, St. Cruz and the 

closure of the sluice gates thus 

affecting theflow of water as thereis 

i need of putting up apipe or a sluice 

gate to regulate the water flow. 

Smt.VictoriaFemandes The shortage of water supply 

to Cacra Village in St. Cruz 

1 constituency. 

40. 02-08-2004 ~mt. ~ictoriabernandes Theillegal saleof liquor andalarming 

large-scale adulteration inbars md 

taverns in the city. 

41. @2&3-2004 ShtlFrancisc Sardinha Theissueofcirculardated21-1-2004 

that teachers will have to put 200 

hours of remedial teaching in a year 

in hgher Secondary aided Schools. 

42. 02-0&~' ~bri~uizinhofialeiro 

, 

The registered and recognized 

Occupational healthPhysidans who 

are post-graduates, holding 

.I* 

Diplomas in occupation. and 

. . 1 Industrial Health and areauthorized 

. ". 

' I to issue medcal fitness. -' - - " - - 

I

A BRIEF REPORT - Goa Legislative Assembly

Create successful ePaper yourself

Delete template?

Save as template?