29.04.2015 Views

02020311 - Cafet Innova

02020311 - Cafet Innova

02020311 - Cafet Innova

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

International Journal of Earth Sciences and Engineering<br />

ISSN 0974-5904, Vol. 02, No. 03, July 2009, pp. 264-271<br />

264<br />

The passive environment control system of Kerala<br />

vernacular residential architecture:<br />

An experimental investigation on wind flow and<br />

thermal comfort<br />

DILI A. S.*, NASEER M. A. ** and ZACHARIA VARGHESE T. *<br />

* Department of Civil Engineering, National Institute of Technology Calicut, Kerala, India<br />

** Department of Architecture, National Institute of Technology Calicut, Kerala, India<br />

Email: dili@nitc.ac.in, naseer@nitc.ac.in, zacharia@nitc.ac.in<br />

Abstract: A building envelope is not only designed to house its occupants for various<br />

functional requirements but also for a comfortable indoor environment that is essential<br />

to perform various activities efficiently. The vernacular architecture at any place is<br />

evolved through ages by consistent and continuous effort for more efficient and perfect<br />

solutions. The vernacular architecture of Kerala is known for its use of natural and<br />

passive methods for a comfortable indoor environment. The orientation of building,<br />

internal arrangement of spaces, the presence of internal court-yard, use of locally<br />

available materials and special methods of construction etc. have together created the<br />

indoor environment. The authors have conducted a detailed investigation of the passive<br />

environment control system of vernacular architecture of Kerala by continuously<br />

monitoring the indoor comfort conditions in residential buildings of more than 250 years<br />

old. This investigation proves that the passive environment control system of Kerala<br />

vernacular architecture is very effective.<br />

Key words: Kerala, passive environment control system, vernacular architecture, wind<br />

velocity, thermal comfort<br />

Introduction<br />

One of the basic functions of a building is<br />

to provide its occupants, not only safety<br />

and shelter, but also protection from<br />

adverse natural elements like sun, rain<br />

and wind. In order to ensure that the<br />

occupants are comfortable physiologically<br />

and psychologically, it is important that<br />

the indoors are kept at optimum comfort<br />

conditions. The climatic elements –solar<br />

radiation, air temperature, relative<br />

humidity and air movement – play a vital<br />

role in conditioning the indoor<br />

environment.<br />

Climate of a region has a direct influence<br />

on the settlement pattern and in its built<br />

form. Any good building should relate and<br />

respond to the climate it is situated in. A<br />

built form is designed for the beneficial<br />

aspect of the climate and to reduce the<br />

impact of unfavorable conditions. The<br />

layout, orientation and scale of buildings<br />

and settlements should therefore be<br />

controlled in relation to the climatic zones<br />

(Krishnan A., et. al., 2001). The influence<br />

of climate in the evolution of vernacular<br />

architecture is evident from various forms<br />

that exist in many parts of the globe.<br />

Kerala has a characteristic Warm-Humid<br />

climate because of its geographic settings.<br />

The presence of high amount of moisture<br />

in the atmosphere for major part of the<br />

year causes thermal discomfort as there is<br />

less evaporation, resulting in sweating.<br />

This becomes more acute in summer when<br />

the air temperature is higher than the<br />

body temperature. Prolonged exposure to<br />

thermal discomfort conditions can create<br />

adverse effects including extensive loss of<br />

efficiency in work along with physical<br />

strain (Lekha S Hegde and K S<br />

Ananthakrishna, 2008).<br />

The principles of vernacular architecture of<br />

Kerala are based on empirical observations<br />

and experimental wisdoms acquired<br />

through generations (A. Achyuthan and<br />

Balagopal T S Prabhu, 1998). The strength<br />

of vernacular architecture is that it makes<br />

#<strong>02020311</strong> Copyright © 2009 CAFET-INNOVA TECHNICAL SOCIETY. All rights reserved.


265<br />

The passive environment control system of Kerala vernacular<br />

residential architecture: An experimental investigation on<br />

wind flow and thermal comfort<br />

buildings that are in natural harmony with<br />

climate, built form and people. The use of<br />

natural and passive methods in the<br />

vernacular Kerala architecture is found to<br />

be highly effective in providing thermal<br />

comfort – cool indoor climate during<br />

summer and warmth in winter.<br />

The modern practice in architecture lacks<br />

conscious effort in using passive methods<br />

of controlling the indoor environment<br />

(Sunil Edward and Dona Kurian, 2008).<br />

Excessive use of modern materials<br />

irrespective of their efficiency in regulating<br />

the indoor environment has often resulted<br />

in high energy consumption, leading to<br />

many environmental problems. There is a<br />

close connection between energy use in<br />

buildings and the resulted environmental<br />

damage. This is because of energy<br />

intensive solutions that are required in<br />

buildings to attain comfort conditions in<br />

terms of cooling, ventilation and lighting.<br />

This has caused severe depletion of nonrenewable<br />

energy resources and<br />

environmental degradation.<br />

Investigations on natural and passive<br />

methods of ventilation in buildings are<br />

underway in the form of continuous<br />

evaluation of thermal comfort parameters<br />

of traditional buildings, in various countries<br />

(Kyung-Hoi Lee et. al., 1996, Lin Borong,<br />

et. al., 2004, Do-Kyoung Kim, 2005.<br />

Youngryel Ryu et. al., 2008). Although<br />

there have been attempts for qualitative<br />

analysis of the traditional buildings of<br />

Kerala, a comprehensive and quantitative<br />

study of the efficiency of these buildings is<br />

so far absent. No detailed investigations in<br />

this area have been published, especially<br />

in the form of technical papers in referred<br />

journals so far. Thus, there is a need for a<br />

quantitative analysis of the passive design<br />

of traditional residential buildings of Kerala<br />

using a real-time evaluation method. This<br />

would help the present day architects and<br />

engineers to adopt suitable techniques to<br />

make their design energy efficient and<br />

sustainable.<br />

Climate of Kerala<br />

According to Bureau of Indian Standards,<br />

India has been divided into five different<br />

regions with distinct climates in which<br />

Kerala comes under the warm – humid<br />

region. The climate of Kerala is<br />

characterized by heavy rainfall and high<br />

relative humidity, and relatively moderate<br />

temperature. In effect, Kerala has only two<br />

predominant seasons- rainy and dry<br />

seasons. The rainy season lasts for about<br />

half of the year, which has greatly<br />

determined the character of built form with<br />

its characteristic sloping roof. Summer<br />

comes under the dry season with hot and<br />

humid days and nights and intense solar<br />

radiation during the day time.<br />

Wind speed and direction is determined by<br />

the season and the temperature<br />

differences between land and sea.<br />

Predominant wind direction during<br />

monsoon period, i.e., June to September is<br />

west to South west and the effect of land<br />

breeze is not dominant during this period.<br />

During October – November, wind<br />

direction changes from South - West to<br />

North - East. Though predominantly south<br />

west, the wind is influenced by the<br />

presence of other topographical features<br />

including the presence of large water<br />

bodies.<br />

Vernacular Architecture of Kerala<br />

Kerala vernacular buildings are built<br />

according to the principles of<br />

Vaastushastra, the Indian discipline on<br />

architecture (A. Achyuthan and Balagopal<br />

T S Prabhu, 1998). The basic house<br />

module of a vernacular Kerala house is<br />

nalukettu with four blocks built around an<br />

open courtyard. The blocks are topped<br />

with a sloping roof on four sides. They are<br />

generally rectangular or square in plan and<br />

the courtyard is open to sky for letting air<br />

and light inside.<br />

The enclosed courtyard is usually sunken<br />

such that cooler air settles down. The eves<br />

of the roof of the main blocks extends<br />

beyond the outer walls, covering another<br />

verandah at the front of the building (Fig<br />

1).<br />

The roofs have high pitch up to 45 degrees<br />

to help the rain water drainage easier. The<br />

gables (mughappu) provided at the ends<br />

of roof helps to enhance ventilation and to<br />

allow the warm air to escape. Further,<br />

International Journal of Earth Sciences and Engineering<br />

ISSN 0974-5904, Vol. 02, No. 03, July 2009, pp. 264-271


DILI A. S, NASEER M. A, and ZACHARIA VARGHESE. T<br />

266<br />

ventilators are provided for attic<br />

ventilation when wooden false ceiling is<br />

incorporated for the room spaces. The<br />

roofs thus enclose a large insulated air<br />

space thus, keeping the lower areas<br />

cooler.<br />

and used as building blocks. Laterite<br />

blocks are mainly bonded in lime mortar,<br />

the classic binding material, in traditional<br />

buildings. It is strong and durable with<br />

exposure to atmospheric air.<br />

Wood is the major building material, used<br />

for construction, in Kerala. The skilful<br />

selection of wood, perfect joinery, artful<br />

assembly and subtle carving for columns,<br />

walls and roof frames are the unique<br />

characteristics of Kerala residential<br />

architecture. Mud is also used in many<br />

forms in traditional buildings which include<br />

mud walling, bricks, clay tiles (both roofing<br />

and flooring), mud mortar for laterite<br />

masonry and as filler for timber floors.<br />

Passive Environment Control System<br />

Fig. 1: Plan and Longitudinal Section of a<br />

typical vernacular Kerala house with two<br />

courtyards of different sizes<br />

A typical Kerala traditional house consists<br />

of two major living areas - inner one<br />

forming the core of the house and the<br />

outer verandahs forming the periphery.<br />

The house form offer flexibility and it helps<br />

the inhabitants to shift their activities from<br />

one place to another in different climatic<br />

conditions. An important aspect of the<br />

Kerala traditional architecture is the usage<br />

of courtyards. In dry season the inner<br />

courtyards are used for drying, cleaning<br />

and preparing cereals, food etc (D. Vyas,<br />

2005). The courtyard also functions as a<br />

major functional element in the house with<br />

most of the internal movement and<br />

circulation of people defined by the<br />

verandahs around the courtyard, as the<br />

major rooms are entered from this<br />

verandah.<br />

The commonly used building materials for<br />

vernacular construction in Kerala are mud,<br />

laterite, granite stone, lime mortar, wood,<br />

bamboo, clay tile roofing and coconut palm<br />

leaves. Laterite, seen in shallow depth, is<br />

the building material available in plenty in<br />

Kerala, which can be easily cut, dressed<br />

The traditional houses of Kerala are<br />

designed for the major problems faced due<br />

to excess<br />

of moisture in<br />

the atmosphere, heavy rainfall, intense<br />

solar radiation and effect of high<br />

temperature. Kerala vernacular buildings,<br />

square or rectangle in plan, are oriented<br />

strictly to the cardinal directions. This<br />

makes the spatial planning more perfect to<br />

control its environment with maximum<br />

comfort in all distinct seasons.<br />

The courtyard is commonly referred to as<br />

microclimate modifiers. They enjoy better<br />

microclimatic conditions than the<br />

surrounding open areas; have a positive<br />

effect on the indoor comfort conditions of<br />

the enclosing building volume (Krishnan<br />

A., et. al., 2001).<br />

Buildings usually have large number of<br />

openings, windows and ventilators.<br />

Provision of open or semi enclosed spaces<br />

also give comfort condition to the interiors.<br />

The buildings have verandahs located<br />

either on its two sides or on all four sides.<br />

Another remarkable feature in the Kerala<br />

vernacular architecture is the provision of<br />

open gables (mughappu) in the roof and<br />

the provision of wooden jalli (azhi) in the<br />

external walls at appropriate positions. The<br />

open gables (mughappu) seen mostly in<br />

southern part of Kerala, provides an<br />

opening in the roof for internal hot air to<br />

escape where false ceiling is not provided.<br />

The wooden jalli (azhi) in the external<br />

walls in appropriate positions helps to<br />

International Journal of Earth Sciences and Engineering<br />

ISSN 0974-5904, Vol. 02, No. 03, July 2009, pp. 264-271


267<br />

The passive environment control system of Kerala vernacular<br />

residential architecture: An experimental investigation on<br />

wind flow and thermal comfort<br />

draw external air with the effect of<br />

courtyards.<br />

The thermal insulation in buildings is<br />

achieved by the effective use of materials<br />

and the construction techniques used in<br />

building walls and roof. The external walls<br />

of vernacular buildings are usually very<br />

thick up to a maximum of 750 mm with<br />

double layer of laterite masonry with a gap<br />

in between that is filled with fine sand.<br />

This makes the external wall highly<br />

insulative. The roofs are sloping and in<br />

some cases at two levels - one provided<br />

over the verandah and other covering the<br />

rest of the rooms.<br />

Inorder to achieve thermal insulation,<br />

wooden ceiling (tattu) is also provided<br />

beneath the roof. This provides a large air<br />

space, which acts as an insulation layer<br />

against the conduction of external heat<br />

through the roof. The air space above the<br />

wooden false ceiling is well ventilated with<br />

openings (jalli) on both sides to permit<br />

maximum cross ventilation. The breathing<br />

space between the clay tiles that is used<br />

for roofing further helps in ventilating the<br />

under side of the roof reducing the<br />

temperature.<br />

Penetration of water to the interiors<br />

through the roof due to rain is prevented<br />

by pitched roofs protected with impervious<br />

materials like burnt roofing tiles, thatch<br />

etc. Dampness is eliminated by building on<br />

elevated lands with high plinths.<br />

sensors, data logger, memory module and<br />

computer interface (Figures 2, 3, 4, 5) was<br />

used to record the field data. Temperature<br />

sensors were located outside the building,<br />

in the courtyard, in the semi open space<br />

around the courtyard and in a bedroom<br />

adjacent to the courtyard. Indoor and<br />

outdoor wind velocities were also recorded<br />

simultaneously. A humidity sensor was<br />

fixed in the semi open space around the<br />

courtyard to record the indoor relative<br />

humidity. Continuous data were recorded<br />

for a period of 45 days at an interval of 15<br />

minutes. The windows were kept open<br />

throughout the investigation for<br />

unobstructed wind flow inside the building.<br />

Fig. 2: Data logger and memory module of<br />

the AES installed in the traditional house<br />

Experimental Investigation<br />

An investigation using quantitative<br />

recording of climatic parameters was<br />

carried out in a traditional residential<br />

building (around 250 years of old) at<br />

Nilambur in the Malappuram district of the<br />

northern part of Kerala. The courtyard of<br />

the building has an inward looking<br />

verandah of 1m width. The two sides of<br />

the courtyard are semi open spaces used<br />

for living and prayer. The other two sides<br />

are adjoined with rooms having windows<br />

opening to the courtyard.<br />

A custom made instrumentation set up<br />

called Architectural Evaluation System<br />

(AES), which is a combination of electronic<br />

Fig. 3: Indoor wind velocity sensor<br />

(bottom), Temperature and Humidity<br />

sensors (top)<br />

International Journal of Earth Sciences and Engineering<br />

ISSN 0974-5904, Vol. 02, No. 03, July 2009, pp. 264-271


DILI A. S, NASEER M. A, and ZACHARIA VARGHESE. T<br />

268<br />

Fig. 5: Outdoor wind velocity sensor<br />

Results<br />

Fig. 4: Outdoor temperature sensor<br />

While a diurnal variation of 17 o C (18 o C to<br />

35 o C) was observed in the outdoor<br />

temperature, a diurnal variation of just<br />

about 4 o C (24 o C to 28 o C) was observed<br />

in the simultaneous indoor temperature<br />

(Fig. 6). The temperature recorded inside<br />

the room is found to be lower than that of<br />

semi open space around the courtyard. It<br />

is observed that the indoor air<br />

temperature is maintained around 24 o C<br />

during night even when the outdoor<br />

temperature is as low as 18 o C. From the<br />

figure 6 it is evident that there is no time<br />

lag between the temperature outdoor and<br />

indoor. The indoor relative humidity varies<br />

from 45% to 90% and it is inversely<br />

proportional to the air temperature.<br />

The wind flow through the courtyard is<br />

almost continuous and consistent<br />

irrespective of the outside wind velocity.<br />

The figures 7 and 8 show the indoor and<br />

outdoor wind velocity when the outside<br />

wind velocity is very high and low.<br />

International Journal of Earth Sciences and Engineering<br />

ISSN 0974-5904, Vol. 02, No. 03, July 2009, pp. 264-271


269<br />

The passive environment control system of Kerala vernacular<br />

residential architecture: An experimental investigation on<br />

wind flow and thermal comfort<br />

Fig. 6: Air Temperature and Relative Humidity vs. Time<br />

Fig. 7: Wind Velocity vs. Time (when outdoor wind velocity is high)<br />

Discussion<br />

Fig. 8: Wind Velocity vs. Time (when outdoor wind velocity is low)<br />

The low diurnal variation of the indoor<br />

temperature proves the high thermal<br />

insulation property of the building<br />

envelope. The absence of time lag<br />

between outdoor and indoor temperatures<br />

is mainly due to the continuous air flow<br />

through the building. The air flow inside<br />

the building is maintained throughout<br />

(figures 7 and 8). This allows a convective<br />

heat exchange from outdoor to indoor.<br />

That is, when outdoor is very hot, those<br />

heat scalars are only transmitted into<br />

indoor by wind, which reduces the<br />

intensity of heat.<br />

International Journal of Earth Sciences and Engineering<br />

ISSN 0974-5904, Vol. 02, No. 03, July 2009, pp. 264-271


DILI A. S, NASEER M. A, and ZACHARIA VARGHESE. T<br />

270<br />

Figure 6 shows that during day time when<br />

the indoor temperature is high up to 28 o C,<br />

the humidity is as low as 45%. This falls<br />

well within the comfort zone of the<br />

bioclimatic chart (fig. 9) constructed by V.<br />

Olgyay (Koenigsberger, et al, 1975). This<br />

provides a very comfortable indoor<br />

environment. During night, since<br />

temperature becomes low up to 24 o C, the<br />

increase in humidity (up to 88%) does not<br />

really affect the indoor comfort condition.<br />

There is a very common saying that the<br />

main reason for the traditional buildings to<br />

keep cool when outside is hot is due to the<br />

maximum ventilation. In fact, maximum<br />

ventilation may bring more heat into the<br />

room and destroys the indoor thermal<br />

environment (Lin Borong, et. al., 2004).<br />

From the figures 7 and 8 it is evident that<br />

the passive environment control system of<br />

Kerala vernacular architecture really<br />

control and reduces the wind velocity<br />

inside the building in order to maintain its<br />

comfort level better.<br />

architecture. The presence of highly<br />

insulative building envelop for thermal<br />

protection, provision of verandahs for<br />

protection of external walls from solar<br />

radiation and the pitched roof for<br />

protection from heavy rain together are<br />

highly effective for a passive environment<br />

control system in Kerala vernacular<br />

residential architecture. The setting of<br />

building in the open land with judicious<br />

arrangement of living spaces around a<br />

courtyard with optimum size window<br />

openings is according to the requirement<br />

of wind for giving comfort in the humid<br />

climate.<br />

Conclusion<br />

Control of the indoor environment is<br />

always an important aspect of vernacular<br />

Fig. 9: Bioclimatic Chart (Koenigsberger, et al, 1975)<br />

International Journal of Earth Sciences and Engineering<br />

ISSN 0974-5904, Vol. 02, No. 03, July 2009, pp. 264-271


271<br />

The passive environment control system of Kerala vernacular<br />

residential architecture: An experimental investigation on<br />

wind flow and thermal comfort<br />

Acknowledgements<br />

The authors extend sincere gratitude to<br />

Mr. Ravi Varma of Nilamboor Kovilakam<br />

for his kind co operation for the conduct of<br />

the investigation. The authors also extend<br />

sincere gratitude to Dr. Ziaudeen,<br />

Principal, TKM College of Engineering for<br />

providing the equipment for this research.<br />

Mr. Sreejith T. S., Production Executive of<br />

EMCON, is also acknowledged by the<br />

authors for the supply and service of the<br />

equipment “Architectural Evaluation<br />

System”.<br />

References<br />

[1] A. Achyuthan, Balagopal T S Prabhu,<br />

An Engineering Commentary on<br />

Manusyalayacandrika of Tirumangalat<br />

Nilakantan<br />

musat,<br />

Vastuvidyapratisthanam, Calicut,<br />

Kerala, 1998.<br />

[2] Do-Kyoung Kim, The natural<br />

environment control system of Korean<br />

traditional architecture: Comparison<br />

with Korean contemporary<br />

architecture, Building and<br />

Environment, 2006, 41, 1905–1912.<br />

[3] D. Vyas, Traditional Indian architecture<br />

- The future solar buildings,<br />

International Conference on Passive<br />

and Low Energy Cooling for the Built<br />

Environment, Santorini, Greece, May<br />

2005.<br />

[4] Koenigsberger, et al, Manual of tropical<br />

Housing and building – Climatic design,<br />

Orient Longman Private Limited, 1975.<br />

[5] Krishnan, A., et al.,. Climate<br />

Responsive Architecture- A design<br />

handbook for energy efficient buildings.<br />

New Delhi:Tata Mcgraw – Hill<br />

Publishing Co. Ltd., 2001.<br />

[6] Kyung-Hoi Lee, Dong-Wook Han, Ho-<br />

Jin Lim, Passive design principles and<br />

techniques for folk houses in Cheju<br />

Island and Ull ng Island of Korea,<br />

Energy and Buildings 23 (1996) 207-<br />

216<br />

[7] Lekha S Hegde, K S Ananthakrishna,<br />

Indoor Temperature in Vernacular,<br />

Conventional and Alternative<br />

Technology Construction – A<br />

Comparative Investigation, The Journal<br />

of the Indian Institute of Architects,<br />

2008, 16 – 18.<br />

[8] Lin Borong, et. al., 2004, Study on the<br />

thermal performance of the Chinese<br />

traditional vernacular dwellings in<br />

Summer, Energy and Buildings, vol.<br />

36, pp.73–79.<br />

[9] Sunil Edward, Dona Kurian, Thermal<br />

Performance of Traditional Buildings in<br />

Kerala, The Journal of the Indian<br />

Institute of Architects, 2008, 7 – 8.<br />

[10] Youngryel Ryu, Seogcheol Kim,<br />

Dowon Lee, The influence of wind flows<br />

on thermal comfort in the Daechung of<br />

a traditional Korean house, Building<br />

and Environment, 2009, 44, 18–26.<br />

International Journal of Earth Sciences and Engineering<br />

ISSN 0974-5904, Vol. 02, No. 03, July 2009, pp. 264-271

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!