ISSN 0971-0973 J Indian Acad Forensic Med, <strong>32</strong>(2)Original research paperA study of homicidal deaths by mechanical injuries in Surat,Gujarat*Dr. Pranav Prajapati, MD, **Dr. M. I. Sheikh, MD, DNB, ***Dr. Shyam Patel, MBBSAbstract:Violence has been always an integral part of the human civilization since its inception. Human beings havebeen progressively become expert in producing various type of weapons both for offensive and defensive purposes.This study was aimed to evaluate the mechanical injuries in homicidal cases of different motives and also to find outthe most vulnerable portion of the body so as to minimize the loss of human life and common weapon used in suchcases.The present study was carried out on 166 cases of homicidal deaths due to mechanical injuries during theyear 2004 -05. Incidence of homicidal death due to mechanical injuries was averagely 83 cases per year. Mechanicalinjuries were quite common in homicidal deaths involving 130 males and 36 female victims. Majority of victimswere in the age group of 21-40 years include 104 cases (62.65%). Stab injuries were commonly seen on theabdomen and chest due to sharp cutting weapons. Blunt force was the most commonly employed method in 80 cases(48.19%). Incidence of firearm was quite rare. Lungs were commonly involved internal organ. Male group wasdominant over female group in defensive mechanism.Key Words: Violence, Defense Wound, Homicidal Injury, Hard, Blunt WeaponIntroduction:Homicide is the death of one human beingas a result of the conduct of another. Homicide is anexpression of aggression in its most extreme form.Amongst the strongest factors that predict aggressionand violence in a poor family atmosphere as reflectedin is rejection, punitiveness, hostility, permissivenessand aggression. Factors weakly related to aggressionare a male gender, neuropsychological deficits,having a muscular physique, high plasma testosteronelevels and being raised in an urban environment.In addition to factors that trigger or provokeaggression. There are other elements of a potentiallyaggressive situation that facilitate the expression ofthe behavior. These facilitators include the presenceof weapons and seeing other people acting violently;which may either simply increase arousal or they maysuggest to the observer that violence is an acceptableoption. [1, 2]Corresponding author:Dr. Pranav Prajapati*Assistant Professor,Forensic Medicine &Toxicology,Surat Municipal Institute of Medical Education &Research,Surat – 395010 IndiaMobile: +91- 9426362474Email: pprajapati79@gmail.com**Professor & Head***TutorInjuries are a leading cause of death in allage groups and both sexes (sex). Violence andinjuries account for 9% of the global mortality and12% of all disability adjusted life years (DALYs). [3]It is estimated that 5.8 million people worldwide dieeach year as a result of some form of injury. [4]Globally, around 520,000 people die each year as aresult of interpersonal violence, which equates to1400 deaths every single day. [5]The crime is now days propagatedthrough the most advanced audio-visual apparatusthrough television transmission, modern motives andcrime friction stories without any inhibition andcontrol over quality and variety of material in them.Killing of human being is very common; a deathbeing flashed in the columns of the popularnewspapers every day. It is still a challengeable taskfor investigating agency to reveal the mystery and forjudiciary to award a deterrent sentence to the guilty.The circumstances become more complex when suchexercise also involves socio-economic factors inaddition to medico legal ingredients of a case.Homicide investigation can never becomplete without a detailed postmortem examination.The detailed analysis and scientific interpretation ofautopsy finding is imperative to reconstruct thecrime. The medical criterion of homicide isconclusive demonstration that death was violent, i.e.caused by injury. Demonstration that the lethalviolence arouse from an unlawful act, agency,134
J Indian Acad Forensic Med, <strong>32</strong>(2) ISSN 0971-0973procurement or culpable omission of another person,satisfies the legal requirement. [5]Material and Methods:The present study was carried out onhomicide victims, consisting of 193 cases brought formedico legal postmortem examination to ForensicMedicine & Toxicology Department of GovernmentMedical College and New Civil Hospital, Surat fromJanuary 2004 to December 2005 and Surat MunicipalInstitute of Medical Education and Research(SMIMER) from June 2005 to December 2005(fivepolice station area were being authorized toSMIMER for doing postmortem examination from 1 stJune 2005).The study was conducted for two year periodduring which 4680 medico legal postmortem wereconducted. Out of them 193 cases were of homicide.166 cases showed homicidal mechanical injuries. Allcases of homicidal victims either confirmed byinvestigating police officer or suspected or found tobe homicide at postmortem.Every case of this study was examined todetermine age, sex, type of mechanical injury, type ofweapons to be used, involvement of organs and bloodvessels, and type of defense wound.Observations:Scientifically significant data of medicolegal nature are highlighted in table mentioningbelow. The figure in bold letters in tables highlightsthe higher incidence or important parameters.In this study, 78.31% of total cases were of male andonly 21.69% were of female. The percentage ofhomicide by mechanical injuries among males was3.61times more than females. (Table 1)In homicidal deaths, male group receivedmore mechanical injuries than the female group. 18male victims showed more than 20 injuries. (Table3)Sharp cutting injuries (Chop and incisedwounds) as well as blunt injuries were commonlyseen over head. Head (22.65%) was the target regionfor mechanical injuries followed by chest (21.48%)and abdomen (16.15%). Most of the stab woundswere due to single edged sharp cutting weapon andtarget region for stab injuries were abdomen andchest as evident from (Table 4).Majority of the victims were of age group21-30 years (37.95%) followed by age group 31-40years age group (24.70%). The least incidences wereseen in above 61 years of age groups. (Table 2)Amongst 166 cases of homicide due tomechanical injuries, 74 victims showed stab injuries.55 cases (74.<strong>32</strong>%) were of male while only 19victims (25.68%) were female. Three stab woundswere found in 25 cases (33.76%). (Table 5)In 80 cases (48.19%), hard & bluntweapons/objects were likely to be used formechanical injuries in this study which was followedby sharp cutting weapons (39.16%). Incidence ofusing firearms (4.22%) was quite rare. (Table 6)On examination of mechanical injuries overbody, 93 cases (56.02%) showed both superficial anddeep injuries followed by deep injuries (24.10%)alone. (Table 7)Internal injuries affecting the viscera andblood vessels were produced by sharp cuttingweapons (66.00%). 147 cases showed involvement ofinternal organs and blood vessels. Lungs were mostfrequently involved internal organ seen in 34 cases(23.13%) followed by major blood vessels, heart andsmall intestines. (Table 8)Only 54 cases (<strong>32</strong>.53%) showed defenseinjuries over right and left arm, forearm and hand.Males (88.89%) were eight times more defensivethan female (11.11%). Most defensive group is 20-29years (40.74%) followed by 30-39 years (27.78%).(Table 9)The most common type of injury in defensewounds was incised wound (48.30%) followed bycontusion (18.52%) and lacerated wound (16.67%).(Table 10)Discussion:Day by day, incidences of homicides areincreasing in Surat city due to industrialization,urbanization and migration of people. As it is crimeagainst human by human, various epidemiological,social and geographical factors of human life affectthe pattern. Only in two year, 193 cases (4.12%) ofhomicide which were lower than observed by Dikshitet. al [6]– 28%, Khanagwal & Paliwal [7]– 10%,Tosayonand[8] – 7.7% but higher than O.Ghambhir[9] -2.89%.Male victims were commonly involved inhomicides due to mechanical injuries. In this regardthe present study is in the same line with most of theauthors. The male predominance may be explainedby the fact that males by nature indulge in moreviolent activities as compared to females. In society,revenge is also usually aimed at males, women andchildren being generally spared. Higher incidence ofhomicide was seen in the age group of 21–40 years,104 cases, (62.65%). Persons in this age group aremore active, violent, and more vulnerable to the fastchanging social trends and culture, and usually theyget married by this age. Most importantly they are themain earning member of the family. However,Kominato et al [10] reported 46–55 years to be themost commonly involved age group.Male victims also showed presence of moremultiple injuries as compared to the female victims.As the majority of the external injuries were due toblunt force, they appear mostly either superficial orsuperficial and deep. There are many reasons formultiplicity of injury. One of them is firm135