Allegheny Commons - City of Pittsburgh

More documents

Recommendations

Info

United States Department of the InteriorNational Park Service / National Register of Historic Places Registration FormNPS Form 10900 OMB No. 10240018 (Expires 5/31/2012)Allegheny CommonsName of PropertyAllegheny County, PACounty and StateHampton Battery allee; and the lighting of the Hampton Battery Memorial with historically-appropriate lightingfixtures. As part of the project, this portion of the park was also surrounded by a two-foot metal post-and-railfence, as seen in historic photographs of the park (photo 6; Figure 4).South CommonSouth Common was historically the area of the park west of Sherman Street and south of Church Street. Ithas always been the slightest, most fragmented section of the park, tapering to a single row of trees betweenFederal Street and the railroad in Mitchell and Grant’s original plan. Other than plantings, it contained for atime only one feature: a stone fountain, flanked by a curving staircase, was installed in the narrow strip of parkbetween Stockton and Canal Streets sometimes in the late 19th century and removed ca. 1935.With the eradication of Church Street’s original alignment during the redevelopment of Allegheny City’s historiccenter in the 1960s, the definition of South Common changed somewhat. It currently consists of three distinctareas: the tennis courts, built ca. 1970, adjoining the East Common pool and pool house; a long, linear, formallawn defined by a double allee of oak trees south of Church Street between Federal and Sandusky Streetswhose current design dates from WPA-funded improvements to the park in 1935 (photo 28); and an openmeadow, dotted with trees, between the southeastern edge of West Common and the western terminus ofChurch Street. The World War II memorial, a noncontributing object since it was sited in South Common in the1980s, after the park’s period of significance, is located near the southwestern corner of the tennis courts. Thecourts are buffered from the surrounding streets by earth berms, consistent with the Simonds & Simonds era ofpark improvements in the late 1960s.Numerous uncounted landscape and other small-scale features are located throughout the four sections of thepark. The locations of playgrounds and types and locations of fencing are noted above. Different lightingstandards also exist, with the most historically-appropriate being the gaslight-type ones installed in EastCommon in 2005 as part of the pilot Master Plan implementation project. Signage in the park predominantlyaddresses rules and regulations and is placed in heavily used areas, but the 2005 pilot project placed a metalpark identification sign (“Allegheny Commons Est. 1788”) in East Common. The park also includesmiscellaneous, non-integral furnishings such as benches, trash receptacles, picnic tables, and flagpoles. Manyof these features are not consistent throughout the park. Some benches are made of metal, others of wood;picnic tables are of painted wood and placed sporadically.IntegrityDecorative features and park furnishings throughout the park have been removed or replaced over time evenas the basic structure and design of the Commons has remained intact. Allegheny Commons possessesintegrity of location; only the removal of Monument Hill in the 1930s and the realignment of the city’s originalstreet grid south of Church Street in the 1960s have affected the original boundaries of the park. Theboundaries of North, East, and West Commons (minus Monument Hill) remain intact and clearly defined, whileSouth Common – always the slenderest, least visually coherent area of the park, functioning mainly to connectEast and West Common below Allegheny Center – remains so.The park’s integrity of setting, likewise, is strong. While the historic core of Allegheny was much altered byredevelopment in the 1960s, several key buildings – such as St. Peters Roman Catholic Church, AlleghenyHigh School and Elementary School, the Whiteside Memorial Building, the Community House of the FirstUnited Presbyterian Church, the former U. S. Post Office, Buhl Planetarium, and Carnegie Library – still standto attest to the historic character of the original commercial and civic core surrounded by Allegheny Commonsfor its first 100 years. On the streets which form the park’s outer boundaries, the densely-built, architecturallyvariedcharacter of the 19th century neighborhoods, now historic districts, adjacent to the park remains.10
United States Department of the InteriorNational Park Service / National Register of Historic Places Registration FormNPS Form 10900 OMB No. 10240018 (Expires 5/31/2012)Allegheny CommonsName of PropertyAllegheny County, PACounty and StateThe park’s integrity of materials, design, and workmanship derive from the execution of its landscape planning,the continuity of its plantings, and the existence and quality of buildings, structures, sites and objects whichcommunicate the park’s historic functions as a place of outdoor recreation (both passive and active) andcultural remembering. In these respects, the park has good integrity to all eras of its history. The form of thepark – its basic boundaries, cross-cut by the railroad and Ohio Street, and its overall path system – date fromMitchell and Grant’s original plan, as does the park’s overall character: the symmetrical formality of linearNorth, East, and South Commons, linked to the pastoral expanse of West Common. Successive campaigns ofpark improvement in 1935 and in 1967 tinkered with, but did not substantially alter, the ways in which thepark’s four quadrants were designed to be experienced by pedestrian users. The swimming pool, pool house,and tennis courts are evidence of the City’s early- to mid-20 th century emphasis on active recreational facilities.The streamlined path layouts of North and lower East Commons, which date to the Civil Works Administrationfundedimprovements designed by Ralph Griswold in 1934, also have integrity to this period. While introducinga modern design vocabulary to West Common, Simonds and Simonds’ 1966 plan also resurrected LakeElizabeth, an original feature of the park whose function has evolved from ornamental to recreational toornamental again, after a 20-year period of nonexistence. West Common’s meandering, pastoral characterhas its origins in Mitchell and Grant’s original 1867 plan, while extant features such as the lake, its concretearched footbridges, the mounded earth, and the brick perimeter walls have integrity to the Simonds plan of1966.Plantings from all periods are present and are true to the original park designers’ intent, with formal alleesemphasizing linear features and more informal specimen plantings filling in lawns and meadows. Among thetrees and parklands, the park’s first 50 years saw an accumulation of monumental furnishings, such hasfountains and sculptures. The fountains were gradually removed as their maintenance became burdensome tothe City and the park’s emphasis on ornamentation shifted to one of recreation during the 20th century. Yetmany major monuments and sculptures from the Victorian period remain: the Hampton Battery Memorial, theSoldier’s Monument, the Thomas Armstrong Memorial, George Washington Memorial, Maine Memorial, andiron deer sculpture. These contribute not only to the park’s integrity of materials, design, and workmanship,but to its feeling and association as a repository of cultural memory and political commemoration. Likewise,bridges erected to facilitate the interaction of the park’s multimodal transportation systems – pedestrian paths,vehicular roads, and a railroad which predated the park itself – are still extant with integrity (although theircondition currently is poor). No buildings from the park’s first 50 years survive, but two from the park’s secondera as a recreational destination (the pool house and restroom building) do, also with integrity. Of the park’stwo non-contributing buildings, the maintenance building has little impact on the park’s overall integrity since itis tucked into an out-of-the way location. The Aviary, though a primary presence in the park, does not presenta major barrier to integrity because its location has always been the site of a city-owned institution, from thepenitentiary to the former conservatory. Its use is compatible with that of the park, and its siting does notrepresent a removal of park land.Together, the park’s unchanged location, its strong and consistent boundaries, its largely intact setting, and thepresence of its contributing buildings, structures, sites, and objects – including the park as a site, itself –contribute to its integrity of feeling and association. The park’s green lawns and extensive tree canopycontinue to represent a verdant oasis within a densely-built area of Pittsburgh. Its surrounding street wall of19th and early 20th century buildings, combined with its gentle topography, its lush and varied plantings, itsfocal nodes occupied by historic statuary, its reflective water feature, and the presence of recreationalresources, cumulatively communicate Allegheny Commons’ history as an ornamental Victorian park whichevolved to meet the wants and needs of the city it served over its first 100 years. Intact paths, roads, andbridges underscore the park’s essential identity as a public work, a City-built pleasure ground which mustnevertheless accommodate the urban region’s industrial and transit functions. Only two noncontributingsculptures, unobtrusively sited, intrude on the feeling of Victorian commemoration supplied by the park’scontributing monuments and memorials. Active recreational features such as ball courts and the swimming11
Page 1 and 2: NPS Form 10900 OMB No. 10240018 (Ex
Page 3 and 4: United States Department of the Int
Page 5: United States Department of the Int
Page 40 and 41: NPS Form 10-900-a OMB No. 1024-0018
Page 42 and 43: NPS Form 10-900-a OMB No. 1024-0018
Page 44 and 45: NPS Form 10-900-a (Rev. 8/2002) OMB
Page 50: (NC (NC Building)Structure)(NC Obje
Page 57 and 58: 1112
Page 59 and 60: 1516
Page 61 and 62:
1920
Page 63 and 64:
2324
Page 65:
2728
show all

Allegheny Commons - City of Pittsburgh

Create successful ePaper yourself

Delete template?

Save as template?