Beach Nov 2016

More documents

Recommendations

Info

Former U.S. Middle East Commander David Petraeus expresses optimism for Iraq in an otherwise cautionary talk During a reception for General David Petraeus, hosted by Torrance Memorial Medical Center in the Manhattan Beach Shade Hotel patio on October 25, Milo Basic asked the general, “Why did we go into the Middle East after 9-11? Think of all the suffering there now. In your opinion, would we be better off if we hadn’t.” Basic is the Croatian-born father-in-law of Shade Hotel owner Michael Zislis. Petraeus broke the uncomfortable silence that followed the bold question by acknowledging, “That’s a legitimate question.” He prefaced his answer first by observing, “The question presumes we had a choice.” Then he recounted the events of the Arab Spring that destabilized Muslim countries, from Africa to the Middle East. “If Egyptian President Mubarak had been able to stick around, we might have been less hasty in declaring his time was over. But there were not thousands, but millions demonstrating for his overthrow in Tahrir Square in Cairo.” “Mubarak was a mentor and father figure to me when I was a major stationed in the Middle East, 25 years earlier. One day he put his hand on my knee and said, ‘General, listen to the Arab Street. Never forget the Arab Street.’” Petraeus said he wished Mubarak had followed his own advice. “In Tunisia, there was no saving President Ben Ali [after a fruit vendor set himself on fire, triggering the Tunisian revolution]. In Libya, we helped the opposition take down Gaddafi. And certainly, our invasion of Iraq took out Saddam Hussein. But he was the personification of a kleptocrat and I don’t think he would have lasted much longer.” Finally, Petraeus responded to Basic’s question. “In all honesty, I don’t second guess the decision. The worst thing for a military leader, especially one who has written more letters than I care to remember to mothers and fathers, would be to give an opinion, one way or another. I think it would be inappropriate. Our focus now should be on how to make the future as good as possible.” Petraeus was less reticent in discussing President Barack Obama’s controversial decision to withdraw troops from Afghanistan in 2011. Petraeus had been named Commander of U.S. Forces in the Middle East by President George W. Bush in 2007 and served in that post until being named Director of the CIA by President Obama in 2011. The subject came up when Vietnam veteran and former Manhattan Beach councilman Bob Holmes asked Petraeus what lessons he had learned from Vietnam. Petraeus’ doctoral dissertation was on Vietnam. Petraeus answered, “I took from that experience how a military commander should give advice to a president. In my view, the advice Blood and treasure in the Middle East by Kevin Cody Photos by Deidre Davidson/Torrance Memorial Medical Center General David Petraeus addresses guests at the Torrance Memorial Medical Center reception prior to his Distinguished Speaker Series talk. 18 Easy Reader / Beach magazine • November 10, 2016
Joe Hohm, Bob Holmes, General Petraeus, Russ Lesser and Rich Lucy. General David Petraeus and Milo Basic. should be based on facts on the ground, but informed by the issues a president has to deal with. I’m focused on the Middle East, he’s focused on the whole world. Coalition politics, domestic politics, Congressional politics, budgetary constraints – these issues may not be material to war decisions, but can’t be divorced from it.” “During the final [2011] meeting on the drawdown of forces in Afghanistan, the president went around the room and elicited support from everyone, until he came to me. I said, ‘Mr. President, with all due respect (not always the most sincere words, Petraeus interjected, eliciting laughter from his listeners), I said a year ago, and again last week, based on the facts on the ground, and informed by the issues you have to deal with, I think the drawdown is too aggressive. The facts have not changed in the last week, so my recommendation remains the same.’” “If you ever want to feel the oxygen go out of the situation room in the West Wing, try that,” he said. Petraeus was peppered with ‘What if’ questions both during the reception and the talk he gave later that evening to Distinguished Speaker subscribers at the Redondo Beach Performing Arts Center. (He deflected questions about his extramarital affair and mishandling of classified information, which led to a misdemeanor plea and his dismissal as CIA director, by saying, “I won’t address painful, personal topics, such as Why Army can’t beat Navy,” again eliciting laughter. (He also declined to discuss the current presidential election, except to dismiss, without naming Trump, “the suggestion in the presidential campaign that [our intervention in Iraq] is a grab for oil.” “The oil is in the south, not in the northern area controlled by the Islamic State,” he said. He added, “We could have bought 100 years of oil with what we’ve spent in Iraq.”) Former Manhattan Beach councilman Russ Lesser asked Petraeus at the reception, “Had we kept 10,000 troops in Iraq, would ISIS be there now?” “That’s a fantastic question,” Petraeus said. “As then director of the CIA, I thought keeping 10,000 troops there would have been the correct course of action. But the answer is not as clear as you might think, given how Iraqi Prime Minister Maliki upended everything we had done.” During his Distinguished Speaker address, Petraeus expanded on his answer. He described Maliki’s arrest of Sunnis in his administration and Maliki’s use of force against protesters as “predictable, but a tragic undoing of what we sacrificed for.” The U.S sacrifice he referred to was the 2007 “surge,” which he led. “When Ambassador Crocker and I arrived in Baghdad, we were summoned by Maliki’s national security advisor. Just 45 days earlier, President Bush and Maliki had agreed to a strategy that was 180 degrees different from mine. They wanted U.S. military out of the cities. We were going back into the cities. They wanted detainees released. We weren’t going to release detainees because there was no rehabilitation program. They wanted to dial back nighttime activities. We were going to double them. There was nothing in their program about reconciliation. “I told the national security advisor to tell Maliki that if he disagreed with my policies, he could tell that to our president the next day on the scheduled teleconference. But if he did, I’d be on the next plane back to Washington D.C. “The next day Maliki didn’t mention it. I had 25,000 U.S. troops, 250 helicopters and the authority of an occupying commander and was not reticent to exercise that authority. We drove down violence by 85 percent. “Some three and a half years later, after our withdrawal, Maliki went after Sunni leaders because he was worried about his Shiite base in the upcoming election. The Sunni area then became fertile grounds for extremism. “Before we went to Iraq [in 2003], I’d been in Craig Leach, Judy Leach, David Petraeus, Judith Gassner, Michael Zislis and Mark Lurie, M.D. Ty Bobbit, Nadine Bobbit, David Petraeus, Lenore Levine, Mary Jo Unatin, Song Cho Klein and David Klein
Page 1: November 10, 2016 Volume 47, Issue
Page 6: November 10, 2016 Volume 47, Issue
Page 12: CRYSTAL BED THERAPY Many people who
Page 16 and 17: each health “PINTS FOR PROSTATES
Page 20 and 21: 310.539.6685 310.884.1870 310.326.9
Page 22: each charity HALLOWEEN BALL FOR PED
Page 25 and 26: Musical Gifts for Everyone Give a g
Page 27 and 28: Kris Hall in his favorite place on
Page 29 and 30: item was delivered. The octopus her
Page 31 and 32: The Bisignano family, from left, Jo
Page 33 and 34: It’s just too much.” Jonathan l
Page 35 and 36: Lunada Bay Ocean Bluff Property wit
Page 37 and 38: “While Melia is naturally talente
Page 39 and 40: Chittenden plans to study Internati
Page 41 and 42: Simply Tiles Design Center Fine Cer
Page 43 and 44: AMERICAN EXPRESS ® ® MasterCard®
Page 45 and 46: Michael Burstein is a probate and e
Page 47: MAUREEN GIANCANELLI Keller Williams

Beach Nov 2016

Create successful ePaper yourself

Delete template?

Save as template?