27.12.2016 Views

Federation Star - January 2017

Monthly newspaper of the Jewish Federation of Collier County (Naples, Florida)

Monthly newspaper of the Jewish Federation of Collier County (Naples, Florida)

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

24A <strong>Federation</strong> <strong>Star</strong> <strong>January</strong> <strong>2017</strong><br />

Book review by Philip K. Jason, Special to the <strong>Federation</strong> <strong>Star</strong><br />

Phil Jason<br />

JEWISH INTEREST<br />

Ambition, loyalty and obsession darken<br />

dazzling bio-fiction treatment of Marc Chagall<br />

The Bridal Chair, by Gloria<br />

Goldreich. Sourcebooks Landmark.<br />

496 pages. Trade Paperback $14.99.<br />

Who was Marc Chagall? Of<br />

course he was an immensely<br />

talented and prolific artist in<br />

many styles and various media whose<br />

works brought him a towering reputation<br />

and towering<br />

sales figures over<br />

several decades.<br />

He was a Russian<br />

Jew raised in a religious<br />

household<br />

whose life, until<br />

after the end of<br />

World War II, was<br />

a series of relocations<br />

brought on<br />

first by the need to escape Russian/Soviet<br />

anti-Semitism and later the Nazi’s<br />

brutal takeover of France. Though he<br />

spoke Yiddish and employed Jewish<br />

imagery and themes in some of his<br />

most renowned works, he was not otherwise<br />

attached to Jewish culture, theology<br />

or ritual.<br />

While these elements of Chagall’s<br />

identity are well dramatized in Gloria<br />

Goldreich’s book, her main concerns<br />

are his personality and his relationships.<br />

The central strategy in revealing<br />

these aspects of the historical Chagall is<br />

Goldreich’s brilliant decision to make<br />

Chagall’s daughter, rather than the man<br />

himself, the book’s central character. It<br />

is through tracing (and perhaps imagining)<br />

Ida Chagall’s journey from the<br />

age of seven into early middle age as<br />

the adoring daughter, business manager,<br />

and enabler of Chagall’s best and<br />

worst qualities that the author paints<br />

her astounding word picture of the man<br />

in his time and in his places.<br />

The teenage Ida is a ravishing<br />

young woman, a real head-turner who<br />

enjoys the smiles on men’s faces. She<br />

is confident, intelligent, fashionably attired<br />

and articulate. Living in a world<br />

of art and artists, she is already quite<br />

knowledgeable about that world. She<br />

is pleased to be her father’s daughter.<br />

In time, she will want to be more than<br />

that – but Marc’s approval will always<br />

be important.<br />

In fact, Marc’s estimate of people<br />

is directly proportional to how well<br />

they serve his needs. Vain in matters<br />

of appearance and status in the world<br />

of art, he is insecure and dependent in<br />

other ways. In some ways a rebel, he<br />

is also a slave to propriety. When Ida<br />

becomes pregnant, he is horrified. He<br />

and Ida’s mother, Bella, insist on an<br />

abortion. This is not Ida’s preference,<br />

but she agrees to it. Somewhat less<br />

threatening to Marc is Ida’s marriage to<br />

a non-Jew, but he accommodates himself<br />

to it as long as Ida puts her father’s<br />

Thursday, <strong>January</strong> 5, 11:30 a.m. - 2:00 p.m. at Hilton Naples<br />

Tickets must be purchased by December 30 • Sponsored by U.S. Bank<br />

Jesse Itzler<br />

Living With a SEAL<br />

www.JewishBookFestival.org • 239.263.4205<br />

needs above all else.<br />

And, sometimes reluctantly,<br />

she does. Her place<br />

in the world is not as someone’s<br />

wife, or an independent<br />

identity (which she<br />

often longs for), but as<br />

the great Marc Chagalls’<br />

daughter.<br />

Ida becomes the<br />

manager of the Chagall<br />

domestic situation and<br />

the Chagall industry. She selects their<br />

various residences, arranges for the<br />

smooth running of these households,<br />

and becomes the principal agent for the<br />

display and marketing of her father’s<br />

artworks. Thus, she is in constant contact<br />

with prominent collectors, dealers,<br />

gallery owners and museum curators.<br />

These overlapping responsibilities,<br />

which she handles with determination<br />

and skill, define her place in the world.<br />

They also limit it. She couldn’t<br />

be doing this for Picasso, or for herself.<br />

Indeed, her personal artistic ambitions<br />

are sacrificed to serving her<br />

father, whose appreciation is rarely<br />

shown. She even arranges for his mistresses<br />

(officially housekeepers), one<br />

of which, non-Jewish, brings a Chagall<br />

son into the world.<br />

Marc is a grand manipulator,<br />

whose practiced ineptness in many areas<br />

leaves others to pick up the pieces.<br />

He is not lazy. Indeed, his dedication<br />

to his art consumes him, but he shuns<br />

everyday responsibilities and insists<br />

that his work demands ideal environments<br />

without distractions.<br />

Generally, he gets what he wants.<br />

Eventually, Ida also gets what she<br />

wants: a fine, devoted husband; three<br />

children; respect; and much-needed<br />

peace of mind.<br />

Goldreich’s narrative<br />

has many strengths<br />

beyond those of characterization<br />

and the<br />

exploration of relationships<br />

(though the large<br />

cast of vividly depicted<br />

characters is a powerful<br />

achievement). Readers<br />

will learn a great deal<br />

about the history of modern<br />

art, artistic technique<br />

and the business of art. The author’s<br />

descriptions of particular artworks are<br />

spectacular.<br />

Her handling of setting is also superb.<br />

Readers are invited to visit many<br />

places exquisitely described, places<br />

that have not only dimensions, materials<br />

and colors, but atmosphere. We explore<br />

homes in Paris and its environs,<br />

other communities in France, New<br />

York City, upstate New York, Zurich,<br />

and many more. Goldreich’s descriptions<br />

are lavish backdrops for her characters’<br />

actions. Almost too lavish.<br />

The pace is leisurely, and on occasion<br />

seems too slow. The detailed<br />

descriptions slow it down. Some readers<br />

will feel that less would have been<br />

more. Others will enjoy every morsel<br />

of information.<br />

All in all, The Bridal Chair is a towering<br />

achievement: emotionally powerful,<br />

psychologically deft, and a feast<br />

of sensory images.<br />

Philip K. Jason is Professor Emeritus<br />

of English from the United States Naval<br />

Academy. He reviews regularly for<br />

Florida Weekly, Jewish Book World,<br />

Southern Literary Review, and other<br />

publications. Please visit Phil’s website<br />

at www.philjason.wordpress.com.<br />

Interest-Free Financing up to 2019 *<br />

*See store for details.<br />

Storewide Savings ON ALL MATTRESSES<br />

Sleep Logic<br />

2500 Pillow Top<br />

TWIN $ 277 FULL $ 327<br />

QUEEN $ 347 KING $ 697<br />

Simmons Beautysleep<br />

Keesville Luxury Firm<br />

TWIN $ 499 FULL $ 579<br />

QUEEN $ 599 KING $ 899<br />

A Modern Twist on the<br />

Traditional Sleeper Sofa<br />

Parks Collection<br />

Glacier Bay 2<br />

Firm, Plush or Euro Top<br />

TWIN $ 699 FULL $ 779<br />

QUEEN $ 799 KING $ 1,149<br />

Serta iComfort<br />

Foresight<br />

TWIN $ 799 FULL $ 1,099<br />

QUEEN $ 1,299 KING $ 1,899<br />

Organic Sleeper Sofas,<br />

Sleeper Loveseats and<br />

Sleeper Chairs<br />

ESTERO - NOW OPEN<br />

239-284-1281<br />

NORTH NAPLES<br />

239-302-1533<br />

NAPLES<br />

239-434-0077<br />

FORT MYERS<br />

239-433-0779<br />

BONITA SPRINGS<br />

239-390-9600<br />

CLEARANCE CENTER<br />

239-415-5961<br />

HOURS Saturday 9 am - 6 pm • Sunday 11 am - 5 pm • Monday–Friday 9 am - 8 pm<br />

Shop In-Store or Online at CityMattress.com<br />

Choose from over 80 comforts from the best name brands.<br />

PranaSleep • Om • Lotus • Karma • Vispring • Sealy • Stearns & Foster • RedBed • Simmons • Serta • Aireloom • Tempur-Pedic

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!