The Star: May 04, 2017
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Star</strong> 15<br />
News<br />
Latest Christchurch news at www.<br />
Can Wagner rise to<br />
the challenge?<br />
.kiwi<br />
Thursday <strong>May</strong> 4 <strong>2017</strong><br />
New rebuild boss Nicky<br />
Wagner has been dubbed<br />
the “personable politician”.<br />
But has she got the goods<br />
to finish the job that Gerry<br />
Brownlee started? Bridget<br />
Rutherford reports<br />
IT WOULD be hard to find two more<br />
different political personalities.<br />
Within minutes of speaking to<br />
National Christchurch Central MP<br />
Nicky Wagner (right), you know she’s a<br />
glass-half-full kind of person.<br />
<strong>The</strong> former schoolteacher turned<br />
businesswoman and Environment<br />
Canterbury councillor, is popular<br />
and personable with her “grass roots”<br />
attitude to politics.<br />
She clawed her way to win the<br />
Christchurch Central seat in 2011,<br />
through hard yakka, and pounding the<br />
pavements.<br />
Christchurch’s future clearly excites her.<br />
Former rebuild boss and now Foreign<br />
Affairs Minister Gerry Brownlee, on<br />
the other hand, was a different type of<br />
politician.<br />
He’s not afraid to be critical – and then<br />
sometimes having to apologise.<br />
Infamously, he called former <strong>May</strong>or Bob<br />
Parker a “clown.” He later phoned Parker<br />
to mend fences.<br />
He said in 2012 some landowners<br />
after the earthquake<br />
were “carping and moaning”<br />
about their situation.<br />
During his six-year tenure<br />
Gerry<br />
Brownlee<br />
overseeing the city’s rebuild,<br />
he’s been accused of not<br />
communicating and failing<br />
to listen. But many say he had a role too<br />
big for one person.<br />
It’s been more than a week since Prime<br />
Minister Bill English announced Mrs<br />
Wagner would take over Mr Brownlee’s<br />
role as Minister Supporting Greater<br />
Christchurch Regeneration.<br />
Already she’s copped flak. Critics say<br />
at number 22 on National’s list, she will<br />
be powerless because she is not a Cabinet<br />
Minister, and therefore the Government<br />
was walking away from Christchurch.<br />
Former mayor Garry Moore said Mrs<br />
Wagner had been given a “poisoned chalice”<br />
because everything was in place.<br />
“Being outside Cabinet will mean Wagner<br />
will have to sit, Lazarus-like, in the hall<br />
outside the Cabinet meeting room hoping<br />
that she will be able to influence the way<br />
things are being managed in Christchurch.<br />
“Cabinet decisions will be passed out the<br />
door to her as a recipient, just like most of<br />
us in Christchurch have experienced for<br />
years.”<br />
By comparison Labour MP Megan<br />
Woods, who has the Christchurch issues<br />
portfolio, is number five on her party’s list.<br />
But Mrs Wagner said whenever a decision<br />
about Christchurch was made in<br />
Cabinet, she would be there.<br />
It also meant she would have an extra<br />
day each week to be in Christchurch, she<br />
said.<br />
But Canterbury University political science<br />
associate professor Bronwyn Hayward<br />
said Mrs Wagner would have more<br />
resources and support if she was a Cabinet<br />
Minister.<br />
“I think it is a concern that the Government<br />
does not see the need to sustain the<br />
focus on Christchurch or why even they<br />
‘Being outside Cabinet will mean Nicky Wagner will have to<br />
sit, Lazarus-like, in the hall outside the Cabinet meeting room<br />
hoping that she will be able to influence the way things are<br />
being managed in Christchurch.’ – Garry Moore, former mayor<br />
need MPs like Wagner in their inner circle.”<br />
She said Mr Brownlee was not the “right<br />
personality” for the city and Mrs Wagner<br />
had the ability to restore relationships –<br />
but it might be too late.<br />
“He [Brownlee]. . . tended to work with<br />
a fairly narrow community of loyal supporters<br />
and similar interests.”<br />
She said Mr Brownlee had a large workload,<br />
and perhaps was asked to perform<br />
the role for too long.<br />
PHOTO: MARTIN HUNTER<br />
He was a “polarising figure” who exacerbated<br />
anger and frustration, she said.<br />
In comparison, Mrs Wagner was popular<br />
and personable, she said.<br />
Mrs Wagner said she wants to keep the<br />
ball rolling, and build on the “tough” decisions<br />
Mr Brownlee had made and “copped<br />
flack” for, including the residential red<br />
zone’s future.<br />
Labour’s earthquake recovery spokeswoman<br />
Megan Woods said she had “grave<br />
concerns” that Canterbury was slipping<br />
down the Government’s priority agenda.<br />
“Canterbury doesn’t have a place at the<br />
table when decisions are being made.”<br />
Mrs Wagner said the city was in a great<br />
position compared to 15 years ago where<br />
you could “shoot a gun down Cashel Mall<br />
at 11am” some days.<br />
“Who would have believed down the track<br />
we’re in such a strong position?”<br />
She said following the February 22,<br />
2011, earthquake, their original expectations<br />
on how quickly the rebuild could<br />
happen were not realistic.<br />
“That was the biggest challenge.<br />
“We’ve got the momentum going in the<br />
right direction.”