2012 100 - Networld Media Group
2012 100 - Networld Media Group
2012 100 - Networld Media Group
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Recent headlines tell a dismal story: “Best Buy’s<br />
Dunn Should Be Next CEO Fired” wrote Douglas<br />
A. McIntyre on 24/7WallStreet.com. Then, just a few<br />
weeks later, “Why Best Buy is Going out of Business<br />
… Gradually” topped a 3,000-word screed by Forbes<br />
contributor Larry Downes, that garnered some 15,700<br />
Facebook shares, 17,500 tweets, and a blunt response<br />
from Dunn himself titled “My Thoughts on Best Buy’s<br />
Recent <strong>Media</strong> Coverage,” albeit without mentioning<br />
either McIntyre or Downes by name. Best Buy has<br />
posted a string of poor quarterly results since Dunn<br />
assumed the CEO mantle in June 2009. Throughout<br />
his reign, Downes charges, Dunn has pursued a strategy<br />
of protecting market share over profit. In the quarter<br />
ending November 30, 2011, store sales increased 1<br />
percent — marking the retailer’s first increase in two<br />
years. Margins, however, sank, with net income dropping<br />
by 29 percent. For the quarter ending May 28,<br />
2011, the firm posted a sales increase of only 1 percent<br />
to $10.9 billion. EPS fell by 3 percent to 35 cents.<br />
Online revenue rose only 10 percent in the U.S., not<br />
nearly enough to keep up with Amazon, which continues<br />
to grow more than 50 percent per quarter.<br />
Dunn maintains that his company is well positioned<br />
to poach significant online market share from Ama-<br />
BRIAN DUNN<br />
zon.com with Best Buy Marketplace, a new service<br />
meant to challenge the world’s largest e-commerce<br />
company. The effort addresses challenges shared by<br />
all retailers committed to maintaining<br />
large bricks-and-mortar<br />
operations while simultaneously<br />
trying to flank Amazon online.<br />
Although Best Buy Marketplace<br />
substantially increases the selection<br />
of products and brands available at BestBuy.com,<br />
Wall Street appears to be losing patience with Best<br />
Buy’s plans to overhaul itself. Despite Dunn’s upbeat<br />
assurances to the contrary, Amazon.com has badly<br />
damaged Best Buy’s earnings and its future projects.<br />
As evidence of investor reaction to the CEO’s tenure,<br />
Best Buy’s shares are off 43 percent over the past two<br />
years, while Amazon’s are up 39 percent, and the S&P<br />
500 is higher by 12 percent over the same period. The<br />
market’s stunned response to Best Buy’s third quarter<br />
2011 results and forecasts resulted in shares plummeting<br />
more than 15 percent. A decisive blow to Dunn’s<br />
tenure may have come just days before Christmas<br />
when the world’s largest consumer electronics retailer<br />
announced that it would be unable to fill an undisclosed<br />
number of holiday orders placed online.<br />
24