Clttsr nf Nr}lrrnrtRtttiurn, 1{. 0.

•
12
1 ~I51 ., Aootor, whieh FayU : 'h2ai ;.oal perr,poot :9.ve rcquires rccogu :ltion
d of' slgnSf :leant. ben6f'3r.9a1M effcrc.ts o'.' sl .tok;nt YrSncvi .)y ,n thc :
a ca of Mmltdr] hea)th,
c 'h'hoac BoneSi.ts or3.ginato In a Nsyc:hc9mt ;c search f'o .r
p iontwltment ana are uroasvxabl .o on?y In t.exi!s of i11G'iv5dua]
~
p hetav9or . SSnoo no nm^rns of nuanti .tat,nE; those he:neS :lta; . :is
p aplHront thm Comrnfttwe finds no 4ae . :is a or al ;iudgmont rrtsl.c.h Wo.1et
a weSgh benef :its versuU flaRcrds of slnolxing 1 :e, :it tn•;.y apPly to the
K~ goneralj pop~a] .at;ion .~~
to Tlln othor wor'$s, there arc'll't yc'u bc+y :i .11Q;, not y[ra bUt yolU'
It oomnii.tl.ee, the conmi5ttec tA,at has nmde ?t.s rel?ort to you say :ing
/P }rlt In certtin 3nta.ncoe :,moK :nig 9as brnefic'~e~t ., and t8trt the
• 18 co &ro7ttec found or krrc°e of no way whero they c:oul.d quant ;taMeJ .y
te Iltwalancc off the bencfits against t,he detn ;p:ents of smolcang`~
16 f~' Ure Tcrry, 3 suppose thJ.e. is what thcy are tryS .nf; to sfty .
y
ts ~) thinlc it :IS very ~iAf'ficu7t to he any rnoro spec5f9c than they
Ip Iravc beon hore, and th7s r,as the op7.nionn of i.ho cosMt•ee .
4s I Nh• . 6:o :^nceily . Jn othor words,, t.hcs report does recognSzc
tA It'd>a.t In cortoai .n Artcarlces cigarottes ecrc benoficia), the rnnacing
?o oA' c5.p„rottes fr, beneflo2al ? Woul .dnrt that be a fair anetSysSe
pt of that statement anco eone] .usion and summ;ry7
~ gx lry' . TePry, Y. Qell't: IUIOIV roally .
v.' rw.y llr . }lvnd7.ey oommcnt on this?
D1ro Sorne-y.:yp A7.7 r5t;h1., cfn,
;'I~I Pr, },t,iad7cy . lt},inlc vra ;nly, Ufr, the Conirrita .ee's i'ndMP,
http://legacy.library.ucsf.edu/tid/lly24f00/pdf