Works and Facilities Agenda (14/11/06, 8766kb) - Eurobodalla Shire ...
Works and Facilities Agenda (14/11/06, 8766kb) - Eurobodalla Shire ...
Works and Facilities Agenda (14/11/06, 8766kb) - Eurobodalla Shire ...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
EUROBODALLA SHIRE COUNCIL<br />
AGENDA<br />
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE<br />
MEETING<br />
<strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong>
EUROBODALLA SHIRE COUNCIL<br />
ETHICAL DECISION MAKING AND<br />
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST<br />
A GUIDING CHECKLIST FOR COUNCILLORS, OFFICERS<br />
AND COMMUNITY COMMITTEES<br />
ETHICAL DECISION MAKING<br />
• Is the decision or conduct legal?<br />
• Is it consistent with Government policy, Council’s objectives <strong>and</strong> Code of Conduct?<br />
• What will the outcome be for you, your colleagues, the Council, anyone else?<br />
• Does it raise a conflict of interest?<br />
• Do you st<strong>and</strong> to gain personally at public expense?<br />
• Can the decision be justified in terms of public interest?<br />
• Would it withst<strong>and</strong> public scrutiny?<br />
CONFLICT OF INTEREST<br />
A conflict of interest is a clash between private interest <strong>and</strong> public duty. There are two types of<br />
conflict: Pecuniary – regulated by the Local Government Act <strong>and</strong> Department of Local Government;<br />
<strong>and</strong> Non-Pecuniary – regulated by Codes of Conduct <strong>and</strong> policy, ICAC, Ombudsman, Department of<br />
Local Government (advice only).<br />
THE TEST FOR CONFLICT OF INTEREST<br />
• Is it likely I could be influenced by personal interest in carrying out my public duty?<br />
• Would a fair <strong>and</strong> reasonable person believe I could be so influenced?<br />
• Conflict of interest is closely tied to the layperson’s definition of “corruption” – using public<br />
office for private gain.<br />
• Important to consider public perceptions of whether you have a conflict of interest.<br />
IDENTIFYING PROBLEMS<br />
1st Do I have private interests affected by a matter I am officially involved in?<br />
2nd Is my official role one of influence or perceived influence over the matter?<br />
3rd Do my private interests conflict with my official role?<br />
Whilst seeking advice is generally useful, the ultimate decision rests with the person concerned.<br />
AGENCY ADVICE<br />
Officers of the following agencies are available during office hours to discuss the obligations placed<br />
on Councillors, Officers <strong>and</strong> Community Committee members by various pieces of legislation,<br />
regulation <strong>and</strong> Codes.<br />
CONTACT PHONE EMAIL WEBSITE<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council<br />
Public Officer<br />
4474-1000 council@eurocoast.nsw.gov.au www.esc.nsw.gov.au<br />
ICAC 8281 5999 icac@icac.nsw.gov.au www.icac.nsw.gov.au<br />
Local Government Department 4428 4100 dlg@dlg.nsw.gov.au www.dlg.nsw.gov.au<br />
NSW Ombudsman<br />
8286 1000<br />
Toll Free 1800 451 524<br />
Nswombo@ombo.nsw.gov.au www.ombo.nsw.gov.au
GLOSSARY<br />
Reports to Committee are presented generally by ‘exception’ - that is, only those items that do<br />
not comply with legislation or policy, or are the subject of objection, are discussed in a report.<br />
Reports address areas of business risk to assist decision making. Those areas include legal, policy,<br />
environment, asset, economic, strategic <strong>and</strong> financial.<br />
Reports may also include key planning or assessment phrases such as:<br />
Setback Council’s planning controls establish preferred st<strong>and</strong>ards of setback (eg 7.5m front; 1m<br />
side <strong>and</strong> rear);<br />
Envelope taking into account the slope of a lot, defines the width <strong>and</strong> height of a building with<br />
preferred st<strong>and</strong>ard of 8.5m high;<br />
Footprint the percentage of a lot taken up by a building on a site plan.<br />
Acronym Meaning Description<br />
ACR Australian Capital The political <strong>and</strong> strategic grouping of the ACT government <strong>and</strong> 17<br />
Region<br />
adjacent councils<br />
AEP Annual Exceedance For floods expressed as a % eg 1% = 1:100 year event. The NSW<br />
Probability<br />
Flood Guidelines nominate types of development <strong>and</strong> controls<br />
AHD Australian Height Floor levels for buildings set to remain at or above flood level<br />
Datum<br />
(expressed as 'freeboard')<br />
APZ Asset Protection Zone Area to be cleared <strong>and</strong> maintained around habitable buildings in<br />
bushfire prone areas<br />
ARP Arterial Road Plan 20-year plan to develop, through developer contributions, grants <strong>and</strong><br />
loans, a series of link <strong>and</strong> loop roads to <strong>and</strong> around major urban centres<br />
AS Australian St<strong>and</strong>ard St<strong>and</strong>ards set by national body as minimum construction, service,<br />
system, planning or design requirements<br />
BCA Building Code of Prescribes minimum st<strong>and</strong>ards or performance base for building<br />
Australia<br />
construction<br />
CAMP Companion Animal Required by state law, plan nominating management of dogs <strong>and</strong> cats<br />
Management Plan <strong>and</strong> areas for access for the exercise of dogs (eg beaches <strong>and</strong> reserves).<br />
CC Construction Certificate Floor Plans approved by council or private certifier in compliance with<br />
development conditions <strong>and</strong> BCA<br />
CCP Coastal Capacity Plan Scientific research behind assessment of capacity of l<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
waterways in rural residential <strong>and</strong> urban expansion l<strong>and</strong>s to sustain<br />
human settlement<br />
COPW Condition of Public Required by state law to define the condition of infrastructure assets,<br />
<strong>Works</strong> Report<br />
the cost to upgrade to defined st<strong>and</strong>ards, the current costs of<br />
maintenance <strong>and</strong> desired levels of maintenance<br />
CP Cultural Plan<br />
CSR Complaint <strong>and</strong> Service Requests received from public by phone, letter, email or Councillor to<br />
Request<br />
attend to certain works (eg pothole) or complain of certain service or<br />
offence (eg dogs barking)<br />
DA Development<br />
Required by state law to assess suitability <strong>and</strong> impacts of a<br />
Application<br />
development proposed for l<strong>and</strong><br />
DAP Disability Action Plan Council plan outlining proposed works <strong>and</strong> services to upgrade<br />
facilities to progressively meet Disability Discrimination Act<br />
DCP Development Control Local planning policy defining the characteristics sought in residential,<br />
Plan<br />
commercial l<strong>and</strong><br />
DEC Department of State agencies (former Environment Protection <strong>and</strong> National Parks)<br />
Environment <strong>and</strong> managing state l<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> regulating council activity or advising on<br />
Conservation (formerly<br />
EPA, NPWS)<br />
development applications<br />
DEUS Department of Energy, State agency managing funding <strong>and</strong> approvals for town <strong>and</strong> country<br />
Utilities& Sustainability water <strong>and</strong> sewer services <strong>and</strong> State energy requirements.<br />
DOP Department of Planning State agency managing state l<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> regulating council activity or<br />
advising on development applications or strategic planning<br />
DLG Department<br />
Government<br />
of Local State agency responsible for regulating local government
DLRA Department of L<strong>and</strong>s State agency managing state l<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> advising on development<br />
<strong>and</strong> Rural Affairs applications or crown l<strong>and</strong> management<br />
DOC Department of State agency (formerly Public <strong>Works</strong>) managing state public water,<br />
Commerce<br />
sewer <strong>and</strong> buildings infrastructure <strong>and</strong> advising/supervising on council<br />
infrastructure construction<br />
DoH Department of Health State agency responsible for oversight of health care (community <strong>and</strong><br />
hospital) programs. Also responsible for public warning of reportable<br />
health risks<br />
DOTAP Department of Transport Federal agency incorporating the national department for local<br />
<strong>and</strong> Planning<br />
government <strong>and</strong> administering financial assistance grants<br />
DNR Department of Natural<br />
Resources<br />
State Agency managing natural resources.<br />
EBP <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Bike Plan Strategic Plan identifying priorities <strong>and</strong> localities for cycleways in the<br />
<strong>Shire</strong><br />
EIS Environmental Impact Required for designated <strong>and</strong> state developments researching <strong>and</strong><br />
Statement<br />
recommending solutions to social, economic <strong>and</strong> environmental<br />
impacts<br />
EMP Estuary Management Community based plan, following scientific research of hydrology <strong>and</strong><br />
Plan<br />
hydraulics, recommending actions to preserve or enhance social,<br />
economic <strong>and</strong> environmental attributes of estuary<br />
EMS Environmental<br />
Plans prepared by council (such as waste management <strong>and</strong> strategic<br />
Management System planning) around AS<strong>14</strong>000<br />
EOI Expressions of Interest Often called in advance of selecting tenders to ascertain capacity <strong>and</strong><br />
cost of private sector performing tasks or projects on behalf of council<br />
EP&A Environment Planning State law defining types of development on private <strong>and</strong> public l<strong>and</strong>s,<br />
& Assessment Act the assessment criteria <strong>and</strong> consent authorities<br />
EPAS Environment Planning Committee of council determining referred development applications<br />
& Administrative <strong>and</strong> other matters<br />
ESD<br />
Services Committee<br />
Ecologically Sustainable Global initiative recommending balance of social, economic <strong>and</strong><br />
Development<br />
environmental values in accord with 7 ESD principles<br />
ET Equivalent Tenement Basis of calculation of dem<strong>and</strong> or impact of a single dwelling on water<br />
<strong>and</strong> sewer system<br />
FAG Financial Assistance Federal general-purpose grant direct to local government based on<br />
Grant<br />
population <strong>and</strong> other 'disability' factors<br />
FSR Floor Space Ratio A measure of bulk <strong>and</strong> scale, it is a calculation of the extent a building<br />
floor area takes up of an allotment<br />
GIS Geographic Information Computer-generated spatial mapping of l<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> attributes such as<br />
System<br />
infrastructure, slope, zoning<br />
GSAHS Greater Southern Area State board commissioned with oversight of health care in Highl<strong>and</strong>s,<br />
Health Service<br />
Monaro <strong>and</strong> Far South Coast<br />
H Division H Division Political <strong>and</strong> strategic grouping of councils along the NSW southern<br />
tablel<strong>and</strong>s, Monaro <strong>and</strong> far south coast under the umbrella of LGSA<br />
discussing local government <strong>and</strong> regional issues <strong>and</strong> resourcing sharing<br />
initiatives<br />
IPART Independent Pricing & State body that reviews statutory or government business regulatory<br />
Regulatory Tribunal frameworks <strong>and</strong> pricing levels<br />
IPWEA Institute Public <strong>Works</strong><br />
Engineers Australia<br />
Professional association<br />
IWCMS Integrated Water Cycle Council plan identifying risk <strong>and</strong> social, economic <strong>and</strong> environmental<br />
Management Strategy benefit of proposed augmentation to water, sewer <strong>and</strong> stormwater<br />
(or Plan)<br />
systems<br />
IWMS Integrated Waste Council plan identifying risk <strong>and</strong> social, economic <strong>and</strong> environmental<br />
Management<br />
benefit of proposed augmentation of waste (solids, effluent,<br />
(Minimisation) Strategy contaminated, liquid trade waste)<br />
LEP Local Environment Plan The statutory planning instrument defining the zones <strong>and</strong> objectives of<br />
urban <strong>and</strong> rural areas
LGAct Local Government Act State law defining the role of Mayor, Councillors, staff, financing,<br />
approvals etc<br />
LGA Local<br />
Authority<br />
Government<br />
LGMA Local Government Professional association<br />
LGSA<br />
Managers Australia<br />
Local Government &<br />
<strong>Shire</strong>s Association<br />
Representative advisory <strong>and</strong> advocacy group for councils in NSW<br />
MEU Ministry of Energy <strong>and</strong> State agency that subsidises, approves of proposed council water <strong>and</strong><br />
Utilities<br />
sewer augmentation<br />
MOU Memor<strong>and</strong>um of Agreement in principle between parties (eg council <strong>and</strong> agency) to<br />
Underst<strong>and</strong>ing<br />
achieve defined outcomes<br />
NPWS National Parks & Now merged into DEC<br />
Wildlife Service<br />
NRM Natural<br />
Management<br />
Resource<br />
NVC Native Vegetation<br />
Conservation Act<br />
State law defining means of protection of threatened legislation <strong>and</strong><br />
approval processes to clear l<strong>and</strong><br />
OC Occupation Certificate Issued by council or private certifier that building is safe to occupy <strong>and</strong><br />
in compliance with development conditions <strong>and</strong> BCA<br />
OSMS On site sewage Includes septic tanks, aerated systems, biocycles etc<br />
OSTF<br />
management system<br />
Our <strong>Shire</strong> the Future Brief outline of elements of shire vision<br />
PCA Principal Certifying The person or organisation appointed by applicant to inspect <strong>and</strong><br />
Authority<br />
certify structures<br />
PIA Planning<br />
Australia<br />
Institute Professional association<br />
POEO Protection of the State law outlining st<strong>and</strong>ards for emissions <strong>and</strong> discharges <strong>and</strong><br />
Environment Operations<br />
Act<br />
penalties for pollution<br />
POM Plan of Management Council plan nominating type of uses for community l<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> range of<br />
(usually for community<br />
l<strong>and</strong>)<br />
facilities progressively to be provided on l<strong>and</strong><br />
POPE Place of Public Approvals required for clubs <strong>and</strong> halls to ensure safety measures in<br />
Entertainment<br />
place for public<br />
PPP Public<br />
Partnerships<br />
Private<br />
PricingPol Pricing Policy Council approach to defining type <strong>and</strong> level of fees <strong>and</strong> charges<br />
PTS Public Transport Council strategy to initiate mechanisms to promote <strong>and</strong> facilitate public<br />
Strategy<br />
transport (bus, taxi, community transport, cycles) in design of<br />
subdivisions, developments <strong>and</strong> council works<br />
REF Review of Council examination of risk <strong>and</strong> social, economic <strong>and</strong> environmental<br />
Environmental Factors benefit of proposed works, assessed against state planning,<br />
environment <strong>and</strong> safety laws<br />
REP Regional Environment Outlines compulsory state planning objectives to be observed in<br />
Planning Policy development assessment <strong>and</strong> strategic planning<br />
RFS Rural Fire Service State agency responsible for providing equipment <strong>and</strong> training for<br />
volunteer firefighter brigades, <strong>and</strong> the assessment <strong>and</strong> approval of<br />
developments in bushfire prone l<strong>and</strong>s<br />
RLF Regional Leaders Forum The group of mayors <strong>and</strong> general managers representing the councils in<br />
the ACR<br />
RLS Rural L<strong>and</strong> Strategy<br />
RTA Roads & Traffic State agency responsible for funding, construction <strong>and</strong> maintenance of<br />
Authority<br />
state roads, the approval of council works on arterial roads <strong>and</strong><br />
development applications<br />
S64 S64 Contributions Plan Developer contributions plan to enable, with council <strong>and</strong> state funds,<br />
the augmentation of water, sewer <strong>and</strong> stormwater infrastructure
S94 S94 Contributions Plan Developer contributions to enable construction of public infrastructure<br />
<strong>and</strong> facilities such as roads, reserves, carparks, amenities etc.<br />
SCG Southern Councils Political <strong>and</strong> strategic grouping of councils along the NSW south coast<br />
Group<br />
from Wollongong to the border, lobbying government for assistance<br />
(eg Highways) <strong>and</strong> resourcing sharing initiatives<br />
SEA Strategic Environment Spatial assessment of environmental constraints of l<strong>and</strong> considered in<br />
Assessment<br />
design <strong>and</strong> assessment of subdivision <strong>and</strong> infrastructure.<br />
SEPP State Environment Outlines compulsory state planning objectives<br />
Planning Policy<br />
SOER State of the Required by state law, the comprehensive assessment (every four<br />
Environment Report years) of the condition <strong>and</strong> the pressures on the social, economic <strong>and</strong><br />
environmental features of the <strong>Shire</strong> <strong>and</strong> appropriate responses to<br />
address or preserve those issues.<br />
SP Social Plan Required by state law, the comprehensive assessment (every four<br />
years) of the condition <strong>and</strong> the pressures on the social framework of the<br />
community, their services <strong>and</strong> facilities <strong>and</strong> economic interactions<br />
…….SP Structure Plan Plan promoting l<strong>and</strong>uses <strong>and</strong> siting of infrastructure <strong>and</strong> facilities in<br />
towns (eg, BBSP – Batemans Bay Structure Plan).<br />
SRCMA Southern Rivers State agency commissioned with assessment <strong>and</strong> monitoring of health<br />
Catchment Management <strong>and</strong> qualities of catchments from Wollongong to the border, <strong>and</strong><br />
Authority<br />
determine directions <strong>and</strong> priorities for public <strong>and</strong> private investment or<br />
assistance with grants<br />
STP Sewer Treatment Plant Primary, secondary <strong>and</strong> part tertiary treatment of sewage collected<br />
from sewers before discharge into EPA approved water ways or<br />
irrigation onto l<strong>and</strong><br />
TAMS Total Asset Computer aided system recording condition <strong>and</strong> maintenance profiles<br />
Management System of infrastructure <strong>and</strong> building assets<br />
TBL Triple Bottom Line Commercial term coined to encourage business to consider <strong>and</strong><br />
disclose social <strong>and</strong> environmental risk, benefit <strong>and</strong> costs in the conduct<br />
of business to guide investors as to the long term sustainability <strong>and</strong><br />
ethics of a business. Taken up by Council to record the basis of<br />
prioritisation, the review of condition, the monitor of progress <strong>and</strong> the<br />
financial disclosure of preventative or maintenance investment in<br />
council-based social <strong>and</strong> environmental activities<br />
TOR Terms of Reference<br />
TSC Threatened Species State law governing the protection of nominated species <strong>and</strong> relevant<br />
Conservation Act assessment <strong>and</strong> development controls<br />
UDIA Urban Development Professional association<br />
ULEP<br />
Institute Australia<br />
Urban Local Statutory planning instrument (below SEPP <strong>and</strong> REP) outlining l<strong>and</strong><br />
Environment Plan uses <strong>and</strong> objectives by zone in urban areas<br />
USS Urban Settlement Council strategy prepared with assistance of government to identify<br />
Strategy<br />
best uses <strong>and</strong> re-uses of urban l<strong>and</strong>s, the appropriate siting of private<br />
<strong>and</strong> public investment (eg institutions, employment areas or high<br />
density residential) based on current <strong>and</strong> planned infrastructure <strong>and</strong><br />
l<strong>and</strong> capacity<br />
VCS Volunteer Centre Study Independent study commissioned to assess impact of earlyretirees/unemployed<br />
on labour market, their effect on social structures<br />
<strong>and</strong> mechanism to engage that group in council or commercial<br />
sponsored public good activities<br />
WCF Water Cycle Fund Combination of water, sewer <strong>and</strong> stormwater activities <strong>and</strong> their<br />
financing arrangements<br />
W & F <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> Council committee considering works activities <strong>and</strong> priorities<br />
WSUD<br />
Committee<br />
Water Sensitive Urban Principle behind the IWCMS <strong>and</strong> council development codes requiring<br />
Design<br />
new developments to reduce dem<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> waste on water resources<br />
through contemporary subdivision <strong>and</strong> building design
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
TO BE HELD AT THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS, MORUYA<br />
ON <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong><br />
COMMENCING AT 3.45PM<br />
APOLOGIES AND LEAVE OF ABSENCE<br />
CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES<br />
<strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee Meeting held on 10 October 20<strong>06</strong><br />
BUSINESS ARISING<br />
PUBLIC FORUM AND QUESTIONS FROM THE PUBLIC<br />
DEPUTATIONS<br />
Mr Steve Heffernan will address the Committee regarding Rehabilitation of Moruya River<br />
Foreshore – Glenduart (W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>6).<br />
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE FROM THE PUBLIC<br />
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE FROM COUNCILLORS Page No.<br />
PQN<strong>06</strong>/38 Questions Without Notice from Councillor 1<br />
QN<strong>06</strong>/99 Questions Without Notice from Councillor 2<br />
QN<strong>06</strong>/102 Questions Without Notice from Councillor 3<br />
QN<strong>06</strong>/104 Questions Without Notice from Councillor 4<br />
PQN<strong>06</strong>/44 Questions Without Notice from Councillor 5<br />
WPF<strong>06</strong>/20 Public Forum 6<br />
WPF<strong>06</strong>/21 Public Forum 10<br />
WQN<strong>06</strong>/66 Questions Without Notice from Councillor 13<br />
DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST<br />
MAYORAL MINUTE<br />
DELEGATES REPORTS<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW Roads Congress – Delegates Report <strong>14</strong><br />
ENVIRONMENT REPORTS<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>6 Rehabilitation of Moruya River Foreshore – Glenduart 29<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>7 Bengello Forest 35<br />
DEVELOPMENT REPORTS<br />
STRATEGIC REPORTS
GOVERNANCE REPORTS<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>8 Botanic Gardens Annual Report – 2005-<strong>06</strong> 41<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>9 Dissolution of Bodalla Ovals Management Committee 42<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/120 Dissolution of Surfside Recreational Reserve Management Cttee 44<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/121 Dissolution of Gundary Ovals Management Committee 47<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/122 Annual Reporting Requirements for Crown L<strong>and</strong> 49<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/123 Licence for Pedal Boat Hire – Corrigans Beach 52<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/124 Licence to Operate Sea Kayak Tour <strong>and</strong> Rental Business –<br />
Corrigans Beach 54<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/125 Extinguishment of Easement Within Lot 1242 DP 218665 –<br />
Tuross Head 56<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/126 Lease for Water Bores – Bodalla 58<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/127 Draft Plan of Management – Bill Smyth Reserve, Narooma<br />
Leisure Centre, Narooma Swimming Pool, NATA Oval<br />
Wagonga Inlet Foreshore Reserves & Ken Rose Park 61<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/128 Moruya Golf Course & Showground Draft Plan of Management 64<br />
COMMUNITY SERVICES REPORTS<br />
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORTS<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/129 Traffic Committee Meeting No 2 for 20<strong>06</strong>/07 held on<br />
12 October 20<strong>06</strong> 69<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/130 Grant Funding – Country Passenger Transport Infrastructure 79<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/131 Infrastructure Planning (<strong>Works</strong>) – Status Report 80<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/132 Contribution to Cost of Wooden Carving 87<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/133 Regional Resource Recovery Program 89<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/134 Southern Villages Sewerage Community Consultation 92<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/135 Water <strong>and</strong> Waste Quarterly Report 96<br />
NOTICES OF RESCISSION<br />
NOTICES OF MOTION<br />
CLOSED SESSION TO CONSIDER CONFIDENTIAL MATTERS<br />
In accordance with Section 10A(2) of the Local Government Act 1993, Council exclude<br />
members of the public from the meeting <strong>and</strong> go into Closed Session to consider the following<br />
confidential matters.<br />
In accordance with Section 10A(4) of the Local Government Act 1993 the Chairperson<br />
invites members of the public to make verbal representations to the Council on whether the<br />
meeting should be closed to consider the following matters.
CONFIDENTIAL REPORTS<br />
C<strong>06</strong>/05 L<strong>and</strong> Swap – Tilba<br />
Reason for Confidentiality<br />
This item has been classified confidential under the provisions of Section 10A(2)(d) of the<br />
Local Government Act 1993 which permits the meeting to be closed to the public for business<br />
relating to the following:<br />
(g) advice concerning litigation, or advice that would otherwise be privileged from<br />
production in legal proceedings on the ground of legal professional privilege.<br />
Council will be required to consider material in relation to current litigation proceedings <strong>and</strong><br />
if disclosed could prejudice those proceedings. Public discussion of the subject material<br />
would be contrary to the public interest as it relates to current litigation proceedings.<br />
C<strong>06</strong>/<strong>06</strong> Dedication of Bumbo Road, Bodalla<br />
Reason for Confidentiality<br />
This item has been classified confidential under the provisions of Section 10A(2)(d) of the<br />
Local Government Act 1993 which permits the meeting to be closed to the public for business<br />
relating to the following:<br />
(a) personal matters concerning particular individuals.<br />
Council will be required to consider material in relation the proposed negotiations with<br />
individuals. Public discussion of the subject material would be contrary to the public interest<br />
as it relates to proposed negotiations.<br />
CONFIDENTIAL BRIEFINGS<br />
Reason for Confidentiality<br />
This item has been classified as confidential under the provisions of Section 10A(2)(a-h) as<br />
the General Manager is required to brief Councillors from time to time on confidential matters<br />
of an urgent nature.<br />
Discussion of the material would be contrary to the public interest for reasons relating to one<br />
or more of the matters prescribed by the Local Government Act 1993 Section 10A(2)(a-h).<br />
(a) personnel matters concerning particular individuals; or<br />
(b) the personal hardship of any resident or ratepayer; or<br />
(c) information that would, if disclosed, confer a commercial advantage on a person with<br />
whom the council is conducting (or proposes to conduct) business; or<br />
(d) commercial information of a confidential nature that would, if disclosed:<br />
i) prejudice the commercial position of the person who supplied it, or<br />
ii) confer a commercial advantage on a competitor of the council, or<br />
iii) reveal a trade secret,<br />
(e) information that would, if disclosed, prejudice the maintenance of law; or<br />
(f) matters affecting the security of the council, councillors, council staff or council property;<br />
or
(g) advice concerning litigation, or advice that would otherwise be privileged from<br />
production in legal proceedings on the ground of legal professional privilege; or<br />
(h) information concerning the nature <strong>and</strong> location of a place or an item of Aboriginal<br />
significance on community l<strong>and</strong>.<br />
DECLASSIFICATION OF REPORTS – Council’s policy requires consideration of the<br />
declassification.<br />
BRIEFING BY STAFF<br />
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE FROM COUNCILLORS<br />
J F LEVY<br />
GENERAL MANAGER<br />
All Councillors are members of this Committee. The Chairperson is Councillor Pollock.
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 1<br />
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE FROM COUNCILLOR <strong>06</strong>.0041; 91.2122<br />
Environment Planning <strong>and</strong> Administrative Services held on 5 September 20<strong>06</strong><br />
PQN<strong>06</strong>/38<br />
Councillor Thomson said the Local Emergency Management Committee’s had requested the<br />
State Government should coordinate communications channels between emergency<br />
organisations. None of these organisations could communicate with the State Emergency<br />
Service or the Police. Councillor Thomson said that the <strong>Works</strong> Manager should pursue this<br />
with the State Government.<br />
Reply<br />
This matter will be referred to the Local Emergency Management Committee for discussion.
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 2<br />
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE FROM COUNCILLOR <strong>06</strong>.0041; 05.9616<br />
Ordinary Council Meeting held on 26 September 20<strong>06</strong><br />
QN<strong>06</strong>/99<br />
Councillor Pollock called for an update on the Bill Smyth Oval project. He indicated that the<br />
Briefing Notes to Councillors indicate that the design work for Bill Smyth Oval was<br />
progressing <strong>and</strong> that everyone was happy but letters have been received from residents that<br />
this is not the case.<br />
The Mayor advised that the Group Manager, Roads <strong>and</strong> Recreation would provide a briefing<br />
to the next meeting <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee Meeting.<br />
Reply<br />
A report on the Bill Smyth Oval project was considered at the last <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong><br />
Committee meeting held on 10 October 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
A deputation was received from the President of the Narooma Rugby League Association.<br />
Council resolved that:<br />
1. Council proceed with constructing the new Bill Smyth Amenities Building in the current<br />
location.<br />
2. Council seek further comment on the proposal to widen the Bill Smyth Rugby League<br />
field during the exhibition of the draft Plan of Management in the coming months.
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 3<br />
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE FROM COUNCILLOR <strong>06</strong>.0041; 03.7823<br />
Ordinary Meeting of Council held on 26 September 20<strong>06</strong><br />
QN<strong>06</strong>/102<br />
Councillor Kowal asked if the footpath between the Post Office <strong>and</strong> the Bakery at Bodalla<br />
could be inspected as it needs urgent attention.<br />
The Deputy General Manager advised that an inspection of the area would be organised.<br />
Reply<br />
It is proposed to install a concrete footpath in the area in the 20<strong>06</strong>/07 financial year.<br />
<strong>Works</strong> are currently scheduled for completion prior to Christmas 20<strong>06</strong>.
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 4<br />
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE FROM COUNCILLOR <strong>06</strong>.0041; 98.24<strong>14</strong><br />
Ordinary Council Meeting held on 26 September 20<strong>06</strong><br />
QN<strong>06</strong>/104<br />
Councillor Morton, on behalf of the Duty Manager at the Batemans Bay Pool, asked if the<br />
trees overshadowing the building could be lopped. He indicated that the primary source of<br />
heating for the pool is solar <strong>and</strong> the trees are causing overshadowing. Leaves are also<br />
blowing into the pool <strong>and</strong> causing drama with the pool pumps.<br />
Councillor Morton also indicated that the Shade Cover over the Baby Pool had lost its UV<br />
protection <strong>and</strong> could something be done. Further the pool was broken into recently <strong>and</strong><br />
repairs needed to be undertaken to the fence. He asked if these matters could be attended to.<br />
The Deputy General Manager took the question on notice.<br />
Reply<br />
Council staff have programmed the pruning of the overshadowing trees through a local tree<br />
removal company. This work was completed week ending Friday 27 October 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
The shading from the trees currently affect the solar heating from mid-afternoon to dusk,<br />
whereas the primary heating time of solar for the pool is early morning to mid-afternoon.<br />
Pruning of the trees may not reduce wind blown leaves from entering the pool.<br />
The shade cover over the tiered seating was replaced during the closure of the Batemans Bay<br />
Pool due to damage to the cover.<br />
Assessment of the cover of the baby pool has indicated that it will be due for replacement in<br />
the near future due to deterioration. However, in its current state, the cover still retains its<br />
UV protection capacity.<br />
Repairs to the barbed wire fence were completed week ending Friday 27 October 20<strong>06</strong>.
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 5<br />
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE FROM COUNCILLOR <strong>06</strong>.0041; 98.2369<br />
Environment, Planning <strong>and</strong> Administrative Services Committee Meeting held on<br />
3 October 20<strong>06</strong><br />
PQN<strong>06</strong>/44<br />
Councillor Brown referred to the Tuross Cycleway. He asked if a large section of this<br />
cycleway had been removed <strong>and</strong> redone, <strong>and</strong>, if so why did it occur <strong>and</strong> how much extra did it<br />
cost?<br />
The matter was taken on notice <strong>and</strong> will be referred to the <strong>Works</strong> Manager.<br />
Reply<br />
A short length of shared pathway was removed as it was constructed out of alignment by the<br />
volunteer group.<br />
This additional work cost an estimated $1,800, which was part funded by the Tuross Progress<br />
Association.
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 6<br />
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE FROM PUBLIC <strong>06</strong>.0042; 04.8820<br />
<strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee Meeting held on 10 October 20<strong>06</strong><br />
The following questions were taken on notice from Mrs Morley. The responses are shown in<br />
italics following the questions.<br />
WPF<strong>06</strong>/20<br />
Councillors, our workers have brought to my attention some facts about the Bypass <strong>and</strong> felt<br />
that it was worth sharing with you. So, to my favourite topic the Bypass <strong>and</strong> Surf Beach<br />
Avenue which was classified as a major road <strong>and</strong> mentioned as such once again on 30 March<br />
20<strong>06</strong>. Major roads are to be protected as through traffic routes from the effects of traffic<br />
generating development, the primary role is to be safe <strong>and</strong> efficient transport routes.<br />
The Urban LEP, No. 63 states:<br />
“A major road means any main road or arterial road or any other road which in the opinion of<br />
the Council, carries or is likely to carry a significant volume of vehicular traffic.”<br />
(At latest count Surf Beach Avenue 2,800vpd.)<br />
If you turn to Page 4 of today’s agenda, “34 What are the objectives of the road zones?” You<br />
will see that it is mentioned again.<br />
So we ask is it really consistent with the Urban LEP to cut a major road, Surf Beach Avenue<br />
when its function is a through traffic route?<br />
In Clause 34 of the Urban LEP three objectives are listed for the road zones. The first of<br />
these objectives is “to identify existing <strong>and</strong> future major roads to reinforce the hierarchy of<br />
roads in the area of <strong>Eurobodalla</strong>”. Clearly the proposed intersection arrangements reinforce<br />
<strong>and</strong> even re-establish the hierarchy of roads with George Bass Drive being the major arterial<br />
road <strong>and</strong> lower Surf Beach Avenue returning to its function of a residential collector road.<br />
You will also be interested to know that in a report to <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Meeting March<br />
2004 the total revised cost of the construction of the Spine Road <strong>and</strong> Bypass was $10,812,000<br />
with a built in contingency factor of 20%, $1802 indicating that the cost was only $9,010,000.<br />
There were 4 costings of the 15 that are of extreme interest that were allocated to the Surf<br />
Beach area, which indicates that in 2004 there was still to be an intersection at Surf Beach<br />
Avenue <strong>and</strong> the bypass.<br />
If Surf Beach Avenue was to be cut, where is the costing for the proposed Link Access Road?<br />
The extract of the report presented by Mrs Morley included a table entitled “Details of<br />
Estimate – Spine Road”. Amongst the items listed in that table was the following:<br />
“270,000 Spine Road to Surfbeach Avenue<br />
100,000 New Surfbeach Avenue intersection”.<br />
Both these items refer to the Link Road connecting the Spine Road to Surf Beach Avenue <strong>and</strong><br />
the intersection of the Link Road <strong>and</strong> the Bypass.
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 7<br />
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE FROM PUBLIC <strong>06</strong>.0042; 04.8820<br />
How come there is a costing for an intersection in 2004 when many Council people have<br />
stated that the road was to be cut in 1996? Was this a fabrication? Two people who attended<br />
that public meeting in 1996 told me that they certainly don’t remember it being mentioned.<br />
The Link Road will need an intersection to the Bypass in order to function. It is unfortunate<br />
that there seems to be some confusion about the description of the item which is clearly<br />
identified in the 2004 report as “Spine Road to Surf Beach Avenue” <strong>and</strong> the Link Road<br />
(which will become part of Surf Beach Avenue) which are both the same piece of road.<br />
Does this explain why the ESC web-site had not been changed to show the Link Road as it<br />
was only a suggestion by staff?<br />
The map on the ESC website shows the Link Road.<br />
Was the recommendation to close Surf Beach Avenue listed as under delegated authority also<br />
made up especially for the Council meeting of 13 June 20<strong>06</strong>?<br />
The <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee has delegated authority from Council to deal with<br />
certain matters. These delegations are available on the website. Recommendations to the<br />
<strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee are therefore phrased to call up the Committee’s delegated<br />
authority.<br />
If this is not so, where was it indicated before <strong>and</strong> would you please show me what page, date<br />
<strong>and</strong> agenda it was in before?<br />
The report presented to the <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee meeting of 13 June 20<strong>06</strong> was<br />
written to be presented to that meeting <strong>and</strong> had not been previously presented to another<br />
Council meeting.<br />
In July, Mr Parkinson, stated that: “Council has prepared estimates for the whole of the<br />
project. To respond to you enquiry relating to the cost to construct between Surf Beach<br />
Avenue <strong>and</strong> Beach Road would require further investigation.”<br />
Don’t these statements now contradict each other, or was this another “oversight”?<br />
No oversight.<br />
The separate costings had been completed, at least in 2004.<br />
Wouldn’t similar methods of costings be prepared the same way in 20<strong>06</strong>?<br />
Yes.
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 8<br />
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE FROM PUBLIC <strong>06</strong>.0042; 04.8820<br />
By the ESC Spring Newsletter the overall project cost for completion had risen to an<br />
estimated cost of $17.4M.<br />
I realise bananas have risen exponentially due to a hurricane, but road costs surely haven’t<br />
increased 61% in two years, have they?<br />
Road construction costs have risen at a rate much greater than CPI. However, in this case<br />
the largest cause of increased costs is changes in the scope of the works to be undertaken, in<br />
particular relating to the intersection with the Princes Highway.<br />
Mr Levy assured Council 22 August that he had complete faith in his engineer’s figures.<br />
Maybe someone can explain these apparent anomalies?<br />
Because by 22 August, Mr Levy made the comment:<br />
“One dollar more that the cheapest option is too much,” he said, adding, “he was nervous<br />
about the $20 million cost of the project”. (Bay Post 25 August 20<strong>06</strong>). So in two years <strong>and</strong> 5<br />
months the cost had increased by 85%.<br />
Isn’t it time for an independent Road Construction Company such as Armpell was asked to<br />
quote for the complete Spine Road <strong>and</strong> Bypass including a bridge overpass over Surf Beach<br />
Avenue <strong>and</strong> even a safer connection at the Princes Highway? This cost will be saved <strong>and</strong><br />
redeemed if they quote for under $20 million <strong>and</strong> we will then know accurate costings at<br />
today’s rates, not just engineer’s estimates that are not accurate.<br />
Seeking a quote from a road construction company at this point would be akin to asking a<br />
builder for a price to build a house without supplying plans. The accuracy of any quote at<br />
this time would be so poor as to render the figure useless. Notwithst<strong>and</strong>ing the above advice,<br />
it would also contravene the Local Government tendering regulations.<br />
How can you accept a cost estimate that has basically doubled in two years?<br />
If this was private enterprise they would all be out of a job. The scary aspect of it all is that<br />
Council is contemplating Public Private Partnerships, what is going to happen then?<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council is known throughout Australia as one of the few Councils that has<br />
successfully used Public Private Partnerships to successfully deliver infrastructure for the<br />
community.<br />
Residents Opposing Surf Beach Avenue Closure (ROSBAC) feels there have already been<br />
enough oversights <strong>and</strong> incompetencies.<br />
The bypass can be built for less, including a 20M bridge overpass for Surf Beach Avenue for<br />
a two lane bypass. A four lane bypass is not required for twenty years.<br />
The residents need answers, when do we get a public meeting?<br />
Councillors why aren’t you dem<strong>and</strong>ing an enquiry into oversights <strong>and</strong> incompetencies <strong>and</strong><br />
broken government laws as well as cost increases of 85%.
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 9<br />
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE FROM PUBLIC <strong>06</strong>.0042; 04.8820<br />
Please, will you take a st<strong>and</strong> before more money is wasted, more flora <strong>and</strong> fauna destroyed<br />
<strong>and</strong> further mistakes made that cannot be rectified?<br />
Councillors we need safe road, not economic rationalist’s speedways to the Surf Beach<br />
Industrial Park. The Government Grant is for the Bypass <strong>and</strong> not for link roads to the<br />
Industrial Park, or RTA overtaking lanes on the Princes Highway.
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 10<br />
QUESTIONS WITH NOTICE FROM PUBLIC <strong>06</strong>.0042; 04.8820<br />
<strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee Meeting held on 10 October 20<strong>06</strong><br />
The following questions were taken on notice from Mr Dunbar. The responses are shown in<br />
italics following the questions.<br />
WFF<strong>06</strong>/21<br />
Council staff do not keep Councillors updated with correct information. Council staff do not<br />
appear to read reports that have been commissioned previously!<br />
ESC Residential Urban Maps, Postal Address Maps etc at Administration Counter do not<br />
even show a dotted line for proposed Bypass, maps printed in January 20<strong>06</strong>!<br />
Council produces a large variety of maps for many specific purposes. Some such as sewer<br />
maps show the location of physical infrastructure such as pipes, others such as zoning maps<br />
identify future l<strong>and</strong> uses. The zoning maps for the Urban LEP clearly show the bypass route<br />
as zoned 5b – Arterial Road.<br />
Why was there complete silence for the community on what was happening with the Surf<br />
Beach Industrial Park the first official mention in ESC Spring Newsletter September 20<strong>06</strong>?<br />
This statement is clearly incorrect. In fact, Mrs Morley speaking before Mr Dunbar at the<br />
meeting drew attention to the report to the <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee meeting on<br />
9 March 2004 regarding the options for the Surf Beach Industrial L<strong>and</strong>.<br />
It was advertised in Sydney Morning Herald 8 July 20<strong>06</strong>, <strong>and</strong> not advertised locally, why?<br />
Given that this matter was reported on by the local press, Council chose to target advertising<br />
toward potential purchasers in the broader market.<br />
For Sale by Expression of Interest showed private l<strong>and</strong> for future development stages in<br />
Sydney Morning Herald, page 63 which included the Baptist Church <strong>and</strong> five other private<br />
properties. Lines drawn around properties on aerial view map which also included roads over<br />
some of these properties. Why was there no official retraction?<br />
This matter has been previously addressed with Council <strong>and</strong> the l<strong>and</strong>owners concerned.<br />
Why is it so difficult for Council to answer questions on the costs of closure of Surf Beach<br />
Avenue?<br />
Why were there no postal surveys, which are requirements of Traffic Guidelines for closure of<br />
road? If one disadvantage, alternatives should be considered. There were nine disadvantages.<br />
Residents Opposing Surf Beach Avenue Closure (ROSBAC) costed a bridge for Surf Beach<br />
Avenue, as Council stated that a bridge would cost $3-4 million. Council at a later date<br />
confirmed that ROSBAC should cost a bridge which they did.<br />
The ROSBAC group were not allowed to present revised costings due to the wrong<br />
measurements being given by Council staff to the ROSBAC engineer, for example: spans<br />
went from 30 metres to 36 metres. Then no piers, finally at a 20 metre span.
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page <strong>11</strong><br />
QUESTIONS WITH NOTICE FROM PUBLIC <strong>06</strong>.0042; 04.8820<br />
Options were presented to ROSBAC <strong>and</strong> again to Councillors <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong><br />
Committee Meeting 8 August. Why wasn’t everybody addressed together, this would have<br />
saved wasting three engineer’s time for 28 July <strong>and</strong> again for <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> meeting?<br />
Oversight of engineers to research all possible bridge options. Nine companies build bridges<br />
<strong>and</strong> instead of selecting a cost effective option they select a massive structure that was built<br />
over the Pacific Highway on the North Coast. Why? A single span bridge over the bypass<br />
will cost approximately $800,000. Why didn’t Council find a similar costing?<br />
Why was there overdesigning <strong>and</strong> overcosting for bridge design BEBO arches, two/30 metre<br />
long tunnels on Bypass with a 36 metre cutting for a two lane Surf Beach Avenue for<br />
overpass? The Surf Beach Avenue road really would only need to be a 10 metre wide road.<br />
Why was staff designing for a four lane bypass at Surf Beach, two northbound, two<br />
southbound when supposed to be designing for a two lane bypass when four lanes not<br />
required for twenty years?<br />
Why did l<strong>and</strong> acquisition for bridge option C start at $50,000 July 28 <strong>and</strong> by August 25 had<br />
risen to $300,000?<br />
The costing of a bridge will be far more cost effective than the option that Council are going<br />
with directed by staff for a link access road!<br />
Why would Engineers not admit to new proposed roads entering the link road from the Light<br />
Industrial Park July 28?<br />
Four proposed roads join up with Garbage Tip access road <strong>and</strong> will also join the Link Road!<br />
With the Bypass being constructed ten metres below the present road surface, barriers <strong>and</strong><br />
fences will need to be constructed to stop pedestrians <strong>and</strong> cars from into the Bypass. Where is<br />
provision for pedestrians to walk over the Bypass?<br />
Mr Parkinson came up with the brilliant suggestion that pedestrians could walk down Kauzal<br />
Crescent to the fourth house, walk through the reserve (actually a drainage ditch) <strong>and</strong> through<br />
the Bypass, over the Bypass <strong>and</strong> through another road reserve to Eric Fenning Drive on the<br />
east <strong>and</strong> back up to Surf Beach Avenue. Is this very convenient for people trying to catch a<br />
bus?<br />
The above matters mirror previous questions from Mrs Morley <strong>and</strong> as such have been<br />
previously addressed.<br />
If the original motion on 13 June about Surf Beach Avenue had two parts is it correct to only<br />
bring up one part <strong>and</strong> leave the second part out?<br />
The motion of 13 June 20<strong>06</strong> was that the issue be deferred. The original recommendation<br />
from staff was that pedestrian usage be further investigated to decide whether a bridge was<br />
warranted. This recommendation was not adopted by Council.<br />
The figures for traffic using Surf Beach Avenue was incorrect
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 12<br />
QUESTIONS WITH NOTICE FROM PUBLIC <strong>06</strong>.0042; 04.8820<br />
Average daily use of Surf Beach Avenue 2,800vpd at Beach Road<br />
Surf Beach Avenue at western end of SBA 997 vpd<br />
Surf Beach Avenue at Timber Way 1680 vpd<br />
Andrew Parkinson stated only 1000 would use the Link Road.<br />
Why is residential traffic being diverted to go through an industrial area?<br />
Why would a Council encourage industrial traffic to go through residential areas?<br />
What is Council’s hidden agenda?<br />
Surf Beach Avenue (lower section) is currently carrying heavy vehicles from Beach Road to<br />
the rural section. The construction of the Link Road will remove these heavy vehicles from<br />
the urban areas. There is no proposal on the table that would result in residential traffic<br />
being diverted through an industrial area. Council’s hidden agenda in this instance is to<br />
improve the amenity <strong>and</strong> reduce traffic impacts on the urban residents of Surf Beach Avenue.
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 13<br />
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE FROM COUNCILLOR <strong>06</strong>.0041; 00.4085<br />
<strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee Meeting held on 10 October 20<strong>06</strong><br />
WQN<strong>06</strong>/66<br />
Cr Brown asked with regard to the Bay Stages Rally. How much is the total money received<br />
from the organisers of the Rally.<br />
Taken on notice.<br />
Reply<br />
As noted on Page 7 of the <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee <strong>Agenda</strong> on 10 October 20<strong>06</strong>, 68<br />
vehicles competed in the Rally at a cost of $15.00 per vehicle.<br />
We were previously advised that 68 vehicles had competed in the event, however the payment<br />
made by the Rally organisers reflects that 69 vehicles competed in the event. Therefore, the<br />
total amount received was $1,035.
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page <strong>14</strong><br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
The following brief summary of information is provided from the NSW Roads Congress for<br />
the information of Council.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
The inaugural NSW Roads Congress was held in 2005, allowing presentation of information,<br />
including the NSW Roads & Transport Directorate’s Road Benchmarking Reports, sharing of<br />
ideas <strong>and</strong> setting of directions by Councillors <strong>and</strong> staff.<br />
Much of this information then fed directly into the Local Government Sustainability Report<br />
authored by Professor Percy Allen.<br />
Councillor Rob Pollock, Chair of the <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee, <strong>and</strong> Warren Sharpe,<br />
Group Manager Roads <strong>and</strong> Recreation Services attended the 20<strong>06</strong> NSW Roads Congress on<br />
16 & 17 October 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
ISSUES<br />
Day One<br />
Welcome & Opening – John Truman, President NSW Institute of Public <strong>Works</strong> &<br />
Engineering (IPWEA)<br />
All <strong>11</strong>2 delegates welcomed. Emphasised that it was very important to get feedback from the<br />
delegates, in particular the elected representative to assist in setting directions for the next<br />
12 months.<br />
John Truman is also represented on the NSW Roads & Transport Directorate.<br />
Infrastructure Management Session<br />
Councillor Barry Johnston, representing Local Government <strong>Shire</strong>s Association<br />
Infrastructure Taskforce<br />
Councillor Johnston provided a brief overview of activities <strong>and</strong> a summary of some of the<br />
work done so far, in particular the Professor Allen report into the sustainability of local<br />
government.<br />
This report was jointly funded by LGSA & the LGA. It has set a benchmark for the<br />
assessment of local government.<br />
Some findings:<br />
• 25% of Councils financially unsustainable, 50% are marginal<br />
• 165,000km of local roads & 18,000km of regional roads under local government control<br />
in NSW<br />
• $6.3B backlog of works increasing at $500M per year (really figure may be even<br />
higher)
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 15<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
• most Councils have not revalued their assets <strong>and</strong> do not have formal asset management<br />
plans in place<br />
• increase in rates fall well below the increase in gross domestic product (GDP)<br />
• NSW is the only State in Australia where the State does not pass on a component of the<br />
Goods & Services Tax (GST) made available to them by the Federal Government<br />
• the Federal Government’s Roads to Recovery Program has been a “godsend”, but it is<br />
not guaranteed to continue, it is not enough <strong>and</strong> it is not indexed<br />
• survey of NSW residents indicates that roads topped the list of things people are least<br />
satisfied with<br />
August 20<strong>06</strong> – Local Government Sustainability Taskforce was created. It includes political,<br />
engineering <strong>and</strong> managers representation as this issue requires a collective approach to<br />
address it properly. The taskforce is working on:<br />
• prioritisation of the 49 recommendations from the Percy Allen report;<br />
• creation of working parties for specific areas;<br />
• development of an inter-government agreement between local government <strong>and</strong> State<br />
Government leading into the 2007 State elections;<br />
• improved financial reporting required to assist in supporting case;<br />
• development of a communications strategy – including business <strong>and</strong> community<br />
forums;<br />
• good levels of cooperation with State Government to date.<br />
Percy Allen report:<br />
• bring about a change in local government<br />
• recommended that local government should increase loans for infrastructure renewal<br />
• remember the figures in the Allen report excludes consideration of growth <strong>and</strong> costs<br />
necessary to meet changing expectations of the community. Both of these are<br />
significant, particularly in growth areas<br />
2007 State election strategy includes a number of issues, but notably:<br />
• regional road timber bridge program – backed by Liberals but not by Labour currently;<br />
• regional road block grant – not currently keeping pace with costs <strong>and</strong> there is a risk of<br />
the current State Government transferring additional State roads to a regional status<br />
without providing any additional funding into the overall pool of funds. Working on this<br />
issue with both parties.<br />
Ross Woodward, Deputy Director General Department of Local Government, Chair of<br />
the DLG Infrastructure Taskforce<br />
Ross agreed to discuss concepts being discussed currently openly. This is great to see <strong>and</strong><br />
provides an insight into to early thoughts from the DLG with opportunities for further<br />
discussion.<br />
The infrastructure funding shortfall is the number one issue facing local government today.
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 16<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
Lack of formal asset management planning is a major gap in NSW local government which<br />
must be addressed. A lot has happened this year including:<br />
• May 20<strong>06</strong><br />
- IPWEA Conference 20<strong>06</strong><br />
- Ministerial Round Table<br />
- Local Government Inquiry – Allen report<br />
• July 20<strong>06</strong> - NSW DLG Taskforce formed<br />
• August 20<strong>06</strong><br />
- recommendation of the Ministerial Round Table accepted<br />
- National approach required<br />
- More Federal funding required to assist with the gap<br />
- Asset Management -> Financial Reporting -> Sustainability<br />
• October 20<strong>06</strong> - Local Government & Planning Ministers hope to sign off on a position<br />
• DLG Taskforce includes DLG, LGSA, LGA, IPWEA, LGMA, RTA, DUES, LG<br />
Auditors<br />
• System will be developed to advise Asset Management in Local Government for NSW<br />
Current gaps (Statewide):<br />
• no requirement for asset management system<br />
• reporting inconsistent<br />
• service level not determined<br />
• inconsistent National approach to asset management<br />
Suggested way forward:<br />
• Asset Management Policy (State)<br />
• Strategic Plan<br />
• Asset Management Plan/Long Term Financial Plan<br />
• improved governance <strong>and</strong> management<br />
• defining level of service (more consistent basis)<br />
• data <strong>and</strong> systems management<br />
• development of skills <strong>and</strong> processes<br />
• evaluation <strong>and</strong> review<br />
NSW DLG is suggesting we scrap the way we currently do things <strong>and</strong> start with a fresh<br />
approach. Discussion paper coming out shortly.
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 17<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
Early suggestion for discussion is:<br />
• Long term strategic plan (minimum 10 years) – a Community Futures Plan (for want of<br />
a better term) with strong links to formal asset management plans based on whole of life<br />
analysis.<br />
• Delivery Program (4 year plan) – suggesting this would require feedback from other<br />
agencies including the Department of Planning. (Comment: This is a significant<br />
concern given the lack of resources <strong>and</strong> the difficulty getting information from the<br />
Department of Planning already. This concern was shared by many at the Congress.)<br />
• Operational Plan (the budget for next year) - annual plan.<br />
• Annual Report – reporting against objective of all plans.<br />
DLG wants to build capacity within local government. It does not want a consultant “drop <strong>and</strong><br />
go” approach.<br />
Draft State Government Framework:<br />
• needs enabling legislation<br />
• phased in with supporting tools<br />
• asset management plans linked to long term financial plans (min 10 years)<br />
• service levels defined within Community Future Plan<br />
• underlying assumptions well explained<br />
• st<strong>and</strong>ardised reporting <strong>and</strong> terminology<br />
• peer review by other Councils of plans (note: this would require significant additional<br />
resources to achieve – possible cost shift??)<br />
• improved knowledge, information <strong>and</strong> management will assist with arguments with the<br />
Commonwealth<br />
Next Step – Discussion Paper due out pre-Christmas. This is a separate paper to the<br />
discussion paper on Strategic L<strong>and</strong>-Use Planning but will be run in parallel.<br />
The draft concept of Council’s Management Plan being subject to peer review <strong>and</strong>/or review<br />
by the Department of Planning is of significant concern. It is likely to require significant<br />
additional resources <strong>and</strong> may potentially lead to delays. Council staff have been asked to<br />
review the discussion paper when it becomes available <strong>and</strong> submit a report to Council for<br />
consideration.<br />
Chris Champion, National CEO – Institute of Public <strong>Works</strong> & Engineering Australia<br />
(IPWEA)<br />
IPWEA doing a large amount of work to support local government’s cause. This includes:<br />
• NSW Roads & Transport Directorate<br />
• Roads Benchmarking Reports 2005 (led into Percy Allen report)<br />
• Local Government Sustainability Report – detailed submissions made<br />
• Participation in the Local Government Infrastructure Taskforce<br />
• Production of the International Infrastructure Management Manual 20<strong>06</strong> (IIMM now<br />
sold in Australia, NZ, USA, Canada, South Africa <strong>and</strong> the UK)
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 18<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
• National Asset Management group – NAMS.AU:<br />
- includes finance managers <strong>and</strong> engineers<br />
- see web for sample asset management plan<br />
- quarterly newsletter coming soon<br />
- supported by consultants to ensure on-going funding<br />
- provide “Assetmates” forum for practitioners<br />
- NAMS helping with other states too – Victoria step program, Queensl<strong>and</strong> Local<br />
Government Asset, TAMI, WAMI & SA programs<br />
• IPWEA seeking consistent approach to asset management<br />
• Requires whole of organisation participation<br />
• Two ways to go for government – legislation vs carrot & stick approach<br />
• Requires more tool <strong>and</strong> capacity building across the industry<br />
• South Australian experience may serve some benefit for a way forward:<br />
- legislation in place requiring 10 year financial plan based on formal asset<br />
management plans<br />
- adopted the IIMM as State framework<br />
- commissioned IPWEA to lead<br />
- involved focus groups<br />
- IPWEA developed templates <strong>and</strong> guidelines<br />
- includes a capacity building program<br />
- pilot testing now imminent<br />
- integrates technical, financial <strong>and</strong> political processes<br />
- long term financial plans (LTFP) based on formal asset management plans (AMPs)<br />
- leads to elected officials being provided with better information on which to base<br />
their decisions<br />
• IPWEA promoting Sustainable Communities:<br />
- Councillors have a stewardship role to ensure their communities remain viable for<br />
the long term<br />
- managing existing assets as well as providing new<br />
- LTFPs are an essential part of Council business<br />
- stewardship role – DVD has been produced <strong>and</strong> will be made available to all<br />
Australian Councils. Aimed at elected members <strong>and</strong> includes political, engineering<br />
<strong>and</strong> financial perspectives:<br />
need to comprehend the whole of life costs of assets – the initial cost is usually the<br />
smallest proportion – sometimes less than 20%<br />
must move from annual budgeting to LTFPs<br />
need to prepare “core” AMP based on whole of life or min 20 years analysis of<br />
assets, then develop a 10 year financial plan<br />
use the International Infrastructure Management Manual for these plans<br />
• Core AMP – basic AMP – very good starting point. Top down approach. Assume<br />
current level of service, use to development forward replacement programs.<br />
• Advanced AMP - requires more detailed analysis of assets on an individual basis.<br />
Greater levels of community consultation. Agreed levels of service. Optimised decision<br />
making. Very good goal. NZ experience indicates the process can become lengthy <strong>and</strong><br />
costly if bogged down in excessive public consultation. Councillors will need to decide<br />
how much consultation is appropriate <strong>and</strong> affordable.
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 19<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
• AMPs include:<br />
- best information currently available to each Council<br />
- simple risk assessment – do not get too complicated in first run through<br />
- gap analysis<br />
- provision for growth<br />
- analysis of remaining life – can be simple network or complicated – start simple <strong>and</strong><br />
improve with time<br />
- establishment of renewal costs<br />
- projections of required cash flow<br />
- identification of improvement program for asset management including capacity<br />
building<br />
• IPWEA AMP templates being piloted in South Australia where South Australia<br />
Councils required to have “core” AMP by July 2007.<br />
• New National Accounting Guidelines being worked on – refer NAMS.AU web-site.<br />
Optimising Service Delivery<br />
Murray Russell,– Coonamble <strong>Shire</strong> Council – A Road Asset Management Plan<br />
Murray provided an overview of a road asset management plan put together for his Council.<br />
This is a “core” plan <strong>and</strong> uses the same approach used by this Council in preparing its budget<br />
<strong>and</strong> case for the Infrastructure Fund.<br />
Greg Moxon, DOTARS<br />
Auslink for local government identifies the following sources of funds:<br />
• Strategic Funds – Roads to Recovery<br />
• Black Spot Program<br />
• Roads to Recovery<br />
Roads to Recovery:<br />
• 15,000 projects to date<br />
• extra $308M late 2005/<strong>06</strong><br />
• Council must make sure they spend their original R2R funds first<br />
• several years to spend extra R2R<br />
• new web-site reporting by end of year – information goes directly back to Federal<br />
Government – important it is completed accurately <strong>and</strong> on time<br />
• local government must maintain or increase its own expenditure on roads, exclusive of<br />
R2R<br />
• st<strong>and</strong>ards of reports across industry needs to be improved<br />
• Councils must now show their historical expenditure on roads in their R2R reports –<br />
signed off by the auditor<br />
• Councils need to calculate a reference amount for Council expenditure – see criteria<br />
• projects under $10k do not need individual signs but all others must have signs<br />
• once funds paid to Council, Council has six months to spend same. All interest earnt on<br />
R2R should be spent on roads.
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 20<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
• DOTARs will audit 20-25 Councils per year<br />
• seven Councils audited in July. Results of audit were poor, especially the lack of<br />
knowledge about maintaining Council funding levels being m<strong>and</strong>atory<br />
• many Councils doing right thing – some excellent results on the ground<br />
• for continuation of funding from Federal Government:<br />
- Councils must maintain/increase their road funding<br />
- demonstrate a strong collective case/need<br />
Murray Brown, GM Strategic Development – <strong>Works</strong> Infrastructure Pty Ltd<br />
Alternate Funding for Roads<br />
Infrastructure <strong>Works</strong> is a company that starts from the NZ equivalent of the RTA. Now a<br />
multi-national service provider.<br />
Murray discussed his experience in Victoria whereby his company borrowed funds to upgrade<br />
Council roads <strong>and</strong> then Council engaged his company for a 15 year period to maintain the<br />
roads. This requires Council to commit to an annual payment plus contract variations for that<br />
timeframe.<br />
Jason Gordon, Director of Engineering & Technical Services – Cabonne <strong>Shire</strong> Council<br />
Jason provided an outline of the alliance between Wellington, Blayney <strong>and</strong> Cabonne Councils<br />
for the delivery of the Single Invitation Contract to the RTA. This alliance operates under a<br />
board arrangement with members from all three Councils, with a legal agreement in place.<br />
Cabonne Council is the lead Council with Blayney & Wellington Councils also forming part<br />
of the alliance. Cabonne undertakes the administration of the contract <strong>and</strong> charges a 5%<br />
overhead on prices from Wellington & Blayney Councils to cover this cost. The RTA only<br />
has to deal with “one” contractor, delivering administrative savings to the State.<br />
Each Council still does their own work within their own <strong>Shire</strong>s. Some future resource sharing<br />
may be possible. This arrangement suits these small Councils as they can now afford a single<br />
roads inspector, releasing qualified engineers for other more important tasks.<br />
Note: At <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> we have combined our RTA work with our local/regional roadwork to<br />
provide a roads inspector <strong>and</strong> maintenance planner. In effect, an internal alliance. This allows<br />
for improved management of all road assets, including the RTAs. We have indicated to the<br />
RTA that we are not supportive of forming an alliance with Palerang <strong>Shire</strong> Council, due to the<br />
additional administration that would follow from Council, <strong>and</strong> the geographical issues<br />
associated with the Clyde Mountain.<br />
Nevertheless, there may be other areas in the State where this proposal offers similar<br />
advantages to the alliance as outlined by Jason Gordon.
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 21<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
Les Wiellinga, CEO RTA<br />
Les has recently been appointed to the position of CEO of the RTA following recent<br />
controversy on the roads portfolio. “Building Infrastructure in the City is a Tough Game”<br />
Les is an engineer of some 34 years experience in road building.<br />
Les is bringing about a shift in the RTA. He is re-engineering the RTA to deliver work. This<br />
includes a restructuring of the RTA with less bureaucracy <strong>and</strong> more personnel suited to<br />
delivering works, including qualified engineers <strong>and</strong> other specialists.<br />
The new structure generally has four main areas:<br />
• major infrastructure<br />
• road maintenance <strong>and</strong> traffic management<br />
• operation <strong>and</strong> engineering services<br />
• road safety<br />
Senior engineers will be appointed to specialist positions, restoring the RTA as a specialist in<br />
the road engineering field (eg specialist geotechnical).<br />
Skills shortage will be addressed through a range of measures including traineeships.<br />
There will be increased delegation to Regional Managers to make decisions within their own<br />
areas.<br />
The RTA will increase their level of effort in Asset Management Planning linked to strategic<br />
l<strong>and</strong>-use <strong>and</strong> transport studies.<br />
NSW Auditor General:<br />
• State roads worth $70B covering almost 20,000km<br />
• general level of service has increased but some concerns with road roughness<br />
• performance based st<strong>and</strong>ards are the way forward<br />
• new tools being developed to assist with condition assessment <strong>and</strong> management of the<br />
road asset<br />
Review of regional roads is still to be finalised. (Note: Original proposal involved about<br />
500km going from State road to regional road without increased funding – the final outcome<br />
has been pending for some time now.)<br />
Heavy mass limits – companies can now apply for increases in HML on roads within 100km<br />
of Auslink roads. (Note: In our area the Auslink road is the Hume Highway, hence this<br />
possibility does not apply to our <strong>Shire</strong> at this time.)
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 22<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
20<strong>06</strong> NSW Roads Congress Communique<br />
A draft communique was presented <strong>and</strong> discussed by Congress representative, prior to<br />
formulation <strong>and</strong> presentation on the 2 nd day of the Congress.<br />
Day Two<br />
RTA Liaison Session – Bob Sharpe, GM Infrastructure Maintenance & Lou Lang<br />
Existing partnerships with local government include:<br />
• Liaison Committee<br />
• NSW Roads & Transport Directorate<br />
• DLG Infrastructure Taskforce<br />
NSW Auditor General:<br />
• need transparency in condition of RTA roads<br />
• share the workload with Council (not clear what was intended here)<br />
RTA:<br />
• want to establish levels of service based on condition<br />
• existing renewal targets 2-3% of road network – only achieving 1.2% which is not<br />
sustainable<br />
• looking to establish a “brownfields” design guide to produce more pragmatic solutions<br />
to renewal works based on better value for money<br />
• developing an improved method for predicting remaining pavement life -> based on<br />
structural condition -> better estimation -> better asset management<br />
• propose to rank roads by function <strong>and</strong> use, thereby employing a risk management<br />
approach – lower ranked roads will have a lower level of service<br />
• automatic data collection to be engaged<br />
Roads Classification Review:<br />
• panel deliberation is complete<br />
• should go to the Minister soon<br />
Clustering for Single Invitation Contracts:<br />
• has worked in some areas<br />
• encourage each Council to consider the applicability to their own circumstances<br />
Development application matters:<br />
• RTA developing specific DA officers to h<strong>and</strong>le such matters
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 23<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
Contact for bridge research in the RTA:<br />
• Chris Harris GM Bridge Research<br />
Phillip Hallam, GM Compliance & Freight Strategy RTA – Heavy Mass Limits &<br />
Intelligent Access Programs (IAP)<br />
• roads are critical infrastructure, vital for the social <strong>and</strong> economic well-being of our<br />
communities <strong>and</strong> nation<br />
• the freight issue is of key economic importance for NSW<br />
• 80% of the nations freight moves within or through NSW (50 billion tonne km)<br />
• freight task is predicted to double by 2020<br />
• Council of Australian Governments (COAG) February 20<strong>06</strong> – made 40 decisions<br />
relating to freight<br />
• emergence of higher productivity vehicles:<br />
- higher mass limits<br />
- performance based st<strong>and</strong>ards<br />
• strategy is for higher quality vehicles on higher quality roads<br />
• HML vehicles are not larger vehicles but are permitted to carry 10-13% increase in<br />
payload so long as stringent new safeguards are met<br />
• HML vehicles will limit the growth in heavy vehicles using the network<br />
Auslink agreement:<br />
• Clause 66 – vehicles operating at HML must have compliance monitored by intelligent<br />
access programs (IAP)<br />
• Clause 74 – compliance shall include maintenance of suspension systems<br />
Higher mass limit vehicles must:<br />
• be accredited under the National Heavy Vehicle Accreditation Scheme (NHVAS)<br />
• be fitted with road friendly suspension<br />
• meet new suspension maintenance requirements<br />
• have their compliance checked under an IAP<br />
HML vehicles are approved for specific routes. Use of local <strong>and</strong> regional roads will only be<br />
approved if the local Council agrees to their use.<br />
Achieving route compliance is a major issue. This will be achieved using satellite tracking<br />
technology.
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 24<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
IAP Service Providers<br />
Transport Certification<br />
Australia TCA<br />
Roads Authority Transport Operators<br />
Approval granted to Intelligent Access System providers for their systems is given by<br />
Transport Certification Australia <strong>and</strong> applies across all States once given. Still requires<br />
registration in each State.<br />
TCA will commence approvals in January 2007.<br />
In NSW, the IAP will connect to the existing suite of compliance systems including “Safe-T-<br />
Cam”, “TruckScan” <strong>and</strong> the Heavy Vehicle Registration System.<br />
For example, Safe-T-Cam does 21,000,000 checks on heavy vehicles each year, covering<br />
about 30 different issues as each truck is scanned at 100km/hour in about 0.3 seconds.<br />
The proposed system linked to the IAP will produce non-conformance reports. These will be<br />
passed on for further investigation <strong>and</strong> where necessary, action against an offending trucking<br />
company <strong>and</strong>/or driver.<br />
Transitional implementation has already commenced from 1 July 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
Transport operators seeking to operate HML in NSW must pre-enrol for the IAP.<br />
The Minister has allowed transport operators to seek approval for all local <strong>and</strong> regional routes<br />
within 100km of Auslink roads subject to approval being granted from the responsible road<br />
authority. State government cannot overrule local government if local government knocks<br />
back the approval for a local road.<br />
The RTA will assess operator’s route applications within 40 days of receipt.<br />
The RTA will maintain a register of all approved routes, including local roads.<br />
The RTA is working with the LGSA <strong>and</strong> IPWEA to make further information available to<br />
local government on higher mass limit vehicles. This will be in the form of Technical Notes.
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 25<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
The new suspension systems are designed to allow heavier mass limits with minimal extra<br />
damage to roads. However, bridges remain a significant potential obstacle to permitting extra<br />
loading on specific routes.<br />
The approval for HML on local roads is a technical assessment that would normally be<br />
approved by a Council Engineer, delegated this task by their Council. The RTA does not<br />
require the matter to go to Local Traffic Committee. However, Council can, if they wish, refer<br />
such matters through their Local Traffic Committee.<br />
Stuart St Clair, CEO Australian Trucking Association<br />
Stuart spoke in favour of higher mass limits (HML) re-confirming the economic benefits of<br />
allowing the freight industry to be able to deliver goods <strong>and</strong> services in an economical<br />
manner.<br />
Stewart McCleod, Director of Technical Services Dubbo City Council<br />
Stewart spoke of the strategic plan put together to address the major freight routes going to<br />
<strong>and</strong> through Dubbo.<br />
Importantly, l<strong>and</strong>-use planning for industrial activities have been placed off major highways<br />
coming into the town, thereby avoiding heavy transport within or adjacent to residential areas.<br />
Key heavy vehicle routes were identified <strong>and</strong> works listed to assist in enhancing transport<br />
corridors.<br />
Stewart indicated an in principle agreement with HML but only subject to appropriate funding<br />
being made available to local government for the upgrading of key routes including local<br />
bridges. He also indicated that they have rejected applications for HML on the grounds that<br />
road pavements <strong>and</strong> bridges are not able to cope with such transport.<br />
He also indicated that clearer guidelines needed to be made available to local government<br />
practitioners to be able to properly assess applications for HML on local <strong>and</strong> regional roads.<br />
Jacqui Clarke, Road Safety Project Manager IPWEA NSW<br />
Jacqui provided an overview of the Road Safety Officer program <strong>and</strong> the work done in recent<br />
years to promote road safety at a local level. She also spoke of the annual awards run in<br />
conjunction with the NSW IPWEA Conference each year <strong>and</strong> the upcoming Road Safety<br />
Conference planned for January 2007.
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 26<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
Bronwyn Kelly, Director of Corporate & Technical Services Waverley City Council<br />
Development of a Parking Enforcement Strategy as a Tool to Implement a Transport<br />
Policy<br />
Waverley City Council covers only 9sqkm <strong>and</strong> takes in Bondi Beach.<br />
• 2500 parking spaces under parking meters<br />
• 2001 Council takes over parking from NSW Police<br />
• 2002 Transport Plan developed:<br />
- aim to shift people out of cars into other modes<br />
- $8M of engineering works to reduce speed <strong>and</strong> limit vehicular movement<br />
- enforcement officers increased from 4 to 38<br />
- fines increased from $2M pa to $12M pa (over 99/00 to 05/<strong>06</strong>), now making up 25%<br />
of Council’s revenue<br />
- targets set<br />
• 2003 DCP put in place to limit the provision of off-street parking on private property to<br />
discourage car ownership<br />
• 2004 – green links program providing pathways, etc <strong>and</strong> car sharing <strong>and</strong> other projects<br />
encouraging change in behaviour<br />
Outcomes:<br />
• target set harder to bring to reality – require specific strategies to try to reach targets set<br />
• Waverley has now set new Strategic Plan with parking <strong>and</strong> traffic management being<br />
the number one issue<br />
• 1997-2005:<br />
- car ownership grew by 17%<br />
- visitation to Bondi grew by 10% (now 6M pa)<br />
- day visitors grew by 65%<br />
- Westfield Shopping Centre underwent a major upgrade – now 21.3M people pa<br />
- State Government increased the value of fines<br />
- h<strong>and</strong> held devices for parking officers greatly increased their efficiency of producing<br />
fines<br />
- illegal parking increased, as residents squeezed out of spaces in their local streets<br />
resulting in many residents being fined <strong>and</strong> bringing a backlash from the community<br />
• review undertaken:<br />
- implemented a more educative approach (eg “move on” protocol – if you move on<br />
when asked, no fine imposed)<br />
- widespread education on parking regulations stressing road safety benefits (eg illegal<br />
parking around junctions)<br />
- recognise balance needed in enforcement with enforcement to be based on safety <strong>and</strong><br />
amenity<br />
- staff performance monitored to ensure balanced approach<br />
• over four year period:<br />
- accidents down 26%<br />
- pedestrian accidents down 54%<br />
- significant credit to engineering treatments implemented <strong>and</strong> enforcement of illegal<br />
unsafe parking
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 27<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
Mick Savage, Manager NSW Roads & Transport Directorate<br />
Mick provided a summary of the activities of the NSW Roads & Transport Directorate<br />
(R&TD) of the last year.<br />
• 123 Councils now members (up <strong>14</strong>)<br />
• roads <strong>and</strong> bridges benchmarking reports now updated <strong>and</strong> available on the IPWEA website<br />
• includes 135 (89%) of Councils with validated responses to the IPWEA roads <strong>and</strong><br />
bridges survey – <strong>14</strong>7 (97%) received with 12 requiring further work to validate<br />
• this data was used to input into the Local Government Sustainability Inquiry (Allen<br />
report)<br />
• R&TD made a detailed submission to the Inquiry<br />
• Timber Bridge Working Party active <strong>and</strong> investigating a number of areas (Note: ESCs<br />
Senior Project Engineer Russell Burke is represented on this technical working party.)<br />
• NSW Roads Congress provided<br />
• R&TD forum provided at IPWEA Annual Conference<br />
• new groups formed:<br />
- Transport Working Party<br />
- St<strong>and</strong>ard Operating Procedures Working Party (Note: ESCs Mike Clement is<br />
represented on this group.)<br />
• observed <strong>and</strong> assisted NAMS.AU group<br />
• Roads & Bridges Asset Benchmarking Project to be run again based on 2005/<strong>06</strong><br />
information. Surveys to be sent to Councils in November seeking data by end of 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
This information will again be collated to provide Statewide summaries of the current<br />
shortfall in funding, progress on asset management planning <strong>and</strong> other valuable<br />
information<br />
• next NSW Roads Congress proposed to be held in 18 months time in conjunction with<br />
the IPWEA Conference to allow Councillors the opportunity to participate in the Local<br />
Government Engineering <strong>and</strong> Road Safety Awards, <strong>and</strong> reduce the cost of sending staff<br />
<strong>and</strong> Councillors to separate events<br />
John Truman, President NSW IPWEA – Congress Communique<br />
Final discussion <strong>and</strong> input into the Congress Communique prior to final drafting.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
The NSW Congress provided valuable updates on issues affecting roads <strong>and</strong> transport within<br />
NSW as well as informal discussion with other elected members <strong>and</strong> senior staff.
DELEGATES REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 28<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>5 NSW ROADS CONGRESS – DELEGATES REPORT 98.2473<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee<br />
resolve the following:<br />
THAT the Delegates Report provided by Councillor Rob Pollock, Chair of the <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
<strong>Facilities</strong> Committee on the NSW Roads Congress be received <strong>and</strong> noted.<br />
CR ROB POLLOCK<br />
CHAIR<br />
WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE
ENVIRONMENT REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 29<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>6 REHABILITATION OF MORUYA RIVER<br />
FORESHORE - GLENDUART 93.5760.B<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
This report addresses recommendation WR<strong>06</strong>/25 (5) from the <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong><br />
Committee meeting held on 12 September 20<strong>06</strong> as follows:<br />
5. A report be prepared on the proposed rehabilitation of the foreshore reserve on the<br />
northern bank of Moruya River at Glenduart.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
Council has secured funding from the Department of Natural Resources (DNR) <strong>and</strong> from the<br />
Natural Heritage Trust through the Southern Rivers Catchment Management Authority<br />
(SRCMA) to implement work on public l<strong>and</strong>s managed by Council. Project works are<br />
aligned with the Estuary Management Plans, the Council Management Plan <strong>and</strong> the draft<br />
Southern Rivers Catchment Action Plan (CAP). Social <strong>and</strong> economic considerations are also<br />
determining factors that are evaluated in the project design <strong>and</strong> implementation. A report<br />
(P<strong>06</strong>/43) detailing the works implemented through these programs was presented to the<br />
Environment, Planning <strong>and</strong> Administrative Services Committee meeting on 4 July 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
Minute PM<strong>06</strong>/68 states that report P<strong>06</strong>/43 was received <strong>and</strong> noted.<br />
A report presented to the Environment, Planning <strong>and</strong> Administrative Services Committee<br />
meeting on 5 September 20<strong>06</strong> (File No 00.4464/2) outlined the key aims of the Estuary<br />
Program application as follows:<br />
“The Glenduart Reserve is 13ha of public l<strong>and</strong> adjoining Moruya River. This site will require<br />
targeted ongoing restoration works, with this application being Stage (1) of a planned 3-5<br />
year program. The objectives of Stage (1) are: Protect identified cultural heritage sites,<br />
identify encroachments from adjoining private properties, engage in public consultation<br />
regarding use/values of Reserve, control weeds & prepare site for future regeneration<br />
projects, protect existing remnants of riparian corridor (2 EEC’s), commence restoration of<br />
riparian corridor.”<br />
The primary aim of the Glenduart <strong>and</strong> other riverside restoration projects around the <strong>Shire</strong> is<br />
to restore riparian (riverside) vegetation. The riparian zone provides the best opportunities for<br />
creating corridors, contains the highest diversity of flora <strong>and</strong> fauna <strong>and</strong> is the most productive.<br />
The riparian zone is essential to filtering sediment <strong>and</strong> recycling nutrients <strong>and</strong> trace elements<br />
that would otherwise overload <strong>and</strong> pollute our waterways. Therefore, restoring the riparian<br />
zone will translate to considerable environmental <strong>and</strong> social benefits.<br />
Riparian corridor widths have been addressed in the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong>’s Draft Rural L<strong>and</strong>s<br />
Strategy. The Draft Strategy states a minimum width of 100m for riparian buffers on major<br />
waterways (pp. 38,39). Further discussions with the Department of Natural Resources,<br />
Department of Planning <strong>and</strong> the Southern Rivers Catchment Management Authority have<br />
supported an allocated riparian buffer width of 100m for major estuaries <strong>and</strong> rivers. This<br />
width provides for the:<br />
• reduction of contamination of waterways caused by pollutants washed from the l<strong>and</strong><br />
surface;<br />
• reduction of location specific process affected by erosion <strong>and</strong> streambank collapse;<br />
• enhanced riparian endemic vegetation;
ENVIRONMENT REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 30<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>6 REHABILITATION OF MORUYA RIVER<br />
FORESHORE - GLENDUART 93.5760.B<br />
• increased faunal habitat <strong>and</strong> faunal movement;<br />
• vegetation corridors which overall assist natural processes such as species movement,<br />
water movement <strong>and</strong> provide resource rich areas for native fauna.<br />
The reduction of riparian zones potentially undermines the services that the zone can <strong>and</strong> does<br />
provide.<br />
The Moruya River Estuary Management Plan is currently under development <strong>and</strong> will address<br />
key environmental objectives such as: erosion control; protection of Endangered Ecological<br />
Communities; restoration of faunal corridors <strong>and</strong> rehabilitation of native vegetation. This<br />
project, along with related estuary, biodiversity <strong>and</strong> L<strong>and</strong>care works, are in keeping with<br />
Council’s commitment to best management of the Nature Coast.<br />
ISSUES<br />
Currently there are l<strong>and</strong>holders that have had access to the community l<strong>and</strong>s. This access has<br />
been inclusive of agricultural practices, grazing, mown reserve areas, dumping garden refuse<br />
<strong>and</strong> other activities that prevent natural regeneration. These practices are not allied with the<br />
best outcomes for the riparian zone. Council is able to rectify this position through the<br />
financial support of State <strong>and</strong> Federal funds to enable riparian restoration works on the<br />
Moruya <strong>and</strong> other waterways across the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong>.<br />
The project works will address the following issues:<br />
• loss of riparian vegetation <strong>and</strong> habitat for endemic fauna;<br />
• stock access from neighboring properties that may damage regrowth, compact soil,<br />
disperse weeds <strong>and</strong> pollute waterways;<br />
• impacts on water quality;<br />
• invasive weeds;<br />
• protection of cultural heritage assets;<br />
• ongoing public access <strong>and</strong> use;<br />
• encroachment from adjoining rural <strong>and</strong> semi-rural properties.<br />
Policy<br />
All project works will align with the NSW Coastal Policy 1997, the guiding Principles of<br />
Ecologically Sustainable Development, the draft Rural L<strong>and</strong>s Strategy <strong>and</strong> other relevant<br />
legislation <strong>and</strong> policies as follows:<br />
• State Rivers <strong>and</strong> Estuaries Policy, 1992;<br />
• NSW Biodiversity Strategy, 1999;<br />
• Threatened Species Conservation Act;<br />
• State Water Management Outcomes Plan - Target 28; Percentage of native riparian<br />
vegetation increased on waterfront l<strong>and</strong>.
ENVIRONMENT REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 31<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>6 REHABILITATION OF MORUYA RIVER<br />
FORESHORE - GLENDUART 93.5760.B<br />
The project works also align with development suitability assessment established via the<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Coastal Environmental Capacity Planning Project 2001, which identified<br />
absolute constraints of 100m for estuaries <strong>and</strong> lakes. This is further reflected in the Rural<br />
L<strong>and</strong>s Strategy via the Strategic Environmental Assessment.<br />
ENVIRONMENTAL<br />
The current <strong>and</strong> future projects will link strategically with implementing the draft Rural L<strong>and</strong>s<br />
Strategy that has been supported <strong>and</strong> endorsed by Council. The Glenduart project will aim to<br />
restore the minimum buffer of 100m that was recommended for major waterways within the<br />
draft Strategy. This project will also link with State Planning Instruments such as the<br />
Department of Natural Resources Riparian Corridor Objective Setting (RCOS) guidelines.<br />
The RCOS guidelines classify the Moruya River as a Category (1) Stream; determining that<br />
the estuarine reaches require a minimum riparian buffer of 90m.<br />
It is important to note that the project will be implemented in stages over the next five years.<br />
Initial financial support has been provided by the Southern Rivers CMA <strong>and</strong> additional funds<br />
have been sought from the Department of Natural Resources Estuary Program. Details of<br />
projects operating under the Estuary Program were outlined in an earlier report to the<br />
Environment, Planning <strong>and</strong> Administrative Services Committee meeting held on 5 September<br />
20<strong>06</strong> (File No 00.4464/2). Expected outcomes of the Glenduart program are:<br />
• minimum 100m of native riparian vegetation restored (where width of community owned<br />
l<strong>and</strong> permits);<br />
• natural <strong>and</strong> cultural heritage values of the site protected;<br />
• restoration of community access to public l<strong>and</strong>;<br />
• removal <strong>and</strong> control of illegal encroachments;<br />
• setting a precedent for the management of illegal encroachments on environmentally<br />
sensitive riparian l<strong>and</strong>.<br />
The project has significant advantages for the local environment <strong>and</strong> Council as a l<strong>and</strong><br />
manager. The project demonstrates Council’s commitment to environmental management in<br />
alignment with state <strong>and</strong> local planning objectives.<br />
Asset<br />
The project site is community owned l<strong>and</strong> on the northern bank of Moruya River. The project<br />
will protect <strong>and</strong> regenerate the following adjoining Council controlled reserves with property<br />
numbers as follows (Map 1):<br />
• Lot 37 – DP 264448<br />
• Lot 21 – DP 246754<br />
• Lot 36 – DP 264448
ENVIRONMENT REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 32<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>6 REHABILITATION OF MORUYA RIVER<br />
FORESHORE - GLENDUART 93.5760.B<br />
MORUYA RIVER<br />
MAP 1: Glenduart Reserve – showing the proposed riparian restoration zone in the<br />
encroached, mown, cleared <strong>and</strong> grazed areas.<br />
The reserves are categorised as follows:<br />
ENCROACHMENTS, MOWING & CLEARING<br />
Lot 37 - DP 264448<br />
• General Community Use<br />
• Natural Area Foreshore<br />
• Natural Area Bushl<strong>and</strong><br />
• Rural Heritage Item (Mogendoura Cemetery)<br />
Lot 21 - DP 246754<br />
ENCROACHMENTS & GRAZING<br />
PROPOSED GRAZING LEASE<br />
KEY<br />
Community l<strong>and</strong><br />
Target regeneration sites<br />
Lot 36 - DP 264448<br />
The core objectives for management of community l<strong>and</strong> categorised as a natural area are:<br />
(a) to conserve biodiversity <strong>and</strong> maintain ecosystem function in respect of the l<strong>and</strong>, or the<br />
feature or habitat in respect of which the l<strong>and</strong> is categorised as a natural area, <strong>and</strong><br />
(b) to maintain the l<strong>and</strong>, or that feature or habitat, in its natural state <strong>and</strong> setting, <strong>and</strong><br />
(c) to provide for the restoration <strong>and</strong> regeneration of the l<strong>and</strong>, <strong>and</strong><br />
(d) to provide for community use of <strong>and</strong> access to the l<strong>and</strong> in such a manner as will minimise<br />
<strong>and</strong> mitigate any disturbance caused by human intrusion, <strong>and</strong><br />
(e) to assist in <strong>and</strong> facilitate the implementation of any provisions restricting the use <strong>and</strong><br />
management of the l<strong>and</strong> that are set out in a recovery plan or threat abatement plan<br />
prepared under the Threatened Species Conservation Act 1995 or the Fisheries<br />
Management Act 1994.
ENVIRONMENT REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 33<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>6 REHABILITATION OF MORUYA RIVER<br />
FORESHORE - GLENDUART 93.5760.B<br />
Core objectives for management of community l<strong>and</strong> categorised as foreshore:<br />
(a) to maintain the foreshore as a transition area between the aquatic <strong>and</strong> the terrestrial<br />
environment, <strong>and</strong> to protect <strong>and</strong> enhance all functions associated with the foreshore’s role<br />
as a transition area, <strong>and</strong><br />
(b) to facilitate the ecologically sustainable use of the foreshore, <strong>and</strong> to mitigate impact on the<br />
foreshore by community use.<br />
The works proposed all adhere to the categorisation of the l<strong>and</strong>s.<br />
Community Consultation<br />
Community consultation will be facilitated through the Moruya Estuary Advisory Committee<br />
<strong>and</strong> through notification of works through the local media. Field days <strong>and</strong> site meetings will<br />
be conducted if sufficient interest is shown. Localised consultation will also occur with<br />
l<strong>and</strong>holders whose input will be sought in developing an Action Plan for the reserve.<br />
Staff<br />
The project works will be implemented through the Environment Team of Council.<br />
Strategic Links<br />
The projects are in consultation with the Moruya Estuary Advisory Committee <strong>and</strong><br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Local Management Team (ELMT) to ensure that the project directions are<br />
aligned with the objectives of the Committees, SRCMA, DNR <strong>and</strong> Council. Further<br />
consultation is with the Department of Natural Resources, <strong>and</strong> other relevant government<br />
departments as required. The projects are also linked with the Estuary Management Plans to<br />
deliver appropriate works along with the Council Management Plan, the draft Rural L<strong>and</strong>s<br />
Strategy, draft Urban Settlement Strategy, <strong>and</strong> the draft Southern Rivers Catchment Action<br />
Plan.<br />
Financial<br />
Environment estuary projects are funded by <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council <strong>and</strong> externally sourced<br />
grants from agencies including the Department of Natural Resources, Southern Rivers CMA<br />
<strong>and</strong> the Australian Government Envirofund.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
The proposed works at Glenduart will add value to the <strong>Shire</strong>’s natural resource assets. The<br />
project links strategically with works being undertaken across the <strong>Shire</strong> to implement Estuary<br />
Management Plans <strong>and</strong> meet targets outlined in other Council <strong>and</strong> State Planning Instruments.<br />
This <strong>and</strong> other foreshore projects currently underway are critical to setting a precedent in<br />
terms of managing areas of community owned foreshore l<strong>and</strong>s. The outcomes of this project<br />
will not only maintain <strong>and</strong> improve the environmental services provided by a broad riparian<br />
buffer; it will ensure ongoing <strong>and</strong> sustainable community access to a publicly owned resource.<br />
This project aligns with directions determined by the Moruya Estuary Advisory Committee.<br />
The project will also aim to foster community <strong>and</strong> l<strong>and</strong>holder ownership <strong>and</strong> appreciation for<br />
the community l<strong>and</strong> in line with the environmental benefits that riparian zones provide.
ENVIRONMENT REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 34<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>6 REHABILITATION OF MORUYA RIVER<br />
FORESHORE - GLENDUART 93.5760.B<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee<br />
resolve the following:<br />
THAT Council:<br />
1. receive <strong>and</strong> note the report on Rehabilitation of Moruya River Foreshore - Glenduart; <strong>and</strong><br />
2. endorse the proposed works on community owned l<strong>and</strong> on the Moruya River foreshore at<br />
Glenduart.<br />
DEBORAH LENSON<br />
ENVIRONMENT TEAM LEADER<br />
DEVELOPMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES
ENVIRONMENT REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 35<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>7 BENGELLO FOREST 05.9452/2<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
This report discusses the ecological significance of the tracts of Council managed l<strong>and</strong><br />
between Moruya North Head <strong>and</strong> the village of Broulee, both east <strong>and</strong> west of George Bass<br />
Drive. Additionally, the report outlines some of the options available to Council for the<br />
future management of this unique area.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
The Bengello Forest area is significant from geological, cultural, aesthetic <strong>and</strong> ecological<br />
perspectives. The area has exceptionally high biological diversity <strong>and</strong> supports a range of<br />
threatened flora <strong>and</strong> fauna as well as forming a key corridor facilitating migration <strong>and</strong><br />
dispersal to the north <strong>and</strong> west. The nearby freshwater wetl<strong>and</strong>s Williga <strong>and</strong> Waldrons<br />
Swamps together with Malabar Lagoon <strong>and</strong> Mogo State Forest complement the areas<br />
biodiversity values. This report refers to ~230Ha of l<strong>and</strong> (parts of Lot 70-DP 83<strong>11</strong><strong>11</strong>, Lot 8<br />
DP 258299 <strong>and</strong> Lot 7008 DP 1020750 – see map).<br />
The Bengello area is the largest of only two main clusters of the Endangered Bangalay S<strong>and</strong><br />
Forest community in the <strong>Shire</strong> (the other being the Pedro/Congo area). Reflected by its<br />
present status, [listed under the Threatened Species Conservation (TSC) Act <strong>and</strong> presently<br />
being considered for listing under the Federal Environment Protection <strong>and</strong> Biodiversity<br />
Conservation (EPBC) Act], this community is likely to become extinct in nature unless key<br />
threatening processes impacting its health <strong>and</strong> extent are controlled or cease to operate (Final<br />
Determination - Scientific Committee 2005). These processes include l<strong>and</strong> clearing,<br />
degradation <strong>and</strong> disturbance associated with heavy recreational use, frequent burning, rubbish<br />
dumping <strong>and</strong> weed invasion.<br />
A number of key user groups such as the racing community, professional <strong>and</strong> recreational<br />
fishers, naturalist <strong>and</strong> conservation groups <strong>and</strong> those involved with passive forms of<br />
recreation, eg cycling, walking <strong>and</strong> dog walking have a keen interest in the area. As the<br />
primary l<strong>and</strong> managers of the Bengello Forest area, Council has a responsibility to apply<br />
appropriate management, protect the ecological function of the area <strong>and</strong> ensure the viability of<br />
this tract is maintained <strong>and</strong> eventually improved.<br />
ISSUES<br />
The Bengello Forest area is presently being impacted by a number of processes – these threats<br />
are generally associated with proximal development <strong>and</strong> recreational use such as:<br />
• Arson activity – the area is frequently subject to unprescribed burns particularly around<br />
Broulee.<br />
• Clearing - present pruning activity north of the Airport runway for air safety purposes has<br />
an impact for approximately 900m.<br />
• Recreational use – significant degradation <strong>and</strong> disturbance associated with recreational<br />
use is obvious along the tracks through the Bengello Forest area.<br />
• Rubbish dumping –area is a dumping ground <strong>and</strong> the refuse littered along the tracks<br />
includes domestic, industrial/commercial waste <strong>and</strong> cars.<br />
• Weed invasion - due to the great number of access tracks cutting through the endangered<br />
community, there is an increasing potential for further spread of weeds.
ENVIRONMENT REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 36<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>7 BENGELLO FOREST 05.9452/2<br />
Legal<br />
There are numerous forms of legislation <strong>and</strong> policies at the international, national, state <strong>and</strong><br />
local levels that require Council to consider biodiversity, Ecologically Sustainable<br />
Development (ESD) <strong>and</strong> threatened species <strong>and</strong> vegetation management.<br />
Council has obligations as one of the largest l<strong>and</strong> managers in the area ensuring that the<br />
Bengello area is afforded a level of protection commensurate with its ecological value <strong>and</strong><br />
Council’s financial capacities.<br />
Environmental<br />
This report proposes opportunities for contribution to biological diversity conservation by<br />
improving <strong>and</strong> certifying management <strong>and</strong> other activities occurring within the area. Recent<br />
investigations have established that a range of conservation options are available for Council<br />
to consider <strong>and</strong> additional research may be required to establish the best mechanism to<br />
support aspirations for the area. Essentially, Council can choose to:<br />
Option 1 - Enter into a Voluntary Conservation Agreement<br />
There are two main secure <strong>and</strong> reputable forms of covenant available:<br />
1. Voluntary Conservation Agreement (VCA)<br />
This agreement is administered through the National Parks Act <strong>and</strong> signed off by the<br />
Minister for the Environment <strong>and</strong> Council – it is noted on the title of the property in<br />
perpetuity. Discussions with National Parks have indicated that they would be interested<br />
in investing in this proposal should Council wish to proceed with this option. Generally<br />
DEC/Parks covers the legal costs of establishing the agreement <strong>and</strong> assist with the<br />
facilitation of any community consultation sessions. A comprehensive property plan <strong>and</strong><br />
management conditions are established jointly by the proponent (Council) <strong>and</strong> Parks.<br />
2. Property Vegetation Plan (PVP)<br />
A PVP is administered through the Native Vegetation Act <strong>and</strong> signed off by the Southern<br />
Rivers Catchment Management Authority (SRCMA). This agreement is a legal<br />
commitment noted on the Section <strong>14</strong>9 Certificate relating to the property <strong>and</strong> there is an<br />
option to include a PVP notation on the certificate of title. The SRCMA has given a firm<br />
commitment that they are prepared to invest in the establishment of a PVP should Council<br />
wish to proceed with this action.<br />
Property plan <strong>and</strong> vegetation surveys are undertaken <strong>and</strong> general management conditions<br />
established through a PVP. The development of a management plan would be the<br />
responsibility of Council <strong>and</strong> community consultation is not a requirement of the<br />
agreement but would be desirable from Council’s perspective.
ENVIRONMENT REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 37<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>7 BENGELLO FOREST 05.9452/2<br />
Option 2 - Maintain Current Status<br />
This option relies on the rezoning of part of the Bengello Forest to 7(f1) Environmental<br />
Protection (Coastal L<strong>and</strong>s Protection) to protect the values <strong>and</strong> integrity of the locality. The<br />
rezoning of the area does not address the issues relating to management <strong>and</strong> detrimental<br />
impacts on an endangered community <strong>and</strong> key l<strong>and</strong>scape link, nor does it cover the critical<br />
portion of Council managed l<strong>and</strong> west of George Bass Drive.<br />
Asset<br />
The Bengello Forest area is an extremely valuable environmental asset due to its location in<br />
the l<strong>and</strong>scape <strong>and</strong> function as a wildlife corridor, its composition, condition <strong>and</strong> overall high<br />
biodiversity values. It is culturally, scientifically <strong>and</strong> aesthetically significant to a wide range<br />
of people.<br />
The Bengello Forests are situated adjacent to the airport entrance to the <strong>Shire</strong> <strong>and</strong> as such<br />
provide a valuable visual introduction to the Nature Coast. This proposal would serve to<br />
protect this visual asset <strong>and</strong> is not intended to affect any aspect of the present or future airport<br />
operations (as specified in the adopted Airport Concept Plan), or rezoned uses proposed on<br />
the northern end of the site.<br />
Social Impact<br />
The natural beauty <strong>and</strong> amenity of the Bengello Forest precinct ensures a high level of<br />
community interest <strong>and</strong> visitation. The area provides the local community with a range of<br />
ecological services <strong>and</strong> passive recreational activities that enhance the quality of life for<br />
individuals <strong>and</strong> groups. The area is also archaeologically <strong>and</strong> socially important to the<br />
Aboriginal community with known sites of significance concentrated in the area.<br />
Community Consultation<br />
Council has been approached by Coastwatchers <strong>and</strong> the Broulee Community Association<br />
(July 2005), who would like to see the area better managed, its environmental significance<br />
recognised <strong>and</strong> for it to be protected in line with the Bengello Bounty Report. Further<br />
community consultation via the Moruya Airport Structure Plan demonstrated support for the<br />
protection <strong>and</strong> maintenance of the environmental <strong>and</strong> aesthetic values of the Bengello Forests.<br />
More recent submissions on the Broulee Beaches Concept Plan <strong>and</strong> the Rural LEP<br />
(Amendment No.38) exhibited in mid-2005 show general support <strong>and</strong> encouragement from<br />
the community to protect the Bengello Forest area.<br />
Further community consultation would be anticipated for the conservation of the identified<br />
areas.<br />
Staff<br />
Investigations to date on management options for the Bengello Forest area have been<br />
undertaken through the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Biodiversity Program, in consultation with staff from the<br />
Strategic, Property, <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> Environment areas.
ENVIRONMENT REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 38<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>7 BENGELLO FOREST 05.9452/2<br />
Strategic Links<br />
The proposal has been discussed with the Southern Rivers Catchment Management Authority,<br />
Department of Environment <strong>and</strong> Conservation, Department of Natural Resources <strong>and</strong><br />
Department of L<strong>and</strong>s. Each agency has conveyed support for the proposal with both DEC<br />
<strong>and</strong> SRCMA offering assistance in drafting a management plan for the area through their<br />
respective conservation/incentive programs.<br />
The project is aligned with the Estuary Management Plans of the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>and</strong> Catchment<br />
Action Plan of the Southern Rivers region, Councils Plan of Management for Natural Areas<br />
<strong>and</strong> Undeveloped Reserves <strong>and</strong> the Rural LEP. It further complements the Yellow Bellied<br />
Glider Policy of Council.<br />
A separate but related project has also been investigated relating to a large portion of l<strong>and</strong><br />
(Lot 92, DP 63<strong>14</strong>93) under the care <strong>and</strong> control of the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s. This 272Ha<br />
block is also ecologically significant, adjoins Council’s Lot 4 (Williga Swamp), <strong>and</strong><br />
completes the regional corridor connecting the coast through wetl<strong>and</strong>s, State Forest <strong>and</strong><br />
National Park to the escarpment. Negotiations will continue concurrently with NRM agencies<br />
<strong>and</strong> the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s to establish an appropriate means of managing <strong>and</strong> protecting<br />
this lot with discussions to date focusing on a Property Vegetation Plan through the Southern<br />
Rivers Catchment Management Authority.<br />
Financial<br />
If Council were to enter into a voluntary conservation agreement (including an accompanying<br />
plan of management), the Bengello area would be considered a high priority for investment of<br />
public monies inclusive of on-ground rehabilitative works. These funds would address many<br />
of the issues relevant to the area <strong>and</strong> sources include Natural Heritage Trust, SCRMA,<br />
Department of Natural Resources, Department of Environment <strong>and</strong> Conservation <strong>and</strong> other<br />
Federal <strong>and</strong> State monies.<br />
The Bengello Forest also has the potential to be established as a biobank site [Threatened<br />
Species Conservation Amendment (Biodiversity Banking Bill, 20<strong>06</strong>)]. This Amendment, if<br />
passed, will allow the creation of biodiversity credits for management actions that are carried<br />
out within the biobank site. These credits would be tradeable commodities, with the potential<br />
to be purchased to offset an impact on biodiversity from another public or private<br />
development.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
This report recommends that the highest level of protection available under current legislation<br />
be provided to the Bengello Beach <strong>and</strong> Forest area for ongoing protection, to ensure<br />
management certainty <strong>and</strong> as an assurance to the community that their wishes for the area will<br />
be honoured into the future.
ENVIRONMENT REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 39<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>7 BENGELLO FOREST 05.9452/2<br />
If supported by Council, a formal conservation agreement over the public l<strong>and</strong> in the Bengello<br />
Beach vicinity, would be a legally binding notation on the certificate of title <strong>and</strong> would<br />
provide permanent protection for the tract of l<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> the endangered ecological community,<br />
flora <strong>and</strong> fauna it supports. It would ensure the core of the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong>’s largest functional<br />
east-west vegetation corridor would remain intact <strong>and</strong> give confidence to the public that their<br />
highly valued Bengello Forest will be maintained for its natural <strong>and</strong> cultural values. A<br />
commitment from Council, the largest l<strong>and</strong> manager in the area, will hopefully encourage<br />
neighbouring l<strong>and</strong>holders to manage their holding in a manner consistent with these overall<br />
aims <strong>and</strong> complement the efforts of those already voluntarily doing so.<br />
The Council controlled areas of the Bengello Forests deserve priority consideration for<br />
reservation <strong>and</strong> permanent environmental protection through a conservation agreement for the<br />
following reasons:<br />
• The Bengello Forests’ size, condition, function, viability <strong>and</strong> conservation status.<br />
• The community’s expectation <strong>and</strong> aspirations for the area, (identified in various<br />
community surveys <strong>and</strong> forums).<br />
• The area’s position in the l<strong>and</strong>scape contributing to a functional east-west corridor<br />
linkage.<br />
• Protecting <strong>and</strong> enhancing one of the few remaining examples of a unique local<br />
ecosystem.<br />
• Compliance with recommendations of relevant legislation, policies <strong>and</strong> planning controls.<br />
• Realising an immense environmental <strong>and</strong> social benefit at a minimal capital cost.
ENVIRONMENT REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 40<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>7 BENGELLO FOREST 05.9452/2<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee<br />
resolve the following:<br />
THAT Council convene a workshop on the Bengello Forest to discuss the issues <strong>and</strong> options<br />
related to Bengello Forest Report. This workshop would include:<br />
1. the acknowledgement of the ecological importance of the Bengello Forest <strong>and</strong> the area’s<br />
environmental attributes are considered in a strategic planning context;<br />
2. support for the concept of securing the parts of Lots 70, 8, 7008 <strong>and</strong> 4 (as described in<br />
attached map), under a formal conservation agreement <strong>and</strong> support further investigation<br />
into the suitability of either a Voluntary Conservation Agreement or Property Vegetation<br />
Plan to meet this objective;<br />
3. preparation of a Plan of Management over the Bengello Forest area as a matter of priority<br />
(portions presently under Council care <strong>and</strong> control);<br />
4. request that the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s pursue a similar course of action for Lot 92<br />
DP 63<strong>14</strong>93;<br />
5. development of a vegetation management plan for the airport vegetation management<br />
activities ensuring grooming is undertaken as sensitively as possible <strong>and</strong> a functional<br />
connection to the north <strong>and</strong> west is maintained;<br />
6. review of the opportunities for the site as a biodiversity offset or biobanking.<br />
DEBORAH LENSON<br />
ENVIRONMENT TEAM LEADER<br />
DEVELOPMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES<br />
Attach
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 41<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>8 BOTANIC GARDENS ANNUAL REPORT – 2005-<strong>06</strong> 87.6703<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
The <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Management Committee is required to submit an<br />
Annual Report for the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens (ERBG) for 2005-<strong>06</strong>. The<br />
attached Annual Report, documents the activities of the ERBG for 2005-<strong>06</strong> <strong>and</strong> describes<br />
what has been achieved in 2005-<strong>06</strong> through the active partnership between the Council, its<br />
officers <strong>and</strong> the volunteers.<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee<br />
resolve the following:<br />
THAT:<br />
1. The <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report for 2005-<strong>06</strong> be received <strong>and</strong><br />
noted.<br />
2. A letter of congratulations be forwarded to the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens<br />
Management Committee for their efforts over the last 12 months.<br />
WARREN SHARPE<br />
GROUP MANAGER<br />
ROADS AND RECREATION SERVICES<br />
Attach
Annual Report<br />
2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
EUROBODALLA REGIONAL BOTANIC GARDENS<br />
BATEMANS BAY NSW<br />
October 20<strong>06</strong>
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
CONTENTS<br />
Map of the Gardens 2<br />
Message from the Chair 3<br />
Highlights of the twelve months July 2005—June 20<strong>06</strong> 4<br />
Putting our mission into practice 6<br />
Conservation 6<br />
Education 8<br />
Recreation 9<br />
Keeping the wheels turning—administrative matters 10<br />
Honour for Gardens Supervisor 12<br />
Management of the Gardens 13<br />
ERBG volunteers 15<br />
Report against Management Plan performance indicators 16<br />
Financials 17<br />
Herbarium 18<br />
Friends of ERBG 19<br />
Appendix 1 ERBG Management Committee membership 20<br />
Appendix 2 Sponsors 2005-<strong>06</strong> 21<br />
ERBG opening hours <strong>and</strong> contacts 21<br />
3<br />
Page
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
2
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
MESSAGE FROM THE CHAIR<br />
This is the second time that I have been privileged to write the<br />
foreword to the Annual Report for the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional<br />
Botanic Gardens (ERBG). In the past year I have been amazed at<br />
what has been achieved through the active partnership between<br />
the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council, its officers <strong>and</strong> the volunteers.<br />
There are even more volunteers working for more hours; the<br />
Friends of ERBG have continued as financial sponsors of the<br />
Gardens through fundraising activities; <strong>and</strong> the staff have<br />
excelled themselves. In this Report you will note that the<br />
Gardens Supervisor, John Knight, was selected for a prestigious<br />
award, <strong>and</strong> the Gardens apprentice, Ryan Harris, won an<br />
achievement award from apprentice coordination authority, SERTEC. The honorary<br />
Herbarium Curator, Jennifer Liney, received a NSW State Government Seniors Day award.<br />
With these excellent human resources, it is no wonder that the value of our outst<strong>and</strong>ing<br />
community asset continues to grow <strong>and</strong> to be appreciated by all visitors, whether local<br />
residents or interstate <strong>and</strong> international tourists.<br />
Leisa Brennan, Council’s Recreation Co-ordinator, has continued to guide Management<br />
Committee in its liaison with Council. Again her efforts in promoting the ERBG have been<br />
invaluable, especially through the Family Picnic Day <strong>and</strong> the Film Night. Bernadette Davis<br />
of Council’s Environment team has coordinated the schools program that the <strong>Shire</strong>’s<br />
children enjoy so much. Cr Chris Kowal, the Council nominee on Management Committee,<br />
has shown his support <strong>and</strong> interest by coming to events such as the Bird Hide opening <strong>and</strong><br />
attending the Conference of Botanic Gardens.<br />
The members of the Management Committee <strong>and</strong> its sub-committees have worked together<br />
to improve <strong>and</strong> promote the ERBG, <strong>and</strong> I thank all the conveners of the sub-committees for<br />
the huge contribution they have made. Special thanks are also due to Don Brewster for<br />
drafting the Management Plan for 20<strong>06</strong>-10. At the October 2005 meeting Leslie<br />
Lockwood’s resignation was accepted after eight years on the Committee. At that time we<br />
noted that her expertise, assistance <strong>and</strong> friendship would be sorely missed.<br />
I do not intend to st<strong>and</strong> for re-election as Chair in December 20<strong>06</strong> as I believe that two-year<br />
terms for executive positions on community committees encourage continuing renewal in<br />
organisations. In my experience people are more willing to take on office for a known term.<br />
On behalf of the Management Committee <strong>and</strong> all associated with the Gardens I thank the<br />
many contributors for their efforts. It has been rewarding to work with this communitybased<br />
Committee, dedicated volunteers <strong>and</strong> staff <strong>and</strong> to see the ERBG grow. I look forward<br />
to working with you next year in a different capacity.<br />
Sue Grahame<br />
Chair, ERBG Management Committee<br />
October 20<strong>06</strong><br />
3
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
HIGHLIGHTS OF THE TWELVE MONTHS JULY 2005 – JUNE 20<strong>06</strong><br />
July 2005<br />
National Tree Day celebrations include sales of plants bringing in $500 for ERBG projects<br />
August<br />
New publicity flyer is printed for distribution with the mail-out of ESC rates notices<br />
September<br />
900 people attend the Active Australia<br />
Family Picnic Day<br />
Three guides attend the Australasian<br />
Conference of Voluntary Guides in<br />
Botanic Gardens in Melbourne<br />
The Arboretum Gazebo is completed<br />
The volunteers <strong>and</strong> staff who contributed to the<br />
October<br />
Arboretum gazebo design <strong>and</strong> construction<br />
Country Energy donates poles, <strong>and</strong> Pierlite<br />
& Phillips donate floodlights for the car-park.<br />
Gardens Supervisor John Knight is awarded the biennial national Australian Plants Award<br />
by the Association of Societies for Growing Australian Plants<br />
November<br />
500 people attend the InTheBin film night only to be<br />
drenched in a downpour: but 300 come to a repeat<br />
performance in December<br />
The crowd assembles<br />
for the film night<br />
December<br />
About 60 of the over 100 eligible volunteers attend the<br />
annual Volunteers Thank you Lunch<br />
ERBG’s apprentice, Ryan Harris, wins the SERTEC<br />
Foundation award 2005 which recognises his<br />
outst<strong>and</strong>ing achievements both at the Gardens <strong>and</strong><br />
academically through TAFE, his community awareness<br />
<strong>and</strong> vision for the future<br />
Ryan Harris<br />
Collecting trips are made to Big Badja Hill <strong>and</strong> Monga<br />
National Park<br />
Three banners advertising ERBG are erected on the<br />
Highway<br />
4
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
January 20<strong>06</strong><br />
The <strong>Shire</strong> presents the Friends with the Event of the Year award at its Australia Day function<br />
February<br />
Council adopts the Management Plan for 20<strong>06</strong>-10 <strong>and</strong><br />
Annual Report 2004-05<br />
Monthly workshops for outdoor volunteers commence<br />
ERBG, at the request of the Centre for Plant Biodiversity<br />
Research (National Herbarium), locates an uncommon<br />
native Hibiscus species<br />
March<br />
The ERBG website overhaul is completed<br />
April<br />
About 250 people enjoy morning tea on 5 April during Seniors Week<br />
Jennifer Liney, Honorary Curator of the ERBG<br />
Herbarium, receives a NSW Senior Citizens award<br />
in the category Education <strong>and</strong> Lifelong Learning<br />
Picnic shelter seating is completed<br />
May<br />
ERBG contingent of eight (plus three partners) is the<br />
largest from any one site to attend the biennial<br />
Conference of Botanic Gardens of Australia <strong>and</strong><br />
New Zeal<strong>and</strong>, NSW branch, held in Albury<br />
Bird Hide sponsored by Rotary Batemans Bay is<br />
completed <strong>and</strong> officially opened<br />
June<br />
Farewell for longst<strong>and</strong>ing volunteers,<br />
Dorothy <strong>and</strong> Keith Maynard.<br />
Opening the Bird Hide<br />
Dot <strong>and</strong> Keith Maynard<br />
at their farewell<br />
IMB Community Foundation announces grant of<br />
$3,500 for a Children’s Walk<br />
5<br />
Jenny Liney cuts the<br />
cake at the Seniors<br />
morning tea<br />
Group prune at workshop
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
PUTTING OUR MISSION STATEMENT INTO PRACTICE<br />
Conservation, Education, Recreation<br />
Conservation<br />
Funding through the Access Planning Action<br />
Committee of Council has been used to<br />
construct the first stage of the Sensory<br />
Garden. When completed, this garden will<br />
display up to 600 plants, selected for their<br />
tactile, visual <strong>and</strong> olfactory qualities. The<br />
garden will also feature sounds of running <strong>and</strong><br />
falling water, as well as paths of differing<br />
surfaces.<br />
The major rockwork, ponds <strong>and</strong> the pergola,<br />
<strong>and</strong> planting in all sections have been<br />
completed. By late summer 2007 it is expected<br />
that the plants will be sufficiently mature <strong>and</strong><br />
the official opening will take place at that time.<br />
Plans drawn by L<strong>and</strong>scape Architect Warwick<br />
Ralph (volunteer) for the Sensory Garden,<br />
Rainforest Garden <strong>and</strong> new S<strong>and</strong>stone Garden<br />
have guided all layout <strong>and</strong> planting. Warwick’s<br />
design for the interface between the Sensory<br />
<strong>and</strong> the Rainforest Garden means that visitors<br />
will be able to move seamlessly between the<br />
two.<br />
Unfortunately unsuitable drainage has resulted<br />
in major losses in the S<strong>and</strong>stone Garden near<br />
the Visitors Centre. Construction of a new<br />
garden with soil <strong>and</strong> drainage suitable for fussy<br />
s<strong>and</strong>stone species has commenced adjacent to<br />
the Xeriscape Garden, <strong>and</strong> the current garden<br />
will become home to the more robust species.<br />
One of the highlights of the year was the<br />
opening of the Bird Hide on Saturday 27 May.<br />
Rotary Batemans Bay gave generous financial<br />
assistance to make this venture possible, with<br />
the Friends contributing to the final fit-out.<br />
Building <strong>and</strong> adjacent l<strong>and</strong>scape work was<br />
done by volunteers. Over 400 plants had been<br />
planted in the two new gardens next to the<br />
northern lake to help to ensure that the 120<br />
species of birds recorded at the Gardens will<br />
keep coming.<br />
Invitations to the early morning opening <strong>and</strong><br />
breakfast were sent to Rotary Batemans Bay;<br />
Birds Australia offices in Sydney, Canberra<br />
<strong>and</strong> Melbourne; <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Natural History<br />
Society; Friends of ERBG; the Mayor <strong>and</strong><br />
<strong>Shire</strong> Councillors. Approximately 90 people<br />
attended. Guest speakers were Jill Whiter<br />
(<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Natural History Society) <strong>and</strong><br />
Maureen Manning (President, Rotary<br />
Batemans Bay). Eric Andrew provided bird<br />
photographs for the Bird Hide display boards.<br />
6<br />
With upgraded tracks <strong>and</strong> many new plantings,<br />
the Arboretum is beginning to mature,<br />
providing visitors with many examples of trees<br />
suitable for home gardens.<br />
To provide a focus for visitors, volunteers<br />
constructed an information gazebo. It was<br />
opened in September 2005.<br />
The gazebo is h<strong>and</strong>ed over by construction<br />
volunteers, Dave Fox <strong>and</strong> Geoff Boocock to Keith<br />
Maynard. Keith made the Arboretum his special<br />
project for many years.<br />
Artwork by local artist Denise Luke adorns the<br />
gazebo, comprising a map of the area <strong>and</strong> a<br />
rural scene of Buckenbowra valley.
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
A new feature of the Arboretum is the Grass<br />
Tree collection. Management Committee<br />
agreed to the purchase of mature specimens of<br />
these slow growing plants, for the seedlings<br />
grown some 10 years ago are still quite<br />
insignificant <strong>and</strong> will not provide a presence<br />
for many more years.<br />
Part of the Grass Tree collection<br />
An avenue of the Garden’s emblem,<br />
Burrawangs, Macrozamia communis has been<br />
planted in the Arboretum. The plants were<br />
sourced from a logging site in Mogo State<br />
Forest, <strong>and</strong> when established, will be a<br />
highlight with the associated Spotted Gums,<br />
Corymbia maculata.<br />
The Wisconsin mound, which disposes of the<br />
Gardens effluent, is 45 metres long <strong>and</strong> 12<br />
metres wide. Filtered water flows through an<br />
adjacent pond where further nutrient removal<br />
occurs before the water finds its way to a<br />
settling pond. Over 2,500 plants, grown by<br />
volunteers, have been planted on the mound<br />
<strong>and</strong> in adjacent garden beds to facilitate<br />
nutrient removal. The mound has been<br />
inspected by a number of local rural property<br />
holders who are faced with similar disposal<br />
problems.<br />
Who uses ERBG plants?<br />
At the ERBG nursery, volunteers work to<br />
produce plants for sale.<br />
As all the plants are native to the Region, sales<br />
help to spread the use of such plants in all parts<br />
of the Region <strong>and</strong> beyond. In 2005-<strong>06</strong> 18,667<br />
plants which left the nursery for use in public<br />
<strong>and</strong> private locations. The chart below shows<br />
where these plants were bound.<br />
L<strong>and</strong>care,<br />
Creekcare,<br />
Council,<br />
10,657<br />
Users of ERBG plants: 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
Planted at<br />
ERBG,<br />
2,472<br />
The plant propagation nursery area was<br />
exp<strong>and</strong>ed by building a retaining wall <strong>and</strong><br />
upgrading the gravel surface. This has allowed<br />
more of the larger plants to be held in good<br />
conditions.<br />
Volunteers made additional propagation<br />
benches so plants could be stored off the<br />
ground. These improve conditions for<br />
volunteers by making weeding <strong>and</strong> sorting<br />
more ergonomic, <strong>and</strong> for plants by improving<br />
soil drainage <strong>and</strong> reducing weed seed spread.<br />
Two plant collecting trips were made in<br />
November <strong>and</strong> December 2005:<br />
1. Big Badja Hill to take cutting material<br />
of endemic grevilleas. Other<br />
Herbarium collections were made at<br />
the same time.<br />
2. Monga National Park, firstly to find<br />
<strong>and</strong> take Herbarium specimens <strong>and</strong><br />
cutting material from another localised<br />
grevillea, <strong>and</strong> secondly to fill in gaps in<br />
the Herbarium collection.<br />
The report on the Herbarium appears on a<br />
later page.<br />
Public sales,<br />
5,108<br />
Donations,<br />
430<br />
Grasses <strong>and</strong> clumping plants on the Wisconsin mound<br />
7
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
Education<br />
Volunteer Guides<br />
The volunteer guides lead free regular walks<br />
every Sunday at <strong>11</strong>.00am. Eight groups were<br />
taken on specially booked walks at a charge of<br />
$3 per person. Autumn <strong>and</strong> spring appear to be<br />
the favoured times. The guides offered short<br />
walks on Seniors Day in April; helped with<br />
children’s puzzle activities on the Active<br />
Australia Family Picnic Day in September<br />
2005; <strong>and</strong> led walks for Friends <strong>and</strong> for<br />
'meeters <strong>and</strong> greeters' as part of their ongoing<br />
familiarisation <strong>and</strong> training at ERBG.<br />
Three guides attended the Australasian<br />
Conference of Voluntary Guides in Botanic<br />
Gardens in Melbourne in September 2005.<br />
Three guides were also amongst the nine<br />
representatives from ERBG at the BGANZ<br />
NSW Conference at Albury in May 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
Some of the ERBG participants at the<br />
Albury Conference<br />
The guides have all agreed to ‘adopt a track’,<br />
monitoring condition of signage on the gardens<br />
tracks <strong>and</strong> children’s puzzle clues where<br />
necessary. Meetings continue to be held on the<br />
second Saturday of the month when the walks<br />
roster is filled <strong>and</strong> training activities take place.<br />
The number of volunteer guides as at 1 July<br />
20<strong>06</strong> st<strong>and</strong>s at 10.<br />
Signage<br />
Our Gardens receives compliments from many<br />
visitors, in particular regarding the quality of<br />
our signage <strong>and</strong> the ease with which plants can<br />
be identified. Throughout the Gardens, 472<br />
new plant signs were installed to assist visitors<br />
identify those plants which they are interested<br />
in. Signage explaining the purpose of the<br />
Arboretum has been installed <strong>and</strong> is being<br />
upgraded as new plantings take place.<br />
8<br />
A large sign welcoming visitors, outlining<br />
'rules' <strong>and</strong> displaying the Gardens map in the<br />
car-park gazebo has been essential. A number<br />
of 'you are here' style signs have been updated<br />
in the Gardens. Noticeboards at the Visitors<br />
Centre <strong>and</strong> car-park gazebo continue to be<br />
updated with coming events <strong>and</strong> volunteer<br />
activities.<br />
Descriptive signs of plants for sale now include<br />
a photo of the plant in flower.<br />
Leaflets<br />
Four more puzzle walks for children have<br />
been prepared as well as several 'treasure hunt'<br />
style sheets <strong>and</strong> a colouring-in sheet.<br />
The Schools program continues with year<br />
four classes in the shire schools. The program<br />
emphasises enjoyment of <strong>and</strong> care for the<br />
environment <strong>and</strong> is organised <strong>and</strong> delivered by<br />
the Environment/Education Officer from ESC<br />
with assistance from Gardens volunteers.<br />
Management Committee was successful in its<br />
application for an IMB Community Foundation<br />
Grant amounting to $3500 for a Children’s<br />
Walk at the Gardens. The walk is designed to<br />
introduce children in an interactive <strong>and</strong> fun way<br />
to some local animals <strong>and</strong> the importance of<br />
their habitats. The opening is planned for early<br />
December 20<strong>06</strong>, in time for the summer school<br />
holidays.<br />
IMB Batemans Bay Manager Daniel Coffey with<br />
the walk designer, volunteer Margaret Lynch, <strong>and</strong><br />
children who will be keen to explore the new walk
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
Recreation<br />
Our focus is on improving the experience of<br />
all who visit: almost 3000 metres of Limited<br />
Mobility Tracks allow easy access to<br />
developed areas for everyone. Theme gardens<br />
along these tracks will add interest, the latest<br />
additions being the Sensory Garden <strong>and</strong><br />
Rainforest Garden at the western area.<br />
Active Australia Family Picnic Day: This day<br />
of varied entertainment held on 27 September<br />
was such a great success, attracting about 900<br />
visitors, that the <strong>Shire</strong> Council presented the<br />
Friends of the ERBG with the Community<br />
Event of the Year award at a ceremony on<br />
Australia Day 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
Entertainment at Family Picnic Day<br />
The Film Night organised for 12 November<br />
promised to be an exciting experience ‘for kids<br />
of all ages from two to ninety-two’according to<br />
ERBG’s media release. The Queensl<strong>and</strong> company,<br />
IntheBin, was engaged to screen a Festival<br />
of 12 of Australia's best short films created<br />
purely to entertain. The gates of the Gardens<br />
opened at 6.30 pm when 500 visitors could<br />
choose to enjoy a sausage sizzle <strong>and</strong> soft drinks<br />
organised by the Friends or bring a picnic.<br />
The raffle was generously supported by<br />
sponsors <strong>and</strong> those attending<br />
9<br />
Unfortunately, the heavens opened at 8.00 pm<br />
<strong>and</strong> the evening was washed out. However,<br />
IntheBin kindly agreed to a second visit in<br />
early December, when approximately 300<br />
people attended on a fine mild evening.<br />
Floodlights in the car park <strong>and</strong> low voltage<br />
lights across the entrance walkway were<br />
installed in time for this after dark<br />
entertainment, to ensure safe access to the<br />
Visitor Centre after hours. Sponsors Country<br />
Energy, Pierlite <strong>and</strong> Phillips, two electrician<br />
volunteers <strong>and</strong> the Friends made this possible.<br />
The annual Volunteers Thank you Lunch in<br />
early December was attended by about 60 of<br />
the over 100 eligible volunteers.<br />
Planning for our Seniors Day 5 April 20<strong>06</strong><br />
was aided by a grant from the NSW<br />
Department of Ageing, Disability <strong>and</strong> Home<br />
Care. About 35 volunteers <strong>and</strong> ESC staff<br />
were involved in entertaining <strong>and</strong> serving<br />
morning tea to approximately 250 people of<br />
whom residents of retirement villages <strong>and</strong><br />
nursing homes were a noticeable proportion,<br />
but probably not the most numerous.<br />
Four publicity articles appeared in the Bay<br />
Post over several days, <strong>and</strong> a ‘Thumbs Up’ to<br />
the volunteers afterwards. A limited mobility<br />
st<strong>and</strong>ard path across the lawn <strong>and</strong> fixed<br />
seating <strong>and</strong> tables in the barbecue shelter<br />
were completed just in time, <strong>and</strong> were much<br />
appreciated on a very warm day. Activities<br />
included Tai Chi, guided walks, a ceremonial<br />
tree planting <strong>and</strong> a display featuring sensory<br />
plants (colour, fragrance, texture, taste).<br />
Longst<strong>and</strong>ing volunteer Noel Murray gets<br />
ready to plant a tree on Seniors Day
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
20000<br />
18000<br />
16000<br />
<strong>14</strong>000<br />
12000<br />
10000<br />
8000<br />
6000<br />
4000<br />
2000<br />
0<br />
Management Plan for 20<strong>06</strong>-10 <strong>and</strong><br />
Annual Report 2004-05<br />
Council adopted these documents in<br />
February 20<strong>06</strong>. Advice to Council on matters<br />
raised in the Management Plan will be<br />
provided via annual reports.<br />
ERBG Web page<br />
The ERBG maintains a web site which is<br />
hosted on the ESC’s web site, at<br />
www.esc.nsw.gov.au/gardens. A significant<br />
number of changes have brought its content<br />
up to date, <strong>and</strong> amended its technical design.<br />
A simpler design with fewer photographs<br />
much compressed allows quick downloading<br />
by those who have low speed dial-up access.<br />
Peter Anderson, Secretary for the August<br />
2005 meeting, took on the technical design<br />
<strong>and</strong> made the changes. Sue Grahame updated<br />
the content <strong>and</strong> Audrey Walton provided<br />
many of the photos. Karen MacLatchy will<br />
make changes as requested <strong>and</strong> arrange<br />
updates with ESC staff. Google found the<br />
revised listing in 0.28 seconds.<br />
Towards additional indoor space<br />
The Management Plan noted that the Visitors<br />
Centre had become overcrowded <strong>and</strong> that<br />
additional space is required. A working party<br />
has met a number of times <strong>and</strong> is exploring<br />
options <strong>and</strong> possible funding, in association<br />
with ESC staff.<br />
Visitor Numbers 2001-<strong>06</strong><br />
2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
KEEPING THE WHEELS TURNING—ADMINISTRATIVE MATTERS<br />
10<br />
Special Events<br />
General Visitors<br />
The review date for the Café licence (August)<br />
was seen as an opportunity to re-consider the<br />
space reserved for Café operations exclusively.<br />
However, in April the Café licensee sought<br />
early release <strong>and</strong> from the agreed termination<br />
date, 31 May 20<strong>06</strong>, the Café has been operated<br />
by volunteers under Management Committee<br />
administration.<br />
Management Committee’s recommendation to<br />
Council on the licence arrangements that<br />
should apply is with Council officers. Council<br />
will seek expressions of interest ahead of the<br />
ESC’s decision on a new licensee.<br />
A related matter is inadequate electricity<br />
infrastructure for the Visitors Centre, <strong>and</strong> for<br />
events in or near the barbecue shelter. As<br />
ERBG’s power is supplied from Deep Creek<br />
Dam, an ESC facility, Country Energy is<br />
unable to assist. ESC’s Water <strong>and</strong> Sewer<br />
Operations Manager, Angus McLean, has<br />
advised that the power output at the Dam is the<br />
highest in the <strong>Shire</strong> <strong>and</strong> therefore ERBG could<br />
draw more power from it. As a first step, an<br />
ERBG volunteer who is a qualified electrician<br />
will assist with drawing up specifications.
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
Computers, software <strong>and</strong> related<br />
hardware<br />
The computer facilities serve the needs of the<br />
Herbarium, staff, <strong>and</strong> volunteers. Volunteers<br />
maintain databases, prepare <strong>and</strong> print<br />
Arboretum <strong>and</strong> other signs, children’s puzzles,<br />
letters <strong>and</strong> invitations.<br />
The ERBG may be able to benefit from the<br />
ESC computer upgrade program: Leisa<br />
Brennan is investigating this with ESC IT staff.<br />
Adequate updated software also needs to be<br />
acquired, preferably as part of Council IT<br />
arrangements. The Herbarium requires high<br />
quality computing resources <strong>and</strong> it was<br />
agreed that, if necessary, separate funds<br />
should be sought for appropriate computing<br />
facilities.<br />
The Internet connection at the ERBG is dialup<br />
<strong>and</strong> very slow because pair gain has been<br />
used to provide enough telephone lines for<br />
the site. Broadb<strong>and</strong> is not available <strong>and</strong> a<br />
satellite connection would not be cost<br />
effective.<br />
Hiring Arrangements<br />
Hiring of space in the Gardens for weddings<br />
<strong>and</strong> other ceremonies has been made part of a<br />
<strong>Shire</strong>-wide approach to the hiring of public<br />
facilities operated by the Council. The ERBG<br />
brochure for ceremonies, including<br />
weddings, has been revised so it can be part<br />
of a ‘package’ for members of the public<br />
who make enquiries. Fees set by ESC are<br />
consistent with its policies for other areas.<br />
The arrangement is that people who seek to<br />
hold weddings or other ceremonies in the<br />
ERBG will first contact the ERBG to check<br />
the date <strong>and</strong> time, <strong>and</strong> then the ESC officer<br />
located at the Batemans Bay Community<br />
Centre (BBCC) who will give them an<br />
information kit. Payments may be made in<br />
person to the BBCC. Weddings <strong>and</strong> other<br />
ceremonies may be held within ERBG<br />
opening hours. If ceremonies run over time,<br />
ESC will bill the person/group concerned for<br />
staff support hours.<br />
Volunteer arrangements <strong>and</strong> support<br />
A new volunteer application form has been<br />
designed <strong>and</strong> is available from the ERBG, the<br />
Batemans Bay Community Centre, <strong>and</strong> the<br />
ERBG web pages.<br />
<strong>Works</strong>hops for outdoor volunteers were held<br />
once a month from February.<br />
Management committee has agreed that more<br />
structure is needed to support volunteers, such as<br />
job descriptions; <strong>and</strong> to streamline<br />
administration, for instance through a Microsoft<br />
Access database. It is proposed that a working<br />
party would look at ERBG policy materials <strong>and</strong><br />
those of RBG Sydney, <strong>and</strong> seek assistance from<br />
ESC’s community services area which has<br />
recently put updated material to Council. Once<br />
background work has been done, the ERBG may<br />
take up the offer of a visit/workshop from a staff<br />
member of RBG Sydney, arising out of the 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Albury Conference of Botanic Gardens of<br />
Australia <strong>and</strong> New Zeal<strong>and</strong>, NSW branch.<br />
<strong>11</strong><br />
Extract from volunteer application form<br />
Recognition of funds from external sources<br />
When seeking sponsors it is important to have a<br />
clear policy on recognition of funds from<br />
external sources: this was a clear message from<br />
the Albury Conference. The sponsorship <strong>and</strong><br />
recognition policies agreed over the years have<br />
been collated, will be reviewed at an early<br />
opportunity, <strong>and</strong> implemented with appropriate<br />
publicity for sponsorship opportunities.
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
John Knight has been a passionate advocate for Australian native plants for over thirty years, <strong>and</strong><br />
that passion was rewarded last week when John joined a very select b<strong>and</strong> of horticulturists to be<br />
honoured with an Australian Plants Award.<br />
Awarded every two years by the Association of Societies for Growing Australian Plants, John is one<br />
of only two professionals in his field chosen for the national award. The award recognises John’s<br />
contribution to the knowledge of Australian plants in the course of a notable professional career<br />
spanning thirty years in the natural science field.<br />
Photo: Ben Eyles<br />
HONOUR FOR GARDENS SUPERVISOR<br />
National award for Knight of the Gardens<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Media Release 12 October 2005<br />
as printed in the Bay Post 19 October 2005<br />
GREEN THUMB: John Knight is a passionate advocate<br />
for Australian native plants<br />
John is the head horticulturist at <strong>Eurobodalla</strong>’s own Regional Botanic Gardens, <strong>and</strong> believes that<br />
using indigenous plants should be more widely promoted in municipal <strong>and</strong> other parks. This<br />
philosophy is reflected in his work at the Botanic Gardens <strong>and</strong> at the Karwarra Garden in Victoria,<br />
which John had a h<strong>and</strong> in rebuilding.<br />
John has also been generous in sharing his knowledge through adult education, conferences,<br />
workshops, <strong>and</strong> as leader of the Boronia <strong>and</strong> Allied Genera Study Group for many years.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Councillors were delighted to hear of John’s award at yesterday’s <strong>Works</strong><br />
Committee meeting. Mayor Neil Mumme said that Council is fortunate to have people like John who<br />
are so committed to their work.<br />
12
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
The framework for the Gardens development<br />
<strong>and</strong> maintenance program is a collaborative<br />
effort between the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council<br />
<strong>and</strong> the ERBG Management Committee. The<br />
Management Plan, endorsed by Council, sets<br />
out both short-term <strong>and</strong> long-term goals for<br />
development <strong>and</strong> maintenance of the site.<br />
Work is undertaken with regard to the<br />
availability of resources <strong>and</strong> Council’s policies<br />
regarding Occupational Health <strong>and</strong> Safety, <strong>and</strong><br />
current best practice procedures. Day to day<br />
management of the Gardens is the<br />
responsibility of the Gardens Supervisor,<br />
assisted by staff <strong>and</strong> volunteers.<br />
Staffing<br />
The Gardens has two full-time permanent<br />
staff, the Gardens Supervisor, John Knight,<br />
<strong>and</strong> the Gardens Labourer, Dugald Bennett.<br />
Laurie Ball, a casual employee sourced<br />
through Campbell Page, works most<br />
Saturdays, as well as volunteering for two<br />
days a week.<br />
Our Horticulture Apprentice, Ryan Harris,<br />
continues to impress with his commitment <strong>and</strong><br />
enthusiasm, not only at the Gardens but also in<br />
his after-hours surveying <strong>and</strong> collecting in<br />
local forests. Ryan is also achieving excellent<br />
results at TAFE.<br />
The number of volunteer workers continues to<br />
grow steadily, with over 120 assisting during<br />
the year. It is a worthwhile investment of<br />
management time to ensure that the volunteers<br />
are engaged in suitable <strong>and</strong> meaningful tasks<br />
to suit their varied skills, while adhering to<br />
Council’s OH&S policies.<br />
Gardens development program<br />
Work continues to upgrade some of the major<br />
walking tracks to Limited Mobility St<strong>and</strong>ard,<br />
with almost 3000 metres now completed. All<br />
new track work will be similarly designed to<br />
ensure safe access for all visitors.<br />
Site maintenance<br />
St<strong>and</strong>ard Operation Procedures have been<br />
developed for general maintenance of the site.<br />
All areas open to the public are inspected at<br />
least once a week, <strong>and</strong> more often during<br />
stormy, windy or wet weather. Risk<br />
assessment analysis for all works is<br />
undertaken by staff, <strong>and</strong> volunteers are<br />
encouraged to assist in this process, giving<br />
them ownership of any works they are<br />
associated with.<br />
MANAGEMENT OF THE GARDENS<br />
13<br />
Walking tracks<br />
The bush tracks <strong>and</strong> the gardens tracks are<br />
kept in good repair. The bush tracks are<br />
inspected twice a week, repaired as needed<br />
<strong>and</strong> debris removed. Bush tracks are closed to<br />
the public on days of Total Fire Ban, <strong>and</strong> also<br />
during windy weather, to ensure the safety of<br />
visitors. Gravel paths throughout the Gardens<br />
are raked regularly to prevent build up of<br />
debris. We are lucky to have several<br />
volunteers who like to rake paths, <strong>and</strong> there is<br />
talk of ‘the golden rake’. A program of gravel<br />
renewal is undertaken to ensure the tracks are<br />
in a safe condition for all users. Regular<br />
inspections are made of the many large old<br />
trees to ensure dangerous limbs are removed.<br />
Fire management<br />
The emergency generator is started weekly,<br />
<strong>and</strong> the sprinkler lines operated along the<br />
creek lines to ensure successful management<br />
of fire if it were to occur. All fire trails <strong>and</strong> fire<br />
lines are cleared twice each year, in August<br />
<strong>and</strong> December, to ensure ready access for<br />
vehicles. Clearing involves removal of debris,<br />
mowing or slashing to 50mm high, <strong>and</strong> cutting<br />
back of encroaching plants to keep the tracks<br />
at the required width for safe passage of fire<br />
vehicles.<br />
Plans for hazard reduction burns in the<br />
prescribed area were again thwarted this year<br />
due to rain in the weeks prior to <strong>and</strong> after the<br />
proposed burn. To overcome the lack of<br />
burning, further slashing was undertaken to<br />
reduce the height of ground flora. This work is<br />
believed to be sufficient to satisfy the<br />
requirements of reducing the fire risk. Within<br />
the high visitation sites, open areas of gravel,<br />
irrigated lawn <strong>and</strong> low mass foliage are<br />
maintained to assist in controlling wildfire<br />
should such an event occur.<br />
Pest <strong>and</strong> animal control<br />
Termite inspections of the Visitors Centre <strong>and</strong><br />
the Residence were completed as required.<br />
Despite the site having many trees harbouring<br />
termite colonies, no evidence of termites was<br />
found in the buildings.<br />
Rabbits continue to inhabit the site in low<br />
numbers. Damage is minimal to date, but the<br />
situation is constantly monitored, <strong>and</strong><br />
appropriate action is taken to prevent a build<br />
up of their population.
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
Wallabies are causing more <strong>and</strong> more damage<br />
as their population builds, continually<br />
damaging new plantings. With the surrounding<br />
bush areas providing little food, more wallabies<br />
have come onto the site putting further pressure<br />
on our young plants. Of more concern is that<br />
plants thought to be safe from attack, especially<br />
those in the Proteaceae Family, are being<br />
continually browsed, leaving little energy for<br />
the plants to grow away. The permanent fence<br />
around the Arboretum will protect the<br />
developing gardens, <strong>and</strong> other measures such<br />
as foliage treatment are being trialled where<br />
fencing is impractical.<br />
Kangaroo numbers have also increased<br />
dramatically, with mobs rather than single<br />
animals regularly mowing the open grassed<br />
areas. While they do little damage to plants,<br />
they sometimes break plants by jumping on<br />
them. It is unlikely that we can keep either<br />
wallabies or kangaroos out of the gardens.<br />
Monitoring their numbers <strong>and</strong> seeking<br />
assistance from the Dept of Environment <strong>and</strong><br />
Heritage in managing the animals is all that can<br />
be realistically done at this time.<br />
Building <strong>and</strong> facilities maintenance<br />
Regular inspections are made of all buildings,<br />
including the Visitors Centre, to ensure the<br />
value of the asset is not diminished. Attention<br />
is paid to guttering <strong>and</strong> drainage around the site<br />
to prevent damage to foundations.<br />
A leak from the ceiling in the Visitors Centre<br />
breezeway has been drawn to the attention of<br />
Council’s <strong>Facilities</strong> Management Officer.<br />
16,000<br />
<strong>14</strong>,000<br />
12,000<br />
10,000<br />
8,000<br />
6,000<br />
4,000<br />
2,000<br />
0<br />
Weed management<br />
All instances of major weed infestation are<br />
addressed as soon as they become apparent. No<br />
notifiable weeds are known to occur on the site,<br />
although a range of pasture weeds have<br />
established small populations following the<br />
importation of soil. These weeds are eradicated<br />
before they have a chance to become a<br />
maintenance problem. Garden beds are kept as<br />
clean as practicable, with the resources<br />
available.<br />
Volunteers mulch ‘Ruth’s garden’<br />
Volunteer Hours by Year 2001-<strong>06</strong><br />
‘Adopt a garden’<br />
It is pleasing that so many volunteers have<br />
agreed to ‘adopt a garden’, taking on<br />
responsibility for weeding, mulching, pruning,<br />
replacement planting <strong>and</strong> whatever is<br />
necessary. The garden volunteers have<br />
appreciated the workshops given by John<br />
Knight <strong>and</strong> Ryan Harris on a range of subjects<br />
including weed recognition <strong>and</strong> eradication,<br />
plant propagation, pruning, plant identification<br />
<strong>and</strong> recording. They are building up confidence<br />
to take on projects, <strong>and</strong> enjoying helping each<br />
other with ‘their’ gardens when two or more<br />
makes lighter work.<br />
2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
<strong>14</strong>
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
Bev Anderson<br />
Peter Anderson<br />
Cyril Appleby<br />
Judy Appleby<br />
Carol Ball<br />
Laurie Ball<br />
June Bates<br />
Kath Beare<br />
Ruth Beeren<br />
Jo Benyon<br />
Ellen Birrell<br />
Margaret Blacksell<br />
Richard Blacksell<br />
Geoff Boocock<br />
Don Brewster<br />
John Buchanan<br />
Sybil Buchanan<br />
Helen Byrne<br />
Jim Byrne<br />
Brian Cant<br />
Noela Cant<br />
Isabel Carey<br />
Ken Carey<br />
Ian Cargill<br />
Margaret Carney<br />
Owen Cartledge<br />
Bill Carter<br />
Margaret Cherry<br />
Tom Cherry<br />
Karen Cockerill<br />
Bruce Cox<br />
Helen Cox<br />
VOLUNTEERS 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
Jock Cumming<br />
Margaret Cumming<br />
Geraldine Currie<br />
John Davis<br />
Jenny Edwards<br />
Rob Edwards<br />
Annabel Fox<br />
David Fox<br />
Jennifer Fraser<br />
Margaret Geddes<br />
Joan George<br />
Sue Grahame<br />
Gabriele Harding<br />
Mark Harris<br />
Lyndall Hatch<br />
Heather Haughton<br />
Peter Haughton<br />
Hazel Henry<br />
Heather Hilliard<br />
Graham Hogg<br />
Margaret Hogg<br />
Marion Holl<strong>and</strong><br />
Tristan Hoy<br />
Bob Hughes<br />
Lesley Hul<strong>and</strong>s<br />
Norm Hul<strong>and</strong>s<br />
Brenda Inwards<br />
Agnieszka Jablonska<br />
Jean Kenway<br />
Leonie Kestel<br />
Jean Konkes<br />
Jenny Liney<br />
John Liney<br />
Bill Lloyd<br />
Margaret Lloyd<br />
Leslie Lockwood<br />
Don Loudon<br />
Margaret Lynch<br />
Sharon Macdonald<br />
Karen MacLatchy<br />
Audrey Maher<br />
Dorothy Maynard<br />
Keith Maynard<br />
Margaret McClintock<br />
Marietta McGregor<br />
Sally McDonald<br />
Graham McKenzie<br />
Leslie McKenzie<br />
Elizabeth Mitchell<br />
Geoff Mitchell<br />
Helen Moore<br />
Virginia Moore<br />
Ainslie Morris<br />
Cecelia Moschitz<br />
Noel Murray<br />
Jean Pengilly<br />
Malcolm Pengilly<br />
Lauren Peri<br />
Alison Powell<br />
Bob Pulford<br />
Ruth Pulford<br />
Warwick Ralph<br />
Helen Rees<br />
Helen Rees jnr<br />
Volunteer working hours Year to Year comparison<br />
Barbara Roberts<br />
Gaetan Rouillon<br />
Pauline Rouillon<br />
Josef Saunders-Kowal<br />
Bob Scott<br />
Helen Scott<br />
Janet Simpson<br />
Christine Slack<br />
Roy Starkey<br />
Bernard Stauce<br />
Bob Stephens<br />
Myf Thompson<br />
Jean Thomson<br />
Judy Thomson<br />
Bob Tomkins<br />
Laurie Tooley<br />
Marjorie Tooley<br />
Brian Versey<br />
Jenny Vine<br />
Ralph Vine<br />
Fay Vonthethoff<br />
Janet Vost<br />
Leila Walker<br />
David Wallace<br />
Audrey Walton<br />
Don Walton<br />
Andy Wass<br />
Val Wass<br />
Sarah Wilkie-Snow<br />
Joy Williams<br />
Rob Williams<br />
Job 2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-<strong>06</strong> % of total % Last year<br />
Administration 249 <strong>14</strong>3 345 561 1240 8.69% 4.4%<br />
Information 2820 2223 1932 1874 1988 13.93% <strong>14</strong>.7%<br />
Guides 509 261 356 2.50% 2.0%<br />
Education 599 175 294 325 344 2.41% 2.5%<br />
Herbarium <strong>11</strong>81 809 738 941 <strong>11</strong>05 7.74% 7.4%<br />
Nursery 2328 2268 1862 1964 1784 12.50% 15.4%<br />
Data input <strong>11</strong>51 173 159 1.<strong>11</strong>% 1.4%<br />
Construction 727 472 370 856 917 6.43% 6.7%<br />
Develop gardens <strong>14</strong>6 103 625 595 856 6.00% 4.7%<br />
Develop tracks 949 1394 1038 7.28% 10.9%<br />
Maintain Arboretum 425 261 566 675 841 5.89% 5.3%<br />
Maintain gardens 948 1030 1280 1630 2038 <strong>14</strong>.28% 12.8%<br />
Maintain tracks 259 <strong>11</strong>91 493 626 729 5.<strong>11</strong>% 4.9%<br />
Maintenance, general 6<strong>06</strong> 269 660 6<strong>14</strong> 396 2.78% 4.8%<br />
Maintain roads 10 22 263 1.84% 0.2%<br />
Fire mitigation 62 43 68 238 2<strong>14</strong> 1.50% 1.9%<br />
Total <strong>11</strong>501 8987 10701 12749 <strong>14</strong>268 100% 100%<br />
15
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
REPORT AGAINST MANAGEMENT PLAN PERFORMANCE INDICATORS<br />
Performance indicator Work in progress<br />
Gardens Development<br />
Complete list of projects in Management Plan within<br />
the timelines, where shown<br />
Consider other proposals when sponsors come<br />
forward with proposals<br />
Undertake maintenance of the buildings, paths, <strong>and</strong><br />
other facilities in accordance with an annual program<br />
that reflects immediate priorities<br />
Preliminary discussions held on improving access<br />
Lighting installed in the car-park<br />
Sensory Garden under construction, to be opened in late summer 2007<br />
Bird Hide completed; officially opened May 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Rainforest Gardens being constructed <strong>and</strong> planted<br />
Re-development of old nursery as a fern garden planned<br />
Path <strong>and</strong> track network progressively developed<br />
Initial design work on the Geology Garden to be undertaken 20<strong>06</strong>-07<br />
Propagation nursery space for holding plants improved<br />
No external sponsors have come forward with proposals<br />
On-going<br />
Undertake planting 3,000 plants, on average, per year Fewer plants required for 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
Visitor numbers<br />
Five per cent increase per year General visitor numbers increased by 7%<br />
Banners erected on Highway<br />
Volunteers on duty every day the Gardens is open to inform visitors<br />
Media publicity for all special events<br />
Education functions<br />
Extend quality <strong>and</strong> quantity of school visits IMB Children’s Walk will extend quality of school visits as relevant<br />
to curriculum.<br />
Review content <strong>and</strong> style of brochures On-going. Several new brochures designed <strong>and</strong> printed.<br />
Provide signs <strong>and</strong> explanatory information New signs <strong>and</strong> explanatory information installed<br />
Conservation functions<br />
Propagation <strong>and</strong> sales of regional plants On-going<br />
Consultation with local nurseries Will depend on staff <strong>and</strong> volunteer resources<br />
Maintain contact with ESC officers On-going. Active liaison on L<strong>and</strong>care <strong>and</strong> Creekcare projects<br />
Herbarium activity On-going. Herbarium Curator awarded NSW Senior Citizen award.<br />
Surveys undertaken for ESC.<br />
Demonstrate conservation practices On-going through Xeriscape Garden <strong>and</strong> Wisconsin Mound.<br />
Management <strong>and</strong> quality assurance functions<br />
Discussions on the nature, siting <strong>and</strong> possible<br />
funding of more indoor space<br />
Prepare a longer-term maintenance plan for<br />
discussion with ESC<br />
Provide support for volunteers <strong>and</strong> report annually<br />
on numbers <strong>and</strong> hours worked<br />
Discussions have commenced. Recommendation to ESC re Café.<br />
Discussions have commenced<br />
Report given in this Annual Report<br />
Host 2008 BGANZ conference Preliminary discussions have been held<br />
Arrange ceremony Sensory Garden opening Ceremony will be held in late summer 2007<br />
Prepare <strong>and</strong> print publicity material On-going<br />
Develop a longer-term strategy for increasing the use<br />
of ERBG for formal education<br />
Analyse <strong>and</strong> summarise the formal <strong>and</strong> informal<br />
feedback from visitors<br />
In abeyance until topic of increased indoor space has made progress<br />
To be undertaken once café has been re-opened<br />
16
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
FINANCIALS<br />
ERBG Budget 2005-<strong>06</strong> $ $<br />
Operations Income Expenditure<br />
ESC operations contribution 250,761.56<br />
Gardens income 26,786.00<br />
Operations funds available 277,547.56<br />
Operations expenditure 278,090.09<br />
Capital works<br />
Council contribution (Sensory Garden) 20,000.00<br />
APAC contribution (Sensory Garden) 8,865.00<br />
Friends donations 16,800.00<br />
Rotary Batemans Bay donation 4,000.00<br />
Capital works funds available 49,665.00<br />
Capital works expenditure 48,927.15<br />
Total budget 327,212.56<br />
Total expenditure 327,017.24<br />
Management Committee Account 30 June 20<strong>06</strong><br />
The accounts of ERBG are operated within the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council financial system. The table below<br />
provides details only in respect of the funds under Management Committee control.<br />
Opening Balance 1 July 2005 17,679.40<br />
Plus income<br />
Interest 1,204.87<br />
Donations 8,000.00 * Rotary Batemans Bay for Bird Hide<br />
<strong>and</strong> Rainforest Garden<br />
Grant funds, Seniors week 500.00<br />
Events income 2,749.22<br />
Hire fees 227.27<br />
Other income 558.18<br />
Sub total 13,239.54<br />
Total 30,918.94<br />
Less expenses<br />
Capital project (Bird Hide) 4,000.00<br />
Volunteer Training 2,910.80<br />
Education expenses 1<strong>14</strong>.76 from Charcoalition contribution<br />
Maintenance & repairs 289.10<br />
Meeting expenses 230.50<br />
Licence fees 134.92<br />
Advertising 101.81<br />
Gardens Projects 1,713.64<br />
Stationery 129.01<br />
Events expenses 2,157.10<br />
Sub total <strong>11</strong>,781.64<br />
Total funds 19,137.30<br />
add Café balance 354.29<br />
Total funds 19,491.59<br />
Less commitments<br />
Grant 3,290.92<br />
Rolled over. To be spent on car<br />
park gardens<br />
Education grant 1,880.56 Balance of grant<br />
Project funds 1,726.31 Friends contributions for projects<br />
Rainforest Garden 4,000.00<br />
Total commitments 10,897.79<br />
Funds available 8,593.80<br />
*This sum represents donations made to the Management Committee. Donations for capital works <strong>and</strong> other specific<br />
purposes are placed in appropriate ESC accounts when work begins on particular projects.<br />
17
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
HERBARIUM<br />
Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
This is my thirteenth Annual Report as Honorary Curator of the Wallace Herbarium at ERBG.<br />
In late 2005, we were asked to lend our support to a proposal that argued against the re-naming of most of the<br />
Australian Acacia genera. We composed a persuasive e-mail; this, together with about 200 other e-mails <strong>and</strong> support<br />
from the international botanic community, managed to persuade the International Council of Botanic Nomenclature<br />
not to re-name the majority of the Australian genera. So all the Acacia species in our Region will remain Acacia.<br />
In February 20<strong>06</strong>, the Centre for Plant Biodiversity Research (National Herbarium) in Canberra called us, to ask for<br />
locations of an uncommon native Hibiscus species. On two field trips, the second in company with the botanists<br />
from Canberra, we found some specimens growing, some about to flower. We were asked us to collect seeds for a<br />
research project, which in due course we did. Later, Canberra requested the loan of some of our Herbarium<br />
specimens of another Hibiscus species for a PhD student to work with. I feel that this kind of activity connects us<br />
with the wider, professional botanic world.<br />
Four vegetation surveys were conducted for the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council: a follow-up of Coila Lake saltmarsh, a<br />
wide-ranging survey of the Yarragee Reserve, work on some of the Narooma Council Reserves <strong>and</strong> a quick<br />
inventory of the Surf Beach Reserve. Information <strong>and</strong> reports are used by Council officers to assess the value of<br />
natural vegetation remnants when compiling grant proposals. All this activity earned income for the Friends of the<br />
ERBG. The species lists will be useful to us in the future, especially for any work done on weeds.<br />
For a long time I have wanted to produce distribution maps for selected species, but had neither the time nor the<br />
expertise to do so. Early this year, I contacted the Council staff member who works with their Geographical<br />
Information System. He explained how to present our database to enable maps to be drawn. A new Gardens<br />
volunteer spent a considerable amount of time making the necessary adjustments to our computer records. The next<br />
step is to show this to the Council staff member, <strong>and</strong> see how it goes from there.<br />
It is estimated that in the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Region between 1,700 <strong>and</strong> 2,000 plant species might occur, so our collection<br />
represents between 73% <strong>and</strong> 85% of all indigenous plants thought to grow locally. There has not been a great deal of<br />
collecting since my last report; efforts are concentrated on adding new data rather than covering old ground, all the<br />
easy places having been visited; <strong>and</strong> Gardens staff <strong>and</strong> volunteers have been very busy developing new features in<br />
the Gardens. When the current spate of work slows down, <strong>and</strong> the weather is warmer <strong>and</strong> days longer, we should be<br />
able to plan some trips.<br />
We have begun collecting voucher specimens from plants in the Gardens, so that we have an identification number<br />
linking all the named plants to a dried specimen in the Herbarium. However, pressure of other work <strong>and</strong> events has<br />
prevented much progress being made. We hope to further this project in the coming year.<br />
We continue to send surplus specimens to ANBG Canberra <strong>and</strong> to the RBG Sydney as donations. Canberra also<br />
gives us great assistance in identifying difficult species. The ERBG Herbarium made approximately 70 plant<br />
identifications at public request.<br />
Collection figures are as shown in the table:<br />
Volunteer hours in the Herbarium totalled <strong>11</strong>05 for the period.<br />
My thanks go to Karen MacLatchy, Helen Moore, Brian Cant <strong>and</strong> David<br />
Wallace for giving more of their time than I would expect, to Mark Harris<br />
for work on the database, to Don Walton for his ongoing support, <strong>and</strong> to<br />
John Knight <strong>and</strong> Ryan Harris for their helpfulness <strong>and</strong> co-operation.<br />
Jennifer Liney<br />
Herbarium Curator<br />
30 June 20<strong>06</strong><br />
18<br />
31 August 2005 - 30 June 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Total<br />
Specimens<br />
9,617 9,856<br />
Families 173 174<br />
Genera 617 622<br />
Species 1,445 1,460<br />
Fungi 794 797
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
FRIENDS OF THE EUROBODALLA REGIONAL BOTANIC GARDENS<br />
Report for the ERBG Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
The Friends support <strong>and</strong> promote the ERBG aims to the community, <strong>and</strong> provide a source of volunteer<br />
assistance for many programs. Membership of the Friends continues to grow with 35 new members joining<br />
this year, bringing our numbers to 3<strong>06</strong> including six corporate members.<br />
The Friends Committee meets monthly to monitor its own activities <strong>and</strong> to discuss the most appropriate<br />
ways of assisting Gardens staff <strong>and</strong> the Management Committee to achieve their aims. Informative quarterly<br />
newsletters are sent to all members, Management Committee, <strong>Shire</strong> Councillors <strong>and</strong> those <strong>Shire</strong> staff who<br />
through their work interact with ERBG staff.<br />
During the past year, four public meetings were held at the Gardens. Besides updating members <strong>and</strong> visitors<br />
on what is happening at ERBG, these meetings present an ideal forum for those attending to seek more indepth<br />
information about the Friends <strong>and</strong> volunteering. Guest speakers provided a range of entertaining<br />
topics. These included foundation member Helen Rees, who spoke of her exciting travels to Warburton in<br />
the Gibson Desert; Council’s Weeds Officer, Graham Harding, who described the noxious weeds of the<br />
south coast, <strong>and</strong> the current eradication program; our Gardens Supervisor, John Knight, who provided an<br />
overview of the plants <strong>and</strong> birdlife of Lord Howe Isl<strong>and</strong>; <strong>and</strong> Kath Lawler from Moruya who detailed the<br />
development <strong>and</strong> use of the bridle trails through the rugged south coast ranges.<br />
Friends also supported special events such as the Family Picnic Day <strong>and</strong> ‘IntheBin’ film nights.<br />
One of the Friends’ main aims is to raise funds to assist with development works at the Gardens. To this<br />
end, members who are on the Management Committee’s sub-committees discuss those projects from the<br />
approved works list which would benefit from additional funding to see them to completion. <strong>Works</strong> funded<br />
this year were:<br />
Upgrade of the Arboretum tracks $ 4,000<br />
Seating in the BBQ area $ 1,000<br />
Fit-out of the Bird Hide $ 300<br />
Improvements to the information alcove $ 1,200<br />
Upgrade of the propagation benches $ 1,500<br />
Improvements to the nursery $ 4,000<br />
Nursery purchases $ 1,000<br />
Capital equipment purchases $ 3,000<br />
Total funding for 2005 - <strong>06</strong> was $16,000<br />
Commitments to 20<strong>06</strong>-07 projects:<br />
Fencing of Arboretum $ 5,000<br />
Repairs to Deep Creek bridge at Hill Track $ 5,000<br />
Visitors Centre lake garden $ 2,000<br />
BBQ area garden development $ 2,000<br />
Capital equipment purchases $ 3,000<br />
Commitments to future projects:<br />
Geology Garden $ 7,000<br />
Building contingency fund $50,000<br />
The Friends hold Deductible Gift Recipient status, <strong>and</strong> presently hold funds of $8,500 in the Gift Trust<br />
Account. This amount is also available for Gardens projects as requested by the Management Committee<br />
<strong>and</strong> agreed to by the Trustees <strong>and</strong> Friends.<br />
A complete report on the activities of the Friends is provided in their 2005–<strong>06</strong> Annual Report.<br />
Don Walton<br />
President<br />
19
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
APPENDIX 1<br />
ERBG Management Committee<br />
July 2005 to June 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Committee members at 30 June 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Chris Kowal Councillor, ESC<br />
Allan Brown Councillor, ESC (alternate)<br />
Jennifer Liney Friends of the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens<br />
Don Walton Friends of the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens<br />
Don Brewster Community (Secretary, December 05, leave of absence<br />
mid March – mid July)<br />
Heather Haughton Community (appointed October 05)<br />
(Acting Secretary during Don Brewster’s leave of absence)<br />
Margaret Lynch Community (appointed October 05)<br />
Sue Grahame Community (Chair, re-elected December 05 for a further year)<br />
Committee members who served during the year<br />
Peter Anderson (Secretary July – August 05)<br />
Owen Cartledge (resigned September 05)<br />
Leslie Lockwood (resigned October 05)<br />
Marietta McGregor (resigned December 05)<br />
ESC staff who attend meetings:<br />
John Knight Gardens Supervisor<br />
Leisa Brennan Recreation Coordinator<br />
Composition of Management Committee<br />
The ESC agreed, 8 February 2005, that the ERBG Management Committee would comprise:<br />
(a) two members nominated by the Friends of the ERBG;<br />
(b) two members nominated by Council who shall be elected Councillors (one delegate,<br />
one alternate);<br />
(c) up to six members from the community, appointed on a skills basis; <strong>and</strong><br />
(d) one member to be the Honorary Secretary.<br />
Membership of sub-committees July 2005 to June 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Administration sub-committee<br />
Convener: Sue Grahame from October 2005<br />
Leslie Lockwood to October 2005<br />
Don Brewster<br />
Heather Haughton (Friends nominee) from August 05<br />
Friends nominee to be appointed<br />
one vacancy<br />
Gardens Supervisor John Knight ex officio<br />
Gardens sub-committee<br />
Convener: Jennifer Liney<br />
Don Walton (Friends nominee)<br />
Helen Rees (Friends nominee)<br />
Gabriele Harding<br />
Keith Maynard (to end May <strong>06</strong>)<br />
Joan George (from June <strong>06</strong>)<br />
Gardens Supervisor John Knight ex officio<br />
Interpretation <strong>and</strong> Education sub-committee<br />
Convener: Margaret Lynch from September 2005<br />
Owen Cartledge to September 2005<br />
Sue Grahame<br />
Isabel Carey (Friends nominee) from July 05<br />
Friends nominee to be appointed<br />
one vacancy<br />
20
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens Annual Report 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
Promotion <strong>and</strong> Fundraising sub-committee<br />
Convener: Heather Haughton from October 2005<br />
Marietta McGregor to October 2005<br />
Leslie Lockwood to October 2005<br />
Audrey Walton (Friends nominee)<br />
Jean Pengilly (Friends nominee)<br />
Sharon Macdonald from March 20<strong>06</strong><br />
ESC Recreation Coordinator Leisa Brennan ex officio<br />
Events Working Party<br />
varies with event <strong>and</strong> volunteers are listed on a separate page<br />
APPENDIX 2<br />
Sponsors 2005-<strong>06</strong><br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Gardens maintenance <strong>and</strong> development<br />
See page 17<br />
Friends of the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens $16,000 for many projects See page 16<br />
Access Planning Action Committee, ESC $10,000 for Sensory Garden<br />
Rotary Batemans Bay $4,000 for Bird Hide, <strong>and</strong> $4,000 for<br />
Rainforest Garden, both along Rotary<br />
Limited Mobility Track<br />
IMB Community Foundation $3,500, announced 27 June 20<strong>06</strong>, for a<br />
Children’s Walk at the Gardens<br />
NSW Department of Ageing, Disability <strong>and</strong> Home Care $500 plus GST for Seniors Week event<br />
Pierlite <strong>and</strong> Phillips <strong>and</strong> Ian Aitken Floodlights for car park: installation<br />
Country Energy Poles for floodlights in car park including<br />
pole installation<br />
Warwick Ralph Designs for Sensory Garden, Rainforest<br />
Garden<br />
Gabriele Harding Designs for Sensory Garden, Fern Garden<br />
Woolworths, Batemans Bay Generous amount of biscuits for Seniors<br />
Day morning tea<br />
Angus <strong>and</strong> Robertson; Australian Native Plants Society,<br />
Canberra Region; Bay Bookshop; Bloomin Things<br />
Nursery; Coles; C Wirth of Chef’s Cap Café; Friends of<br />
the ERBG; M <strong>and</strong> J Harris of Malua Bay Supermarket;<br />
Mogo Zoo; Mother Natures; <strong>and</strong> individual volunteers<br />
ERBG OPENING HOURS AND CONTACTS<br />
Wednesday to Sunday, <strong>and</strong> every day of the NSW school holidays: 9.00am - 4.00pm<br />
Princes Highway 5 kms south of Batemans Bay<br />
Visitors Centre : Phone: 02 4471 2544 Fax: 02 4471 2500<br />
Herbarium: Phone/Fax 02 4471 2500 E-mail: erbgherb@acr.net.au<br />
Internet address: www.esc.nsw.gov.au/community/gardens (at October 20<strong>06</strong>)<br />
Gardens Supervisor <strong>and</strong> Nursery: Phone 02 4471 3348 (answering service)<br />
Postal address C/- PO Box <strong>11</strong>6, Batemans Bay NSW 2536<br />
Management Committee:<br />
Postal address: The Secretary, PO Box 10<strong>14</strong>, Batemans Bay NSW 2536<br />
Friends of the Gardens:<br />
Postal address: The Secretary, PO Box 1<strong>06</strong>8, Batemans Bay NSW 2536<br />
21<br />
Vouchers <strong>and</strong> gift items for events<br />
including Film Night raffle <strong>and</strong> the Bird<br />
Hide opening
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 42<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>9 DISSOLUTION OF BODALLA OVALS MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE<br />
98.2509<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
The Bodalla Ovals Management Committee has struggled to maintain members to carry out<br />
the administration requirements of the ground. This report recommends Council dissolves the<br />
Management Committee <strong>and</strong> resumes the control of the facility itself.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
Throughout the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> area, Council provides a wide variety of public facilities, such as<br />
halls <strong>and</strong> sporting facilities. To assist in the care, control <strong>and</strong> management of these facilities<br />
Council appoints Committees of local residents to undertake these functions on Council’s<br />
behalf.<br />
The Bodalla Ovals Management Committee was initially formed to raise funds <strong>and</strong> oversee<br />
the development of the grounds. Once established the Management Committee was<br />
responsible for maintenance <strong>and</strong> bookings of the ground.<br />
ISSUES<br />
The Management Committee has struggled to maintain volunteer numbers, increasing the<br />
workload for the remaining members. The remaining members have expressed their<br />
difficulty in organising meetings <strong>and</strong> following up casual hire of the grounds.<br />
Sports Liaison Management Committee<br />
The Bodalla Soccer Club <strong>and</strong> Bodalla Cricket Club, who are regular hirers of the grounds,<br />
both have association representation on the Sports Liaison Management Committee. The<br />
Sports Liaison Management Committee has the responsibility of collection of annual ground<br />
fees <strong>and</strong> allocation of seasonal hire, hence reducing the need for an individual grounds<br />
management committee.<br />
Future needs <strong>and</strong> planning of the grounds has been addressed by the Sports Liaison<br />
Committee <strong>and</strong> will be completed in consultation with the seasonal user groups. The Soccer<br />
<strong>and</strong> Cricket Associations have been very supportive of the Sports Liaison Management<br />
Committee.<br />
Legal<br />
The Local Government Act 1993 provides that:<br />
• Under Section 377 of the Act, Council may appoint in respect of any work, park, reserve,<br />
cemetery or undertaking under the control of the Council, a committee of local citizens,<br />
<strong>and</strong> delegate to the Committee (Section 377) the care, control <strong>and</strong> management of the<br />
work, park, reserve, cemetery or undertaking, <strong>and</strong> the expenditure of such money’s as the<br />
Council may vote.<br />
• Any such Committee may be dissolved by the Council at any time.<br />
Asset<br />
Council officers will inspect the playing field <strong>and</strong> facilities on a weekly basis. Council is<br />
responsible for st<strong>and</strong>ard mowing of outdoor grassed fields, however any special mowing<br />
requirements will be carried out at the user’s expense.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 43<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/<strong>11</strong>9 DISSOLUTION OF BODALLA OVALS MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE<br />
98.2509<br />
Staff<br />
Staff are currently developing a central booking system which will allow for the casual <strong>and</strong><br />
regular hire of Council’s sports grounds. The <strong>Facilities</strong> Booking Officer will take all<br />
bookings for the grounds until the central booking system is in place.<br />
Financial<br />
Upon a resolution being passed, all assets <strong>and</strong> funds of the Management Committee shall,<br />
after payment of all expenses <strong>and</strong> liabilities, be h<strong>and</strong>ed over to Council.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
The Bodalla Ovals Management Committee has made a significant contribution to the <strong>Shire</strong>’s<br />
sporting facilities. The newly formed Sports Liaison Management Committee will continue<br />
to develop the grounds in consultation with the user groups <strong>and</strong> enable the remaining<br />
members of the Management Committee to be involved with future developments without the<br />
burden of the care <strong>and</strong> control of the facilities.<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee<br />
resolve the following:<br />
THAT:<br />
1. The Bodalla Ovals Management Committee be dissolved <strong>and</strong> Council resume the care<br />
<strong>and</strong> control of the facility itself.<br />
2. A letter of appreciation for the committee members’ contribution to the provision of the<br />
ground <strong>and</strong> facilities <strong>and</strong> the services they offered the community be sent to remaining<br />
committee members.<br />
WARREN SHARPE<br />
GROUPS MANAGER<br />
ROADS AND RECREATION SERVICES
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 44<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/120 DISSOLUTION OF SURFSIDE RECREATIONAL RESERVE<br />
MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE 98.2375<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
The Surfside Recreation Reserve Management Committee has been involved in the design<br />
<strong>and</strong> reconstruction of the Surfside Ovals. The oval project is now complete. This report<br />
recommends Council dissolves the management committee <strong>and</strong> resumes the control of the<br />
facility itself.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
Throughout the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> area, Council provides a wide variety of public facilities, such as<br />
halls <strong>and</strong> sporting facilities. To assist in the care, control <strong>and</strong> management of these facilities<br />
Council appoints Committees of local residents to undertake these functions on Council’s<br />
behalf.<br />
The Surfside Recreation Reserve Management Committee was initially formed to raise funds<br />
<strong>and</strong> oversee the development of the sporting oval.<br />
At its <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Meeting held on <strong>14</strong> February 20<strong>06</strong> Council resolved:<br />
THAT the Surfside Recreational Reserve Management Committee not be disb<strong>and</strong>ed<br />
until all the works which are currently underway have been completed. The<br />
disb<strong>and</strong>ment to take place when all current <strong>and</strong> agreed works are completed to the<br />
satisfaction of the Management Committee.<br />
The oval work has now been completed. The field has recently been topdressed <strong>and</strong> will be<br />
watered from the underground bore supplies over the summer period. This will ensure the<br />
fields are available for the commencement of the winter soccer competition.<br />
Separate to the oval project, Council will soon commence construction of a new amenities for<br />
the sports complex. The sporting groups have agreed on the floor plans of the amenities<br />
building <strong>and</strong> a Development Application has been lodged. Tenders have been called <strong>and</strong> it is<br />
anticipated these will be submitted to Council in November for determination of the<br />
successful contractor.<br />
Council Recreation Coordinator has liaised with both the President of the Soccer Club <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Cricket Club <strong>and</strong> they are both pleased with the progress of the grounds. They have also been<br />
encouraged to attend the Sports Liaison Management Committee meetings to continue their<br />
active involvement in the future development of the grounds. The cricket club is working<br />
closely with Council staff to obtain additional materials for the practice nets which is a clear<br />
indication of the commitment to continue working together to develop the highest quality<br />
st<strong>and</strong>ards that we can achieve with funding available.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 45<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/120 DISSOLUTION OF SURFSIDE RECREATIONAL RESERVE<br />
MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE 98.2375<br />
ISSUES<br />
The Management Committee has played an integral role in the development of the Surfside<br />
Sporting Complex.<br />
Sports Liaison Management Committee<br />
The Clyde United Soccer Club <strong>and</strong> Cavaliers Cricket Club, who will be regular hirers of the<br />
Surfside grounds, both have association representation on the Sports Liaison Management<br />
Committee. The <strong>Facilities</strong> Booking Officer <strong>and</strong> Sports Liaison Management Committee has<br />
the responsibility of collection of annual ground fees <strong>and</strong> allocation of seasonal hire, hence<br />
reducing the need for an individual grounds management committee.<br />
Future needs <strong>and</strong> planning of the Reserve has been addressed by the Sports Liaison<br />
Committee <strong>and</strong> will be completed in consultation with the seasonal user groups. The<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Soccer Association <strong>and</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Cricket Association have been very<br />
supportive of the Sports Liaison Management Committee.<br />
Legal<br />
The Local Government Act 1993 provides that:<br />
• Under Section 377 of the Act, Council may appoint in respect of any work, park, reserve,<br />
cemetery or undertaking under the control of the Council, a committee of local citizens,<br />
<strong>and</strong> delegate to the Committee (Section 377) the care, control <strong>and</strong> management of the<br />
work, park, reserve, cemetery or undertaking, <strong>and</strong> the expenditure of such money’s as the<br />
Council may vote.<br />
• Any such Committee may be dissolved by the Council at any time.<br />
Asset<br />
Council officers will inspect the playing field <strong>and</strong> facilities on a weekly basis. Council is<br />
responsible for st<strong>and</strong>ard mowing of outdoor grassed fields, however any special mowing<br />
requirements over <strong>and</strong> above that will be carried out at the user’s expense (if required by<br />
users).<br />
Staff<br />
Staff are currently developing a central booking system which will allow for the casual <strong>and</strong><br />
regular hire of Council’s sports grounds. Council’s Facility Booking Officer will take all<br />
bookings for the Surfside Sporting Complex until the central booking system is in place.<br />
Financial<br />
Upon a resolution being passed, all assets <strong>and</strong> funds of the Management Committee shall,<br />
after payment of all expenses <strong>and</strong> liabilities, be h<strong>and</strong>ed over to Council.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 46<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/120 DISSOLUTION OF SURFSIDE RECREATIONAL RESERVE<br />
MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE 98.2375<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
The Surfside Recreation Reserve Management Committee has made a significant contribution<br />
to the <strong>Shire</strong>’s sporting facilities.<br />
The newly formed Sports Liaison Management Committee will continue to develop the<br />
Surfside Recreation Reserve in consultation with the user groups <strong>and</strong> enable the remaining<br />
members of the Surfside Recreation Reserve Management Committee to be involved with<br />
future developments without the burden of the care <strong>and</strong> control of the facilities.<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee<br />
resolve the following:<br />
THAT:<br />
1. The Surfside Recreation Reserve Management Committee be dissolved <strong>and</strong> Council<br />
resume the care <strong>and</strong> control of the facility itself.<br />
2. A letter of appreciation for the committee members’ contribution to the development of<br />
Surfside Recreation Reserve, the facilities <strong>and</strong> services they offered the community, be<br />
sent to the remaining committee members.<br />
WARREN SHARPE<br />
GROUP MANAGER<br />
ROADS AND RECREATION SERVICES
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 47<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/121 DISSOLUTION OF GUNDARY OVALS MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE<br />
89.3008<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
The Gundary Ovals Management Committee has struggled to maintain members to carry out<br />
the administration requirements of the ground. This report recommends Council dissolves the<br />
management committee <strong>and</strong> resumes the control of the facility itself.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
Throughout the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> area, Council provides a wide variety of public facilities, such as<br />
halls <strong>and</strong> sporting facilities. To assist in the care, control <strong>and</strong> management of these facilities<br />
Council appoints Committees of local residents to undertake these functions on Council’s<br />
behalf.<br />
The Gundary Ovals Management Committee was initially formed to raise funds <strong>and</strong> oversee<br />
the development of the grounds. Once established the committee was responsible for<br />
maintenance <strong>and</strong> bookings of the ground.<br />
ISSUES<br />
The Management Committee has struggled to maintain volunteer numbers, increasing the<br />
workload for the remaining members. The remaining members have expressed their difficulty<br />
in organising meetings <strong>and</strong> following up casual hire of the grounds.<br />
Sports Liaison Management Committee<br />
The Moruya Soccer Club, Moruya Touch Football Club, Moruya Hockey <strong>and</strong> Moruya Cricket<br />
Club who are regular hirers of the grounds all have association representation on the Sports<br />
Liaison Management Committee. The Sports Liaison Management Committee has the<br />
responsibility of collection of annual ground fees <strong>and</strong> allocation of seasonal hire hence<br />
reducing the need for an individual grounds management committee.<br />
Future needs <strong>and</strong> planning of the grounds have been addressed by the Sports Liaison<br />
Committee <strong>and</strong> will be completed in consultation with the seasonal user groups. The Soccer,<br />
Touch Football, Hockey <strong>and</strong> Cricket Associations have been very supportive of the Sports<br />
Liaison Management Committee.<br />
Legal<br />
The Local Government Act 1993 provides that:<br />
• Under Section 377 of the Act, Council may appoint in respect of any work, park, reserve,<br />
cemetery or undertaking under the control of the Council, a committee of local citizens,<br />
<strong>and</strong> delegate to the Committee (Section 377) the care, control <strong>and</strong> management of the<br />
work, park, reserve, cemetery or undertaking, <strong>and</strong> the expenditure of such money’s as the<br />
Council may vote.<br />
• Any such Committee may be dissolved by the Council at any time.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 48<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/121 DISSOLUTION OF GUNDARY OVALS MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE<br />
89.3008<br />
Asset<br />
Council officers will inspect the playing field <strong>and</strong> facilities on a weekly basis. Council is<br />
responsible for st<strong>and</strong>ard mowing of outdoor grassed fields, however any special mowing<br />
requirements will be carried out at the user’s expense.<br />
Staff<br />
Staff are currently developing a central booking system which will allow for the casual <strong>and</strong><br />
regular hire of Council’s sports grounds. The <strong>Facilities</strong> Booking Officer will take all<br />
bookings for the grounds until the central booking system is in place.<br />
Financial<br />
Upon a resolution being passed, all assets <strong>and</strong> funds of the Management Committee shall,<br />
after payment of all expenses <strong>and</strong> liabilities, be h<strong>and</strong>ed over to Council.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
The Gundary Ovals Management Committee has made a significant contribution to the<br />
<strong>Shire</strong>’s sporting facilities. The newly formed Sports Liaison Management Committee will<br />
continue to develop the grounds in consultation with the user groups <strong>and</strong> enable the remaining<br />
members of the Management Committee to be involved with future developments without the<br />
burden of the care <strong>and</strong> control of the facilities.<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee<br />
resolve the following:<br />
THAT:<br />
1. The Gundary Ovals Management Committee be dissolved <strong>and</strong> Council resume the care<br />
<strong>and</strong> control of the facility itself.<br />
2. A letter of appreciation for the committee members’ contribution to the provision of the<br />
grounds <strong>and</strong> facilities <strong>and</strong> the services they offered the community be sent to remaining<br />
committee members.<br />
WARREN SHARPE<br />
GROUPS MANAGER<br />
ROADS AND RECREATION SERVICES
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 49<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/122 ANNUAL REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR CROWN LAND 97.<strong>14</strong>45<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
The new Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Regulation 20<strong>06</strong> requires Trustees to provide substantial reports on<br />
their Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Reserves. This requirement will place a significant burden on Council<br />
resources. This issue could be best addressed by Council forwarding a submission to the<br />
Minister for L<strong>and</strong>s seeking relief from these reporting requirements.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
The Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Regulation 20<strong>06</strong> was updated on 1 September 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>and</strong> includes new<br />
requirements for Trustees to provide annual reports on Crown L<strong>and</strong> Reserves.<br />
ISSUES<br />
Section 32 of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Regulation 20<strong>06</strong> requires that Trust Managers provide the<br />
following information of each of the Crown Reserves under their trusteeship within three<br />
months of the close of the financial year:<br />
(a) financial statements setting out details of income, expenditure, assets <strong>and</strong> liabilities,<br />
(b) details of the value <strong>and</strong> condition of all assets (other than l<strong>and</strong>) valued at $5,000 or more,<br />
(c) details of heritage items,<br />
(d) details of the value of work <strong>and</strong> improvements undertaken costing more than $5,000,<br />
(e) details of any insurance arrangements in place,<br />
(f) details of the fire prevention <strong>and</strong> occupational, health <strong>and</strong> safety measures in place,<br />
(g) details of any plans of management in place,<br />
(h) details of any environmental management initiatives undertaken,<br />
(i) details of leases or licences that have been granted or are in force, including rent <strong>and</strong> fee<br />
levels,<br />
(j) details of the purposes for which the reserve is used,<br />
(k) any particulars of pecuniary interests recorded in the book referred to in clause 1 (3) of<br />
Schedule 4 to the Act,<br />
(l) details of any grants or sponsorship received,<br />
(m) details of employees <strong>and</strong> contractors, including details about any training provided to<br />
such persons,<br />
(n) the number of trust board meetings held during the financial year <strong>and</strong> records of<br />
attendance at such meetings.<br />
The Minister may also require that Trust Manager’s reports be audited by a person approved<br />
by the Minister.<br />
The above reporting requirements are onerous <strong>and</strong> required a substantial allocation of time<br />
<strong>and</strong> resources to complete. It would also require a carefully planned restructure of parts of the<br />
financial accounting system to be able to provide the information required. Added to this is<br />
the practical difficulty of ensuring correct allocation of financial data by staff.<br />
Council has over 90 Crown Reserves in the <strong>Shire</strong> located on over 1020 hectares. A wide<br />
variety of activities take place on each Crown Reserve which may include several parcels of<br />
l<strong>and</strong>. Most reserves would also include assets valued at over $5,000 <strong>and</strong> similarly works <strong>and</strong><br />
improvements on each reserve would be valued at over $5,000.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 50<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/122 ANNUAL REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR CROWN LAND 97.<strong>14</strong>45<br />
The Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Regulation 2000 was less onerous <strong>and</strong> required that Trust Managers<br />
provide the following information:<br />
(1) For the purposes of section 122 (1) (a) of the Act, a reserve trust must furnish to the<br />
Minister each year, within 3 months of the close of the trust’s financial year, a report on its<br />
activities.<br />
(2) Any such report is to include details of income, expenditure, assets, liabilities,<br />
improvements effected, leases <strong>and</strong> licences granted or in force, uses made of the reserve<br />
<strong>and</strong> any particulars of pecuniary interests recorded in the book referred to in clause 31.<br />
(3) If directed by the Minister by notice in writing to do so, a reserve trust must arrange for<br />
any such report to be audited by a person approved by the Minister.<br />
To date Council has not had the resources or funds to provide the information as required<br />
under the 2000 regulation.<br />
Legal<br />
As Trust Manager of over 90 Crown Reserves, Council is obliged to meet the requirements of<br />
the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Regulation 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
Staff<br />
Shoalhaven Council has advised that it takes one staff member approximately six weeks full<br />
time to prepare the report as required under the 2000 regulation. This staff member also relies<br />
on assistance from many other staff to compile the information in the report.<br />
The time required for one staff member to meet the requirements of the 20<strong>06</strong> regulation<br />
would be extensive <strong>and</strong> not achievable with the current staffing levels.<br />
Financial<br />
No funds have been allocated in the Management Plan to engage a staff member to complete<br />
the reporting requirements.<br />
Council’s accounting software is more than capable of accounting separately for the Crown<br />
L<strong>and</strong>s reserves. However these would need to be structured to account separately for each<br />
reserve plus the main business activities within each reserve. We anticipate this would result<br />
in separate accounting for at least 90, possibly considerably more “projects”. The main<br />
difficulty would be in practical terms to ensure staff, including field staff, code labour, plant,<br />
materials <strong>and</strong> contracts to the correct projects. At the same time the turnover on most of the<br />
projects would be relatively insignificant. It is difficult to see the costs <strong>and</strong> benefits of such an<br />
extensive exercise in micro accounting given that the Council already goes to considerable<br />
lengths to annually consult its Management Plan with the public.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
The provisions of the new Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Regulation 2000 are onerous. Council does not have<br />
the resources or funds to provide the information required. The benefits of providing over 90<br />
reports with such detailed information are questionable <strong>and</strong> place an unnecessary financial<br />
<strong>and</strong> resource burden on Council.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 51<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/122 ANNUAL REPORTING REQUIREMENTS FOR CROWN LAND 97.<strong>14</strong>45<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee<br />
resolve the following:<br />
THAT:<br />
1. Council write to the Minister for L<strong>and</strong>s expressing concern on the reporting requirements<br />
for Crown Reserves.<br />
2. Council seek funding from the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s in order to meet the requirements of<br />
Section 32 of the Crown L<strong>and</strong> Regulation 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
3. Council seek amendments to the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Regulation 20<strong>06</strong> so that reporting<br />
requirements are achievable.<br />
ANDREW PARKINSON<br />
EXECUTIVE MANAGER<br />
STRATEGIC PLANNING AND DESIGN
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 52<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/123 LICENCE FOR PEDAL BOAT HIRE - CORRIGANS BEACH 92.73<strong>11</strong><br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
A request has been received for the issuing of a licence to operate a pedal boat hire business<br />
from Crown Reserve R66122 at Corrigans Beach, Batehaven. This report recommends<br />
granting of a temporary licence.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
A request has been received from Umeus Enterprises for approval to operate a pedal boat hire<br />
business from Corrigans Beach Reserve at the location shown in the plan below.<br />
ISSUES<br />
The applicant proposes to initially run eight pedal boats from Corrigans Beach Reserve. The<br />
applicant has advised that the business will be staffed by a minimum of two people with two<br />
safety vessels. All staff hold First Aid Certificates <strong>and</strong> are competent in water safety.<br />
The pedal boats comply with Australian St<strong>and</strong>ards <strong>and</strong> are all equipped with extra buoyancy<br />
features so that operating them in the small swell at Corrigans Beach would be feasible. All<br />
boats will have life vests equipped with whistles <strong>and</strong> users will be instructed on the use of<br />
these as well as other safety issues.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 53<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/123 LICENCE FOR PEDAL BOAT HIRE - CORRIGANS BEACH 92.73<strong>11</strong><br />
The pedal boats will be transported to the site each day on a purpose built trailer <strong>and</strong> removed<br />
at the close of business each evening. As this is a summer sport the business would mainly<br />
operate in the warmer months, targeting weekends <strong>and</strong> holiday periods.<br />
The Waterways Act requires a Hire <strong>and</strong> Drive Permit to operate the business. Umeus<br />
Enterprises is currently in the process of obtaining this permit <strong>and</strong> have been advised by the<br />
Waterways Authority that the business should be located on the southern end of Corrigans<br />
Beach to avoid impacting with the jet ski hire currently licensed to operate from the Reserve.<br />
Legal<br />
Corrigans Beach Reserve is a Crown Reserve. The Plan of Management has recognized <strong>and</strong><br />
authorises such activities as watercraft hire. In accordance with Section 108 of the Crown<br />
L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989 Council as Trust Manager for the Reserve can issue a temporary licence for a<br />
period not exceeding 12 months.<br />
Policy<br />
Public liability insurance will be required in accordance with Council policy.<br />
Social Impact<br />
This operation will provide an attraction <strong>and</strong> activity for local residents as well as tourists to<br />
this area.<br />
Financial<br />
A licence fee of $695 excluding GST in line with an existing temporary licence for watercraft<br />
operating from the Reserve is considered appropriate.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
Licences for other types of watercraft hire have been granted at Corrigans Beach <strong>and</strong> pedal<br />
boats will complement these water based activities. The Plan of Management for Corrigans<br />
Beach authorises watercraft hire. Given the scale of the operation proposed by the applicant,<br />
the granting of a temporary licence for a pedal boat hire business for a fee of $695 excluding<br />
GST is considered reasonable.<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT Council as Trust Manager consent to the granting of a temporary licence, in<br />
accordance with Section 108 of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989, to operate a pedal boat hire<br />
business from Crown Reserve R66122 at Corrigans Beach, Batehaven to Umeus Enterprises<br />
at a rental of $695 plus GST, commencing 1 December 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>and</strong> expiring on 30 November<br />
2007 subject to provision of the relevant permit required by the Waterways Authority.<br />
ROB ADDISON<br />
PROPERTY MANAGER<br />
COMMERCIAL
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 54<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/124 LICENCE TO OPERATE SEA KAYAK TOUR AND RENTAL BUSINESS -<br />
CORRIGANS BEACH 92.73<strong>11</strong><br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
The temporary licence for a sea kayak tour <strong>and</strong> rental business to operate from Crown<br />
Reserve R66122 at Corrigans Beach, Batehaven is due to expire on 25 December 20<strong>06</strong>. The<br />
current licensee has requested a further licence be granted. This report recommends the<br />
granting of a temporary licence.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
At its meeting on 20 December 2005 Council resolved:<br />
“THAT Council as Trust Manager consent to the granting of a temporary licence, in<br />
accordance with Section 108 of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989, to operate a sea kayak tour<br />
<strong>and</strong> rental business from Crown Reserve R66122 at Corrigans Beach, Batehaven to<br />
Straight Up Kayaks Pty Ltd at a rental of $670 plus GST commencing 26 December<br />
2005 <strong>and</strong> expiring on 25 December 20<strong>06</strong> subject to provision of the relevant permit<br />
required by the Waterways Authority.”<br />
Since that time the business has been operating from the Reserve at the location shown in the<br />
plan below.<br />
Council has received a request from the operator to renew the licence.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 55<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/124 LICENCE TO OPERATE SEA KAYAK TOUR AND RENTAL BUSINESS -<br />
CORRIGANS BEACH 92.73<strong>11</strong><br />
ISSUES<br />
The applicant has carried out business on a Hire <strong>and</strong> Drive Licence from Waterways to<br />
operate a sea kayak hire <strong>and</strong> tour business in the waters off Corrigans Beach between one<br />
hour before sunrise <strong>and</strong> one hour after sunset.<br />
The applicant is seeking to renew a licence to park the sea kayaks on a trailer <strong>and</strong> conduct the<br />
business transactions on an area fronting the beach.<br />
No written complaints have been received regarding the operations of this business over the<br />
past 12 months.<br />
Legal<br />
Corrigans Beach Reserve is a Crown Reserve. The Plan of Management for the Reserve<br />
authorises licences for watercraft businesses. In accordance with Section 108 of the Crown<br />
L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989 Council as Trust Manager for the Reserve can issue a temporary licence for a<br />
period not exceeding 12 months.<br />
Social Impact<br />
This operation provides an attraction <strong>and</strong> activity for local residents as well as tourists to this<br />
area.<br />
Financial<br />
The previous licence fee for this operation was $670.00pa. An increase in accordance with<br />
the CPI being $695.00pa excluding GST is considered appropriate.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
A licence has previously been granted to the applicant <strong>and</strong> no written complaints have been<br />
received by Council regarding the applicant’s business within the past 12 months.<br />
Given the scale of the operation, the granting of a temporary licence for a sea kayak tour <strong>and</strong><br />
rental business for a fee of $695.00pa excluding GST is considered reasonable.<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT Council as Trust Manager consent to the granting of a temporary licence, in<br />
accordance with Section 108 of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989, to operate a sea kayak tour <strong>and</strong><br />
rental business from Crown Reserve R66122 at Corrigans Beach, Batehaven to Straight Up<br />
Kayaks Pty Ltd at a rental of $695.00pa excluding GST commencing 26 December 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
expiring on 25 December 2007.<br />
ROB ADDISON<br />
PROPERTY MANAGER<br />
COMMERCIAL
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 56<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/125 EXTINGUISHMENT OF EASEMENT WITHIN LOT 1242 DP 218665 –<br />
TUROSS HEAD 90.<strong>14</strong>44.E<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
Council has received an Application to extinguish an existing easement within Lot 1242<br />
Deposited Plan 218665 Tuross Head from the registered proprietor. This report recommends<br />
approval of the extinguishment.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
Lot 1242 DP 218665 is burdened by an Easement for Drainage 10 feet wide.<br />
A sketch showing the easement is set out below.<br />
The registered proprietors whose names are set out in the confidential attachment have made<br />
an application for the easement to be extinguished.<br />
ISSUES<br />
The Easement for Drainage was created as part of the original subdivision in 1964.<br />
Stormwater pipes were never constructed within the easement <strong>and</strong> when Foam Street was<br />
reconstructed earlier in 20<strong>06</strong> any future requirement for drainage within Lot 1242 was<br />
negated.<br />
The existing Easement is therefore redundant.<br />
Legal<br />
Council as the benefiting authority for the easement has the power to seek its extinguishment.<br />
To extinguish the easement a Transfer Releasing Easement is registered at the L<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
Property Information Office <strong>and</strong> the notation is removed from the Certificate of Title.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 57<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/125 EXTINGUISHMENT OF EASEMENT WITHIN LOT 1242 DP 218665 –<br />
TUROSS HEAD 90.<strong>14</strong>44.E<br />
Financial<br />
In accordance with Council’s policy on extinguishment of easements, the applicant should<br />
pay all costs associated with the extinguishment of easement together with compensation<br />
determined by a Registered Valuer <strong>and</strong> valuation fee.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
The easement for drainage within Lot 1242 DP 218665 is not required by Council <strong>and</strong> can be<br />
extinguished in accordance with Council’s policy.<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT:<br />
1. Consent be given to extinguish the Easement for Drainage within Lot 1242 DP 218665<br />
subject to:<br />
(a) the registered proprietor paying compensation in an amount determined by a<br />
Registered Valuer on Council’s List of Preferred Valuers;<br />
(b) all legal <strong>and</strong> administrative costs associated with the extinguishment be borne by<br />
the registered proprietor.<br />
2. Authority be given to affix the Common Seal of Council to the necessary<br />
documentation regarding the extinguishment.<br />
ROB ADDISON<br />
PROPERTY MANAGER<br />
COMMERCIAL<br />
Clrs
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 58<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/126 LEASE FOR WATER BORES - BODALLA 93.5526.E<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
Council has previously resolved to enter into a Lease with the registered proprietors of<br />
property on <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Road, Bodalla for water bores. The registered proprietors have<br />
reconsidered Council’s offer <strong>and</strong> seek an increased annual fee <strong>and</strong> compensation for<br />
necessary easements. This report recommends the increased fee <strong>and</strong> compensation for the<br />
easements be agreed to.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
Following consideration of a report to the <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee on 8 November<br />
20<strong>06</strong>, Council at its Ordinary meeting held on 22 November resolved:<br />
THAT:<br />
1. A lease be entered into with the registered proprietor for water bores within Lot 47<br />
DP 776415 <strong>and</strong> Lot 24 DP752131 being an area of about 8 hectares shown in the<br />
sketch in the report with the following terms <strong>and</strong> conditions:<br />
2.<br />
3.<br />
a) The term be twenty years with an option for twenty years commencing 1 October<br />
2004;<br />
b) The annual rental be the amount set out in the confidential attachment increased<br />
annually in line with the CPI;<br />
c) An exit clause for Council in the event that the bores are no longer required.<br />
a) Easements for electricity supply be acquired within Lots 24 <strong>and</strong> 47 at no l<strong>and</strong> cost.<br />
b) Consent be given for the registered proprietor erecting at its own cost a powerbox<br />
from the transformer supplying electricity to the bores.<br />
a) All actions necessary be taken for the acquisition of l<strong>and</strong> required for road<br />
opening purposes within Lots 46 <strong>and</strong> 47 DP 776415 <strong>and</strong> Lot 24 DP752131.<br />
b) All actions necessary be taken for the closure of part <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Road <strong>and</strong><br />
transfer of that part to the owner of Lot 47 DP 776415 <strong>and</strong> Lot 24 DP752131 <strong>and</strong><br />
consolidated with that l<strong>and</strong>.<br />
c) An amount set out in the confidential attachment be paid in addition to the<br />
transfer of the closed road as part compensation.<br />
4. All costs associated with the Lease, easements for electricity, road widening <strong>and</strong> road<br />
closure including the registered proprietor’s reasonable legal costs be borne by Council.<br />
5. Consent be given to affix the Common Seal of Council to all necessary documents<br />
associated with the Lease, easements for electricity, road widening <strong>and</strong> road closure.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 59<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/126 LEASE FOR WATER BORES - BODALLA 93.5526.E<br />
ISSUES<br />
A copy of the report presented to the <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee is attached for<br />
information.<br />
The negotiations that lead to the recommendations of the report were based on a valuation<br />
report that provided for several options. A copy of the valuation report is attached for<br />
Councillors’ information.<br />
The valuation report provided for annual rental based on either a lease or a licence.<br />
The difference between the lease <strong>and</strong> a licence being Council would have exclusive use <strong>and</strong><br />
control over the whole of the area including the right to construct further bores, whereas the<br />
licence only provides for use of the l<strong>and</strong> immediately surrounding each bore.<br />
A lease is the preferred option.<br />
Discussions were held with a Director of the company being the registered proprietors, whose<br />
name is set out on the confidential attachment.<br />
As a result of the discussions, agreement was reached as set out in the original<br />
recommendation, ie a lease with rental based on licence valuation <strong>and</strong> no compensation<br />
sought for the electricity easements.<br />
Following notification of Council’s resolution the registered proprietors advised they wished<br />
to reconsider the offer.<br />
Following further discussions, written confirmation has been received that the company is<br />
prepared to accept rental <strong>and</strong> compensation in line with the valuation. The amounts are set out<br />
in the confidential attachment.<br />
Financial<br />
Sufficient funds are available in the Water budget to cover the acquisition <strong>and</strong> ongoing annual<br />
lease payments.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
The proposed lease fee <strong>and</strong> compensation for the electricity easements is in accordance with<br />
the valuation report prepared by a registered Valuer on Council’s list of preferred valuers <strong>and</strong><br />
is therefore considered acceptable.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 60<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/126 LEASE FOR WATER BORES - BODALLA 93.5526.E<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT:<br />
1. A lease be entered into with the registered proprietor for water bores within Lot 47<br />
DP 776415 <strong>and</strong> Lot 24 DP752131 being an area of about 8 hectares with the following<br />
terms <strong>and</strong> conditions:<br />
(a) The term be twenty years with an option for twenty years commencing 1 October<br />
2004.<br />
(b) The annual rental be the amount set out in the confidential attachment increased<br />
annually in line with the CPI.<br />
(c) An exit clause for Council in the event that the bores are no longer required.<br />
2. (a) Easements for electricity supply be acquired within Lots 24 <strong>and</strong> 47 with payment of<br />
compensation in the amount set out in the confidential attachment.<br />
(b) Consent be given for the registered proprietor erecting at its own cost a powerbox<br />
from the transformer supplying electricity to the bores.<br />
3. All costs associated with the Lease <strong>and</strong> easements for electricity including the registered<br />
proprietor’s reasonable legal costs be borne by Council.<br />
4. Consent be given to affix the Common Seal of Council to all necessary documents<br />
associated with the Lease <strong>and</strong> easements for electricity.<br />
ROB ADDISON<br />
PROPERTY MANAGER<br />
COMMERCIAL<br />
Attach<br />
Clrs
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY 8 NOVEMBER 2005 Page 81<br />
W05/126 LEASE FOR WATER BORES - BODALLA 93.5526E<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
Council has established water bores on a property on <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Road, Bodalla for<br />
emergency supply. This report recommends a lease be entered into with the registered<br />
proprietor.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
During the recent drought, sources of water were sought through the sinking of bores in<br />
certain areas.<br />
Successful bores have been established on a property on <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Road, Bodalla being<br />
Lot 47 DP 776415 <strong>and</strong> Lot 24 DP 752131.<br />
The registered proprietor has agreed to leasing l<strong>and</strong> for those bores.<br />
As a result of a survey carried out to determine the location of the bores, it has been brought<br />
to light that the formation of <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Road is not contained within the road reserve<br />
through this property.<br />
A plan showing the proposed lease area <strong>and</strong> road widening <strong>and</strong> closing is below.<br />
G:\Word\WF\WFREP\Wfattachments20<strong>06</strong>\November\Lease Water Bores Bodalla.doc
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY 8 NOVEMBER 2005 Page 82<br />
W05/126 LEASE FOR WATER BORES - BODALLA 93.5526E<br />
ISSUES<br />
1. Bores<br />
Asset<br />
The bores are an important water utility asset <strong>and</strong> need to be secured by a lease over the<br />
associated l<strong>and</strong>.<br />
Associated with the bores will be a requirement for electricity easements for the supply of<br />
electricity to the bores.<br />
The registered proprietor has requested the erection of a powerbox from the transformer<br />
supplying electricity to the bores. This will not interfere with the operation of the bores.<br />
Legal<br />
It is proposed that the term of the lease will be 20 years with an option for a further twenty<br />
commencing 1 October 2004, being the date Council first occupied the property.<br />
An exit clause will allow termination of the lease in the event the bores are no longer<br />
required.<br />
Financial<br />
The annual rental based on a valuation determined by a registered valuer <strong>and</strong> agreed to by the<br />
registered proprietor is set out in the confidential attachment.<br />
This rental will be increased each year in line with the CPI.<br />
2. Road Widening<br />
Asset<br />
Part of the road formation of <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Road through the property is not contained within<br />
the road reserve. It is proposed that part of the property be acquired for road widening <strong>and</strong><br />
that part of the road reserve not required be closed <strong>and</strong> transferred to the adjoining property.<br />
More l<strong>and</strong> is required for road widening than is proposed to be closed.<br />
Legal<br />
Application will need to be made to the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s to close part of the road. Upon<br />
closure the l<strong>and</strong> will vest in Council <strong>and</strong> it can then be transferred as part compensation. A<br />
consolidation of the closed road will be necessary with the adjoining property.<br />
Financial<br />
A valuation has been determined for the additional l<strong>and</strong> in excess of the proposed road<br />
closure. This amount is set out in the confidential attachment.<br />
All survey <strong>and</strong> legal costs associated with the road widening <strong>and</strong> lease should be borne by<br />
Council together with the registered proprietor’s reasonable legal fees.<br />
G:\Word\WF\WFREP\Wfattachments20<strong>06</strong>\November\Lease Water Bores Bodalla.doc
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY 8 NOVEMBER 2005 Page 83<br />
W05/126 LEASE FOR WATER BORES - BODALLA 93.5526E<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
A lease is required to secure the emergency water bores within 47 DP 776415 <strong>and</strong> Lot 24 DP<br />
752131 <strong>and</strong> road widening is required within Lots 46 <strong>and</strong> 47 DP 776415 <strong>and</strong> Lot 24 DP<br />
752131 to legalize part of <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Road.<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT:<br />
1. A lease be entered into with the registered proprietor for water bores within Lot 47<br />
DP 776415 <strong>and</strong> Lot 24 DP752131 being an area of about 8 hectares shown in the sketch<br />
in the report with the following terms <strong>and</strong> conditions:<br />
2.<br />
3.<br />
a) The term be twenty years with an option for twenty years commencing 1 October<br />
2004.<br />
b) The annual rental be the amount set out in the confidential attachment increased<br />
annually in line with the CPI.<br />
c) An exit clause for Council in the event that the bores are no longer required.<br />
a) Easements for electricity supply be acquired within Lots 24 <strong>and</strong> 47 at no l<strong>and</strong> cost.<br />
b) Consent be given for the registered proprietor erecting at its own cost a powerbox<br />
from the transformer supplying electricity to the bores.<br />
a) All actions necessary be taken for the acquisition of l<strong>and</strong> required for road<br />
opening purposes within Lots 46 <strong>and</strong> 47 DP 776415 <strong>and</strong> Lot 24 DP752131.<br />
b) All actions necessary be taken for the closure of part <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Road <strong>and</strong><br />
transfer of that part to the owner of Lot 47 DP 776415 <strong>and</strong> Lot 24 DP752131 <strong>and</strong><br />
consolidated with that l<strong>and</strong>.<br />
c) An amount set out in the confidential attachment be paid in addition to the transfer<br />
of the closed road as part compensation.<br />
4. All costs associated with the Lease, easements for electricity, road widening <strong>and</strong> road<br />
closure including the registered proprietor’s reasonable legal costs be borne by Council.<br />
5. Consent be given to affix the Common Seal of Council to all necessary documents<br />
associated with the Lease, easements for electricity, road widening <strong>and</strong> road closure.<br />
ROB ADDISON<br />
PROPERTY MANAGER<br />
TECHNICAL SERVICES AND PROPERTY<br />
Attach (Clrs – Confidential)<br />
G:\Word\WF\WFREP\Wfattachments20<strong>06</strong>\November\Lease Water Bores Bodalla.doc
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 61<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/127 DRAFT PLAN OF MANAGEMENT - BILL SMYTH RESERVE, NAROOMA<br />
LEISURE CENTRE, NAROOMA SWIMMING POOL, NATA OVAL,<br />
WAGONGA INLET FORESHORE RESERVES & KEN ROSE PARK 05.9616<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
To consider the adoption of the draft Plan of Management for Bill Smyth Reserve, Narooma<br />
Leisure Centre, Narooma Swimming Pool, Nata Oval, Wagonga Inlet Foreshore Reserves <strong>and</strong><br />
Ken Rose Park for public exhibition <strong>and</strong> comment.<br />
These reserves are located on Crown L<strong>and</strong> Reserves 63051 <strong>and</strong> 80515 for Public Recreation<br />
<strong>and</strong> Resting Place. Council is the appointed Trust Manager for these reserves under the<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> (South) Reserve Trust.<br />
A copy of the Draft Plan of Management is attached.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
A Plan of Management for Bill Smyth Reserve was adopted on 27 May 1998. A new Plan of<br />
Management has been developed to encompass all of the reserves in Crown Reserves 63051<br />
<strong>and</strong> 80515 as per the recommendation of the Narooma Structure Plan.<br />
The new draft Plan of Management provides updated information on leases <strong>and</strong> licences <strong>and</strong><br />
more detailed l<strong>and</strong>scape plans.<br />
At the <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee of 10 October 20<strong>06</strong> Council resolved the following:<br />
THAT:<br />
1. Council proceed with constructing the new Bill Smyth Amenities Building in the current<br />
location.<br />
2. Council seek further comment on the proposal to widen the Bill Smyth Rugby League<br />
field during the exhibition of the draft Plan of Management in the coming months.<br />
The draft Plan of Management includes the proposal to widen the existing Rugby League<br />
practice field at Bill Smyth Oval for public comment. The new amenities building will be<br />
constructed in the location of the existing building.<br />
ISSUES<br />
Legal<br />
Council has prepared this Draft Plan of Management in consultation with the Department of<br />
L<strong>and</strong>s. The l<strong>and</strong> must be developed in accordance with the Crown Purpose of “Public<br />
Recreation <strong>and</strong> Resting”.<br />
The exhibition of the Draft Plan of Management will be in accordance with the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s<br />
Act.<br />
After the submission period the Draft Plan of Management may be amended to reflect the<br />
comments addressed in the submissions. Council will then be required to endorse the Plan of<br />
Management prior to its final adoption by the Minister L<strong>and</strong>s.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 62<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/127 DRAFT PLAN OF MANAGEMENT - BILL SMYTH RESERVE, NAROOMA<br />
LEISURE CENTRE, NAROOMA SWIMMING POOL, NATA OVAL,<br />
WAGONGA INLET FORESHORE RESERVES & KEN ROSE PARK 05.9616<br />
Policy<br />
The Draft Plan of Management is consistent with:<br />
• Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989<br />
• Food <strong>and</strong> Beverage Outlets on Crown Reserves Policy 1996<br />
• The NSW Coastal Policy<br />
• <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Local Environmental Plan<br />
• Narooma Structure Plan<br />
Community Consultation<br />
A public meeting was held on 5 December 2005 <strong>and</strong> the public were invited to share their<br />
comments about how the reserves should be managed for the future. A summary of the<br />
comments made at this meeting are included in the Plan of Management at Attachment A.<br />
A Community Reference Group was established <strong>and</strong> has met on six occasions over the past<br />
10 months to assist Council staff with developing the draft Plan of Management.<br />
Strategic<br />
The draft Plan of Management will be referred to the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s for their comment<br />
during the exhibition period.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
The amended draft Plan of Management has been completed for Council’s adoption for public<br />
exhibition <strong>and</strong> comment.<br />
The Moruya Showground Conservation Management Plan has been finalised <strong>and</strong> its<br />
recommendations have been incorporated in the Draft Plan of Management. Adoption of the<br />
Conservation Management Plan is now sought.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 63<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/127 DRAFT PLAN OF MANAGEMENT - BILL SMYTH RESERVE, NAROOMA<br />
LEISURE CENTRE, NAROOMA SWIMMING POOL, NATA OVAL,<br />
WAGONGA INLET FORESHORE RESERVES & KEN ROSE PARK 05.9616<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
That under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee resolve<br />
the following:<br />
THAT:<br />
1. Council adopt the draft Plan of Management for Bill Smyth Reserve, Narooma Leisure<br />
Centre, Narooma Swimming Pool, Nata Oval, Wagonga Inlet Foreshore Reserves <strong>and</strong><br />
Ken Rose Park located on Crown Reserves 63051 <strong>and</strong> 80515 for Public Recreation <strong>and</strong><br />
Resting Place.<br />
2. The draft Plan of Management be exhibited for public comment for a minimum period of<br />
six weeks.<br />
3. A public presentation of the draft Plan of Management be held during the exhibition<br />
period.<br />
ANDREW PARKINSON<br />
EXECUTIVE MANAGER<br />
STRATEGIC PLANNING AND DESIGN<br />
Attach
Draft<br />
Plan of Management<br />
Bill Smyth Reserve<br />
Narooma Leisure Centre<br />
Narooma Swimming Pool<br />
Nata Oval<br />
Wagonga Inlet Foreshore Reserve<br />
Ken Rose Park<br />
Crown Reserve Nos 63051 & 80515<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> (South) Reserve Trust<br />
Crown Reserves for Public Recreation & Resting Place<br />
Draft presented to Council’s <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee <strong>14</strong> November 20<strong>06</strong> for public comment.
Plan of Management No 38.<br />
This Plan of Management was prepared by <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council in consultation with the Department of<br />
L<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> with the assistance of a community Reference Group which comprised the following members:<br />
Mrs Lyn Field Easts Narooma Shores Holiday Park<br />
Mr Neil Mumme Instep Management Group<br />
Mr Peter McCulloch Narooma Australian Rules<br />
Mr Graham Reeve Narooma Sporting <strong>and</strong> Services Club<br />
Mr Max Murray Narooma Croquet Club<br />
Mr Bob Burnside Narooma Junior & Senior Rugby League<br />
Ms Terese Aston Narooma Netball<br />
Mr Terry Moulang Narooma Tennis Club Inc<br />
Ms Patricia Eaton Narooma Swimming Pool Users<br />
Mr Ben Bate Narooma Touch Football<br />
Mrs Jenni Bourke Narooma residents<br />
Mr Rob O’Brien Narooma residents<br />
Mr Kevin Young Narooma Sport & Leisure Centre<br />
Any requests for further information or questions regarding this Plan of Management can be addressed to:<br />
Plans of Management Officer<br />
Ref: 05.9616<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council<br />
PO Box 99<br />
MORUYA NSW 2537<br />
Phone: (02) 4474 1000<br />
Table of Amendments:<br />
No Date Endorsed by<br />
Council<br />
Exhibition Period Adopted by<br />
Minister for L<strong>and</strong>s<br />
Details of Amendments<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 2 of 43
TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />
1. Introduction – Why a Plan of Management ........................................................................................ 4<br />
2. Site Location ...................................................................................................................................... 5<br />
3. Executive Summary............................................................................................................................ 6<br />
4. Consultation Process.......................................................................................................................... 7<br />
4.1 Timeline .............................................................................................................................. 7<br />
4.2 Supporting the Consultation Process................................................................................... 8<br />
4.3 Reference Group ................................................................................................................. 8<br />
4.4 Role of the Reference Group................................................................................................ 8<br />
5. Desired Outcomes ............................................................................................................................. 9<br />
6. Relevant Legislation <strong>and</strong> Policies ...................................................................................................... 10<br />
6.1 NSW Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989 ............................................................................................. 10<br />
6.1.1 Crown L<strong>and</strong>, the Reserve System <strong>and</strong> Trust Management................................... 10<br />
6.1.2 How Crown Reserves <strong>and</strong> Dedications can be used ............................................ 10<br />
6.1.3 Principles of Crown L<strong>and</strong> Management .............................................................. <strong>11</strong><br />
6.1.4 Food <strong>and</strong> Beverage Outlets on Crown Reserves Policy 2004 .............................................. <strong>11</strong><br />
6.2 Environmental Planning <strong>and</strong> Assessment Act 1979............................................................ 12<br />
6.2.1 Zoning Objectives .............................................................................................. 12<br />
6.2.2 Permissible Development in the Zone................................................................. 12<br />
6.3 Narooma Structure Plan – December 2005 ....................................................................... 13<br />
6.4 State Environmental Planning Policy No 71- Coastal Protection ......................................... <strong>14</strong><br />
6.5 NSW Coastal Policy 1997................................................................................................... 15<br />
6.6 The Comprehensive Coastal Assessment ........................................................................... 16<br />
6.7 <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Companion Animals Policy ............................................................................ 17<br />
6.8 Other Relevant Legislation <strong>and</strong> Policies.............................................................................. 17<br />
7. L<strong>and</strong> Description <strong>and</strong> Analysis.......................................................................................................... 18<br />
7.1 L<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management........................................................................ 18<br />
7.2 History .............................................................................................................................. 20<br />
7.3 Vegetation Survey ............................................................................................................. 21<br />
7.4 Fire Management .............................................................................................................. 27<br />
8. Leases <strong>and</strong> Licences.......................................................................................................................... 28<br />
8.2.1 Existing Leases <strong>and</strong> Licences ............................................................................... 28<br />
8.2.2 Requirements for Future Leases <strong>and</strong> Licences...................................................... 29<br />
8.2.3 Temporary Licences............................................................................................ 31<br />
8.2.4 Future Activities .................................................................................................. 31<br />
9. Values of the Reserve........................................................................................................................ 32<br />
10. Operational Plan .............................................................................................................................. 33<br />
9.1 Access – Generally............................................................................................................. 34<br />
9.2 Access – Pedestrian ........................................................................................................... 34<br />
9.3 Access – Vehicular ............................................................................................................. 34<br />
9.4 Fire Management .............................................................................................................. 34<br />
9.5 Leases, Licences, Contract Management & Casual Hiring .................................................. 34<br />
9.6 Recreational & Cultural Activities....................................................................................... 35<br />
9.7 Signage............................................................................................................................. 35<br />
9.8 Vegetation Management................................................................................................... 35<br />
<strong>11</strong>. L<strong>and</strong>scape Masterplans.................................................................................................................... 36<br />
1. Bill Smyth Oval – L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan........................................................................ 37<br />
2. Nata Oval <strong>and</strong> adjacent Reserves – L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan ............................................. 38<br />
3. Ken Rose Park – Site Analysis Plan to guide future detailed design ..................................... 39<br />
12. Stakeholders & Interest Groups........................................................................................................ 40<br />
13. Attachment A – Public Meeting Comments...................................................................................... 41<br />
<strong>14</strong>. Attachment B – Council’s Direction for the redevelopment of the Narooma Swimming Pool ........... 42<br />
15. Attachment C – Historical Review of the Reserves............................................................................. 43<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 3 of 43
1. Introduction – Why a Plan of Management<br />
All l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management is Crown L<strong>and</strong> Reserve. <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council is the<br />
appointed Trust Manager under Part 5 of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989 for the l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of<br />
Management.<br />
This Plan of Management guides the future use <strong>and</strong> development of these reserves. It outlines how Council,<br />
in consultation with the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s, intends to use, develop <strong>and</strong> manage the l<strong>and</strong>; how leases,<br />
licences or other interests are granted on the reserve; <strong>and</strong> determines the scale <strong>and</strong> intensity of development<br />
on the l<strong>and</strong> for today <strong>and</strong> the future.<br />
As a planning tool, it provides objectives for the management of the l<strong>and</strong>. This gives both Council, the<br />
Department of L<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> the community, goals to work towards in achieving desirable outcomes for the<br />
management of the l<strong>and</strong>. A Plan of Management can be used to identify projects that could be achieved<br />
through community working groups as well as providing supporting documentation when applying for<br />
grants.<br />
The Plan of Management is structured to firstly give an overview of the relevant legislation <strong>and</strong> policies that<br />
govern the development of the l<strong>and</strong> included in the plan. This is followed by an assessment of the existing<br />
condition of the reserves’ various features – both natural <strong>and</strong> constructed.<br />
Throughout the consultation process, the community’s values of the reserves have been identified. These<br />
values direct the strategies <strong>and</strong> actions which are illustrated in the L<strong>and</strong>scape Masterplan.<br />
There are various Appendices that support the information in the plan <strong>and</strong> give more background<br />
information to its development.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 4 of 43
2. Site Location<br />
Narooma is the main township for the southern district of the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong>, located approximately<br />
350km south of Sydney. Narooma is set within a spectacular natural location surrounded by the Wagonga<br />
Inlet, forests <strong>and</strong> mountains on the west <strong>and</strong> the ocean <strong>and</strong> Montague Isl<strong>and</strong> to the east.<br />
The reserves included in this Plan of Management are located at the southern end of the area known locally<br />
as “The Flat” in Narooma.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 5 of 43
3. Executive Summary<br />
This Plan of Management provides a guide for the future development of Bill Smyth Reserve, Narooma<br />
Leisure Centre, Narooma Swimming Pool, Nata Oval, Wagonga Inlet Foreshore Reserves <strong>and</strong> Ken Rose Park.<br />
The reserves provide the community with access to passive <strong>and</strong> active recreational opportunities including<br />
sporting fields, cycleways, a swimming pool <strong>and</strong> a visitor information centre.<br />
This Plan of Management provides for additional parking <strong>and</strong> future netball courts at Bill Smyth Oval as well<br />
as the widening of the rugby league practice field to accommodate a full sized field. A village green is<br />
proposed for Nata Oval as well as an expansion of the cycleway network which connects the reserve to the<br />
foreshore <strong>and</strong> to Bill Smyth Oval.<br />
The Plan of Management reflects December 2005 Council’s resolution to redevelop the swimming pool to<br />
accommodate a 25m x 6 lane pool <strong>and</strong> program pool within the existing structure. This would be<br />
incorporated in a new Sports <strong>and</strong> Aquatic Centre which would also include an indoor sports hall. Once this is<br />
developed it is proposed that the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre be demolished <strong>and</strong> replaced with car parking to<br />
improve access to adjacent facilities <strong>and</strong> the foreshore.<br />
The Wagonga Foreshore Reserve will continue to be managed as open parkl<strong>and</strong> with shade trees through to<br />
Ken Rose Park which will continue to function as resting place for travellers <strong>and</strong> the local community with<br />
picnic <strong>and</strong> public toilet facilities.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 6 of 43
4. Consultation Process<br />
4.1 Timeline<br />
Public Meeting 5 December 2005<br />
Refer to Attachment A for a summary of comments made at this meeting<br />
Reference Group<br />
Meetings<br />
10 April 20<strong>06</strong><br />
8 March 20<strong>06</strong><br />
29 May 20<strong>06</strong><br />
10 July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
<strong>14</strong> August 20<strong>06</strong><br />
20 September 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Adoption of Draft <strong>14</strong> November <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council’s <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee<br />
Meeting<br />
Exhibition Period 4 weeks minimum<br />
Submission Period 6 weeks minimum<br />
Public Meeting During exhibition period<br />
Date to be advised<br />
Submissions Considered Approximately 2 week timeframe from conclusion of submission period<br />
Final Endorsement <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council’s <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee Meeting<br />
Date to be advised<br />
Final Adoption Minister for L<strong>and</strong>s<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 7 of 43
4.2 Supporting the Consultation Process<br />
The consultation process was supported by the development of a web page on Council’s website that<br />
provided up-to-date information on the development of this Plan of Management.<br />
In addition, a folder containing information discussed at all Reference Group meetings, <strong>and</strong> other relevant<br />
information, was placed at the Narooma Library for public viewing.<br />
Council staff were available to answer questions at any time throughout the consultation process.<br />
4.3 Reference Group<br />
At the public meeting on 5 December 2005, expressions of interest were sought from the community to be<br />
included in a Reference Group. The Reference Group was established to work with Council in the<br />
development of this Plan of Management <strong>and</strong> comprises the following members:<br />
Mrs Lyn Field Easts Narooma Shores Holiday Park<br />
Mr Neil Mumme Instep Management Group<br />
Mr Peter McCulloch Narooma Australian Rules<br />
Mr Graham Reeve Narooma Sporting <strong>and</strong> Services Club<br />
Mr Max Murray Narooma Croquet Club<br />
Mr Bob Burnside Narooma Junior & Senior Rugby League<br />
Ms Terese Aston Narooma Netball<br />
Mr Terry Moulang Narooma Tennis Club Inc<br />
Ms Patricia Eaton Narooma Swimming Pool Users<br />
Mr Ben Bate Narooma Touch Football<br />
Mrs Jenni Bourke Narooma residents<br />
Mr Rob O’Brien Narooma residents<br />
Mr Kevin Young Narooma Sport & Leisure Centre<br />
4.4 Role of the Reference Group<br />
The Role of the Reference Group was determined in consultation with the members of the Reference Group<br />
as follows:<br />
To represent the views of the community;<br />
to promote <strong>and</strong> raise the community awareness of the issues;<br />
to encourage interaction with the community;<br />
be involved in open discussion with Council;<br />
to ensure a transparent decision making process;<br />
to recognise that the redevelopment of the swimming pool is a separate issue;<br />
to protect, maintain <strong>and</strong> enhance the natural environment, scenic qualities, recreational <strong>and</strong> cultural<br />
activities;<br />
to encourage passive recreational activities; <strong>and</strong><br />
to be involved in the development of a Plan of Management for Bill Smyth Reserve, the Narooma<br />
Leisure Centre, Narooma Swimming Pool, NATA Oval <strong>and</strong> Wagonga Inlet Foreshore Reserves;<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 8 of 43
5. Desired Outcomes<br />
To provide quality recreational facilities that meet the needs of the community<br />
To protect <strong>and</strong> enhance existing native vegetation.<br />
To ensure public access to foreshore reserves<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 9 of 43
6. Relevant Legislation <strong>and</strong> Policies<br />
6.1 NSW Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989<br />
Bill Smyth Reserve, the Narooma Leisure Centre, Narooma Swimming Pool, Nata Oval <strong>and</strong> the Wagonga Inlet<br />
Foreshore Reserve are all Crown Reserves <strong>and</strong> as such, this Plan of Management is prepared in accordance the<br />
provisions of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act (in particular Division 6) which governs the management <strong>and</strong> use of<br />
Crown Reserves.<br />
6.1.1 Crown L<strong>and</strong>, the Reserve System <strong>and</strong> Trust Management<br />
The Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989 governs the planning, management <strong>and</strong> use of Crown L<strong>and</strong>. It includes<br />
provisions to reserve or dedicate l<strong>and</strong>s for prescribed public purposes <strong>and</strong> facilitates leasing <strong>and</strong> licensing of<br />
Crown L<strong>and</strong> where appropriate. The collection of Crown l<strong>and</strong> for which has been set aside for a public<br />
purpose is called the Crown Reserve System.<br />
The Department of L<strong>and</strong>s, together with reserve trusts appointed by the Minister for L<strong>and</strong>s, is responsible for<br />
the administration <strong>and</strong> management of the Crown Reserve System. <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council is the Reserve<br />
Trust Manager appointed by the Minister for L<strong>and</strong>s to care, control <strong>and</strong> these reserves.<br />
6.1.2 How Crown Reserves <strong>and</strong> Dedications can be used<br />
Uses <strong>and</strong> activities in l<strong>and</strong> reserved for public purposes are broadly defined by the public purpose of the<br />
reservation or dedication, in conjunction with any conditions <strong>and</strong> provisions within the specific zoning in the<br />
Councils Local Environmental Plan.<br />
In addition, case law judgements influence the policy <strong>and</strong> practice of the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> the Trust<br />
Managers. The body of case law which helps define acceptable uses <strong>and</strong> activities on public recreation<br />
reserves provides the following guidance:<br />
• Improvements <strong>and</strong> developments to l<strong>and</strong> which is reserved or dedicated are confined to those which<br />
support, or are ancillary to, the public purpose of the reservation;<br />
• L<strong>and</strong> reserved or dedicated for public recreation must be open to the public generally as a right. The<br />
public may only be restricted from access to parts of the reserve <strong>and</strong> buildings thereon, if it is<br />
necessary for the public’s enjoyment of the reserve to be excluded, eg. a workshop, equipment<br />
storage or operational facilities;<br />
• Right of access does not mean entirely free access. Reasonable entry fees <strong>and</strong> charges may be<br />
imposed as well as other legal constraints to entry, such as relate to health <strong>and</strong> safety;<br />
• Use of the reserve must be consistent with the public purposes for which the l<strong>and</strong> is dedicated or<br />
reserved. This includes uses ancillary or supportive of the purpose, such as a kiosk on l<strong>and</strong> dedicated<br />
for public recreation; <strong>and</strong><br />
• A lease or licence must be consistent with the reason or purpose of the l<strong>and</strong>’s reservation or<br />
dedication.<br />
In order to change a reservation, a l<strong>and</strong> assessment is required under the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989. The<br />
Minister can waive an assessment if it is in the public interest, <strong>and</strong> if it is consistent with the principles of<br />
Crown L<strong>and</strong> management.<br />
In July 2005 the NSW Parliament passed legislation amending to Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989 to give the Minister<br />
power to authorise additional uses of Crown reserves providing such uses are compatible with the existing<br />
gazetted public purpose, consistent with the principles of Clown l<strong>and</strong> management <strong>and</strong> determined to be in<br />
the public interest.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 10 of 43
6.1.3 Principles of Crown L<strong>and</strong> Management<br />
Crown l<strong>and</strong> must be used <strong>and</strong> managed in accordance with the principles of Crown l<strong>and</strong> management as set<br />
out in Section <strong>11</strong> of the Act. These principles guide the development, use <strong>and</strong> management of Crown L<strong>and</strong>.<br />
Principles of Crown L<strong>and</strong> Management:<br />
(a) that environmental protection principles be observed in relation to the management <strong>and</strong><br />
administration of Crown l<strong>and</strong>,<br />
(b) that the natural resources of Crown l<strong>and</strong> (including water, soil, flora, fauna <strong>and</strong> scenic quality) be<br />
conserved wherever possible,<br />
(c) that public use <strong>and</strong> enjoyment of appropriate Crown l<strong>and</strong> be encouraged,<br />
(d) that, where appropriate, multiple use of Crown l<strong>and</strong> be encouraged,<br />
(e) that, where appropriate, Crown l<strong>and</strong> should be used <strong>and</strong> managed in such a way that<br />
both the l<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> its resources are sustained in perpetuity, <strong>and</strong><br />
(f) that Crown l<strong>and</strong> be occupied, used, sold, leased, licensed or otherwise dealt with in the<br />
best interests of the State consistent with the above principles.<br />
Crown l<strong>and</strong> may be reserved or dedicated for a variety of public purposes. There are currently many<br />
purposes for which Crown l<strong>and</strong> can be reserved. Uses <strong>and</strong> activities on l<strong>and</strong> reserved for pubic purposes are,<br />
firstly, broadly defined by the public purpose of the reservation, in conjunction with any conditions <strong>and</strong><br />
provisions within the specific zoning in the local council’s local environmental plan. The l<strong>and</strong> uses are then<br />
more specifically defined by either a statutory mechanism (a Plan of Management), contractual agreement<br />
(lease or licences), or a combination of both.<br />
In order to change a reservation, a l<strong>and</strong> assessment is required under the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989. The<br />
Minister can waive an assessment if it is in the public interest, <strong>and</strong> if it is consistent with the principles of<br />
Crown L<strong>and</strong> management.<br />
Division 6 of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act specifies that Draft Plans of Management must be exhibited for a minimum<br />
of 28 days <strong>and</strong> any person may make representations concerning the plan to the Minister. Once a Plan of<br />
Management is adopted for a Crown Reserve no operations may be undertaken on or in relation to the<br />
reserve unless they are in accordance with the plan.<br />
6.1.4 Food <strong>and</strong> Beverage Outlets on Crown Reserves Policy 2004<br />
This policy provides guidance for assessing food <strong>and</strong> beverage outlets which may be acceptable <strong>and</strong> those<br />
which may not be acceptable on Crown reserves. In determining whether a proposal is appropriate the<br />
following criteria should be applied:<br />
• The facility should enhance the public use of the reserve <strong>and</strong> not become the main focus of the<br />
reserve;<br />
• The integrity of the reserve in terms of its public purpose <strong>and</strong> environmental qualities should be<br />
preserved;<br />
The public’s right of access to the reserve should be preserved.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> <strong>11</strong> of 43
6.2 Environmental Planning <strong>and</strong> Assessment Act 1979<br />
All of the l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management is zoned 6a1 under Council’s Urban Local Environmental<br />
Plan (with the exception of Lot 476 DP 752155 which is partially unzoned).<br />
6.2.1 Zoning Objectives<br />
Any future uses of the reserve must be consistent the objectives for the 6a1 Public Open Space Zone which<br />
are as follows:<br />
(a) to recognise the importance of l<strong>and</strong> in the zone as open space <strong>and</strong> allow a limited range of uses<br />
compatible with keeping the l<strong>and</strong> as open space <strong>and</strong> in public ownership, <strong>and</strong><br />
(b) to permit a range of uses, especially recreational uses, where those uses comply with the plan of<br />
management for the l<strong>and</strong>, <strong>and</strong><br />
(c) to allow development on foreshores where that development is water related <strong>and</strong> enhances the<br />
recreational use or natural environment of the foreshore, <strong>and</strong><br />
(d) to reserve privately owned l<strong>and</strong> that is essential for future public open space <strong>and</strong> provide for its<br />
acquisition by the Council, <strong>and</strong><br />
(e) to ensure that development in areas of environmental significance does not reduce that significance.<br />
6.2.2 Permissible Development in the Zone<br />
The Urban Local Environmental Plan also defines what development may be carried out in the 6a1 Public<br />
Open Space Zone with or without development consent as follows.<br />
Development for the purpose of the following is allowed without development consent within the 6a1 Public<br />
Open Space zone (development not included in the following list is prohibited within the 6a1 Public Open<br />
Space zone):<br />
on community l<strong>and</strong>, development by or on behalf of a public authority that is consistent with an adopted<br />
plan of management for that community l<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong>, if not so consistent, would be allowed by subclause<br />
(2) or otherwise by this subclause,<br />
utility installations,<br />
works (including l<strong>and</strong> clearing) carried out by or on behalf of a public authority involved in l<strong>and</strong>scaping,<br />
gardening, bushfire hazard reduction, erosion control or rehabilitation, or drainage.<br />
Development for the purpose of the following is allowed only with development consent within the 6a1<br />
Public Open Space zone (development not included in the above or below list is prohibited within the 6a1<br />
Public Open Space zone):<br />
agriculture,<br />
aquaculture,<br />
caravan parks for short-term residents only,<br />
car parks,<br />
cemeteries,<br />
child care centres,<br />
community centres,<br />
development by a public authority,<br />
dwelling-houses required for the management<br />
of the reserve or facilities on the reserve,<br />
educational establishments,<br />
forestry,<br />
helipads for emergency use only,<br />
indoor recreation facilities,<br />
l<strong>and</strong> clearing,<br />
marinas,<br />
places of assembly,<br />
racecourses,<br />
recreation areas,<br />
recreation establishments,<br />
restaurants,<br />
roads,<br />
showgrounds,<br />
telecommunications facilities,<br />
waste collection centres.<br />
The proposals included in this Plan of Management are consistent with the above objectives for the use of<br />
l<strong>and</strong> zoned Public Open Space.<br />
This Plan of Management recommends that at the next review of the Urban Local Environmental Plan, all of<br />
Lot 476 DP 752155 be zoned as 6a1 Public Open Space.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 12 of 43
6.3 Narooma Structure Plan – December 2005<br />
The Narooma Structure Plan was adopted as a Development Control Plan (DCP) on 6 December 2005. The<br />
provisions of this DCP must be considered in the assessment of any new development applications for<br />
activities on the l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management. Similarly, the provisions of this DCP must be<br />
considered when granting any lease or licence on any l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management. The DCP<br />
includes a Style Guide that guides the development of all new buildings <strong>and</strong> structures.<br />
The following issues are addressed in the Structure Plan for future consideration/implementation on the l<strong>and</strong><br />
included in this Plan of Management.<br />
Public Open Space <strong>and</strong> Public <strong>Facilities</strong> (p40)<br />
The existing leisure centre site is suitable for re-development.<br />
Maintain golf courses, ovals <strong>and</strong> parks.<br />
Maintain caravan parks on Princes Highway <strong>and</strong> the beach.<br />
Existing public open spaces are to be maintained <strong>and</strong> enhanced.<br />
Public facilities are to be maintained in current locations. No schools or other public buildings<br />
outside the settlement boundary.<br />
New public open space protects vegetation <strong>and</strong> creates pedestrian <strong>and</strong> habitat corridors from East<br />
to West.<br />
Maintain existing sporting, cultural, health <strong>and</strong> social facilities in their present location.<br />
Area including Bill Smyth Oval, Bowling Club, Leisure Centre, Nata Oval <strong>and</strong> Swimming Pool to<br />
become the ‘Sport <strong>and</strong> Recreation Precinct’. Any new sporting facilities should be located within<br />
this Precinct. A Plan of Management should be prepared for this area as a whole.<br />
Urban Native Vegetation Retention (p42)<br />
Vegetation within the forested perimeter around Bill Smyth Oval shall be retained <strong>and</strong> appropriate<br />
controls for the retention included in the Plan of Management for the oval.<br />
Access <strong>and</strong> Circulation (p50)<br />
Ensure foreshore streets are for recreation, water access <strong>and</strong> are pedestrian environments.<br />
Ensure public access is continuous along foreshore edges.<br />
Create pedestrian links from East to West through the town (ensure access from Bill Smyth Oval to<br />
Forsters Bay Road <strong>and</strong> through to the Princes Highway).<br />
The Flat Desired Future Character (p68)<br />
Maintain existing sporting, cultural, health <strong>and</strong> social facilities in their present location<br />
Consider the two sites suitable for public facilities. The Bluewater Drive site is well situated for a<br />
sports centre.<br />
Maintain the existing foreshore caravan park. The park footprint is to be limited to the existing<br />
extent. Building scale <strong>and</strong> massing is to be similar to existing buildings.<br />
All public open spaces are to maintain or improve the current level of public access, particularly<br />
those spaces adjacent to a foreshore.<br />
Provide a pathway linking the main street to the foreshore.<br />
Potential to provide a new public pedestrian pathway through park.<br />
An intersection upgrade at the corner of McMillan Rd <strong>and</strong> highway is under investigation, as too is<br />
the location of future recreational uses (p69).<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 13 of 43
6.4 State Environmental Planning Policy No 71- Coastal Protection<br />
State Environmental Planning Policy No. 71 (SEPP 71) – Coastal Protection is a key element of the NSW<br />
Government’s Coastal Protection Package to protect the State’s beaches, headl<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> other coastal<br />
features for future generations. The NSW Minister for Planning determined that the protection of the NSW<br />
coast is a matter of environmental planning significance for the State under the Environmental Planning <strong>and</strong><br />
Assessment Act 1979.<br />
SEPP 71 applies to all l<strong>and</strong> located within the Coastal Zone, as defined in Section 7.3 above.<br />
The policy has been made to ensure:<br />
development in the NSW coastal zone is appropriate <strong>and</strong> suitably located<br />
there is a consistent <strong>and</strong> strategic approach to coastal planning <strong>and</strong> management<br />
there is a clear development assessment framework for new development in the coastal zone.<br />
All of the Crown L<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management is included in the coastal zone. The provisions of<br />
SEPP 71 apply to all of this l<strong>and</strong>.<br />
Therefore, certain types of Development Applications (DA) may need to be referred to the Department of<br />
Infrastructure, Planning <strong>and</strong> Natural Resources (DIPNR). DIPNR will then determine who will assess the DA<br />
(under Section 89A of the Environmental Planning <strong>and</strong> Assessment Act) – whether it be Council or DIPNR.<br />
The types of developments that would need to be referred to DIPNR includes, but is not limited to, two storey<br />
developments <strong>and</strong> tourist facilities (including camping grounds). Refer to Schedule 2 of SEPP 71 for more<br />
information.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> <strong>14</strong> of 43
6.5 NSW Coastal Policy 1997<br />
The Coastal Policy responds to the fundamental challenge to provide for population growth <strong>and</strong> economic<br />
development without putting the natural, cultural <strong>and</strong> heritage values of the coastal environment at risk. To<br />
achieve this, the Policy has a strong integrating philosophy based on the principles of ecologically sustainable<br />
development (ESD).<br />
The coastal zone is defined in section 4A of the Coastal Protection Act 1979 (as amended 2002). Generally it<br />
includes l<strong>and</strong> that is one kilometre l<strong>and</strong>ward of the western boundary of the coastal waters of New South<br />
Wales, also, one kilometre l<strong>and</strong>ward around any bay, estuary, coastal lake or lagoon, also, follows the length<br />
of any coastal river inl<strong>and</strong> generally at a distance of one kilometre from each bank of the river, also, to one<br />
kilometre beyond the limit of any recognised mangroves on or associated with the river, or, if there are no<br />
such recognised mangroves to one kilometre beyond the tidal limit of the river is shown to the nearest<br />
cadastral boundary or easily recognisable physical boundary.<br />
Therefore, all of the l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management is located in the Coastal Zone <strong>and</strong> is subject to<br />
the provisions of the NSW Coastal Policy 1997.<br />
The nine goals of the Coastal Policy are:<br />
1. Protecting, rehabilitating <strong>and</strong> improving the natural environment of the coastal zone.<br />
2. Recognising <strong>and</strong> accommodating the natural processes of the coastal zone.<br />
3. Protecting <strong>and</strong> enhancing the aesthetic qualities of the coastal zone.<br />
4. Protecting <strong>and</strong> conserving the cultural heritage of the coastal zone.<br />
5. Providing for ecologically sustainable development <strong>and</strong> use of resources.<br />
6. Providing for ecologically sustainable human settlement in the coastal zone.<br />
7. Providing for appropriate public access <strong>and</strong> use.<br />
8. Providing information to enable effective management of the coastal zone.<br />
9. Providing for integrated planning <strong>and</strong> management of the coastal zone.<br />
Some of the Key Actions of the Coastal Policy that are especially relevant to this Plan of Management include:<br />
Protection <strong>and</strong> restoration of important fisheries habitats, such as seagrasses <strong>and</strong> mangroves.<br />
SEPP <strong>14</strong> Coastal Wetl<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> SEPP 26 Littoral Rainforests will be rigorously enforced <strong>and</strong> extended<br />
where appropriate in recognition that what remains of these valuable ecosystems needs to be fully<br />
protected from inappropriate development.<br />
Coastal l<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> aquatic environments with conservation values will be assessed <strong>and</strong> appropriate<br />
tenures, reservations, zonings <strong>and</strong>/or regulations will be put in place to protect them, conserve<br />
biodiversity <strong>and</strong> to protect <strong>and</strong> ensure the recovery of threatened species.<br />
Water quality in coastal waters, estuaries <strong>and</strong> rivers will be maintained where it is currently adequate, or<br />
improved where it is currently inadequate. This will be addressed through a number of specific actions<br />
designed to control discharges from both point <strong>and</strong> non-point sources, including development <strong>and</strong><br />
implementation of management <strong>and</strong> monitoring programs.<br />
Cultural heritage will be protected <strong>and</strong> conserved through a variety of planning <strong>and</strong> management<br />
programs.<br />
As at the date of adoption of this Plan of Management the 1997 Coastal Policy was under review.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 15 of 43
6.6 The Comprehensive Coastal Assessment<br />
The original broad guidance from Government when the Comprehensive Coastal Assessment (CCA) was<br />
initiated indicated that the CCA would:<br />
Acquire then utilise information on the values (<strong>and</strong> therefore opportunities) of the NSW coast to enable<br />
better <strong>and</strong> more certain economic, social <strong>and</strong> environmental decision-making.<br />
Provide data on, <strong>and</strong> an analysis of, the environmental, economic, social <strong>and</strong> cultural values of coastal<br />
l<strong>and</strong> for use in planning <strong>and</strong> management with a focus on l<strong>and</strong> use decision making at the regional scale.<br />
Ensure the st<strong>and</strong>ardisation <strong>and</strong> integration of existing data sets <strong>and</strong> to identify <strong>and</strong> fill significant data <strong>and</strong><br />
information gaps, based on clearly defined policy objectives.<br />
Document a range of key data sets (for example, vegetation; tenure; economic resources such as<br />
minerals) which will be used to, for example:<br />
Identify areas suitable for growth industries such as aquaculture development <strong>and</strong> boat building;<br />
Identify areas suitable to support tourism development ranging from major new resorts to low key<br />
eco-tourism;<br />
Define <strong>and</strong> delineate areas suitable for rural <strong>and</strong> residential development;<br />
Identify <strong>and</strong> then protect key economic resources, for example, minerals <strong>and</strong> aggregate s<strong>and</strong>s;<br />
Identify highly sensitive coastal <strong>and</strong> estuarine habitats <strong>and</strong> catchments; <strong>and</strong><br />
Develop an inventory of areas with potential for public open space or conservation management.<br />
Be consistent with Government objectives to sustain Indigenous coastal communities <strong>and</strong> their<br />
heritage.<br />
The CCA will achieve these through the Department of Infrastructure Planning <strong>and</strong> Natural Resources’<br />
Coastal Regional Strategies that are being developed for priority areas including the South Coast. These new<br />
regional strategies will direct how sustainable development will occur in the regions over the next 30 years<br />
(looking at growth, infrastructure to support economic development <strong>and</strong> creating regions that are better<br />
places to live <strong>and</strong> work). Each strategy will be informed by a strategic assessment to test the impacts of<br />
different development scenarios, <strong>and</strong> this is where the CCA will be important.<br />
The CCAs have developed an integration framework plus tools, methods <strong>and</strong> data via CCA projects. The<br />
integration framework is being used to varying degrees across the different regional strategies to evaluate <strong>and</strong><br />
rank development scenarios based on a suite of coastal values.<br />
The regional strategies will not be legislative (like Regional Environmental Plans), but Local Environmental<br />
Plans up-dated over the next 3-5 years will be directed to take them into account.<br />
Changes to <strong>Eurobodalla</strong>’s LEPs may impact on the future development of the reserves, depending on how<br />
the various regional strategies from the CCA are incorporated into amended LEPs.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 16 of 43
6.7 <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Companion Animals Policy<br />
The <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Companion Animals Policy makes the following provisions for dogs on the l<strong>and</strong> included in<br />
this Plan of Management:<br />
Dogs are allowed 24 hour off leash access to the southern end of Bill Smyth Oval below Canty Street.<br />
Dogs are allowed on all other areas of l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management on leash only.<br />
6.8 Other Relevant Legislation <strong>and</strong> Policies<br />
Coastal Protection Act 1979<br />
Local Government Act 1993<br />
Native Vegetation Conservation Act 1997<br />
Noxious Weeds Act 1993<br />
New South Wales Biodiversity Strategy – NPWS<br />
Native Vegetation Conservation Strategy<br />
State Rivers & Estuaries Policies<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 17 of 43
7. L<strong>and</strong> Description <strong>and</strong> Analysis<br />
7.1 L<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management<br />
All of the l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management is Crown L<strong>and</strong>. <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council has been Trust<br />
Manager of Reserve No. 63051 since 6 May 1938 <strong>and</strong> Trust Manager of Reserves No. 80515 since 1 August<br />
1958.<br />
Table A provides a summary of the l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management.<br />
Reserve Name Crown Reserve<br />
Purpose<br />
Caravan Park (East’s<br />
Narooma Shores Holiday<br />
Park)<br />
Wagonga Inlet Foreshore<br />
Reserve<br />
Narooma Indoor Sports<br />
& Aquatic Centre<br />
Crown Reserve<br />
Trust Name<br />
Crown<br />
Reserve<br />
No<br />
Lot & DP<br />
Number<br />
Lot 916 DP<br />
823230<br />
Part<br />
DP 1055108<br />
& Lot 476<br />
DP 752155<br />
DP 1055108<br />
Nata Oval Lot 70<strong>11</strong><br />
DP 1055108<br />
Southern Bluewater<br />
Reserve (Narooma Leisure<br />
Centre)<br />
Bill Smyth Recreation<br />
Reserve<br />
Bill Smyth Reserve<br />
Natural Area<br />
Narooma Sporting &<br />
Services Club – Bowling<br />
Club Carpark<br />
Public Recreation<br />
& Public Resting<br />
Public Recreation<br />
& Public Resting<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong><br />
(South) Reserve<br />
Trust<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong><br />
(South) Reserve<br />
Trust<br />
63051<br />
80515<br />
Part<br />
DP 1055108<br />
&<br />
Lot 1 Sec 17<br />
DP 758754<br />
Lot 912<br />
DP 7292<strong>06</strong><br />
Lot 7026<br />
DP 1020248<br />
Lot 9<strong>11</strong><br />
DP 7292<strong>06</strong><br />
Table A: L<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management<br />
Area Address Zoning<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 18 of 43<br />
5.694<br />
ha<br />
Princes<br />
Highway,<br />
Narooma<br />
4.12ha Princes<br />
Highway,<br />
Narooma<br />
5913m2 Bluewater<br />
Drive,<br />
Narooma<br />
7.21ha Princes<br />
Highway,<br />
Narooma<br />
1.446ha Barker<br />
Parade,<br />
Narooma<br />
3244m2 Princes<br />
Highway,<br />
Narooma<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council has been Trust Manager of Reserve No. 63051 since 6 May 1938 <strong>and</strong> Trust<br />
Manager of Reserve No. 80515 since 1 August 1958.<br />
These are illustrated on the following map:<br />
6a1<br />
6a1<br />
(Lot 476 DP<br />
752155<br />
uncoloured)<br />
6a1<br />
6a1<br />
6a1<br />
6a1
Rotary<br />
Park<br />
Technical Services<br />
Division<br />
RIVERSIDE DR<br />
RIVERSIDE DR<br />
LEGEND<br />
Approved On Behalf Of<br />
EUROBODALLA SHIRE COUNCIL<br />
Date<br />
BURRAWANG ST<br />
DUDLEYS LN<br />
Technical Services Manager<br />
GRAHAM ST<br />
Narooma<br />
Library<br />
LYNCH ST<br />
NICHELSEN ST<br />
BURRAWANG LN<br />
BRICE ST<br />
FIELD ST<br />
BARKER PDE<br />
MCMILLAN RD<br />
FORSTERS BAY RD<br />
Caravan Park (East's Narooma Shores<br />
Holiday Park) Part Crown Reserve 630515<br />
Wagonga Inlet Foreshore Reserve<br />
Part Crown Reserve 630515<br />
Narooma Indoor Sports & Aquatic Centre<br />
Part Crown Reserve 630515<br />
Wagonga Inlet<br />
Foreshore Reserve<br />
HYLAND AVE<br />
WALKER LN<br />
Caravan Park<br />
TAYLOR ST<br />
TAYLOR LN<br />
PRINCES HWY<br />
Wagonga Inlet<br />
Nata Oval<br />
Indoor<br />
Sports &<br />
Aquatic<br />
Centre<br />
Bill Smyth<br />
Recreation<br />
Reserve<br />
Bill Smyth Reserve<br />
Natural Area<br />
EUROBODALLA SHIRE COUNCIL 2397 - A<br />
Bill Smyth, Nata Oval & Adjacent Reserves<br />
Princes Highway, Narooma<br />
Plan of Management<br />
Crown L<strong>and</strong> Status as at July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Southern Bluewater Drive Reserve<br />
(Narooma Leisure Centre)<br />
Bill Smyth<br />
Lease Area<br />
Scale: 1:5000 @ A4<br />
Drawn: DP<br />
Date: July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Files: 05.9616<br />
Sheet: 1 of 1<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 19 of 43<br />
BARKER PDE<br />
MCMILLAN RD<br />
Nata Oval<br />
Part Crown Reserve 630515<br />
Southern Bluewater Drive Reserve<br />
Part Crown Reserve 630515<br />
Bill Smyth Recreational Reserve<br />
Part Crown Reserve 80515<br />
BLUEWATER DR<br />
Narooma Sporting &<br />
Services Bowling Club<br />
BARKER PDE<br />
Bill Smyth Reserve Natural Area<br />
Part Crown Reserve 80515<br />
Bill Smyth Reserve Lease Area<br />
Part Crown Reserve 80515<br />
WHARF ST<br />
CAMPBELL ST<br />
Council is Trust Manager for both Crown Reserve<br />
63051 & 80515 - <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> (South) Reserve Trust
7.2 History<br />
During the development of this Plan of Management Ms Laurelle Pacey was engaged by Council to provide a<br />
historical review of the reserves included in this Plan of Management. This report provides a brief summary of<br />
the changing uses of the Crown Reserves on the flat <strong>and</strong> the contributions made by the Narooma community<br />
in establishing <strong>and</strong> maintaining the grounds <strong>and</strong> the facilities enjoyed by both locals <strong>and</strong> tourists over many<br />
years. It is a combination of anecdotal <strong>and</strong> limited primary source material, as well as limited time.<br />
A copy of this report is included at Attachment C.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 20 of 43
7.3 Vegetation Survey<br />
In May 20<strong>06</strong> the following Vegetation Survey was completed for Bill Smyth Reserve, Nata Oval, Narooma<br />
Visitor Information Centre, Wagonga Foreshore & Park <strong>and</strong> the Narooma Sports & Leisure Centre by the<br />
Friends of the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Regional Botanic Gardens.<br />
7.3.1 Bill Smyth Reserve<br />
Bill Smyth Reserve covers two vegetation types. While these can be fitted into the Terrestrial Ecosystems of<br />
the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Local Government Area up to a point, the impact of introduced weeds <strong>and</strong> the surrounding<br />
domestic gardens has had a profound influence on the species makeup of each type.<br />
The majority of the reserve is dominated by Corymbia maculata (Spotted gum) on the moist south east facing<br />
slopes. This fits approximately into the Forest Ecosystem 9: Coastal lowl<strong>and</strong>s Cycad dry shrub dry forest -<br />
Corymbia maculata/Macrozamia communis. Macrozamia communis specimens are present, as well as<br />
Pittosporum undulatum (Sweet pittosporum), Notelaea venosa (Smooth mock olive), several species of twiner<br />
<strong>and</strong> a few native grasses. However, the intrusion of weeds has severely degraded the integrity of this Forest<br />
Type.<br />
The northern end of the Reserve, being somewhat drier (except for a watercourse draining into a small dam),<br />
could probably have once been likened to Forest Ecosystem 171: Coastal shrub/Grass forest - Eucalyptus<br />
tereticornis. However, apart for a small portion still with a shrub <strong>and</strong> ground cover layer, in the majority of<br />
the E. tereticornis (Forest red gum) ecosystem much of the shrub <strong>and</strong> ground cover layers have been removed<br />
to make way for mown grass, leaving just the large trees in place.<br />
The margins of the reserve, along the playing field, Barker Parade <strong>and</strong> bush pathways, contain a very large<br />
number of weeds, most of them environmentally problematic. These include escapees from the<br />
neighbouring gardens. Many of these species have spread into the forested areas <strong>and</strong> will present huge<br />
problems in control.<br />
There were only two species of noxious weeds encountered (see below). The Lantana (Lantana camara) is<br />
widespread through the moist <strong>and</strong> dry areas of the forest, while the Blackberry (Rubus discolor) is mostly<br />
concentrated alongside bush tracks in high light situations.<br />
NOXIOUS WEEDS<br />
Family Genus Species Common name<br />
VERBENACEAE Lantana camara Lantana<br />
ROSACEAE Rubus discolor Blackberry<br />
There are at least nine environmental weeds present in the reserve, most of them on the margins, but others<br />
spread throughout. Senna septemtrionalis (Cassia), Myrsiphyllum asparagoides (Bridal veil creeper) <strong>and</strong><br />
Protosparagus plumosus (Asparagus fern) appear to be the worst offenders in this regard. The vine Delairea<br />
odorata (Cape ivy) is unattractive <strong>and</strong> rampant along the watercourses, while there is a number of fully<br />
grown (huge) specimens of the escaped Canary Isl<strong>and</strong> Palm. There are also quite a few palm seedlings in the<br />
reserve. Given the number of adult specimens of this plant, it is likely that these are juveniles of the Canary<br />
Isl<strong>and</strong> Palm (Phoenix canariensis).<br />
ENVIRONMENTAL WEEDS<br />
Family Genus Species Common name<br />
ARECACEAE Phoenix canariensis Canary Isl<strong>and</strong> palm<br />
LILIACEAE Agapanthus campanulatus Agapanthus<br />
ASTERACEAE Delairea odorata Cape ivy<br />
FABACEAE Genista monspessulana Montpelier broom<br />
LILIACEAE Lilium formosanum Formosa lily<br />
ASPARAGACEAE Myrsiphyllum asparagoides Bridal veil creeper<br />
POLYGALACEAE Polygala virgata Broom milkwort<br />
ASPARAGACEAE Protosparagus plumosus Climbing asparagus<br />
ASPARAGACEAE Protosparagus aethiopicus Asparagus fern<br />
CAESALPINACEAE Senna septemtrionalis Cassia<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 21 of 43
The hillside behind the playing fields appears to have a high diversity of species. However, this is almost<br />
entirely due to the number of introduced weedy species – 40 of the 105 total.<br />
HILLSIDE BEHIND OVAL<br />
Family Genus Species Common name Intro Abundance<br />
ASTERACEAE blue/white daisy * 2<br />
MIMOSACEAE Acacia irrorata Green wattle 3<br />
MIMOSACEAE Acacia longifolia Golden wattle 2<br />
MIMOSACEAE Acacia floribunda Gossamer wattle 3<br />
MIMOSACEAE Acacia implexa Hickory 3<br />
MYRTACEAE Acmena smithii Lilly pilly 2<br />
LILIACEAE Agapanthus campanulatus Agapanthus * 2<br />
CUNONIACEAE Aphanopetalum resinosum Gum vine 2<br />
LILIACEAE Arum italicum Arum lily * 2<br />
ASPLENIACEAE Asplenium australasicum Birds nest fern 2<br />
EUPHORBIACEAE Beyeria oblongifolia 2<br />
ASTERACEAE Bidens pilosa Cobblers pegs * 2<br />
PITTOSPORACEAE Billardiera sc<strong>and</strong>ens Apple fine 2<br />
STERCULIACEAE Brachychiton acerifolius Lacebark 1<br />
DICKSONIACEAE Calochlaena dubia Ground fern 2<br />
CYPERACEAE Carex appressa 2<br />
ASTERACEAE Cassinia longifolia 3<br />
ANTHERICACEAE Chlorophytum comosum Ribbon grass * 2<br />
ASTERACEAE Conyza albida Fleabane * 2<br />
RUBIACEAE Coprosma repens Mirror bush * 2<br />
MYRTACEAE Corymbia maculata Spotted gum 5<br />
MALACEAE Cotoneaster lacteus Cotoneaster * 2<br />
ASTERACEAE Delairea odorata Cape ivy * 3<br />
CONVOLVULACEAE Dichondra repens Kidney weed 3<br />
BLECHNACEAE Doodia aspera Rough fern 2<br />
POACEAE Ehrharta erecta Veld grass * 2<br />
MYRTACEAE Eucalyptus botryoides Swamp mahogany 4<br />
MYRTACEAE Eucalyptus paniculata Ironbark 2<br />
MYRTACEAE Eucalyptus tereticornis Forest red gum 3<br />
LUZURIAGACEAE Eustrephus latifolius Wombat berry 2<br />
SANTALACEAE Exocarpos cupressiformis Native cherry 3<br />
CYPERACEAE Gahnia melanocarpa Sword grass 2<br />
LUZURIAGACEAE Geitonoplesium cymosum Scrambling lily 2<br />
FABACEAE Genista monspessulana Montpelier broom * 2<br />
GERANIACEAE Geranium sol<strong>and</strong>eri Wild geranium 2<br />
EUPHORBIACEAE Glochidion ferdin<strong>and</strong>i Cheese tree 1<br />
FABACEAE Glycine cl<strong>and</strong>estina 2<br />
GOODENIACEAE Goodenia ovata 2<br />
FABACEAE Hadenbergia violacea Happy w<strong>and</strong>erer 3<br />
DILLENIACEAE Hibbertia sc<strong>and</strong>ens Guinea flower 2<br />
DILLENIACEAE Hibbertia dentata Guinea vine 3<br />
APIACEAE Hydrocotyle bonariensis Pennywort * 2<br />
ASTERACEAE Hypochaeris radicata D<strong>and</strong>elion * 2<br />
POACEAE Imperata cylindrical Blady grass 2<br />
FABACEAE Indigofera australis Indigo plant 2<br />
FABACEAE Kennedia rubicunda Coral pea 1<br />
VERBENACEAE Lantana camara Lantana * 4<br />
CYPERACEAE Lepidosperma laterale 2<br />
OLEACEAE Ligustrum sinense Small leaved privet * 3<br />
OLEACEAE Ligustrum lucidum Large leafed privet * 1<br />
LILIACEAE Lilium formosanum Formosa lily * 2<br />
LOMANDRACEAE Lom<strong>and</strong>ra longifolia Spiky matrush 2<br />
CAPRIFOLIACEAE Lonicera japonica Honeysuckle * 2<br />
ZAMIACEAE Macrozamia communis Burrawamg 2<br />
ASCLEPIDIACEAE Marsdenia rostrata Common milk vine 3<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 22 of 43
HILLSIDE BEHIND OVAL<br />
Family Genus Species Common name Intro Abundance<br />
LAMIACEAE Melissa offianalis Balm * 2<br />
ARACEAE Monstera deliciosa * 1<br />
RUBIACEAE Morinda jasminoides 2<br />
ASPARAGACEAE Myrsiphyllum asparagoides Bridal veil creeper * 3<br />
OLEACEAE Notelaea venosa Smooth mock-olive 3<br />
OCHNACEAE Ochna serrulata * 3<br />
EUPHORBIACEAE Omalanthus populifolius Bleeding heart 3<br />
POACEAE Oplismenus imbecillis 2<br />
RANUNCULACEAE P<strong>and</strong>ora p<strong>and</strong>orea Wonga vile 3<br />
POACEAE Paspalum dilatatum Paspalum * 3<br />
PASSIFLORACEAE Passiflora edulis Passionfruit * 1<br />
PASSIFLORACEAE Passiflora mollissima Banana passionfruit * 1<br />
PHORMIACEAE Patersonia sericea Native iris 2<br />
SINOPTERIDACEAE Pellaea falcata Sickle fern 3<br />
POACEAE Pennisetum cl<strong>and</strong>estimum Kikuyu * 2<br />
ARECACEAE Phoenix canarienis Canary Isl<strong>and</strong> palm * 3<br />
SOLANACEAE Physalis peruviana` Cape gooseberry * 3<br />
PITTOSPORACEAE Pittosporum undulatum Pittosporum 3<br />
PITTOSPORACEAE Pittosporum revolutum 1<br />
PLANTAGINACEAE Plantago lanceolata Plaintain * 2<br />
PLATANACEAE Platanus ?occidentalis Plane tree * 2<br />
LAMIACEAE Plectranthus suaveolens 2<br />
POACEAE Poa meionectes 2<br />
POACEAE Poa labillardieri 2<br />
POLYGALACEAE Polygala virgata Broom milkwort * 2<br />
ARALIACEAE Polyscias sambucifolia Elderberry panax 2<br />
RHAMNACEAE Pomaderris aspera Hazel pomaderris 2<br />
ASPARAGACEAE Protasparagus plumosus Climbing<br />
asparagus<br />
* 4<br />
ASPARAGACEAE Protasparagus aethiopicus Asparagus fern * 2<br />
ACANTHACEAE Pseuderanthemum variable Pastel flower 2<br />
DENNSTAEDTIACEAE Pteridium esculentum Bracken 3<br />
MYRSINACEAE Rapanea howittiana Muttonwood 2<br />
CHENOPODIACEAE Rhaagodia c<strong>and</strong>olleana Sea berry saltbush 1<br />
MALACEAE Rhaphiolepis indicus Indian hawthorn * 2<br />
ASTERACEAE Roldana petasitis * 2<br />
ROSACEAE Rubus discolor Blackberry * 2<br />
ROSACEAE Rubus parvifolius Native raspberry 2<br />
MENISPERMACEAE Sarcopetalum harveyanum Pearl vine 1<br />
GOODENIACEAE Scaevola aemula Fan flower 2<br />
ASTERACEAE Senecio hispidulus Hill fireweed 2<br />
CAESALPINACEAE Senna septemtrionalis Cassia * 4<br />
SMILACACEAE Smilax australis Lawyer vine 2<br />
SOLANACEAE Solanum pseudocapsicum Jerusalem cherry * 2<br />
POACEAE Sporobolus indicus Parramatta grass * 2<br />
MENISPERMACEAE Stephania japonica Snake vine 2<br />
MELIACEAE Synoum gl<strong>and</strong>ulosum Rosewood 1<br />
POACEAE Themeda australis Kangaroo grass 2<br />
COMMELINACEAE Tradescantia albiflora W<strong>and</strong>ering jew * 3<br />
ASCLEPIDACEAE Tylophora barbata Bearded tylophora 3<br />
TYPHACEAE Typha orientalis Bullrush 2<br />
URTICACEAE Urtica incisa Stinging nettle 2<br />
RUTACEAE Zieria smithii S<strong>and</strong>fly bush 3<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 23 of 43
Recommendations for Bill Smyth Reserve<br />
Recovering Bill Smyth Reserve from its present degraded state will pose an enormous challenge, but one well<br />
worth attempting. The reserve contains the nucleus of a healthy Corymbia maculata/Macrozamia communis<br />
forest; however, restoring the Eucalyptus tereticornis complex on the northern corner does not appear to be<br />
feasible. Far better to leave it a grassy woodl<strong>and</strong> (with the Kikuyu kept under control) with space under the<br />
trees for children to play.<br />
The first priority would be to persuade the residents of the houses in Barker Parade to cease throwing their<br />
garden waste into the bush. Council’s new Green Waste removal system should help in this regard.<br />
Control of the two noxious weed species (Lantana <strong>and</strong> Blackberry) is a matter of some urgency. This applies<br />
especially to the Lantana camara (Lantana), as at this stage there are few large dense thickets.<br />
A strategy to cope with the environmental weeds is also an important management issue. The worst<br />
offenders such as the Canary Isl<strong>and</strong> Palms (Phoenix canarienses), Bridal veil creeper (Myrsiphyllum<br />
asparagoides), the Asparagus ferns (Protosparagus species) <strong>and</strong> the Cassias (Senna septemtrionalis) dem<strong>and</strong><br />
immediate attention.<br />
It appears that the best way to tackle the weeding problem would be h<strong>and</strong> weeding with regular follow up<br />
work, especially around the margins. While this method of vegetation restoration is tedious <strong>and</strong> slow going,<br />
it is thorough as it ensures the removal of underground tubers <strong>and</strong> bulbs. It also minimises the disturbance<br />
of existing desirable vegetation <strong>and</strong> keeps the soil seed bank intact (a most important aspect for future<br />
regeneration). If h<strong>and</strong> weeding is done well, there would probably be little need for any supplementary<br />
planting to be undertaken.<br />
7.3.2 Nata Oval <strong>and</strong> Narooma Visitor Information Centre<br />
The significant trees in this area were grouped according to their location as shown on the following map.<br />
A. The row of pines behind the Swimming Pool - Cupressus macrocarpa ‘Aurea’ (Golden Cypress)<br />
B. The trees in front of the Visitor Centre - Eucalyptus cinerea (Argyle apple) <strong>and</strong> E. botryoides (Swamp<br />
mahongany)<br />
C. Four or five trees in front of the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre - Corymbia ficifolia (Western Australian red<br />
flowering gum)<br />
Recommendations for Nata Oval <strong>and</strong> Narooma Visitor Information Centre<br />
None of the above trees are irreplaceable. Some, such as the C. Corymbia ficifolia (Western Australian red<br />
flowering gum) have ‘passed their use by date’, <strong>and</strong> would not be missed.<br />
If it was found to be necessary during the pool upgrade to remove the A. trees Cupressus macrocarpa ‘Aurea’<br />
(Golden cypress), which at present provide a good shelter for the Swimming Pool from the summer western<br />
sun, it would not be difficult to plant a replacement row (not necessarily the same species) after construction<br />
work had ceased. But provided these pines do not pose any threat to the operation of the current pool, there<br />
does not seem any good reason to remove them.<br />
Neither does there appear to be any reason to interfere with the trees in B. between the Visitor Centre <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Highway. At the same time, the planted gardens surrounding the Centre could do with some attention,<br />
including judicious pruning <strong>and</strong> removal of old specimens.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 24 of 43
7.3.3 Wagonga Foreshore & Park<br />
The vegetation along the inlet side of the stone wall is in reasonably good condition, given the high volume<br />
traffic during the summer months. There are few weeds of any description. Provided that there is minimal<br />
disturbance in this area, including the mangrove section, it should remain in its present healthy state. The<br />
beds of Cyperus laevigatus near the drainage channels prevent movement of the Inlet mud, <strong>and</strong> perform as an<br />
efficient filter for the waters of the Inlet as the tides flow in <strong>and</strong> out. The main two native grasses noted,<br />
Sporobolus virginicus <strong>and</strong> Zoysia macrantha, help bind the s<strong>and</strong> at the edge of the Inlet, <strong>and</strong>, together with the<br />
Cyperus laevigatus, act as water filters.<br />
Most of the weeds listed appear in the mown ‘lawn’ in front of the Caravan Park; however constant mowing<br />
<strong>and</strong> the pressure of people apparently keeps them under control. Some of these weeds could cause<br />
problems if they were allowed to escape, but this is not considered likely. There were no noxious weeds<br />
surveyed along the foreshore <strong>and</strong> in the Park at the northern end.<br />
FORESHORE VEGETATION<br />
Family Genus Species Common name Intro Abundance<br />
MIMOSACEAE Acacia longifolia Sydney wattle 1<br />
MYRSINACEAE Aegiceras corniculatum River mangrove 4<br />
ARAUCARIACEAE Araucaria heterophylla Norfolk Isl<strong>and</strong> pine * 3<br />
CYPERACEAE Carex pumila 4<br />
AIZOACEAE Carpobrotus glaucescens Pigs face 3<br />
CASUARINACEAE Casuarina glauca Swamp oak 3<br />
ASTERACEAE Conyza albida Fleabane * 2<br />
POACEAE Cynodon dactylon Couch grass * 4<br />
CYPERACEAE Cyperus laevigaus 4<br />
POACEAE Errharta erecta Veldt grass * 2<br />
ASTERACEAE Hypochaeris radicata D<strong>and</strong>elion * 2<br />
JUNCACEAE Juncus krausii Sea rush 2<br />
PLUMBAGINACEAE Limonium australe Sea lavender 2<br />
MYRTACEAE Melaleuca armillaris Honey myrtle 2<br />
OXALIDACEAE Oxalis pres-caprae Soursob * 1<br />
OXALIDACEAE Oxalis corniculata Creeping oxalis * 3<br />
POACEAE Pennisetum cl<strong>and</strong>estinum Kikuyu * 3<br />
PITTOSPORACEAE Pittosporum undulatum Sweet pittosporum 1<br />
PLANTAGINACEAE Plantago lanceolata Plaintain * 2<br />
POACEAE Poa poiformis 2<br />
CHENOPODIACEAE Rhagodia c<strong>and</strong>olleana Sea berry saltbush 1<br />
PRIMULACEAE Samolus repens Creeping brookweed 3<br />
CHENOPODIACEAE Sarcocornia quinqueflora Glasswort 1<br />
POACEAE Spinifex sericeus Spinifex 3<br />
POACEAE Sporobolus virginicus S<strong>and</strong> couch 3<br />
POACEAE Sporobolus indicus Parramatta grass * 2<br />
CHENOPODIACEAE Suaeda australis 4<br />
AIZOACEAE Tetragonia tetragonioides Warrigal 3<br />
POACEAE Themeda australis Kangaroo grass 1<br />
POACEAE Zoysia macrantha Prickly couch 2<br />
Recommendations Wagonga Foreshore & Park<br />
A vigilant watch should be kept along the foreshore in front of the retaining wall so that any problematic<br />
weeds can be removed as soon as they are seen. The general appearance of the water margin would be<br />
improved if the rubbish could be cleared regularly. So that the Cyperus laevigatus beds may remain intact<br />
<strong>and</strong> therefore function efficiently, it would be desirable to discourage users of the mudflats from making<br />
tracks through the reeds. It also might be advantageous to reduce the force of stormwater <strong>and</strong> the amount of<br />
rubbish entering the inlet by the careful placement of barriers.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 25 of 43
7.3.4 Narooma Sports <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre<br />
Significant trees in the area behind the Sports & Leisure centre were grouped according to their location, as<br />
shown on the following map.<br />
D. Behind the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre – Eucalyptus botryoides (Swamp mahogany), Eucalyptus<br />
tereticornis (Forest red gum)<br />
E. On the eastern side of the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre building - Cupressus macrocarpa ‘Aurea’ (Golden<br />
cypress), Banksia integrifolia (Coast banksia), Hakea sericea (Prickly hakea), Metrosideros excelsa (NZ<br />
Christmas tree), Acacia longifolia (Golden wattle), Acacia mearnsii (Black wattle)<br />
Recommendations Narooma Sports <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre<br />
Depending on the extent of the upgrade plans for the Swimming Pool <strong>and</strong> Sport & Leisure Centre, it would<br />
be worth drawing up a new ‘tree plan’, perhaps incorporating some of the apparent original Eucalyptus trees<br />
in D.<br />
The trees in E. on the eastern side of the Sport building were obviously planted when the pathway up the hill<br />
was rebuilt. If any of these had to go, they could easily be replaced. The huge Golden cypress near the top<br />
of the hill is not attractive at all, having suffered greatly from the effects of wind <strong>and</strong> old age.<br />
Key to Vegetation Survey<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 26 of 43
7.4 Fire Management<br />
Council’s Fire Mitigation Officer has provided the following advice on the fire risk associated with Bill Smyth<br />
Reserve.<br />
The vegetation is defined as Coastal Lowl<strong>and</strong>s Spotted Gum-Burrawang Cycad Dry Scrub Forest. This<br />
vegetation is identified as medium tall forest bushfire category 1, however the l<strong>and</strong> is not currently mapped<br />
as fire prone. The vegetation is approx. 3.5ha in size. Any revegetation works surrounding the oval would<br />
not significantly increase the fire risk.<br />
Barker Parade is a through road offering adequate defendable space for fire vehicles, also the road verge<br />
slashing which is required for site clearances increases the protection to the dwellings on the upper side of<br />
Barker Parade.<br />
A potential fire path is from the north west, however this is unlikely as the vegetation at Bill Smyth Reserve is<br />
isolated with no real linkages to other bush l<strong>and</strong>. The dwellings on the upper side of Barker Parade have at<br />
least 25m <strong>and</strong> often 35m of Asset Protection Zone.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 27 of 43
8. Leases <strong>and</strong> Licences<br />
8.2.1 Existing Leases <strong>and</strong> Licences<br />
The following leases <strong>and</strong> licences were current as at the date of adoption of this Plan of Management<br />
(excluding short term licences):<br />
Table B: Existing Leases <strong>and</strong> Licences<br />
PIN No Lot & DP Reserve Name or Use Lease or Licence<br />
Description / Purpose<br />
15762 Lot 916<br />
DP 823230<br />
26392 Lot 1, Sec 17<br />
DP 758764<br />
East’s Narooma Shores<br />
Holiday Park<br />
26391 Lot 70<strong>11</strong> Narooma Swimming<br />
DP 1055108 Pool<br />
20787 Wagonga Inlet<br />
Foreshore<br />
20787<br />
Nata Oval<br />
17425 Lot 476<br />
DP 752155<br />
24870 Lot 912<br />
DP 7292<strong>06</strong><br />
18388 Lot 7026<br />
DP 1020248<br />
24871 Lot 9<strong>11</strong><br />
DP 7292<strong>06</strong><br />
Lease for a Caravan Park<br />
<strong>and</strong> Camping Ground<br />
Status of Lease or licence Address<br />
Expires on 5 November<br />
2012<br />
41 Princes Highway,<br />
Narooma<br />
Narooma Leisure Centre n/a n/a Bluewater Drive,<br />
Narooma<br />
Wagonga Inlet<br />
Foreshore<br />
Contract Agreement to<br />
manage the swimming<br />
pool<br />
Expires on 30 June 2009<br />
with a 2 year option.<br />
Bluewater Drive,<br />
Narooma<br />
n/a n/a Bluewater Drive,<br />
Narooma<br />
Monthly Markets Temporary licence Princes Highway,<br />
Narooma<br />
Annual Christmas<br />
Carnival<br />
Temporary licence Princes Highway,<br />
Narooma<br />
n/a n/a Princes Highway,<br />
Narooma<br />
Bill Smyth Oval n/a n/a 86 Princes Highway,<br />
Narooma<br />
Bill Smyth Reserve<br />
Bushl<strong>and</strong><br />
Narooma Sporting &<br />
Services Club – Bowling<br />
Club Carpark<br />
n/a n/a Barker Parade,<br />
Narooma<br />
Licence for Carpark Expires on 30 April 2012 Princes Highway,<br />
Narooma<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 28 of 43
8.2.2 Requirements for Future Leases <strong>and</strong> Licences<br />
Leases or licences of Crown reserves may only be entered into by trustees of Crown reserves who have been<br />
appointed under the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act. Consent must be obtained from the Minister (Department of L<strong>and</strong>s)<br />
before the lease or licence is executed (with the exception of licences for a period of less than 12 months).<br />
The following issues must be considered when Council, as Trust Manager, is granting a lease or licence on<br />
Crown Reserves:<br />
1. Broadly speaking, leases are executed where exclusive control of the whole or part of a reserve is<br />
proposed. A licence is executed where intermittent occupation or control of the whole or part of a<br />
reserve is proposed (eg Monthly markets on Nata Oval).<br />
2. A lease may only be entered into by the Trust where it can be demonstrated that any Native Title<br />
interest in the l<strong>and</strong> has been extinguished.<br />
3. The term of any lease/licence should be as short as practicable, appropriate to all circumstances <strong>and</strong><br />
commensurate with changing community needs. Generally terms in excess of 20 years are not<br />
favoured.<br />
4. Generally options for renewal or holding over clauses are not favoured. Consideration can be given<br />
to the granting of a new lease/licence on expiry of the old lease/licence. Any "holding over" shall not<br />
exceed 12 months.<br />
5. The Minister may not consent to the granting of a lease for a term exceeding 5 years (or a lease for a<br />
term that, by the exercise of an option, could exceed 5 years) unless at least <strong>14</strong> days have elapsed since<br />
notice of intention to give consent has been published in a newspaper circulating in the locality in<br />
which the l<strong>and</strong> is situated or in a newspaper circulating generally in the State.<br />
6. Clauses conferring a right to compensation for improvements are not acceptable, in appropriate cases<br />
the lessee should be required to clear <strong>and</strong>/or restore the l<strong>and</strong> to the satisfaction of the Trust <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Minister. The lease should clearly reflect the intentions in respect of the improvements on expiry of the<br />
lease (ie lease area to be cleared <strong>and</strong> restored or improvements to remain <strong>and</strong> become the property of<br />
the trust).<br />
7. Where the conditions require the lessee to undertake development works, the agreement should specify<br />
that no work is to be undertaken until plans have been approved by the Trust <strong>and</strong> the Minister <strong>and</strong> any<br />
necessary development or building consents are obtained from the local Council.<br />
8. Rental should reflect a commercial approach of market rent having regard to purpose of the<br />
lease/licence, site value <strong>and</strong> ownership of existing improvements. Agreements for other than a short<br />
term should provide for regular periodic redetermination of rental (say every three to five years) as well<br />
as being linked to increases in the Consumer Price Index for intervening annual reviews. Where the<br />
parties cannot agree on the redetermination of the rent, clauses should provide for reference to an<br />
independent arbitrator (not the Department). Where a nominal rental is imposed because the lessee is<br />
a charitable or non-profit organisation, such rental should generally not be less than the statutory<br />
minimum rental ($350-00 as at 1 July 2004 <strong>and</strong> linked to CPI) prescribed for tenures under the Crown<br />
L<strong>and</strong>s Act, 1989.<br />
9. A diagram specifying the area involved must be annexed to <strong>and</strong> form part of the lease agreement.<br />
10. In the case of sub-leases, reference should be made to the head lease in the preamble <strong>and</strong> the term of<br />
any sub-lease should not extend beyond the date of expiry of the head lease.<br />
<strong>11</strong>. If the reserve has a Real Property title, then leases for more than three years must be registered at the<br />
L<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> Property Information Office (formerly L<strong>and</strong> Titles Office).<br />
12. Where applicable, the agreement should include clauses providing for use/access by the general public.<br />
13. A clause requiring the lessee to bear the lessor’s reasonable expenses involved with the lease (eg Trust’s<br />
solicitors, advertising, stamp duty etc) should be considered for inclusion in the lease agreement.<br />
<strong>14</strong>. The proceeds from a lease or licence granted by a reserve trust shall be applied in accordance with<br />
directions (if any) given by the Minister under Section 1<strong>06</strong> of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989. In the<br />
absence of any direction, the proceeds shall be applied for the general purposes of the reserve trust <strong>and</strong><br />
may be invested or applied by the trust accordingly.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 29 of 43
The following describes the general principles which a reserve trust manager must take into consideration<br />
when negotiating commercial lease or licence proposals on Crown reserves:<br />
• Leases or licences for commercial purposes can only be granted where the commercial activity is<br />
consistent with the purpose for which the reserve was dedicated or reserved <strong>and</strong> should not overpower<br />
or dominate the reserve.<br />
• Commercial leases/licences on Crown reserves should be established by a fair, open, impartial <strong>and</strong><br />
transparent process <strong>and</strong> provide optimum environmental, social <strong>and</strong> economic returns from such use of<br />
the reserve for the people of NSW.<br />
• Appointed Trust Managers must be able to demonstrate that they have met their responsibility to the<br />
people of NSW of ensuring that the best possible result will be realised from the lease arrangement.<br />
• Other than where special circumstances exist, opportunities to lease/licence public reserves should be<br />
decided by a competitive process. The Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) advises<br />
public sector organisations against entering into negotiations which bypass a competitive process on the<br />
basis that direct negotiations can lack openness, fairness <strong>and</strong> accountability, <strong>and</strong> may result in outcomes<br />
which deliver less than the best outcome for the community. Accordingly, the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s has a<br />
responsibility when considering the granting of consent under Sections 102 & 103 of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s<br />
Act 1989 to ensure that the best possible outcome has being obtained by the reserve trust.<br />
• Where public tendering is not to be used to identify a suitable lessee, then there needs to be a clear<br />
account of how alternative processes serve the public good. This account would need to demonstrate<br />
openness, fairness <strong>and</strong> accountability.<br />
• NSW Treasury directions which require that any commercial use of State owned public l<strong>and</strong>s realise the<br />
best possible financial return.<br />
ICAC guidelines suggest that a public competition process would avoid the following problems:<br />
• Any public perception that the trust is not getting the best possible deal for the public<br />
• Opportunity for corruption in direct dealings with current lessee<br />
• Reduced opportunity to discover new or innovative ideas<br />
• Possible lack of transparency <strong>and</strong> accountability in the process<br />
• Lack of opportunity to test value for money<br />
In accordance with these guidelines the overall objectives of a Crown reserve trust when negotiating<br />
commercial lease/licence arrangements should be to:<br />
• Obtain the best value for money through a fair <strong>and</strong> impartial process<br />
• Minimise the level of risk for the trust<br />
• Minimise the opportunity for corrupt conduct<br />
• Obtain the best environmental, social <strong>and</strong> economic outcome for the public<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 30 of 43
8.2.3 Temporary Licences<br />
Temporary licences allow the trust to permit short-term <strong>and</strong> generally low impact activities on the reserve<br />
without the Minister’s consent. Under section 108 of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989 (the Act), a reserve trust can<br />
grant temporary licences for purposes which may not always fall strictly within the permitted purposes for<br />
that reserve.<br />
However, the use of the reserve through these temporary licences should not diminish the availability <strong>and</strong> use<br />
of the reserve for the purpose for which it was set aside. The purposes for which a temporary licence may be<br />
issued, in addition to those temporary licences whose purposes are consistent with the Reserves’ Crown<br />
Reserve Purpose of Public Recreation <strong>and</strong> Resting Place, are as follows (S 32 Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Regulation):<br />
grazing<br />
advertising<br />
camping using a tent, caravan or otherwise<br />
catering<br />
entertainment<br />
equestrian events<br />
exhibitions<br />
filming (this term is defined in detail in the Local Government Act 1993)<br />
functions<br />
hiring of equipment<br />
holiday accommodation<br />
markets<br />
meetings<br />
mooring of boats to wharves or structures<br />
sales<br />
shows<br />
sporting <strong>and</strong> organised recreational activities<br />
stabling of horses<br />
8.2.4 Future Activities<br />
This Plan of Management supports the issuing of new leases, licenses or temporary licenses for the following<br />
activities on the Crown L<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management:<br />
Café/Restaurant/s<br />
Short Term Camping (in accordance with the requirements of the Local Government (Caravan Parks,<br />
Camping Grounds & Moveable Dwellings) Regulation 2005<br />
Carnivals<br />
Circuses<br />
Cultural activities <strong>and</strong> uses ancillary to cultural activities<br />
Festivals<br />
Great Southern Blues & Rockabilly Festival<br />
Markets<br />
Outdoor eating<br />
Sporting activities <strong>and</strong> uses ancillary to sporting activities<br />
Any other future activity that is consistent with the requirements of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989 <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Regulation 2000. In particular, any future lease or licence must be for a purpose that is<br />
consistent with the Crown Reserve Purpose of Public Recreation <strong>and</strong> Resting Place.<br />
This Plan of Management supports re-leasing or directly managing the following activities:<br />
Caravan Park<br />
Narooma Swimming Pool <strong>and</strong> associated infrastructure (contract management)<br />
Narooma Leisure Centre<br />
Any other future activity that is consistent with the requirements of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989 <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Regulation 2000.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 31 of 43
9. Values of the Reserve<br />
Ascertaining the community values of l<strong>and</strong> means identifying what the community finds important <strong>and</strong> special<br />
about it. These values also identify what people most enjoy or appreciate about a place.<br />
L<strong>and</strong> management issues change over time, depending on the needs of the community; <strong>and</strong> communities<br />
change – what may be important in the present may be more or less important in the future. Values,<br />
however tend to transcend the everyday issues of l<strong>and</strong> management <strong>and</strong> set a more strategic vision for the<br />
management of the l<strong>and</strong>. Values coexist, augment <strong>and</strong> support each other. Where singular issues may be<br />
really important in the short term, the overriding values attached to the l<strong>and</strong> will tend to be relevant for a<br />
longer period.<br />
How can values be implemented in l<strong>and</strong> management? Once values <strong>and</strong> their level of significance are<br />
determined, l<strong>and</strong> maintenance <strong>and</strong> development practices that recognise, manage <strong>and</strong> conserve these values<br />
may then be implemented. Refer to the Operational Plan <strong>and</strong> L<strong>and</strong>scape Masterplans for more information<br />
on how the values are reflected in strategies for l<strong>and</strong> management.<br />
At the public meeting held on 5 November, 2005 at the Narooma Sports & Services Club those in attendance<br />
identified what they appreciate <strong>and</strong> value about the reserves included in this Plan of Management. The<br />
Reference Group also provided input. The following table includes these values as they relate to State<br />
Government legislation <strong>and</strong> Council policy:<br />
Value & description<br />
Access<br />
<br />
Accommodation<br />
<br />
Cultural Opportunities<br />
<br />
Community Cohesion<br />
<br />
Natural Environment<br />
<br />
Recreational Opportunities<br />
<br />
Scenic Qualities<br />
<br />
Where:<br />
Neighbourhood – Local: the street <strong>and</strong> surrounding streets<br />
Suburb: within the suburb area (ie. within Moruya<br />
District: the suburb area <strong>and</strong> adjacent suburbs (eg. Moruya Heads, Broulee <strong>and</strong> Tuross Head)<br />
<strong>Shire</strong>: within the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Local Government Area<br />
Regional: within the far south coast of NSW<br />
State: within the state of NSW<br />
These values have assisted with the identification of the appropriate Community L<strong>and</strong> categories for the l<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
provide a guide for identifying the objectives <strong>and</strong> actions in the Operational Plan.:<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 32 of 43<br />
Neighbourhood -<br />
Local<br />
Suburb<br />
District<br />
<strong>Shire</strong><br />
Regional<br />
State
10. Operational Plan<br />
The Operational Plan identifies the principal l<strong>and</strong> management issues. A set of management strategies <strong>and</strong><br />
actions accompany each issue providing an ongoing framework for the management of the reserve. These<br />
management issues relate to the values of the reserve <strong>and</strong> are reflected in the L<strong>and</strong>scape Masterplan. Each<br />
action is given a implementation category.<br />
The following terminology is used in the Operational Plan.<br />
Management Issue The issue that requires a detailed approach to future management<br />
Strategy The broad management strategies required to address management issue of<br />
concern<br />
Action Specific actions that address the strategies<br />
Implementation Priority Category 1: These actions are those that can be implemented immediately or<br />
very soon after the adoption of the Plan. They are policy or procedural matters<br />
<strong>and</strong> require minimal or no funding.<br />
Category 2: These actions are those that require funding <strong>and</strong> are principally<br />
concerned with improving public safety, maintenance <strong>and</strong> improvement matters<br />
<strong>and</strong> protecting or conserving the values of the community l<strong>and</strong>. The timing of<br />
their implementation would be dependent upon the availability of funds from<br />
Council.<br />
Category 3: These actions are capital improvement items or items requiring a<br />
significant injection of funds. The timing of their implementation would be<br />
dependent upon the availability of funds from Council <strong>and</strong> other sources.<br />
Council has adopted many policies <strong>and</strong> procedures that govern the management <strong>and</strong> maintenance of<br />
Community L<strong>and</strong>. The issues raised in this section need to be considered in parallel with these other policies<br />
<strong>and</strong> procedures.<br />
The Operational Plan provides a summary of the proposed developments <strong>and</strong> improvements along with an<br />
implementation priority for their completion. Many of these items are illustrated in the L<strong>and</strong>scape<br />
Masterplans. Note: The scheme does not propose one action to be more important than the next, but<br />
presents categories of timing for implementation.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 33 of 43
Management Issue Strategy Action Implementation<br />
Category<br />
9.1 Access – Generally To provide for public access. 1. Provide access to the reserves consistent with Occupational Health <strong>and</strong><br />
Safety requirements.<br />
1<br />
2. Restrict public access to buildings, workshops, buildings, storage areas,<br />
operational facilities <strong>and</strong> any other facility as deemed required on the<br />
reserves. There may be a fee associated with the use of such facilities.<br />
1<br />
3. Allow for the levying of reasonable entry fees <strong>and</strong> charges to the<br />
reserves.<br />
1<br />
9.2 Access – Pedestrian To provide linkages with 1. Develop cycleways <strong>and</strong> footpaths consistent with the intent of the<br />
2/3<br />
other pedestrian pathways.<br />
Concept L<strong>and</strong>scape Masterplan<br />
9.3 Access – Vehicular To facilitate vehicular access 1. Develop vehicular access <strong>and</strong> parking areas consistent with the intent of 2/3<br />
<strong>and</strong> parking on the reserves.<br />
the Concept L<strong>and</strong>scape Masterplan.<br />
9.4 Fire Management Manage the risk of fire 1. Council’s Bush Fire Mitigation Officer to monitor the vegetation in the<br />
1<br />
accordance with the Rural<br />
Fires Act 1997.<br />
reserves <strong>and</strong> take action as required<br />
9.5 Leases, Licences, Provide for the use <strong>and</strong> 1. Fees charged in accordance with Council’s adopted Fees & Charges. 1<br />
Contract<br />
management of the reserves<br />
Management & in accordance with the 2. Leases, licences, contracts <strong>and</strong> other estates managed in accordance<br />
1<br />
Casual Hiring Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act <strong>and</strong><br />
with Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Policy. Refer to Section 8. Exception may apply to<br />
consistent with Section 8<br />
Leases <strong>and</strong> Licences (refer to<br />
page 28) of this Plan of<br />
management in order to<br />
raise funds for the ongoing<br />
management <strong>and</strong><br />
maintenance of reserves<br />
included in the Euroobodalla<br />
(South) Reserve Trust.<br />
non-profit groups.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Preliminary Draft Plan of Management – July 20<strong>06</strong> 34 of 43
Management Issue Strategy Action Implementation<br />
Category<br />
9.6 Recreational & Encourage, promote <strong>and</strong> 1. Recreation activities developed in accordance with the strategies of<br />
1<br />
Cultural Activities facilitate recreational<br />
activities on the reserve.<br />
Council’s Sports Liaison Committee.<br />
Develop <strong>and</strong> maintain 2. Provide for future needs consistent with the intent of the Concept<br />
2/3<br />
facilities on the reserves.<br />
L<strong>and</strong>scape Masterplan <strong>and</strong> the strategies of Council’s Sports Liaison<br />
Committee.<br />
Encourage, promote <strong>and</strong> 3. Allow for the casual hire <strong>and</strong> use of the reserves. Refer to Events policy & 1<br />
facilitate cultural, social,<br />
passive recreational <strong>and</strong><br />
casual hirers.<br />
educational activities on the 4. Temporary camping accommodated as per the requirements of the<br />
1<br />
reserves.<br />
Local Government (Caravan Parks, Camping Grounds & Moveable<br />
Dwellings) Regulation 2005.<br />
Allow for events on the 5. All events held on the reserve must be consistent with Council’s adopted 1<br />
reserves that are consistent<br />
with Council’s Events Policy.<br />
Events Policy.<br />
9.7 Signage To ensure signage in the 1. Prepare a Signage Style Guide <strong>and</strong> Plan that provides a guide for<br />
1<br />
reserves is uniform in its<br />
installing signs in appropriate locations that are consistent in the use of<br />
style <strong>and</strong> form.<br />
materials, colour, fonts etc.<br />
2. Signs installed as per the Signage Style Guide <strong>and</strong> Plan. 2<br />
9.8 Vegetation<br />
Management<br />
Restore <strong>and</strong> rehabilitate<br />
natural areas.<br />
Remove all weed species<br />
that are either declared<br />
Noxious Weeds (Noxious<br />
Weeds Act 1993) or are<br />
identified as Environmental<br />
Weeds of the NSW South<br />
Coast.<br />
Reduce the spread of plants<br />
identified as environmental<br />
weeds from private gardens<br />
1. Seek funds to implement restoration <strong>and</strong> rehabilitation works. 1<br />
2. Encourage the formation <strong>and</strong> involvement of a local L<strong>and</strong>care Group to<br />
participate in environmental projects.<br />
2<br />
3. Council’s Noxious Weeds Officer notified of noxious weeds <strong>and</strong> provides<br />
for their removal.<br />
1<br />
4. Seek funds <strong>and</strong> remove environmental weeds. 2<br />
5. Raise local community awareness of environmental weeds. This may be<br />
in the form of letterbox drops, media releases, public meeting on site,<br />
workshops etc.<br />
into the reserve. 6. Give nearby residents assistance with planting appropriate species on<br />
their properties.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Preliminary Draft Plan of Management – July 20<strong>06</strong> 35 of43<br />
1<br />
1
<strong>11</strong>. L<strong>and</strong>scape Masterplans<br />
The Concept L<strong>and</strong>scape Masterplans illustrate the proposed developments, uses <strong>and</strong> management actions<br />
for the reserves. They have been developed to reflect the Council’s direction <strong>and</strong> community expectations<br />
for the l<strong>and</strong> while complying with <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council <strong>and</strong> State Government policies <strong>and</strong> guidelines.<br />
While L<strong>and</strong>scape Masterplans guide the future improvements <strong>and</strong> developments in the reserves, further<br />
detailed construction documentation to finalise the designs will be required. While the overall concept <strong>and</strong><br />
intent will remain, the plan may be amended to reflect new information, funding or construction issues. As<br />
long as the changes are consistent with the overall intent of the Plan of Management, this will not require the<br />
re-exhibition of this Plan of Management.<br />
This Plan of Management includes the following plans:<br />
1. Bill Smyth Oval – L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan<br />
2. Nata Oval <strong>and</strong> adjacent Reserves – L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan<br />
3. Ken Rose Park – Site Analysis Plan to guide future detailed design<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Preliminary Draft Plan of Management – July 20<strong>06</strong> 36 of 43
12. Stakeholders & Interest Groups<br />
Easts Narooma Shores Holiday Park<br />
Euroswims Pty Ltd<br />
Instep Management Group<br />
Narooma Aquafit<br />
Narooma Australian Rules – Juniors & Seniors<br />
Narooma Sporting <strong>and</strong> Services Club<br />
Narooma Croquet Club<br />
Narooma High School<br />
Narooma Hydrotherapy<br />
Narooma Junior Rugby League<br />
Narooma Netball<br />
Narooma Primary School<br />
Narooma Senior Rugby League<br />
Narooma Swimming Club<br />
Narooma Tennis Club Inc<br />
Narooma Veterans Touch Football<br />
Residents<br />
Rotary Club of Narooma Inc<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 40 of 43
13. Attachment A – Public Meeting Comments<br />
The following comments were noted from the Public Meeting held on 5 December 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
Nata Oval<br />
Alternatives for the leisure centre <strong>and</strong> Nata Oval<br />
Nata oval used by animal welfare league – needs to be<br />
upgraded<br />
Reclaiming more l<strong>and</strong> from dredging – make a bigger<br />
park<br />
Nata Oval – hate to see capital expenditure on structures<br />
– a big open space in the centre of town can be used for<br />
anything, families get together, just mow it!<br />
Nata – good for all purposes.<br />
Leisure Centre<br />
Leisure centre under utilised<br />
Sprung floor – flooding issues, roof problems, should<br />
we bulldoze?<br />
Provide for the community by rotary, most work done<br />
by volunteers – thanks Rotary!<br />
Leisure Centre – tends not to be used, has a concrete<br />
floor – oh&s, insurance, what about a minimal cost<br />
study into a timber sprung floor – basketball, soccer,<br />
netball, volleyball – was used in the 80s.<br />
Revisit Phil Rose’s plans.<br />
Bill Smyth<br />
Bill Smyth – amenities disgrace<br />
Bill Smyth approx. $70,000 is allocated for the amenities<br />
– 2004/05<br />
Bill Smyth – oval is used by <strong>14</strong>0 juniors, 45 seniors, vet<br />
touch, aussie rules – being flogged to death 9 months of<br />
the year. Goal posts are in the wrong spot. Car parking,<br />
public toilets – issues.<br />
Bill Smyth – amenities - $ are not enough won’t go far<br />
enough<br />
Access to netball courts – what about the surrounds,<br />
walked away hasn’t been cleaned up, needs turfed,<br />
clean up the gravel, wet weather no hope getting<br />
around, trees are too close, money runs out <strong>and</strong> that’s it,<br />
surrounds are terrible,<br />
Maintenance on the oval is shocking, user bodies not<br />
looked after, no top dressing <strong>and</strong> fertiliser.<br />
Practice field is 10m short of a full size field. 6-8 teams<br />
on the field – high use. Would like a full size rugby<br />
league field on the practice field. Goal posts difficult to<br />
get in.<br />
Amenities are terrible. A disgrace.<br />
Public toilets near ambulance station are shocking,<br />
things needs to be done.<br />
Netball done on the spur of the moment.<br />
Practice field waste of space, one team training on it –<br />
can’t play a game on it.<br />
Just want the facilities looked after.<br />
Want to see something done.<br />
Narooma Sports & Services Club – links to Bill Smyth –<br />
eg. croquet <strong>and</strong> car park. Represent 2,500 residents +<br />
1,500visitors to the club. Partnership opportunities for<br />
the future. Get involved with business, may get $$ for<br />
public facilities. Work closely<br />
Bill Smyth Oval fenced – new clubs room, netball court<br />
finished, 2 nd field.<br />
Acknowledge the past input into the facilities – result in<br />
what we’ve got today.<br />
Croquet<br />
Croquet – funding from Sport & Rec – they funded ½.<br />
Looking for another court, numbers have gone up by<br />
100%, still growing. Getting involved in running<br />
competitions, Aust Croquet Club, bursting at the seams.<br />
Tennis<br />
Need a windbreak for the tennis courts. Tennis occupied<br />
regularly for 12mths of the year. Hope to exp<strong>and</strong> in the<br />
future.<br />
The Swimming Pool<br />
Does the upgrade involve heating?<br />
Pool looks bad – the building at the front – the entry<br />
Bins at entry look bad<br />
Will it be a 50m pool? It is not an Olympic pool because<br />
it only has 6 lanes, not 8.<br />
The pool is too cold, heating is a problem.<br />
50m pool brings people to town <strong>and</strong> the whole<br />
community benefits<br />
Swimming Club has large scale meets – other clubs<br />
travel to Narooma – good for the local accommodation<br />
Closest 50m pool would be C<strong>and</strong>elo <strong>and</strong> Bega – these<br />
are both outdoor pools<br />
The pool currently costs $190,000 pa to run<br />
The current cost is unaffordable<br />
Will the pool close during upgrades – yes there will be<br />
disruption. Work should be done during summer when<br />
there are other water bodies to use<br />
Pool used to close 2 weeks pa for maintenance – why<br />
not any more?<br />
There are medical reasons to swim, patients are reluctant<br />
to use the pool because of the temperature of <strong>and</strong> access<br />
to the pool. Will access be addressed? Yes.<br />
Water quality should be high priority – <strong>and</strong> the whole<br />
complex!<br />
Don’t do a 25m!!<br />
Pool will stay in its current location.<br />
Ageing population to consider – future needs.<br />
The pool is nearly 40 years old.<br />
The pool is the greatest thing Narooma has – even<br />
though the temp goes up <strong>and</strong> down that’s ok, should be<br />
thankful of what you’ve got, recognise the problems<br />
<strong>and</strong> errors of the past.<br />
Will the new pool be solar heated?<br />
The $$ seems to be there for other things eg. libraries<br />
Pools are a community service – not a money making<br />
facility – Council has acknowledged this<br />
The number of swimmers won’t be accommodated in a<br />
6 x 25 pool (too crowded)<br />
There used to be a salt water pool – it was very popular<br />
– just needs a little bit of maintenance <strong>and</strong> dredging –<br />
this can be considered in the Plan of Management<br />
What is the depth of a 25m pool?<br />
What about a gym for the pool – bring revenue,<br />
membership, café, outdoor eating – other revenue<br />
streams<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 41 of 43
<strong>14</strong>. Attachment B – Council’s Direction for the redevelopment of the Narooma Swimming Pool<br />
At the <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee Meeting on 13 December 2005, Council resolved the following in regard<br />
to the future redevelopment of the Narooma Swimming Pool.<br />
MINUTE WM05/168<br />
W05/<strong>14</strong>5 SWIMMING POOL AND LEISURE CENTRE WORKSHOP 04.8636<br />
WM05/168 MOTION Councillor Mumme/Corbin<br />
THAT under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee resolved the<br />
following:<br />
THAT:<br />
1. Council adopt the following preferred options for the swimming pools <strong>and</strong> Narooma Leisure Centre:<br />
(a) Batemans Bay Pool remain at Mackay Park <strong>and</strong> be upgraded to an indoor 25m x 8 lane pool <strong>and</strong> indoor<br />
program pool.<br />
(b) Moruya Pool to have no major upgrades.<br />
(c) Narooma Pool be converted to a 25m x 6 lane pool <strong>and</strong> program pool within the existing structure.<br />
(d) An indoor sports hall be incorporated with the Narooma Pool to create an integrated indoor sports <strong>and</strong><br />
aquatic centre.<br />
2. Public consultation be undertaken on the preferred options.<br />
3. $18,000 be allocated from within the existing 2005/<strong>06</strong> pool budget to cover structural repairs to the<br />
support of the precast wall panels at Narooma Swimming Pool.<br />
4. A further allocation of $180,000 for structural repairs for Narooma Swimming Pool be considered in the<br />
20<strong>06</strong>/07 Management Plan.<br />
5. Council receive a financial strategy taking up options outlined in the <strong>Works</strong>hop for consideration with<br />
regard to the 20<strong>06</strong>/10 Management Plan <strong>and</strong> Revised Section 94 Plan.<br />
(The Motion on being put was declared CARRIED.)<br />
Councillor McGillivray asked that it be noted that he thinks that it is short sighted to remove all 50 metre<br />
pools from our <strong>Shire</strong>.<br />
The following illustrations demonstrate the resolutions in 1 above.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 42 of 43
15. Attachment C – Historical Review of the Reserves<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Draft Plan of Management – presented to November 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> 43 of 43
Narooma’s Crown Reserves on the Flat<br />
An Historical Review<br />
Narooma Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre<br />
Narooma Swimming Pool<br />
Nata Oval<br />
Wagonga Inlet Foreshore Reserve<br />
Bill Smyth Reserve<br />
Narooma Bowling Club (part)<br />
Ken Rose Park<br />
7 August 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Laurelle Pacey, Narooma
Table of Contents<br />
Back in 1885 – the first town survey........................................................................................................ 3<br />
The role of the Narooma Urban Committee............................................................................................. 5<br />
1. Reserve 80515 .................................................................................................................................. 7<br />
Narooma Common – Camping Reserve – Bill Smyth Reserve............................................................ 7<br />
Narooma Bowling Club...................................................................................................................... 15<br />
The Ambulance Station ...................................................................................................................... 17<br />
2. Reserve 63051 ................................................................................................................................ 19<br />
Narooma Sport & Leisure Centre site ................................................................................................ 19<br />
Swimming baths to covered pool on reclaimed l<strong>and</strong>.......................................................................... 23<br />
Narooma creates in-ground pool on reclaimed l<strong>and</strong>........................................................................... 25<br />
Covering the pool ............................................................................................................................... 27<br />
NATA Oval ........................................................................................................................................ 31<br />
Wagonga Inlet Foreshore Reserve & Ken Rose Park......................................................................... 34<br />
Captions Summary ................................................................................................................................. 37<br />
Note: Laurelle Pacey retains copyright of this document but this permits <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council to use this material in<br />
whole or in part for the purpose intended, namely to be included in the Plan of Management for these reserves.<br />
Page 2 of 38
Introduction<br />
This is a brief summary of the changing uses of the Crown Reserves on the flat <strong>and</strong> the enormous<br />
contributions made by the Narooma community in establishing <strong>and</strong> usually maintaining the grounds <strong>and</strong><br />
the facilities enjoyed by both locals <strong>and</strong> tourists over the years. It is a combination of anecdotal <strong>and</strong><br />
limited primary source material, as well as limited time.<br />
The concentration is on where use has changed over the years. Some stories, like that of Narooma<br />
Football Club <strong>and</strong> the ever-moving tennis courts, are beyond the scope of this study.<br />
The Crown Reserves included in this summary are as follows:<br />
• Reserve 63051, occupied by:<br />
o Narooma Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre<br />
o Narooma Swimming Pool<br />
o NATA Oval<br />
o Wagonga Inlet Foreshore Reserve<br />
• Reserve 80515, occupied by Bill Smyth Reserve <strong>and</strong> part of the Bowling Club<br />
BACK IN 1885 – THE FIRST TOWN SURVEY<br />
The NSW Government Survey of the Village of Noorooma 1885 shows that little of what is now called<br />
Crown Reserve 63051 (that now includes Narooma Swimming Pool, NATA Oval <strong>and</strong> the foreshore<br />
reserve) existed as dry l<strong>and</strong> at that time. 1 It was mostly under water at high tide, with a shallow channel<br />
running along the then shore.<br />
The part of Reserve 63051 that was dry l<strong>and</strong> in 1885 plus what is now Reserve 80515 were part of a<br />
much larger <strong>14</strong>0 acre Reserve for the village’s “water supply <strong>and</strong> depasturage”. That Reserve was<br />
bounded by Garvan Street, the Inlet (on the entrance side), approximately the road from Wagonga (now<br />
the Old Highway), through to the Inlet to the west <strong>and</strong> an area set aside for a general cemetery further<br />
along the flat (towards the bridge end of the s<strong>and</strong>y flat). 2<br />
The 1885 survey also shows marked graves on the flat (as distinct from the area on the flat designated<br />
for a cemetery along further towards the bridge). They also appear on subsequent maps of the area,<br />
marked R 24353 (or R 24363?) which some locals say were still there in living memory inside the<br />
current caravan park fence, roughly opposite what is now Narooma Pharmacy <strong>and</strong> Katungul. They are<br />
now within R 63051.<br />
Although the Reserve where the golf course is located is quite separate from the Reserves on S<strong>and</strong>y Flat<br />
which are the subject of this Management Plan, their history is related.<br />
The 1885 Survey shows 56 acres running along the coast for a Reserve for Public Recreation, dedicated<br />
in October 1893. In the early part of the twentieth century, Narooma’s sportsground was where the golf<br />
course is today between Pilot Street <strong>and</strong> Ballingalla Streets <strong>and</strong> the sea. Like all Crown Reserves, its<br />
management was in the h<strong>and</strong>s of three Trustees.<br />
The late Arnim Willcocks remembered a cycle racing track there as well as a horse track which was also<br />
used for running races. 3 The late Bertie Martin said that was also where they played football <strong>and</strong> cricket. 4<br />
Ron Constable, whose father was captain of the cricket team that played there, said the cricket pitch was<br />
1<br />
Charles Potter (licensed surveyor), Plan showing the survey of the Village of Noorooma, County of Dampier 1885,<br />
Department of L<strong>and</strong>s, Mitchell Library ZM2 8<strong>14</strong>-139 Narooma 1885.<br />
2<br />
Charles Potter (licensed surveyor), ibid.<br />
3<br />
Arnim Willcocks,<br />
4<br />
Bertie Martin, interview by Laurelle Pacey 2 July 1990.<br />
Page 3 of 38
inside the track as well as the football ground, <strong>and</strong> there was a gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> cum weather shed <strong>and</strong> change<br />
rooms. 5 Apparently as golfing took off in the 1920s, golfers shared the area with other users. 6 Doug Rose<br />
said his father would race his Douglas motor bike around the track, <strong>and</strong> when he was at school in the<br />
1940s, school sports used an area in front of the clubhouse, <strong>and</strong> the bunkers were used for long <strong>and</strong> high<br />
jumps <strong>and</strong> they played football in an area east of the current Pro’s shop. 7<br />
Narooma Football team of 1909 would have played on the Sportsground-recreation ground but the background<br />
looks more like the flat. Photo courtesy of John Annis.<br />
Narooma Golf Club was formed at a public meeting in the School of Arts Memorial Hall on 2 July 1930,<br />
with Dr Gordon Thomas the inaugural president, although golf had been played for some years before<br />
that. 8 The newly formed committee then wrote to the Recreation Ground Trustees about rental of the<br />
links <strong>and</strong> suggested improvements. Presumably they agreed with whatever they requested because the<br />
weather shed <strong>and</strong> changerooms were converted into the first clubhouse ready for the gr<strong>and</strong> opening in<br />
December 1930. 9<br />
Bertie Martin, a keen footballer, said there was an argument when the golfers wanted to take the area<br />
over exclusively for golf. 10 He said some cricketers <strong>and</strong> footballers were against it, as was John<br />
McMillan who said the golfers had no right to take over a public recreation ground. Bertie said<br />
McMillan eventually agreed provided another site was cleared for a sports ground. <strong>11</strong> That site of course<br />
5 Alan Murphy, The First 50 years of Narooma Golf Club 1930-1980, Narooma Historical Society Archives.<br />
6 Narooma Golf Club history. Unfortunately my inquiries at the Golf Club about original records to check this out resulted in<br />
the club stating they have no early records.<br />
7 Conversation with Doug Rose, 30/7/20<strong>06</strong><br />
8 Alan Murphy, ibid, p.5<br />
9 Ron Constable notes, 10/7/20<strong>06</strong><br />
10 Bertie Martin Interview by Laurelle Pacey 2 July 1990; Bertie Martin at Narooma Historical Society meeting 19 December<br />
1993.<br />
<strong>11</strong> Bertie Martin at Narooma Historical Society meeting 19 December 1993. John McMillan was also a foundation member of<br />
the Golf Club.<br />
Page 4 of 38
was on the flat where the oval is now. It would be interesting to find out more, because in April 1932 a<br />
meeting of football enthusiasts under the patronage of Dr Gordon Thomas <strong>and</strong> the presidency of J Inglis<br />
decided to form a new football club <strong>and</strong> start a new competition to include the Wallaga Lake team. 12<br />
The Golf Club’s history mentions that for the Club to use the recreation ground, it had to tender for the<br />
grass rights at the beginning of each year. 13 From 1935, the Golf Club paid the Trustees for exclusive<br />
agistment rights for the reserve where the Club charged people to graze their cattle on the reserve,<br />
effectively removing other sports from the area. <strong>14</strong><br />
At this stage, each Crown Reserve had its own trustees. It seems fair to assume, given the size of the<br />
town, there would have been some overlap in Trustees.<br />
Over subsequent years, areas of the original reserve on the flat were excised for residential or other<br />
purposes or leased until we are left with the two much smaller reserves of today.<br />
THE ROLE OF THE NAROOMA URBAN COMMITTEE<br />
The first Narooma Urban Committee was formed in December 1931, at the instigation of <strong>Eurobodalla</strong><br />
<strong>Shire</strong> Council, to manage matters within the Narooma urban boundaries, including garbage <strong>and</strong> sanitary<br />
collection, local roads, <strong>and</strong> camping. Council collected a levy with the rates to finance the Committee’s<br />
work. Dr Thomas was the first chairman – obviously a busy man! 15<br />
One of the Committee’s first requests to Council was to apply for the revocation of Trustees of all<br />
reserves etc in the Narooma urban area <strong>and</strong> to have those reserves come under the care <strong>and</strong> control of the<br />
Urban Committee. 16 They told Council Narooma was “first <strong>and</strong> last a Tourist Resort” <strong>and</strong> to hold its<br />
place among first class resorts, several improvements were necessary along the foreshore <strong>and</strong> on other<br />
reserves, but the Trustees of these reserves had no funds to do anything. The committee said it had “a<br />
definite scheme for extending the facilities of the several reserves that would boost tourism”, but without<br />
executive power over those reserves they could do nothing about it.<br />
For example, in July 1932, the committee asked the Trustees of the Sportsground (then the golf course)<br />
to “place an area outside of the golf ground fence southerly” under the care <strong>and</strong> control of the Urban<br />
Committee to create the Surf Beach camping area. 17 C T Carter, on behalf of the Narooma Recreation<br />
Reserve Trustees (now the golf course l<strong>and</strong>), agreed for an unlimited period. 18<br />
In September 1932, the Committee also asked the Trustees of the Reserve from the bridge to the tennis<br />
courts (then Reserve 6559-60?) to allow them to control it on a “purely experimental” basis. They also<br />
asked the Trustees of the tennis courts, then on the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre site, to h<strong>and</strong> over their<br />
maintenance <strong>and</strong> control. 19 From actions taken by the Committee it seems safe to assume that they<br />
agreed at least to their managing of the areas without necessarily h<strong>and</strong>ing over control. These areas were<br />
combined into one Reserve <strong>and</strong> came under the Trusteeship of Council on 6 May 1938. 20<br />
12 The Examiner, 16/4/1932.<br />
13 Alan Murphy, ibid<br />
<strong>14</strong> Alan Murphy, ibid, p. <strong>14</strong>. The Club even bought <strong>and</strong> sold its own cattle in 1938. It undertook to make improvements to the<br />
property of at least ₤50. The Club entered into its first 30 year lease with the Trustees in 1950.<br />
15 Two of the major items on the committee’s first agendas were establishing a town water supply <strong>and</strong> a power supply;<br />
16 Minutes of Narooma Urban Committee, 26 February 1932, Narooma Historical Society Collection.<br />
17 Minutes of Narooma Urban Committee, 1 July 1932, Narooma Historical Society Collection.<br />
18 Minutes of Narooma Urban Committee, 17 November 1932, Narooma Historical Society Collection.<br />
19 Minutes of Narooma Urban Committee, 27 September 1932, Narooma Historical Society Collection.<br />
20 Email from Linda Barr at Department of L<strong>and</strong>s, 13 July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Page 5 of 38
The Urban Committee under President J P Hyl<strong>and</strong> wrote to the L<strong>and</strong> Board Office in October 1940<br />
stating that it “objected to the alienation of any portion of any reserve to any person”. 21 This followed an<br />
application by F W Tober to lease part of Portion 451 on Reserve 31660 (?).<br />
The Narooma Urban Committee employed a camping ranger/caretaker ranger for the flat from the early<br />
1930s, initially just for the camping season. From late 1937 the job came with a house which is clearly<br />
seen on both the 1937/38 photo <strong>and</strong> the one from the early 1950s. The house was located on what is now<br />
the Croquet Lawn.<br />
Camping at Narooma <strong>and</strong> Dalmeny became popular from the late 1920s with some families returning at the same<br />
time to the same site year after year. Photo courtesy Narooma Historical Society.<br />
21 Minutes of the Narooma Urban Committee, 10 October 1940, Narooma Historical Society archives.<br />
Page 6 of 38
1. RESERVE 80515<br />
Narooma Common – Camping Reserve – Bill Smyth Reserve<br />
Under the 1885 survey plan for Narooma, <strong>14</strong>0 acres was reserved for the town’s water supply <strong>and</strong> cattle<br />
grazing which included this Reserve.<br />
The Narooma <strong>and</strong> Corunna Progress Committee referred to this area as ‘Narooma Common’ in 19<strong>06</strong><br />
when they voted to write to their local member to see if the Government would match the public in<br />
providing ten guineas to erect a windmill there to water stock <strong>and</strong> travelling horses. 22<br />
The Map of The Village of Noorooma 19<strong>06</strong>-1921 shows the Reserve had been greatly reduced by this<br />
stage with some areas excised for residential development. 23 This map notes it was then Reserve 54482<br />
reserved as a Temporary Common <strong>and</strong> notified as such 4 March 1921. It was bounded by Garvan Street,<br />
what is now the Princes Highway on the flat, roughly where the upper part of Forsters Bay Rd is today<br />
<strong>and</strong> through to the Princes Highway.<br />
The community gathers for a sports day on the reserve in the mid 1920s, before the sportsground relocated to the<br />
flat from the old recreation reserve where the golf course is now located. Crushes for the cattle <strong>and</strong> horses were<br />
then located around to the left of the photo. Photo courtesy Narooma Historical Society.<br />
With the growing popularity of motor vehicles, camping holidays in Narooma became really popular<br />
from the 1920s <strong>and</strong> this area became known as the camping reserve. Note there was a well on the reserve<br />
(where the Narooma Bowling Club’s No. 1 green is located) used by locals during drought as well as<br />
22 Minutes Narooma <strong>and</strong> Corunna Progress Committee, 3/10/19<strong>06</strong>, Narooma Historical Society Collection<br />
23 Plan of Village of Noorooma 19<strong>06</strong>-1921, Archives Office of NSW.<br />
Page 7 of 38
campers which had a windlass <strong>and</strong> a kerosene tin for bringing up water. 24 There was an old cricket pitch<br />
on the western side of the reserve. 25<br />
Bertie Martin said Jack McMillan was instrumental in coming up with the compromise that this area<br />
would become the new recreation grounds for all sports except golf. The way Bertie told it, it was a<br />
decision that appeased everyone. 26 He suggested it should really have been called the McMillan Reserve.<br />
Up until then, the area had been used for camping <strong>and</strong> apparently various sports day, Narooma’s<br />
equivalent of an annual show.<br />
Narooma’s football team on Narooma Oval on the flat circa 1930s. Photo courtesy John Annis <strong>and</strong> Narooma<br />
Historical Society.<br />
What Narooma Football Club records exist suggest football competitions began on the new reserve in<br />
1932. 27<br />
Ron Constable, then a keen cricketer, recalls that a concrete cricket pitch had to be built on the s<strong>and</strong>based<br />
oval on the flat after an unsuccessful attempt at a turf wicket using soil bought in from Kiama<br />
failed. 28 During the football season, the pitch would be covered in sawdust from Mitchell’s Mill. The<br />
fence around the oval was built with voluntary labour <strong>and</strong> timber donated by Mitchell’s Mill. 29 Older<br />
residents like Ron refer to the ground as Narooma Oval.<br />
24<br />
Doug Rose, conversation 30/7/<strong>06</strong>.<br />
25<br />
Doug Rose,<br />
26<br />
Jack McMillan, a Narooma mover <strong>and</strong> shaker of the time, provided the impetus for Narooma to build a reticulated water<br />
supply in 1935.<br />
27<br />
Conversation with George Barker, article from ‘The Examiner’ 16/4/1932.<br />
28<br />
Ron Constable notes 10 July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
29<br />
Ron Constable notes<br />
Page 8 of 38
It seems that the town’s sports days - with woodchopping, crosscut sawing, sleeper squaring, footrace, a<br />
boxing ring <strong>and</strong> cattle events, including steer-riding, novelty events – may have been happening on this<br />
area before the football <strong>and</strong> serious cricket moved down to the flat. They were certainly happening on<br />
the flat in the 1920s <strong>and</strong> continued on the grounds each year after the oval was created 30 In the 1930s,<br />
Gordon Simpson of Punkally Creek would donate bullocks for the Narooma rodeo – he would drive<br />
them to Narooma with Reg Brice <strong>and</strong> then drive them back home afterwards. Sometimes they were sold<br />
on the day. 31 These sports days were mainly used as fundraisers for the community, either to help pay for<br />
the construction of the town’s then multi-purpose hall – the Narooma Soldiers Memorial School of Arts -<br />
or from 1948 <strong>and</strong> in the 1950s, to raise money for the Narooma Community Aid Centre.<br />
Camping also continued in the area, but now around the perimeter of the oval. “It was like a tent city,<br />
always called that,” Ron Constable said. “There weren’t many flats or houses to rent in those days. Each<br />
year the visitors <strong>and</strong> local cricket teams would play several matches on the oval.”<br />
The Narooma Urban Committee was advised in September 1941 of the notification of the ‘Reserve for<br />
Recreation at Narooma’, presumably that applied to this area on the flat including the areas now<br />
occupied by the bowling club <strong>and</strong> the Ambulance Station.<br />
This section of a much larger aerial photo dates from 1937/38, dated from the house having been moved to the<br />
reserve for the camping ranger (see left arrow near the junction of McMillan Rd <strong>and</strong> the Princes Highway. Note<br />
tennis courts on the site where the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre is now, but no courts over on the Crown Reserve<br />
where the Bowling Club’s Number 2 green is today. The cabins were Ken Rose’s. (Photo courtesy Narooma<br />
Historical Society).<br />
Two more clay tennis courts with a gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> were built for the community on the reserve in the late<br />
1930s, presumably by the Narooma Tennis Club or the Narooma Urban Committee. The Narooma<br />
Urban Committee minutes of 20 August 1934 notes correspondence from the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s about<br />
an agreement for a permissive occupancy for Narooma Tennis Courts. This could be a different<br />
arrangement for the new courts or the existing courts. While there are various mentions of<br />
30 Ron Constable notes.<br />
31 Bertie Martin<br />
Page 9 of 38
correspondence from Narooma Tennis Club to the Urban Committee in the Committee’s 1937 minutes,<br />
it does not actually refer to the construction of two courts.<br />
In July 1938, Narooma Cricket Club <strong>and</strong> the Football Club wrote to the Urban Committee about the<br />
possibility of erecting a sports pavilion at the new sports ground, but the committee replied it did not<br />
have the funds to it at that stage. But it added it was “very sympathetic towards the scheme” <strong>and</strong> would<br />
consider it again when funds became available.<br />
Then in 1939, the Urban Committee proposed building a sports pavilion, presumably what was to<br />
become the gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> beside the tennis courts. At the instigation of the Narooma Chamber of<br />
Commerce, the committee approached the Defence department for assistance so they could make<br />
provision for it to be also used as a Drill Hall. 32 The football club used the change-rooms underneath the<br />
gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>. 33<br />
This photo, taken probably 1949/1950, shows the newly created Bowling Club house <strong>and</strong> original green with the<br />
two clay tennis courts <strong>and</strong> gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>. Note football being played on the oval. (Photo courtesy Narooma Bowling<br />
Club.<br />
Camping in Narooma had become very popular, particularly on this reserve. The Urban Committee<br />
appointed A Maver to clean lavatories <strong>and</strong> collect fees on the camping ground, take bookings <strong>and</strong> collect<br />
fees for tennis for the 1934/35 tourist season. 34 The Urban Committee also accepted Mason Johnson’s<br />
offer of collecting camping fees for the season from Surf Beach. 35 Johnson also took on the job of camp<br />
ranger for the 1935-36 season, <strong>and</strong> was then kept on as full time camp ranger with the extra<br />
responsibilities of impounding officer <strong>and</strong> poundkeeper.<br />
32 Minutes of the Narooma Urban Committee<br />
33 Ron Constable notes<br />
34 Minutes of the Narooma Urban Committee, 6 September 1934, Narooma Historical Society archives.<br />
35 Minutes of the Narooma Urban Committee, 7 December 1934, Narooma Historical Society archives.<br />
Page 10 of 38
He was given permission to occupy a tent alongside the tennis courts for the 1936/37 season. 36 By late<br />
1937, the Committee had erected a caretaker’s cottage - ‘the urban cottage’ - with front office complete<br />
with telephone. It was rented to Mr Johnson for ₤-/18/1 from 1 September that year. 37 The Committee<br />
decided the front office should only be used for Urban Committee business. 38 The cottage was where the<br />
croquet lawn is now. The back ver<strong>and</strong>ah was closed in the following year. The Urban Committee<br />
supplied Mr Johnson with a pair of gumboots “for use on the wet places on the camping area”. 39 The<br />
reserve was well known for flooding problems, with swampy areas on the edge of the Reserve,<br />
particularly where the netball courts are now.<br />
Andrew Carr stood in for Johnson during his holidays, before being appointed camp ranger <strong>and</strong> caretaker<br />
in 1941 at the ruling basic wage, less ₤-/18/9 per week for the use of the committee’s cottage. 40 . His son<br />
Bob remembers waiting out the front for months for the return home of local Prisoners of War. “The first<br />
Christmas holiday season after the end of the war was huge with about 5,000 people camped in<br />
Narooma,” Bob said. “People were camped absolutely everywhere,”. 41<br />
Camping ranger Andy Carr shows the problems campers sometimes faced on this reserve (Photo courtesy Angela<br />
Hansen .<br />
36 Minutes of the Narooma Urban Committee, 5 December 1936, Narooma Historical Society archives.<br />
37 Minutes of the Narooma Urban Committee, 24 August 1937, Narooma Historical Society archives.<br />
38 Minutes of the Narooma Urban Committee, 4 November 1937, Narooma Historical Society archives<br />
39 Minutes of the Narooma Urban Committee, 31 March 1939, Narooma Historical Society archives.<br />
40 Minutes Narooma Urban Committee (15 Dec 1931-Dec 1941),<br />
41 Interview with Bob Carr, 9 July 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
Page <strong>11</strong> of 38
The Urban Cottage for the camping ranger, that used to be located where the croquet lawn is now located. (Photo<br />
courtesy Angela Hansen).<br />
Many campers had their regular spots year after year. Many played tennis on the courts at the grounds or<br />
across where the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre is now. Bob Carr remembers the Armstrongs from<br />
Cootamundra <strong>and</strong> others from Sydney who played regularly. Many campers were also keen fishermen.<br />
Camping on the other side of the oval. (Photo courtesy Angela Hansen).<br />
Page 12 of 38
Bob thinks they lived there until the early 1950s when Athol Wheatley took over as Camping Ranger.<br />
The cottage was still there in 1964, but part of the enclosed yard shown in the 1950s aerial photo had by<br />
then been taken over for the ambulance station. 42<br />
Local dentist Paul Mood leased the cottage from the L<strong>and</strong>s Department for his surgery from 1975 for<br />
two to three years until his current premises were built. 43 Dr Jenny Wray then used the cottage as her<br />
temporary surgery while her current premises were completed in late 1980. 44 Paul thinks the cottage was<br />
demolished soon after. There was then a playground on the site for a number of years which became<br />
quite rundown <strong>and</strong> was dismantled before it became the croquet lawn.<br />
This photo believed to be from the early 1950s (before extensions to School of Arts) shows the location of the<br />
town’s four clay tennis courts – two on the site of what is now the Bowling Club’s No. 2 Green (complete with<br />
gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>), <strong>and</strong> two where the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre is now. Note you can vaguely see the cattle yard for the<br />
steer-riding etc for the sports days just past the entrance off McMillan Road <strong>and</strong> the campers. Note camping<br />
around the perimeter of the oval <strong>and</strong> on the inlet side of the intersection of Bluewater Drive <strong>and</strong> the Princes<br />
Highway. Photo courtesy Narooma Historical Society.<br />
On 28 March 1958, the area was notified as Reserve 80515 for Public Recreation & Resting Place, but<br />
still included the area set aside for the Ambulance Station (Portions 660 <strong>and</strong> 546). <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong><br />
Council was appointed Trustee on 1 August 1958 when Bill Smyth was a <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Councilor,<br />
hence the name of the Reserve. 45 At that stage the Reserve also still included the Bowling Club area<br />
Over the years the Reserve has had a myriad of uses. It is the home of Narooma Football Club (which<br />
built the change room <strong>and</strong> kiosk facilities), initially Union <strong>and</strong> then League, <strong>and</strong> when AFL started<br />
playing on the ground, the netball courts that had been at one end of the oval went. 46<br />
42<br />
Letter with site plan of Ambulance Station site from Surveyors F S Mance & D N Allen to Builders Messrs Tober & Tober,<br />
2/12/1964, Narooma Ambulance Station Records,<br />
43<br />
Conversation with Paul Mood, 31/7/20<strong>06</strong><br />
44<br />
Conversation with Jock Munro, 31/7/20<strong>06</strong><br />
45<br />
Note from Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Linda Barr, via Council.<br />
46<br />
Former chairman of the Narooma Ovals Management Committee George Barker.<br />
Page 13 of 38
The Narooma Ovals Management Committee managed the Narooma Oval <strong>and</strong> NATA Oval (see later)<br />
for over 20 or so years. 47 George said soccer <strong>and</strong> cricket were played on the reserve for many years until<br />
they moved out to Dalmeny.<br />
The tennis courts finally moved back onto the Crown Reserve in 1992/1993 after been removed from<br />
this reserve in 1954 <strong>and</strong> from the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre site in 1967.<br />
This Reserve is where circuses are located when they come to town, the destination of many town<br />
parades, <strong>and</strong> in the last few years the home of the Blues Festival. Last year, camping returned to the<br />
Reserve in association with the Blues Festival.<br />
47 George Barker, ibid.<br />
Page <strong>14</strong> of 38
Narooma Bowling Club<br />
All of Narooma Bowling Club is located on a Crown Reserve, but the greens <strong>and</strong> club house area<br />
(Portion 829) are now under perpetual lease with the Club as Trustee not Council. That portion was<br />
revoked from Reserve 80515, then under Council’s Trusteeship, in September 1967 <strong>and</strong> gazetted 18<br />
April 1968. The parking area at the rear of the Club is on a term lease from Council as Trustee for<br />
Reserve 80515. 48<br />
A public meeting was held on 27 August 1946 to consider forming Narooma Bowling Club. The meeting<br />
agreed that Narooma’s Urban Committee be asked to make sufficient ground available between the<br />
tennis courts <strong>and</strong> the then septic tanks [for the camping area?] for a bowling green.<br />
It also agreed that the Urban Committee be asked to approach Council for a loan (no more than ₤1500 to<br />
build the bowling green <strong>and</strong> auxiliary building). Noel Woods was elected Foundation president.<br />
The new facility was officially opened on <strong>11</strong> December 1948, the first bowling club apparently in the<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong>.<br />
Photo from 1948/49 shows the original clubhouse (before extensions in 1950), the tennis courts next door <strong>and</strong><br />
camping on the Crown Reserve. (Photo courtesy Narooma Bowling Club).<br />
This photo from 1948/49 shows the original clubhouse <strong>and</strong> the Number 1 bowling green. Recent work<br />
on that green showed it had been built on top of a well (at northern end of Rink No. 4 – note the whole<br />
area had been originally reserved for the town’s water supply). The clubhouse was extended in 1950.<br />
In May 1954, the committee decided the site of the two tennis courts next door with gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> should<br />
be secured for an extra green, that ₤250 be paid to the Urban Committee for the removal of the Court,<br />
<strong>and</strong> that the Club should clinch the deal with the Urban Committee immediately with a ₤25 deposit. 49<br />
The tennis courts became Number 2 green in 1956 - the Club signed a lease with Council for the new<br />
48 Graham Reeve, President Narooma Sporting <strong>and</strong> services Club, June 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
49 That money was raised from loans from members.<br />
Page 15 of 38
green on <strong>11</strong> July1956. 50 (It would be interesting to find out what the tennis players thought of this,<br />
especially the loss of the impressive gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> or sports pavilion as it was called. Apparently about this<br />
time several private tennis courts were established in Narooma <strong>and</strong> this could have contributed to a lack<br />
of interest by tennis players in this facility.)<br />
In 1965, the Club was looking to buy the l<strong>and</strong> where the bowling greens were located <strong>and</strong> build a future<br />
clubhouse on the hill. Instead, in July 1968 the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s gazetted a lease to the Club in<br />
perpetuity over the l<strong>and</strong> they had applied to buy (Special lease 1967/5 L<strong>and</strong> District Moruya). What had<br />
once been the camping area behind the clubhouse <strong>and</strong> greens became Number 3 green in 1973.<br />
In January 1979, the Club approached Council for l<strong>and</strong> south of the clubhouse. In December, the Club<br />
wrote to the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s about the possibility of acquiring more l<strong>and</strong> for a fourth green. In<br />
December 1984, the Southern Star reported the Club’s application for more l<strong>and</strong> on the south-eastern<br />
comer to the L<strong>and</strong> Office would be supported by Council. That l<strong>and</strong> had been used as a BMX track<br />
In 1992, Council supported the Club in gaining a lease from the NSW Department of L<strong>and</strong>s for extra<br />
l<strong>and</strong> at rear of the club for car parking, part of Reserve 80515 (DP 7292<strong>06</strong> – Lot 9<strong>11</strong>).<br />
50<br />
Page 16 of 38
The Ambulance Station<br />
The area where the Ambulance Station is located was once part of this Crown Reserve.<br />
Narooma community raised money in the late 1940s/early 1050s towards building the Narooma<br />
Community Aid Centre. This was to consist of an ambulance station, baby health centre <strong>and</strong> an exservicemen’s<br />
club for the town in Campbell Street (where the current Servos Club, CWA <strong>and</strong> council car<br />
park are located). But apparently it soon became apparent there was not enough room for all three so<br />
Council organised for the corner block of the Crown Reserve where the ambulance station is now<br />
located to be excised from the Crown Reserve in 1958. 51 It had been part of the yard of the camping<br />
ranger’s cottage.<br />
The town’s ambulance service started about 1951 with 12 volunteer drivers <strong>and</strong> no ambulance, initiated<br />
by Alf Compton <strong>and</strong> Les Flukes. 52 Narooma Community Aid contributed ₤350 in 1951 to the town’s<br />
first ambulance, a secondh<strong>and</strong> Buick purchased from the Armidale District for ₤650. 53 It was first<br />
housed at Alf Compton’s residence. 54<br />
In 1956, the community built a timber ambulance station on the present site using voluntary labour <strong>and</strong><br />
donated materials. 55 The station consisted of a garage for the ambulance <strong>and</strong> a small casualty room (see<br />
top right of pic).<br />
Narooma’s voluntary ambulance drivers <strong>and</strong> ambulance. (Photo courtesy Joan Hyl<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> Narooma Historical<br />
Society) Note the camping ranger’s cottage far left.<br />
51<br />
Notes from Cliff Field’s talk on the early days of Narooma’s ambulance service, Narooma Historical Society Minutes<br />
Book, 15 August 1999.<br />
52<br />
Notes from Cliff Field’s talk on the early days of Narooma’s ambulance service, Narooma Historical Society Minutes<br />
Book, 15 August 1999.<br />
53<br />
Narooma Community Aid Centre Minute Book, Annual General Meeting 19 November 1951, Narooma Historical Society<br />
records; ‘The History of the Ambulance Service in Narooma’, Narooma Ambulance Station files.<br />
54<br />
Narooma Community Aid Centre Minute Book<br />
55<br />
The timber was donated by Mrs Face from Faces’ Sawmill, the roofing tiles were donated by Mr W Heard, according to a<br />
h<strong>and</strong>written note (in red biro) in the station’s records. The shed was moved to the rear of the property when the present station<br />
prior to the present building being built in 1965 <strong>and</strong> became a garage. The ambulance was only stored in the shed when not in<br />
use. Otherwise it was taken to the home of the officer on duty. OIC Mark Jolly said it was demolished a few years ago<br />
because of extensive white ant damage.<br />
Page 17 of 38
Then Ted <strong>and</strong> Daisy Street of Streets Ice Cream fame, who had sold Streets to Unilever in 1960 for<br />
nearly ₤4 million, retired to Narooma where they became local philanthropists. 56 Ted Street recognised<br />
the community’s efforts <strong>and</strong> the need to have a quality Ambulance Station especially because of its<br />
relative isolation. He gave a huge boost to the community’s efforts.<br />
The present station, complete with three-bedroom residence on top, was built by P J <strong>and</strong> T F Tober for<br />
₤13,225 <strong>and</strong> officially opened by Ted Street on 1 May 1965. The Station’s history states “this was made<br />
possible by the late Mr E Street <strong>and</strong> a loan with long term repayments at low interest”. 57<br />
New ambulance station . (Photo courtesy Narooma Ambulance Station).<br />
The community raised money to pay Street back plus pay the wages of the permanent ambulance drivers<br />
<strong>and</strong> general running expenses through over 20 years of raffles, housie <strong>and</strong> running the skating rink <strong>and</strong><br />
carnivals (see section on Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre). 58 It was a huge community effort. So apparently the<br />
community ended up owning the station (it paid Ted Street off) plus the service.<br />
Portion 660 containing the Ambulance Station was revoked from Reserve 80515 <strong>and</strong> gazetted on 26<br />
April 1968.<br />
The Housie Room <strong>and</strong> rear of the residence were remodelled in 1971, with Ted Street lending more<br />
money to do it. 59 There were further renovations in 1975 to the rear of the station to form a bedroom for<br />
relief staff <strong>and</strong> a store room. 60<br />
When the NSW Government took over the Ambulance Service in 1977, much to the relief of many, but<br />
all the assets automatically went to the Government, much to the upset of many others in the Narooma<br />
community. 61<br />
56<br />
Stephen Garton, ‘Street, Edwin (1891-1975)’, Australian Dictionary of Biography – Online Edition, Melbourne University<br />
Press, viewed <strong>14</strong> June 20<strong>06</strong>, pp. 371-372.<br />
57<br />
Station Officer I C Bagster, ‘History of Narooma Ambulance Service’, 1978, Narooma Ambulance Station records.<br />
58<br />
Notes from Cliff Field’s talk on the early days of Narooma’s ambulance service, Narooma Historical Society Minutes<br />
Book, 15 August 1999.<br />
59<br />
Notes from Cliff Field’s talk on the early days of Narooma’s ambulance service, Narooma Historical Society Minutes<br />
Book, 15 August 1999; Mark Jolly, OIC Narooma Ambulance Station..<br />
60<br />
Station Officer I C Bagster, ‘History of Narooma Ambulance Service’, 1978, Narooma Ambulance Station records.<br />
Page 18 of 38
2. RESERVE 63051<br />
What was then the foreshore was gazetted as Reserve 63051 for public Recreation <strong>and</strong> Resting Place on<br />
13 November 1931, following some small reclamation following the construction of the western training<br />
wall.<br />
At that stage it did not include the l<strong>and</strong> now occupied by much of NATA Oval, the swimming pool, nor<br />
some of the foreshore l<strong>and</strong>. Council was appointed Trustee on 6 May 1938, no doubt following<br />
representations of the Narooma Urban Committee.<br />
The Reserve today extends from opposite the current town wharf to along the foreshore to the bridge.<br />
Narooma Sport & Leisure Centre site<br />
Originally it was part of the original Reserve for Water <strong>and</strong> Depasturage but formed into a separate<br />
reserve some time after. It had been a Crown Reserve though before that with its own three Trustees. 62<br />
It was part of Reserve 63051 gazetted in 1931.<br />
In the early 1900s, at least one boat was built where the Sport & Leisure Centre is today, fronting the<br />
shallow channel. The boat was nowhere near the size of the ships like the Kianga built in Mill Bay or<br />
over near Apex Park which were used for the coastal trade. Doug Rose said that as a boy in the late<br />
1930s/1940s, he would go prawning in front of the shipyard site <strong>and</strong> there were big girders <strong>and</strong> old logs<br />
in the water there. He believes they would still be there under the s<strong>and</strong>.<br />
Sometime pre 1930s, two clay tennis courts were built by the community on what was the old shipyard<br />
site, roughly where the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre is now located. It is not clear at this stage when they<br />
were built or by whom. (Another two courts were built in the late 1930s/ early 1940s where the Bowling<br />
Green No.2 is now.) In the 1930s <strong>and</strong> later, bookings <strong>and</strong> collection of fees for the courts were done by<br />
the Urban Committee’s Camping Ranger.<br />
At some stage, Council (or the Urban Committee) must have decided to asphalt the courts on the Sport<br />
<strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre site, possibly in the early 1960s. 63 Keen tennis player at the time Kevin Young is not<br />
sure if it was a botched job or what, but says it was disastrous for serious tennis players because it made<br />
the balls <strong>and</strong> the racquets go black. This increased the popularity of the Young’s Girrahween Courts on<br />
Cemetery Road although the town courts continued to be used for casual games <strong>and</strong> visitors. Youngs<br />
sold the Girrahween Courts <strong>and</strong> surrounding block to Garry Darnell, Kevin thinks probably in the mid<br />
1960s. 64<br />
This coincided with the time of Ted Street’s gr<strong>and</strong> plan of the community running regular fundraising<br />
events to pay for the new Ambulance Service, particularly when tourists were in town. He recognised the<br />
strategic importance of this site, then occupied by the community’s two tennis courts.<br />
Street encouraged local tennis players to form, or rather re-form, the Narooma Tennis Club (the<br />
inaugural meeting was held on 20 June 1967) <strong>and</strong> relocate the town’s remaining tennis courts to a new<br />
site in McMillan Road which Ted bought on the club’s behalf. He also helped finance the Club’s<br />
building of the new all-weather courts of plastic covered concrete (opened December 1967), with<br />
another low interest loan, which the club eventually repaid. 65<br />
61<br />
Laura Field <strong>and</strong> Bob Carr at Narooma Historical Society meeting, 16 July 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
62<br />
Narooma Urban Committee Minutes Book,<br />
63<br />
Kevin Young conversation.<br />
64<br />
Phone conversation with Kevin Young, <strong>14</strong> July 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
65<br />
Narooma Tennis Club minute books. Ted Street also encouraged the Club to buy an adjoining block of l<strong>and</strong> from Bill<br />
Hyl<strong>and</strong>. That block was bought by Council on the club’s behalf, <strong>and</strong> the money repaid over four years.<br />
Page 19 of 38
Tennis moves off the Crown Reserves for over 30 years to McMillan Road. (Photo courtesy Narooma Historical<br />
Society).<br />
Ted Street then had the old courts dismantled on the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre site <strong>and</strong> organised a<br />
generous loan to pay for a concrete slab to be poured for an open air skating rink. George Barker says a<br />
specialist Italian concreter came down from Wollongong especially to do the job. A permanent carnival<br />
ground was located alongside. 66 It was completed in time for the 1966-67 holiday season. 67<br />
The community through the Ambulance Auxiliary ran carnivals on the skating rink site for many years<br />
<strong>and</strong> operated the open air skating rink each weekend <strong>and</strong> through the holiday season. They also ran<br />
housie from the rear of the ambulance station, <strong>and</strong> sold raffle <strong>and</strong> art union tickets. Funds raised in this<br />
way bought ambulances, financed the local service, paid for the ambulance station, <strong>and</strong> there were also<br />
generous contributions from residents of items for the Service. 68<br />
66 George Barker, interviewed 9 July 20<strong>06</strong>; Chairman’ Report, ‘NSW Ambulance Transport Service Far South Coast District<br />
Thirty-third Annual Report <strong>and</strong> Financial Statement for the year ended 30 June 1967’<br />
67<br />
68<br />
Page 20 of 38
Outdoor roller skating funded the operation of the town’s Ambulance Service for many years <strong>and</strong> helped pay for<br />
the building of the station (Photo courtesy Narooma Historical Society).<br />
Initially all drivers were voluntary. The community continued to be responsible for financing the service<br />
until it was finally taken over by the NSW Government-funded NSW Ambulance Service in 1977. 69 It<br />
appears some fundraising continued for a few years for the Ambulance Service after that.<br />
Narooma Rotary Club, assisted by other volunteers, incorporated the open-air skating rink into the<br />
Narooma Sports <strong>and</strong> Leisure Complex in 1984. The concrete floor is still that built by Ted Street. This<br />
was a major undertaking for Rotary using their own <strong>and</strong> voluntary labour, assisted by a Government<br />
grant, a $10,000 loan from <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council, <strong>and</strong> with financial contributions <strong>and</strong> loans from<br />
its own members.<br />
Narooma Rotary Club dismantles the fencing around the open-air skating rink ready for the construction of the<br />
Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre. (Photo courtesy Narooma Rotary Club).<br />
69 OIC Narooma Ambulance Station Mark Jolly <strong>11</strong>/7/20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
Page 21 of 38
The enclosure of the open air rink is underway. (Photo courtesy Narooma Rotary Club).<br />
When Narooma High burnt down in 1987, the centre was rented by the school for use as several<br />
temporary classrooms for a few months until sufficient demountables were on site at the school for<br />
everyone to return to the school.<br />
Mick Turner managed the centre from about 1987 to 1997. He said the centre was run by a voluntary<br />
management committee under chairman Neville Gough answerable to <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council. He<br />
said the bulk of the business was rollerskating, followed by indoor cricket, regular basketball <strong>and</strong> netball,<br />
indoor soccer, <strong>and</strong> also inline hockey.<br />
“One of the things that ultimately beat the centre was insurance,” Mick said. “Council brought in that<br />
people had to belong to associated sporting bodies which covered them for insurance, <strong>and</strong> council picked<br />
up the insurance for rollerskating <strong>and</strong> inline hockey <strong>and</strong> the prices had to go up accordingly. Many<br />
Narooma people just couldn’t afford to play.”<br />
He said it also coincided with the time when people over 30 were concerned at the damage concrete<br />
floors could have on their knees, but to put a sprung wooden floor in at that time was difficult to justify<br />
because rollerskating was the bulk of the business.<br />
The centre has also been used for a range of functions, from weddings to exhibitions, various auctions<br />
including the Apex (later VRA), music concerts <strong>and</strong> festivals, elections, <strong>and</strong> public meetings. It<br />
continues to be used in this way.<br />
Narooma High used the premises for tutorials for students having difficulties with normal classes for a<br />
number of years, up until fairly recently.<br />
Page 22 of 38
Swimming baths to covered pool on reclaimed l<strong>and</strong><br />
Training walls create first swimming baths<br />
This was not part of a Reserve, but its history affects it.<br />
The first big change to the foreshore area was the construction of the first training wall in the inlet to try<br />
to overcome the increasing problems the port was having with ships crossing the bar at the entrance <strong>and</strong><br />
shoaling within the inlet. Many entries in the Narooma Pilot station logs <strong>and</strong> notes report the bar at this<br />
time was playing havoc with shipping. 70<br />
As the training wall on this side of the inlet was extended, it created a shark-free area which could be<br />
used as the town’s swimming baths by both tourists <strong>and</strong> locals. This was a time of increasing tourism for<br />
Narooma, with guest houses like St Kilda shown on the hill (top right), <strong>and</strong> Noorooma House <strong>and</strong><br />
Hyl<strong>and</strong>'s Hotel nearby.<br />
The shark-proof swimming baths. Note the St Kilda Guesthouse on the hill, top right. (Photo courtesy Narooma<br />
Historical Society).<br />
In 1932, the newly created Narooma Urban Committee cleared the swimming baths of “seaweed <strong>and</strong><br />
refuse" <strong>and</strong> provided two lavatories at the dressing sheds, at the request of the Narooma Swimming<br />
Club. The Urban Committee gave C M F Johnson permission to erect a diving tower etc at the baths in<br />
December 1932, provided the Committee had the option of purchasing them in two years, or they may be<br />
removed to the committee’s satisfaction.<br />
70 Narooma Pilot Station Logbooks 1.<strong>11</strong>.1910- 30.<strong>11</strong>.1931 CGS 4789 State Archives Kingswood 6/5124-24, 2 vols; Laurelle<br />
Pacey, Narooma’s Past – steamers, salmon <strong>and</strong> sawmills, Revised edition 2005, pp.<br />
Page 23 of 38
This photo from the 1930s shows the dressing sheds, <strong>and</strong> the diving tower. (Photo courtesy of the Douglas Fox<br />
collection <strong>and</strong> Narooma Historical Society).<br />
The Narooma Urban Committee strongly opposed an application for an oyster lease on the training walls<br />
round the Narooma Baths in 1936. They gained permission from the Department of Public <strong>Works</strong> to<br />
insert four sets of pipes through the training wall to improve the circulation of water in the baths. 71 The<br />
swimming baths continued to be a great attraction for the area, with change sheds, a diving tower <strong>and</strong><br />
later swimming lanes. They continued to be used until pool was built in 1966.<br />
71 Minutes of the Narooma Urban Committee, 24 March <strong>and</strong> 8 May 1936, Narooma Historical Society archives.<br />
Page 24 of 38
Narooma creates in-ground pool on reclaimed l<strong>and</strong><br />
The inaugural president of Narooma Amateur Swimming Club John Burbidge said it was at Ted Street’s<br />
prompting that the community started pushing for an in-ground pool. One problem with the existing pool<br />
behind the training wall was the difficulty of running races there because the turning boards would grow<br />
oysters that cut swimmers’ feet. 72<br />
In 1964 the Streets gave ₤5,000 towards the construction of the Moruya pool <strong>and</strong> a similar amount<br />
towards Batemans Bay’s pool, but they gave ₤10,000 towards the construction of Narooma’s pool <strong>and</strong><br />
offered to back loans for construction. 73 Mr Burbidge said the Streets always wanted to give something<br />
back to kids because they believed it was because of kids their company had been such a success. 74<br />
First though the ground had to be elevated above the tide. S<strong>and</strong> was dredged from behind the training<br />
wall <strong>and</strong> placed on site. “Council had a dredge in there, operated by Roy Face I think, pumping s<strong>and</strong> up<br />
into this area,” said the new pool’s first manager <strong>and</strong> coach Alan Dufty. “Before that, this was all<br />
swamp.”<br />
The resulting l<strong>and</strong> was gazetted as a Reserve for Resting Place <strong>and</strong> Public Recreation on 27/1/1967 <strong>and</strong><br />
added to the existing Reserve 63051.<br />
The swimming centre with 50 metre six-lane main pool, toddlers’ pool, dressing sheds, a kiosk <strong>and</strong> a<br />
plant room, opened to the public on 16 December 1966 with the official opening in February the<br />
following year. Alan Dufty took up his appointment as manager on 20 December 1966. 75<br />
Narooma’s Olympic size in-ground swimming pool became a major tourist attraction, as it appeared in a late<br />
1960s tourist brochure. (Photo courtesy Narooma Historical Society).<br />
72 Neville Gough.<br />
73 William A Bayley, Behind Broulee - Central South Coast New South Wales, <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council 1978, p.127.<br />
74 John Burbidge, conversation 31/7/<strong>06</strong><br />
75 Alan Dufty,<br />
Page 25 of 38
“The pool was just ‘a pimple on a pumpkin’ then with s<strong>and</strong> all around it,” Alan said. Long time<br />
Narooma Pool manager <strong>and</strong> coach Alan Dufty said Ted Street had plans drawn up by an architect in<br />
Sydney for the construction of the pool which included a manager’s house as part of the complex. 76<br />
“Ted’s original plans were better than what we ended up with… 77 I think if they [Council] had gone with<br />
that [those plans], Ted probably would have paid for the whole lot,” Alan said.<br />
Alan had a fair bit to do with Ted over the years. “Everybody used to say ‘Oh, Ted’s always got strings<br />
attached’. He didn’t believe in giving things away. He would say, ‘people don’t appreciate it if you just<br />
give it to them, they’ve got to contribute somehow”. All the things I got the swimming club through Ted,<br />
the swimming club had to raise the rest of the money. The first thing the club got was gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>s. It<br />
cost $5,000 at the time. Ted put in $4,000 so the swimming club had to raise $1,000. We created a<br />
windbreak along the back of the gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> – we had big letters along them saying ‘Narooma Olympic<br />
Pool’. Those gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>s are still at the pool <strong>and</strong> belong to the Club.”<br />
Alan said the Swimming Club put in a two million BTU oil-fired boiler to keep the water warm in<br />
summer because at the start of the season it would be 15 degrees. The swimming club paid for the oil.<br />
“But we found it was losing a lot of heat so we went to Sydney <strong>and</strong> found a mob <strong>and</strong> bought covers,”<br />
Alan said. “Ray McCarthy of Tilba Engineering built us a big roller so we then put covers on both the<br />
main <strong>and</strong> toddlers’ pools at night.”<br />
He said the swimming club also built a shadecloth windbreak at the southern end, put in hot showers<br />
with the two water heaters donated by “the electricity mob then”. The swimming club also put in the<br />
anti-wave ropes which are still there.<br />
In 1981 the Swimming Club built the Fitness Centre <strong>and</strong> Club rooms. “Theo Schutz was Club president<br />
then,” said Alan. “The pillars <strong>and</strong> beams were donated by Davis & Herbert where Theo worked.” The<br />
Club received some financial assistance from the NSW Department of Sport <strong>and</strong> Recreation. Labour was<br />
provided by various Narooma service clubs.<br />
Then the Club put solar heating on the Club Room roof to assist the boiler, after fundraising by the<br />
swimming club with assistance from various groups around town. 78 “It was never as efficient as it could<br />
have been – the slope of the roof didn’t help. That solar system went down to Cobargo but was never<br />
used. This new building would have been ideal now – it was built to take a solar system.<br />
Alan said Ted Street wanted to build the manager’s house for Alan Dufty, but Council didn’t want Ted<br />
to build it so they did.”<br />
76 Alan Dufty was manager from December 1966 until about 1995, but then stayed on until about 1997 helping his son Shane<br />
Dufty <strong>and</strong> his wife Wendy who had taken on the pool’s management.<br />
77 Alan Dufty said when he moved house he threw the plans away<br />
78 Narooma School of Arts $500, Letter Narooma School of Arts secretary Henry Ramage to Narooma Amateur Swimming<br />
Club secretary Pauline Gill, 8/5/1981. It was a Zane Solar Heating System, Letter Narooma Amateur Swimming Club<br />
president Theo Schutz to Narooma School of Arts secretary 1/9/80<br />
Page 26 of 38
Covering the pool<br />
The covering of Narooma Swimming Pool in 1992 <strong>and</strong> the extra heating was a joint community effort<br />
initiated by Narooma Hydrotherapy Club <strong>and</strong> the Swimming Club.<br />
“Pop Brown was terrific, he was the driving force,” Alan said. “He’d been running exercise classes in<br />
the pool but said it was too cold for old people. He wanted to build a wall as a windbreak, but I said it<br />
wouldn’t work. They also needed hydrotherapy through the year. So we decided we had to cover it. We<br />
formed the Hydrotherapy Club in April 1989, <strong>and</strong> started going about, looking at things.”<br />
The Hydrotherapy Club wanted to provide gentle exercises for those suffering from arthritis, cardiovascular<br />
problems <strong>and</strong> other ailments all through the year. The Swimming Club wanted to be able to<br />
provide year-round training for its talented swimmers, year-round learn to swim classes, as well as other<br />
water activities like aquarobics, water polo, <strong>and</strong> underwater diving.<br />
In May 1989, the two clubs formed a joint committee to gain community support <strong>and</strong> interest in<br />
fundraising for the project. That committee consisted of Gordon ‘Pop’ Brown (chairman), Dot Philip<br />
(secretary), Hilton Philip (?), Barbara McEwen, Swimming Club president Carol Mead <strong>and</strong> Alan<br />
Mulhall. 79 They set about investigating various grants <strong>and</strong> their availability, <strong>and</strong> possible fundraising<br />
activities.<br />
A deputation approached Council for a grant or interest free loan to help the ‘Cover the Pool’ Project<br />
proceed, the project’s estimate then being about $230,000. 80 The first public meeting was held on 16<br />
October 1990 at Narooma Ex-Servicemen’s Club.<br />
79 Alan Dufty <strong>and</strong> Hydrotherapy Club records.<br />
80 Narooma Area News, 30 August 1989<br />
Tireless workers to cover the pool – Pop Brown <strong>and</strong> Dot Philip.<br />
(Photo courtesy Narooma Hydrotherapy Club).<br />
Page 27 of 38
From all accounts, Gordon ‘Pop’ Brown was a remarkable man. He was a former chairman of Warringah<br />
<strong>Shire</strong> Council <strong>and</strong> understood the workings of all levels of government. He also knew how to bring<br />
people together to get something done.<br />
“No words could do justice to the relentless campaign Pop Brown undertook on the community’s<br />
behalf,” said <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Mayor at that time Chris Vardon. “He would appear at home without warning,<br />
his big booming voice filling the air with a ‘dare to go against’ me attitude. We had some pretty good<br />
arguments but he always went away knowing that if he could back his argument Council would support<br />
him. I remember him with affection.”<br />
Pop Brown said the Club was “fortunate to have members like Doug Tribe with a lifetime of building<br />
experience <strong>and</strong> Peter Phelps, the local architectural designer, who put together this superb structure.”<br />
Doug became the honorary project director <strong>and</strong> laboured long <strong>and</strong> hard for the community. 81<br />
The committee refused to engage expensive consultants, which Pop Brown said saved them $15,000-<br />
$18,000 as a result. Some committee members visited other pools to check out at how they had been<br />
enclosed.<br />
Former pool manager <strong>and</strong> coach Alan Dufty inside the covered pool.<br />
“Doug Tribe, Ash Garrard <strong>and</strong> Peter Phelps picked out the best ideas <strong>and</strong> incorporated them into the<br />
design,” Alan said. “These big doors, for example, were an idea from Blacktown. The idea was to use<br />
nature <strong>and</strong> have an air flow through system but they never use it now. Like, if it’s a real hot day with a<br />
nor-easter blowing, you can keep this side open <strong>and</strong> it creates a beautiful atmosphere. That was why it<br />
was designed like that…And then we put louvres up the top at both ends of the pool so you could open it<br />
up to let air flow right through the pool. The main purpose was to get rid of the condensation, because<br />
we didn’t have air conditioning then <strong>and</strong> condensation was a real problem.” Pop Brown claimed this<br />
design in conjunction with the great doors (each cost $10,500) saved thous<strong>and</strong>s of dollars in airconditioning<br />
costs at that stage. 82<br />
81 Pop Brown’s notes, ibid.<br />
82 Narooma Hydrotherapy Club records<br />
Page 28 of 38
Peter drew up the plans free of charge <strong>and</strong> lodged them with Council on 17 June 1991. Council approved<br />
the plans about a year later. Mr Vardon said technical details were dealt with by senior Council<br />
engineers. “They had some disagreement with the advice Doug <strong>and</strong> Ash were giving but eventually the<br />
project was approved,” Mr Vardon said. “Council contributed about $12,000 to the building program.”<br />
The committee’s emphasis from the start was that the facility should be for the use of the whole<br />
community, hence their push to cover the whole pool. These clubs eventually managed to get Council on<br />
side, after some councillors initially felt the community was railroading council. 83 Hydrotherapy Club<br />
records state Council had wanted them to build <strong>and</strong> cover a small hydrotherapy pool, but the Club<br />
wanted something to benefit the whole community, young <strong>and</strong> old. The Hydrotherapy Club felt it would<br />
not be fair to raise funds in the community to cover a pool just for the use of the elderly.<br />
The Club’s records also state Council was concerned the building <strong>and</strong> running of the covered pool could<br />
be a strain on ratepayers’ money. This was confirmed by Mr Vardon. “Some councillors believed the<br />
project was a ‘white elephant’ <strong>and</strong> would prove to be too costly to run <strong>and</strong> maintain,” he said. “This was<br />
food for thought <strong>and</strong> the Committee had much fast talking to do to convince Council. But Pop Brown<br />
was unrelenting in his pursuit of this project.” 84<br />
Council said they wouldn’t even look at the project until their committee had raised $80,000-$90,000.<br />
Once Council saw how the community had got behind the project <strong>and</strong> raised about $86,000 even before<br />
the project had really got underway, Council agreed to support it.<br />
Pop Brown said that from the start the Hydrotherapy Club <strong>and</strong> the Swimming Club had “splendid<br />
community support”. They received Council’s support <strong>and</strong> the cooperation of the then two MPs Russell<br />
Smith (State) <strong>and</strong> Jim Snow (Federal).<br />
In an article in the Narooma Area News soon after the opening, Pop Brown acknowledged the support of<br />
the project from day one of Councilors Vardon, Cairney, Blacker, Pollock, Reid <strong>and</strong> Doust, with Cr<br />
Doust Council’s representative on the committee. 85<br />
Work began on 18 July 1992 with the help of the swimming club <strong>and</strong> many volunteer <strong>and</strong> trades people<br />
giving their time to clear fences <strong>and</strong> seats so the work could begin. The new covered pool was officially<br />
opened by <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Mayor Chris Vardon on 23 January 1993.<br />
Pop Brown believed their fundraising efforts were unprecedented “because in fact we [the community]<br />
were responsible for raising all the funds from the Federal Government, the NSW Government, Local<br />
Government <strong>and</strong> a wonderful community of approximately 5,000 people.” He said the whole project<br />
ended up costing about $450,000. That money was raised by the fundraising committee <strong>and</strong> members of<br />
the two clubs ($171,000), as well as from generous Federal <strong>and</strong> State Government grants <strong>and</strong><br />
contributions by <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council which the clubs applied for. 86<br />
The massive community fundraising effort was headed by Dorothy Wilson <strong>and</strong> assisted by members of<br />
both the Hydrotherapy <strong>and</strong> Swimming clubs. Activities included market stalls, theatre nights, street<br />
stalls, a monster car raffle, a recession buster raffle <strong>and</strong> of course the clubs’ famous lamingtons which<br />
appeared to be everywhere. In one year, Dorothy Wilson <strong>and</strong> her team made <strong>and</strong> sold 12,000<br />
lamingtons. 87<br />
Pop Brown proudly stated in 1996, Narooma’s was the only 50 metre fully covered enclosed <strong>and</strong> heated<br />
pool in NSW outside of Sydney. 88 It was also the biggest single span in the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong>. He<br />
83 Narooma Hydrotherapy Club records<br />
84 Email Chris Vardon to Laurelle Pacey 12 July 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
85 Narooma Area News, xx 1993<br />
86 Narooma Hydrotherapy Club records – ‘Questions <strong>and</strong> Answers’.<br />
87 Pat Eaton said Dorothy Wilson’s team included Betty Bettini, Betty Halford, Bee Beaumont <strong>and</strong> ?<br />
88 Notes by ‘Pop’ Brown for something on 1 March 1996, Narooma Hydrotherapy Club records.<br />
Page 29 of 38
always said the shire’s pools belong to the people of the shire <strong>and</strong> are administered <strong>and</strong> held in trust by<br />
Council on the community’s behalf.<br />
Pop Brown said that covering the pool “… was achieved because a group of the older generation had the<br />
vision to convert an existing facility which lay idle for at least six months of the year [April to late<br />
September], into a superb sporting venue that everyone from the unborn to the most elderly could enjoy<br />
seven days a week all year round”. 89<br />
That vision is now under threat with major structural repairs now underway <strong>and</strong> the heat pumps possibly<br />
needing to be replaced.<br />
Alan Dufty said part of the work in 1992 involved changing over to a gas-fired burner. After a few years<br />
the decision was made to up the water temperature which created greater condensation. He said that’s<br />
when they added the air conditioning with all the piping <strong>and</strong> heat pumps to cope with the extra<br />
condensation. He also maintains the structure has not been operated over the intervening years in the<br />
way it was intended which could well have contributed to the problems.<br />
89 Notes by ‘Pop’ Brown for something on 1 March 1996, Narooma Hydrotherapy Club records.<br />
Page 30 of 38
NATA Oval<br />
NATA Oval, sometimes these days referred to it as NATA Park, was mainly created from s<strong>and</strong> dredged<br />
from the inlet in the mid 1960s. Only the fringe of the reserve between Bluewater Drive <strong>and</strong> about the<br />
caravan park existed as dry l<strong>and</strong> before then (See 1950s aerial pic).<br />
Former Chairman of the Ovals Management Committee George Barker said it was used for town cricket<br />
in its early days before it moved to Dalmeny as well as hockey up to the 1990s. It was used by Narooma<br />
Public School for weekly sports (cricket, soccer <strong>and</strong> softball) in the 1970s through to the late 1990s as<br />
well as Infants School sports carnivals until recent years. 90<br />
NATA st<strong>and</strong>s for the Narooma Area Tourist Association which existed to promote tourism in Narooma,<br />
before it amalgamated with the Chamber of Commerce. NATA was responsible for building the<br />
Narooma Visitors Information Centre on part of the reserve in 1981. Various businesses <strong>and</strong><br />
organisations contributed towards the cost of building the centre, including the Narooma School of Arts<br />
Committee. 91<br />
NATA Oval was the venue for the lighting of the Olympic Cauldron in Narooma, done by Narooma local Deb<br />
Tinson with Matt Tate. (Photo courtesy Narooma Historical Society).<br />
90<br />
Conversation with Bob Burnside, 4/8/20<strong>06</strong><br />
91<br />
The School of Arts contributed $3,000. Letter from NATA Tourist Officer Robyn Hoyer to Narooma Hall Committee,<br />
12/9/1982, Narooma School of Arts archives.<br />
Page 31 of 38
Narooma Chamber of Commerce in the late 1990s suggested that NATA Oval should be considered as a<br />
possible site for the new town library <strong>and</strong> community health centre met, but it met with some community<br />
opposition. Many felt it should be kept as green open space, a kind of village green which could be<br />
adapted for a multiple of uses.<br />
It has had many uses since it was created. It is often used for informal recreation, just kicking a ball<br />
around, the odd game of cricket by campers or passers by, school sports, regular dog training, the<br />
Narooma Rotary markets on the fourth Sunday of the month, carnivals, Beach Missions over the<br />
summer, <strong>and</strong> various public events.<br />
NATA Oval is the venue for the monthly Narooma Rotary Markets.<br />
It has also been used for Australia Day ceremonies, the Sydney Olympic Torch relay in 2000, <strong>and</strong> Blues<br />
Festivals.<br />
Page 32 of 38
The Blues Festival covered NATA Oval <strong>and</strong> the outside of the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre site for the 2003 Telstra<br />
Great Southern Blues <strong>and</strong> Rockabilly Festival. (Photo courtesy of Telstra).<br />
Page 33 of 38
Wagonga Inlet Foreshore Reserve & Ken Rose Park<br />
The following photo shows the greatly reduced area of the foreshore reserve prior to the reclamation,<br />
possibly some in the 1930s, <strong>and</strong> also as a result of the reclamation for the swimming pool.<br />
Camping fees were collected by the Urban camping ranger from the 1930s on.<br />
The foreshore reserve before the reclamation showing camping in the early days on the reserve along towards the<br />
bridge. (Photo courtesy Doug Rose).<br />
The Narooma Urban Committee which managed the Reserve on Council’s behalf from the late 1930s,<br />
decided in November 1940 that the trees in the camping area along the waterfront should be lopped. 92<br />
They also cleared a lot of undergrowth to provide extra areas for camping.<br />
92 Minutes Narooma Urban Committee , 10 October 1940, Narooma Historical Society Archives<br />
Page 34 of 38
Camping along the foreshore reserve in the 1960s, possibly before reclamation<br />
(Photo courtesy Doug Rose).<br />
This has been a popular camping area since at least the 1930s, as this postcard pic above shows.<br />
Apparently the camping area was leased to someone before Easts, details unknown at this stage.<br />
Easts have leased the area since 1986. 93<br />
The foreshore area was opened up to the public with the construction of the cycleway-pathway in the late<br />
1990s. Local architect Phil Rose came up with the concept while working on the Design guidelines for<br />
Development Control Plan the Narooma town centre for <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council in 1995. It was an<br />
extension to his brief. 94<br />
That concept was developed further by him in association with Connybeare & Morrison in the Narooma<br />
Foreshore <strong>and</strong> Township Masterplan, adopted by Council in 1998.<br />
Ken Rose Park near the bridge was named after the ferryman who with his brother Alan operated the<br />
ferry for many years up until the bridge was built. Ken Rose’s house is the old cottage opposite. Ken also<br />
had holiday cabins on the flat for many years.<br />
93 Lyn Field of Easts.<br />
94 Phil Rose, conversation <strong>14</strong>/8/20<strong>06</strong><br />
Page 35 of 38
Ken Rose Park – Federation Arch<br />
The Federation Arch was built to commemorate the Centenary of Federation <strong>and</strong> Narooma’s Federation<br />
Festival which was held on 3 November 2001. It was funded by donations by the people of Narooma <strong>and</strong><br />
surrounding district organised through Project Manager Coral Phillips. The arch was unveiled Australia<br />
Day 2002. Australia Day ceremonies have been held in the Ken Rose Park ever since.<br />
Page 36 of 38
CAPTIONS SUMMARY<br />
1. Narooma Football team of 1909 would have played on the Sportsground-recreation ground but the background looks<br />
more like the flat. Photo courtesy of John Annis.<br />
2. Camping at Narooma <strong>and</strong> Dalmeny became popular from the late 1920s with some families returning at the<br />
same time to the same site year after year. Photo courtesy Narooma Historical Society.<br />
3. The community gathers for a sports day on the reserve in the mid 1920s, before the sportsground relocated to<br />
the flat from the old recreation reserve where the golf course is now located. Crushes for the cattle <strong>and</strong> horses<br />
were then located around to the left of the photo. Photo courtesy Narooma Historical Society.<br />
4. Narooma’s football team on Narooma Oval on the flat circa 1930s. Photo courtesy John Annis <strong>and</strong> Narooma<br />
Historical Society.<br />
5. This section of a much larger aerial photo dates from 1937/38, dated from the house having been<br />
moved to the reserve for the camping ranger (see left arrow near the junction of McMillan Rd <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Princes Highway. Note tennis courts on the site where the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre is now, but no<br />
courts over on the Crown Reserve where the Bowling Club’s Number 2 green is today. The cabins were<br />
Ken Rose’s. (Photo courtesy Narooma Historical Society)<br />
6. This photo, taken probably 1949/1950, shows the newly created Bowling Club house <strong>and</strong> original green with<br />
the two clay tennis courts <strong>and</strong> gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>. Note football being played on the oval. (Photo courtesy Narooma<br />
Bowling Club)<br />
7. Camping ranger Andy Carr shows the problems campers sometimes faced on this reserve (Photo courtesy<br />
Angela Hansen )<br />
8. The Urban Cottage for the camping ranger, that used to be located where the croquet lawn is now located.<br />
(Photo courtesy Angela Hansen )<br />
8b. Camping on the other side of the oval. (Photo courtesy Angela Hansen )<br />
9. This photo believed to be from the early 1950s (before extensions to School of Arts) shows the location of the<br />
town’s four clay tennis courts – two on the site of what is now the Bowling Club’s No. 2 Green (complete with<br />
gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>), <strong>and</strong> two where the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre is now. Note you can vaguely see the cattle yard for the<br />
steer-riding etc for the sports days just past the entrance off McMillan Road <strong>and</strong> the campers. Note camping<br />
around the perimeter of the oval <strong>and</strong> on the inlet side of the intersection of Bluewater Drive <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Princes Highway. Photo courtesy Narooma Historical Society)<br />
10. Photo from 1948/49 shows the original clubhouse (before extensions in 1950), the tennis courts next door <strong>and</strong><br />
camping on the Crown Reserve. (Photo courtesy Narooma Bowling Club)<br />
NO PIC <strong>11</strong><br />
Page 37 of 38
12. Narooma’s voluntary ambulance drivers <strong>and</strong> ambulance. (Photo courtesy Joan Hyl<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
Narooma Historical Society) Note the camping ranger’s cottage far left.<br />
13. PIC of new ambulance station. (Photo courtesy Narooma Ambulance Station)<br />
<strong>14</strong>a. Tennis moves off the Crown Reserves for over 30 years to McMillan Road. (Photo courtesy<br />
Narooma Historical Society)<br />
<strong>14</strong>b. Outdoor roller skating funded the operation of the town’s Ambulance Service for many years <strong>and</strong><br />
helped pay for the building of the station (Photo courtesy Narooma Historical Society)<br />
15. Narooma Rotary Club dismantles the fencing around the open-air skating rink ready for the construction of<br />
the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre. (Photo courtesy Narooma Rotary Club)<br />
16. The enclosure of the open air rink is underway. (Photo courtesy Narooma Rotary Club)<br />
17. The shark-proof swimming baths. Note the St Kilda Guesthouse on the hill, top right. (Photo courtesy<br />
Narooma Historical Society)<br />
18. This photo from the 1930s shows the dressing sheds, <strong>and</strong> the diving tower. (Photo courtesy of the Douglas Fox<br />
collection <strong>and</strong> Narooma Historical Society)<br />
19. Narooma’s Olympic size in-ground swimming pool became a major tourist attraction, as it appeared in a late<br />
1960s tourist brochure. (Photo courtesy Narooma Historical Society)<br />
20. Tireless workers to cover the pool – Pop Brown <strong>and</strong> Dot Philip. (Photo courtesy Narooma Hydrotherapy<br />
Club)<br />
21. Former pool manager <strong>and</strong> coach Alan Dufty inside the covered pool.<br />
22. NATA Oval was the venue for the lighting of the Olympic Cauldron in Narooma, done by Narooma local Deb<br />
Tinson with Matt Tate. (Photo courtesy Narooma Historical Society)<br />
23. NATA Oval is the venue for the monthly Narooma Rotary Markets.<br />
24. The Blues Festival covered NATA Oval <strong>and</strong> the outside of the Sport <strong>and</strong> Leisure Centre site for the 2003<br />
Telstra Great Southern Blues <strong>and</strong> Rockabilly Festival. (Photo courtesy of Telstra).<br />
25. The foreshore reserve before the reclamation showing camping on the reserve along towards the bridge.<br />
(Photo courtesy Doug Rose)<br />
26. Camping along the foreshore reserve in the 1960s, possibly before reclamation. (Photo courtesy Doug Rose)<br />
27.Ken Rose Park Federation Arch<br />
Page 38 of 38
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 64<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/128 MORUYA GOLF COURSE & SHOWGROUND DRAFT PLAN<br />
OF MANAGEMENT 95.9434; 95.9434.P<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
The draft Plan of Management for the Moruya Golf Course <strong>and</strong> Showground has been<br />
publicly exhibited <strong>and</strong> submissions received. A copy of the finalised draft Plan of<br />
Management is attached.<br />
Once endorsed by Council, the Plan of Management will be forwarded to the Department of<br />
L<strong>and</strong>s for final adoption.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
1995 – development of the draft Plan of Management for the Moruya Golf Course <strong>and</strong><br />
Showground commenced at the requestion of the Department of L<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> Water<br />
Conservation (now the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s).<br />
July 2002 – draft Plan of Management endorsed <strong>and</strong> exhibited at Council’s <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
<strong>Facilities</strong> Committee Meeting.<br />
October 2002 - Moruya Showground Working Group formed (including representatives<br />
from: Moruya Showground Management Committee, Equestrian/Dressage Association,<br />
Rodeo Association, Moruya Basketball Stadium & Community Centre Management<br />
Committee <strong>and</strong> the Moruya Show Society) to discuss the issues of the future development of<br />
the Moruya Showground. In particular the merits of extending the basketball stadium <strong>and</strong>/or<br />
constructing a Clear Span Pavilion was a central issue that the Working Group was aiming to<br />
resolve.<br />
November 2002 – Working Group’s first meeting <strong>and</strong> application for $12,500 in grant<br />
funding sought from the Department of L<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> Water Conservation Public Reserves<br />
Management Fund (Showgrounds) to complete a Conservation Management Plan for the<br />
Moruya Showground precinct.<br />
December 2002 – Application for grant funding from the Department of L<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> Water<br />
Conservation to complete a Conservation Management Plan for the Moruya Showground<br />
precinct was unsuccessful.<br />
May 2003 – Application for grant funding from the Department of L<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> Water<br />
Conservation was reconsidered <strong>and</strong> Council was offered $4,000 in grant funding <strong>and</strong> $8,000<br />
in loan funding (total $12,000) from the Department of L<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> Water Conservation.<br />
August 2003 – Department of L<strong>and</strong>s requested to review their offer.<br />
June 2003 – Council was advised that the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s offer had been resubmitted to<br />
the Public Reserves Management Fund (Showgrounds). Department of L<strong>and</strong>s staff sought<br />
support to increase the grant funding from $4,000 to $6,000 with an additional $6,000 offered<br />
in loan funds. The offer of $6,000 in loan funds could alternatively be matched by an equal<br />
contribution from Council.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 65<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/128 MORUYA GOLF COURSE & SHOWGROUND DRAFT PLAN<br />
OF MANAGEMENT 95.9434; 95.9434.P<br />
February 2004 – Council resolved to “provide a matching contribution of $6,000 (in lieu of<br />
accepting a $6,000 loan) for the completion of a Conservation Management Plan for the<br />
Moruya Showground precinct, pending this revised offer being endorsed by the Minister for<br />
Natural Resources (L<strong>and</strong>s)”.<br />
June 2004 – Council advised by the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s that a grant of $6,000 for the<br />
Conservation Management Plan was available subject to Council contributing the balance of<br />
funds to complete the project.<br />
July 2004 – Council accepted the grant of $6,000 from the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s for the<br />
development of a Conservation Management Plan <strong>and</strong> confirms their previous resolution to<br />
match the grant funding with an additional $6,000.<br />
August 2004 – Expressions of Interest sought from appropriately qualified consultants to<br />
prepare a Conservation Management Plan for the Moruya Showground precinct.<br />
September 2004 – John Armes <strong>and</strong> Associates (Architects <strong>and</strong> Heritage Consultants) were<br />
selected to complete the Conservation Management Plan for the Moruya Showground<br />
precinct.<br />
January 2005 – Preliminary draft of the Conservation Management Plan for the Moruya<br />
Showground precinct given to the Working Group members for their comment.<br />
February 2005 - Preliminary draft of the Conservation Management Plan for the Moruya<br />
Showground precinct discussed at a meeting of the Moruya Showground Working Group with<br />
John Armes.<br />
March 2005 – Moruya Showground Conservation Management Plan adopted by Council for<br />
exhibition.<br />
May 2005 – Moruya Showground Conservation Management Plan exhibition completed <strong>and</strong><br />
appropriate amendments made to the plan in response to submissions received. The<br />
Conservation Management Plan states that the Moruya Showground precinct, setting <strong>and</strong><br />
some buildings <strong>and</strong> spaces are important values for:<br />
• associations with the consolidation of Moruya as a township;<br />
• the development of recreational activity in Moruya;<br />
• its reflection of pastoral <strong>and</strong> agricultural aspects of the <strong>Shire</strong>’s life;<br />
• supporting the activities of a number of community organisations;<br />
• its status as a cultural asset of the <strong>Shire</strong>;<br />
• its aesthetic features, notably some buildings, spaces, <strong>and</strong> relationship to the structure of<br />
the town;<br />
• a venue for sporting <strong>and</strong> Agricultural Show for a variety of users <strong>and</strong> supporters.<br />
The Conservation Management Plan found that although the basketball stadium contributes to<br />
the vitality of the precinct, proposals to exp<strong>and</strong> the facility would have an adverse effect on<br />
the heritage character of the showground.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 66<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/128 MORUYA GOLF COURSE & SHOWGROUND DRAFT PLAN<br />
OF MANAGEMENT 95.9434; 95.9434.P<br />
February 20<strong>06</strong> – Second Draft Plan of Management adopted at Council’s <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
<strong>Facilities</strong> Committee Meeting for public exhibition <strong>and</strong> comment with the support of the<br />
Department of L<strong>and</strong>s who made comment on the draft. The Conservation Management Plan<br />
for the Moruya Showground precinct was also adopted at this meeting.<br />
ISSUES<br />
Legal<br />
Council has prepared this draft Plan of Management at the request of the Department of<br />
L<strong>and</strong>s. The l<strong>and</strong> must be developed in accordance with the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1993 <strong>and</strong><br />
activities on the reserves must be consistent with the Crown Reserve Purpose of “Public<br />
Recreation”.<br />
Once endorsed by Council, the draft Plan of Management must be adopted by the Minister for<br />
L<strong>and</strong>s. The Department of L<strong>and</strong>s may request that changes be made to the plan to facilitate<br />
final adoption.<br />
Policy<br />
The Draft Plan of Management is consistent with:<br />
• Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989<br />
• Food <strong>and</strong> Beverage Outlets on Crown Reserves Policy 1996<br />
• The NSW Coastal Policy<br />
• NSW Government Floodplain Management Manual 2004<br />
• Moruya River Floodplain Risk Management Plan 2004<br />
• <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Local Environmental Plan<br />
Asset<br />
The Moruya Golf Course <strong>and</strong> Showground provides recreational, social <strong>and</strong> cultural benefits<br />
to the Moruya community <strong>and</strong> visitors to the area. These assets are well known <strong>and</strong> highly<br />
valued by the community.<br />
Community Consultation<br />
During the development of the draft Plan of Management there has been extensive<br />
consultation with the relevant stakeholders <strong>and</strong> the wider community. In particular, the<br />
Moruya Showground Management Committee <strong>and</strong> the user groups have provided valuable<br />
contributions <strong>and</strong> feedback into the draft Plan of Management.<br />
The first draft Plan of Management was publicly exhibited <strong>and</strong> submissions received during<br />
2002.<br />
The second draft Plan of Management was publicly exhibited <strong>and</strong> submissions received from<br />
1 March 20<strong>06</strong> to 8 June 20<strong>06</strong>. Copies of the plan were sent to the following groups for<br />
comment:<br />
• Council’s Heritage Advisory Committee<br />
• NSW Heritage Office<br />
• NSW Department of Natural Resources
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 67<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/128 MORUYA GOLF COURSE & SHOWGROUND DRAFT PLAN<br />
OF MANAGEMENT 95.9434; 95.9434.P<br />
• NSW Department of Planning<br />
• Moruya Showground Management Committee<br />
• Moruya Basketball Stadium & Community Hall Management Committee<br />
• Council’s Action Plan Access Committee<br />
In addition, the draft plan was available on Council’s website, Council’s libraries, at the<br />
Moruya Administration Office <strong>and</strong> at the Department of L<strong>and</strong>’s Nowra Administration<br />
Office. An advertisement advising that the draft plan was open for comment was placed on<br />
Council’s Noticeboard in the local papers.<br />
Six submissions were received during this time <strong>and</strong> a summary of the submissions is attached.<br />
This summary documents the submission <strong>and</strong> the changes that have been made to the draft<br />
Plan of Management in response to the issues raised in the submission. The six submissions<br />
were received from:<br />
• Heritage Council of NSW<br />
• <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District Show Society (2)<br />
• APAC Committee<br />
• Moruya Tuross JRLFC<br />
• Department of Natural Resources<br />
These submissions will also be considered by the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s prior to final adoption<br />
of the Plan of Management by the Minister for L<strong>and</strong>s.<br />
Strategic Links<br />
The draft Plan of Management reflects the recommendations of the Moruya Showground<br />
Conservation Management Plan.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
The draft Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management has been completed for<br />
Council’s endorsement <strong>and</strong> presentation to the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s for final adoption. The<br />
Department of L<strong>and</strong>s may require that changes be made to the Plan of Management prior to<br />
final adoption.
GOVERNANCE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 68<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/128 MORUYA GOLF COURSE & SHOWGROUND DRAFT PLAN<br />
OF MANAGEMENT 95.9434; 95.9434.P<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
That under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee resolve<br />
the following:<br />
THAT:<br />
1. Council endorse the Moruya Golf Course <strong>and</strong> Showground Plan of Management located<br />
on Crown L<strong>and</strong> Reserves D580020 <strong>and</strong> 96313 for Public Recreation.<br />
2. Council forward the endorsed Moruya Golf Course <strong>and</strong> Showground Plan of Management<br />
to the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s for final adoption.<br />
ANDREW PARKINSON<br />
EXECUTIVE MANAGER<br />
STRATEGIC PLANNING AND DESIGN<br />
Attach
PLAN OF MANAGEMENT<br />
Moruya Golf Course & Showground Reserves<br />
Crown Reserve D580020 for Public Recreation<br />
Crown Reserve 96313 for Public Recreation<br />
Submitted to Council’s <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee Meeting <strong>14</strong> November 20<strong>06</strong>
Table of Amendments:<br />
This Plan of Management was prepared by<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council at the request of the<br />
Department of L<strong>and</strong>s.<br />
ESC Plan of Management No. <strong>11</strong><br />
This Plan of Management details the<br />
Moruya Golf Course <strong>and</strong> Showground Reserves.<br />
This l<strong>and</strong> is identified as Crown Reserve 96313 for public recreation<br />
<strong>and</strong> Crown Dedication 580020 for public recreation.<br />
Any requests for further information or questions regarding this<br />
Plan of Management can be addressed to:<br />
Plans of Management Officer<br />
(Reference 95.9434)<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council<br />
PO Box 99<br />
MORUYA NSW 2537<br />
Phone: (02) 4474 1000<br />
Email: council@eurocoast.nsw.gov.au<br />
No Date Endorsed by Council Exhibition Period Adopted by Minister for<br />
L<strong>and</strong>s<br />
Details of Amendments
Table of Contents<br />
1.0 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................................................................. 6<br />
1.1 Executive Summary.............................................................................................................................................................. 6<br />
1.2 About The Plan of Management........................................................................................................................................... 7<br />
1.3 Community Consultation ...................................................................................................................................................... 7<br />
2.0 LEGISLATION AND POLICIES .......................................................................................................................................................... 8<br />
2.1 The Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989.................................................................................................................................................. 8<br />
2.2 Food <strong>and</strong> Beverage Outlets on Crown Reserves Policy 2004 ............................................................................................. 9<br />
2.3 The NSW Coastal Policy 1997 ............................................................................................................................................. 9<br />
2.4 NSW Government Floodplain Management Manual 2001 ................................................................................................... 9<br />
2.5 Moruya River Floodplain Risk Management Plan 2004 ..................................................................................................... 10<br />
2.6 <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Council Urban Local Environmental Plan 1999.............................................................................................. <strong>11</strong><br />
2.6.1 6a1 Public Open Space Zone ................................................................................................................................ <strong>11</strong><br />
2.6.2 5c Main Road Zone................................................................................................................................................ <strong>11</strong><br />
2.6.3 Heritage Items........................................................................................................................................................ <strong>11</strong><br />
2.7 Heritage Act 1977............................................................................................................................................................... 12<br />
3.0 RESERVE ANAYLSIS, USE AND MANAGEMENT ......................................................................................................................... 13<br />
3.1 Site Description .................................................................................................................................................................. 13<br />
3.2 Natural Environment........................................................................................................................................................... <strong>14</strong><br />
3.3 Existing Use <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong>.................................................................................................................................................. 15<br />
3.3.1 Moruya Golf Club Ltd – Golf Course...................................................................................................................... 15<br />
3.3.2 Moruya Showground Precinct................................................................................................................................ 16<br />
3.3.1 Existing Conditions Plan - Moruya Showground <strong>and</strong> Golf Course........................................................................ 19<br />
3.3.2 Existing Conditions Plan - Moruya Showground ................................................................................................... 20<br />
3.4 Heritage.............................................................................................................................................................................. 21<br />
3.4.1 History of the Moruya Showground........................................................................................................................ 21<br />
3.4.2 Heritage Listing ...................................................................................................................................................... 22<br />
3.4.3 Conservation Management Plan............................................................................................................................ 23<br />
3.4.3.1 Background to the development of the Conservation Management Plan .....................................................................23<br />
3.4.3.2 Recommendations of the Conservation Management Plan ..........................................................................................24<br />
3.4.3.3 Recommendations of the Conservation Management Plan – Non Heritage Issues......................................................30<br />
3.5 Leases & Licences ............................................................................................................................................................. 31<br />
3.5.1 Requirements of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act .................................................................................................................. 31<br />
3.5.2 Existing Leases & Licences.................................................................................................................................... 32<br />
3.5.3 Moruya Golf Course Lease .................................................................................................................................... 32<br />
2.5.5 Residential Tenancy Agreement – Moruya Showground Caretakers Cottage.......................................................33<br />
3.6 Management Committees .................................................................................................................................................. 34<br />
3.6.1 Moruya Showground Management Committee...................................................................................................... 34<br />
3.6.2 Moruya Basketball Stadium Management Committee ........................................................................................... 34<br />
3.7 Sports Liaison Committee .................................................................................................................................................. 34<br />
3.8 Moruya Golf Course – Pressures on Use........................................................................................................................... 35<br />
3.8.1 Access through Golf Course .................................................................................................................................. 35<br />
3.8.2 Access through the Showground & Golf Course.................................................................................................... 35<br />
3.8.3 Parking................................................................................................................................................................... 36<br />
3.9 Moruya Showground Precinct – Pressures on Use............................................................................................................ 37<br />
3.10 Native Title.......................................................................................................................................................................... 37<br />
August 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 3 of 57
3.<strong>11</strong> Finance............................................................................................................................................................................... 38<br />
3.<strong>11</strong>.1 Operating Costs – Moruya Showground Precinct.................................................................................................. 38<br />
3.<strong>11</strong>.2 Sources of Funds................................................................................................................................................... 38<br />
3.<strong>11</strong>.3 Capital Improvements ............................................................................................................................................ 39<br />
4.0 BASIS FOR MANAGEMENT ............................................................................................................................................................ 40<br />
4.1 Values................................................................................................................................................................................. 40<br />
4.2 Role of the Moruya Golf Course & Showground Reserves ................................................................................................ 41<br />
4.3 Objectives for Management................................................................................................................................................ 41<br />
5.0 STRATEGIC ACTIONS ..................................................................................................................................................................... 42<br />
5.1 Strategic Plan ..................................................................................................................................................................... 42<br />
5.2 Monitoring Strategic Performance ...................................................................................................................................... 42<br />
6.0 ACTION PLAN................................................................................................................................................................................... 43<br />
6.1 Access – Pedestrian........................................................................................................................................................... 44<br />
6.2 Access – Vehicular ............................................................................................................................................................. 44<br />
6.3 Conservation Management Plan ........................................................................................................................................ 45<br />
6.4 Environmental Management............................................................................................................................................... 50<br />
6.5 Management....................................................................................................................................................................... 50<br />
6.6 Recreation – Ack Weyman Oval......................................................................................................................................... 51<br />
6.7 Recreation – Basketball Stadium/Community Centre ........................................................................................................ 51<br />
6.8 Recreation – Camping........................................................................................................................................................ 51<br />
6.9 Recreation – Golf................................................................................................................................................................ 51<br />
6.10 Recreation – Showground Arena ....................................................................................................................................... 51<br />
6.<strong>11</strong> Services.............................................................................................................................................................................. 51<br />
6.12 Signage .............................................................................................................................................................................. 51<br />
6.13 Weed Management ............................................................................................................................................................ 52<br />
7.0 MANAGEMENT ACTIONS – The L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan ......................................................................................................... 53<br />
7.1 The L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan – Overview ......................................................................................................................... 53<br />
7.2 L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan – Moruya Showground <strong>and</strong> Golf Course ................................................................................... 54<br />
7.3 L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan – Moruya Showground .............................................................................................................. 55<br />
Appendix A: Stakeholders <strong>and</strong> User Groups.............................................................................................................................................. 56<br />
Appendix B: References ............................................................................................................................................................................... 56<br />
Appendix C: Equal Access Shelter concept drawing ................................................................................................................................. 57<br />
August 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 4 of 57
List of Photos<br />
Photo 1: Aerial view of Study Area - 1996 ......................................................................................................................................................................................6<br />
Photo 2: View down the 1st Fairway ..............................................................................................................................................................................................15<br />
Photo 3: 9th <strong>and</strong> 18th Greens .........................................................................................................................................................................................................15<br />
Photo 4: Golf Course 16th Green...................................................................................................................................................................................................15<br />
Photo 5: Golfer walking through Showground area from the 12th Green to 13th Tee....................................................................................................................15<br />
Photo 6: Aerial Photograph of the Moruya Showground Precinct during the 1988 <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District Show.............................................................................16<br />
Photo 7: Ticket Box 1/Entrance – December 2005.......................................................................................................................................................................17<br />
Photo 8: Ticket Box 2 – December 2005 .......................................................................................................................................................................................17<br />
Photo 9: Ack Weyman Oval scoreboard .......................................................................................................................................................................................17<br />
Photo 10: Moruya Basketball Stadium / Community Hall..............................................................................................................................................................17<br />
Photo <strong>11</strong>: Caretaker’s residence - 2000........................................................................................................................................................................................17<br />
Photo 12: Caretaker’s residence - 2002........................................................................................................................................................................................17<br />
Photo 13: Old Secretary’s Office - 2005........................................................................................................................................................................................17<br />
Photo <strong>14</strong>: <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District Show 2003 – Horses in temporary yards .....................................................................................................................................17<br />
Photo 13: Moruya Showground Exhibits Pavilion (pre 2005 extensions)......................................................................................................................................22<br />
Photo <strong>14</strong>: Moruya Showground Exhibits Pavilion .........................................................................................................................................................................22<br />
Photo 17: Moruya Showground Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>.................................................................................................................................................................................22<br />
Photo 18: Moruya Showground Poultry Pavilion...........................................................................................................................................................................22<br />
Photo 19: Bucking Horse at the 2002 Moruya Rodeo...................................................................................................................................................................24<br />
Photo 20: Bucking Bull at the 2002 Moruya Rodeo ......................................................................................................................................................................24<br />
Photo 21: Rides at the 2003 <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District Show ...............................................................................................................................................................24<br />
Photo 22: Equestrian Events at the 2003 <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District Show ...........................................................................................................................................24<br />
Photo 23: Eucalypts dominate the south eastern end of the Showground Precinct .....................................................................................................................27<br />
Photo 24: Pink Gates at the northern end of the north-south axis ................................................................................................................................................27<br />
Photo 25: Female Public Toilets – December 2005......................................................................................................................................................................28<br />
Photo 26: Male Public Toilets – December 2005 ..........................................................................................................................................................................28<br />
Photo 27: Western Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> additions –Changerooms............................................................................................................................................................28<br />
Photo 28: Western Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> additions – Male & Female Toilets ..............................................................................................................................................28<br />
Photo 29: Bar/Canteen – December 2005 ....................................................................................................................................................................................28<br />
Photo 30: Secretary’s Office - December 2005..............................................................................................................................................................................28<br />
Photo 31: Horse Stables – December 2005..................................................................................................................................................................................29<br />
Photo 32: Horse Stables – December 2005...................................................................................................................................................................................29<br />
Photo 33: Golf Club Maintenance Compound (east) – December 2005.......................................................................................................................................29<br />
Photo 34: Golf Club Maintenance Compound (west) – November 2001 .......................................................................................................................................29<br />
Photo 35: Pedestrian refuge Moruya Golf Course ........................................................................................................................................................................36<br />
August 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 5 of 57
1.0 INTRODUCTION<br />
1.1 Executive Summary<br />
Moruya Golf Course & Showground DRAFT Plan of Management<br />
Located just minutes from the central business district of Moruya, the Moruya Golf Course <strong>and</strong> Showground are well known attractions in the<br />
community. Both destinations host popular recreational, cultural <strong>and</strong> social events that attract local patronage <strong>and</strong> visitors from further afield.<br />
All of the l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management is Crown L<strong>and</strong> included in the Moruya (D580020) Showground Reserve Trust <strong>and</strong> the<br />
Moruya (R96313) Reserve Trust.<br />
This Plan of Management illustrates the diversity of existing uses <strong>and</strong> potential future uses of the Moruya Golf Course <strong>and</strong> the Moruya<br />
Showground. The Moruya Golf Course is a popular 18 hole course with an open parkl<strong>and</strong> character <strong>and</strong> the Moruya Showground features<br />
heritage listed buildings in an open recreational environment. The showground is an excellent venue for popular regional events such as the<br />
Moruya Rodeo <strong>and</strong> the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District Show.<br />
In order to continue to provide an attractive destination there are many issues that need to be addressed. For example, existing facilities<br />
need to be upgraded, shade amenity in the showground precinct needs to be improved <strong>and</strong> pedestrian <strong>and</strong> vehicular movement around the<br />
reserve made easier.<br />
This Plan of Management identifies the main opportunities <strong>and</strong> constraints that need to be addressed. Public consultation has been<br />
instrumental in identifying the current issues <strong>and</strong> the present <strong>and</strong> future needs of the various user groups of the reserves. The Plan of<br />
Management discusses the issues <strong>and</strong> authorises, among many things, measures that can be taken to ensure the appropriate future<br />
development of the reserves. The L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan illustrates these developments <strong>and</strong> specific information addressing the<br />
management issues are addressed in the Action Plans.<br />
Photo 1: Aerial view of Study Area - 1996<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 6 of 57
1.2 About The Plan of Management<br />
This Plan of Management has been prepared by <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council with the assistance of the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s (owner of the<br />
l<strong>and</strong>). It is a statutory document under the provisions of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act, 1989. The final plan requires adoption by the Minister for<br />
L<strong>and</strong>s, as a statutory Plan of Management under section 1<strong>14</strong> of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act, 1989. Once a Plan of Management is adopted for a<br />
Crown Reserve no operations may be undertaken on or in relation to the reserve unless they are in accordance with the plan.<br />
The main function of the plan will be to provide the Trust Manager (<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council), the l<strong>and</strong> owner (Department of L<strong>and</strong>s) <strong>and</strong> all<br />
users of the reserves with a working document that sets out a statutory framework for the future use, development <strong>and</strong> management of the<br />
area over the next 10-15 years. The strategies <strong>and</strong> actions outlined in the plan will be subject to a program of ongoing review <strong>and</strong> monitoring.<br />
Any proposed significant changes to the adopted Plan of Management will require the approval of the Minister for L<strong>and</strong>s.<br />
This plan provides a strategy for the management of the area that meets community expectations, complies with current government policy,<br />
legislation <strong>and</strong> statutory planning requirements <strong>and</strong> will enable the area to be utilised sustainably for the benefit of all users. The principles of<br />
Crown l<strong>and</strong> management as set down by the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act, 1989 <strong>and</strong> the Moruya Showground Precinct Conservation Management Plan<br />
provided a basis for making decisions about the future use <strong>and</strong> management of this area.<br />
1.3 Community Consultation<br />
A draft Plan of Management was adopted for exhibition by Council at its <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee meeting in July 2002. The draft was<br />
also endorsed by the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s for exhibition.<br />
Division 6 of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act specifies that Draft Plans of Management must be exhibited for a minimum of 28 days <strong>and</strong> any person may<br />
make representations concerning the plan to the Minister. Once a Plan of Management is adopted for a Crown Reserve no operations may<br />
be undertaken on or in relation to the reserve unless they are in accordance with the intent of the plan.<br />
The initial draft was exhibited for public comment by both Council <strong>and</strong> the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s under the provisions of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act,<br />
1989. This draft was exhibited from Wednesday 17 July 2002 to Friday 16 August 2002 <strong>and</strong> submissions were accepted until Friday 30<br />
August 2002.<br />
The main features of the draft Plan of Management were:<br />
• Possible developments including: a commentator’s box, clear span pavilion, outdoor basketball practice area, upgrading the pavilion, an<br />
equal access viewing shelter, l<strong>and</strong>scape improvements <strong>and</strong> other long term upgrades for the showground precinct.<br />
• The relocation of the Golf Course Maintenance Compound from the Showground precinct to an area within the Golf Course lease area<br />
by 2010. This will create more area for additional facilities in the showground precinct.<br />
• Possible extension of the Golf Club’s carparking area to the south of the existing Club House.<br />
• Pedestrian refuges along the pathway from the Showground through the golf course to Murray Street.<br />
• Fencing the boundaries of the golf course along Evans & Albert Street.<br />
During the submission period 66 written submissions were received. All comments were considered jointly by <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council <strong>and</strong><br />
the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s, <strong>and</strong> where appropriate, the plan has been amended. The main concern regarding the draft Plan of Management<br />
was the inclusion of a large Clear Span Pavilion <strong>and</strong> the exclusion of an extension to the basketball stadium to accommodate another<br />
basketball court.<br />
The proponents of the Clear Span Pavilion withdrew their request for this structure <strong>and</strong> the Moruya Amateur Basketball Association submitted<br />
that a 2 court basketball facility be provided at the Showground. The proposed development of the showground precinct for this activity raised<br />
concerns in regard to the heritage value of the precinct <strong>and</strong> the impacts future built development may have on the showground. In order to<br />
resolve this development issue, a specialist heritage consultant (John Armes & Associates) was engaged to complete a Conservation<br />
Management Plan for the Moruya Showground Precinct.<br />
The Conservation Management Plan found that although the basketball stadium <strong>and</strong> community centre contribute to the vitality of the precinct,<br />
proposals to exp<strong>and</strong> the facility would have an adverse effect on the heritage character of the showground. For more information on the<br />
Conservation Management Plan refer to Section 2.3 at page 15.<br />
The Plan of Management was amended such that the Clear Span Pavilion was removed from the L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan. The plan was<br />
also amended to include the recommendations of the Conservation Management Plan.<br />
August 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 7 of 57
2.0 LEGISLATION AND POLICIES<br />
2.1 The Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989<br />
This Plan of Management is prepared in accordance the provisions of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act (in particular Division 6) which governs the<br />
management <strong>and</strong> use of Crown Reserves.<br />
Crown l<strong>and</strong> must be used <strong>and</strong> managed in accordance with the principles of Crown L<strong>and</strong> Management as set out in Section <strong>11</strong> of the Act.<br />
These principles guide the development, use <strong>and</strong> management of Crown L<strong>and</strong>.<br />
Principles of Crown L<strong>and</strong> Management:<br />
(a) that environmental protection principles be observed in relation to the management <strong>and</strong> administration of Crown l<strong>and</strong>,<br />
(b) that the natural resources of Crown l<strong>and</strong> (including water, soil, flora, fauna <strong>and</strong> scenic quality) be conserved wherever possible,<br />
(c) that public use <strong>and</strong> enjoyment of appropriate Crown l<strong>and</strong> be encouraged,<br />
(d) that, where appropriate, multiple use of Crown l<strong>and</strong> be encouraged,<br />
(e) that, where appropriate, Crown l<strong>and</strong> should be used <strong>and</strong> managed in such a way that both the l<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> its resources are<br />
sustained in perpetuity, <strong>and</strong><br />
(f) that Crown l<strong>and</strong> be occupied, used, sold, leased, licensed or otherwise dealt with in the best interests of the State consistent<br />
with the above principles.<br />
Crown l<strong>and</strong> may be reserved or dedicated for a variety of public purposes. There are currently 26 different purposes for which Crown l<strong>and</strong><br />
can be reserved. Uses <strong>and</strong> activities on l<strong>and</strong> reserved for pubic purposes are, firstly, broadly defined by the public purpose of the reservation,<br />
in conjunction with any conditions <strong>and</strong> provisions within the specific zoning in the local council’s local environmental plan. The l<strong>and</strong> uses are<br />
then more specifically defined by either a statutory mechanism (a Plan of Management), contractual agreement (lease or licences), or a<br />
combination of both.<br />
In addition, case law judgements influence the policy <strong>and</strong> practice of the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> the Trust Managers. The body of case law<br />
which helps define acceptable uses <strong>and</strong> activities on public recreation reserves provides the following guidance:<br />
• Improvements <strong>and</strong> developments to l<strong>and</strong> which is reserved or dedicated are confined to those which support, or are ancillary to, the<br />
public purpose of the reservation;<br />
• L<strong>and</strong> reserved or dedicated for public recreation must be open to the public generally as a right. The public may only be restricted<br />
from access to parts of the reserve <strong>and</strong> buildings thereon, if it is necessary for the public’s enjoyment of the reserve to be excluded,<br />
eg. a workshop, equipment storage or operational facilities;<br />
• Right of access does not mean entirely free access. Reasonable entry fees <strong>and</strong> charges may be imposed as well as other legal<br />
constraints to entry, such as those that relate to health <strong>and</strong> safety;<br />
• Use of the reserve must be consistent with the public purposes for which the l<strong>and</strong> is dedicated or reserved. This includes uses<br />
ancillary or supportive of the purpose, such as a kiosk on l<strong>and</strong> dedicated for public recreation; <strong>and</strong><br />
• A lease or licence must be consistent with the reason or purpose of the l<strong>and</strong>’s reservation or dedication.<br />
In order to change a reservation, a l<strong>and</strong> assessment is required under the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989. The Minister can waive an assessment if it<br />
is in the public interest, <strong>and</strong> if it is consistent with the principles of Crown L<strong>and</strong> management.<br />
In July 2005 the NSW Parliament passed legislation amending to Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989 to give the Minister power to authorise additional<br />
uses of Crown reserves providing such uses are compatible with the existing gazetted public purpose, consistent with the principles of Clown<br />
l<strong>and</strong> management <strong>and</strong> determined to be in the public interest.<br />
August 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 8 of 57
2.2 Food <strong>and</strong> Beverage Outlets on Crown Reserves Policy 2004<br />
This policy provides guidance for assessing food <strong>and</strong> beverage outlets which may be acceptable <strong>and</strong> those which may not be acceptable on<br />
Crown reserves. In determining whether a proposal is appropriate the following criteria should be applied:<br />
• The facility should enhance the public use of the reserve <strong>and</strong> not become the main focus of the reserve;<br />
• The integrity of the reserve in terms of its public purpose <strong>and</strong> environmental qualities should be preserved;<br />
The public’s right of access to the reserve should be preserved.<br />
2.3 The NSW Coastal Policy 1997<br />
The Moruya Golf Course <strong>and</strong> Showground reserves are within the coastal zone as described by the Coastal Protection Act 1979:<br />
S 4A (c) the boundary is to follow the length of any coastal river inl<strong>and</strong> generally at a distance of one kilometre from each bank of the river:<br />
(i) to one kilometre beyond the limit of any recognised mangroves on or associated with the river, or<br />
(ii) if there are no such recognised mangroves—to one kilometre beyond the tidal limit of the river,<br />
The 1997 NSW Coastal Policy responds to the fundamental challenge to provide for population growth <strong>and</strong> economic development without<br />
putting the natural, cultural <strong>and</strong> heritage values of the coastal environment at risk. To achieve this, the Policy has a strong integrating<br />
philosophy based on the principles of ecologically sustainable development (ESD).<br />
The nine goals of the Coastal Policy are:<br />
1. Protecting, rehabilitating <strong>and</strong> improving the natural environment of the coastal zone.<br />
2. Recognising <strong>and</strong> accommodating the natural processes of the coastal zone.<br />
3. Protecting <strong>and</strong> enhancing the aesthetic qualities of the coastal zone.<br />
4. Protecting <strong>and</strong> conserving the cultural heritage of the coastal zone.<br />
5. Providing for ecologically sustainable development <strong>and</strong> use of resources.<br />
6. Providing for ecologically sustainable human settlement in the coastal zone.<br />
7. Providing for appropriate public access <strong>and</strong> use.<br />
8. Providing information to enable effective management of the coastal zone.<br />
9. Providing for integrated planning <strong>and</strong> management of the coastal zone.<br />
2.4 NSW Government Floodplain Management Manual 2001<br />
Some of the l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management is subject to flooding. The NSW Government Floodplain Management Manual 2001<br />
must be complied with by all agencies dealing with the management of flood risk as it relates to use <strong>and</strong> development of the floodplain. It<br />
incorporates the Flood Prone L<strong>and</strong> Policy.<br />
The primary objective of the NSW Government Floodplain Management Manual is:<br />
“To reduce the impact of flooding <strong>and</strong> flood liability on individual owners <strong>and</strong> occupiers of flood prone property, <strong>and</strong> to reduce<br />
private <strong>and</strong> public losses resulting from floods, utilising ecologically positive methods where possible”.<br />
The average of tangible (financial) flood damage in New South Wales is estimated to be more than $<strong>11</strong>0 million dollars per year. There other<br />
intangible damages including increased levels of emotional stress <strong>and</strong> mental <strong>and</strong> physical illness caused be a flood episode. A flood is a<br />
traumatic experience for many victims.<br />
The manual provides guidelines for better management of flood prone areas.<br />
August 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 9 of 57
2.5 Moruya River Floodplain Risk Management Plan 2004<br />
The Moruya River Floodplain Risk Management study was carried out for the Floodplain Management Committee established by <strong>Eurobodalla</strong><br />
<strong>Shire</strong> Council. The objectives of the floodplain management study are:<br />
• to define the nature of the flood hazard;<br />
• to examine the impact of flooding, in physical, economic <strong>and</strong> social terms on the existing community <strong>and</strong> the potential for future<br />
development;<br />
• to develop structural <strong>and</strong> non-structural measures for mitigating the effects of the flood hazard;<br />
• to review council’s current flood policy provisions in light of the hazard, the risk <strong>and</strong> the means of mitigating the risk; <strong>and</strong><br />
• to discuss the environmental <strong>and</strong> social impacts of proposed mitigation works.<br />
The highest recorded flood, which occurred in 1925, is believed to have reached a level of approximately 5.4m AHD at Moruya Bridge. This<br />
flood was followed by two severe floods in 1963 <strong>and</strong> 1975. Since then, relatively minor floods have occurred in the Moruya River, <strong>and</strong><br />
although primarily affecting agricultural l<strong>and</strong>, these floods have had an impact on the entire community.<br />
The Moruya River Floodplain Management Risk Plan was adopted by Council on 23 November 2004. This Plan includes the Moruya River<br />
Floodplain Development Control Plan (DCP) which defines the flood planning levels <strong>and</strong> controls development within the Moruya River<br />
Floodplain.<br />
During periods of high rainfall the Golf Course may be required to close due to inundation. This occurs approximately two to three times per<br />
annum. During a sever flood, the Moruya Golf Course <strong>and</strong> Showground reserves would be subject to a high level of hazard. Under extreme<br />
flood conditions, Racecourse Creek flood inundation extends upto 100 metres from the creek channel.<br />
During the early stages of a typical flood, flood waters back up along Ryan’s Creek <strong>and</strong> Racecourse Creek from the river inundating adjacent<br />
l<strong>and</strong>. Flood depths in the Moruya CBD area during a frequent flood event are upto ½ a metre, with velocities up to 0.4 metres/second.<br />
The flooding regime of the Moruya Golf Course Showground is well known throughout the community.<br />
The implication for the flood prone l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management is that future development must comply with the provisions of the<br />
relevant planning controls in place for flood prone areas. In particular, the Moruya River Floodplain DCP severely restricts the development of<br />
any permanent structures within flood prone areas. Any developments proposed on the flood prone l<strong>and</strong> must comply the Moruya River<br />
Floodplain DCP.<br />
August 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 10 of 57
2.6 <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Council Urban Local Environmental Plan 1999<br />
Any l<strong>and</strong> use proposed for any site within this plan of management must be consistent with the zoning that is applied to the l<strong>and</strong> by the<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Council Urban Local Environmental Plan (LEP). The LEP is established under the provisions of the Environmental Planning <strong>and</strong><br />
Assessment Act 1979.<br />
Any l<strong>and</strong> use, building or structure proposed for a site within this plan of management may also require development consent under the<br />
provisions of the LEP unless it is exempt development.<br />
The reserves included in this Plan of Management are zoned as follows:<br />
TABLE A: Zoning<br />
Property<br />
Reserve Name Area Lot & DP Reserve No Address Zoning as at the date of Proposed Future<br />
Identification No<br />
(ha)<br />
adoption of this Plan Zoning<br />
<strong>11</strong>876 Moruya Golf Course & Moruya 36.77 Lot 7035 Dedication Albert St, 6a1 Public Open Space 6a1 Public Open<br />
Showground Reserve<br />
DP 1029448 580020 Moruya<br />
Space<br />
26861 Moruya Golf Course Reserve 1.446 Lot 1 Reserve 96313 Murray St, 5c Main Road* 6a1 Public Open<br />
(previously a closed road)<br />
DP 44297<br />
Moruya<br />
Space<br />
2.6.1 6a1 Public Open Space Zone<br />
The objectives of the 6a1 Public Open Space zone are<br />
(a) to recognise the importance of l<strong>and</strong> in the zone as open space <strong>and</strong> allow a limited range of uses compatible with keeping the l<strong>and</strong><br />
as open space <strong>and</strong> in pubic owner ship, <strong>and</strong><br />
(b) to permit a range of uses, especially recreational uses, where those uses comply with the plan of management for the l<strong>and</strong>, <strong>and</strong><br />
(c) to allow development on foreshores where that development is water-related <strong>and</strong> enhances the recreational use or natural<br />
environment of the foreshore, <strong>and</strong><br />
(d) to reserve privately owned l<strong>and</strong> that is essential for future public open space <strong>and</strong> provide for its acquisition by the Council, <strong>and</strong><br />
(e) to ensure that development in areas of environmental significance does not reduce that significance.<br />
2.6.2 5c Main Road Zone<br />
The area zoned 5c Main Road reflects the previous l<strong>and</strong> use. This Plan of Management recommends that this zoning be reviewed <strong>and</strong><br />
amended to 6a1 at the next amendment of Council’s Urban Local Environmental Plan.<br />
2.6.3 Heritage Items<br />
The Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>, Moruya Exhibits Pavilion <strong>and</strong> the Moruya Showground Precinct have been nominated for inclusion on the NSW State<br />
Heritage Register. The Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> the Moruya Exhibits Pavilion are listed on Council’s LEP as heritage items of state significance. The<br />
Poultry pavilion is under further investigation for possible inclusion in the LEP <strong>and</strong> nomination for inclusion on the NSW State Heritage<br />
Register. The Urban Local Environmental Plan provides specific controls for development that may affect heritage items as follows:<br />
(1) Consent of the Council is required to:<br />
(a) demolish, deface, damage or move a heritage item, or<br />
(b) alter a heritage item by making structural changes to its exterior, or<br />
(c) alter a heritage item by making non-structure changes to the detail, fabric, finish or appearance of its exterior, except<br />
changes resulting from any maintenance necessary for its ongoing protective care which does not adversely affect its<br />
heritage significance, or<br />
(d) move a relic, or excavate l<strong>and</strong> for the purpose of discovering, exposing or moving a relic, or<br />
(e) erect a building on, or subdivide, l<strong>and</strong> on which a heritage item is located.<br />
(2) Development consent is not required by this clause if the Council is of the opinion that the proposed development would not<br />
adversely affect the heritage significance of the heritage item.<br />
(3) In assessing an application for consent required by this clause, the Council must take into account the extent to which the carrying<br />
out of the proposed development would affect the heritage significance of the heritage item.<br />
August 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page <strong>11</strong> of 57
2.7 Heritage Act 1977<br />
Legal protection for heritage items in New South Wales generally comes from the Heritage Act 1977. Items included in the State Heritage<br />
Register in particular are protected under this legislation.<br />
The Stage Heritage Register is a is a list of places <strong>and</strong> objects of particular importance to the people of NSW. There register lists a diverse<br />
range of over 1,500 items, in both private <strong>and</strong> public ownership. It includes a diverse range of places, buildings <strong>and</strong> objects including:<br />
Aboriginal places buildings, objects, monuments, gardens, natural l<strong>and</strong>scapes, archaeological sites, shipwrecks, relics, streets, industrial<br />
structures, public buildings, shops, factories, houses, religious buildings, schools, conservation precincts, jetties, bridges <strong>and</strong> movable items<br />
such as church organs <strong>and</strong> ferries. To be listed, an item must be significant for the whole of NSW.<br />
A place or object is State significant if it is important for the whole of NSW. Heritage items may be valued by particular groups in the<br />
community, such as Aboriginal communities, religious groups or people with a common ethnic background.<br />
Once an item is included on the State Heritage Register it is deemed to be of particular importance to the people of NSW <strong>and</strong> enriches our<br />
underst<strong>and</strong>ing of our history <strong>and</strong> identity.<br />
The Moruya Showground Precinct was nominated for inclusion on the NSW State Heritage Register on 29 April 2003. If it is included on the<br />
NSW State Heritage Register it will be legally protected as a heritage item under the NSW Heritage Act <strong>and</strong> any major changes will require<br />
approval from the Heritage Council of NSW.<br />
August 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 12 of 57
3.0 RESERVE ANAYLSIS, USE AND MANAGEMENT<br />
3.1 Site Description<br />
All l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management is Crown L<strong>and</strong> in the Moruya (D580020) Showground Reserve Trust <strong>and</strong> the Moruya (R96313)<br />
Reserve Trust. Bounded by Albert Street in the south, the Princes Highway in the east, Evans Street in the west <strong>and</strong> Murray Street in the<br />
north, the reserves comprise over 38 hectares <strong>and</strong> are located within the Moruya Township, approximately eight kilometres inl<strong>and</strong> from the<br />
coast, as shown on Plan 1 below. The Moruya Golf Course however, also extends over adjacent freehold l<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> other Crown l<strong>and</strong> that is<br />
leased directly from the Crown, as shown on Plan 1 below <strong>and</strong> is illustrated in Photo 1 on page 5.<br />
The Moruya Showground Reserve Trust was originally dedicated for Public Recreation on 2 October 1866. <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council was<br />
appointed Trustee on October 2 1942 <strong>and</strong> now manages the Moruya Showground Reserve Trust. <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council is also the Trust<br />
Manager for the Moruya (R96313) Reserve Trust which was created on 16 September 1994.<br />
Until 1985 the area also contained the Moruya Racecourse which has since been relocated to North Head, Moruya. The Moruya Showground<br />
is the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> region’s only agricultural showground <strong>and</strong> the use of the area has strong links to the <strong>Shire</strong>’s early settlement history <strong>and</strong><br />
heritage. The area is a visually <strong>and</strong> physically dominant feature of the area. The showground precinct includes sporting fields, pavilion <strong>and</strong><br />
an indoor basketball stadium.<br />
Plan 1: Planning Area Location Map. The shaded area illustrates the l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan of Management.<br />
(refer to following plans for more detail)<br />
August 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 13 of 57
The Moruya Golf Course was developed on the reserve initially as a nine hole course in the period from 19<strong>14</strong> – 1925. The course was<br />
exp<strong>and</strong>ed to an 18 hole course with the extension officially opened on 1 October 1988. Part of the expansion is located on freehold l<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
part on l<strong>and</strong> that was previously Crown Road. The freehold l<strong>and</strong> is owned by the Moruya Golf Club. This l<strong>and</strong> is not considered in this Plan<br />
of Management. The Crown Roads became Crown Reserve 96313. All the Crown L<strong>and</strong> is dedicated for Public Recreation.<br />
The Moruya Golf Clubhouse occupies a Special Lease to the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s on Lot 308 DP 752<strong>14</strong>1 which is not directly part of this<br />
Plan of Management.<br />
The reserve is also used regularly by the public for pedestrian access from the southern parts of town including the Moruya High School to the<br />
town centre. The closed road reserve extending Murray Street to the highway is also maintained for non vehicle public through access under<br />
the lease conditions. Table B, below, contains property details for the l<strong>and</strong> included in this Plan.<br />
TABLE B: SUMMARY OF LAND INCLUDED IN THIS PLAN OF MANAGEMENT<br />
Property<br />
Reserve Name Area Lot & DP Crown Reserve Reserve No Address Zoning as at the date of<br />
Identification No<br />
(ha)<br />
Purpose<br />
adoption of this Plan<br />
<strong>11</strong>876 Moruya Golf Course & Moruya 36.77 Lot 7035 Public Recreation Dedication Albert St, 6a1 Public Open Space<br />
Showground Reserve<br />
DP 1029448<br />
580020 Moruya<br />
26861 Moruya Golf Course Reserve 1.446 Lot 1 Public Recreation Reserve 96313 Murray St, 5c Main Road*<br />
(previously a closed road)<br />
DP 44297<br />
Moruya<br />
* This Plan of Management recommends that Lot 1 of DP 44297 be re-zoned to 6a1 Public Open Space.<br />
3.2 Natural Environment<br />
The site is predominantly flat l<strong>and</strong> with a low rise to the southeast <strong>and</strong> again in the northwest of the reserve. The area was extensively cleared<br />
of native vegetation earlier this century. However, a number of mature eucalypts remain scattered throughout. Most of the existing vegetation<br />
on the golf course consists of l<strong>and</strong>scape planting for the extended golf course of approximately ten years growth. These native plantings are<br />
now providing a visually attractive area visible from the highway to the south of the town <strong>and</strong> an attractive backdrop to the town centre. In the<br />
showground area, apart from a number of mature Eucalypts, vegetation is minimal. The area is mostly grassed open space which is regularly<br />
maintained.<br />
The reserve is divided by Racecourse Creek which is a major drainage line for the south Moruya area into the Moruya River which flows to<br />
the sea. Racecourse Creek is a formed open drain that passes through the Golf Course, changing direction midway through the course <strong>and</strong><br />
turning east before passing under the Princes Highway through box culverts.<br />
The Golf Course contains a number of artificial water bodies the largest of which acts as a holding dam for treated effluent from Moruya<br />
Sewerage Treatment <strong>Works</strong> prior to its use as irrigation water on the Golf Course.<br />
Birdlife, particularly native ducks, is abundant on the golf course due to the level of tree cover, grass areas <strong>and</strong> water bodies. Some of these<br />
species have been affected by management practices in the past <strong>and</strong> great care should be taken to manage the reserve for the benefit of<br />
both human <strong>and</strong> fauna users in the future.<br />
The reserve is subject to flooding. The severity of the flood is in part determined by the sea tide levels at the time of the flood event. Much of<br />
the reserve is subject to flooding in a minor flood event.<br />
The ‘Bugwatch’ program has been conducted on Racecourse Creek since 1997. Bugwatch is an educational program that shows the links<br />
between water quality <strong>and</strong> the bug numbers <strong>and</strong> types in a system. This allows for a scoring system to be utilised in identifying the pollution<br />
index <strong>and</strong> the water quality ranking of the waterbody. The process is relatively simple <strong>and</strong> fun for school children <strong>and</strong> people interested in<br />
monitoring the health of waterbodies.<br />
Water monitoring tests on the creek are also conducted, this assists in encouraging best environmental practices on the golf course <strong>and</strong><br />
showground.<br />
August 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page <strong>14</strong> of 57
3.3 Existing Use <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong><br />
Plan 3797 (refer to page 19) shows the current boundaries of the Moruya Showground Precinct, the Golf Course lease area, the Golf Course<br />
licence area <strong>and</strong> all existing facilities located within the study area.<br />
3.3.1 Moruya Golf Club Ltd – Golf Course<br />
Approximately three quarters of the Reserve is leased <strong>and</strong> occupied by the Moruya Golf Club Ltd which operates an 18 hole public golf<br />
course. Racecourse Creek flows through the golf course fairways exiting the Reserve on the eastern boundary <strong>and</strong> there are several dams<br />
<strong>and</strong> ponds throughout the golf course.<br />
The Moruya Golf Course has undergone a period of significant development in the past ten years <strong>and</strong> provides a well utilised quality 18 hole<br />
golf course with a substantial clubhouse <strong>and</strong> facilities. The Golf Clubhouse is located on Crown L<strong>and</strong> which is leased directly from the Crown<br />
<strong>and</strong> is not included in this Plan of Management.<br />
Within the showground precinct the Moruya Golf Club operates a maintenance shed <strong>and</strong> yard. This facility is licensed to the Golf Club by the<br />
Trust Manager (refer to Section 2.4 Leases & Licences on page 31 for more information).<br />
The Moruya Golf Course has been using treated effluent from the Moruya Sewerage Treatment Plant since approximately 1985. The Moruya<br />
Sewerage Treatment Plant underwent augmentation in 2000 so that it now treats effluent to an advanced secondary st<strong>and</strong>ard including<br />
disinfection with ultra violet light. Effluent that is to be used on the golf course undergoes a secondary disinfection with ultra violet<br />
immediately prior to it being pumped to the golf course.<br />
The Golf Course operates seven days a week. On rare occasions the course may be closed prior to a tournament to ensure that the course<br />
is in excellent condition. Similarly it is only on rare occasions that the general public would be restricted access to play golf because of a<br />
tournament or similar event. Even on those occasions it is most likely that access would be restricted for ½ a day only.<br />
Photo 2: View down the 1 st Fairway<br />
Photo 3: 9 th <strong>and</strong> 18 th Greens<br />
Photo 4: Golf Course 16 th Green Photo 5: Golfer walking through Showground area from the 12 th Green to 13 th<br />
Tee<br />
August 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 15 of 57
3.3.2 Moruya Showground Precinct<br />
The Moruya Showground Precinct includes:<br />
• Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> (includes public toilets <strong>and</strong> change rooms)<br />
• Exhibits Pavilion<br />
• Poultry Pavilion<br />
• Bar<br />
• Public Toilets<br />
• Storage Shed<br />
• Ticket Box at main entrance<br />
• <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District Show Society’s Secretary’s Office<br />
• Football oval with lights<br />
• Showground oval (fenced) with lights<br />
• Golf Club Maintenance Shed <strong>and</strong> Compound<br />
• Caretaker’s Cottage<br />
• Rodeo yards<br />
• Basketball Stadium/Community Hall<br />
• Ack Weyman Oval Scoreboard<br />
Various facilities including the show oval, rodeo yards <strong>and</strong> show pavilions, gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>, basketball stadium/community hall <strong>and</strong> a major<br />
sporting field, are all equipped with lights for night use.<br />
The Moruya Showground area is well utilised by locals for regular sporting events <strong>and</strong> competitions <strong>and</strong> is the site for tourist attracting events<br />
such as the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Agricultural Show, travelling circus, equestrian events, the Moruya Rodeo, golfing competitions <strong>and</strong> various other<br />
events. In association with a number of these events, overnight or extended camping occurs managed by the Moruya Showground<br />
Management Committee. In situations of extended camping this places additional pressure on some site facilities such as toilets <strong>and</strong> waste<br />
removal. The provision of camping meets the requirements of the Local Government (Caravan Parks, Camping Grounds <strong>and</strong> Moveable<br />
Dwellings) Regulations 1995.<br />
Photo 6: Aerial Photograph of the Moruya Showground Precinct during the 1988 <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District Show<br />
August 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 16 of 57
Photo 7: Ticket Box 1/Entrance – December 2005<br />
Photo 8: Ticket Box 2 – December 2005<br />
Photo 9: Ack Weyman Oval scoreboard Photo 10: Moruya Basketball Stadium / Community Hall<br />
Photo <strong>11</strong>: Caretaker’s residence - 2000 Photo 12: Caretaker’s residence - 2002<br />
Photo 13: Old Secretary’s Office - 2005<br />
Photo <strong>14</strong>: <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District Show 2003 – Horses in temporary yards<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 17 of 57
3.3 Existing Conditions Plans<br />
The existing conditions plans illustrate the reserves as at February 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
They provide a historical reference to the development of the reserves since 2002.<br />
There are two existing conditions Plans.<br />
1. Existing Conditions Plan - Moruya Showground <strong>and</strong> Golf Course (this plan illustrates both the Moruya Showground <strong>and</strong> the Moruya<br />
Golf Course).<br />
2. Existing Conditions Plan – Moruya Showground (this plan provides more detail of the Moruya Showground precinct).<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 18 of 57
3.4 Heritage<br />
3.4.1 History of the Moruya Showground<br />
The Conservation Management Plan for the Moruya Showground precinct includes a detailed history of the development of the Moruya<br />
Showground precinct as researched by Mr Brendan O’Keefe. The following time line was prepared by Mr O’Keefe <strong>and</strong> summarises events in<br />
the history of the site.<br />
By 1871<br />
Before recorded history, the l<strong>and</strong> was occupied by the Katungal Aboriginal people.<br />
Moruya has an agricultural <strong>and</strong> pastoral show.<br />
1878 Two portions of l<strong>and</strong> on south of river dedicated as showground.<br />
1881 Exhibitions Hall complete for first show on dedicated site. Shed <strong>and</strong> committee room built late in 1881.<br />
By 1885 Lighting for Hall, <strong>and</strong> stalls <strong>and</strong> pens for livestock built.<br />
1890’s Economic depression restricts show activities.<br />
1904-5 Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> built at Racecourse (replaced an earlier one to the east). Sited to be overlooked from the Moruya<br />
township.<br />
By 1910 New secretary’s office, publican’s booth built. Show ring fences <strong>and</strong> gates painted. Cattle yards established. Poultry<br />
shown on temporary st<strong>and</strong>s.<br />
By 1912 Luncheon booth <strong>and</strong> rotunda for brass b<strong>and</strong> (Rotunda remains at golf club).<br />
1912 Some consideration of relocation of show to Moruya Park (present-day site). Original site proving to be poorly<br />
drained <strong>and</strong> subject to floods. A gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> already in place at proposed site, used by racecourse, which was wellestablished<br />
there since 1866<br />
1913 Fruit stall, soft drink stall <strong>and</strong> Indian dart board stalls in place. Moruya Park re-dedicated to allow for showground<br />
uses. NSW provides assistance for relocation of old Showground buildings.<br />
19<strong>14</strong> Exhibition Hall relocated to present-day site, east of the saddling.<br />
1915 First show on present site. Cattle yards pig pens <strong>and</strong> poultry coops located behind gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>.<br />
19<strong>14</strong>–25 Nine-hole golf course built.<br />
1920 Addition to Exhibition Hall.<br />
1930’s Lighting to show ring, <strong>and</strong> installation of public address system<br />
By 1940 Additional lighting <strong>and</strong> a ‘main gate’ built.<br />
1940’s Showground used by the Army. Some war-time shows cancelled.<br />
1942 <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council resumes trusteeship of showground.<br />
1944 Extension to pavilion.<br />
1952 Toilet facilities built.<br />
1977 Pavilion upgraded. Basketball Stadium/Community Centre built.<br />
1985 Horseracing ceases.<br />
1987-88 Ack Weyman Oval built.<br />
1988 Golf course extended to eighteen holes.<br />
10 May 2002 Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> Exhibits Pavilion listed on <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council’s Local Environmental Plan<br />
29 April 2003 Showground Precinct nominated for inclusion on the NSW State Heritage Register<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 21 of 57
3.4.2 Heritage Listing<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> has many places that are significant to the community because of their indigenous, natural or cultural values. The<br />
protection of these places adds value to living in or visiting the area. It also lends support to the tourism industry by ensuring that what<br />
attracts us is conserved for others.<br />
Council affords legal protection to individual heritage items by listing them in a Local Environmental Plan (LEP). Significant l<strong>and</strong>scapes <strong>and</strong><br />
villages, such as those within the Tilba Conservation Area, are protected in the same way.<br />
In 1997 a <strong>Shire</strong> Wide Heritage Study was completed on behalf of Council. The study included a thematic history of the <strong>Shire</strong>, a series of<br />
recommendations <strong>and</strong> the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Heritage Inventory. At the time that the study was carried out, members of the community nominated<br />
places thought to be of significance. The consultants then assessed those items <strong>and</strong> determined their values <strong>and</strong> level of significance.<br />
Most of the recommendations put forward in the <strong>Shire</strong> Wide Heritage Study have been adopted <strong>and</strong> implemented as a Heritage Conservation<br />
& Management Program. The program includes the creation of the Heritage Advisory Committee to provide expert advice to councillors <strong>and</strong><br />
staff, the engagement of a consultant Heritage Adviser, <strong>and</strong> the listing of items identified in the Heritage Inventory in Local Environmental<br />
Plans.<br />
The Moruya Showground precinct includes two buildings which are afforded State Significance in Council’s Urban Local Environmental Plan –<br />
the Exhibits Pavilion & the Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>. These two buildings <strong>and</strong> the Moruya Showground Precinct have been nominated for inclusion on the<br />
NSW State Heritage Register with the NSW Heritage Office. DA plans have been approved for extensions <strong>and</strong> upgrades to the Exhibits<br />
Pavilion. As at the date of adoption of this Plan of Management, these nominations were being considered by the NSW Heritage Office.<br />
Photo 15: Moruya Showground Exhibits Pavilion (pre 2005 extensions)<br />
Listed at State Significant on Council’s Urban LEP<br />
Photo 16: Moruya Showground Exhibits Pavilion<br />
(October 20<strong>06</strong>)<br />
Listed at State Significant on Council’s Urban LEP<br />
The Moruya Showground Precinct Conservation Management Plan found that the poultry pavilion warrants inclusion on the Heritage<br />
Schedule of the LEP. It is the major building that expresses the spirit of functional improvisation used by the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District Show<br />
Society to establish <strong>and</strong> consolidate the activities of the Agricultural Show.<br />
Photo 17: Moruya Showground Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong><br />
Listed at State Significant on Council’s Urban LEP<br />
Photo 18: Moruya Showground Poultry Pavilion<br />
Further investigation is recommended for its inclusion as a Heritage Item on<br />
Council’s Urban LEP<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 22 of 57
3.4.3 Conservation Management Plan<br />
3.4.3.1 Background to the development of the Conservation Management Plan<br />
In July 2002 <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council adopted a draft of this Plan of Management for exhibition to seek community comment. Amongst<br />
other things, the plan proposed the development of a clear span pavilion to the west of the existing Basketball Stadium that would also<br />
encompass a new poultry pavilion.<br />
The community feedback on this draft Plan of Management demonstrated a high level of concern from the Moruya Amateur Basketball<br />
Association who requested that Council consider extending the existing basketball stadium to accommodate a second basketball court.<br />
However, this was in conflict with the draft Plan of Management which proposed to locate a Clear Span Pavilion in this same area. Other user<br />
groups felt that the showground should not be developed any more given its historical value <strong>and</strong> the pressures on the existing infrastructure<br />
during various show events.<br />
In an attempt to resolve these conflicting desires amongst the various user groups, Council established a working group. The working group<br />
comprises of the following representatives from the main user groups <strong>and</strong> government departments:<br />
User Group Representatives<br />
Moruya Showground Management Committee<br />
Equestrian/Dressage Association<br />
Rodeo Association<br />
Moruya Basketball Stadium & Community Centre Management Committee<br />
Moruya Show Society<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council<br />
Manager Technical Services <strong>and</strong> Property Division – Mr Andrew Parkinson<br />
Strategic Unit Team Leader – Mr Allen Grimwood<br />
Plans of Management Officer – Ms Deborah Purss<br />
Department of L<strong>and</strong>s<br />
Reserves Co-ordinator Officer – Ms Karen Fowler<br />
Senior L<strong>and</strong> Manager/Surveyor – Mr John Filocomo<br />
Environmental Officer, L<strong>and</strong>scape Management – Mr Bob Britten<br />
The working group supported the development of a Conservation Management Plan in an attempt to provide a benchmark for decision<br />
making in the future <strong>and</strong> to assist with resolving the issues associated with the conflicting desires of various user groups. It would also assist<br />
with expediting the final adoption of the Plan of Management for the reserve.<br />
In November 2002 the Working Group agreed to apply for $12,500 in grant funding from the Department of L<strong>and</strong>’s Public Reserves<br />
Management Fund (Showgrounds) to complete a Conservation Management Plan for the Moruya Showground precinct.<br />
In June 2004 Council was offered a grant of $6,000 from the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s for the Conservation Management Plan subject to council<br />
contributing the balance of funds to complete the project. In July 2004 Council agreed to match the grant funding <strong>and</strong> expressions of interest<br />
were sought from Heritage Consultants to complete the Conservation Management Plan.<br />
A draft Conservation Management Plan (CMP) was completed by John Armes & Associates <strong>and</strong> exhibited for comment in March 2005. By<br />
this time, the Moruya Showground Management Committee had resolved not to pursue a Clear Span Pavilion on the site. Therefore, the<br />
main proposed development issue for the Conservation Management Plan was an extension to the existing Basketball Stadium/Community<br />
Centre to create a 2 nd basketball court.<br />
The draft CMP found that although the basketball stadium <strong>and</strong> community centre contribute to the vitality of the precinct, proposals to exp<strong>and</strong><br />
the facility would have an adverse effect on the heritage character of the showground. The draft CMP was supported by all user groups <strong>and</strong><br />
Council’s Heritage Advisory Committee made some minor recommendations that were then incorporated into the final plan. The Moruya<br />
Amateur Basketball Association also made requests for amendments <strong>and</strong> these were also incorporated into the final CMP.<br />
The CMP was completed on 26 May 2005 <strong>and</strong> was adopted by Council at its <strong>Works</strong> & <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee Meeting on <strong>14</strong> February 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
Copies of the CMP are available from Council <strong>and</strong> from Council’s website.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 23 of 57
3.4.3.2 Recommendations of the Conservation Management Plan<br />
This Conservation Management Plan (CMP) investigated <strong>and</strong> established the cultural significance of the Showground in Moruya NSW. The<br />
investigation found that the site, setting <strong>and</strong> some buildings <strong>and</strong> spaces are important values for:<br />
• associations with the consolidation of Moruya as a township;<br />
• the development of recreational activity in Moruya;<br />
• its reflection of pastoral <strong>and</strong> agricultural aspects of the <strong>Shire</strong>’s life;<br />
• supporting the activities of a number of community organisations;<br />
• its status as a cultural asset of the <strong>Shire</strong>;<br />
• its aesthetic features, notably some buildings, spaces, <strong>and</strong> relationship to the structure of the town; <strong>and</strong><br />
• a venue for sporting <strong>and</strong> Agricultural Show for a variety of users <strong>and</strong> supporters.<br />
Photo 19: Bucking Horse at the 2002 Moruya Rodeo Photo 20: Bucking Bull at the 2002 Moruya Rodeo<br />
Photo 21: Rides at the 2003 <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District Show Photo 22: Equestrian Events at the 2003 <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District Show<br />
Council’s Urban Local Environmental Plan (LEP) contains provisions that apply to the protection of heritage values at the showground<br />
(clauses 71 <strong>and</strong> 73). The CMP emphasises the need for these provisions to be applied to the showground.<br />
The CMP found that the poultry pavilion warrants inclusion on the Heritage Schedule of the LEP. It is the major building that expresses the<br />
spirit of functional improvisation used by the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District Show Society to establish <strong>and</strong> consolidate the activities of the Agricultural<br />
Show.<br />
The need to recognise that the lesser buildings (toilets, gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> additions, bar, horse stalls <strong>and</strong> secretary’s office) do not have a long,<br />
useful life ahead, <strong>and</strong> that their replacements are not being planned was also identified in the CMP. The loss of these lesser buildings will<br />
alter the character of the showground, which is a major element in the heritage value of the place. The CMP has found that the character of<br />
the showground relies on a scattered array of small buildings, which should be reflected in future replacements.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 24 of 57
The CMP made the following recommendations on the l<strong>and</strong>scape, heritage buildings <strong>and</strong> non-heritage buildings in the showground:<br />
Statement of Conservation Policy<br />
The study has found that it is appropriate for the showground to be conserved as a site, which provides tangible links to the heritage of the<br />
<strong>Shire</strong>. These should be conserved <strong>and</strong> promoted for a wide sector of the community. The gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>, exhibits pavilion, poultry pavilion <strong>and</strong><br />
arena are key heritage elements for conservation.<br />
The heritage values of the showground are best protected by an emphasis of the traditional uses of the site, such as equestrian sport, the<br />
Agricultural Show <strong>and</strong> other sport limited to their present facilities <strong>and</strong> activities.<br />
It is essential for a clear plan to be devised for replacement of lesser buildings within the Showground Buildings Group, whilst maintaining the<br />
informal, understated <strong>and</strong> scattered character of the precinct.<br />
Heritage buildings<br />
Recommendations for the gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> exhibits pavilion are provided on the data sheets in the Conservation Management Plan.<br />
It is recommended that the heritage values of the cottage <strong>and</strong> poultry pavilion shed are recognised, <strong>and</strong> that it is recommended that they<br />
remain in their locations.<br />
All proposed work to heritage buildings should be guided by a suitably experienced, heritage architect.<br />
Showground Arena<br />
The arena is a key feature of the showground, <strong>and</strong> should be protected as a space to continue its present uses.<br />
New buildings<br />
The construction of additions to the basketball stadium are not supported (as proposed in 2002).<br />
New buildings will be required to replace those which have a short life expectancy. It is recommended that concept designs be prepared for<br />
replacement facilities. These will provide <strong>and</strong> architectural theme, <strong>and</strong> a direction to which to plan for the future. The new buildings should<br />
not be ‘mock heritage’ in design, but use traditional, simple details <strong>and</strong> materials that result in a pleasing, distinctive local character.<br />
The CMP has considered the impact of the proposed Equal Access Shelter for spectators with special requirements. Preliminary designs<br />
have been prepared.<br />
New buildings should be separate rather than amalgamated, in order to sustain the scattered character of the showground. However, their<br />
locations do need to be carefully considered, to a structured <strong>and</strong> effective plan.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 25 of 57
General Recommendations<br />
The Plan of Management has identified several values (refer to page 40) of a non-heritage nature. These are however, relevant to a full<br />
appreciation of the importance of the showground. Specific recommendations for each existing building are presented in the data sheets in<br />
section 4.3. This section of the CMP makes recommendations of an overall nature, as they relate to the buildings <strong>and</strong> the key open spaces<br />
in the precinct. The following recommendations are made with regard to the heritage values of the showground. These have been<br />
summarised in point form as follows:<br />
Ack Weyman Oval<br />
• Retain for continued use<br />
• Additional moveable seating acceptable<br />
• Additional shade trees<br />
Ack Weyman Oval Scoreboard<br />
• Retain for continued use<br />
Bar/Kiosk/Canteen<br />
• Retain surrounding open space<br />
• The bar is considered to be an important facility, but its<br />
appearance is poor. A new building is recommended.<br />
Basketball Stadium/Community Centre<br />
• Conserve in original appearance<br />
Caretaker’s Cottage<br />
• Retain in present location.<br />
• Compatible alterations <strong>and</strong> additions are acceptable.<br />
• Some internal elements are of heritage interest, but upgrading is<br />
possible<br />
Entrance / Ticket Box 1<br />
• The main entrance should be improved to provide a more<br />
inspiring sense of arrival to the facilities, <strong>and</strong> to highlight the<br />
precinct’s heritage values<br />
• Replace Ticket Box with improved facility<br />
Exhibits Pavilion<br />
• Complete Heritage Listing Process<br />
• Remove intrusive elements<br />
• Restump with timber stumps at perimeter<br />
• Prepare detailed Conservation Management Plan<br />
Golf Course Compound<br />
• Formulate strategy for use of the l<strong>and</strong><br />
• Record <strong>and</strong> remove<br />
Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong><br />
• The building should be progressively returned to a state where<br />
its original features are emphasised <strong>and</strong> project the original<br />
appearance.<br />
• Additions <strong>and</strong> block sidewalls are intrusive to the significance of<br />
the building, <strong>and</strong> should be progressively removed<br />
• Adaptation of the building can proceed, with sensitive<br />
architectural guidelines.<br />
Grassy Hill (west of Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>)<br />
• Retain <strong>and</strong> continue present use<br />
• Equal access shelter is acceptable<br />
Poultry Pavilion<br />
• Detailed heritage assessment recommended<br />
• Retain for continued use<br />
• Need to monitor condition of timber <strong>and</strong> corrosion of steel<br />
components<br />
Public Toilets<br />
• Formulate strategy for new facilities<br />
• Record <strong>and</strong> remove<br />
Rodeo Yards<br />
• Retain examples of timber elements of interest<br />
Stables<br />
• Formulate strategy for new facilities if required<br />
• Record <strong>and</strong> remove/replace<br />
Secretary’s Office<br />
• Formulate strategy for new facilities<br />
• Record <strong>and</strong> remove<br />
Showground Arena<br />
• Retain <strong>and</strong> continue its use<br />
• Shade tree planting around the perimeter would improve the<br />
amenity of the area, as well as emphasise the circular character<br />
• No buildings or permanent structures should be permitted<br />
• Future fencing requirements be allowed on merit<br />
Showground Precinct<br />
• Complete Heritage Listing Process<br />
• Develop Conservation Strategies for high ranking buildings<br />
• Develop program for replacement of lesser buildings<br />
• Commence L<strong>and</strong>scape Masterplan<br />
• Develop concepts for main entrance<br />
• An improved entrance at the northern end will provide some<br />
sense of arrival into the showground. This could be achieved<br />
with a gate structure with special design treatment<br />
Storage Shed<br />
• Conserve for continued use as storage, or possible new, small<br />
scale, compatible use.<br />
Ticket Box 2 (near the bar)<br />
• Formulate strategy for new facilities if required<br />
• Record <strong>and</strong> remove/replace<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 26 of 57
L<strong>and</strong>scape<br />
The l<strong>and</strong>scape <strong>and</strong> open spaces in the showground require the following works to enhance <strong>and</strong> improve the basic level of amenity:<br />
The lack of shade trees restricts full appreciation of the quality of events at the showground. The l<strong>and</strong>scape masterplan should be revised to<br />
include more shade trees in key congregating areas, around the arena, <strong>and</strong> around the football pitch. Exotic species can be considered.<br />
Prominent eucalypts are a feature of the natural heritage of the precinct, those with poor health require assessment. This feature of the<br />
l<strong>and</strong>scape’s character should be enhanced <strong>and</strong> strengthened with new plantings in selected areas.<br />
Photo 23: Eucalypts dominate the south eastern end of the Showground Precinct<br />
Northern Axis to Moruya Town Centre<br />
There is an opportunity to enhance the pedestrian <strong>and</strong> cycling link with the addition of suitable trees, <strong>and</strong> possibly some improvements to path<br />
alignment. These should be achievable without adverse impact on the golf course. The result should be to emphasise this axis, <strong>and</strong> increase<br />
a focus on the arena <strong>and</strong> a better northern entrance to the showground. It will also strengthen the visual connection to the town centre <strong>and</strong><br />
local topographical features at the north <strong>and</strong> southern ends of the axis.<br />
The ‘Pink Gates’, which are located on this axis, have an historic association with the showground, <strong>and</strong> this report supports their<br />
reconstruction. It is understood that a surviving gate is available for reference, <strong>and</strong> the reconstruction should be accurate <strong>and</strong> authentic, rather<br />
than a poor imitation.<br />
Photo 24: Pink Gates at the northern end of the north-south axis<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 27 of 57
Lesser buildings<br />
There is a need to recognise that the lesser buildings (toilets, gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> additions, bar, horse stalls <strong>and</strong> secretary’s office) do not have a<br />
long, useful life ahead, <strong>and</strong> it is recommended that their replacements be planned.<br />
The loss of lesser buildings will alter the character of the showground, which is a major element in the heritage value of the place. Prior to<br />
replacement, they should be recorded photographically, <strong>and</strong> with measured drawings for archival purposes.<br />
Photo 25: Female Public Toilets – December 2005<br />
Photo 27: Western Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> additions –Changerooms<br />
December 2005<br />
Photo 29: Bar/Canteen – December 2005<br />
Photo 26: Male Public Toilets – December 2005<br />
Photo 28: Western Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> additions – Male & Female Toilets<br />
December 2005<br />
Photo 30: Secretary’s Office - December 2005<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 28 of 57
Photo 31: Horse Stables – December 2005<br />
Lesser buildings - continued<br />
Photo 32: Horse Stables – December 2005<br />
Asset Management - Management Structure<br />
The Plan of Management outlines the areas of responsibility <strong>and</strong> the legal responsibilities for the management of the showground. This CMP<br />
recommends that the Plan of Management recognises the need for appropriate heritage advice on matters relating to all development within<br />
the showground. Some issues can be addressed by Council’s heritage adviser, but in some cases, consultant expertise will need to be<br />
appointed.<br />
Asset Management – Statutory Approvals<br />
Items within the Precinct can be altered, demolished, maintained or developed in terms of the heritage protection provisions of the LEP.<br />
Asset Management – Maintenance<br />
It is desirable that the high ranking heritage buildings (the Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> the Exhibits Pavilion) <strong>and</strong> the moderate ranking buildings (Poultry<br />
Pavilion, Storage Shed <strong>and</strong> Caretaker’s Cottage) be maintained <strong>and</strong> developed with their heritage values in focus. The <strong>Shire</strong>’s heritage<br />
adviser is able to provide this expertise. It is appropriate that the heritage adviser meet with those responsible for maintenance, <strong>and</strong> coordinate<br />
mutual objectives.<br />
Future maintenance of buildings <strong>and</strong> the precinct shall be carried out with regard to this Conservation Management Plan, The Burra Charter<br />
<strong>and</strong> directed by suitably qualified expert supervision.<br />
Golf club compound<br />
The potential for this area to serve a number of interests should be explored as part of the development of the showground. The l<strong>and</strong> will<br />
provide for a number of conflicting priorities, <strong>and</strong> its use needs careful consideration. Development of this area shall complement heritage<br />
values established in this report.<br />
Photo 33: Golf Club Maintenance Compound (east) – December 2005 Photo 34: Golf Club Maintenance Compound (west) – November 2001<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 29 of 57
3.4.3.3 Recommendations of the Conservation Management Plan – Non Heritage Issues<br />
During the preparation of the CMP, many non-heritage issues emerged from the discussions with the user groups. These were beyond the<br />
scope of the CMP, but need to be appreciated, advanced <strong>and</strong> resolved. These issues <strong>and</strong> responses are as follows:<br />
Issue 1: The feasibility <strong>and</strong> cost-effectiveness of an enlarged stadium has not been established.<br />
Response: The issue of providing a two court indoor facility in the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> will be discussed through Council’s Sports Liaison<br />
Committee.<br />
Issue 2: The possibility of integrating new showground facilities into the existing or enlarged stadium has not been explored.<br />
Response: The development of the stadium to better accommodate the needs of the showground would be possible as along as the<br />
proposed development was consistent with the Moruya Showground Conservation Management Plan <strong>and</strong> Council’s LEP.<br />
This issue would require additional consultation with user groups if <strong>and</strong> when this requirement arises in the future.<br />
Issue 3: The separate ambitions of the Basketball Association <strong>and</strong> other user organisations hinder a cohesive process of planning for<br />
the future of the showground.<br />
Response: The Moruya Basketball Management Committee has a representative on the Moruya Showground Management Committee.<br />
Their regular attendance at this meeting would assist with a more coordinated approach to managing the Moruya Showground<br />
precinct wholistically. Refer also Section 2.7 Management Committees on page 34.<br />
Issue 4: There is a need to review the relevance of the role of the stadium as an effective ‘community centre’.<br />
Response: The stadium is available to the community as a venue that can be hired. It is anticipated that the booking of this facility will be<br />
through Council’s centralised booking system. This improve the general public’s accessibility to hire this facility.<br />
Issue 5: The valuable, air-thrust floor of the stadium restricts other uses.<br />
Response: Future developments of the stadium/community centre must obtain the consent of Council to ensure that the facility is<br />
managed to best meet the needs of the community <strong>and</strong> that maximum multi-use is achieved.<br />
Issue 6: Availability of the golf club compound will delay opportunities for change.<br />
Response: The l<strong>and</strong> currently occupied by the golf club’s maintenance compound will return to the Showground precinct in June 2010.<br />
The L<strong>and</strong>scape Masterplan illustrates how this l<strong>and</strong> will contribute to the development of showground precinct in the future.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 30 of 57
3.5 Leases & Licences<br />
3.5.1 Requirements of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act<br />
Leases or licences of Crown reserves may only be entered into by trustees of Crown reserves who have been appointed under the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s<br />
Act. Consent must be obtained from the Minister (Department of L<strong>and</strong>s) before the lease or licence is executed. The following issues must be<br />
considered when Council, as Trust Manager, is granting a lease or licence on Crown Reserves:<br />
1. Broadly speaking, leases are executed where exclusive control of the whole or part of a reserve is proposed. A licence is executed<br />
where intermittent occupation or control of the whole or part of a reserve is proposed (eg a lease for a swimming pool or kiosk, a<br />
licence to a football club for the use of an area for the season on a Saturday).<br />
2. A lease may only be entered into by the Trust where it can be demonstrated that any Native Title interest in the l<strong>and</strong> has been<br />
extinguished.<br />
3. The term of any lease/licence should be as short as practicable, appropriate to all circumstances <strong>and</strong> commensurate with changing<br />
community needs. Generally terms in excess of 20 years are not favoured.<br />
4. Generally options for renewal or holding over clauses are not favoured. Consideration can be given to the granting of a new<br />
lease/licence on expiry of the old lease/licence. Any "holding over" shall not exceed 12 months.<br />
5. The Minister may not consent to the granting of a lease for a term exceeding 5 years (or a lease for a term that, by the exercise of an<br />
option, could exceed 5 years) unless at least <strong>14</strong> days have elapsed since notice of intention to give consent has been published in a<br />
newspaper circulating in the locality in which the l<strong>and</strong> is situated or in a newspaper circulating generally in the State.<br />
6. Clauses conferring a right to compensation for improvements are not acceptable, in appropriate cases the lessee should be required to<br />
clear <strong>and</strong>/or restore the l<strong>and</strong> to the satisfaction of the Trust <strong>and</strong> the Minister. The lease should clearly reflect the intentions in respect of<br />
the improvements on expiry of the lease (ie lease area to be cleared <strong>and</strong> restored or improvements to remain <strong>and</strong> become the property<br />
of the trust).<br />
7. Where the conditions require the lessee to undertake development works, the agreement should specify that no work is to be<br />
undertaken until plans have been approved by the Trust <strong>and</strong> the Minister <strong>and</strong> any necessary development or building consents are<br />
obtained from the local Council.<br />
8. Rental should reflect a commercial approach of market rent having regard to purpose of the lease/licence, site value <strong>and</strong> ownership of<br />
existing improvements.<br />
Agreements for other than a short term should provide for regular periodic re-determination of rental (say every three to five years) as<br />
well as being linked to increases in the Consumer Price Index for intervening annual reviews. Where the parties cannot agree on the redetermination<br />
of the rent, clauses should provide for reference to an independent arbitrator (not the Department). Where a nominal<br />
rental is imposed because the lessee is a charitable or non-profit organisation, such rental should generally not be less than the statutory<br />
minimum rental ($350-00 as at 1 July 2004 <strong>and</strong> linked to CPI) prescribed for tenures under the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act, 1989.<br />
9. A diagram specifying the area involved must be annexed to <strong>and</strong> form part of the lease agreement.<br />
10. In the case of sub-leases, reference should be made to the head lease in the preamble <strong>and</strong> the term of any sub-lease should not extend<br />
beyond the date of expiry of the head lease.<br />
<strong>11</strong>. If the reserve has a Real Property title, then leases for more than three years must be registered at the L<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> Property Information<br />
Office (formerly L<strong>and</strong> Titles Office).<br />
12. Where applicable, the agreement should include clauses providing for use/access by the general public.<br />
13. A clause requiring the lessee to bear the lessor’s reasonable expenses involved with the lease (eg Trust’s solicitors, advertising, stamp<br />
duty etc) should be considered for inclusion in the lease agreement.<br />
<strong>14</strong>. The proceeds from a lease or licence granted by a reserve trust shall be applied in accordance with directions (if any) given by the<br />
Minister under Section 1<strong>06</strong> of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989. In the absence of any direction, the proceeds shall be applied for the general<br />
purposes of the reserve trust <strong>and</strong> may be invested or applied by the trust accordingly.<br />
The following describes the general principles which a reserve trust manager must take into consideration when negotiating commercial lease<br />
or licence proposals on Crown reserves:<br />
• Leases or licences for commercial purposes can only be granted where the commercial activity is consistent with the purpose for which<br />
the reserve was dedicated or reserved <strong>and</strong> should not overpower or dominate the reserve.<br />
• Commercial leases/licences on Crown reserves should be established by a fair, open, impartial <strong>and</strong> transparent process <strong>and</strong> provide<br />
optimum environmental, social <strong>and</strong> economic returns from such use of the reserve for the people of NSW.<br />
• Appointed Trust Managers must be able to demonstrate that they have met their responsibility to the people of NSW of ensuring that the<br />
best possible result will be realised from the lease arrangement.<br />
• Other than where special circumstances exist, opportunities to lease/licence public reserves should be decided by a competitive process.<br />
The Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) advises public sector organisations against entering into negotiations which<br />
bypass a competitive process on the basis that direct negotiations can lack openness, fairness <strong>and</strong> accountability, <strong>and</strong> may result in<br />
outcomes which deliver less than the best outcome for the community. Accordingly, the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s has a responsibility when<br />
considering the granting of consent under Sections 102 & 103 of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989 to ensure that the best possible outcome<br />
has being obtained by the reserve trust.<br />
• Where public tendering is not to be used to identify a suitable lessee, then there needs to be a clear account of how alternative<br />
processes serve the public good. This account would need to demonstrate openness, fairness <strong>and</strong> accountability.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 31 of 57
• NSW Treasury directions which require that any commercial use of State owned public l<strong>and</strong>s realise the best possible financial return.<br />
ICAC guidelines suggest that a public competition process would avoid the following problems:<br />
• Any public perception that the trust is not getting the best possible deal for the public<br />
• Opportunity for corruption in direct dealings with current lessee<br />
• Reduced opportunity to discover new or innovative ideas<br />
• Possible lack of transparency <strong>and</strong> accountability in the process<br />
• Lack of opportunity to test value for money<br />
In accordance with these guidelines the overall objectives of a Crown reserve trust when negotiating commercial lease/licence arrangements<br />
should be to:<br />
• Obtain the best value for money through a fair <strong>and</strong> impartial process<br />
• Minimise the level of risk for the trust<br />
• Minimise the opportunity for corrupt conduct<br />
• Obtain the best environmental, social <strong>and</strong> economic outcome for the public<br />
3.5.2 Existing Leases & Licences<br />
As at the date of adoption of this Plan of Management, the following leases <strong>and</strong> licences were current on the Reserves:<br />
PIN No<br />
Crown Reserve No<br />
<strong>11</strong>876<br />
Crown Dedication 580020<br />
<strong>11</strong>876<br />
Crown Dedication 580020<br />
26861<br />
Crown Reserve No. 96313<br />
<strong>11</strong>876<br />
Crown Dedication 580020<br />
Legal Definition Type of Agreement Expiry Date Activity Location Lessee/Licensor<br />
Lot 7035<br />
DP 1029448<br />
Lot 7035<br />
DP 1029448<br />
Lot 1<br />
DP 44297<br />
Lot 7035<br />
DP 1029448<br />
3.5.3 Moruya Golf Course Lease<br />
Residential Tenancy<br />
Agreement<br />
Annual Caretakers Residence Albert Street, Moruya Subject to change<br />
Lease 30 June 2025 Golf Course - Part Moruya Moruya Golf Club<br />
Lease 30 June 2025 Golf Course - Part Moruya Moruya Golf Club<br />
Licence December 2010 Golf Club Maintenance<br />
Compound<br />
Moruya Showground Moruya Golf Club<br />
Approximately three quarters of the reserve is leased to the Moruya Golf Club Pty Ltd by <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council under a 20 year lease<br />
agreement which expires on 30 June 2025. Special conditions included in the current lease agreement that relate to the management of the<br />
Golf Course reserve include (but are not limited to):<br />
To keep the l<strong>and</strong> (including all fixtures <strong>and</strong> additions thereto) in good <strong>and</strong> substantial repair <strong>and</strong> condition.<br />
To keep the l<strong>and</strong> in such order that the game of golf may be properly played thereon.<br />
All residents within a radius of 20 kilometres from the Moruya Post Office shall be eligible for membership as a playing member.<br />
The l<strong>and</strong> can only be occupied <strong>and</strong> used for a Golf Course.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council staff shall have access to the l<strong>and</strong> at all time for any lawful purpose.<br />
The Golf Club will pay all rates <strong>and</strong> taxes levied, <strong>and</strong> excess water used on or in connection with the l<strong>and</strong>.<br />
The public shall have reasonable access on foot that will not interfere with the playing of golf, nor have access to or interfere with<br />
the tees, fairways <strong>and</strong> greens.<br />
The public shall have the right to pass <strong>and</strong> repass on foot, horseback or pedal cycle on the existing path between Murray Street <strong>and</strong><br />
the showground.<br />
The golf club must have current Public Liability insurance as per Council’s requirements.<br />
This is a summary only, the original lease agreement must be referred to further detail.<br />
The Moruya Golf Club has indicated that they may wish to provide additional parking to the south of the main Golf Club building. If this<br />
proceeds, it will require a review of the existing Golf Course lease. Any approval for additional car parking would only be approved on the<br />
basis that it would be available for all users of the reserve, not just for members of the Golf Club.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 32 of 57
3.5.4 Moruya Golf Course Maintenance Compound Licence<br />
The Golf Club’s Maintenance Compound is located within the Showground precinct <strong>and</strong> is licensed to the Moruya Golf Club. The licence<br />
agreement ends in December 2010 at which time the area will be returned to the Showground precinct.<br />
Special conditions included in the licence agreement that relate to the occupation of the Golf Course Maintenance Compound include (but are<br />
not limited to):<br />
To use the premises <strong>and</strong> structures for the purpose of a machinery <strong>and</strong> general storage shed, together with the provision of staff<br />
amenities, <strong>and</strong> for no other purpose.<br />
The licence can not be assigned or sub- licensed to any person.<br />
The premises must be kept clean <strong>and</strong> tidy.<br />
To comply with the directions <strong>and</strong> guidelines by responsible Commonwealth <strong>and</strong> State Government bodies, including the<br />
Environment Protection Authority. Including directions <strong>and</strong> guidelines for safe working conditions <strong>and</strong> the safe storage of chemicals,<br />
fuels <strong>and</strong> other hazardous substances.<br />
The golf club must have current Public Liability insurance as per Council’s requirements.<br />
On expiry of the licence, if requested by <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council, the Golf Club must remove any fixtures, fittings or property<br />
belonging to the Golf Club. The premises must be left clean <strong>and</strong> available for use <strong>and</strong> occupation <strong>and</strong> in the same condition as at<br />
the commencement of the licence agreement.<br />
Must comply the Development Consent No. 565/00.<br />
This is a summary only, the original licence agreement must be referred to further detail.<br />
The Golf Club has committed to relocating its Maintenance Compound to the south eastern corner of the Golf Course reserve. This was<br />
confirmed in writing on 27 December, 2000 with an undertaking to remove the Maintenance Compound from its current location in a 5 to 10<br />
year time frame (ie by end of 2010). The Golf Club Maintenance Compound will form part of the “Rural Precinct” of the showground In<br />
January 20<strong>11</strong>.<br />
2.5.5 Residential Tenancy Agreement – Moruya Showground Caretakers Cottage<br />
This Plan of Management provides for an onsite Caretaker to accommodate the Caretakers Cottage, located on Albert Street <strong>and</strong> adjacent to<br />
the Moruya Basketball Stadium. The tenant will be a part time employee of Council.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 33 of 57
3.6 Management Committees<br />
Management Committee Agreements delegate many of the day to day management responsibilities of the reserve to the management<br />
committees. They are delegated responsibility for management <strong>and</strong> maintenance of facilities, such as booking of activities <strong>and</strong> the collection<br />
of fees <strong>and</strong> charges as adopted by council. The management agreements, which detail the responsibilities of the management committees,<br />
may be updated <strong>and</strong> changed over time to reflect more current circumstances.<br />
The establishment of two Management Committees at the Moruya Showground has evolved over time <strong>and</strong> was the result of a Council<br />
Resolution.<br />
Refer to Attachment 6 for a list of groups using the facilities as at the date of adoption of the Plan of Management. In addition, refer to Section<br />
2.8 on Council’s Sports Liaison Committee <strong>and</strong> the potential for change to the structure of Management Committees throughout the <strong>Shire</strong>.<br />
3.6.1 Moruya Showground Management Committee<br />
There is a management agreement in accordance with sections 355 <strong>and</strong> 377 of the Local Government Act with the committee known as the<br />
"Moruya Showgrounds Management Committee" authorised to control <strong>and</strong> manage part of the reserve <strong>and</strong> its related facilities in the area not<br />
covered by the Golf Club lease area <strong>and</strong> the Basketball Stadium.<br />
A representative from the Moruya Basketball Stadium Management Committee is a member of the Moruya Showground Management<br />
Committee to ensure that both management committees are communicating relevant information that assists the management of the reserve.<br />
3.6.2 Moruya Basketball Stadium Management Committee<br />
There is also a management agreement in accordance with sections 355 <strong>and</strong> 377 of the Local Government Act with the committee known as<br />
the "Moruya Basketball Stadium Management Committee" authorised to control <strong>and</strong> manage the basketball stadium/community hall <strong>and</strong> its<br />
related facilities on part of the reserve known as the Moruya Showground.<br />
3.7 Sports Liaison Committee<br />
In January 2005 Council established the Sports Liaison Committee. The role of this Committee is:<br />
To maintain, improve <strong>and</strong> promote <strong>Eurobodalla</strong>'s Sporting <strong>and</strong> Active Recreation <strong>Facilities</strong> <strong>and</strong> activities in a fair <strong>and</strong> equitable manner.<br />
Over time, Council will be rationalising the number of Management Committees. The Sports Liaison Committee will work closely with the<br />
professional sporting associations throughout the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> in centralising the management of recreational activities. This will<br />
improve the distribution of funds throughout the shire for the development, maintenance <strong>and</strong> management of sporting facilities.<br />
This may result in the Moruya Basketball Stadium Management Committee <strong>and</strong> the Moruya Showground Management Committee being<br />
dissolved in the future. Instead, Council will work closely with the professional sporting <strong>and</strong> user group associations.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 34 of 57
3.8 Moruya Golf Course – Pressures on Use<br />
3.8.1 Access through Golf Course<br />
The Golf Club has experienced some problems with v<strong>and</strong>alism occurring on the golf course, in particular from where access is unobstructed<br />
on the wester perimeter. In order to reduce the risk of this occurring on the reserve, the Golf Club has requested that the western <strong>and</strong><br />
southern boundaries be fenced. Following on-site consultation with the Department of L<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> Water Conservation (now the Department of<br />
L<strong>and</strong>s), Golf Club representatives <strong>and</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Council, DLWC have confirmed that the Evans <strong>and</strong> Albert Street boundaries can be<br />
fenced. This is subject to the following criteria being addressed:<br />
1. A north/south access route through the golf course/showground site is provided <strong>and</strong> is formalised by the construction of a track in<br />
the appropriate location. This may involve consultation with the Showground Management Committee as to its final location.<br />
2. The proposal is considered <strong>and</strong> discussed at the reserve consultative committee [Moruya Showground Management Committee].<br />
3. The proposal is justified <strong>and</strong> outlined in the proposed Plan of Management for the reserve.<br />
4. Careful consideration of the route of the fence to minimise any impact on existing trees on or near the boundary. Council will need<br />
to give consideration to the appropriate footpath width to allow safe passage along the subject streets.<br />
5. The proposed fencing is subject of development application.<br />
The installation of fencing on the Evans <strong>and</strong> Albert Street boundaries will restrict public access to the Golf Course to the appropriate entry <strong>and</strong><br />
exit points <strong>and</strong> will provide a degree of security for the golf course. This is consistent with the lease agreement which states “THAT the Public<br />
shall have: (a) reasonable access on foot to the area hereby leased but shall not interfere with the playing of golf nor have access to or<br />
interfere with the tees, fairways <strong>and</strong> greens.” (Section 9 (a)).<br />
3.8.2 Access through the Showground & Golf Course<br />
Public access north-south through the golf course <strong>and</strong> the Showground is mostly unobstructed. There is a gravel footpath that provides<br />
north/south access which is very well used <strong>and</strong> provides a connection between the Moruya township <strong>and</strong> residential areas, including the<br />
Moruya High School. At times, there has been a conflict of use between playing golf <strong>and</strong> the provision of safe public access through the golf<br />
course at this location.<br />
This issue resulted in the formation of the Golf Course Working Party in 1999 to consider safe public access through the golf course at this<br />
location. The Working Party also discussed the “Pink Gates” which were once the entry point from the main section of Moruya across to the<br />
then showground <strong>and</strong> racetrack, at that time the location of these gates was not know. Since then, as reported in the Moruya Examiner on<br />
May 15 2002, one of the Pink Gates may have been located by Mr Bob McLeay, who “found it at the tip years ago”. This discovery will assist<br />
with the re-creation/restoration <strong>and</strong> installation of the infamous “Pink Gates”.<br />
In November 1999 the Golf Course Working Party recommended that;<br />
a) That public access across the pathway must be maintained.<br />
b) That doing nothing is not an option.<br />
c) That the implementation of pedestrian refuges as a first step is warranted.<br />
d) That longer term the course layout may be adjusted <strong>and</strong> the pathway may be realigned in the eventuality of the Moruya Golf Club no<br />
longer being in a position to meet the conditions of the lease OR where higher levels of use or other factors deem it necessary to revisit<br />
the safety issues of the public pathway.<br />
That any course layout changes be accomplished while meeting each of the following requirements:<br />
1. the pathway remains open<br />
2. the pathway does not traverse a fairway<br />
3. the integrity of the golf course is maintained<br />
e) That the “ Pink Gates “ be recognised in the Plan of Management as having cultural value to Moruya Showground Reserve <strong>and</strong><br />
provision be made for their reinstatement in timber - painted pink.<br />
In the event of the Moruya Golf Club not being able to meet their lease obligations for indemnity to Council we would need to address<br />
the reasons for this <strong>and</strong> possibly investigate course layout change options.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 35 of 57
The location of pedestrian refuges are illustrated in Figure 1 below:<br />
Figure 1: Locations of Pedestrian Refuges<br />
As a result, Council endorsed these recommendations at the <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee Meeting on 5 November 1999 as follows:<br />
1. The recommendations of the Working Party be incorporated into the Plan of Management for Moruya Showground Reserve.<br />
2. Council consider funding pedestrian refuges <strong>and</strong> the “pink gates” from the annual lease rental from the Golf Club.<br />
3. Financial responsibilities for public pathway <strong>and</strong> any possible course layout/pathway realignment be examined in the preparation of<br />
the Moruya Golf Course lease renewal in 2005.<br />
The pedestrian refuges were installed at the locations indicated on Figure 1 in December 2004.<br />
3.8.3 Parking<br />
Photo 35: Pedestrian refuge Moruya Golf Course<br />
The Golf Course had adequate parking for the level of use at present. However, it is anticipated that in the future the increase in use of the<br />
facilities may require additional parking. The area south of the existing Golf Club, in the reserve, has been identified as a possibility for the<br />
construction of additional parking facilities.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 36 of 57
3.9 Moruya Showground Precinct – Pressures on Use<br />
Consultation with the various user groups has highlighted many pressures on the facilities within the showground precinct.<br />
Pressures are exerted on this reserve from a number of areas. Most notably, the increasing requirement for better quality facilities <strong>and</strong>/or<br />
upgrading of existing facilities by reserve users. Pedestrian <strong>and</strong> vehicular circulation <strong>and</strong> access during peak use periods can create conflict<br />
due to the informal nature of parking, roadways <strong>and</strong> pedestrian movement. Pedestrian access for golfers across the showground precinct<br />
<strong>and</strong> for the general public across the golf course pose increasing management difficulties in regard to unrestricted access <strong>and</strong> safety.<br />
Pedestrian access across the reserve for both golfers, other reserve users <strong>and</strong> members of the public is vital to the continued successful<br />
shared use of this reserve.<br />
Many of the buildings within the showground precinct are in poor condition. This includes the Pavilion, the Poultry Shed <strong>and</strong> other associated<br />
small buildings. The Management Committee <strong>and</strong> <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council are endeavouring to maintain <strong>and</strong> improve the buildings where<br />
possible, however funding this work is very challenging.<br />
Camping on the reserve occurs in relation to events held over more than one day or where attendees travel great distances to participate. In<br />
general this proves to be a compatible activity due to its brief impact on the reserve, however, some camping does occur over extended<br />
periods by sideshow operators using the showground area as a base for operations during the summer months. This places additional<br />
pressures on facilities <strong>and</strong> services on the reserve not catered for within budgetary constraints.<br />
The availability of useable l<strong>and</strong> within the Showground precinct is limited. In order to address this problem it is proposed that the Golf Club<br />
Maintenance Compound will be relocated to within the lease area of the Golf Course. The Golf Club has committed to relocating its<br />
Maintenance Compound to the south eastern corner of the Golf Course reserve. This was confirmed in writing on 27 December, 2000 with an<br />
undertaking to look at removing the machinery shed from the area in a 5 to 10 year time frame (ie by end of 2010).<br />
Some of the issues creating pressure on the use of the reserve are listed below:<br />
• Lack of space. This will be addressed to some extent when the Golf Club Maintenance Compound relocates from the showground to<br />
the Golf Course in 2010. However, this is an absolute constraint <strong>and</strong> it would be difficult to provide additional space for camping or<br />
parking on the showground.<br />
• The showground precinct is located on a low point <strong>and</strong> thus drainage will always be an issue on the site. However there are<br />
opportunities to improve the drainage in some areas.<br />
• Lack of shelter <strong>and</strong> shade.<br />
• There are problems with power being overload <strong>and</strong> circuits breaking. Although it has been addressed in the past, additional loads on<br />
the power have resulted in some inefficiencies in its use. More power outlets are required for the campers.<br />
These <strong>and</strong> other issues are addressed in more detail in the Action Plan on page 43.<br />
3.10 Native Title<br />
The l<strong>and</strong> covered by this Plan of Management is owned by the Crown. Native Title may be found to exist on this l<strong>and</strong> in the future if native<br />
title has not been extinguished under the terms of The Native Title Act 1993 <strong>and</strong> a valid claim was lodged, accepted for mediation <strong>and</strong><br />
recognised in a process of mediation or court ruling.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 37 of 57
3.<strong>11</strong> Finance<br />
The following information provides a guide on the finances for the Moruya Showground <strong>and</strong> Golf Course as at the date of adoption of this Plan<br />
of Management. These are indicative only.<br />
3.<strong>11</strong>.1 Operating Costs – Moruya Showground Precinct<br />
In 2004/05 <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council <strong>and</strong> the Management Committees spent approximately $20,000 on the Moruya Showground Precinct<br />
on general maintenance which included the following:<br />
• mowing (with the exception of the golf course)<br />
• roadways<br />
• car parks<br />
• underground services<br />
• toilet maintenance (public toilets)<br />
• litter removal<br />
• painting<br />
• building structural maintenance<br />
• security<br />
• utility expenses (rates, water)<br />
• footpaths<br />
The Management Committee funded the following from income derived from the reserve:<br />
• signage<br />
• toilet maintenance (Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>)<br />
• painting<br />
• general building maintenance<br />
• cleaning<br />
• utility expenses (eg. gas, electricity)<br />
3.<strong>11</strong>.2 Sources of Funds<br />
Funds generated from activities on the Moruya Golf Course <strong>and</strong> Showground reserves <strong>and</strong> are re-invested in expenditure on the reserves<br />
included in the Reserve Trust (as per the requirements of the Crown L<strong>and</strong>s Act 1989). Funds are collected by both the Trust Manager<br />
(<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council) <strong>and</strong> the Management Committees. In 2004/05 approximately $<strong>11</strong>,340 was raised from reserve activities. This<br />
was raised from the following sources as follows:<br />
The Golf Course lease area $800 1<br />
The Golf Course Maintenance Compound licence area $2,000<br />
Ground <strong>and</strong> facility hire fees $6,000<br />
Lighting fees $640<br />
Camping fees $1,900<br />
The residential lease for the Caretaker’s cottage generates $5,200 per year for the Trust (<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council). However, his income is<br />
reinvested by paying the Caretaker $100 per week to undertake 4 hours per week of work on the reserve. This includes ground inspections.<br />
Fees <strong>and</strong> charges are proposed by Council in April each year <strong>and</strong> advertised for public comment during May for adoption in June. Fees<br />
charged must be in accordance with Councils adopted Fees & Charges.<br />
The Department of L<strong>and</strong>s administer the Public Reserves Management Fund – Showgrounds. This fund provides a potential source of grant<br />
funds for future developments. The NSW Heritage Office has grant programs that assist with funding works to Heritage Items of State<br />
Significance.<br />
1 At the Ordinary Meeting of Council of Tuesday 24 January 20<strong>06</strong>, Council resolved to offer a fresh lease to the Moruya Golf Club for the golf<br />
course lease area. The lease fee for the year commencing 1 July 2005 was determined to be $6,327.90 + gst with subsequent years<br />
calculated at 2.5% of the sum of 2/3 members’ subscriptions <strong>and</strong> total of green fees as per the Club’s annual reports.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 38 of 57
3.<strong>11</strong>.3 Capital Improvements<br />
Moruya Showground Precinct<br />
Major capital expenditure on new developments have in the past been funded by Council (Crown Reserve Funds) <strong>and</strong> users of the reserve<br />
via income collected by the Management Committees. In some cases applications for grants from Council <strong>and</strong> the State <strong>and</strong> Federal<br />
Governments have been successful.<br />
Caretaker’s Cottage<br />
Improvements to the Caretakers Cottage cost over $4,500 in the period 2000 – 2002. This was funded by the Management Committee using<br />
work for the dole participants for labour.<br />
Moruya Showground Exhibits Pavilion<br />
In response to the Moruya Showground Exhibits Pavilion being in poor condition an architect was engaged to prepare plans for the<br />
rehabilitation <strong>and</strong> renovation of the building. These plans have been completed <strong>and</strong> development approval granted. As at the adoption of this<br />
Plan of Management, the cost for the upgrade of the Exhibits Pavilion is estimated to be at least $355,000. To assist with funding this capital<br />
improvement, the upgrade of the Exhibits Pavilion will be staged as follows.<br />
Stage 1: Kitchen & Meeting Room to lock-up, weatherproofing, structural framing, roofing, cladding, flooring, internal services (electrical,<br />
water, gas, drainage) <strong>and</strong> various structural repairs (completed in January 20<strong>06</strong> – total cost approximately $150,000).<br />
Stage 2: Fit-out of a commercial kitchen, new ver<strong>and</strong>ah (<strong>14</strong>0m2 ver<strong>and</strong>ah construction including: timber, decking, h<strong>and</strong>rails, roofing,<br />
stairways, disabled access <strong>and</strong> painting), interior lining/painting, structural repairs, drainage repairs <strong>and</strong> floor restumping (this<br />
project was underway as at October 20<strong>06</strong> - cost estimate $180,000).<br />
Stage 3: Toilets (included a disabled toilet) (cost estimate $70,000).<br />
Stage 4: Barbecue area (cost estimate $15,000).<br />
As at the date of adoption of this Plan of Management, Stage 2 upgrades were underway.<br />
Moruya Showground Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong><br />
In 20<strong>06</strong>/07 the following works are to be undertaken on the Moruya Showground Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>:<br />
Installation of barrier walls<br />
Repair of stair treads<br />
Exterior re-finishing <strong>and</strong> painting<br />
External Lighting<br />
The total cost of these works is estimated at $63,500.<br />
Future Projects<br />
This Plan of Management identifies many other projects that will require funding in the future. It is anticipated that these projects will be<br />
funded from a variety of sources such as Council funds, Crown Reserve funds, grants, Management Committee funds <strong>and</strong> other fund raising.<br />
Refer to the Action Plan on page 43 <strong>and</strong> the L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan for more details.<br />
Possible sources of grant funds include:<br />
Public Reserves Management Fund (Showgrounds) – NSW Department of L<strong>and</strong>s<br />
Regional Partnerships – Federal Government Department of Transport <strong>and</strong> Regional Services<br />
Heritage Incentives Program – NSW Heritage Office<br />
Heritage Assistance Fund – <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council <strong>and</strong> the NSW Heritage Office<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 39 of 57
4.0 BASIS FOR MANAGEMENT<br />
4.1 Values<br />
Ascertaining the community values of l<strong>and</strong> is identifying what the community finds important <strong>and</strong> special about it. L<strong>and</strong> management issues<br />
change over time, depending on the needs of the community; <strong>and</strong> community’s change – what may be important in the present may be less<br />
important in the future. Values however tend to transcend the everyday issues of l<strong>and</strong> management <strong>and</strong> set a more strategic vision for the<br />
management of the l<strong>and</strong>. Values coexist, augment <strong>and</strong> support each other. Where singular issues may be really important in the short term,<br />
the overriding values attached to the l<strong>and</strong> will tend to be relevant for a longer period.<br />
How can values be implemented in l<strong>and</strong> management? Once values <strong>and</strong> their level of significance are determined, l<strong>and</strong> maintenance <strong>and</strong><br />
development practices that recognise, manage <strong>and</strong> conserve these values may then be implemented. The following values have evolved<br />
through the community consultation process <strong>and</strong> in consideration of the requirements of relevant legislation <strong>and</strong> policies:<br />
Value & description<br />
Scenic<br />
The reserves provide visual relief from the Princes Highway as a significant patch of<br />
maintained l<strong>and</strong>scape. From the surrounding residential areas, the Moruya Golf Club <strong>and</strong><br />
Moruya Showground provide a very pleasant outlook.<br />
Showground<br />
The Moruya Showground is the only showground in the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> local government<br />
area. It is a focus for equestrian <strong>and</strong> dressage events, rodeos <strong>and</strong> sporting activities. The<br />
presence of the Showground strengthens the rural lifestyle <strong>and</strong> character of Moruya.<br />
Recreational<br />
The Moruya Showground precinct is the centre of many recreational pursuits in Moruya <strong>and</strong><br />
occasionally for regional events. Sports such as golf, basketball <strong>and</strong> other indoor sports,<br />
rugby league, touch football, equestrian events <strong>and</strong> Aussie rules, all use the facilities<br />
provided within the showground.<br />
Environmental<br />
The reserves include important wildlife <strong>and</strong> drainage corridors. Racecourse Creek flows<br />
through the reserves <strong>and</strong> forms an integral part of the drainage system, linking with the<br />
Moruya River. The associated riparian vegetation creates a wildlife corridor through the<br />
reserves.<br />
Heritage<br />
The Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>, Exhibits Pavilion, Poultry Pavilion <strong>and</strong> the Showground Precinct have been<br />
identified as having various heritage status as discussed in this Plan of Management.<br />
Pedestrian Access<br />
Pedestrian access through the Moruya Golf Course <strong>and</strong> the Moruya Showground provides<br />
an important link between the township of Moruya <strong>and</strong> the south of town <strong>and</strong> has done for<br />
many years.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 40 of 57<br />
Neighbourhood<br />
- Local<br />
Suburb<br />
District<br />
<br />
<strong>Shire</strong><br />
Regional<br />
State<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Where:<br />
Neighbourhood – Local: the street <strong>and</strong> surrounding streets<br />
Suburb: within the suburb area (ie. within Moruya)<br />
District: the suburb <strong>and</strong> adjacent suburbs (eg. Broulee, Tuross, Mossy Point, Tomakin, South Head etc)<br />
<strong>Shire</strong>: within the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong><br />
Regional: south coast of NSW<br />
State: within the state of NSW<br />
National: within Australia<br />
National
4.2 Role of the Moruya Golf Course & Showground Reserves<br />
The main functions of Moruya Golf Course <strong>and</strong> Showground Reserve are recreation, sporting activities <strong>and</strong> gatherings for social activities. It<br />
is also a valuable urban greenspace within the township of Moruya.<br />
It is the vision of <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council to maintain the existing Golf Course as a leased area <strong>and</strong> to continue to maintain the sporting <strong>and</strong><br />
informal open space of the main part of the reserve for public enjoyment. All improvements will be aimed at increasing the amenity of the area<br />
for these purposes. The Moruya Showground precinct will continue to be the rural events focus of the shire, providing facilities to encourage<br />
rural activities <strong>and</strong> events to enhance the lifestyle <strong>and</strong> character of Moruya.<br />
4.3 Objectives for Management<br />
The management objectives of this Plan of Management are:<br />
• To provide a flexible open space reserve based on community needs <strong>and</strong> within budgetary constraints.<br />
• To protect <strong>and</strong> enhance the natural, scenic <strong>and</strong> heritage qualities of the area.<br />
• To improve the quality of recreational facilities <strong>and</strong> increase the recreational opportunities within the area.<br />
• To protect <strong>and</strong> enhance native vegetation, natural drainage systems <strong>and</strong> wildlife corridors.<br />
• To protect the reserve <strong>and</strong> its facilities from the effects of flooding.<br />
• To ensure that the area is effectively managed <strong>and</strong> sustainably developed for the benefit of all users.<br />
• To provide a safe environment for all users of the study area.<br />
• To maximise the utilisation of the showground facilities<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 41 of 57
5.0 STRATEGIC ACTIONS<br />
5.1 Strategic Plan<br />
All proposed development must meet the following objectives:<br />
• Compliance with appropriate zoning, development <strong>and</strong> building regulations. Relevant building approvals sought for each development.<br />
Owner’s consent is gained for all developments <strong>and</strong> improvements.<br />
• Ensure all proposals are in accordance with the gazetted public purpose of the reserve <strong>and</strong> the principles of Crown L<strong>and</strong> Management<br />
<strong>and</strong> take into account the guidelines in the NSW Coastal Policy <strong>and</strong> other relevant legislation <strong>and</strong> policies.<br />
• That any new facilities are provided as planned within funding constraints. New facilities must be consistent with any Council adopted<br />
plans for local <strong>and</strong> regional recreational uses.<br />
• Heritage values must be considered in any re-development or new developments on the resereve.<br />
• The use of existing facilities must be fully realised before exp<strong>and</strong>ing or adding new facilities. Existing facilities are not to be duplicated<br />
unnecessarily.<br />
• Development to be consistent with the L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan.<br />
5.2 Monitoring Strategic Performance<br />
The success of the strategic plan will be measured by a number of key indicators<br />
• Construction of new or exp<strong>and</strong>ed facilities carried out according to this plan <strong>and</strong> on schedule or as need arises.<br />
• Increased use of facilities.<br />
• Minimal flood damage to the reserve <strong>and</strong> its facilities.<br />
• Additional l<strong>and</strong>scape amenity in key areas.<br />
• Resolution of any conflict in use of existing facilities by Management Committees.<br />
• No conflict in l<strong>and</strong> use for future facilities.<br />
• Improved cooperation between users groups, Management Committees <strong>and</strong> Council.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 42 of 57
6.0 ACTION PLAN<br />
The Action Plan identifies the principal l<strong>and</strong> management issues <strong>and</strong> identifies a set of management strategies <strong>and</strong> actions for each issue. It<br />
provides an ongoing framework for the management of the reserves. These management issues relate to the values of the reserve <strong>and</strong> are<br />
illustrated in the L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan. Each action is given an implementation category.<br />
The following terminology is used in the Action Plan:<br />
Management Issue: The issue that requires a detailed approach to future management<br />
Strategy: The broad management strategy required to address management issue of concern.<br />
Action: The specific actions that address the strategies.<br />
Implementation Priority: Category 1 actions are those that can be implemented immediately or very soon after the adoption of<br />
the Plan. They are policy or procedural matters <strong>and</strong> require minimal or no funding.<br />
Category 2 actions are those that require some funding <strong>and</strong> are principally concerned with protecting<br />
or conserving the values of the reserves, improving public safety or are maintenance <strong>and</strong><br />
imrprovement matters.<br />
Category 3 actions are capital improvement items or items requiring a significant injection of funds.<br />
The timing of their implementation would be dependent on the availability of funds from Council or<br />
external sources such as grants.<br />
Where action will be implemented: MS: For implementation on the Moruya Showground Precinct<br />
GC: For implementation on The Moruya Golf Course<br />
Note aht all priorities are subject to change depending on the availability of Council resources <strong>and</strong> funding availability.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 43 of 57
Management Issue Strategy Action<br />
Implementation<br />
MS GC Priority<br />
6.1 Access – Pedestrian Provide for safe pedestrian access through the reserves. 1. Define <strong>and</strong> maintain pathways to provide for pedestrian access as required. 1<br />
2. Maintain pedestrian refuges on golf course. 1<br />
Minimise impact of pedestrian activity on the golf course. 3. Maintain fencing at south western corner to reduce disruption to play <strong>and</strong> undesirable behaviour. 1<br />
Improve the surface of the ground in the Showground precinct. 4. Grounds to be levelled to best accommodate pedestrian movement around the showground <strong>and</strong> to<br />
adequately address drainage.<br />
2<br />
Provide access for golfers around the golf course where<br />
required.<br />
5. Construct a footpath along Albert Street (along the southern showground precinct frontage) for golfers to<br />
access holes outside of the showground precinct.<br />
2<br />
6.2 Access – Vehicular<br />
Provide adequate parking at the Moruya Showground precinct. 1. Access to parking areas is safe <strong>and</strong> clearly signed. 1<br />
2. Install vehicle barriers/speedhumps where required. 3<br />
3. Formalise existing informal parking areas if required. 3<br />
Provide parking facilities for disabled use. 4. Provide car parking spaces for disabled use within the vicinity of the Equal Access Viewing Shelter <strong>and</strong> 2<br />
the Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>.<br />
Provide adequate parking for the Golf Course. 5. Extend carpark from southern boundary of the Golf Club building into the reserve if dem<strong>and</strong> for parking<br />
is sufficient to require an extension.<br />
2 Moruya Golf Course to develop <strong>and</strong> fund in accordance with Council’s requirements.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 44 of 57<br />
2 2
Management Issue Strategy Action<br />
6.3 Conservation<br />
Management Plan<br />
To implement the recommendations of the Conservation Plan for the Moruya Showground Precinct as follows:<br />
Ack Weyman Oval<br />
• Retain for continued use<br />
• Additional moveable seating acceptable<br />
• Additional shade trees<br />
Ack Weyman Oval Scoreboard<br />
• Retain for continued use<br />
Asset Management – Management Structure & Statutory<br />
Approvals<br />
• Seek appropriate heritage advice on matters relating to all<br />
development within the showground.<br />
• Some issues can be addressed by Council’s heritage<br />
adviser, but in some cases, consultant expertise will need<br />
to be appointed.<br />
• The Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>, Exhibits Pavilion <strong>and</strong> Moruya<br />
Showground Precinct have been nominated for inclusion<br />
on the State Heritage Register.<br />
• Items within the Moruya Showground Precinct can be<br />
altered, demolished, maintained or developed in terms of<br />
the heritage protection provisions of Council’s LEP.<br />
Asset Management – Maintenance<br />
• It is desirable that the high ranking heritage buildings (the<br />
Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> the Exhibits Pavilion) <strong>and</strong> the moderate<br />
ranking buildings (the Poultry Pavilion, Storage Shed <strong>and</strong><br />
Caretaker’s Cottage) be maintained <strong>and</strong> developed with<br />
Implementation<br />
MS GC Priority<br />
1. Maintain Ack Weyman Oval for active recreational use. 1<br />
2. Allow for additional moveable/relocatable seating that meets the relevant st<strong>and</strong>ards as required. 3<br />
3. Shade trees for Ack Weyman Oval included in the L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Planplan <strong>and</strong> proposed Planting<br />
Plan.<br />
2<br />
4. Maintain Ack Weyman Oval Scoreboard for ancillary use to activities on Ack Weyman Oval. 1<br />
5. Heritage advice must be sought from Council’s Heritage Adviser on all development issues within the<br />
Showground precinct.<br />
6. Council’s Heritage Adviser to determine if specialist consultant expertise is required for assessment of<br />
<strong>and</strong>/or assistance with development proposals.<br />
7. Any items listed on the State Heritage Register are provided with greater level of protection. Under<br />
sections 60 or <strong>14</strong>0 of the Heritage Act 1977, the Heritage Office must be notified of any proposed<br />
alteration, damage, development or demolition. Where proposed work does not ‘materially affect’ the<br />
significance of the item, Councils are empowered to make determinations under delegation to approve<br />
the suitability of the proposed work. In the case of Council owning the property, the Heritage Council<br />
may make the determination to avoid conflicts of interest at local level.<br />
8. Ensure that the provisions of Council’s Local Environmental Plan are addressed (refer to page <strong>11</strong> on this<br />
Plan of Management).<br />
9. Heritage advice must be sought from Council’s Heritage Adviser on maintenance issues within the<br />
Showground precinct. The Heritage Adviser may wish to meet with those responsible for maintenance,<br />
<strong>and</strong> co-ordinate mutual objectives for the maintenance of items in the Showground precinct.<br />
10. Council’s Heritage Adviser to determine if specialist consultant expertise is required for assessment of<br />
<strong>and</strong>/or assistance with significant maintenance proposals.<br />
1<br />
1<br />
1<br />
1<br />
1<br />
1<br />
their heritage values in focus. <strong>11</strong>. Future maintenance works in the Moruya Showground Precinct must have regard to the provisions of<br />
the Conservation Management Plan, The Burra Charter <strong>and</strong> as directed by Council’s Heritage Adviser.<br />
1<br />
Bar/Kiosk/Canteen<br />
• Retain surrounding open space<br />
12. Provide for the future replacement of the bar as required <strong>and</strong> as funds become available. Seek Heritage<br />
advice from Council’s Heritage Advisor on the design <strong>and</strong> siting of any new bar facility.<br />
3<br />
• The bar is considered to be an important facility, but its<br />
appearance is poor. A new building is recommended.<br />
• There is a need to recognise this building does not have a<br />
long, useful life ahead, <strong>and</strong> it is recommended that its<br />
replacements be planned<br />
Basketball Stadium/Community Centre<br />
• Conserve in original appearance<br />
13. Maintain the Basketball Stadium/Community Centre for active recreational use <strong>and</strong> use as a Community<br />
Centre.<br />
1<br />
<strong>14</strong>. Ensure that the Basketball Stadium/Community Centre is maintained in its original appearance. 1<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 45 of 57
Management Issue Strategy Action<br />
Implementation<br />
MS GC Priority<br />
Caretaker’s Cottage<br />
15. Maintain the Caretaker’s Cottage in its current location. 1<br />
• Retain in present location.<br />
•<br />
•<br />
Compatible alterations <strong>and</strong> additions are acceptable.<br />
Some internal elements are of heritage interest, but<br />
16. Seek advice from Council’s Heritage Adviser if alterations <strong>and</strong>/or additions are required – Refer also to<br />
Asset Management – Management Structure & Statutory Approvals above.<br />
1<br />
upgrading is possible<br />
Entrance/Ticket Box 1<br />
• The main entrance should be improved to provide a more<br />
17. Improve the sense of arrival to the Showground. 2<br />
inspiring sense of arrival to the facilities, <strong>and</strong> to highlight<br />
the precinct’s heritage values<br />
18. Seek architectural advice from Council’s Heritage Adviser for replacement <strong>and</strong> siting of aTicket Box at<br />
the entrance. Replace existing Ticket Box with new structure.<br />
3<br />
• Replace Ticket Box with improved facility<br />
Exhibits Pavilion<br />
• Complete Heritage Listing Process<br />
19. Seek advice from Council’s Heritage Adviser if alterations <strong>and</strong>/or additions are required – Refer also to<br />
Asset Management – Management Structure & Statutory Approvals above.<br />
1<br />
•<br />
•<br />
•<br />
Remove intrusive elements<br />
Restump with timber stumps at perimeter<br />
Prepare detailed Conservation Management Plan<br />
20. Follow-up with the Heritage Office on status of listing nomination.<br />
21. Complete extensions/renovations as per DA approved plan.<br />
22. Prepare a detailed Moruya Showground Exhibits Pavilion Conservation Management Plan.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
1<br />
3<br />
3<br />
Golf Course Compound<br />
• Formulate strategy for use of the l<strong>and</strong> once the compound<br />
23. The area used as the Golf Course Maintenance Compound will be developed for uses ancillary to the<br />
needs of user groups once the Golf Club relocated by June 2010. Refer to the L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept<br />
3<br />
is relocated by June 2010.<br />
Planplan for more details.<br />
• Record <strong>and</strong> remove<br />
24. Before the compound is relocated, take photographs as a record of the past use of the l<strong>and</strong>. 1<br />
25. The Golf Course Maintenance Compound will be relocated to the south eastern corner of the golf<br />
course. This area must be l<strong>and</strong>scaped to screen the compound as it is located adjacent to the southern<br />
arrival to the township of Moruya.<br />
3<br />
Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong><br />
26. Seek advice from Council’s Heritage Adviser if alterations <strong>and</strong>/or additions are required – Refer also to 1<br />
• The building should be progressively returned to a state Asset Management – Management Structure & Statutory Approvals above.<br />
where its original features are emphasised <strong>and</strong> project the 27. Investigate the opportunity to include a disabled toilet within the building, depending on the strategy to 1<br />
original appearance.<br />
progressively removed the additions <strong>and</strong> block sidewalls.<br />
• Additions <strong>and</strong> block sidewalls are intrusive to the<br />
28. Follow-up with the Heritage Office on status of listing nomination. 1<br />
significance of the building, <strong>and</strong> should be progressively 29. Prepare a detailed Moruya Showground Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> Conservation Management Plan. This plan must 3<br />
removed<br />
consider that the Moruya Showground Precinct Conservation Management Plan recommended that<br />
• Adaptation of the building can proceed, with sensitive<br />
”there is a need to recognise that the gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> additions do not have a long, useful life ahead, <strong>and</strong> it is<br />
architectural guidelines.<br />
recommended that their replacements be planned.” <strong>and</strong> “additions <strong>and</strong> block sidewalls are intrusive to<br />
the significance of the building, <strong>and</strong> should be progressively removed”.<br />
30. Maintain <strong>and</strong> adapt the Moruya Showground Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> as per the Conservation Management Plan.<br />
This may require the removal of additions <strong>and</strong> block sidewalls to the Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>.<br />
3<br />
Grassy Hill (west of Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>)<br />
• Retain <strong>and</strong> continue present use<br />
• Equal access shelter is acceptable<br />
31. Maintain grassy hill area west of Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> as an open grassed area.<br />
32. Install Equal Access Shelter <strong>and</strong> access pathways as per location on the L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Planplan.<br />
Refer to Appendix C for a concept drawing for this structure.<br />
1<br />
2<br />
33. Install pathways to connect the Equal Access Shelter to parking <strong>and</strong> other facilities as appropriate.<br />
Refer to the L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Planplan.<br />
2<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 46 of 57
Management Issue Strategy Action<br />
L<strong>and</strong>scape<br />
• The lack of shade trees restricts full appreciation of the<br />
quality of events at the showground. Shade trees should<br />
be provided in key congregating areas, around the arena,<br />
<strong>and</strong> around the football pitch.<br />
• Exotic species can be considered.<br />
• Prominent eucalypts are a feature of the natural heritage<br />
of the precinct, those with poor health require assessment.<br />
This feature of the l<strong>and</strong>scape’s character should be<br />
enhanced <strong>and</strong> strengthened with new plantings in selected<br />
areas<br />
New Developments<br />
• New buildings will be required to replace those which have<br />
a short life expectancy. It is recommended that concept<br />
designs be prepared for replacement facilities. These will<br />
provide <strong>and</strong> architectural theme, <strong>and</strong> a direction to which<br />
to plan for the future. The new buildings should not be<br />
‘mock heritage’ in design, but use traditional, simple<br />
details <strong>and</strong> materials that result in a pleasing, distinctive<br />
local character.<br />
• New buildings should be separate rather than<br />
amalgamated, in order to sustain the scattered character<br />
of the showground. However, their locations do need to be<br />
carefully considered, to a structured <strong>and</strong> effective plan.<br />
• There is a need to recognise that the lesser buildings<br />
(toilets, gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> additions, bar, horse stalls <strong>and</strong><br />
secretary’s office) do not have a long, useful life ahead,<br />
<strong>and</strong> it is recommended that their replacements be<br />
planned.<br />
34. Prepare a Planting Plan for the Moruya Showground Precinct to complement the L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept<br />
Planplan. The Planting Plan is to include:<br />
• Retention of existing vegetation where appropriate<br />
• Erosion control<br />
• Planting for shade in key congregating areas, around the Showground Arena <strong>and</strong> around Ack<br />
Weyman Oval<br />
• Planting in car parking areas<br />
• Consideration of both native <strong>and</strong> exotic planting<br />
• Enhancing the native Eucalypt character of the showground.<br />
• Shade tree planting around the perimeter of the Showground Arena to improve the amenity of the<br />
area, as well as emphasise its circular character<br />
35. New <strong>and</strong> replacement buildings are to be sited on the Showground Precinct to ensure that the<br />
‘scattered’ character of the Showground is preserved.<br />
Implementation<br />
MS GC Priority<br />
2<br />
1<br />
36. Prepare architectural designs by a suitably experienced Heritage Architect for new <strong>and</strong> replacement<br />
buildings as required <strong>and</strong> as funds become available, including:<br />
3<br />
• Commentator’s Box (incorporating a scoreboard)<br />
• Bar/Kiosk/Canteen<br />
• Equal Access Viewing Shelter (refer to the section on the Grassy Hill (west of Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>) <strong>and</strong><br />
Appendix C for more information)<br />
• Secretary’s Office<br />
• Stables<br />
Siting of the buildings is to maintain the scatter character of the showground.<br />
37. Public toilets to be demolished. There are other toilet facilities located in the basketball stadium <strong>and</strong><br />
gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> the plans for the upgrade of the Exhibits Pavilion include toilets.<br />
1<br />
38. Ensure photographic records are taken of all structures prior to removal or renovation. 1<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 47 of 57
Management Issue Strategy Action<br />
Northern axis to Town Centre<br />
• There is an opportunity to enhance the pedestrian <strong>and</strong><br />
cycling link with the addition of suitable trees, <strong>and</strong> possibly<br />
some improvements to path alignment. These should be<br />
achievable without adverse impact on the golf course.<br />
The result should be to emphasise this axis, <strong>and</strong> increase<br />
a focus on the arena <strong>and</strong> a better northern entrance to the<br />
showground. It will also strengthen the visual connection<br />
to the town centre <strong>and</strong> local topographical features at the<br />
north <strong>and</strong> southern ends of the axis..<br />
• The ‘Pink Gates’, which are located on this axis, have an<br />
historic association with the showground, <strong>and</strong> this report<br />
supports their reconstruction. It is understood that a<br />
surviving gate is available for reference, <strong>and</strong> the<br />
reconstruction should be accurate <strong>and</strong> authentic, rather<br />
than a poor imitation.<br />
Poultry Pavilion<br />
• The CMP has found that the poultry pavilion warrants<br />
inclusion on the Heritage Schedule of the LEP. It is the<br />
major building that expresses the spirit of functional<br />
improvisation used by the Show Society to establish <strong>and</strong><br />
consolidate the activities of the Agricultural Show.<br />
• Retain for continued use<br />
• Need to monitor condition of timber <strong>and</strong> corrosion of steel<br />
components<br />
Public Toilets<br />
• Formulate strategy for new facilities<br />
• Record <strong>and</strong> remove<br />
Rodeo Yards<br />
• Retain examples of timber elements of interest<br />
Stables<br />
• Formulate strategy for new facilities if required<br />
• Record <strong>and</strong> remove/replace<br />
Secretary’s Office<br />
• Formulate strategy for new facilities<br />
• Record <strong>and</strong> remove<br />
Implementation<br />
MS GC Priority<br />
39. Refer to Section Section 5.4 Conservation Management Plan – L<strong>and</strong>scape in regard to the preparation<br />
of a Planting Plan for the Moruya Showground Precinct which include more details on strengthening the<br />
north - south axis link to town.<br />
2<br />
40. Refer to the L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Planplan for an illustration of the north – south axis link to town. 2<br />
41. Re-instate the pink gates at the northern end of the north – south axis link to town. 2<br />
42. Retain <strong>and</strong> maintain the Poultry Pavilion in its current location. 1<br />
43. Assess heritage significance for possible inclusion on Council’s LEP as a heritage item <strong>and</strong> possible<br />
nomination to the NSW Heritage Office for inclusion on the State Heritage Register.<br />
1<br />
44. Refer to New Developments. 3<br />
45. Retain <strong>and</strong> maintain Rodeo Yards for use in association with equestrian <strong>and</strong> rodeo events. 1<br />
46. Refer to New Developments. 3<br />
47. Refer to New Developments. 3<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 48 of 57
Management Issue Strategy Action<br />
Implementation<br />
MS GC Priority<br />
Showground Arena<br />
• The arena is a key feature of the showground, <strong>and</strong> should<br />
be protected as a space to continue its present uses.<br />
• Shade tree planting around the perimeter would improve<br />
the amenity of the area, as well as emphasise the circular<br />
character<br />
• No buildings or permanent structures should be permitted<br />
48. Retain <strong>and</strong> maintain the Showground Arena for equestrian, rodeo <strong>and</strong> other agricultural show activities.<br />
49. Refer to Section 5.4 Conservation Management Plan – L<strong>and</strong>scape in regard to the preparation of a<br />
Planting Plan for the Moruya Showground Precinct which will include more details in regard to planting<br />
around the Showground Arena.<br />
50. No buildings or permanent structures will be permitted in or around the Showground Arena.<br />
51. Future fencing requirements must be assessed in consultation with Council’s Heritage Adviser.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
1<br />
2<br />
1<br />
3<br />
• Future fencing requirements be allowed on merit<br />
Showground Precinct<br />
• Complete Heritage Listing Process<br />
• Develop Conservation Strategies for high ranking<br />
buildings<br />
• Develop program for replacement of lesser buildings<br />
• Commence L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Planplan<br />
• Develop concepts for main entrance<br />
• An improved entrance at the northern end will provide<br />
some sense of arrival into the showground. This could be<br />
achieved with a gate structure with special design<br />
treatment<br />
52. Follow-up with the Heritage Office on status of listing nomination.<br />
53. Prepare Conservation Management Plans for the Exhibits Pavilion (refer to Exhibits Pavilion above) <strong>and</strong><br />
the Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> (refer to Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> above).<br />
54. Refer to New Developments in regard to the lesser buildings (toilets, gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> additions, bar, horse<br />
stalls <strong>and</strong> secretary’s office).<br />
55. Refer to Entrance/Ticket Box 1 for main entrance actions <strong>and</strong> priorities.<br />
56. Refer to the L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Planplan for an improved entrance at the northern end of the<br />
Showground. Seek architectural advice <strong>and</strong>/or advice from Council’s Heritage Adviser on the design of<br />
a gate structure for this entrance.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
1<br />
3<br />
3<br />
2<br />
Storage Shed<br />
57. Maintain Storage Shed in its current location. 1<br />
• Conserve for continued use as storage, or possible new,<br />
small scale, compatible use<br />
58. Use of Storage Shed to be flexible. <br />
Ticket Box 2 (near the bar)<br />
59. Refer to New Developments. <br />
• Formulate strategy for new facilities if required<br />
• Record <strong>and</strong> remove/replace<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 49 of 57
Management Issue Strategy Action<br />
Implementation<br />
MS GC Priority<br />
6.4 Environmental<br />
Management<br />
To maintain <strong>and</strong> enhance the biodiversity of the reserve. 1.<br />
2.<br />
Protect habitats where possible.<br />
Reinstate habitats or ecological systems where possible.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
1<br />
2<br />
3. Identify <strong>and</strong> maintain wildlife corridors on the reserves. 2<br />
4. Revegetate the riparian zone of Racecourse Creek 10m from the to of bank wherever possible, within<br />
the constraints of the golf course <strong>and</strong> the activities of the showground.<br />
To maintain <strong>and</strong> protect existing vegetation on the reserves. 5. Ensure that all vegetation removal <strong>and</strong>/or pruning is in accordance with approvals granted as per<br />
Council’s Tree Preservation Order.<br />
1<br />
To manage the impact of flooding <strong>and</strong> stormwater on the<br />
reserves.<br />
6. Maintain Racecourse Creek as required to allow for stormwater flow capacity <strong>and</strong> to minimise erosion<br />
<strong>and</strong> bank instability.<br />
1<br />
7. Maintain dams as nutrient/sediment traps. 1<br />
8. Prepare a flood evacuation plan for the Moruya Golf Course. 3<br />
9. Prepare a flood evacuation plan for the Showground Precinct. 3<br />
10. Ensure recreational areas are inspected prior to use to ensure that they can be used safely <strong>and</strong> with<br />
minimal damage to playing fields after rain <strong>and</strong>/or following submersion due to flooding. Access to flood<br />
prone recreational areas is to be restricted during severe/prolonged wet periods.<br />
1<br />
To ensure that the management of the golf course complies<br />
with the regulative <strong>and</strong> legislative requirements.<br />
<strong>11</strong>. Moruya Golf Club to complete an Environmental Management Plan for the Golf Course to ensure that<br />
effluent re-use, stormwater management, irrigation, nutrient monitoring <strong>and</strong> management, vegetation<br />
management, erosion control, stormwater particulate levels, water retention <strong>and</strong> pesticide use is<br />
managed in accordance with World Best Practice. Water quality of Racecourse Creek to meet desired<br />
st<strong>and</strong>ards.<br />
1<br />
To preserve <strong>and</strong> enhance the l<strong>and</strong>scape character to maximise<br />
the recreational, aesthetic <strong>and</strong> environmental values of the<br />
12. Refer to Section 5.4 Conservation Management Plan – L<strong>and</strong>scape in regard to the preparation of a<br />
Planting Plan for the Moruya Showground Precinct.<br />
2<br />
reserves. 13. Moruya Golf Club to develop a planting plan or concept for the golf course. 2<br />
6.5 Management<br />
Fees 2. Fees for the hire/use of all facilities in the Showground Precinct to be included in Council’s Fees <strong>and</strong><br />
Charges.<br />
Maintenance 3. The maintenance of the facilities in the Showground Precinct may be shared between Council, the<br />
Caretaker <strong>and</strong> the user groups.<br />
Management Committees 4. The Moruya Showground Management Committee <strong>and</strong>/or the Moruya Basketball Stadium Management<br />
Committee may be dissolved in the future. At that time, Council will work closely with the professional<br />
sporting associations <strong>and</strong> the user groups in the management <strong>and</strong> development of the showground.<br />
Sports Liaison Committee 5. Sporting activities are to be managed strategically in accordance with the direction of Council’s Sport’s<br />
Liaison Committee.<br />
V<strong>and</strong>alism<br />
13. Provide <strong>and</strong> maintain a Caretaker’s Cottage on the Showground precinct to improve passive<br />
surveillance of the Showground Precinct.<br />
7. Continue to employ an on-site Caretaker at the Showground whose responsibilities may include regular<br />
inspections of the Showground Precinct.<br />
1<br />
1<br />
1<br />
1<br />
1<br />
1<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 50 of 57
Management Issue Strategy Action<br />
6.6 Recreation – Ack<br />
Weyman Oval<br />
6.7 Recreation –<br />
Basketball<br />
Stadium/Community<br />
Centre<br />
6.8 Recreation –<br />
Camping<br />
Maintain for use an active recreational facility available for use<br />
by the general public.<br />
Maintain for use as an active recreational facility <strong>and</strong> as a<br />
Community Centre available for use by the general public.<br />
To allow for temporary, event related camping.<br />
6.9 Recreation – Golf To provide a quality golf course that is well maintained <strong>and</strong> well<br />
patronaged.<br />
6.10 Recreation –<br />
Showground Arena<br />
6.<strong>11</strong> Services<br />
Implementation<br />
MS GC Priority<br />
1. Regular inspection of fields <strong>and</strong> maintain as required. 1<br />
1. Regular inspections of building <strong>and</strong> facilities <strong>and</strong> maintain as required. 1<br />
2. Investigate the opportunity for public art on the exterior walls of the Basketball Stadium/Community<br />
Centre. Subject to the requirements of Council’s Public Art Policy.<br />
3<br />
3. Investigate the opportunity to provide a disabled toilet within the building. 1<br />
1. Event organisers to secure temporary approvals for camping on the reserve as per the requirements of<br />
the Local Government (Manufactured Home Estates, Caravan Parks, Camping Grounds <strong>and</strong> Moveable<br />
Dwellings) Regulation 2005.<br />
1<br />
2. Event organiser to comply with Council’s Special Events Policy. 1<br />
3. Event organiser to provide facilities are required by Council. This could include the provision of<br />
temporary toilets <strong>and</strong> showers, provision of facilities for waste collection <strong>and</strong> removal <strong>and</strong> any other<br />
requirements as directed by Council.d<br />
1<br />
4. Council Rangers will be requested to investigate any illegal camping on the reserve. <br />
<br />
1<br />
1. Continue to lease the l<strong>and</strong> to the Moruya Golf Club for use as a Golf Course <strong>and</strong> to support activities<br />
ancillary to the management of the golf course.<br />
1<br />
To manage the Showground Arena primarily for events related 1. Regular inspection of condition of fields <strong>and</strong> maintained as required. 1<br />
to equestrian, rodeo <strong>and</strong> ‘show’ events. 2. Arena to be remediated after use to ensure it is available for all user groups in safe <strong>and</strong> useable condition. 1<br />
Maintain lights for use on Ack Weyman Oval, the Showground<br />
<strong>and</strong> the Rodeo Ring.<br />
1.<br />
2.<br />
Provide tokens for sale for uninterrupted operation of lights.<br />
Maintain lights for year round use as required.<br />
<br />
<br />
1<br />
1<br />
Provide access to water <strong>and</strong> power in appropriate locations. 3. Provide powerpoints in powerboxes or attached to power poles for access to power for circus, ‘side<br />
show alley’, entrance ticket booth, exterior of the basketball stadium, along the western <strong>and</strong> northern<br />
fences, camping activities etc to avoid extension leads running across roads.<br />
2<br />
4. Provide water as required.<br />
6.12 Signage To provide a coordinated approach to signage.<br />
1. Develop a Signage Strategy for the Moruya Showground Precinct in consultation with the user groups<br />
that indicates the location of signs including, but not limited to: arrival, general way finding, general<br />
information, interpretive information, facilities/amenities locations, pedestrian <strong>and</strong> vehicle access.<br />
Include a st<strong>and</strong>ard for the construction of all signs to ensure that signs are consistent in their form, font,<br />
colour, material, size <strong>and</strong> use of br<strong>and</strong>ing.<br />
2. Install signage as per the locations on the Signage Strategy. Where additional signage is deemed<br />
required beyond what is indicated in the Signage Plan, this will be resolved in consultation with Council<br />
<strong>and</strong> the user groups.<br />
3. Entrance signage should: identify clearly the “place” <strong>and</strong> its entrance, list the various facilities <strong>and</strong><br />
amenities, inform members of the public of current <strong>and</strong> forthcoming events, direct traffic to off-site<br />
parking <strong>and</strong>/or other access points at appropriate timesf.<br />
3<br />
3<br />
3<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 51 of 57
Management Issue Strategy Action<br />
Implementation<br />
MS GC Priority<br />
6.13 Weed Management Remove all weed species that are either declared Noxious<br />
Weeds (as per the Noxious Weeds Act 1993) or are identified<br />
1. Council’s Noxious Weeds Officer advised of noxious weeds <strong>and</strong> appropriate action taken to remove<br />
therm.<br />
1<br />
as Environmental Weeds (as per the Weeds of NSW South<br />
Coast booklet).<br />
2.<br />
3.<br />
Moruya Golf Club responsible for the removal of identified noxious weeds on the golf course.<br />
Progressively remove all other identified weeds from the reserve. <br />
<br />
<br />
1<br />
1<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 52 of 57
7.0 MANAGEMENT ACTIONS – The L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan<br />
7.1 The L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan – Overview<br />
The L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan illustrates the main proposals of the Plan of Management. It gives an indication of approximately where<br />
developments may take place, defines how pedestrians <strong>and</strong> vehicles move through the site, highlights what improvements need to be made<br />
<strong>and</strong> identifies the main activities on the reserves.<br />
It provides a visual summary of the Plan of Management as a guide for future development. To enable the construction of the elements<br />
proposed in the L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan, more planning is required to prepare more detailed layout designs, planting plans, architectural<br />
plans <strong>and</strong> construction drawings. For this reason the plan is named a ‘Concept’ Plan, indicating that more detailed investigation <strong>and</strong> design<br />
work is required to facilitate the development. It is likely that changes will be made to the plan, however any changes will be in keeping with<br />
the intent of the Plan of Management <strong>and</strong> the Moruya Showground Conservation Plan.<br />
There are two L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plans:<br />
1. L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan – Moruya Showground <strong>and</strong> Golf Course<br />
This plan illustrates proposals for the reserve containing the Moruya Golf Course<br />
2. L<strong>and</strong>scape Concept Plan – Moruya Showground<br />
This plan illustrates in more detail the proposals for the Moruya Showground<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 53 of 57
Appendix A: Stakeholders <strong>and</strong> User Groups<br />
Moruya Golf Course & Showground DRAFT Plan of Management<br />
ORGANISATION FACILITIES USED<br />
Campbell Page Employment <strong>and</strong> Training Exhibits Pavilion<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District Show Society Inc All facilities except Golf Course<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Dressage Association Showground Arena, Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>, Horse yards, Stables<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Equestrian Society Inc Showground Arena, Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>, Stables, Horse yards<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Light Horse Troop Showground Arena<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Showjumping Association Showground Arena, Horse yards<br />
Moruya & District Antique Tractor & Machinery Association Inc Showground Arena <strong>and</strong> Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong><br />
Moruya Amateur Basketball Association Basketball Stadium <strong>and</strong> carpark<br />
Moruya Amateur Rugby League Football Club Ack Weyman Oval, Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> amenities <strong>and</strong> Exhibits Pavilion<br />
Moruya District Poultry Club inc Poultry Pavilion<br />
Moruya Golf Club Ltd Golf course, Maintenance shed <strong>and</strong> compound<br />
Moruya Junior Rubgy League Ack Weyman Oval, Exhibits Pavilion<br />
Moruya Martial Arts Aikido Club Exhibits Pavilion <strong>and</strong> carpark<br />
Moruya Over 30’s Touch Football Association Ack Wayman Oval, Pavilion<br />
Moruya Pony Club Inc Showground, stables, horse yards <strong>and</strong> gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong><br />
Moruya Rotary Club Various<br />
Moruya Showground Management Committee All facilities except Golf Course<br />
Moruya Surf Lifesaving Association Showground<br />
Moruya Touch Association inc Ack Weyman Oval <strong>and</strong> Exhibits Pavilion<br />
Moruya Women’s Touch Football Ack Weyman Oval<br />
Moruya Youth Club inc Exhibits Pavilion<br />
Rodeo Association of Moruya Inc Rodeo ground <strong>and</strong> yards <strong>and</strong> portable seating<br />
Scout Association Exhibits Pavilion, Ack Weyman Oval, Showground Arena<br />
Showground Caretaker’s Cottage Tenant Showground Caretaker’s Cottage<br />
Tomago River Crows Ack Weyman Oval<br />
Appendix B: References<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council Local Environment Plan 1999<br />
John Armes & Associates – Moruya Showground Precinct Conservation Management Plan, 2005.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 56 of 57
Appendix C: Equal Access Shelter concept drawing<br />
As per John Armes & Associates – Moruya Showground Precinct Conservation Management Plan, 2005.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> Council & Department of L<strong>and</strong>s Page 57 of 57
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
1 <strong>11</strong> April,<br />
20<strong>06</strong><br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
Alice Br<strong>and</strong>jes<br />
Heritage Council of<br />
NSW<br />
Locked Bag 5020<br />
PARRAMATTA<br />
NSW 2124<br />
Thank you for referring the above mentioned Draft Plan of Management to the NSW Heritage Office for comment<br />
which was received on 2 March 20<strong>06</strong>. The documentation submitted with the application has been reviewed <strong>and</strong> the<br />
following comments are provided.<br />
It is noted that the properties that are the subject of the draft Plan are listed as heritage item of State significance<br />
under the provisions of the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Urban Local Environmental Plan (LEP) <strong>and</strong> have been nominated for listing of<br />
the NSW State Heritage Register (still pending). It is further noted that a Conservation Management Plan (CMP) was<br />
prepared for these sites.<br />
The draft Plan of Management has considered these listings <strong>and</strong> the recommendations of the CMP <strong>and</strong> includes<br />
appropriate provisions <strong>and</strong> strategies for the ongoing conservation <strong>and</strong> management of the subject sites. The draft<br />
Plan makes reference to the CMP <strong>and</strong> this is supported as a best practice process. Accordingly, no objection is<br />
raised to the draft Plan on this basis <strong>and</strong> the intentions of the draft Plan are supported.<br />
There is no need to return the draft Plan to the Heritage Office for comment unless the Plan is further amended as a<br />
result of the submissions received ruing the public exhibition period. If the Plan is changed, the Heritage Office<br />
requests that the Plan be returned for review <strong>and</strong> the following documentation provided for assessment:<br />
A copy of the draft Plan with any amendments highlighted;<br />
A copy of the Council Report <strong>and</strong> Council resolution (including justification as to why the changes are considered<br />
necessary <strong>and</strong>/or appropriate); <strong>and</strong><br />
Any other information that will assist in the consideration of the draft Plan.<br />
Inclusion of the above information will ensure that your draft Plan of Management can be assessed quickly.<br />
I trust these comments are of assistance. If you require any additional information please contact Alice Br<strong>and</strong>jes on<br />
(02) 9873 8500.<br />
The Draft Plan of<br />
Management is supported by<br />
the Heritage Council of<br />
NSW.<br />
A copy of the final plan will<br />
be sent to them, highlighted<br />
with changes. A copy of the<br />
report to Council <strong>and</strong><br />
subsequent resolution will<br />
also be forwarded to them.<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 1 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
2 21 April,<br />
20<strong>06</strong><br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District<br />
Show Society<br />
PO Box 1<br />
MORUYA NSW<br />
2537<br />
Suggestions for the Showground Entrance, Albert Street, Moruya<br />
As requested at the February Management Committee meeting, our suggestions for upgrading the main showground<br />
entrance are listed below <strong>and</strong> photographs of the existing area - with comments highlighted - are attached for your<br />
ease of reference.<br />
We single out the main entrance at this stage as it presents the opportunity to “set the tone” for visitors entering the<br />
site. We believe the entrance should signal the <strong>Shire</strong>’s acknowledgement of the value of such a place to the<br />
community <strong>and</strong> consequently, its visual impact should reflect the community’s pride in the showground’s significant<br />
social, cultural <strong>and</strong> historical importance.<br />
At another level, it is generally acknowledged that areas with high presentation st<strong>and</strong>ards are less subject to the<br />
effects of anti-social behaviour - littering, bad behaviour, public drunkenness, v<strong>and</strong>alism, etc. In regard to this, we<br />
want every practical step to be taken to minimise such activities on the Showground.<br />
Naturally, we would like to see these visual <strong>and</strong> practical improvements in the entrance area being made in line with<br />
several other, much-needed enhancements throughout the whole site – we would be happy to discuss these with you<br />
during our proposed on-site inspections.<br />
General Impact <strong>and</strong> Information<br />
Photos 1, 2 <strong>and</strong> 5 illustrate the lack of positive features in the present entrance area.<br />
It is easy to drive past without realising where the entry point is, <strong>and</strong> the only signage visible for passing traffic is<br />
incomplete, faces one direction only, is relatively small <strong>and</strong> is in poor repair.<br />
In reality, at first sight, the poor state of the existing sign, the Community Centre building walls <strong>and</strong> the lack of<br />
continuity of the eastern kerb easily create a negative impression on visitors not to mention the lack of information<br />
available.<br />
A quality sign with more impact is required to -<br />
identify clearly the “place” <strong>and</strong> its entrance<br />
list the various facilities <strong>and</strong> amenities<br />
The Draft Plan of<br />
Management provides for<br />
entrance signage – as<br />
illustrated on the L<strong>and</strong>scape<br />
Masterplan <strong>and</strong> in the<br />
Operational Plan at page 51.<br />
The specific requirements for<br />
the entrance sign will be<br />
added to the final Plan of<br />
Management in Section 6.12<br />
of the Operational Plan.<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 2 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
inform members of the public of current <strong>and</strong> forthcoming events<br />
direct traffic to off-site parking <strong>and</strong>/or other access points at appropriate times.<br />
At present there is no physical feature that strongly identifies “arrival”. Apart from the suggested improved signage,<br />
something like a stone fence, archway, garden, carving (or whatever) is needed as a “gr<strong>and</strong> gateway” to the site.<br />
Practicality <strong>and</strong> Safety<br />
See photos 3 <strong>and</strong> 4<br />
A ticket booth is sited on the western side of the access roadway with a very narrow passage between it <strong>and</strong> the low<br />
fence in line with the gatepost. It would be prudent to check the width of the passageway beside the booth <strong>and</strong> the<br />
fenced footpath to the south to ensure compliance with any relevant st<strong>and</strong>ards for pedestrian <strong>and</strong> wheelchair access,<br />
etc.<br />
The booth is 2400 long x 1200 wide <strong>and</strong> is a freest<strong>and</strong>ing shed without a lockable door or window. There is no internal<br />
electrical power connection <strong>and</strong> proximity lighting would be inadequate for after dark functions requiring the use of the<br />
booth.<br />
For some events, when the gates are closed to vehicle access, this arrangement is quite satisfactory - although it<br />
could be said that turnstiles would enable better control <strong>and</strong>, if installed at the eastern end of the gates, could provide<br />
the separation of arriving <strong>and</strong> departing pedestrians.<br />
When vehicular traffic is allowed on site during events, a centrally positioned booth would be safer <strong>and</strong> more practical<br />
<strong>and</strong> is recommended. There appears to be sufficient width of roadway to accommodate, say, a 1000–1200 wide<br />
central isl<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> gatehouse by relocating the eastern gatepost <strong>and</strong> incorporating locking points on the new<br />
gatehouse. While not suggested at this time, the ultimate extension of this concept might be the installation of boom<br />
gates controlled by the “gate keeper”.<br />
In any case, for both safety <strong>and</strong> aesthetics -<br />
the footpath leading to the existing ticket booth should be properly formed<br />
lighting <strong>and</strong> power should be supplied to the booth/s<br />
area lighting in the gate vicinity should be upgraded<br />
The Draft Plan of<br />
Management includes a<br />
concrete footpath from Albert<br />
Street to the Basketball<br />
Stadium.<br />
The final Plan of<br />
Management will provide for<br />
the provision of power to the<br />
ticket booth. See Section<br />
6.<strong>11</strong>.<br />
A centrally positioned booth<br />
is not supported by Council’s<br />
Traffic Engineer due to<br />
safety <strong>and</strong> costing<br />
considerations. The<br />
infrequent use of the facility<br />
(2-3 times per year) would<br />
not support the expenditure<br />
of funds to build such a<br />
structure. It would require<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 3 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
the over head power lines should be checked for vehicle clearances<br />
provision should be made at the gate for appropriate, alterable signage for event management – admission<br />
prices, etc – as well as permanent speed signs <strong>and</strong> general directional messages.<br />
Drainage<br />
The kerb <strong>and</strong> guttering stops near the eastern gatepost <strong>and</strong> adjacent to the informal pathway used by golfers. After<br />
rain, the area along the fence line becomes very boggy due to inadequate drainage.<br />
This should be addressed in conjunction with overcoming the aesthetic deficiency mentioned above.<br />
Art <strong>and</strong> Culture<br />
There is any opportunity to provide space on the Community Centre walls for mural art works reflecting the art <strong>and</strong><br />
cultural flavours of the <strong>Shire</strong> – as well as hiding the shabby walls!<br />
An indigenous art statement – mixed with agricultural <strong>and</strong> pastoral images relevant to the showground - would not be<br />
out of place.<br />
We hope that you will agree with the thrust of these suggestions <strong>and</strong> that you will encourage <strong>and</strong> facilitate any further<br />
consultation with whichever groups are involved to achieve a satisfactory outcome for the gateway to our <strong>Shire</strong>’s only<br />
Showground.<br />
We trust, too, that you will note that our raising these matters is less motivated by attaining direct benefits to our<br />
Society than by the desire to promote the Showground acknowledging its past, present <strong>and</strong> potential contributions to<br />
our <strong>Shire</strong>.<br />
road widening, the<br />
construction of a concrete<br />
isl<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> the installation of<br />
protective bollards. Funds<br />
could be more efficiently<br />
spent on other projects,<br />
especially considering the<br />
limited funds available.<br />
Drainage issues will be<br />
addressed when the new<br />
internal roadway is<br />
considered.<br />
The provision of mural art<br />
works is supported <strong>and</strong> will<br />
be added to the Plan of<br />
Management. This would,<br />
however, be subject to the<br />
requirements of Council’s<br />
Public Art Policy. Refer to<br />
Section 6.7.<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 4 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
3 24 April,<br />
20<strong>06</strong><br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
APAC Committee<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong><br />
Council<br />
The committees comments on the plans of Management for the Moruya Golf Course <strong>and</strong> Showground Reserves:<br />
• Pedestrian access to major on-site buildings: members felt that a pathway, at least to the toilets, viewing<br />
platform <strong>and</strong> gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> was of major importance <strong>and</strong> should be included in the plan.<br />
• There was also a point raised about whether there was any consideration given to providing a level <strong>and</strong><br />
accessible walkway around the actual arena itself.<br />
• For some members of the public, the Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> proposed viewing platform may be too far away.<br />
• Disabled parking spaces: location , number <strong>and</strong> the actual pathway access to <strong>and</strong> from the parking areas.<br />
The committee members strongly recommend that a protocol be established <strong>and</strong> presented to any organisation<br />
wishing to use the showground, regardless of the event, stating that disabled parking was reserved for people<br />
who qualify to park there. Furthermore that an area, close to the activity or event be set aside for drop-off only.<br />
This is to ensure the elderly <strong>and</strong> people with disabilities still have access to the showground arena <strong>and</strong> / or<br />
football field, if the disabled parking spaces are full.<br />
• The committee have been informed that the parking around the football field is uneven <strong>and</strong> gravel <strong>and</strong> that the<br />
only task Council could do there was sign-post disabled parking spaces.<br />
The final Plan of<br />
Management will provide for<br />
pathways connecting the<br />
toilets with the viewing<br />
platform <strong>and</strong> to the Pavilion<br />
which will, when funds<br />
become available, include a<br />
disabled toilet.<br />
The construction of a<br />
footpath around the arena is<br />
not supported as will inhibit<br />
the use of the showground<br />
for rural events such as<br />
equestrian <strong>and</strong> show events<br />
for which the arena has been<br />
developed.<br />
The gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong><br />
proposed viewing platform<br />
are located as close to the<br />
arena as possible given the<br />
l<strong>and</strong>form constraints.<br />
Council’s Recreation<br />
Coordinator has been<br />
advised of this concern so<br />
that it can be incorporated in<br />
the next review of Council’s<br />
Event Policy.<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 5 of 21<br />
Noted.
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
• Accessible toilets: There was no mention in the proposed draft for new accessible toilets, however committee<br />
members are aware that an accessible toilet will be located in the facility behind where the Bar is currently<br />
located. This facility will have a ramp for access. Public toilets in the Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> near the storage shed are<br />
to be upgraded <strong>and</strong> a covered walkway is proposed between the toilets <strong>and</strong> the pavilion.<br />
• Uneven ground from car-park to all the facilities within the showground: While it is acknowledged that it<br />
would be extremely difficult to have walkways <strong>and</strong> pathways link all of the facilities, the committee believe it is a<br />
priority to address the pedestrian access for all, as it was not highlighted on the Plan.<br />
The new Pavilion extension<br />
includes a disabled toilet,<br />
however there are<br />
insufficient funds to complete<br />
this at this stage.<br />
The final Plan will<br />
recommend that the toilets at<br />
the rear of the gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong><br />
<strong>and</strong> the basketball court be<br />
considered to be upgraded<br />
to provide disabled access at<br />
the next review of the Public<br />
Toilet Strategy. See Section<br />
6.7 & 6.3<br />
The grounds around the<br />
facilities in the showground<br />
are not at consistent grades.<br />
The Plan of Management will<br />
provide that the grounds be<br />
levelled to best<br />
accommodate pedestrian<br />
movement around the<br />
showground <strong>and</strong> adequately<br />
address drainage. See<br />
Section 6.1.4.<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 6 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
4 17 March,<br />
20<strong>06</strong><br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
John Cornall<br />
President<br />
Moruya Tuross<br />
JRLFC<br />
4 Queen Street<br />
MORUYA NSW<br />
2537<br />
Whilst I am aware that the closing date for submissions has lapsed, I would appreciate consideration of the following<br />
points in regard to how the plan affects Ack Weyman Oval.<br />
The tree plantings on the north western corner of the oval, severely restricts the seating capacity of the ground.<br />
Currently this area is occupied by temporary gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>s which are increased when larger crowds are<br />
anticipated. The temporary gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>s on the southern end are poorly utilised as this is an unpopular place to<br />
watch the game. Reduced seating capacity reduces our club’s ability to vie for big fixtures such as representative<br />
games <strong>and</strong> NRL pre-season trials.<br />
The shelter for ground management sited on the south-western corner would be greatly appreciated, however<br />
the positioning could be more appropriate. Currently we provide a table, seating <strong>and</strong> shelter on the half way line<br />
on the western side for the ground manager <strong>and</strong> officials. These items must be provided by the club <strong>and</strong> are of a<br />
temporary nature so that they can be removed after each use. The positioning of the proposed shelter in this<br />
location would be of real benefit to the ground user groups, <strong>and</strong> is the appropriate position from which to control<br />
the ground. [near ½ way line – there is an existing concrete slab.]<br />
I thank you for your consideration of the matters raised <strong>and</strong> hope that implementation of the Plan of Management will<br />
benefit all users <strong>and</strong> the <strong>Shire</strong> as a whole.<br />
The proposed tree plantings<br />
at the north western corner<br />
of Ack Weyman Oval are at<br />
10m spacings so the<br />
temporary gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>s<br />
(which are approximately<br />
4.2m wide) will easily fit in<br />
between the trees. This was<br />
discussed during the<br />
exhibition of the first draft,<br />
hence the location of the<br />
trees at 10m spacings.<br />
Support for the location of<br />
the shelter at the south<br />
western corner is noted.<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 7 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
5 5 June<br />
20<strong>06</strong><br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> District<br />
Show Society<br />
PO Box 1<br />
MORUYA NSW<br />
2537<br />
The society would like to express thanks to those involved in the formulation of the Draft Plan of Management – their<br />
efforts to improve the area <strong>and</strong> to address many concerns of the past <strong>and</strong> present are very much appreciated.<br />
We believe that the provision of the new signage, improved roadways, additional parking <strong>and</strong> shade trees will<br />
significantly improve the amenity of the site <strong>and</strong> will, particularly in the establishment of the Rural Precinct, enhance<br />
its functionality not only for the Show Society but for the whole community through a wide variety of other uses.<br />
We support the use of the facilities throughout the year for appropriate community <strong>and</strong> commercial purposes <strong>and</strong><br />
therefore welcome the prospect of an additional revenue stream from the upgraded Pavilion’s hire charges albeit, as<br />
noted below, that the current Pavilion plans do not appear to have addressed potential conflicts with the Society’s<br />
needs.<br />
In addition to matters pertaining to the Pavilion, there are a number of suggestions relating to aspects of the published<br />
Draft Plan <strong>and</strong> some other items that we believe should now be incorporated. These are listed below but not in priority<br />
sequence.<br />
In priority terms, we see there are dual needs - those items that enable –<br />
a. Full use of the upgraded Pavilion for both Show purposes <strong>and</strong> other functions.<br />
b. Safe <strong>and</strong> adequate provision of water <strong>and</strong> electricity <strong>and</strong> space efficiencies in areas used for camping <strong>and</strong><br />
sideshows during show time <strong>and</strong> for any other events throughout the year.<br />
(Note: Where relevant the following points have been indicated by number on the site plan submitted with<br />
this document)<br />
1. Pavilion<br />
1.1. Pavilion Exhibition Space<br />
In the Meeting Room area, primarily used for Junior exhibits, the new <strong>and</strong> different configurations of windows, doors,<br />
servery hatch <strong>and</strong> kitchen size have already reduced the amount of floor <strong>and</strong> wall display space for Show purposes.<br />
There will be similar reductions of display space in the Main Hall due to the proposed new servery <strong>and</strong> access<br />
doorway/exit to the toilets.<br />
1.1 Pavilion Exhibition Space<br />
The provision <strong>and</strong> storage of<br />
demountable units to<br />
facilitate exhibitions during<br />
the show will be the<br />
responsibility of the Show<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 8 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
It is recommended that this reduction of space could be largely overcome by providing aesthetically acceptable <strong>and</strong><br />
functionally suitable demountable wall units – pin boards <strong>and</strong> shelving – as ancillary items in the Pavilion’s renovation<br />
works. (Such units would require storage as mentioned below.)<br />
1.2. Pavilion Storage Space<br />
An obstacle to the desirable hiring out of the Pavilion at present is the lack of “out of sight” storage space to<br />
accommodate exhibit fixtures.<br />
At Show time, exhibits in the Main Hall are presented either on pin-boards, on particle board shelving – usually four<br />
shelves high - attached by stripping <strong>and</strong> brackets to the walls or on freest<strong>and</strong>ing floor units which in turn, are either<br />
heavy display cases (used typically for cakes, bread, etc.) or, again heavy, tiered shelving units mostly constructed of<br />
rigid welded frames with particle board shelves. All these, together with a number of other items – tables, chairs, art<br />
<strong>and</strong> photography st<strong>and</strong>s, etc - remain stored in the Pavilion from one Show to the next, mostly in the Main Hall space.<br />
In order for the Pavilion to reach its potential as a hire venue while retaining its primary show purpose, it is<br />
recommended that –<br />
• the areas named “display” on the pavilion plans be allocated for storage purposes<br />
• additional storage space for bulky items be provided adjacent to the Secretary’s Office.<br />
1.3. Pavilion Ventilation<br />
There does not appear to have been any provision made for insulation or ventilation of either the Meeting Room or the<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 9 of 21<br />
Society.<br />
There are insufficient funds<br />
in the Pavilion upgrade<br />
budget to fund such units,<br />
however this will be<br />
considered for future<br />
upgrades<br />
1.2 Pavilion Storage Space<br />
The internal functions of the<br />
Pavilion may be utilised as<br />
agreed by the Moruya<br />
Showground Management<br />
Committee. This issue<br />
therefore will be referred to<br />
the Moruya Showground<br />
Management Committee for<br />
consideration. Note that<br />
there will be a fee for<br />
storage. As an indication of<br />
the fees that would be<br />
payable, storage at the<br />
Batemans Bay Children’s<br />
Centre costs $<strong>11</strong>.30 per<br />
week.<br />
1.3 Pavilion Ventilation<br />
Ventilation in the Meeting
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
Main Hall.<br />
Apart from any show considerations, these issues would properly need to be addressed to make their hiring out<br />
feasible <strong>and</strong> therefore included in the Pavilion’s renovation works.<br />
1.4. Ground Space taken for Pavilion Ver<strong>and</strong>ah, BBQ Deck <strong>and</strong> Toilets.<br />
While welcome additions to the Pavilion, there will be the need to relocate at least four “stalls” at future Shows. See<br />
16. Access to Ack Weyman Oval below.<br />
2. Showground Main Entrance<br />
A separate submission dated <strong>14</strong> March 20<strong>06</strong> suggesting improvements to this area has been made through the<br />
Showground Management Committee Chairman – copy attached.<br />
3. Show Secretary’s Office – Old <strong>and</strong> New<br />
It is unlikely that the “old” Secretary’s Office building would survive relocation so we support its demolition <strong>and</strong> re-use<br />
of materials if feasible.<br />
Room is considered<br />
adequate with the windows<br />
providing cross ventilation.<br />
Ventilation improvement in<br />
the Main Hall will be<br />
considered as part of Stage<br />
2 renovations, if funding is<br />
sufficient.<br />
1.4 Ground Space<br />
Ack Weyman can not be<br />
used for vehicular access<br />
due to the irrigation<br />
infrastructure <strong>and</strong> the<br />
potential for damage to the<br />
field.<br />
2. Refer to submission No.1.<br />
3. Show Secretary Office<br />
The future of the ‘old’<br />
Secretary’s Shed will<br />
continue to be monitored.<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 10 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
It is also suggested the “new” Secretary’s Office be relocated further south than drawn on the plan <strong>and</strong> to form part of<br />
additional structure for storage of bulky pavilion <strong>and</strong> arena equipment (This will address some of the storage issues of<br />
the Pavilion <strong>and</strong> replace the “old” Secretary’s office’s current use.)<br />
Such a building – say 200M 2 - will provide the necessary space in a less visually obtrusive area while allowing<br />
vehicular access to the Community Centre’s roller door.<br />
4. Caretaker’s Cottage Changes<br />
It is suggested that the proposed fence around the yard between the cottage <strong>and</strong> the proposed garage be at least<br />
1800mm high <strong>and</strong> that there be prohibition of the use of other yard areas for storage.<br />
The relocation <strong>and</strong> upsizing<br />
of the ‘new’ Secretary’s<br />
Office will be located to<br />
ensure that its location<br />
conforms with the<br />
recommendations of the<br />
Conservation Management<br />
Plan of the Showground.<br />
The location <strong>and</strong> size of a<br />
new Secretary’s Office will<br />
be reconsidered in the final<br />
Plan’s L<strong>and</strong>scape<br />
Masterplan.<br />
4. Caretaker’s Cottage<br />
The height of the fence will<br />
be determined in<br />
consultation with the Moruya<br />
Showground Management<br />
Committee at the time when<br />
funds are available for its<br />
construction.<br />
The Moruya Showground<br />
Management Committee will<br />
be consulted at the next<br />
review of the lease for the<br />
Caretaker’s Cottage. This<br />
issue can be addressed at<br />
that stage. This lease<br />
agreement is due to expire<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page <strong>11</strong> of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
5. New Pipe Yards <strong>and</strong> Stables<br />
Access Spaces between yards <strong>and</strong> stables <strong>and</strong> any nearby structures should not be less than 5M wide<br />
Stables should be at least 3.6M x 3.6M <strong>and</strong> roofed.<br />
Demountable/portable pipe yards would be acceptable in this area – space would be available for other purposes<br />
throughout the year.<br />
Provision needs to be made for a livestock loading ramp (<strong>and</strong> for vehicle access to it) in this area.<br />
<strong>and</strong> be reviewed on<br />
10/10/08.<br />
5. New Pipe Yards & Stables<br />
Access around facilities will<br />
be maintained to be at least<br />
5m.<br />
The L<strong>and</strong>scape Masterplan<br />
will reflect the sizes of<br />
stables as 3.6m x 3.6m.<br />
Note that this will reduce the<br />
number of stables provided<br />
significantly (by about ½) as<br />
the currently plan illustrates<br />
stables at 3m x 2m as per<br />
the existing stables.<br />
Note that the L<strong>and</strong>scape<br />
Plan is conceptual <strong>and</strong> will<br />
be subject to change when<br />
design issues are<br />
considered in more detail.<br />
Demountable/portable pipe<br />
yards can be managed by<br />
the event organiser.<br />
A livestock loading ramp is<br />
already located near the<br />
Rodeo Ring.<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 12 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
6. Long Vehicle Access <strong>and</strong> Turning Space<br />
A roadway is required as shown on the plan for long (articulated <strong>and</strong> rigid) vehicles to access <strong>and</strong> turn in front of the<br />
existing livestock loading ramp adjacent to the Rodeo Yards. This would link with the roadway shown near the Pump<br />
Station.<br />
7. Wash Down Bay Drainage<br />
Currently waste water from the wash down bays is piped onto the roadway, possibly presenting some health <strong>and</strong><br />
safety risks <strong>and</strong> causing mud which can be tracked out onto Albert Street by exiting vehicles.<br />
It is recommended that proper drainage be provided.<br />
8. Rodeo Yard Size<br />
At some time in the past, there was mention that the yards should be extended to the west.<br />
This might need to be discussed with the Rodeo Committee.<br />
9. Commentators Box<br />
6. Long Vehicle Access <strong>and</strong><br />
Turning Space<br />
This will be accommodated<br />
in the final Plan of<br />
Management.<br />
7. Wash Down Bay Drainage<br />
The Plan of Management will<br />
recommend that connection<br />
of this overflow to the<br />
sewerage system <strong>and</strong>/or that<br />
it is appropriately treated be<br />
considered.<br />
8. Rodeo Yard Size<br />
The Rodeo Committee have<br />
not contacted Council in<br />
regard to this issue.<br />
However, the Plan will be<br />
amended to cater for this<br />
extension if required in the<br />
future.<br />
9. Commentators Box<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 13 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
While primarily a Rodeo committee issue, the Society would prefer the western site for this feature.<br />
10. Roadway around Arena<br />
It is recommended that, commencing near the rodeo yards, a designated roadway be provided around the western,<br />
northern <strong>and</strong> eastern sides of the arena to link up with the sealed road at the western corner of Ack Weyman Oval.<br />
The pathway from the “Pink Gates” could be incorporated in the northeastern section of this roadway.<br />
It is envisaged that this roadway would be some 3M wide <strong>and</strong> would run outside the line of existing power poles, ie<br />
some 1.2M off the arena fence; it will facilitate vehicular movement during events <strong>and</strong> help define areas for camping,<br />
for safe pedestrian/horse movement <strong>and</strong> provide a viewing area near the arena fence for st<strong>and</strong>ing or seated<br />
spectators.<br />
<strong>11</strong>. Shade Trees Around Arena<br />
It is recommended that the shade trees shown near the arena fence be located around the perimeter fence rather<br />
than immediately adjacent to the arena fence. This will leave relatively unobstructed views along the roadway.<br />
The Commentators Box on<br />
the eastern side will be<br />
removed from the<br />
L<strong>and</strong>scape Plan.<br />
10. Roadway around Arena<br />
A roadway around the arena<br />
is not supported. The grass<br />
st<strong>and</strong>s up well to infrequent<br />
access by vehicles <strong>and</strong> a<br />
road will restrict the flexibility<br />
of use of this area. The<br />
capital <strong>and</strong> maintenance<br />
costs involved do not match<br />
the level of use or need for a<br />
roadway around the arena.<br />
<strong>11</strong>. Shade trees around<br />
arena<br />
The trees will be located<br />
adjacent to the fence as this<br />
is where they will be least<br />
obtrusive. They will be<br />
canopy lifted to ensure<br />
unrestricted access around<br />
<strong>and</strong> under the trees. The<br />
plan will be amended to<br />
show the shade trees at<br />
equal distances apart to<br />
achieve the best effect.<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page <strong>14</strong> of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
12. Western <strong>and</strong> Northern Fences<br />
At recent show times <strong>and</strong> no doubt for other equestrian events, there has been increasing dem<strong>and</strong> for on-site<br />
camping <strong>and</strong> accommodation for horses. The lack of defined areas has contributed to situations where already limited<br />
space is wasted <strong>and</strong> where campers attempt to cluster around the water <strong>and</strong> electricity access points, often resorting<br />
to unsafe usage of extension leads <strong>and</strong> water hoses.<br />
It is recommended that subject to Golf Club consultation, the fences be moved to the edge of the creek bed on the<br />
western <strong>and</strong> northwestern sides <strong>and</strong> the northern fence east of the pedestrian access be move to the north side of the<br />
existing trees. This extra space will ease a lot of the past congestion <strong>and</strong>, in conjunction with more electricity <strong>and</strong><br />
watering points, will permit a safer <strong>and</strong> more orderly environment.<br />
13. New Fence<br />
12. Western & Northern<br />
Fences<br />
The relocation of these<br />
fences was discussed during<br />
the development of the first<br />
draft of the Plan of<br />
Management. The fence at<br />
the northern end has already<br />
been relocated to provide<br />
additional area for the show.<br />
The fence can not be<br />
relocated to the other side of<br />
the creek as it presents a<br />
safety issue with cars<br />
manoeuvring around the<br />
area adjacent to the creek.<br />
The fence acts as a safety<br />
barrier to prevent people<br />
accidentally reversing or<br />
driving into the creek –<br />
similarly it provides safety for<br />
pedestrians. There may be<br />
an opportunity to move the<br />
fence closer to the creek in<br />
some areas.<br />
13. New Fence<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 15 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
The most difficult area to organise is the space within the northern boundary east of the pedestrian access.<br />
It is recommended that an arris rail fence (or similar) be erected 20M south of <strong>and</strong> parallel to the above fence as<br />
shown on the plan. This will segregate horse event entrants from side shows <strong>and</strong> provide mounting points for<br />
electricity <strong>and</strong> water.<br />
<strong>14</strong>. Electricity <strong>and</strong> Water Access Points<br />
Existing access to electricity <strong>and</strong> water for campers, exhibitors <strong>and</strong> side shows is limited both in capacity <strong>and</strong> location<br />
resulting in some cases of unsafe use of extension leads <strong>and</strong> hoses. Additionally, the extra load put on power points<br />
through multiple users’ connections - ie use of power boards <strong>and</strong> double adaptors – risks overloading circuits.<br />
It is recommended that additional electricity <strong>and</strong> water access be provided at 15M intervals –<br />
• along the western <strong>and</strong> northern fences<br />
• along the proposed fence 20m south of the northern fence<br />
• within the overflow parking area shown on the plan <strong>and</strong><br />
• around the “side show alley” space (it is suggested that the Society arrange a meeting with representatives<br />
from ESC <strong>and</strong> the Showman’s Guild to determine hard requirements)<br />
It is suggested that electricity power boxes be at least 1500mm above ground level.<br />
It might be necessary for the capacity of existing wiring to be assessed prior to works commencing to ensure safety.<br />
(There has been some discussion of the need for an upgrade for capacity <strong>and</strong> safety in any case)<br />
15. Open Drains<br />
This is not supported. The<br />
Show Society can erect<br />
temporary fencing for the<br />
duration of the show – these<br />
are available from hire<br />
companies.<br />
<strong>14</strong>. Electricity & Water<br />
Access<br />
The Plan will recommend the<br />
locations to which electricity<br />
<strong>and</strong> water should be<br />
provided. However the<br />
proposed fence is not<br />
supported <strong>and</strong> will not be<br />
included.<br />
15. Open Drains<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 16 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
15.1 The dip for the open drain south east of the pedestrian access gate prevents effective use of the space. It is<br />
recommended that this area be levelled <strong>and</strong> provided with underground drainage.<br />
15.2 Similarly, the drain <strong>and</strong> water course on the western side of the rodeo yards require a safer <strong>and</strong> more sanitary<br />
solution.<br />
16 Access to Ack Weyman Oval<br />
Due to general space constraints now accentuated by the Pavilion’s proposed larger footprint, light vehicle <strong>and</strong><br />
pedestrian access to the oval will be required at least at one point for exhibits <strong>and</strong> stalls each side of a roadway<br />
running east just north of the goal posts.<br />
It is requested that provisions be made to allow this access by ensuring the log barriers suggested are removable for<br />
this purpose at show time.<br />
17. Vehicle Access around Pavilions <strong>and</strong> Bar<br />
Although not shown on the plan, vehicle access will still be required to access the pavilions <strong>and</strong> the bar <strong>and</strong> to set up<br />
exhibits <strong>and</strong> stalls in adjacent spaces <strong>and</strong> in the space east of the Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>.<br />
While this access need not be in the form of a sealed road, it is recommended that adequate grading, surface <strong>and</strong><br />
drainage be provided.<br />
18. Public Toilets<br />
The Plan of Management will<br />
recommend that<br />
investigation into the areas<br />
being re-levelled to drain into<br />
to Racecourse Creek be<br />
considered if possible.<br />
16. Access Ack Weyman<br />
Ack Weyman can not be<br />
used for vehicular access<br />
due to the irrigation<br />
infrastructure <strong>and</strong> the<br />
potential for damage to the<br />
field.<br />
17. Vehicle Access around<br />
the Pavilions <strong>and</strong> Bar<br />
Vehicle access will still be<br />
available over these grassed<br />
areas during events, for<br />
service <strong>and</strong> emergency<br />
vehicles etc.<br />
18. Public Toilets<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 17 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
The suggested upgrading might be almost as expensive as demolition <strong>and</strong> rebuilding.<br />
The Society recommends that the feasibility of rebuilding these amenities in a single structure be investigated with<br />
view to reducing the footprint <strong>and</strong> visual impact.<br />
19. Rotunda<br />
The Society believes that reinstallation of a rotunda in the space east of the Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> (similar to the one relocated<br />
to the Golf course some years ago) will add to the amenity <strong>and</strong> heritage feel of the site.<br />
20. Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong><br />
It is noted that the Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> amenities are listed for an upgrade. The society urges that fittings installed are v<strong>and</strong>al<br />
proof wherever possible.<br />
21 Shade Trees near Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong><br />
The provision of shade trees in this area is commended.<br />
The one shown on the plan to the east of the Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>, however, would impinge on the line of site should future<br />
outdoor movie screenings be held at the Showground <strong>and</strong> should be relocated. Similarly, it is recommended in<br />
selecting the other trees that their canopies be sufficiently high to ensure that clear lines of sight for onlookers to<br />
arena events is maintained.<br />
22. Site Grading<br />
<strong>Works</strong> on the public toilets<br />
will be considered when<br />
funds are available. If<br />
disabled toilet facilities are<br />
made available in the<br />
gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong>, the public toilets<br />
may be demolished.<br />
19. Rotunda<br />
This is not supported. The<br />
Conservation Management<br />
Plan did not discuss the<br />
need to provide a rotunda<br />
<strong>and</strong> there is no established<br />
need for such a structure.<br />
20. Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong><br />
V<strong>and</strong>al resistance is<br />
considered for all Council<br />
assets.<br />
21. Shade Trees near<br />
Gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong><br />
Tree locations are<br />
appropriate, but their final<br />
location will be determined<br />
on site when funds are<br />
available to plant.<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 18 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
The surface of space between the existing Secretary’s office, the gr<strong>and</strong>st<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> the pump station has several<br />
irregularities. It is recommended that this space be graded, drained <strong>and</strong> re-grassed if necessary.<br />
23 Electricity Access near Stadium<br />
At times stalls <strong>and</strong> entertainment will be set up under the ver<strong>and</strong>ah of the stadium <strong>and</strong> on the roadway south of the<br />
Poultry Pavilion<br />
It is requested that suitable electrical outlets be provided at say three points along the ver<strong>and</strong>ah wall <strong>and</strong> on the light<br />
pole at the southeastern corner of the Poultry Pavilion.<br />
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------<br />
The Society is grateful for the opportunity to submit the above suggestions <strong>and</strong> recommendations <strong>and</strong> looks forward<br />
to assisting in making the Showground a much more pleasant <strong>and</strong> useful place <strong>and</strong> in extending its usage to more<br />
members of our wider community.<br />
22. Site Grading<br />
This is supported <strong>and</strong> is<br />
included in the Plan of<br />
Management.<br />
23 Electricity Access near<br />
Stadium<br />
See comments to number<br />
<strong>14</strong> above.<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 19 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
6 8 June,<br />
20<strong>06</strong><br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
Keti Nikolovski<br />
Environmental<br />
Review Coordinator<br />
Department of<br />
Natural Resources<br />
Sydney/South<br />
Coast Region<br />
PO Box 867<br />
WOLLONGONG<br />
NSW 2520<br />
Coast & Estuaries Management Comments:<br />
The priority given to the Environmental Management of Racecourse Creek should be higher. For example:<br />
Racecourse Creek no only provides a valuable wildlife corridor within the Moruya Golf Course, the potential exists<br />
for this corridor to be linked to the Moruya River <strong>and</strong> the Endangered Ecological Community of Saltmarsh/SEPP<br />
<strong>14</strong> wetl<strong>and</strong>s through revegetation downstream. It is therefore more appropriate to actively pursue revegetation of<br />
the Creek as a high priority.<br />
The Creek also provides a valuable water feature for the Golf Course <strong>and</strong> revegetation would enhance this.<br />
Native species should be used in any future revegetation on the Golf Course.<br />
Planning & Strategy Unit Comments:<br />
The riparian corridor objectives for most streams in the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>Shire</strong> have been mapped <strong>and</strong> Racecourse Creek<br />
is a Category 2 stream as it connects the upper catchment with a SEPP <strong>14</strong> wetl<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> the Moruya River. This<br />
means that the Racecourse Creek should be revegetated with native vegetation. The vegetation should consist of a<br />
core riparian zone with a minimum width of 20 metres from the top of each bank <strong>and</strong> a 10metre vegetated buffer. The<br />
attached map shows the appropriate width of vegetation required.<br />
Resource Access Comments:<br />
Consistent with the above comments, the protection of habitat values, channel stability <strong>and</strong> water quality within<br />
racecourse creek is considered a priority. This is best achieved through the development <strong>and</strong> maintenance of<br />
effective riparian buffers.<br />
The opportunity would exist to develop the golf course to accommodate much wider native vegetated riparian zone.<br />
This may challenge some of the traditional views of a clean <strong>and</strong> neatly sculptured course, however precedents have<br />
been established where environmental audits have necessitated the establishment of effective riparian buffers<br />
incorporating native vegetation. These have resulted in significant environmental benefit, reduced maintenance costs<br />
<strong>and</strong> ultimately an acceptance <strong>and</strong> acknowledgement of the benefits without significant loss of recreational or aesthetic<br />
value.<br />
Section 6.4 of the Plan of<br />
Management has prioritised<br />
the reinstatement of habitats<br />
or ecological systems where<br />
possible <strong>and</strong> to identify <strong>and</strong><br />
maintain wildlife corridors on<br />
the reserves. This is given<br />
Priority Category 2 –<br />
Category 2 actions are those<br />
that require some funding<br />
<strong>and</strong> are principally<br />
concerned with protecting or<br />
conserving the values of the<br />
reserves, improving public<br />
safety or are maintenance<br />
<strong>and</strong> improvement matters.<br />
Category 1 actions are those<br />
that can be implemented<br />
immediately or very soon<br />
after the adoption of the<br />
plan. They are policy or<br />
procedural matters <strong>and</strong><br />
require minimal or no<br />
funding. Category 3 actions<br />
are capital improvement<br />
items or items requiring a<br />
significant injection of funds.<br />
The timing of their<br />
implementation would be<br />
dependent on the availability<br />
of funds from Council or<br />
external sources such as<br />
grants.<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 20 of 21
No Date<br />
Submission<br />
Registered<br />
Summary of Submissions – Moruya Golf Course & Showground Plan of Management<br />
July 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Author & Address Comments Response & General Comments<br />
Therefore the Category 2<br />
priority which is given to<br />
revegetation of the corridors<br />
is the highest in the Plan of<br />
Management.<br />
Additional information will be<br />
added to the plan<br />
recommending that the<br />
riparian zone 10m from the<br />
top of bank be revegetated<br />
where ever possible, within<br />
the constraints of the golf<br />
course <strong>and</strong> the activities of<br />
the showground – Section<br />
6.4.4. The Concept<br />
L<strong>and</strong>scape Masterplan will<br />
be amended to include a<br />
wider riparian zone along<br />
Racecourse Creek.<br />
G:\Property\D Purss\Plans of Management\<strong>11</strong> Moruya Golf Course & Showground\Submissions\20<strong>06</strong> Draft\Summary of Submissions.doc Page 21 of 21
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 69<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/129 TRAFFIC COMMITTEE MEETING NO 2 FOR 20<strong>06</strong>/07<br />
HELD ON 12 OCTOBER 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>06</strong>.0002<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
To present the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Local Traffic Committee recommendations to Council for<br />
consideration.<br />
The Traffic Committee was convened at 9.30am.<br />
ITEM 1 ATTENDANCE AND APOLOGIES<br />
The <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Local Traffic Committee No 02 for 20<strong>06</strong>/2007 was attended by<br />
Mr Rhod Stevens – Roads <strong>and</strong> Traffic Authority (RTA); Councillors Allan Brown,<br />
Michael Corbin <strong>and</strong> Alan Morton; Sgt Rob Young – Batemans Bay Highway Patrol;<br />
Andrew Parkinson – Chairperson, Stuart Jones – Secretary <strong>and</strong> Karen Sydenham – Road<br />
Safety Officer.<br />
Apologies were tendered by Mr Ron Ingram – Andrew Constance MP representative.<br />
Councillor Alan Morton who replaces Councillor Peter Cairney on the Committee was<br />
welcomed to the meeting.<br />
ITEM 2 CONFIRMATION OF WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE<br />
MINUTES<br />
Minute WM<strong>06</strong>/107 of the <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee meeting held 8 August 20<strong>06</strong> was<br />
read.<br />
ITEM 3 CONFIRMATION OF LOCAL TRAFFIC COMMITTEE MINUTES<br />
The minutes of the previous Local Traffic Committee (LTC) meeting held 27 July 20<strong>06</strong> were<br />
read <strong>and</strong> accepted.<br />
ITEM 4 MATTERS ARISING FROM LOCAL TRAFFIC COMMITTEE<br />
MINUTES 27 JULY 20<strong>06</strong><br />
05<strong>06</strong>.075 Batemans Bay Ambulance Station - parking<br />
Councillor Morton stated that the No Parking wording recently stenciled onto the driveway<br />
surface has faded <strong>and</strong> believes the wording is too small to make an impact <strong>and</strong> alert drivers.<br />
Road users still continue to illegally park at this location. The treatment needs to be more<br />
visible <strong>and</strong> permanent.<br />
It was agreed that a bold white line be painted to show the footpath/driveway boundary to<br />
enable proper enforcement <strong>and</strong> that the words be a larger format.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 70<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/129 TRAFFIC COMMITTEE MEETING NO 2 FOR 20<strong>06</strong>/07<br />
HELD ON 12 OCTOBER 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>06</strong>.0002<br />
ITEM 5 SPECIAL EVENTS – TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT PLANS OR<br />
TRAFFIC CONTROL PLANS<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.104 Tilba Festival Easter Saturday 2007<br />
Mr Sol Ramana-Clarke, Publicity Officer for the event was welcomed to the meeting <strong>and</strong><br />
briefed members about the 20<strong>06</strong> event. The Tilba Festival is a Class 2 Special Event <strong>and</strong> the<br />
20<strong>06</strong> festival had a capacity crowd of approximately 9,000. A designated parking area for<br />
750 vehicles was located on private l<strong>and</strong> approximately 400m from the highway with access<br />
off Latimers Lane. No vehicles were reported queuing back to the highway <strong>and</strong> the Police<br />
confirmed this. A back-up parking area to the west of the village was provided with a<br />
capacity of up to 100 vehicles.<br />
Stalls were located in Bate Street that was blocked off <strong>and</strong> closed to traffic from 9am to 5pm.<br />
Corkhill Road was open for through traffic. Pedestrians were controlled by event officials but<br />
it was noted they were not accredited Traffic Controllers <strong>and</strong> the Committee suggested that<br />
for the 2007 event, organisers approach local VRA or SES who usually have accreditation<br />
<strong>and</strong> anyone controlling traffic <strong>and</strong>/or pedestrians must be accredited. The RTA further<br />
suggested that a buffer zone be created between traffic <strong>and</strong> any barricaded area as a<br />
precaution to protect pedestrians from any motor vehicle impact.<br />
The 2007 event will have all stalls in Bate Street located on one side to allow emergency<br />
vehicles a straight line access free from structures <strong>and</strong> that a fire shed also be located on the<br />
eastern side of the village.<br />
As Council is supporting this event, the Roads <strong>and</strong> Recreation Services will develop the<br />
traffic control plan <strong>and</strong> Mr Ramana-Clarke will liaise with the Highway Patrol Sergeant in the<br />
lead-up to this event.<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.082 Batemans Bay Bridge 50 th Anniversary – 18 November 20<strong>06</strong><br />
Councillor Morton tabled the traffic management plan for this event that has been approved<br />
by RTA Wollongong. The bridge/highway will be closed for 10-15 minutes at midday.<br />
Clyde Street will be closed to traffic from 8am to 8pm. Fixed <strong>and</strong> portable VMS’ will advise<br />
traffic of the changed road conditions.<br />
It was agreed that the Roads <strong>and</strong> Recreation Services provide barricades for the road closures<br />
<strong>and</strong> a large skip type garbage receptacle.<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.085 Moruya Jazz Festival - 20-22 October 20<strong>06</strong><br />
The Police reported that the event organiser has made no further contact since the initial<br />
contact several months ago. The RTA stated that if the event involved a street procession a<br />
Road Occupancy License is needed urgently. The Police will attend throughout the week.<br />
It was agreed that Police contact event organiser about any intended road occupancy.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 71<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/129 TRAFFIC COMMITTEE MEETING NO 2 FOR 20<strong>06</strong>/07<br />
HELD ON 12 OCTOBER 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>06</strong>.0002<br />
ITEM 6 ACTION LIST<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.005 Perry Street, Batemans Bay – pavement arrows<br />
The removal of the pavement arrows has been outst<strong>and</strong>ing for a considerable period of time<br />
<strong>and</strong> due to the time lapse, the pavements arrows have in fact faded <strong>and</strong> not visible to traffic.<br />
It was agreed to delete this item for the outst<strong>and</strong>ing action list.<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.020 Ford <strong>and</strong> Queen Streets, Moruya - linemarking<br />
The warrant has been issued. Roads <strong>and</strong> Recreation Services has advised the new<br />
linemarking will be placed on the schedule <strong>and</strong> will be completed in conjunction with other<br />
linemarking projects.<br />
5<strong>06</strong>.68 Batemans Bay Public School – road safety issues<br />
The new pedestrian fence is currently being installed <strong>and</strong> the RTA has approved the 50%<br />
grant contribution towards the costs.<br />
The design for the possible narrowing of the roadway at the bus bay exit is still pending due<br />
to difficulties with the turning template software.<br />
ITEM 7 REPORTS FOR CONSIDERATION<br />
5<strong>06</strong>.101 Heron Road, Catalina – speeding<br />
Council received correspondence from a resident expressing concern about speeding vehicles<br />
along Heron Road <strong>and</strong> also sought consideration to installing traffic calming devices when<br />
Heron Road links with the future Batemans Bay Bypass road.<br />
Speed classifiers were positioned outside 54 <strong>and</strong> 55 Heron Road for one week including a<br />
weekend. The 85 percentile speed recorded was 69kph in a 50kph posted zone. Maximum<br />
recorded northbound speed was 98kph <strong>and</strong> southbound 87kph. The data showed traffic<br />
volumes from 6am to <strong>11</strong>pm with heavier traffic from 8am to 5pm. The Police stated that they<br />
have patrolled this area but have not infringed any vehicles.<br />
It was agreed not to install 50kph advisory signs at the southern access to Heron Road <strong>and</strong><br />
Albatross Road.<br />
It was also agreed that Police would continue to patrol the area especially where the speed<br />
classifiers were positioned.<br />
It was further agreed that consideration would be given to the installation of threshhold<br />
treatments at residential entry points as part of the Bypass project.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 72<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/129 TRAFFIC COMMITTEE MEETING NO 2 FOR 20<strong>06</strong>/07<br />
HELD ON 12 OCTOBER 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>06</strong>.0002<br />
5<strong>06</strong>.102 Princes Highway <strong>and</strong> South Head Road, Moruya – proposed<br />
roundabout<br />
A copy of Council’s correspondence dated 17 August 20<strong>06</strong> addressed to the RTA Bega was<br />
tabled at the meeting. The correspondence requests the RTA to indicate the status of the<br />
Safety Review of Junctions on the Princes Highway project <strong>and</strong> whether this location will be<br />
considered for a roundabout treatment <strong>and</strong> the envisaged timeframe for construction.<br />
It was agreed to receive <strong>and</strong> note this correspondence.<br />
5<strong>06</strong>.105 George Bass Drive, Malua Bay – speeding<br />
A resident corresponded to Council <strong>and</strong> Andrew Constance MP concerning speeding vehicles<br />
<strong>and</strong> lack of pedestrian crossing facilities on George Bass Drive at the intersections of Kuppa<br />
Avenue <strong>and</strong> Sylvan Street. Speed classifiers were placed on George Bass Drive south of the<br />
Kuppa Avenue <strong>and</strong> Sylvan Street intersection. The classifiers were in position for one week<br />
including a weekend in August 20<strong>06</strong>. The 85 percentile speed recorded was 66kph in a 70kph<br />
posted zone with maximum speed recorded at 100kph. Average annual daily traffic is 4563.<br />
The Police stated that speed detection was difficult to enforce along George Bass Drive due to<br />
the differing speed zones. The RTA stated that the differing speed zones were due to the<br />
differing built-up environments <strong>and</strong> due to these differing environs made setting consistent<br />
speed zones also difficult.<br />
It was agreed that the pedestrian counts at George Bass Drive where it intersects Kuppa<br />
Avenue <strong>and</strong> Sylvan Street did not warrant a pedestrian crossing facility <strong>and</strong> that the existing<br />
facilities are considered adequate at this time.<br />
It was also agreed that the RTA would investigate the speed zoning along George Bass Drive<br />
in conjunction with the review of Beach Road.<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.1<strong>06</strong> Evans Street, Moruya – disabled bus zone<br />
Moruya Public School has corresponded to Council seeking the removal of a disabled bus<br />
zone in Evans Street as it has not been used for several years <strong>and</strong> the school has catered for<br />
disabled parking on-site.<br />
It is recommended that the Disabled Parking Zone located in Evans Street, Moruya outside<br />
Moruya Public School be removed.<br />
It is also recommended that the Disabled Parking Zone located in Evans Street, Moruya<br />
outside Moruya Public School be replaced with 5 minute parking 8.00am-9.00am Monday to<br />
Friday <strong>and</strong> 2 hour parking 9.00am-3.00pm Monday to Friday.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 73<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/129 TRAFFIC COMMITTEE MEETING NO 2 FOR 20<strong>06</strong>/07<br />
HELD ON 12 OCTOBER 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>06</strong>.0002<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.107 Action Plan Access Committee<br />
Correspondence from the Action Plan Access Committee (APAC) was tabled at the meeting.<br />
It provides feedback received from the community as part of the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Disability<br />
Action Plan Review. Listed below are the unedited comments from the community <strong>and</strong> the<br />
LTC’s response is provided in italics:<br />
• Unable to access the cyclepath between Moruya TAFE <strong>and</strong> Moruya CDB as traffic is too<br />
heavy on Princes Highway.<br />
Cyclepath exists from TAFE to CBD, does this comment relate to crossing road at South<br />
Head Road/Princes Highway intersection? More information is required to enable<br />
determination of issue.<br />
• Install a pedestrian isl<strong>and</strong> near IGA Narooma to enable pedestrians to cross Princes<br />
Highway safely.<br />
LTC previously considered a mid-block treatment but the RTA did not support the<br />
recommendation.<br />
• Install a pedestrian isl<strong>and</strong> near Blue Gums Garage to enable pedestrians to cross Princes<br />
Highway safely.<br />
Assume request is due to location being a bus stop area. This location is no longer used<br />
by bus/coach services.<br />
• Better access for passengers getting on the Premier Coach in Narooma near Ben Bate.<br />
Further information needed, maybe better addressed at Passenger Transport Working<br />
Group level.<br />
• Batehaven, Beach Road, remove No Stopping signs.<br />
Not supported, removal of No Stopping would seriously impede traffic flow <strong>and</strong> cause<br />
congestion at the Beach/Edward Roads traffic lights.<br />
• Examine traffic movements at corner Ballingalla Street <strong>and</strong> Bluewater Drive, Narooma as<br />
cars regularly cross double centre lines due to poor positioning of No Stopping signs.<br />
Statement suggests that vehicles are illegally parking in No Stopping zones – refer to<br />
Rangers.<br />
• Crossing needed across Perry Street to Stockl<strong>and</strong> Mall, Batemans Bay.<br />
LTC has discussed this matter on several occasions. Traffic management in Batemans<br />
Bay CBD will be addressed shortly when the RTA set up a Technical Working Group.<br />
• It’s dangerous to cross Pacific <strong>and</strong> Beach Streets, Batemans Bay.<br />
Does this relate to passing traffic or the footpath ramps?<br />
• Roundabout needed at corner of South Head Road <strong>and</strong> Princes Highway.<br />
Refer to these minutes Item 7 - 05<strong>06</strong>.103.<br />
• Bus stop between Princes Highway <strong>and</strong> Mort Avenue at Dalmeny. Poorly lit <strong>and</strong> no<br />
paths. People have to walk on the road, as the grass is very uneven. Very difficult for the<br />
elderly.<br />
Council’s Footpath Strategy will be reviewed in near future – refer to Infrastructure<br />
Planning Engineer.<br />
• Lack of a pedestrian crossing on The Flat, Narooma.<br />
LTC previously considered a mid-block treatment but the RTA did not support the<br />
recommendation.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 74<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/129 TRAFFIC COMMITTEE MEETING NO 2 FOR 20<strong>06</strong>/07<br />
HELD ON 12 OCTOBER 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>06</strong>.0002<br />
• Please build a bus shelter for the Premier bus stops on the highway at Dalmeny <strong>and</strong><br />
Narooma.<br />
Refer to Infrastructure Planning Engineer who can advise on new bus shelter<br />
construction schedule.<br />
• A bus to Batemans Bay leaving to Narooma at 10-<strong>11</strong>am.<br />
Not LTC, refer to Passenger Transport Working Group.<br />
• There is a shortage of disabled parking spaces in Narooma, The Flat, Midtown, Plaza,<br />
Kimena <strong>and</strong> The Services Club carpark.<br />
Private property/developments should provide disabled parking in accordance with<br />
regulations.<br />
• M<strong>and</strong>atory disabled parking in all CBDs, outside medical centres, aged care facilities <strong>and</strong><br />
schools.<br />
Disabled parking is located in all Council owned car parks <strong>and</strong> businesses should<br />
provided disabled parking for their customers/pupils on-site in accordance with<br />
guidelines.<br />
• Disabled parking is needed near Narooma Post Office.<br />
Noted, installing parallel to kerb disabled parking spaces on roads is not preferred in<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong>. To conform with Australian St<strong>and</strong>ards, it requires a bay area plus two<br />
ramps <strong>and</strong> minimum widths (3.2m parallel <strong>and</strong> 5.4 perpendicular parking). ESC prefers<br />
to provide disabled parking in its own car parks, not on-street. A further report will be<br />
presented to the local Traffic Committee.<br />
• Moruya District Hospital. Disabled parking space has no ramp to the footpath so<br />
wheelchairs need to be pushed along the road (disabled parking is adequate adjacent to<br />
Community Health but this is too far <strong>and</strong> steep for a wheelchair user to travel to the main<br />
hospital entrance. The closest disabled parking to main entrance is surrounded by kerb<br />
<strong>and</strong> guttering).<br />
The hospital should provide adequate parking for its own clients/customers in<br />
accordance with parking guidelines.<br />
• Tuross Head shops, parking bays not marked <strong>and</strong> no disabled parking allocated (APAC<br />
feels that this could be a private car park).<br />
This location is a privately owned car park.<br />
• Improve visibility for drivers exiting corner of Hector McWilliam Drive <strong>and</strong> Princes<br />
Highway (APAC feels that the line of sight is good <strong>and</strong> the issue is more about driver<br />
behaviour).<br />
Concur, sight distance is in accordance with guidelines.<br />
• More policing of disabled parking sports.<br />
Refer to Council’s Rangers.<br />
• There are slightly raised slabs on the path over Moruya Bridge – trip hazards.<br />
The RTA is responsible for maintenance <strong>and</strong> repair of this bridge on the highway <strong>and</strong> the<br />
LTC will correspond to the RTA requesting remedial action.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 75<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/129 TRAFFIC COMMITTEE MEETING NO 2 FOR 20<strong>06</strong>/07<br />
HELD ON 12 OCTOBER 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>06</strong>.0002<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.108 Perry Street, Batemans Bay - pedestrians<br />
A long time visitor to Batemans Bay corresponded to Mr Andrew Constance MP requesting a<br />
pedestrian crossing or shared zone be installed in Perry Street, Batemans Bay. Mr Constance<br />
MP’s office had been verbally advised of the action the LTC had previously taken on this<br />
matter, namely, conducting two pedestrian crossing audits with results not warranting the<br />
pedestrian facility <strong>and</strong> the other action being the soon to be formed Technical Working Party<br />
that will address traffic management issues in Batemans Bay CBD. Mr Constance MP’s letter<br />
states that as this matter had been previously raised, he wished the Committee to reconsider<br />
<strong>and</strong> action as appropriate.<br />
It was agreed that the Committee receive <strong>and</strong> note Mr Andrew Constance MP’s letter <strong>and</strong><br />
provide return advice on the two pedestrian movement audits undertaken in 2005 with the<br />
results not justifying the installation of a pedestrian crossing in accordance with RTA<br />
guidelines.<br />
It was also agreed that a copy of Mr Constance MP’s letter be forwarded to the responsible<br />
person within the RTA who will co-ordinate the formation of the Batemans Bay CBD<br />
Technical Working Party for traffic management.<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.109 Council’s Management Plan 20<strong>06</strong>-20<strong>11</strong><br />
Earlier this year, the Traffic Engineer, on behalf of the LTC made a submission to Council’s<br />
Draft Management Plan 20<strong>06</strong>-20<strong>11</strong> seeking Council’s consideration for funding for additional<br />
parking in the Batehaven area <strong>and</strong> consideration to allocating funding for carparking on the<br />
l<strong>and</strong> purchased by Council in Mirrabooka Avenue, Moruya.<br />
Council’s subsequent response in a letter dated 28 July 20<strong>06</strong> informed that additional parking<br />
at Batehaven is a matter that is being considered in the Urban Settlement Strategy; <strong>and</strong> the<br />
situation in Mirrabooka Avenue, Moruya will be reviewed regarding the timing of the<br />
proposed works.<br />
It was agreed to receive <strong>and</strong> note the response provided by Council.<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.<strong>11</strong>0 Derribong Avenue Cnr Calga Crescent, Catalina – motor vehicle<br />
incident<br />
Council has received correspondence from the resident of 33 Derribong Avenue, Catalina.<br />
The resident forwarded a duplicate copy to Mr Andrew Constance MP who in turn has<br />
requested the LTC’s advices on the matter. The resident informs about an incident that<br />
occurred at 3am on 16 August 20<strong>06</strong> when a stolen speeding vehicle lost control at the<br />
intersection of Derribong Avenue <strong>and</strong> Calga Crescent <strong>and</strong> impacted with a vehicle parked in<br />
the driveway of 33 Derribong Avenue. The resident requests that a “slow point” be<br />
constructed at the intersection, erection of signs alerting to concealed driveways <strong>and</strong> a sign<br />
alerting to school children in the area.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 76<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/129 TRAFFIC COMMITTEE MEETING NO 2 FOR 20<strong>06</strong>/07<br />
HELD ON 12 OCTOBER 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>06</strong>.0002<br />
Speed classifiers were placed in Calga Crescent, 100m south of the Derribong Avenue<br />
intersection for a period of one week. The 85 percentile speed recorded was 59kph in a<br />
posted 50kph zone. The Police are not aware of this particular incident of a stolen speeding<br />
vehicle impacting a parked car <strong>and</strong> causing property damage.<br />
It was agreed that this incident is a one-off unfortunate incident <strong>and</strong> that as the incident was<br />
not reported to the Police no further action can be taken due to lack of information.<br />
It was also agreed that positioning warning signs for concealed driveways <strong>and</strong> school<br />
children playing in the area is not practical in a built-up urban area <strong>and</strong> would be applicable to<br />
all residential areas within the <strong>Shire</strong>.<br />
ITEM 8 LATE ITEMS<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.<strong>11</strong>1 Orient Street, Batemans Bay – bus zone extension<br />
A report was tabled at the meeting proposing the extension of the existing bus zone located in<br />
Orient Street at the Clyde/North Streets intersection. The extension would require the<br />
removal of the existing taxi zone currently located west of the existing bus facility. The<br />
current taxi zone, if replaced, has adequate length to allow a coach to enter <strong>and</strong> leave in a<br />
forward motion. This proposal was initiated by Council recognising the lack of accessible<br />
long term bus/coach parking facilities in Batemans Bay CBD <strong>and</strong> further propelled by the<br />
recent approach from a long distance coach service to utilise Batemans Bay as a meal break<br />
spot. Council has addressed the long-term solution of inadequate long-term bus/coach<br />
parking facilities in the Batemans Bay Structure Plan <strong>and</strong> will extend <strong>and</strong> upgrade the current<br />
bus facility as part of the Foreshore Park redevelopment works. These works include the<br />
removal of the existing concrete blister isl<strong>and</strong> that separates the current bus <strong>and</strong> taxi zones.<br />
It is recommended that the Taxi Zone located in Clyde Street at its intersection with Orient<br />
Street, Batemans Bay be removed.<br />
It is also recommended that the Taxi Zone located in Clyde Street at its intersection with<br />
Orient Street, Batemans Bay be replaced with a Bus Zone.<br />
It is further recommended that the concrete blister isl<strong>and</strong> that separates the Bus Zone <strong>and</strong><br />
Taxi Zone located at the Orient <strong>and</strong> Clyde Streets intersection in Batemans Bay remain in<br />
place until the Batemans Bay Foreshore Park redevelopment works are carried out.<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.<strong>11</strong>2 44 Hector McWilliam Drive, Tuross Head – motor vehicle incidents<br />
Council has received correspondence from a resident requesting the speed limit on Hector<br />
McWilliam Drive be reduced from 60kph to 50kph due to three separate incidents of vehicles<br />
impacting with the front fence of 44 Hector McWilliam Drive. The Police stated that they<br />
have no knowledge of these incidents. The Chairperson stated that the issue of the reduction<br />
of the speed limit on this road had been raised in the past <strong>and</strong> had been referred to the RTA<br />
who have jurisdiction over speed zones.<br />
It was agreed that the resident is informed of the action previously taken <strong>and</strong> what resolution<br />
the RTA determined.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 77<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/129 TRAFFIC COMMITTEE MEETING NO 2 FOR 20<strong>06</strong>/07<br />
HELD ON 12 OCTOBER 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>06</strong>.0002<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.<strong>11</strong>3 53 Orient Street, Batemans Bay – driveway obstruction<br />
Council has received a complaint from Ian Russell Motors, 53 Orient Street, Batemans Bay<br />
about repeated obstruction to the driveway due to illegally parked cars. Rangers have<br />
attended <strong>and</strong> infringed the offending vehicles. A suggestion to install No Parking signs at<br />
both ends of the driveway to 53 Orient Street was debated.<br />
It was recommended not to support the installation of No Parking signs at the driveway to 53<br />
Orient Street, Batemans Bay.<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.1<strong>14</strong> Stockl<strong>and</strong> Centre, Batemans Bay – car park<br />
Councillor Brown stated that vehicles are queuing in Perry Street. This is caused when the<br />
vehicles entering the car park are stationary to make an immediate right-turn into the first<br />
aisle in the car park <strong>and</strong> vehicles leaving the car park do not give way. This occurs at both of<br />
the Centre’s car park access points <strong>and</strong> causes queuing within the car park <strong>and</strong> in Perry Street.<br />
It was agreed that the LTC would correspond to Stockl<strong>and</strong> Centre Manager requesting a<br />
review of the car park traffic management.<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.<strong>11</strong>5 George Bass Drive, Mossy Point - speeding<br />
Councillor Corbin stated that he has received complaints concerning speeding vehicles in the<br />
early hours of the morning along George Bass Drive between Tomaga River <strong>and</strong> C<strong>and</strong>lagan<br />
Creek Bridges. The Police stated that speed enforcement exists <strong>and</strong> will continue to be<br />
monitored along this section of road.<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.<strong>11</strong>6 Princes Highway, Batemans Bay – speed cameras<br />
Councillor Morton requested that speed cameras be installed at the section of the Princes<br />
Highway known as the “Mad Mile.’ The RTA stated that speed cameras are not currently<br />
being installed at new locations.<br />
05<strong>06</strong>.<strong>11</strong>7 Burri Point Road, Guerilla Bay – motor vehicle incident<br />
The Police informed the LTC about a recent motor vehicle accident involving a car <strong>and</strong> a<br />
truck in Burri Point Road. As the surface of the road is gravel <strong>and</strong> there is an increase in<br />
traffic volumes due to development, the Police enquired about the frequency of Council’s<br />
gravel roads grading schedule. The Chairperson responded that all gravel roads are graded<br />
three times per annum.<br />
It was agreed that the Chairperson examine the roads resheeting program <strong>and</strong> confirm Burri<br />
Point Road priority ranking within the schedule.<br />
ITEM 9 SITE INSPECTION<br />
There were no scheduled inspections for the meeting.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 78<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/129 TRAFFIC COMMITTEE MEETING NO 2 FOR 20<strong>06</strong>/07<br />
HELD ON 12 OCTOBER 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>06</strong>.0002<br />
ITEM 10 ITEMS FOR NEXT MEETING<br />
No matters were raised at the meeting.<br />
ITEM <strong>11</strong> NEXT COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
The next Committee meeting of the Local Traffic Committee is scheduled for Thursday<br />
30 November 20<strong>06</strong> at 9.30am with the venue being the Committee Room, ESC<br />
Administration Building.<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee<br />
resolve the following:<br />
THAT:<br />
1. The Disabled Parking Zone located in Evans Street, Moruya outside Moruya Public<br />
School be removed.<br />
2. The Disabled Parking Zone located in Evans Street, Moruya outside Moruya Public<br />
School be replaced with 5 minute parking 8.00am-9.00am Monday to Friday <strong>and</strong> 2 hour<br />
parking 9.00am-3.00pm Monday to Friday.<br />
3. The Disabled Parking bay situated outside <strong>11</strong> Clyde Street, Batemans Bay be removed.<br />
4. The Disabled Parking bay situated outside <strong>11</strong> Clyde Street, Batemans Bay be replaced<br />
with extending the adjoining parking restrictions of ½ P 8.30am-6.00pm Monday to<br />
Friday <strong>and</strong> 8.30am-12.30pm Saturday.<br />
5. The Taxi Zone located in Clyde Street at its intersection with Orient Street, Batemans Bay<br />
be removed.<br />
6. The Taxi Zone located in Clyde Street at its intersection with Orient Street, Batemans Bay<br />
be replaced with a Bus Zone.<br />
7. The concrete blister isl<strong>and</strong> that separates the Bus Zone <strong>and</strong> Taxi Zone located at the<br />
Orient <strong>and</strong> Clyde Streets intersection in Batemans Bay remain in place until the Batemans<br />
Bay Foreshore Park redevelopment works are carried out.<br />
8. The installation of No Parking signs at the driveway to 53 Orient Street, Batemans Bay is<br />
not supported.<br />
ANDREW PARKINSON<br />
EXECUTIVE MANAGER<br />
STRATEGIC PLANNING AND DESIGN
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 79<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/130 GRANT FUNDING - COUNTRY PASSENGER TRANSPORT<br />
INFRASTRUCTURE 02.6655<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
Council has been successful in gaining funding for the redevelopment of the main bus<br />
facilities in Clyde Street, Batemans Bay.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
As part of the Batemans Bay Foreshore Redevelopment, it is proposed to make improvements<br />
to the current bus facilities in Clyde Street. Council made application for funds from the<br />
Ministry of Transport under the Country Transport Infrastructure Grants Scheme (CPTIGS)<br />
for the redevelopment of the main bus facilities in Clyde Street, Batemans Bay.<br />
ISSUES<br />
Advice has been received from the Minister of Transport that as a result of our application,<br />
$100,000 has been allocated to Council for the improvement to the bus facilities in Batemans<br />
Bay.<br />
We are required to advise the Department of our acceptance.<br />
The conditions of the grant are that work has to be completed within two years, regular<br />
reports provided <strong>and</strong> funds cannot be transferred to another project without the approval of<br />
the Department.<br />
Asset<br />
The current shelters have been damaged with time <strong>and</strong> the opportunity is being taken to<br />
replace them in conjunction with the foreshore redevelopment.<br />
Financial<br />
Council sought initial funding on a 50:50 basis, ie Council contributing $50,000. The<br />
Department has fully funded the project <strong>and</strong> therefore no additional funds are required.<br />
The design work for the project has not been taken further than concept stage, so detailed<br />
estimates are not yet available. If the project is estimated to cost more than the grant amount,<br />
the contribution proposed by Council originally will be available. These funds were to be<br />
made available from the Foreshore Redevelopment.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
It is recommended that Council accept the funding.<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee<br />
resolve the following:<br />
THAT the offer from the Ministry of Transport of grant funding for the redevelopment of the<br />
main bus facilities in Clyde Street, Batemans Bay be accepted.<br />
ANDREW PARKINSON<br />
EXECUTIVE MANAGER<br />
STRATEGIC PLANNING AND DESIGN
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOV EMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 80<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/131 INFRASTRUCTURE PLANNING (WORKS) - STATUS REPORT 00.4028<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
This quarterly report presents Infrastructure Planning activities for the period to 30 September<br />
20<strong>06</strong> to Council. It ensures that appropriate information is provided on a regular basis.<br />
ISSUES<br />
Infrastructure Planning is involved in a number of continuing projects. The following is a<br />
report on activities for the period to 30 September 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
Operating Items<br />
Participation in local <strong>and</strong> regional infrastructure planning, study <strong>and</strong> lobby forums<br />
All relevant meetings <strong>and</strong> groups have been participated in as appropriate. These groups<br />
include regional groups involved in stormwater, transport, <strong>and</strong> strategic planning.<br />
Preparation of footpath/cycleway, road construction <strong>and</strong> reconstruction programs<br />
Nil activity was required on the preparation of new priority lists during the quarter.<br />
As part of the review of the current footpath strategy, the pointscores used in the development<br />
of the footpath strategy <strong>and</strong> the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Bike Plan have been located. A review of the<br />
methodology <strong>and</strong> weightings has been commenced, with a view to adoption of a revised<br />
system prior to the preparation of the 2007/08 Management Plan.<br />
Further review <strong>and</strong> updating of the sealed roads <strong>and</strong> unsealed road pointscores. This has<br />
primarily involved the collection of current traffic volumes <strong>and</strong> a review of the weighting of<br />
components.<br />
Strategic Items<br />
Strategy Development<br />
Cycleway <strong>and</strong> Footpath Strategies<br />
The review of these has commenced. An initial draft has been prepared that is compatible<br />
with other adopted strategies. The list of works in the previous strategies has been updated<br />
<strong>and</strong> some new projects identified. These have been mapped electronically to assist in the<br />
identification of deficiencies in the network <strong>and</strong> to assist in the future presentation of the<br />
strategy.<br />
To help identify the needs of the wider community, preliminary discussions have been held<br />
with interested persons.<br />
The pointscores used for the preparation of the previous footpath strategy <strong>and</strong> the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong><br />
Bike Plan have been reviewed <strong>and</strong> a revised set of criteria is currently being prepared.<br />
Recreational <strong>Facilities</strong> Strategy<br />
Due to time constraints, no further action has occurred on the draft Recreation <strong>Facilities</strong><br />
Strategy during the quarter. It is envisaged that the draft Strategy will be available for public<br />
exhibition in 2007.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOV EMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 81<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/131 INFRASTRUCTURE PLANNING (WORKS) - STATUS REPORT 00.4028<br />
Swimming Pools Strategic Review<br />
No further action has been undertaken on this review during the quarter.<br />
Strategic Plan for <strong>Shire</strong> Bridges<br />
As advised previously, it is proposed that the existing strategy be rewritten to reflect<br />
Council’s asset management needs rather than as a replacement plan as it is currently. Further<br />
work will be undertaken during 20<strong>06</strong> <strong>and</strong> 2007.<br />
Water Sensitive Urban Design Policy<br />
As noted in previous reports, Council’s Development Design Specification will require<br />
modification to incorporate the requirements of this Policy. This has not yet been undertaken.<br />
It will be undertaken as soon as resources are available.<br />
To assist in the maintenance of skills, assistance was given to an application for Community<br />
Water Grant. This was by way of modelling <strong>and</strong> estimation for a rainwater harvesting project<br />
proposed by a local organisation.<br />
Coastal <strong>and</strong> Estuary Management<br />
Coastal Management<br />
Batemans Bay Coastline Hazard Management Plan<br />
Assistance has been provided in the determination of the status of this plan, including the<br />
sourcing of the final document. Inquiries have indicated that even though Council adopted the<br />
Plan, a final document was never issued. This has been rectified in association with the<br />
Consultants who undertook the study.<br />
Batemans Bay CBD<br />
Involvement has been had in the identification of the needs to be considered in the preparation<br />
of the Structure Plan.<br />
Surfside Erosion<br />
Observation of the site has continued on a routine basis. These inspections have shown that<br />
changes continue to occur with the beach returning to similar levels to those before the<br />
erosion event.<br />
Estuary Management<br />
Estuary Management Committee meetings have been attended <strong>and</strong> relevant technical input<br />
provided as necessary. These have primarily centred on the development of the Batemans Bay<br />
Marine Park.<br />
A meeting between parties involved in the opening of ICOLLs was attended <strong>and</strong> input<br />
provided. This meeting was part of the initial steps toward the development of an opening<br />
policy for all ICOLLs that Council is responsible for, based on the current polices for Coila<br />
Lake <strong>and</strong> Durras Lake.<br />
Moruya River Estuary Management Plan<br />
Assistance has been provided, as required, in the appointment of consultants to undertake the<br />
preparation of this Plan.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOV EMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 82<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/131 INFRASTRUCTURE PLANNING (WORKS) - STATUS REPORT 00.4028<br />
Floodplain Management<br />
The launch of FloodSafe for the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> business community by the NSW SES was<br />
attended on behalf of Council, including the provision of a presentation on flooding data <strong>and</strong><br />
risk to businesses.<br />
As an outcome of this event, work has commenced on the provision of flood data to business<br />
owners within the Moruya owners. This will include the provision of an estimate of the depth<br />
of water for specific flood heights at the Moruya bridge.<br />
Input has been provided to the preparation of the Local Emergency Management Plan with<br />
respect to flooding <strong>and</strong> associated risks.<br />
Input was provided as to the potential flood impacts on the proposed civic art project to be<br />
located in Riverside Park at Moruya.<br />
Grant Management<br />
Current Projects<br />
Roads to Recovery<br />
A works program for the new AusLink (R2R2) Program has been prepared <strong>and</strong> submitted.<br />
This includes the preparation of location maps, estimates <strong>and</strong> timings.<br />
The July quarterly report was submitted as required.<br />
The preparation of the Annual Report for 2005/<strong>06</strong> has commenced. This report is required to<br />
be submitted by 31 October. The project is currently on-track.<br />
Floodplain Management<br />
Discussions were held with the Department to assist in the preparation of final certificates for<br />
all current grants. These included the Narooma Training Wall Restoration, the Batemans Bay<br />
Training Wall Restoration, <strong>and</strong> the Reedy Creek Voluntary Purchase Scheme.<br />
Funding Applications<br />
A number of applications for grant funding were made during the quarter.<br />
NSW Coastal Cycleway<br />
Applications have been sought for funding under the NSW Coastal Cycleway Program. An<br />
application was submitted for funding of the proposed works at Dalmeny.<br />
NSW Maritime – Maritime Infrastructure Program<br />
Applications were called for funding under this Program during the quarter. As noted above,<br />
an application was made for funding of a new pontoon jetty at Quarry Wharf on the basis that<br />
the existing wharf is demolished.<br />
Application was also made for funding towards Council’s contribution to the Nelligen<br />
Pontoon wharf (see Federal Fishing Grant below).
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOV EMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 83<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/131 INFRASTRUCTURE PLANNING (WORKS) - STATUS REPORT 00.4028<br />
Federal Fishing Grant<br />
As advised previously, an application was made by Nelligen Progress Association to the<br />
(Federal) Department of Agriculture, Fisheries <strong>and</strong> Forestry in 2005 for funds to construct a<br />
pontoon wharf adjacent to the Nelligen Wharf. The aim of this project is to improve access to<br />
<strong>and</strong> from the river for anglers. As the Association is not an incorporated body, Council was<br />
approached to hold the funds on behalf of the Association <strong>and</strong> to ensure the works are done to<br />
Council’s st<strong>and</strong>ards.<br />
The application by the community indicated a contribution by Council. This is proposed to be<br />
by the utilisation of grant funds under NSW Maritime’s Maritime Infrastructure Program.<br />
RTA – Southern Cycleway Project<br />
Advice was received that Council’s request for funding toward the review of our Bike Plan<br />
was successful. This funding will be accepted on Council’s behalf.<br />
No new application was made for funding for construction works. The existing projects were<br />
therefore adopted as Council’s continuing priorities.<br />
Transport Management<br />
Regional Transport<br />
Continued support has been given to the Regional Transport Initiative, as possible.<br />
Projects<br />
Discussions were held with Department of L<strong>and</strong>s regarding the redevelopment of the<br />
Batemans Bay Marina. Advice has been received that an Environmental Impact Statement has<br />
been prepared for exhibition.<br />
Quarry Wharf<br />
Discussions were held with the Department of L<strong>and</strong>s regarding the redevelopment of the<br />
wharf. Advice has been received that a Review of Environmental Factors has been prepared<br />
for the demolition of the existing wharf. On this basis, an application was made to NSW<br />
Maritime for funding for the construction of a new wharf if the demolition of the existing<br />
wharf proceeds.<br />
Cycle <strong>Facilities</strong><br />
As part of Bike Week it is hoped to make available a cycleway map of the <strong>Shire</strong> on Council’s<br />
website. Preparations of the required map have been undertaken<br />
Development St<strong>and</strong>ards<br />
Nil modifications to Council’s adopted st<strong>and</strong>ards have been required during this period.<br />
Discussions with the providers of the original documentation have indicated that a revised<br />
st<strong>and</strong>ard specification is due in the near future. This may require a full review of our adopted<br />
st<strong>and</strong>ards to ensure compatibility. The suppliers have also indicated that a revised method of<br />
updating the documentation is proposed <strong>and</strong> this will need investigation.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOV EMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 84<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/131 INFRASTRUCTURE PLANNING (WORKS) - STATUS REPORT 00.4028<br />
Other Tasks <strong>and</strong> Projects<br />
Annual Report<br />
Preparation of information for the Annual Report has commenced.<br />
State of the Environment Report<br />
Preparation of information for the State of the Environment Report has commenced.<br />
FORTHCOMING WORKS<br />
Strategic Plans<br />
In accordance with Council’s adopted policy for the management of its strategies, a number<br />
of adopted strategies are due for revision this year, having been at least four years since they<br />
were adopted. The strategies due for revision during the forthcoming year are:<br />
• Arterial Roads Strategy<br />
• Boat Ramps, Wharves <strong>and</strong> Jetties Strategy<br />
• <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Cycle Plan<br />
• Footpath Strategy<br />
• Bridge Strategy<br />
• Public Toilets Strategy<br />
• Public Transport Strategy<br />
• Skateboard Strategy<br />
Due to the arising need for Asset Management, it is proposed that these will be revised as<br />
Strategic Plans that address the need for provision of new facilities with reference to Asset<br />
Management Plans for the renewal <strong>and</strong> maintenance components. Asset Management Plans<br />
have also been identified for:<br />
• Aquatic <strong>Facilities</strong><br />
• Public Halls<br />
• Bridges<br />
• Sporting Grounds <strong>and</strong> Associated <strong>Facilities</strong><br />
As identified in previous Management Plans the following new strategies are required to be<br />
commenced or completed:<br />
• Swimming Pools<br />
• Recreational <strong>Facilities</strong><br />
• Cemeteries<br />
Council’s Road Safety Plan is due for revision. Council’s Road Safety Officer is progressing<br />
this matter.<br />
The forthcoming quarter will see significant work undertaken on the revision of the Footpath<br />
<strong>and</strong> Cycleway Strategy <strong>and</strong> preparatory works for the revision of other strategies.<br />
To assist in the proper review of the Footpath Strategy <strong>and</strong> the Bike Plan, it is proposed to<br />
attend a Bicycles <strong>and</strong> Pedestrians for Managers Training Course during October.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOV EMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 85<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/131 INFRASTRUCTURE PLANNING (WORKS) - STATUS REPORT 00.4028<br />
Monitoring of vehicle movements at specific sites will be undertaken to enable accurate<br />
traffic figures for the roads pointscores, the footpath pointscore <strong>and</strong> the proposed revision of<br />
the Boat Ramps Strategy.<br />
Work will continue on the development of a remote monitoring system for Narooma Bar.<br />
Investigations will continue into the provision of a new launching point for the Narooma<br />
VRA.<br />
As noted above, a review of the management of Council’s road assets has identified the need<br />
for a revision of its Unsealed Roads Priority Pointscore System <strong>and</strong> Footpath Priority<br />
Pointscore. It is proposed that this will be done during the second half of 20<strong>06</strong> in time for the<br />
preparation of the 2007/20<strong>11</strong> Management Plan.<br />
It has been noted that there is a need for a Bus Stop Program to ensure equitable provision<br />
across the <strong>Shire</strong>. It is proposed to develop a program during the forthcoming quarter.<br />
Grant Applications<br />
The Narooma Dalmeny Cycleway group has identified the possibility of gaining funding for<br />
their project under the Regional Partnerships Program. During the upcoming quarter, it is<br />
proposed to prepare <strong>and</strong> submit an application.<br />
Development St<strong>and</strong>ards<br />
As noted above, Council’s Design Specification requires updating to ensure its currency.<br />
Work is proposed on this project during the forthcoming quarter. Included in this will be the<br />
completion of the Development Guide with a view to adoption. Subsequent to this will be the<br />
preparation of a revised construction specification, based upon the AusSpec Specifications.<br />
Other Projects<br />
It has been previously advised that it is proposed that the method of provision of information<br />
for Council’s web-based Management Plan be reviewed to enable viewing of priority<br />
programs <strong>and</strong> other similar information. This review will be undertaken during the following<br />
quarter. As well it is proposed to continue developing information able to be displayed on<br />
Council’s web site including cycleways, bus routes, <strong>and</strong> roadwork proposals.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
All programs are being monitored <strong>and</strong> will be completed within acceptable timeframes.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOV EMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 86<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/131 INFRASTRUCTURE PLANNING (WORKS) - STATUS REPORT 00.4028<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee<br />
resolve the following:<br />
THAT the Infrastructure Planning (<strong>Works</strong>) status report be received <strong>and</strong> noted.<br />
ANDREW PARKINSON<br />
EXECUTIVE MANAGER<br />
STRATEGIC PLANNING AND DESIGN
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 87<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/132 CONTRIBUTION TO COST OF WOODEN CARVING 99.3482<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
Council has received a letter requesting a donation towards a wooden carving of an<br />
Aboriginal woman, similar to the one of the Aboriginal fisherman displayed in the main street<br />
of Moruya. This report recommends Council consider an allocation of funds for the provision<br />
of the additional woodcarving.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
A number of woodcarvings have been made using Council <strong>and</strong> community funds for the<br />
Moruya Streetscaping project.<br />
Hilda “Shanti” Zanadvoroff who was the leader of a small group of enthusiasts who set up the<br />
Moruya Historical Society in 1970 <strong>and</strong> assisted with many other community projects in<br />
Moruya, passed away in August this year.<br />
To “honour Aboriginal women <strong>and</strong> their children” Hilda wanted to see a wooden carving of<br />
an Aboriginal woman holding a baby or small child as she was concerned that the women<br />
were not honoured <strong>and</strong> hoped the carving could be placed in a prominent position in the main<br />
part of town. Local Aboriginal women were very touched by this idea <strong>and</strong> are keen to see it<br />
happen.<br />
Shanti’s words of “A tribute to show my love for Moruya” will be carved onto the monument.<br />
ISSUES<br />
Social Impact<br />
The works already completed by Mr Brian Carrick have provided a unique feature in the<br />
streetscaping works <strong>and</strong> have been the focus of much attention by visitors to the town during<br />
the construction of the carvings <strong>and</strong> their subsequent placement in the main street.<br />
The high degree of craftmanship <strong>and</strong> unusual design of the woodcarvings has proven to be an<br />
asset to the excellent works already completed in the Moruya streetscaping.<br />
The work will be carried out at Art Central to enable the public to view the work in progress<br />
as a fitting tribute to Shanti. It is proposed to seek media coverage at the beginning of the<br />
work <strong>and</strong> when it is placed in the main street.<br />
Staff<br />
Council staff will determine an appropriate position for the carving to be installed in the main<br />
street of Moruya.<br />
Financial<br />
The Executor of Hilda’s estate has advised Council they have received a quote for $3,000 for<br />
the carving. The Estate will contribute $2,000 towards the carving <strong>and</strong> they are requesting<br />
Council contribute $1,000 as a donation.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 88<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/132 CONTRIBUTION TO COST OF WOODEN CARVING 99.3482<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
It is suggested that the donation of $1,000 to contribute to the memorial woodcarving is<br />
acceptable <strong>and</strong> it will be recommended that the funding be approved.<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee<br />
resolve the following:<br />
THAT a donation of $1,000 be approved from the Moruya Streetscaping budget to fund the<br />
memorial woodcarving for installation in the main street of Moruya.<br />
WARREN SHARPE<br />
GROUP MANAGER<br />
ROADS AND RECREATION SERVICES
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 89<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/133 REGIONAL RESOURCE RECOVERY PROGRAM 95.9550; 95.9385<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
This report seeks Council endorsement of a proposal by the Southern Councils Group (SCG)<br />
to commence implementation of Regional Waste <strong>and</strong> Recycling Opportunities. The first step<br />
involves the appointment by SCG of a dedicated officer on a limited contract basis.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
In 2003 the NSW Government introduced the NSW Waste Avoidance <strong>and</strong> Resource<br />
Recovery Strategy 2003 (NSW WARR Strategy), which set targets for waste minimisation<br />
<strong>and</strong> resource recovery.<br />
Each Council in the SCG has made progress towards meeting the targets through initiatives<br />
such as collection of recyclables <strong>and</strong> waste education programs. However, most of the entire<br />
member Councils are unlikely to reach the targets under their current arrangements.<br />
The SCG, with funding from the Department of Environment <strong>and</strong> Conservation, engaged the<br />
consultant GHD to prepare a “Regional Waste <strong>and</strong> Recycling Background Report <strong>and</strong><br />
Opportunities Paper” to include the Council areas of Wollongong, Shellharbour, Kiama,<br />
Wingecarribee, Shoalhaven, <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> <strong>and</strong> Bega. The Executive Summary is attached to<br />
this report <strong>and</strong> a full copy of the paper will be available at the <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong><br />
Committee meeting.<br />
The purpose of the study was to assist the SCG in identifying critical waste <strong>and</strong> resource<br />
management issues, practical problems <strong>and</strong> potential opportunities <strong>and</strong> to consider<br />
collaborative arrangements at a regional level.<br />
Collaborative arrangements offer significant benefits from potential efficiencies <strong>and</strong> cost<br />
savings through regional consolidation of materials, use of broader resource recovery<br />
networks <strong>and</strong> improved transport economics. These savings should have flow-on impacts on<br />
each Council’s ability to pursue increased resource recovery in line with the WARR targets.<br />
The top priorities, as identified for regional opportunities, that are most likely to significantly<br />
help achieve the NSW Waste Avoidance <strong>and</strong> Resource Recovery Targets are:<br />
1. organics processing, possible in one or two regions using alternate waste technology (eg<br />
enclosed composting);<br />
2. residual waste processing through alternative waste treatment facilities <strong>and</strong> final disposal.<br />
Other regional opportunities are detailed in the report’s Executive Summary, which is<br />
attached to this report.<br />
A presentation on the report was made to the meeting of the SCG General Managers on<br />
23 June 20<strong>06</strong>.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 90<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/133 REGIONAL RESOURCE RECOVERY PROGRAM 95.9550; 95.9385<br />
It was agreed to investigate funding opportunities under the Urban Sustainability Grant<br />
Program <strong>and</strong> this was subsequently done. However, while an application for a regional<br />
project of $2M over three years has been prepared <strong>and</strong> submitted, it cannot provide more than<br />
complementary actions to those requiring implementation from the GHD report.<br />
A proposal for implementation has now been developed, <strong>and</strong> includes the appointment by<br />
SCG of a dedicated officer for a 12-18 month contract. The primary role of this position<br />
would be to prepare a regional waste action plan, building on the findings of the GHD<br />
Opportunities Paper, advocate it to stakeholders <strong>and</strong> manage its implementation <strong>and</strong><br />
evaluation. This position would report to the SCG Executive Officer <strong>and</strong> the General<br />
Managers Committee.<br />
The top priorities identified as regional opportunities in the report require sophisticated<br />
processing technologies. These technologies will require a critical mass of waste <strong>and</strong><br />
substantial capital, which most if not the entire member Councils of the SCG lack.<br />
ISSUES<br />
Financial<br />
A budget for the dedicated officer has been prepared <strong>and</strong> member Council contributions have<br />
been calculated. <strong>Eurobodalla</strong>’s contribution for this financial year is $7,848. The remainder<br />
is anticipated to be about $<strong>14</strong>,159 for 2007/08. These amounts can either be accommodated<br />
from waste restricted cash balance as at 30 June 20<strong>06</strong> (unaudited) or future revenues if<br />
necessary (as waste rates can be increased subject to “reasonable cost”.<br />
Social Impact<br />
By acting on the recommendations Council will be acting to provide the community with<br />
more sustainable waste management.<br />
The top priority recommendations mentioned in the GHD report are medium to long-term<br />
initiatives. Planning <strong>and</strong> implementation of the recommendation will protect the community<br />
in the future from excessive capital expenditure. It should also enhance Council’s ability to<br />
respond to possible changes in regulation <strong>and</strong> the community’s expectations.<br />
Consultation<br />
Consultation has taken place within the SCG, the General Manager Sub Committee, the<br />
Department of Environment <strong>and</strong> Conservation <strong>and</strong> the Southern Council Resource Recovery<br />
Network. Internally, consultation with the Finance Manager regarding funding sources has<br />
been carried out.<br />
Strategic Links<br />
Regional cooperation to implement the recommendations of the report is in keeping with the<br />
concept of resource sharing with other Councils. Further regulation to increase resource<br />
recovery <strong>and</strong> minimise waste should also be anticipated.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 91<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/133 REGIONAL RESOURCE RECOVERY PROGRAM 95.9550; 95.9385<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
Council faces many future challenges in managing the waste generated by our community.<br />
By working collaboratively with the other Councils of the SCG there are regional<br />
opportunities that will enable Council to improve the way our waste is managed <strong>and</strong> assist<br />
Council in achieving the WARR targets. Regional cooperation to implement the<br />
recommendations of the report is in keeping with the concept of resource sharing with other<br />
Councils.<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT:<br />
1. Council accept <strong>and</strong> endorse the “Regional Waste <strong>and</strong> Recycling Background Report <strong>and</strong><br />
Opportunities Paper” prepared for the Southern Councils Group.<br />
2. Council commit funds of $7,848 as their 20<strong>06</strong>/07 contribution to the appointment of a<br />
dedicated officer within the Southern Councils Group to commence development of<br />
regional waste <strong>and</strong> recycling opportunities.<br />
CARMEL KROGH<br />
GROUP MANAGER<br />
WATER AND WASTE<br />
Attach
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 92<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/134 SOUTHERN VILLAGES SEWERAGE COMMUNITY CONSULTATION<br />
01.5357<br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
To inform Council of the progress in determining the best options for provision of Sewerage<br />
Services to the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Southern Villages of Akolele, Koori Village, Tilba Tilba <strong>and</strong><br />
Central Tilba, as well as Mystery Bay <strong>and</strong> to seek concurrence for release of a newsletter<br />
informing these communities of the options developed, prior to a public meeting.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
A report was submitted to Council’s <strong>Works</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Facilities</strong> Committee on 13 December 2005<br />
presenting a draft feasibility study for the provision of sewerage services to the villages in the<br />
south of the shire. The feasibility study examined the options for construction of a st<strong>and</strong>alone<br />
sewerage system in the <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> area north of Wallaga Lake versus a scheme<br />
combined with the Bega Valley <strong>Shire</strong> proposed system. The feasibility study found that<br />
significant cost savings could be realised in the st<strong>and</strong>-alone system by the use of new<br />
technologies for Advanced On-site Treatment Systems (AOTS) <strong>and</strong> further minor treatment<br />
for disinfection to allow reuse of the effluent on agricultural l<strong>and</strong> in the Tilba Valley. This<br />
compares with Pressure Sewer (PS) systems requiring a full package treatment plant to be<br />
installed <strong>and</strong> operated to provide suitable effluent quality for reuse.<br />
The preferred option was for a staged approach to provision of sewerage to the villages as<br />
financial assistance was only available for Akolele <strong>and</strong> the Koori Village at this time.<br />
At this meeting it was resolved in Minute W05/134 that:<br />
1. The draft <strong>Eurobodalla</strong> Southern Villages Sewerage Scheme Feasibility Study be noted.<br />
2. Council commence community consultation with the residents of the Koori Villages <strong>and</strong><br />
Akolele to further develop a preferred option for the provision of sewerage services.<br />
3. Council continue to liaise with the Department of Aboriginal Affairs to ensure that any<br />
preferred option meets funding requirements.<br />
ISSUES<br />
Progress in implementing the project is as follows:<br />
• A Stakeholder Meeting for the Bodalla Sewerage System was held in April involving all<br />
interested Government agencies including representatives of the Department of<br />
Aboriginal Affairs (DAA) <strong>and</strong> the Koori community. The workshop considered issues<br />
similar to those for the Southern Villages scheme including options for Advanced On-site<br />
Treatment System (AOTS) versus Pressure Sewerage (PS) system. The workshop<br />
generally endorsed the former system subject to confirmation of the effluent st<strong>and</strong>ard<br />
produced by the AOTS systems being confirmed.<br />
• Trial of an AOTS system installed for this purpose in Koori Village is underway, with<br />
sampling to date providing some positive results.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 93<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/134 SOUTHERN VILLAGES SEWERAGE COMMUNITY CONSULTATION<br />
01.5357<br />
• Further investigations by Department of Commerce have been commissioned. The terms<br />
of engagement have been agreed to in consultation with DAA. A preliminary Planning<br />
<strong>and</strong> Environment Overview is currently underway. Refined costs have been developed as<br />
listed in the attached draft newsletter.<br />
• Formal effluent reuse investigations are currently underway. Early indications are that<br />
there is more than sufficient suitable dairy l<strong>and</strong> available in the Tilba Valley to sustainably<br />
reuse all anticipated volumes of effluent potentially generated. A local dairy farmer has<br />
confirmed willingness to accept the effluent.<br />
• A Procurement <strong>Works</strong>hop was conducted on <strong>11</strong> October 20<strong>06</strong>. The recommendation from<br />
the workshop is to call separate tenders for construction of the system <strong>and</strong> supply of PS<br />
units as well as AOTS units for a period of 5 years with possible extension. It is proposed<br />
that indicative numbers be included in the supply contract for the Southern Villages,<br />
Bodalla Sewerage Scheme <strong>and</strong> other development sites in the shire for which these types<br />
of technologies are appropriate. This will create a competitive climate for the possible<br />
greater number of units to be supplied <strong>and</strong> more certainty as to overall scheme costs.<br />
• A draft Newsletter to residents <strong>and</strong> property owners in the Southern Villages has been<br />
prepared for endorsement of Council prior to release (copy attached for Councillors’<br />
information). The Newsletter outlines the issues identified with existing on-site sewerage<br />
systems <strong>and</strong> provides details of the solutions identified in the IWCMS.<br />
Legal<br />
There are no currently known legal impediments to adopting the proposed possible<br />
arrangements for connection <strong>and</strong> maintenance of the PS or AOTS systems.<br />
Policy<br />
Should the community <strong>and</strong> Government stakeholder organisations endorse the adoption of the<br />
PSS or on site system solutions, formal policies relating to the issues of connection <strong>and</strong><br />
maintenance costs will be required at that time.<br />
Environmental<br />
Existing septic tanks have been identified as having a significant impact on the Wallaga Lake<br />
environment. Provision of sewerage services to these areas would greatly reduce this impact.<br />
Adoption of the option to provide reuse of highly treated effluent in the Tilba Valley has<br />
positive environmental benefits.<br />
The proposed sewer collection system relies upon individual properties being served by a<br />
small integral tank <strong>and</strong> pump system, discharging into a common pressurised main. This<br />
system has the benefit of reduced disturbance to the environment during construction <strong>and</strong> less<br />
chance of tree root blockages <strong>and</strong> inflow of stormwater.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 94<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/134 SOUTHERN VILLAGES SEWERAGE COMMUNITY CONSULTATION<br />
01.5357<br />
Asset<br />
The PSS or on site system solutions may have lower overall capital costs than the other<br />
alternatives. However, with infrastructure being installed on each property, new arrangements<br />
for servicing <strong>and</strong> maintenance will be required to be developed.<br />
Community Consultation<br />
The release of the draft Newsletter <strong>and</strong> provision of the Fact Sheets on the alternative options<br />
is similar to the approach taken for the communities of Bodalla/Potato Point <strong>and</strong><br />
Rosedale/Guerilla Bay. The Newsletter wording has been reviewed <strong>and</strong> endorsed by DAA<br />
<strong>and</strong> members of the Merrimans Aboriginal L<strong>and</strong>s Council.<br />
The Newsletter addresses the opportunities for provision of sewerage services for all of the<br />
Southern Villages, but advises that the staged approach of initial construction for Akolele <strong>and</strong><br />
Koori Villages be proposed due to current funding constraints. While it is proposed to issue<br />
the Newsletter to all Southern Village residents <strong>and</strong> l<strong>and</strong>owners within the village boundaries,<br />
it is proposed to issue two separate covering letters for the Newsletter containing specific<br />
advice for each of the areas.<br />
This approach provides Tilba <strong>and</strong> Mystery Bay residents opportunity for initial consultation<br />
while maintaining focus on gaining community feedback on the specific issues relating to the<br />
Akolele/Koori Village scheme required to be resolved in the near future.<br />
Financial<br />
At the recent Procurement <strong>Works</strong>hop, DAA funding for the Koori Village share of the costs<br />
was confirmed as available until June 2008. DEUS funding is also indicated as being<br />
available for the Akolele component of scheme costs until at least this time. The procurement<br />
strategy provides for substantial commencement of construction within this timeframe.<br />
The revised Country Towns Water Supply <strong>and</strong> Sewerage Program rules provide for up to 20%<br />
DEUS subsidy of backlog component for the Akolele Village.<br />
The project has been included in the Capital <strong>Works</strong> program of the 20<strong>06</strong>–<strong>11</strong> Management<br />
Plan. Firmer estimates will be available of the scheme costs when the tenders are received for<br />
procurement of the on site systems.<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
Progress is being made for the implementation of a sewerage scheme for the Koori Village<br />
<strong>and</strong> Akolele in accordance with Council’s previous resolution.<br />
The next stage in the process is to formally consult with the respective communities to gain<br />
feedback on the proposed options to allow further detailed investigations <strong>and</strong> design to be<br />
carried out.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 95<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/134 SOUTHERN VILLAGES SEWERAGE COMMUNITY CONSULTATION<br />
01.5357<br />
A draft Newsletter has been developed for issue to the l<strong>and</strong>holders <strong>and</strong> residents of the<br />
Southern Villages to advise on progress <strong>and</strong> options developed with a view to stimulating<br />
informed debate at a Community <strong>Works</strong>hop meeting proposed to be held in late<br />
November/early December 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT under delegated authority dated 26 August 2003 (Minute No 422) the Committee<br />
resolve the following:<br />
THAT:<br />
1. Council endorse the release of the draft Community Newsletter attached to this report.<br />
2. Council endorse the proposed general timing for Community Consultation <strong>Works</strong>hops to<br />
inform <strong>and</strong> discuss with the community the proposed scheme options <strong>and</strong> seek indication<br />
of a preferred option.<br />
CARMEL KROGH<br />
GROUP MANAGER<br />
WATER AND WASTE<br />
Clrs
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 96<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/135 WATER AND WASTE QUARTERLY REPORT 91.30<strong>14</strong><br />
SYNOPSIS<br />
This quarterly report presents key water <strong>and</strong> waste information to Council. It contains<br />
information on new infrastructure development, operational status <strong>and</strong> any key issues.<br />
WATER SUPPLY<br />
1. Water Supply Status<br />
The graph below shows the river flows <strong>and</strong> weekly consumption patterns since the beginning<br />
of July to the end of October. Council resolved on 24 October to implement Level 1 water<br />
restrictions.<br />
River Flows ML/Week<br />
2500<br />
2000<br />
1500<br />
1000<br />
500<br />
0<br />
9/07/20<strong>06</strong><br />
16/07/20<strong>06</strong><br />
23/07/20<strong>06</strong><br />
30/07/20<strong>06</strong><br />
6/08/20<strong>06</strong><br />
Water Consumption V River Flows 3/7/6 - 29/10/<strong>06</strong><br />
13/08/20<strong>06</strong><br />
20/08/20<strong>06</strong><br />
27/08/20<strong>06</strong><br />
2. Water Quality<br />
The following table summarises the results for NSW Health testing of reticulation samples<br />
collected for the last quarter.<br />
Total coliform bacteria have been detected in 1 of the 90 samples submitted to the NSW<br />
Health laboratory during the September 20<strong>06</strong> quarter. NSW Health consider that the presence<br />
of total coliforms in the absence of E.coli does not represent a health concern. No samples<br />
submitted for bacteriological analysis, during the quarter, tested positive for E.coli. All<br />
chemical analysis results met the Australian Drinking Water Guideline values.<br />
3/09/20<strong>06</strong><br />
Flow-Bucken Flow-Moruya Flow-Tuross WaterToRetic<br />
10/09/20<strong>06</strong><br />
17/09/20<strong>06</strong><br />
24/09/20<strong>06</strong><br />
1/10/20<strong>06</strong><br />
8/10/20<strong>06</strong><br />
15/10/20<strong>06</strong><br />
22/10/20<strong>06</strong><br />
Level 1 Water Restrictions Commenced<br />
29/10/20<strong>06</strong><br />
120<br />
100<br />
80<br />
60<br />
40<br />
20<br />
0<br />
WaterToRetic ML/Week
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 97<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/135 WATER AND WASTE QUARTERLY REPORT 91.30<strong>14</strong><br />
Guideline Number Number % meeting<br />
of of guideline<br />
Parameter<br />
Value samples exceptions values<br />
Total Coliforms 0.0000 cfu/100<br />
mL<br />
90 1 99<br />
E. coli 0.0000 cfu/100<br />
mL<br />
90 0 100<br />
pH 6.5 - 8.5 3 0 100<br />
Turbidity 5.0000 NTU 3 0 100<br />
Free Chlorine 5.0000 mg/L 84 0 100<br />
Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) 500.0000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Aluminium 0.2000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Antimony 0.0030 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Arsenic 0.0070 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Barium 0.7000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Boron 4.0000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Cadmium 0.0020 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Calcium 9999.0000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Chloride 250.0000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Chromium 0.0500 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Copper 2.0000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Fluoride 1.5000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Iodine 0.1000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Iron 0.3000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Lead 0.0100 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Magnesium 9999.0000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Manganese 0.5000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Mercury 0.0010 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Molybdenum 0.0500 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Nickel 0.0200 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Nitrate 50.0000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Nitrite 3.0000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Selenium 0.0100 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Silver 0.1000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Sodium 180.0000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Sulfate 500.0000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Total Hardness as CaCO3 200.0000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
True Colour 15.0000 Hazen<br />
Units (HU)<br />
3 0 100<br />
Zinc 3.0000 mg/L 3 0 100<br />
Increased monitoring of Deep Creek Dam has been necessary due to the identification of blue<br />
green algae in the dam. Blue green algae concentrations have been elevated but the dominant<br />
species has been of low risk type. Due to reduced river flows, all areas of the <strong>Shire</strong> are<br />
periodically being fed from Deep Creek Dam.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 98<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/135 WATER AND WASTE QUARTERLY REPORT 91.30<strong>14</strong><br />
3. Water Supply Capital <strong>Works</strong><br />
(a) Pipeline from Moruya to Deep Creek Dam<br />
The tender documents for the pipe supply <strong>and</strong> construction contracts are now complete.<br />
A letter has been sent to the Minister for Energy, Utilities <strong>and</strong> Sustainability (DEUS) advising<br />
of completion of preconstruction activities for the proposed works <strong>and</strong> requesting that<br />
approval be granted to calling of tenders for the construction of the proposed pipeline <strong>and</strong><br />
associated pumping facilities. A submission requesting funding under the Country Towns<br />
Water <strong>and</strong> Sewer Program has also been sent.<br />
Despite numerous attempts to extract a response through DEUS, nothing has yet been<br />
received in writing from the Minister or DEUS.<br />
(b) Southern Dam<br />
The Environmental Impact Statement for the southern dam site is currently being undertaken<br />
by Consultants, Patterson Britton <strong>and</strong> Partners. It is expected that the EIS will be completed in<br />
December.<br />
A draft concept design has also been completed by the Department of Commerce which deals<br />
with embankment configuration, spillway capacity, inlet <strong>and</strong> outlet structures, <strong>and</strong> power<br />
requirements. The final concept plan will be presented to Council for consideration with the<br />
EIS.<br />
(c) Water Treatment Options Study<br />
A 50% review meeting was held on 13 October for the Options Study for the northern water<br />
treatment plant. The draft Options Report is due on 15 November.<br />
(d) Watermain Renewal Program<br />
Watermains renewed or upgraded in the first quarter of this year are as follows:<br />
• Moruya south extension (Bergalia Street)<br />
• Sunshine Bay Road<br />
• Spine Road – Stage 1 - Silverdell Place<br />
• Goolara Street, Dalmeny<br />
• Shore Street, Moruya<br />
• Clyde Street Carpark<br />
• Mort Avenue, Dalmeny<br />
• Various road crossings to meet General Fund Work Schedule ($31,000)
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 99<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/135 WATER AND WASTE QUARTERLY REPORT 91.30<strong>14</strong><br />
(e) Other Water Asset <strong>Works</strong><br />
The New automatic chlorination system, installed by Council staff at Tilba Reservoir, has<br />
been working effectively <strong>and</strong> during this period, a second unit has been designed to be placed<br />
at Narooma.<br />
New electrical switch gear has been installed at the Buckenboura Water Pump Intake, to<br />
upgrade control mechanisms <strong>and</strong> improve reliability.<br />
New telemetry equipment to the value of $32,000 has been installed throughout the water<br />
system to provide reliable remote control <strong>and</strong> monitoring.<br />
Replacement of part of the ageing fleet of domestic water meters has taken place following<br />
the latest meter reading event. These new meters will improve meter records <strong>and</strong> accurately<br />
monitor individual consumption for accounting purposes to domestic properties.<br />
Tender documents were prepared <strong>and</strong> advertised, for the supply <strong>and</strong> delivery of pipes <strong>and</strong><br />
fittings to support the eventual construction of the Spine Road water main relocation,<br />
scheduled for construction during November/December 20<strong>06</strong>.<br />
Eurowater electrical staff have upgraded the Mt W<strong>and</strong>ella Radio Tower to improve radio <strong>and</strong><br />
communications throughout the southern portion of the <strong>Shire</strong>.<br />
(f) Deep Bore Investigations – Tuross River Valley<br />
A report submitted to Council during the period, has allowed Stage 1 of the investigations to<br />
proceed with approved funds. Field work is continuing to increase knowledge of the water<br />
bearing characteristics of the region.<br />
(g) Shallow Bore Preparation – Tuross River Banks<br />
The Tuross River Bank bores have been continually flushed in an endeavour to help with<br />
underst<strong>and</strong>ing the capabilities of the asset, for both quantity <strong>and</strong> quality. Current information<br />
indicated that relatively high iron content remains consistent. This iron content does not<br />
presents a health problem, rather an aesthetic problem with water coloration <strong>and</strong> staining.<br />
Investigations are continuing to confirm the consistency <strong>and</strong> quality of this supply, should<br />
current dry conditions determine that alternate water supply is needed beyond the capability<br />
of Deep Creek.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 100<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/135 WATER AND WASTE QUARTERLY REPORT 91.30<strong>14</strong><br />
SEWERAGE<br />
1. Batemans Bay Treatment Plant Upgrade<br />
Discussions were held in October with the Department of Environment <strong>and</strong> Conservation to<br />
confirm their requirements for the treatment plant upgrade. Concept designs can now be<br />
finalised.<br />
2. Spine Road Sewerage<br />
A final concept report for the Spine Road sewage pump station has been received.<br />
The Spine Road pumping station will comprise submersible pumps in a 5 metre diameter wet<br />
well. The station will incorporate three submersible pumps – two duty <strong>and</strong> one st<strong>and</strong> by. The<br />
rising main will be 6500 metres in length <strong>and</strong> will utilise the section of the existing Rising<br />
Main 5 which will become redundant when the proposed diversion to the new Spine Road<br />
SPS is completed. That section is 1.5km in length <strong>and</strong> 375mm in diameter. The new section<br />
of rising main will be 450mm in diameter.<br />
3. Small Town Sewerage Program<br />
Council is aware of previous submissions for State Government funding for the provision of<br />
sewerage facilities in the <strong>Shire</strong>’s small towns. Council has been formally advised by the<br />
Minister for Energy <strong>and</strong> Utilities that funds have been made available under the Country<br />
Towns Water Supply <strong>and</strong> Sewerage Program for the Bodalla Sewerage Scheme.<br />
The Country Towns Program requires Council to complete all pre-construction activities <strong>and</strong><br />
approvals <strong>and</strong> seek funding approval prior to calling tenders. At that stage a subsidy<br />
percentage will be determined for the scheme <strong>and</strong> approval to call tenders will be given.<br />
<strong>Eurobodalla</strong> is eligible for 20% of the backlog components of the Bodalla Sewerage Scheme.<br />
Funding is also currently available under the DEUS program for Akolele. In addition, funding<br />
for the Wallaga Lake Village is available from the Department of Aboriginal Affairs. This<br />
scheme is the subject of a separate report to this meeting.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 101<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/135 WATER AND WASTE QUARTERLY REPORT 91.30<strong>14</strong><br />
4. Sewerage Operations <strong>and</strong> Construction<br />
Sewer Operations <strong>Works</strong><br />
Sewage odour in the Long Beach area continued to be controlled, using calcium nitrate, fed<br />
into the top of the sewage system. This chemical effectively locks the odour producing<br />
elements from joining together to produce the offensive hydrogen sulphide. This product is<br />
now being investigated at other locations throughout the <strong>Shire</strong> <strong>and</strong> if continued success is<br />
evident, a submission will be made to introduce a new budget item into the 2007/08 financial<br />
year.<br />
A tender was prepared, advertised <strong>and</strong> subsequently let to a contractor to construct a new<br />
sewer pumping station in Bergalia Street, Moruya. This work will allow neighbouring<br />
various developers’ sewer works to connect to the existing system.<br />
Improvement works took place to the Sewer Pumping Station 5 in Gem Crescent, Narooma.<br />
New hardware was positioned in the manhole <strong>and</strong> valve chamber, along with portion of the<br />
rising main, which had shown high levels of corrosion, influenced by the acid sulphate soil in<br />
that area. This work will improve reliability to the system in this environmentally sensitive<br />
area. The work was carried out effectively <strong>and</strong> efficiently by a local contractor, RJS<br />
Solutions. Similar work has commenced on Pump Station 3 at Apex Park Narooma.<br />
SOLID WASTE ISSUES<br />
1. Staff Issues<br />
The new Waste Unit Leader, David Owen, commenced on 26 October 20<strong>06</strong>. Temporary<br />
operational supervisory staff have been employed over the last few months to cover staff<br />
vacancies <strong>and</strong> absences.<br />
2. Brou L<strong>and</strong>fill<br />
Brou l<strong>and</strong>fill has had no major operational issues for the past three months. Any day to day<br />
issues has been resolved following discussions with the contractor. The contractor has<br />
maintained its st<strong>and</strong>ard of operation with no recorded complaints. The contractor has been<br />
notified of Council’s intention to terminate the current agreement <strong>and</strong> discussions have been<br />
held with the contractor for a new short-term contract.<br />
The l<strong>and</strong>fill has been operating two tip faces, one for household <strong>and</strong> the other for inert<br />
material. The household waste is going into the first lined cell of the extension area. The<br />
method of compaction of the household waste has been changed from previous practice to<br />
maximise l<strong>and</strong>fill space. Operational water levels have been substantially reduced (the<br />
leachate pond via on-site irrigation) <strong>and</strong> the sediment pond (by off site discharge in line with<br />
EPA conditions).<br />
A number of on site <strong>and</strong> laboratory test have been completed that indicate the extension cell<br />
soils will not meet EPA guidelines for permeability without other methods being employed.<br />
This confirms that the remaining extension area will require installation of an impermeable<br />
liner.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 102<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/135 WATER AND WASTE QUARTERLY REPORT 91.30<strong>14</strong><br />
A draft operational plan has now been developed for the site to allow development of the<br />
specification for the long-term contract. In addition, the operational review undertaken has<br />
provided some potential for modifications which could extend the life of the l<strong>and</strong>fill to 25+<br />
years. A full report with final l<strong>and</strong>form levels is being finalised <strong>and</strong> a more detailed report<br />
will be submitted to Council with a full strategy for implementation.<br />
3. Surf Beach L<strong>and</strong>fill<br />
Over recent years the l<strong>and</strong>fill has operated on the basis of separate cells for mixed solid waste<br />
<strong>and</strong> inert waste. Compaction of both cells being undertaken by a Caterpillar D7 Dozer.<br />
The inert cell has been developed by the method of dozing the deposited <strong>and</strong> accumulated<br />
waste over the edge of the cell. This has resulted in a cell characterised by a lift of<br />
approximately 10 meters plus (see Figure 1.1 in the Councillors’ attachment) with the<br />
compaction being carried out by the vehicle movement on the cell <strong>and</strong> by the weight of the<br />
operating dozer.<br />
Council in consultation with WSN Environmental Solutions (WSN) a waste collection <strong>and</strong><br />
disposal contractor, recently completed a trial whereby the existing inert cell was reshaped<br />
<strong>and</strong> recompacted utilising a purpose built waste 31 tonne compactor (Tana).<br />
The purpose of the trial being to determine whether the use of this type of equipment would<br />
provide an increased level of compaction <strong>and</strong> a corresponding reduction in the volume of air<br />
space being utilised, <strong>and</strong> to provide a safer <strong>and</strong> more efficient methodology for the operation<br />
of the l<strong>and</strong>fill.<br />
Figure 3.2 (in the Councillors’ attachment) shows the new working face after the major<br />
physical works were undertaken. Due to the achieved reduction in the volume of air space<br />
utilised (almost 50%), a compactor is still being utilised on site. A further report will be<br />
presented to Council to determine the most suitable plant procurement for the future.<br />
4. Litter Bin Collection <strong>and</strong> Issues<br />
The litter bin collection service is undergoing a major review in consultation with the Parks<br />
<strong>and</strong> Gardens staff. An audit of all litter bins is almost complete. This audit was necessary<br />
due to problems being experienced with bins overflowing <strong>and</strong> numerous complaints being<br />
received, particularly in the northern area of the shire. This situation has meant that<br />
additional collection days have been required to meet the dem<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> avoid public health<br />
issues. A full report detailing the outcomes of the audit including the financial considerations<br />
will be presented to the next Committee meeting.<br />
5. Hazardous Waste Collection<br />
The Household Hazardous Waste Collection was held in August.<br />
This year the Household Hazardous Collection received over 18 tonnes of material. This is up<br />
from previous years of 7 to 9 tonnes. Participation has also increased from 271 participants in<br />
2003 to 534 participants in 20<strong>06</strong>. Despite this dramatic increase the cost of the collection will<br />
fall within the budget due to the funding from the DEC.
INFRASTRUCTURE REPORT TO WORKS AND FACILITIES COMMITTEE MEETING<br />
HELD ON TUESDAY <strong>14</strong> NOVEMBER 20<strong>06</strong> Page 103<br />
W<strong>06</strong>/135 WATER AND WASTE QUARTERLY REPORT 91.30<strong>14</strong><br />
RECOMMENDED<br />
THAT the Water <strong>and</strong> Waste Division Quarterly Report be received <strong>and</strong> noted.<br />
CARMEL KROGH<br />
GROUP MANAGER<br />
WATER AND WASTE<br />
Clrs