Pasha Bulker 243 - Independent investigation into the grounding of ...

APPENDIX F: MEDIA RELEASE
ATSB releases final Pasha Bulker report
The ATSB has found that the grounding of Pasha Bulker on Nobbys Beach on 8 June 2007
occurred despite a gale warning that should have prompted the master to ballast the ship for
heavy weather and take it to sea. A number of other ships also failed to take to sea.
The Australian Transport Safety Bureau investigation found that Pasha Bulker’s master
had an inadequate understanding of heavy weather ballast, anchor holding power and the
limitations of Newcastle’s weather exposed anchorage.
The investigation also found that a number of other ships attempted to ride out the gale at
anchor and the majority dragged their anchors. A number of masters did not appropriately
ballast their ships and many did not understand Newcastle Vessel Traffic Information
Centre’s purely advisory role, expecting that it would instruct or inform them to put to sea
at an appropriate time. It was also found that the substantial ship queue increased the risks
in the anchorage and resulted in another near grounding, a near collision and a number of
close-quarters situations at the time.
On 23 May, the Panamanian registered bulk carrier Pasha Bulker anchored about two miles
off the coast near Newcastle and joined the queue of 57 ships to wait its turn for loading
coal. The ship was ballasted for the good weather conditions. Newcastle anchorage is
suitable only in good weather and nautical publications contain warnings about the local
weather conditions and recommend that masters put to sea before conditions become
severe.
On the morning of 7 June, the Bureau of Meteorology issued a gale warning for the area.
Winds were expected to increase to 45 knots, with gusts up to 63 knots, after 0400 on 8
June with high seas and a heavy swell. At midday, Pasha Bulker’s master deployed
additional anchor cable and decided to monitor the weather and the ship’s anchor position.
By midnight, the southeast wind was gusting to 30 knots and ships began dragging their
anchors. Newcastle Vessel Traffic Information Centre advised those ships that were
dragging their anchors. Only seven ships had put to sea in the deteriorating weather while
another had weighed anchor to berth in the port.
By 0600 on 8 June, the wind was gusting to nearly 50 knots and Pasha Bulker was amongst
27 ships still at anchor. At 0637, when the master was certain that the anchor was dragging,
he decided to weigh anchor. At 0748, the ship got underway and for more than an hour,
moved in a northeast direction parallel to the coast about one mile away with the wind on
its starboard bow.
At 0906, the master decided to alter course to put the wind on the ship’s port bow and clear
the coast in a southerly direction. The course change in the extreme weather was poorly
controlled and Pasha Bulker’s heading became south-westerly instead of south-southeast as
intended. The ship then rapidly approached Nobbys Beach and the master’s desperate
attempt to turn the ship to starboard to clear the coast inevitably led to its grounding at
0951 with both anchors in their hawse pipes.
The ATSB is pleased to report that safety actions have already been taken following the
incident but has issued a number of other recommendations and safety advisory notices
with the aim of preventing similar incidents in the future.
- 89 -