house of lords official report - United Kingdom Parliament
house of lords official report - United Kingdom Parliament
house of lords official report - United Kingdom Parliament
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
1127 Organophosphates<br />
[LORDS]<br />
Organophosphates<br />
1128<br />
[THE COUNTESS OF MAR]<br />
health. Since then there has been progress and their<br />
acute effects are readily acknowledged. Many OPs<br />
have been removed from the market, while stringent<br />
instructions now apply to those that are still in use.<br />
But there is still no recognition <strong>of</strong> their chronic central<br />
and autonomic nervous system effects.<br />
Following close on the heels <strong>of</strong> the sheep farmers<br />
and other agricultural workers were some Gulf War<br />
veterans who <strong>report</strong>ed very similar adverse health<br />
effects following medication with pyridostigmine bromide,<br />
a carbamate closely related to OPs, and exposure to<br />
OP nerve gas and pesticide sprays. Despite the fact<br />
that the US Research Advisory Committee on Gulf<br />
War Illnesses recently concluded that some 25 per cent<br />
<strong>of</strong> Gulf War veterans—25 per cent <strong>of</strong> more than 6,000<br />
people—are suffering the effects <strong>of</strong> OP poisoning, the<br />
British Government persist in their denial that these<br />
same exposures have had any effect on our troops.<br />
More recently, airline pilots and crew have <strong>report</strong>ed ill<br />
effects following exposure to cabin air contaminated<br />
by leaking engine oil that produces very toxic OPs<br />
when heated.<br />
In all these groups, scientific research has shown<br />
consistently that there may be a relationship between<br />
long-term, low-level exposure to organophosphates<br />
and the development <strong>of</strong> neurobehavioural problems.<br />
The first study <strong>of</strong> sheep farmers was in 1991, and the<br />
latest was published this year. As there have been very<br />
few <strong>report</strong>s <strong>of</strong> adverse reactions to OP sheep dips in<br />
recent years, it is fairly safe to assume that the problems<br />
are persistent. It is interesting that Dr Sarah Mackenzie<br />
Ross, who conducted the DEFRA-funded research<br />
entitled “Neuropsychological and Psychiatric Functioning<br />
in Sheep Farmers Exposed to Organophosphate<br />
Pesticides”, had to eliminate 60 per cent <strong>of</strong> possible<br />
subjects, all <strong>of</strong> whom were sheep farmers exposed to<br />
OPs, because they had other conditions. Among those<br />
eliminated were people with a history <strong>of</strong> acute exposure;<br />
those with a neurological condition such as Parkinson’s<br />
disease or multiple sclerosis; heart conditions and lung<br />
disease, all <strong>of</strong> which are associated with possible toxic<br />
causation. This means that those in whom she did find<br />
neuropsychiatric problems were likely to have been<br />
those who had the lowest exposure to OPs.<br />
When the Labour Party came into Government in<br />
1997, Ministers from all the departments involved<br />
agreed that an interdepartmental group <strong>of</strong> high-level<br />
<strong>of</strong>ficials should be formed to <strong>report</strong> to Ministers on<br />
the continuing public debate over whether OPs damage<br />
human health. This was the Official Group on<br />
Organophosphates, also known as the Carden Committee,<br />
although I understand that Mr Carden has since retired.<br />
The group <strong>report</strong>ed in 1998 and a number <strong>of</strong> its<br />
recommendations, including a research programme,<br />
were implemented, for which I am grateful. I understand<br />
that the group has met occasionally since then, the last<br />
time being 26 June 2007. As the minutes <strong>of</strong> its meetings<br />
are not published, we have no means <strong>of</strong> knowing the<br />
detail <strong>of</strong> their discussions.<br />
What is clear is that the science has moved on<br />
considerably since 1998. The Carden <strong>report</strong> gives at<br />
paragraph 2.2 a simple explanation <strong>of</strong> the manner in<br />
which inhibitors <strong>of</strong> acetylcholinesterase function,<br />
stating that:<br />
“In the case <strong>of</strong> most OPs and all medicinal and pesticidal<br />
anticholinesterase OP products the effect is either reversible or<br />
recoverable”.<br />
It also reminds us that some non-OPs are<br />
anticholinesterases and that they have similar toxicity<br />
to anticholinesterase OPs, to which I shall come later.<br />
There appears to be a genetic susceptibility to OP<br />
poisoning. It is recognised that cytochrome P450<br />
enzymes, Paraoxonase-1 and butyrylcholinesterase<br />
play important parts in the detoxification <strong>of</strong><br />
anticholinesterases. It has also been recognised for<br />
some time that there are flaws in the traditional methods<br />
<strong>of</strong> assessing exposure to OPs by measuring metabolites<br />
for specific OPs in the urine or measuring levels <strong>of</strong> red<br />
blood cell acetylcholinesterase. The scientific paper<br />
Identification and Characterisation <strong>of</strong> Biomarkers <strong>of</strong><br />
Organophosphorus (OP) Exposure in Humans by Kim<br />
et al, 2009, details,<br />
“the development <strong>of</strong> rapid protocols for extraction <strong>of</strong> the target<br />
biomarker protein from a sample, digesting the enzyme and<br />
identifying the OP modified peptide by mass spectrometry”.<br />
The authors go on to state:<br />
“We feel these methods are optimal for filling the void <strong>of</strong><br />
diagnosing and treating long-term exposures to several ubiquitous<br />
OPs”.<br />
In the UK, the Government have funded a few<br />
neuropsychological function studies and epidemiological<br />
studies <strong>of</strong> shepherds exposed to OPs. None <strong>of</strong> these<br />
has gone into the detail <strong>of</strong> the US research on sick<br />
Gulf veterans. The US neurocognitive studies found<br />
similar significantly poorer performance results on<br />
veterans who had been exposed to anticholinesterase<br />
chemicals to those conducted in the UK on shepherds.<br />
Six out <strong>of</strong> seven projects that evaluated brain structure<br />
and function using highly specialised equipment found<br />
significant differences between veterans with Gulf War<br />
illnesses and healthy controls, although they qualify<br />
their results by stating that additional research is<br />
needed. I could go on, and those interested in the<br />
detail will find it in the US RAC <strong>report</strong> <strong>of</strong> last November.<br />
In view <strong>of</strong> the fact that providing scientific pro<strong>of</strong> has<br />
been a virtual impossibility for those who are suffering<br />
the effects <strong>of</strong> OPs, may I ask the Minister how many<br />
<strong>of</strong> the most recent developments have been accepted<br />
in the UK?<br />
I cannot express adequately the effect that the somewhat<br />
apathetic attitude <strong>of</strong> those who are responsible for<br />
ensuring our health and safety over the past 20 years<br />
has had. By failing to study individuals who <strong>report</strong><br />
symptoms after more than a minute exposure to<br />
OPs in the initial stages and by failing to conduct<br />
longitudinal studies, they may well have exposed many<br />
sick people to at least a poor quality <strong>of</strong> life or at worst<br />
an early death. My own experience has taught me<br />
that there is an almost total lack <strong>of</strong> understanding <strong>of</strong><br />
the life-threatening heart and lung function damage<br />
and <strong>of</strong> the effects <strong>of</strong> administering drugs that act on<br />
the acetylcholine system. The Health and Safety<br />
Executive’s leaflet MS17, Medical aspects <strong>of</strong> work-related<br />
exposures to organophosphates, warns <strong>of</strong> the effects <strong>of</strong><br />
repeated absorption <strong>of</strong> small doses <strong>of</strong> OPs. However,<br />
I can find no warning to the medical pr<strong>of</strong>ession <strong>of</strong> the<br />
effects <strong>of</strong> administering any <strong>of</strong> a wide range <strong>of</strong> drugs<br />
that may have a similar action. First-line drugs for<br />
bladder incontinence, asthmatic symptoms and