house of lords official report - United Kingdom Parliament
house of lords official report - United Kingdom Parliament
house of lords official report - United Kingdom Parliament
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
1145 Political Parties and Elections Bill [17 JUNE 2009] Political Parties and Elections Bill 1146<br />
Perhaps I may push my luck just a fraction further<br />
by mentioning that 70 per cent <strong>of</strong> units have still not<br />
held a service electoral registration day informing<br />
personnel how to register to vote. I am sure that service<br />
personnel will appreciate that they have to go through<br />
this exercise only once every five years as a result <strong>of</strong><br />
the Minister’s welcome concession. However, perhaps<br />
I may press him a little further and ask whether he can<br />
encourage his colleagues in the Ministry <strong>of</strong> Defence to<br />
make representations—indeed, it would seem appropriate<br />
for the Ministry <strong>of</strong> Defence to issue an order—regarding<br />
an electoral registration day so that people know<br />
about the changes that have been made and know also<br />
that their engagement in the democratic process is <strong>of</strong><br />
the highest concern to Members on all sides <strong>of</strong> this<br />
House. I am happy to give way at this point or, if other<br />
people want to contribute to the debate, perhaps I<br />
should sit down and allow that to happen.<br />
Lord Tyler: My Lords, the Minister will recall that<br />
in Grand Committee we, too, were concerned about<br />
this issue, and we very much welcome the concession<br />
that he has made this evening. I cannot remember<br />
whether it was him or his colleague but in Grand<br />
Committee the Minister who spoke was pretty adamant<br />
that he wanted to stick with the three-year period.<br />
Therefore, I am glad that on this issue at least the<br />
opposition parties seem to have moved the Minister a<br />
little.<br />
I want to make a couple <strong>of</strong> additional points. First,<br />
I understand that since 2005, which is after all four<br />
years ago, the Electoral Commission has been working<br />
with the Ministry <strong>of</strong> Defence on this issue because it,<br />
too, has been very concerned about the under-registration<br />
<strong>of</strong> members <strong>of</strong> the Armed Forces. Can the Minister<br />
say how that initiative is progressing, and can he give<br />
us an undertaking that, if further recommendations<br />
come forward as a result <strong>of</strong> that exercise, there will be<br />
a method by which he can, if necessary, move further<br />
without the need for legislation?<br />
Secondly, if the discrepancy is anything like the one<br />
to which the noble Lord, Lord Bates, referred, then is<br />
the Minister serious? After all, in recent years we have<br />
been asking young men and women to fight on behalf<br />
<strong>of</strong> the nation in the most appallingly difficult<br />
circumstances. Following deployment, the very least<br />
that they should expect is every possible assistance to<br />
enable them to use their civic right to vote. I cannot<br />
think <strong>of</strong> any situation more frustrating than for a<br />
young service man or woman coming back from Iraq<br />
or Afghanistan not being able to vote on the big issues<br />
affecting the nation today. I am sure that the Minister<br />
accepts and supports that view. Therefore, if the Electoral<br />
Commission and the MoD feel that further improvements<br />
can be made, I hope that there will be ways in which<br />
that can be achieved outwith this legislation.<br />
Lord Craig <strong>of</strong> Radley: My Lords, I am obviously<br />
very interested in this subject. I should like to be quite<br />
clear that it is the responsibility <strong>of</strong> the Ministry <strong>of</strong><br />
Defence to bring to the attention <strong>of</strong> all service personnel<br />
the current situation, whatever it may be, in relation to<br />
voting. At the moment, it seems that one talks about<br />
the Ministry <strong>of</strong> Defence doing this or that, but I<br />
should like it to be clearly laid out that it is an MoD<br />
responsibility.<br />
Lord Bach: My Lords, I am very grateful to noble<br />
Lords. I should have praised, or at least mentioned,<br />
the noble Lord, Lord Tyler, and his colleagues, who<br />
also pushed for a change in our line on this. We were<br />
always persuaded that there was a problem, even<br />
though the numbers have gone up recently, and we<br />
always knew that more had to be done. However, as I<br />
said, their joint advocacy moved us to believe that we<br />
could alter the rules by statutory instrument as soon<br />
as practicable in order to change the time limit from<br />
three to five years.<br />
As I understand it, getting members <strong>of</strong> the Armed<br />
Forces on to the register is a joint obligation on the<br />
Ministry <strong>of</strong> Defence and my department, the Ministry<br />
<strong>of</strong> Justice, which has responsibility for elections in<br />
general terms. That is the answer to the noble and<br />
gallant Lord.<br />
The question <strong>of</strong> the noble Lord, Lord Tyler, links<br />
with the question <strong>of</strong> the noble Lord, Lord Bates,<br />
asking what more we can do. On the information<br />
gained from the survey last year, we have redoubled<br />
efforts through the annual information campaign to<br />
encourage members <strong>of</strong> the Armed Forces and their<br />
families to register to vote and to update their registration<br />
details when they move. The campaign will continue<br />
to highlight the options for service personnel and their<br />
families to register as an ordinary elector or as a<br />
service voter; a choice that they can exercise depending<br />
on their circumstance.<br />
Officials at my department will support that work<br />
and place particular focus on establishing how the<br />
MoD’s joint personnel administration system can help<br />
to promote service registration. As noble Lords will be<br />
aware, the Electoral Administration Act 2006 placed a<br />
duty on the MoD to maintain a record <strong>of</strong> a service<br />
person’s electoral registration record on a voluntary<br />
basis. The use <strong>of</strong> the system is still in its infancy, but<br />
responses from service personnel themselves in the<br />
2008 survey suggest that they could be better employed<br />
to aid registration. It is clear that more work needs to<br />
be done to identify new ways <strong>of</strong> encouraging service<br />
personnel to register. My <strong>of</strong>ficials will meet with MoD<br />
<strong>of</strong>ficials to discuss the matters in more detail, and I am<br />
happy to write to noble Lords on the outcome <strong>of</strong> that<br />
meeting so that they will be kept informed about how<br />
progress is continuing. I hope that in the light <strong>of</strong> the<br />
<strong>of</strong>fer that I have made to the noble Lord, Lord Bates,<br />
he will consider withdrawing his amendment.<br />
Lord Bates: My Lords, I am grateful for the Minister’s<br />
comments, as I am for the intervention <strong>of</strong> the noble<br />
Lord, Lord Tyler, in these matters, and the intervention<br />
<strong>of</strong> the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Craig <strong>of</strong> Radley,<br />
who sought clarification <strong>of</strong> exactly where responsibility<br />
resides. The Minister’s response was clearly that<br />
responsibility is shared between the Ministry <strong>of</strong> Justice<br />
and the Ministry <strong>of</strong> Defence, in which case responsibility<br />
clearly needs to lead to action. It is not acceptable that<br />
there is such a large fall-<strong>of</strong>f involved. More needs to<br />
happen to realise the aspiration put forward by the<br />
Electoral Commission about electoral registration<br />
awareness days.<br />
There is a special electoral registration form for<br />
armed services personnel which is readily available on<br />
the internet. However, there is no substitute for having