FINAL REPORT - Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism

More documents

Recommendations

Info

known address, with June 27 as his deadline for submission of counteraffidavit June, 2005 – Atty. Alan Paguia submitted to, and the House played, his copy of the Garci Tapes June 22, 2005 – Mr. Bunye changed his earlier position and this time denied that President Arroyo’s voice was ever wiretapped, attributed the contradiction between this and his June 6, 2004 statement to the fact that the latter was just based on his “first impression,” and explained that he had referred, on June 6, 2004, to an “original” (as distinguished from a “spliced” version) because he relied on the labels “original” and “altered” respectively attached to the said tapes which had been anonymously delivered to his house and from there to his office in the morning of June 6, 2004. We quote his testimony during the House of Representatives joint Committee hearings of June 22, 2005: “MR. BUNYE. Hindi po natin matukoy, but ito po ay dumating sa aking tanggapan nung umaga ng June 6. CHAIRMAN GOLEZ. Morning of June 6, and then? MR. BUNYE. Ganito po yung nangyari, dahil inusisa ko po kung paano nakarating itong dalawang CD na ito, ay yung nakagawian na po na mga gusto pong magpadala sa akin ng mga liham, ng mga dokumento na hindi po nakakarating sa Malacañang na pinapadala po doon sa bahay ko sa Alabang. At kapag naiipon na po ito ay yung isa ko pong aide ay dumadaan po duon sa Alabang at kinukuha po these bunch of papers. Kaya’t nung morning of June 6 ay andoon na po kasama po iyon doon sa bunch of documents or papers that were on top of my desk. At… CHAIRMAN GOLEZ. At nung alas-dos ng hapon, June 6, binanggit mo na merong dalawang tape, sa iyong presscon, may isang altered at may isang genuine. MR. BUNYE. Ah, totoo po yan. CHAIRMAN GOLEZ. Ibig ninyong sabihin, Mr. Secretary, sa loob ng ilang oras nalaman mo kung ano ang genuine at kung ano ang altered? Anong technology ang ginamit mo, Mr. Secretary, para malaman kung ano ang altered at kung ano ang … MR. BUNYE. Alam po ninyo, nung atin pong matanggap itong CDs na ito nakalagay po sa brown envelope at nung akin pong buksan ay meron markings na po ano, kung sino man po ang nagpadala nitong tapes nito sa akin ay siya na po yung gumawa 116
ng markings. Nakalagay po doon sa isang CD ay original at duon sa isang CD po ay altered. So, that’s how I got these… CHAIRMAN GOLEZ. Ibig ninyong sabihin, Mr. Secretary, na doon sa marking na ‘yon tinanggap ninyo na totoo without benefit of analysis na iyong isa ay altered at iyong isa ay genuine? MR. BUNYE. Ang ginawa po natin ay pinatugtog po natin pareho. CHAIRMAN GOLEZ. At nalaman ninyo kung ano ang altered at kung ano ang genuine? Paano n’yo nalaman ‘yon kung ano ang altered at ano ang genuine? MR. BUNYE. Actually, nakalagay lang po doon sa CD ‘no, yung altered…original and altered, ‘no. xxx xxx xxx MR. BUNYE. Hindi po tayo technical person ‘no, sabihin na lang po natin na dalawang tapes ‘yung nakarating po sa atin ‘no. At base po doon sa labeling ay meron pong naka-label na original, meron pong altered.” (Transcript of testimony of Bunye before the Joint Hearing of the House Committee on Public Information with the Committees on Public Order and Safety, National Defense and Security, Information Communications Technology, and Suffrage and Electoral Reforms, June 22, 2005; emphasis supplied) Likewise, changing his previous story, Mr. Bunye denied knowing the identity of the source, insisting upon his new answer that the tapes were anonymously delivered to his house, and that his earlier reference to a “she” as the source was probably a typographical error - “REP. ESCUDERO. Mr. Secretary, proceeding to another point. Sabi n’yo po, hindi n’yo alam kung sino ang nagbigay sa inyo ng CD o ng tape, tama po ba ‘yon? MR. BUNYE. Ah, sinabi ko po na ito po ay dinala po nung aming…aming aide, na pinik-up (pick-up) po ito doon sa bahay namin sa Alabang at dinala po sa aming opisina. Ngayon, kung sino po yung nagdala po sa…sa aming bahay sa Alabang, hindi po natin alam. REP. ESCUDERO. Secretary Bunye, on June 6, in a press conference and I have the transcript, tinanong po kayo ng media doon, at sabi po nila, “Nasa inyo ba yung original?” And I quote your answer, “No, no. This was given to us by a source. She does not want to be identified… 117
Page 1 and 2:
FINAL REPORT Findings and Recommend
Page 3 and 4:
(including her former boyfriend T/S
Page 5 and 6:
“Louie” in Garci Tapes, commitm
Page 7 and 8:
directly possible through President
Page 9 and 10:
For the Secretary’s consideration
Page 11 and 12:
NORTH COTABATO Governor Emmanuel Pi
Page 13 and 14:
xxx xxx xxx In the group’s press
Page 15 and 16:
B. Implementation of Electoral Frau
Page 17 and 18:
Some opposition sources sat that Do
Page 19 and 20:
7. Also, according to Doble, there
Page 21 and 22:
men at the San Carlos Seminary guar
Page 23 and 24:
sabihin sa lahat na wala po silang
Page 25 and 26:
MS. SANTOS. MIG 21 po. SEN. PIMENTE
Page 27 and 28:
THE CHAIRMAN. Paki-describe mo nga
Page 29 and 30:
MS. SANTOS. Galing kami ng San Carl
Page 31 and 32:
MS. SANTOS. Opo. (ibid., VI-1, 10:5
Page 33 and 34:
MS. SANTOS. Telepono po. Minsan sa
Page 35 and 36:
MS. SANTOS. Po? SEN. ENRILE. Anong
Page 37 and 38:
Committee on National Defense, Janu
Page 39 and 40:
13. For the duration of our stay an
Page 41 and 42:
ending in the possession of Atty. S
Page 43 and 44:
and another witness. She was able t
Page 45 and 46:
MS. SANTOS. Opo. … SEN. LIM. Baki
Page 47 and 48:
MR. ZUCE. Mayroon na po. Mayroon na
Page 49 and 50:
“Male: Hello. Female: Hello. Male
Page 51 and 52:
One” 13 that the FPJ camp will fi
Page 53 and 54:
I come in compliance of a Senate su
Page 55 and 56:
all armed forces unit commanders we
Page 57 and 58:
We were receiving complaints from a
Page 59 and 60:
xxx xxx xxx MR. GUDANI. He was desi
Page 61 and 62:
MR. GUDANI. Mr. Chairman, I am arri
Page 63 and 64:
the last national - local elections
Page 65 and 66: Code 1: O sige, ok.” Garci Tapes
Page 67 and 68: Ruben: Hindi naman pumupunta, pero
Page 69 and 70: intonation of the spoken (or sung)
Page 71 and 72: Mendoza, and after him, Namfrel Lan
Page 73 and 74: officemates were sent in his behalf
Page 75 and 76: Garcillano told me about them and a
Page 77 and 78: MR. ZUCE. ‘Yong una po, namigay d
Page 79 and 80: MR. ZUCE. Opo. SEN. OSMEÑA. So bal
Page 81 and 82: MR. ZUCE. Siyempre po, marami pong
Page 83 and 84: 3. On May 11, 2004, I was asked by
Page 85 and 86: success of GMA. When Com. Virgilio
Page 87 and 88: MR ZUCE. Ang madalas ho naming kaus
Page 89 and 90: sinasabi mo? Iyon lang narinig mo.
Page 91 and 92: “slacken” his otherwise very st
Page 93 and 94: MR. BALUTAN. In the first place, I
Page 95 and 96: For what purpose do you feel did Co
Page 97 and 98: To cite just five (5) more examples
Page 99 and 100: kinds of fraud, lahat ng klase ng c
Page 101 and 102: Election Returns at saka COC. We re
Page 103 and 104: ibig sabihin kailangang huwag natin
Page 105 and 106: affirming portions of their testimo
Page 107 and 108: JUSTICE CAPULONG: Mayroon po ba kay
Page 109 and 110: small to be the thumbprint of an ad
Page 111 and 112: The Commission on Elections has adm
Page 113 and 114: which every Filipino can glean for
Page 115: Q: And they were indeed having a co
Page 119 and 120: MR. BUNYE. He - Your Honor - that w
Page 121 and 122: MR. DOBLE. Ang totoo po, Your Honor
Page 123 and 124: CHAIRMAN G.C. REMULLA. Hindi…paki
Page 125 and 126: effecting Philippine constitutional
Page 127 and 128: ‘find’. Disgusted with the dece
Page 129 and 130: It is only now that I have come to
Page 131 and 132: We wondered: What did the President
Page 133 and 134: Right now, the venue where we can d
Page 135 and 136: September 29, 2005 - expert witness
Page 137 and 138: -- Marieta Santos likewise testifie
Page 139 and 140: switching of election returns in th
Page 141 and 142: workers and these funds have accumu
Page 143 and 144: The Medicare Fund is a trust fund a
Page 145 and 146: (Annex “L”). In the March-April
Page 147 and 148: Medicare fund to the Philippine Hea
Page 149 and 150: The story of one is the story of al
Page 151 and 152: Its breakdown is as follows: Nature
Page 153 and 154: The Mechanics of the Fertilizer Fun
Page 155 and 156: indicate Undersecretary Poliquit as
Page 157 and 158: The Other Courageous Witnesses Anto
Page 159 and 160: Procurement Law and wanton wastage
Page 161 and 162: committed. xxx xxx xxx A criminal c
Page 163 and 164: ensure that Mrs. Macapagal-Arroyo w
Page 165 and 166: “EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Legality of th
Page 167 and 168:
3. The Contract with Venable Llp. O
Page 169 and 170:
have our national sovereignty, our
Page 171 and 172:
CONCLUSION Massive electoral fraud,
Page 173 and 174:
But President Arroyo did nothing of
Page 175 and 176:
confusion and deception, and suppre
Page 177 and 178:
Comelec/military waged against the
Page 179 and 180:
quashed the impeachment complaints
Page 181 and 182:
7. To conduct other actions and act
Page 183 and 184:
Marcos, which was heard by the Hawa
Page 185 and 186:
He narrated that on 6, 7 and 15 Nov
Page 187 and 188:
his residence. They would ask aroun
Page 189 and 190:
to abduct Patricio’s wife should
Page 191 and 192:
MAXIMIANO M. DE MESA, chairperson o
Page 193 and 194:
5. sinumpaang salaysay or affidavit
Page 195 and 196:
D. Documentary evidence relative to
Page 197 and 198:
Asian Centre for Human Rights (ACHR
Page 199 and 200:
Philippine Army who have been accus
Page 201 and 202:
Article XI Section 2. The President
Page 203:
Recommendations It is respectfully
show all

FINAL REPORT - Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism

Create successful ePaper yourself

Delete template?

Save as template?