FINAL REPORT - Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism
FINAL REPORT - Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism
FINAL REPORT - Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
the last national – local elections under the leadership of General<br />
Gudani, the 1 st Marine Grigade.<br />
I have no prepared statement but I would like to<br />
corroborate and support the statements of General Gudani. And I<br />
believe during that time that we – I was a victim of circumstances.<br />
I stood my ground against <strong>for</strong>ces or pressures from any political<br />
entity and I believe I have done my duty well under, you know, the<br />
– we were deputized by the Commission on Elections under<br />
Sumalipao during that time. And my only frustration at that time<br />
was that my brigade commander was relieved. I cannot – I don’t<br />
know what to reason to my subordinate. That was my dilemma…<br />
Mr. BALUTAN. … dilemma. He was relieved <strong>for</strong> no apparent reason,<br />
maybe <strong>for</strong> doing our job well, <strong>for</strong> being apolitical, <strong>for</strong> being<br />
impartial. And I think that is the dilemma of the ground<br />
commander, me as the battalion commander during that time<br />
which, sir, in fact, I promised the people of Lanao, the area that I<br />
am assigned to, the 17 municipalities, that we will have a peaceful<br />
and credible election. I urged and <strong>for</strong>ced them <strong>for</strong> a peace<br />
covenant, in fact, many times, that your armed <strong>for</strong>ces and the<br />
marines will protect your vote. And we will have a clean and<br />
credible election.”<br />
Garci Tapes reference to Tipo-Tipo, Basilan election supervisor Rashma Hali 16 –<br />
in which Garcillano, in response to the comment that Rashma Hali be kidnapped,<br />
suggested the “soft touch” first, i.e., to look <strong>for</strong> a relative who can persuade her (not to<br />
expose election anomalies)<br />
Garci Tapes Excerpt<br />
“Conversation between “Gary” and someone named “Boy” recorded 05 13:41H<br />
June 2004 TRT – 1:36<br />
Gary<br />
Boy<br />
Gary<br />
Boy<br />
Gary<br />
Boy<br />
Gary<br />
Boy<br />
Gary<br />
Boy<br />
: Hello Boy.<br />
: Hello Sir<br />
: Ano yun?<br />
: Mmmm…si Rashma parang nandyan sa Maynila.<br />
: Nasa Maynila?<br />
: M-mm<br />
: Naku delikado! Hindi ba natin makontak?<br />
: Yung…walang…walang ano…inoff ang cellphone. Pina-pinahanap<br />
ko sa<br />
ISAFP.<br />
: Uhh, baka si…ahh, si kwan…delikado yan.<br />
: Oo nga, sabi ko…sabi ko sa ISAFP …(Translated from<br />
Visayan)…dito na<br />
16<br />
from the Sarthou VCD (Conversation No. 36 in PCIJ’s version of the Garci Tapes [hereafter, “PCIJ Garci Tapes”])<br />
63