08.11.2014 Views

The Penguin Dictionary of American English Usage and Style : A ...

The Penguin Dictionary of American English Usage and Style : A ...

The Penguin Dictionary of American English Usage and Style : A ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

16 an<br />

ately after noon to immediately before<br />

midnight.<br />

In referring to the stroke <strong>of</strong> 12, you<br />

can say 12 noon or 12 midnight, or just<br />

noon or midnight. To avoid confusion,<br />

do not abbreviate. Sometimes “12 M.”<br />

(meridian) is used for noon <strong>and</strong> “12<br />

P.M.” for midnight. But the “M.” can be<br />

misinterpreted as an abbreviation <strong>of</strong><br />

“midnight” <strong>and</strong> people may not know<br />

what to make <strong>of</strong> the “P.M.”<br />

Midnight ends a day. So “midnight<br />

Wednesday” is the end <strong>of</strong> Wednesday,<br />

not the beginning <strong>of</strong> Thursday.<br />

A.M. <strong>and</strong> P.M. are spelled also with<br />

lower-case letters (a.m., p.m. or a.m.,<br />

p.m.) or small capitals (A.M., P.M.).<br />

AN. See A <strong>and</strong> AN.<br />

Anachronism. 1. Historical revision.<br />

2. Illogical captions. 3. Retroactive retitling.<br />

4. Untrue dialogue.<br />

1. Historical revision<br />

In 1867 Secretary <strong>of</strong> State William H.<br />

Seward signed a treaty “to purchase<br />

Alaska from the Soviet Union”—at least<br />

that is what the hostess on a national radio<br />

show said (111 years later). Various<br />

commentators have called Seward ahead<br />

<strong>of</strong> his time; he would have had to be fifty<br />

years ahead to deal with the Soviet<br />

Union, which came into existence in<br />

1917. <strong>The</strong> treaty was with Russia.<br />

That is an example <strong>of</strong> an anachronism,<br />

a verbal or graphic misplacement<br />

in time, a chronological error. Chronology<br />

shares with anachronism the root<br />

khronos, Greek for time. (Ana- means<br />

backward.) Sometimes anachronism is<br />

used erroneously in place <strong>of</strong> anomaly or<br />

contradiction, but time is the key.<br />

We are concerned here mainly with<br />

the distortion <strong>of</strong> history by the intrusion<br />

<strong>of</strong> things that came later, particularly<br />

names, terms, <strong>and</strong> expressions. Anachronisms<br />

are inevitable in fiction representing<br />

the future: 1984 turned out<br />

differently from 1984 (a fact that does<br />

not detract from the eminence <strong>of</strong> Orwell’s<br />

book).<br />

An almanac anachronistically stated<br />

that the Internal Revenue Service (IRS)<br />

was “founded in 1862.” It was so<br />

named in 1953 as a new identity for the<br />

Bureau <strong>of</strong> Internal Revenue. A television<br />

interviewee said Al Capone, the gangster,<br />

was arrested for “IRS violations.” Make<br />

it tax violations. Capone died in 1947.<br />

This statement was made in a TV documentary<br />

about the search for the missing<br />

link by archaeologists in Africa:<br />

Tools were first recognized by Louis<br />

Leakey, when he came to this remote<br />

corner <strong>of</strong> Tanzania in 1931.<br />

Leakey went to Tanganyika. Tanzania<br />

was formed in 1964 (from the union <strong>of</strong><br />

Tanganyika <strong>and</strong> Zanzibar).<br />

2. Illogical captions<br />

Captions <strong>of</strong> photographs published in<br />

the popular press are apt to juxtapose<br />

past <strong>and</strong> present illogically, as this caption<br />

in a Sunday paper does:<br />

UNDER THE GAZE <strong>of</strong> a mannequin<br />

Saturday, Steve C—— . . . tries salmon<br />

sausage . . . at the Pittsburg<br />

Seafood Festival, which continues today.<br />

“Saturday,” yesterday, he “tries” it?<br />

“Tries” should be tried. <strong>The</strong> writer has<br />

forced upon the present tense the impossible<br />

task <strong>of</strong> representing the past as well<br />

as the present (the festival “continues today”).<br />

Having set an action in the past, a<br />

sentence cannot bring in the present<br />

tense to represent that action.<br />

To write that “strawberries await<br />

buyers Thursday at Whole Foods market<br />

. . .” would normally imply that buyers<br />

could expect them next Thursday. But<br />

the quotation is the caption <strong>of</strong> a picture<br />

taken yesterday, Thursday, <strong>and</strong> pub-

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!