16.11.2012 Views

logical language - Developers

logical language - Developers

logical language - Developers

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

in most cases, far exceed the dynamism and range of such English word series.<br />

Another principle underlying the formation of words in Ithkuil is complementarity. Western thought<br />

and <strong>language</strong> generally reflect Aristotelian logic in the way they conceptualize the world and the<br />

interrelationships between discrete entities in that world. Ithkuil, on the other hand, views the world as<br />

being based on complementary principles, where, instead of discrete independence between related<br />

entities, such concepts are seen as complementary aspects of a single holistic entity. Such<br />

complementarity is in turn reflected in the derivation of word-roots. By “complementarity” is meant that<br />

the manifestation of a concept appears in any given context as either one sort of entity or another, but<br />

never both simultaneously; yet, neither manifestation can be considered to be a discrete whole without<br />

the existence of the other. A simple illustration of complementarity is the flip of a coin: the coin can only<br />

land on one side or the other, yet without both sides being part of the coin, any given coin toss has no<br />

meaning or contextual relevance no matter which side is face-up.<br />

For example, in Western <strong>language</strong>s, words such as male, night, limb, sit, and happen are all<br />

autonomous words, linguistically representing what are inherently considered to be basic mental<br />

concepts or semantic primitives. However, in Ithkuil, none of these words is considered to be a<br />

semantic primitive. Instead, they are seen to be parts of greater, more holistic semantic concepts,<br />

existing in complementary relationship to another part, the two together making up the whole.<br />

Thus, Ithkuil lexical structure recognizes that the word male has no meaning in and of itself without an<br />

implicit recognition of its complementary partner, female, the two words mutually deriving from a more<br />

basic, holistic concept, translatable into English as living being. Similarly, the word night(time) derives<br />

along with its complement day(time) from the underlying concept translatable as day (24-hour period),<br />

while limb, along with its complement trunk or torso, derives from the stem (corporeal) body.<br />

Actions, too, are not exempt from this principle of complementarity, an example being the relationship<br />

between sit and seat; one has no meaning without an implicit and joint partnership with the other, i.e.,<br />

one cannot sit unless one sits upon something, and whatever one sits upon automatically functions as a<br />

seat. We see the awkward attempt of English to convey these jointly dependent but mutually exclusive<br />

perspectives when comparing the sentences Please sit down and Please be seated. Another example<br />

involves the word happen or occur, which Ithkuil recognizes as having no real meaning without the<br />

attendant implication of consequence or result, the two being complementary components of a holistic<br />

concept roughly translatable as event or situation.<br />

The Ithkuil word for hole illustrates another instance of complementarity. Holes can be looked at from<br />

two different, but interrelated perspectives: either as an opening connecting two different spaces (or<br />

access point to a previously unavailable space, i.e., a pit), or as a discontinuity in the surface or<br />

structural integrity of the dividing entity separating the two realms. In other words, one can focus on the<br />

potential function or consequences of the hole, or on the structural nature of the hole. Either of these<br />

two perspectives represents a legitimate, but complementary way to consider a hole or puncture. Thus,<br />

the Ithkuil word would have two derivative roots each indicating one of these two perspectives. One<br />

such root would be used when saying There’s a hole in your shirt, while the other would be used when<br />

saying She saw me through a hole in the fence.<br />

Ithkuil recognizes that such complementarity exists for virtually any concept, in fact that it is one of the<br />

foundational principles of the universe itself. No beam of light can be spoken of without implicit<br />

recognition of its source. No signal can be described without accounting for the signaling device. Indeed,

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!