Ambedkar-Philosophy of Hinduism
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
AMBEDKAR'S PHILOSOPHY OF HINDUISM AND CONTEMPORARY CRITIQUES<br />
PROF. M. M. NINAN<br />
IV<br />
NIRMUKTA<br />
Examining the excuses <strong>of</strong> Swami Vivekananda<br />
http://nirmukta.net/Thread-On-Vivekananda-s-defense-<strong>of</strong>-caste<br />
On Vivekananda's defense <strong>of</strong> caste<br />
08-06-2012 06:34 AM<br />
Vivekananda's views on caste are instructive in that they sum up the views <strong>of</strong> today's defenders <strong>of</strong> the caste<br />
system. Even among people who don't defend the caste system, you will find rich echoes <strong>of</strong> thoughts that<br />
Vivekananda puts forth.<br />
What is the point <strong>of</strong> this post?<br />
To show that Vivekananda was a casteist?<br />
If by being casteist, it means that one is willfully justifying an inhuman practice, then no. Vivekananda is not a<br />
casteist in that sense. I don't think he had any malicious intent and means well when he defends the caste system.<br />
The point <strong>of</strong> this post is to show that even though his defense is well meaning, it isn't <strong>of</strong> any good.<br />
So what does Vivekananda say?<br />
He readily accepts that the caste system has become corrupt.<br />
He stresses that caste is not by birth, but is based on qualities.<br />
Not only that, one exhibits qualities <strong>of</strong> all varnas in their life.<br />
The beauty <strong>of</strong> the caste system is that it leads to a stable non-violent system and the end goal is achieving<br />
good for all. To drive home this point, he says that a brahmana is a brahmana only when they share their<br />
knowledge and strive towards making everyone else a brahamana.<br />
On the face, it is a convincing defense. If such a system is put in place, how could it go wrong?<br />
Firstly there is a problem in the assumption underlying “ If such a system is put in place...”. Since dawn <strong>of</strong><br />
civilizations, many have given solutions to all <strong>of</strong> human-kind's problems. None <strong>of</strong> them worked. That is the evidence<br />
we have with us. The reason why they didn't work is they assumed an utopia, a world which has a very low<br />
probability <strong>of</strong> existing.<br />
138