27.02.2017 Views

SPA 3e_ Teachers Edition _ Ch 6

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

ddd<br />

ddd<br />

dddd<br />

ddd<br />

ddd<br />

dd<br />

ddd<br />

ddd<br />

ddd<br />

Lesson 6.2<br />

Sampling Distributions:<br />

center and variability<br />

L e A r n i n g T A r g e T S<br />

d Determine if a statistic is an unbiased estimator of a population parameter.<br />

d Describe the relationship between sample size and the variability of a<br />

statistic.<br />

Learning Target Key<br />

The problems in the test bank are<br />

keyed to the learning targets using<br />

these numbers:<br />

d 6.2.1<br />

d 6.2.2<br />

Lesson 6.2<br />

AcT iviT y<br />

How many craft sticks are in the bag?<br />

In this activity, you will create a statistic for estimating<br />

the total number of craft sticks in a bag (N). The<br />

sticks are numbered 1, 2, 3, . . . , N. Near the end of the<br />

activity, your teacher will select a random sample of<br />

n 5 7 sticks and read the number on each stick to the<br />

class. The team that has the best estimate for the total<br />

number of sticks will win a prize.<br />

1. Form teams of three or four students. As a team,<br />

spend about 10 minutes brainstorming different<br />

ways to estimate the total number of sticks. Try to<br />

come up with at least three different statistics.<br />

2. Before your teacher provides the sample of sticks,<br />

use simulation to investigate the sampling distribution<br />

of each statistic. For the simulation, assume<br />

that there are N 5 100 sticks in the bag and that<br />

you will be selecting samples of size n 5 7.<br />

j Using your TI-83/84 calculator, select an SRS of<br />

size 7 using the command RandIntNoRep(lower:<br />

1,upper:100,n:7). [With older OS, use the command<br />

RandInt(lower:1,upper:100,n:7) and verify<br />

that there are no repeated numbers. If there are<br />

repeats, press ENTER to get a new sample.]<br />

j For each sample, calculate the value of each of<br />

your three statistics.<br />

Unbiased Estimators<br />

j<br />

j<br />

graph these values on a set of dotplots like those<br />

shown here.<br />

Perform as many trials of the simulation as possible.<br />

Statistic 3 Statistic 2 Statistic 1<br />

60<br />

70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140<br />

Estimated total<br />

3. Based on the simulated sampling distributions,<br />

which of your statistics is likely to produce the<br />

best estimate? Discuss as a team.<br />

4. Your teacher will now draw a sample of n 5 7<br />

sticks from the bag. On a piece of paper, write<br />

the names of your group members, your group’s<br />

estimate for the number of sticks in the bag (a<br />

number), and the statistic you used to calculate<br />

your estimate (a formula).<br />

In the craft sticks activity, the goal was to estimate the maximum value in a population,<br />

with the assumption that the members of the population are numbered 1, 2, . . . , N.<br />

Two possible statistics that might be used to estimate N are the sample maximum (max)<br />

and twice the sample median (2 3 median).<br />

Assuming that the population has N 5 100 members and we use SRSs of size n 5 7,<br />

Figure 6.2 shows the simulated sampling distributions of the sample maximum and<br />

twice the sample median.<br />

409<br />

Bell Ringer<br />

Suppose you wish to estimate the<br />

average (mean) height of all students at<br />

your school by taking a random sample<br />

of students and calculating the average<br />

height of the sample. Would you expect<br />

the sample mean to be closer to the<br />

true average height from a sample of<br />

4 students or 40 students?<br />

The best statistics are centered at 100<br />

with low variability. A pre-made Fathom<br />

file is included in the Teacher’s Resource<br />

Materials. If you don’t have Fathom,<br />

the figure shows simulated sampling<br />

distributions for several commonly used<br />

statistics using 200 random samples. The<br />

statistics are<br />

• TwiceMean 5 2 · sample mean<br />

• TwiceMedian 5 2 · sample median<br />

• Max 5 sample maximum<br />

• MeanPlusMed 5 mean 1 median<br />

• SumQuartiles 5 Q 1 1 Q 3<br />

• TwiceIQR 5 2 · IQR<br />

• MeanPlus2SD 5 sample mean 1<br />

2 · sample standard deviation<br />

• Partition 5 (8/7) · sample maximum<br />

TwiceMean<br />

d<br />

d<br />

dd dd ddd<br />

d<br />

dd<br />

d d ddd dddd d<br />

dd d<br />

ddddddddd<br />

dddd d d<br />

dd ddddd d<br />

dd d dd d ddd<br />

d<br />

18/08/16 4:59 PMStarnes_<strong>3e</strong>_CH06_398-449_Final.indd 409<br />

Activity Overview<br />

Time: 40–50 minutes<br />

Materials: Graphing calculators or an Internetconnected<br />

device for each student or group of<br />

students, a prize for the winning team, and a<br />

population of craft sticks. We recommend using<br />

at least 100 sticks (but not exactly 100). Use an<br />

opaque container so students can’t use their<br />

eyes to estimate the total.<br />

Teaching Advice: The point of this activity is to<br />

illustrate the concepts of bias and variability of<br />

statistics. This is a long activity and should be<br />

done during an entire class period.<br />

Start by selecting one or two sticks to<br />

make the contents of the bag less abstract.<br />

Be patient in Step 1! Teams will struggle.<br />

18/08/16 4:59 PM<br />

Let them keep at it. Once one statistic is<br />

proposed, usually more will follow.<br />

During Step 1, rotate around the room to<br />

give suggestions to teams that are struggling.<br />

Consider giving away one or more of the<br />

methods used later in the lesson, such as the<br />

sample maximum, twice the sample median,<br />

or twice the sample mean. These are all<br />

decent statistics but not the best.<br />

During Step 2, students can use their<br />

calculators or a random generator on the<br />

Internet (like random.org) to generate 7<br />

integers without repeats. Groups should<br />

generate at least 20 samples. If you have the<br />

ability to simulate the sampling distributions<br />

for a number of statistics using Fathom or<br />

other software, consider offering another<br />

prize for the team with the best statistic.<br />

TwiceMedian<br />

Max<br />

MeanPlusMed<br />

SumQuartiles<br />

TwiceIQR<br />

MeanPlus2SD<br />

Partition<br />

d<br />

d<br />

dddd<br />

d d<br />

d ddd dd<br />

ddd ddd dd<br />

ddd ddd dddd dd d dd d d dddddddd ddd<br />

d dddd ddd d dd dd<br />

d<br />

dd<br />

dd<br />

d<br />

ddd<br />

d<br />

d<br />

dddd dd<br />

ddd<br />

ddddd d<br />

d d ddddddd ddddddddd d d<br />

dd ddddd<br />

d<br />

d d dd dd dddd<br />

dddd ddd<br />

dddd d ddd dd d dd d d<br />

d<br />

dd<br />

d d dd<br />

d<br />

ddddddd dd ddddddd d dd<br />

dd<br />

dd ddd<br />

dd d d ddd d dd d<br />

ddd<br />

dd<br />

d ddd d<br />

dd<br />

d dd<br />

dd<br />

ddd<br />

dddd<br />

ddddd<br />

d<br />

ddd dd d ddddd d ddd ddd dd d ddd<br />

d d dddd<br />

d<br />

d<br />

ddddd<br />

dddd d d dd ddd<br />

ddddddddd ddd d<br />

dd<br />

ddddd dddd ddddddddddd ddddd<br />

d 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200<br />

ddd<br />

d dddd dd dddd dd dd<br />

dddd d<br />

ddddd d<br />

ddd dd<br />

ddd d<br />

dd ddd dddd<br />

dddddddd d ddddd dddd dddddddd<br />

d<br />

d dd ddd<br />

d<br />

dd d<br />

ddd<br />

dd d dd d<br />

Answers:<br />

1. Answers will vary by student group.<br />

2. Dotplots will vary.<br />

3. Answers will vary. The best statistics<br />

are centered at 100 with low<br />

variability.<br />

4. Answers will vary by student group.<br />

dd<br />

d<br />

d<br />

d<br />

ddd dd<br />

dd<br />

dd<br />

d<br />

dd<br />

dd d d<br />

d<br />

ddd<br />

L E S S O N 6.2 • Sampling Distributions: Center and Variability 409<br />

Starnes_<strong>3e</strong>_ATE_CH06_398-449_v3.indd 409<br />

11/01/17 3:54 PM

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!