13.06.2017 Views

PC_Tech_Authority_July_2017

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

AUSTRALIA’S MOST POPULAR <strong>PC</strong> MAG<br />

THE BEST<br />

FREE APPS<br />

25 CRACKERS FOR: ENTERTAINMENT<br />

* PRODUCTIVITY * MEDIA * SECURITY<br />

THEY’RE<br />

ALL ON<br />

THE DVD!<br />

AUTHORITY<br />

AUTOMATE<br />

EVERYTHING!<br />

LIFE ENHANCEMENTS<br />

WITH IFTTT, MICROSOFT FLOW & ZAPIER<br />

FULL VERSIONS!<br />

APPS WORTH $135<br />

+ ANTI RANSOMWARE <strong>2017</strong><br />

+ ASCOMP BACKUP MAKER<br />

+ NOVA PDF LITE 8<br />

+ ASHAMPOO UNINSTALLER <strong>2017</strong><br />

LABS REVIEWS:<br />

+ INTEL OPTANE<br />

+ HP PAVILLION WAVE<br />

+ OCULUS TOUCH<br />

+ GIGABYTE AERO 15<br />

+ ASUS VC66R MINI <strong>PC</strong><br />

+ DREAMVISION 32”<br />

AIO GAME <strong>PC</strong><br />

+ NETGEAR S8000<br />

+ ASUS FGX533 LAPTOP<br />

AND MORE!<br />

GROUP TEST:<br />

VALUE<br />

SMARTPHONES<br />

11 OF THE<br />

BEST RATED<br />

FROM UNDER<br />

$300!<br />

07<br />

AU$9.99 Inc. GST<br />

NZ$10.99 Inc. GST<br />

9 771329 297006<br />

ISSUE 236 JULY <strong>2017</strong>


TECH DESK LOGIN<br />

ROBOT WARS<br />

Many casualties, hopefully not YOU<br />

Y<br />

esterday I sat through a<br />

keynote by Eugene Kaspersky<br />

at Sydney’s CeBIT event. I<br />

usually steer well clear of CeBIT due<br />

to its heavily enterprise nature. One<br />

can only tolerate so many empty<br />

server racks on display from keen<br />

vendors, or ‘NSW is on the move!”<br />

government exhibitions before the<br />

brain fades completely. I commented<br />

to a colleague who covers these things<br />

that it was all too terrifyingly real<br />

world for my consumer electronics<br />

tastes, to which he replied that<br />

this was “the tech that pays for<br />

everything.”<br />

But I went along to hear the<br />

boss of Kaspersky’s keynote, titled<br />

“Threat Landscapes: What Australia<br />

Can Expect Now & In The Future”.<br />

Unfortunately Mr Kaspersky rolled<br />

out a stock presentation that didn’t<br />

mention any Australia-specific<br />

threats or statistics, not once. A few<br />

anecdotes here, a few (admittedly<br />

good) jokes there, and it was done.<br />

Later in a press conference he was<br />

grilled by a serious bunch of journos,<br />

and again deferred to broad and often<br />

irrelevant stories.<br />

So that was a disappointing waste<br />

of time, and we all expected better<br />

– there was much grumbling among<br />

the other journos about the almost<br />

complete lack of real Aussie-relevant<br />

information. I was saving writing this<br />

page until after the keynote, fully<br />

expecting much juicy info to share<br />

with you.<br />

But all is not lost. One of Eugene’s<br />

better jokey tales was about the<br />

number of new threats the world faces<br />

each day, and how they’re dealt with.<br />

Note I say “the world” because we all<br />

expected Australian stats, not global.<br />

But moving right along...<br />

So apparently there are 300,000<br />

Get exclusive content with<br />

the <strong>PC</strong>&TA iPad app<br />

If you prefer to enjoy <strong>PC</strong> & <strong>Tech</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> via your iPad<br />

(sorry, no Android...), then by all means please do so!<br />

Each issue is just $6.49 and has all the content that<br />

you’ll find in the magazine.<br />

Get the app: <strong>PC</strong> & <strong>Tech</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> for iPad<br />

http://tinyurl.com/iPAD<strong>PC</strong>TA<br />

new threat types (viruses, malware<br />

etc.) every single day. They are<br />

generated by computers, which subtly<br />

modify the code within existing threats<br />

so they circumvent known code and<br />

the blacklists they appear in. That’s an<br />

awful lot of evil computer code to deal<br />

with, and is way beyond the capability<br />

and capacity of mere humans to battle<br />

by hand on a daily basis.<br />

Thus, to make it a fair fight security<br />

outfits like Kaspersky use their own<br />

machines to do battle with the enemy<br />

code, tearing it apart as it is detected,<br />

analysing it and making decisions<br />

about whether it is benign or malignant,<br />

and updating their respective security<br />

products.<br />

Every day across the world computers<br />

are waging war with other computers,<br />

serving us, the human masters. All<br />

without human intervention, and in<br />

most cases, all contained within server<br />

racks, with perhaps a daily report<br />

on total fights fought being the only<br />

time human eyes are set upon the<br />

battlefield.<br />

So, that’s this month’s cool story. I’d<br />

mention how proud Eugene was that<br />

most of the world’s hackers are Russian<br />

– yes he really said that – because, he<br />

boasts, that just shows how talented<br />

they are at technology, and what a<br />

great tech-based education system<br />

Russia has to cultivate such talent, but<br />

I’m out of space.<br />

Ben Mansill<br />

Editor<br />

bmansill@nextmedia.com.au<br />

REAL TECH ADVICE<br />

YOU CAN TRUST!<br />

Our tests are performed by<br />

experienced reviewers in our Labs in<br />

accordance with strict benchtesting<br />

procedures<br />

Our brand new benchmarks have<br />

been tailor-made to reflect realworld<br />

computing needs<br />

We put tech through its paces –<br />

seriously. From processing power to<br />

battery life, from usability to screen<br />

brightness, our tests are exhaustive<br />

We will always offer an honest and<br />

unbiased opinion for every review<br />

THE TEAM...<br />

Digital Editor <strong>Tech</strong><br />

and Gaming<br />

David Hollingworth<br />

E dhollingworth@nextmedia.com.au<br />

T @atomicmpc<br />

Senior Labs Editor<br />

Bennett Ring<br />

National Advertising<br />

Manager <strong>PC</strong>&TA<br />

Sean Fletcher<br />

E sfletcher@nextmedia.com.au<br />

Group Advertising<br />

Manager <strong>Tech</strong> and<br />

Gaming<br />

Cameron Ferris<br />

E cferris@nextmedia.com.au<br />

Art Director<br />

Tim Frawley<br />

E tfrawley@nextmedia.com.au<br />

CONTACT US...<br />

Call us (02) 9901 6100<br />

E-mail us<br />

inbox@pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

Facebook<br />

www.facebook.com/<br />

pcandtechauthority<br />

Twitter<br />

@pctechauthority<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 3


CONTENTS<br />

REGULARS<br />

FEATURES<br />

Upgrade Australia wrap<br />

Our big night went off, see the<br />

photos and hear about what<br />

went down ...................................................... 24<br />

Best free apps<br />

All of them are on the DVD! ....................... 28<br />

Automate your life<br />

How to set automated rules to make life<br />

easier and work more productive .............. 38<br />

TECHDESK<br />

News<br />

IoT under attack, Apple’s next MacPro and<br />

streaming music stats .....................................8<br />

Game news<br />

A look at trends in gaming we don’t<br />

necessarily love ............................................... 12<br />

Chip news<br />

A huge month as all the players release<br />

interesting new products! ............................ 14<br />

FUTURES<br />

<strong>Tech</strong>nology and medicine<br />

How tech is changing health care .............84<br />

REAL WORLD COMPUTING<br />

Jon Honeyball<br />

Jon explores the advantages<br />

of Apple’s new file system, before<br />

explaining why we all need to sit up<br />

and listen when it comes to surround<br />

sound for VR .................................................100<br />

Paul Ockenden<br />

Paul finds the new Raspberry Pi<br />

Zero W is an excellent platform for<br />

creating a “thing”, and a tip for<br />

Netgear Orbi owners ................................... 103<br />

Smart cities<br />

Dr Larissa Suzuki shares insights<br />

from her PhD thesis, which now<br />

forms the basis of London’s city data<br />

strategy. ..........................................................106<br />

Davey Winder<br />

Davey delves deep into the world of<br />

encryption. First, remembering how PGP<br />

began, and then through a service that<br />

promises to secure your email ................ 108<br />

Steve Cassidy<br />

Robot cheerleaders fail to excite<br />

Steve on a visit to trade show CeBIT,<br />

but a plea for more open standards<br />

in IoT does set his pulse racing .................110<br />

ALIST AND KITLOG<br />

The best of the best ..................................92<br />

DVD CONTENTS<br />

Installation and features guide ........... 98<br />

EPILOG<br />

Spies amongst us<br />

Jon Honeyball on government spying and<br />

what can be done about it ........................ 114<br />

4 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


CONTENTS<br />

VALUE SMARTPHONES<br />

Group test 64<br />

REVIEWS<br />

<strong>PC</strong>S & LAPTOPS<br />

HP Pavillion Wave .................................................53<br />

Gigabyte Aero 15 ....................................................54<br />

Asus VC66R ............................................................55<br />

Pioneer Dreamvision 32” AIO <strong>PC</strong>7X ................58<br />

Asus FGX533 ..........................................................59<br />

HANDHELDS<br />

Apple iPhone SE ................................................... 68<br />

Google Nexus 5X.................................................. 69<br />

LG G4 ........................................................................70<br />

Motorola Moto G4 ................................................ 72<br />

Motorola Moto G5 ................................................ 73<br />

Motorola Moto Z Play .......................................... 74<br />

Oneplus 3T..............................................................76<br />

Samsung Galaxy A5 ............................................ 77<br />

Samsung Galaxy A6 ............................................78<br />

Samsung Galaxy S7 .............................................79<br />

Sony Xperia X Compact .................................... 80<br />

PERIPHERALS<br />

Netgear AD7200 ...................................................56<br />

Netgear AC5300 ................................................... 57<br />

Netgear S8000 media switch ......................... 60<br />

Oculus Touch Controller ......................................61<br />

COMPONENTS<br />

Intel Optane ........................................................... 50<br />

GAMES<br />

Prey ........................................................................... 88<br />

Endless Space 2 ................................................... 90<br />

SUBSCRIBE & SAVE!<br />

Get <strong>PC</strong> & <strong>Tech</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> delivered!<br />

For details on the latest subscription<br />

off see page 80.<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 5


INBOX TECHDESK<br />

INBOX<br />

You have mail<br />

ULTIMATE ATARI<br />

Check this lot out Ben… all the old<br />

computers we fondly remember!<br />

These all still work and I have all of<br />

the software as well. The 8bit Atari<br />

days were special to me, I did a lot of<br />

programming and the sound of a set of<br />

daisy chained “happy” drives churning<br />

away was special.<br />

I’ve taken a photo for you which<br />

includes a couple of extra Atari<br />

machines and also two of the Atari<br />

810 ‘happy’ disk drives. Also just for<br />

interest is a photo of a review of my<br />

fractal program coded on the Atari ST<br />

published in Atari ST User issue 53 <strong>July</strong><br />

1990.<br />

Some of the other memorable and<br />

fun times included the anticipation<br />

of hand typing in the program listings<br />

from magazines and the trepidation<br />

of entering ‘run’. Also fun were the<br />

hardware mods like fitting happy<br />

boards, upgrading the Atari 500 ST to<br />

1 meg, and also adapting Commodore<br />

screens to the Atari machines because<br />

as you can see from the photo, the Atari<br />

color screens were tiny. Despite the<br />

memories, I wouldn’t go back because<br />

the gear we have today is fantastic in<br />

comparison.<br />

Ian Connor<br />

Ben Mansill replies: Ian, you’re a total<br />

champ! You’re doing good work there,<br />

preserving those fantastic old machines –<br />

and all in full working order. Sensational,<br />

and thanks so much for sharing.<br />

Does anyone else have a similar home<br />

museum? Send in your pics and stories!<br />

<strong>PC</strong> > TABLET<br />

While I use a 12.9 iPad Pro for most day<br />

to day work, there is still a great deal that<br />

requires a full blown, very fast <strong>PC</strong>.<br />

Apple’s A10 and this year’s A11 are the<br />

most powerful ARM processors available,<br />

yet they are still so far short of an i7 or<br />

Ryzen as to make the death of a <strong>PC</strong><br />

suggestion laughable, with a caveat.<br />

For the vast majority of people I<br />

interact with day to day, and some office<br />

workers, a top of the line tablet and<br />

decent keyboard would be sufficient<br />

(as would a 15 year old <strong>PC</strong>) however for<br />

higher end creatives, full on financial staff<br />

and gamers, get real.<br />

amcmo<br />

WINDOWS WINS<br />

Windows 10 S will become the default<br />

OS, not least of all because it points<br />

toward the ultra mobile world Microsoft<br />

are creating with the creation of 3-in-1<br />

devices capable of interacting with mixed<br />

reality. Win32 and the future do not click<br />

into place.<br />

The Microsoft store is a massive place<br />

with close to a million programmes<br />

available. The app bridges are being<br />

used to capacity. As of last week at build<br />

they have a continual backlog of about<br />

1000 win32 apps waiting to be ported....<br />

and that list is growing. ITunes are even<br />

making an appearance. Let that sink in<br />

for a moment... it’s a very strong indicator<br />

of A) the Microsoft play book and B) the<br />

direction and size of the store.<br />

In another nod to the ultra mobile<br />

direction Microsoft are going, they’re<br />

soon going to offer e-sim mobile<br />

packages in the store. The majority of<br />

mobile companies are on board. Again,<br />

take a moment to reflect on this....every<br />

windows 10 S device sold will have<br />

cellular capability. That’s huge.<br />

Google and Apple have walled gardens<br />

and consumers like them. Note I said<br />

consumers...normal people, regular users,<br />

people who don’t know or care about<br />

win32, x86 or arm architecture. They just<br />

want to visit a store and get what they<br />

need. Why are these firms allowed to<br />

create that safe experience but you grind<br />

Microsoft for doing the same?<br />

Lastly, windows 10S is not a return to<br />

RT, in one sense because the store is far,<br />

far more developed than it was 4 years<br />

ago, but also primarily because windows<br />

10s is actually windows 10pro, with a few<br />

additional locks that can be unlocked<br />

with one click of a mouse. If you pick up<br />

a device running S and want pro, you<br />

have the option to unlock that device.<br />

Microsoft are giving you options.<br />

John Craig<br />

Want to get in touch?<br />

MAIL: Inbox, Level 6, Building A, 207 Pacific<br />

Highway, St Leonards NSW 2065<br />

WEB: pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

EMAIL: inbox@pcand techauthority.com.au<br />

Please limit letters to 200 words,<br />

where possible. Letters may be edited<br />

for style and to a more suitable length.<br />

WANT TO READ MORE?<br />

Go to www.pcandtechauthority.<br />

com.au and join in the conversation.<br />

Also check out the Atomic forums:<br />

http://forums.atomicmpc.com.au<br />

6 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


Adobe RGB<br />

Color


NEWS TECHDESK<br />

TECH NEWS<br />

The latest trends and products in the world of technology<br />

WHO WANTS TO KILL<br />

THOUSANDS OF IOT DEVICES?<br />

Permanent denial-of-service attack hints at price war among Internet of Things hackers<br />

S<br />

ecurity experts are puzzling over<br />

the motivation behind a new threat<br />

that can permanently damage IoT<br />

devices.The devices have been a target<br />

before because they are often poorly<br />

secured with old versions of Linux and<br />

default passwords. Botnets built using<br />

IoT devices infected by the Mirai malware<br />

were blamed for attacks that brought<br />

down several websites last year.<br />

Researchers have been monitoring<br />

the progress of a new form of attacks<br />

– permanent denial-of-service (PDoS) –<br />

that are targeting IoT devices with the aim<br />

of damaging them beyond repair.<br />

They’re a step beyond DDoS attacks.<br />

“If you DDoS a service it recovers straight<br />

away after the attack, but with PDoS it’s<br />

more permanent – stop the attack and it’s<br />

still broken,” explained Pascal Geenens, a<br />

security researcher at anti-DDoS company<br />

Radware. “People need to come in and<br />

intervene and make repairs, so rather than<br />

being able to build a botnet the device is<br />

effectively knocked offline.”<br />

Considering the effort that goes into<br />

developing an attack, the question is what<br />

motivates the attackers, who were<br />

discovered using honeytrap machines<br />

looking for DDoS malware. “There are<br />

several theories behind it,” said Geenens.<br />

“One is that it could be a vigilante who’s<br />

said ‘okay, I’ve had enough of this danger,<br />

so let’s destroy all these devices that are<br />

still vulnerable and whoever left those<br />

devices in a vulnerable state with out-ofdate<br />

firmware or old passwords should be<br />

accountable for this’.”<br />

Another theory is that it’s a turf war.<br />

With vulnerable machines easy to find<br />

– often outside the normal firewalled<br />

architecture that blocks inbound ports<br />

– hackers don’t need to invest time and<br />

money phishing or getting malware onto<br />

Windows machines to build a botnet.<br />

“Prices have been down for a few months,<br />

since Mirai,” Geenens said. “It can cost as<br />

little as $2 to perform an attack of five<br />

minutes for 100Gbits/sec with a thousand<br />

bots, and that’s because it’s so easy to<br />

compromise IoT and build a bot.<br />

“It could be someone who has been in<br />

business for longer and had a Windows<br />

botnet, and he sees the prices and his<br />

margins erode. He wants to attack them<br />

and close them down.”<br />

PDoS attacks<br />

aim to damage<br />

IoT devices<br />

beyond easy<br />

repair – but<br />

why?<br />

APPLE PROMISES<br />

NEW MAC PRO NEXT YEAR (MAYBE)<br />

I<br />

n an interview with Apple blog Daring<br />

Fireball, executives admitted the<br />

company had made mistakes with<br />

its previous configuration, which meant it<br />

couldn’t refresh the machines to meet the<br />

changing requirements of pro customers.<br />

The slim, quiet design meant it couldn’t<br />

be upgraded to more powerful processors<br />

without causing the cylindrical system to<br />

overheat.<br />

“I think we designed ourselves into<br />

a bit of a thermal corner,” said Apple’s<br />

senior vice president, Craig Federighi. “We<br />

designed a system with the kind of GPUs<br />

that… we thought we needed, and that we<br />

thought we could well serve with a two-<br />

GPU architecture.<br />

“That was the thermal limit we needed,<br />

or the thermal capacity we needed. But<br />

workloads didn’t materialise to fit that as<br />

broadly as we hoped. Being able to put<br />

8 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

larger single GPUs required a different<br />

system architecture and more thermal<br />

capacity… so it became fairly difficult to<br />

adjust.”<br />

The unusually early<br />

announcement suggested<br />

the company wanted to<br />

dispel the growing fear that<br />

Apple had abandoned pro<br />

users.<br />

The company said it had<br />

gone back to the drawing<br />

board for a new Mac Pro,<br />

but didn’t specify an exact<br />

launch date, save to say<br />

that it wouldn’t be ready<br />

this year. “We want to<br />

architect it so that we can<br />

keep it fresh with regular<br />

improvements, and we’re<br />

committed to making it our<br />

highest-end, high-throughput desktop<br />

system,” Apple’s marketing chief Phil<br />

Schiller claimed.<br />

In the interim, Apple said it<br />

would improve performance<br />

of its lower-end $4,899 Mac<br />

Pro to match its current<br />

top-spec machine, while<br />

the $6,499 model would get<br />

faster processors.<br />

The $4,899 model will<br />

move from four Xeon CPU<br />

cores to six, and from dual<br />

AMD G300 GPUs to dual<br />

G500 GPUs. The $6,499<br />

model goes from six CPU<br />

cores to eight, and from dual<br />

D500 GPUs to dual D700<br />

GPUs.<br />

The Mac Pro’s slim, cylindrical design<br />

backed Apple into “a thermal corner”


L a u n c h i n g<br />

new possibilities<br />

NVMe SSD 960 PRO/ EVO<br />

Experience the power of performance unleashed with NVMe <strong>PC</strong>Ie Gen 3.0 X 4, packaged in an<br />

M.2 form factor offering exceptional storage capacity. The Samsung SSD 960 PRO and 960 EVO<br />

deliver performance beyond previous generations of Samsung SSDs, enabling you to do more.<br />

The SSD 960 PRO has sequential read and write speeds up to 3,500 MB/s and 2,100 MB/s,<br />

and up to 2TB capacity.*<br />

www.samsung.com/au<br />

* Maximum performance values for the 960 PRO. Results may vary based on the user environment.


NEWS TECHDESK<br />

The ups and downs<br />

of new media<br />

Our media consumption habits are unpredictable. Only a couple of years ago, podcasts<br />

were fast becoming a dwindling niche and paper book sales were in terminal decline.<br />

Now ebooks have swung into decline, while podcasts and audiobooks are more<br />

popular than ever – largely thanks to the ubiquity of the smartphone. We track the<br />

fluctuating fortunes of different types of media over the past few years.<br />

Source: Official Charts Company<br />

MUSIC<br />

Format growth<br />

and decline<br />

2013<br />

Streaming 6.2%<br />

Digital albums 27.2%<br />

Track-equivalent albums¹ 15.2%<br />

Physical albums 51.3%<br />

2014<br />

Streaming 12.6%<br />

Digital albums 25.3%<br />

Track-equivalent albums¹ 13.3%<br />

Physical albums 48.8%<br />

2015<br />

Streaming 22.1%<br />

Digital albums 21.1%<br />

Track-equivalent albums¹ 10.9%<br />

Physical albums 45.9%<br />

2016<br />

Streaming 36.4%<br />

Digital albums 14.6%<br />

Track-equivalent albums¹ 7.9%<br />

1. “Track-equivalent albums” are an industry measure equating to ten separate<br />

song downloads, which is regarded as the equivalent of one album.<br />

US music revenues<br />

from streaming by %<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

25<br />

20<br />

15<br />

10<br />

5<br />

0<br />

PODCASTS:<br />

Listener growth<br />

Percentage of people who<br />

listen to podcasts at least<br />

once a month<br />

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016<br />

Listening devices –<br />

computer vs smartphone<br />

2013 2014<br />

2015 2016<br />

Source: Edison Research<br />

Computer 58%<br />

Smartphone 42%<br />

Computer 43%<br />

Smartphone 57%<br />

Computer 36%<br />

Smartphone 64%<br />

Computer 29%<br />

Smartphone 71%<br />

Source: Edison Research<br />

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016<br />

Source: RIAA<br />

10 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


NEWS TECHDESK<br />

GAMING NEWS<br />

Just for the fun of it<br />

GAME TRENDS<br />

Daniel Wilks dons his RGB hat and examines the good, bad and ugly in gaming trends<br />

COLOURED LIGHTS<br />

How do you know that something is<br />

made for gaming? If you think you<br />

should be looking at the performance<br />

of a component, most manufacturers<br />

appear to think you’re wrong. What you<br />

should be looking for are RGBs. Over<br />

the last few years programmable RGB<br />

lighting has managed to spread from<br />

the keyboards and other peripherals<br />

that featured programmable lighting<br />

and infect nearly every other component<br />

imaginable. You can now get RGBs<br />

on your mobo, graphics card, RAM,<br />

case fans, power supply, mouse pad,<br />

speakers, headphones, microphone,<br />

mouse, controller and almost anything<br />

else you can think of. Don’t be surprised<br />

to see RGB CPU coolers (too late – AMD<br />

just released an RGB CPU cooler. Ed),<br />

USB drives, monitors and even cables<br />

(there are already RGB cables, I think<br />

you’re subconsciously blocking out these<br />

new realities Daniel. Ed) by the end of<br />

the year.<br />

THE YEAR OF VR… AGAIN<br />

2016 was meant to be the year of<br />

VR, and in terms of<br />

12 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

VR becoming available it was. In terms<br />

of VR having any appreciable impact<br />

on the market, no so much. Out of the<br />

six major VR brands released in 2016;<br />

Google Daydream, HTC Vive, Oculus Rift,<br />

PSVR, Samsung Gear VR and Google<br />

Cardboard, only two have managed<br />

to sell over one million units globally.<br />

Google Cardboard leads the pack with<br />

around 90 million units shipped, with<br />

Samsung Gear VR lagging well behind<br />

with around two million sold. PSVR is<br />

close to cracking one million and the<br />

remaining three will reach that mark if<br />

they combine forces. Given the number<br />

of developers who have dedicated<br />

considerable resources to developing<br />

games for VR platforms, be prepared<br />

for some serious marketing and hype as<br />

they attempt to make VR appear much<br />

bigger than it is.<br />

ESPORTS<br />

Parents should be prepared to finally put<br />

to rest the argument that their kids will<br />

never make anything of themselves if<br />

they just sit around playing games, given<br />

the rapid rise of esports as a global<br />

phenomenon. In 2016 the total<br />

prize money awarded to players<br />

totalled $93,505,160.63 USD,<br />

and the total revenue for<br />

esports rose from $194 million<br />

to $463 million between<br />

2014 and 2016, with revenue<br />

expected to top more than<br />

one billion dollars by the end<br />

of 2018. Rather than telling<br />

kids to turn off the TV and do<br />

their homework, it might be<br />

better for their future to tell<br />

them to quit school and get<br />

really good at League of<br />

Legends.<br />

PAY TO KEEP<br />

PLAYING<br />

Why pay once when<br />

you can pay to keep<br />

playing? While more<br />

and more Massively<br />

Multiplayer games are moving away<br />

from a subscription based revenue<br />

stream, more and more single-player<br />

and multi-player game developers and<br />

publishers seem to be looking for ways<br />

to keep players paying for games they<br />

already own. 2016 was a big year for<br />

season passes – a lump sum payment<br />

guaranteeing you a bunch of DLC<br />

available after launch (aside from the<br />

last and best one that is really the only<br />

one you probably wanted in the first<br />

place, forcing you to pay for DLC on<br />

top of the season pass). Expect to see<br />

more of this in the coming year, with<br />

season passes for anything that could<br />

possibly have a season pass, more<br />

paid DLC that you can poke a stick at,<br />

microtransactions required to unlock<br />

content already in the game.<br />

GOODBYE RETAIL<br />

Have you ever opened a game box,<br />

inserted the disk into your drive and<br />

discovered that it contains nothing but<br />

a Steam code, forcing you to download<br />

the game? Get used to it. More and<br />

more developers are ignoring retail for<br />

digital distribution, whilst still paying<br />

lip-service to shops with boxed codes.<br />

GIRL GERMS<br />

Although growth is not as rampant<br />

as it was when GamerGate was still<br />

a thing that people pretended to care<br />

about ethics in games journalism for,<br />

online harassment is still going strong<br />

in <strong>2017</strong> and looks to maintain its steady<br />

foothold in the gaming arena. Around<br />

half of all women face sexualised<br />

harassment online, with that number<br />

going up to 76% for women under 30<br />

according to a 2016 Australian study,<br />

with that percentage growing markedly<br />

when you concentrate solely on the<br />

online gaming statistics. Sorry to end<br />

on a bummer, but this isn’t going to<br />

change any time soon, or at least until<br />

authorities and service providers start<br />

taking a much firmer stance against any<br />

harassment.


NEWS TECHDESK<br />

CHIP NEWS<br />

AMD’s marketing department goes into overdrive announcing an Epyc number<br />

of new products, meanwhile deep learning and AI are the flavour of the month<br />

for GPU makers. Mark Williams covers a busy month in chip news<br />

CPU<br />

AMD FINALLY BACK IN THE<br />

SERVER GAME<br />

AMD’s new server grade CPUs previously<br />

known by its codename, Naples, has<br />

been unveiled at its financial analyst day<br />

as ‘Epyc’. Oh yes “I just bought an Epyc<br />

server!” will be causing meme levels<br />

of Picard facepalms everywhere. I like<br />

it. And what’s not to like? A 32-core,<br />

64-thread monstrosity sitting in a single<br />

socket truly is “Epyc”.<br />

It’s not a single chip monolithic design<br />

though, a de-lidded Epyc CPU was shown<br />

and it’s actually four octo-core CPUs<br />

combined together on the one MCM<br />

package.<br />

The magic tying them together is<br />

AMD’s infinity fabric which we’ve seen<br />

before in the Ryzen desktop parts. AMD<br />

is exploiting this Infinity Fabric for not<br />

only module to module communications<br />

on the same package but also socket<br />

to socket in two and four socket server<br />

configurations as well.<br />

AMD demonstrated a dual socketed<br />

GPU<br />

NEW ULTRA-LOW END PART<br />

Nvidia has released its entry level<br />

graphics card in the form of the GT 1030.<br />

With just a 30W TDP, this featherweight<br />

draws even less than the 50W of AMD’s<br />

competing RX 550, however it appears<br />

this is achieved by halving the memory<br />

bus to 64-bit and only supporting 2GB of<br />

6GHz memory compared to 2GB or 4GB<br />

of 7GHz on the RX 550.<br />

The GT 1030 has a GP108 core with 384<br />

shaders running at 1468MHz, just 10% of<br />

what you can find inside the GTX 1080 Ti<br />

or Titan Xp. Nvidia are spruiking this card<br />

as a replacement for Intel’s integrated<br />

graphics and not directly against AMD’s<br />

part so it could wind up being slower.<br />

The card will come in a plethora of<br />

shapes and sizes, notably half-height,<br />

half-length and passively cooled variants.<br />

NEW ULTRA-HIGH END PARTS<br />

Nvidia has given a sneak peak of its<br />

next generation GPU microarchitecture<br />

dubbed Volta. Showing off a product<br />

14 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

Epyc server compiling a Linux distro<br />

against Intel’s fastest dual socket server<br />

currently on offer. The Epyc system did<br />

the compile in just under sixteen seconds,<br />

compared to Intel’s twenty-two seconds.<br />

Speedy!<br />

AMD RIPS INTO HEDT<br />

At the same analyst event AMD didn’t<br />

reveal much more about its upcoming<br />

HEDT parts we’ve known to be in the<br />

works. They did confirm that a 16-core<br />

32-thread SKU will be coming and they<br />

announced the name of these upcoming<br />

product range: Ryzen 9 Threadripper.<br />

I must hand it to AMD’s marketing<br />

for data crunching, AI and other H<strong>PC</strong><br />

work, Nvidia revealed the Tesla V100, its<br />

successor to the Pascal based P100.<br />

Having a gigantic 815mm2 die size<br />

on a 12nm process node this chip is<br />

at the absolute limits of current chip<br />

fabrication capabilities. They literally<br />

don’t get any bigger than this. With all<br />

that die space, Nvidia has crammed in<br />

5120 CUDA cores, some 33% more than<br />

the previous generation.<br />

With core clock speeds of 1455MHz<br />

and 16GB of HBM2 sitting on a<br />

4096-bit bus giving a jaw dropping<br />

900GB/s of bandwidth the V100 can<br />

pump out 15 TFLOPs of FP32 compute<br />

performance, easily beating the 10.5<br />

and 11.3 TFLOPs of current P100<br />

and Titan Xp products respectively.<br />

Consumer Volta parts aren’t expected<br />

until next year.<br />

Not to be outdone, after pointing<br />

out that it didn’t have any products in<br />

this space and just wanted to show the<br />

flag, AMD revealed its first entry into<br />

department; these names are<br />

fantastically well suited to the products.<br />

Given that Epyc chips are a 4-chip MCM<br />

package, it stands to reason Threadripper<br />

will be a 2-chip MCM package mini Epyc<br />

style product, perhaps with lower end<br />

SKU’s using just one chip for an octo-core<br />

variant. Threadripper will slot into a new<br />

X399 platform and support quad channel<br />

memory and will go head to head with<br />

Intel’s upcoming X299 HEDT platform an<br />

i9 range of CPU’s.<br />

APUS AND RYZEN 3<br />

The final tidbits from AMD’s event was<br />

that Ryzen 3 and APU parts will ship<br />

Q3 this year with the APUs to have new<br />

Vega level IGPs. Asus tripped up later<br />

and accidentally released Ryzen 3 and<br />

APU specs on one of its motherboard<br />

compatibility spec sheets. This confirmed<br />

the Ryzen 3 1200’s existence as a quad<br />

core 3.1GHz 65W part. The APUs listed<br />

showed dual and quad core parts ranging<br />

from 35W to 65W and 3.0-3.8GHz clocks.<br />

the H<strong>PC</strong> market, dubbed Vega Frontier<br />

Edition (VFE). As you can tell by the<br />

name it’s powered by AMD’s new Vega<br />

GPU architecture. Compared to its last<br />

high end product, the HBM1 powered<br />

Fury X, the VFE has 4x the HBM(2)<br />

memory at 16GB and a bandwidth rating<br />

of 480GB/s, 3x the FP16 compute at<br />

25 TFLOPS and 1.5x the FP32 compute<br />

at 13 TFLOPS using a core clocked at<br />

1600MHz.<br />

As you can see by the memory<br />

bandwidth and FP32 numbers it’s less<br />

performant than Nvidia’s upcoming<br />

V100, but to its credit showed a<br />

benchmark where it beat Nvidia’s current<br />

P100 in DeepBench by a solid 33%, so<br />

it’s no slouch. It is power hungry though,<br />

with a 300W TDP there’ll be a watercooled<br />

edition to keep the temperatures<br />

in check. One can only wonder how much<br />

power Nvidia’s massive V100 chip draws.<br />

Consumer Vega cards should be<br />

announced at Computex with availability<br />

a week or so later.


Order online at<br />

www.viavision.com.au<br />

*While stocks Last


MOST WANTED<br />

Anthony Fordham gets his gear on<br />

Mixxim Mixxtape<br />

This plucky little audio player company – not to be confused with Mixxim,<br />

one of the UK’s leading ready-to-pour concrete manufacturers – lives in<br />

a beautiful dream world where the 80s never ended, and the millions<br />

of playlists that angsty teens swap with each other via Social Media<br />

don’t count. Or exist. The only true mixtape is an actual tape, mixed!<br />

So it’s ironic that Mixxim’s Mixtape isn’t an actual tape, but this irony is<br />

softened somewhat by the way it can work in a tape deck...<br />

WANTED: This is a compact digital audio player with a microSD card slot<br />

(64GB max), a 330mAh battery for 12 hours of tunes, a little LCD display<br />

and basic touch controls. It supports most standard-resolution audio<br />

formats, has Bluetooth 3.0 + EDR, a headphone jack and a USB port. So far<br />

so typical, but the clever bit is a magnetic... thingy... that sends a tape-like<br />

signal to a standard tape deck when you shove it right in there. You... you<br />

have a tape deck, right?<br />

NOT WANTED: So rather than tediously listening to Spotify via your<br />

phone, you can download tracks onto a microSD card, put the card in the<br />

Mixxtape, put the Mixxtape in the tape deck and hear the music played<br />

back in all its muted, hissy glory! “Romance would be a lot cooler if kids<br />

still made mixtapes for the girls they liked” says Mixxim’s Kickstarter<br />

campaign, displaying perfect tone-deafness to the sexual politics of <strong>2017</strong><br />

and also the way streaming music services have actual AIs to make new<br />

mixtapes for you every time you log on...<br />

Dyson Pure<br />

Hot + Cold Link<br />

You can buy a $25 floor fan from Aldi<br />

and a room heater, too, for another<br />

$50, but does the combined versatility<br />

of that $75 investment match Dyson’s<br />

$800 solution? Which of these things<br />

has an app, and looks like it comes from<br />

the future? Not the Aldi’s, we can tell<br />

you that. The ‘Pure’ in the product<br />

name denotes the filter inside, which<br />

needs changing or cleaning every<br />

couple of weeks. Bad air in, good air<br />

out, and all about. A regular Dyson Hot<br />

+ Cool fan is $500, so including a $300<br />

air filter as part of the deal doesn’t feel<br />

exorbitant, at least in Dyson terms.<br />

WANTED: The Hot it creates is good,<br />

but it’s more on the generously-warm<br />

side of the scale than a burning heat.<br />

A thermostat kicks it into being when<br />

needed and it can punish you with a<br />

tight jet, or fill the room with a wide<br />

dispersion.<br />

NOT WANTED: The Cool is not<br />

spectacular and you’ll need to crouch<br />

in front of it wearing a wet shirt to<br />

really feel the temps drop. But it’s just<br />

a regular fan, despite looking like a<br />

mini-air-con unit, so performance was<br />

within expectations.<br />

16 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


TECHDESK MOST WANTED<br />

Brydge 12.3 Keyboard<br />

There are times when we love the type cover on the Microsoft<br />

Surface Pro 4... but there are also times when we don’t. Flexibility<br />

is all! So adding a rigid, heavier aluminium half-shell keyboard<br />

gives the Surface the opportunity to act like a normal laptop<br />

when it needs to be. The Brydge has backlit keys, an “adaptive<br />

trackpad” and still lets the Surface bend over through 180 degees<br />

like any other hybrid.<br />

WANTED: There are times when the kickstand doesn’t cut<br />

it, and more options on this expensive computer are always<br />

welcome. The keys have good travel, and there’s also a version<br />

with a built-in 128GB “high speed SSD drive”. Handy!<br />

NOT WANTED: Some might say if you’re going to turn your<br />

Surface Pro into a regular laptop... why not just get a regular<br />

laptop? Or a Surface Book? It also adds considerable bulk. This<br />

makes the whole kit one of the thickest “laptops” on the market.<br />

Sonicam VR Camera<br />

What if you could make professional-quality immersive<br />

360-degree video with perfectly synced 3D-positional<br />

audio, all with one tiny device... and one that looks like<br />

some kind of evil Star Wars spy robot or Death Star<br />

spore, too? Sonicam makes this ancient dream of all<br />

free citizens a reality! Seriously though, Sonicam won’t<br />

be the last compact camera marketed to budding “VR”<br />

filmmakers, but it’s among the first to be so much more<br />

than a $249 gimmick.<br />

WANTED: There are nine F2.2 glass fish-eye lens<br />

cameras (8 around the middle, one on top) each with<br />

its own Sony Exmor R CMOS. It shoots 4K video at<br />

50Mb/s bitrate, and most importantly has 3D positional<br />

audio thanks to 64 MEMS microphones. There’s also<br />

“in-camera stitching” for a live preview.<br />

NOT WANTED: Max framerate for 4K is only 30fps,<br />

and despite being a US$3,999 pro-grade camera,<br />

Sonicam only takes SD cards for internal storage<br />

($4,000 should buy you more options). Kickstarter<br />

backers got the cam from $2,000... so chances of it not<br />

meeting its October <strong>2017</strong> release date are statistically<br />

significant.<br />

Betterspot VPN Router<br />

Spend too much time trawling Indiegogo or Kickstart for cool new gadgets,<br />

and you’ll come to the realisation that tech trends absolutely reflect<br />

the issues of the day. Point: concerns about metadata retention and<br />

government surveillance have led to a proliferation of “secure connection”<br />

routers. Here’s one! Betterspot makes the business of VPNs and<br />

anonymity easy. Plug it in, set it up, and you’re considerably less trackable<br />

online.<br />

WANTED: VPNs are only getting more popular, but using them with just<br />

a <strong>PC</strong> can be tedious – remembering to log in etc. This makes the process<br />

automatic, and largely invisible. You can choose to use a VPN service, or<br />

even run in Tor mode. Shady!<br />

NOT WANTED: Don’t think a product like this can hide you from the<br />

feds, it’s not THAT secure. Also, in this bandwidth-benighted country,<br />

routing everything through a VPN may slow your internet connection,<br />

and VPN services have an ongoing subscription fee.<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 17


System news<br />

MARK WILLIAMS FINDS THAT INTEL HAS A HIT ON ITS HANDS<br />

IN THE FORM OF THE 600P SERIES. WILL OTHERS FOLLOW?<br />

When I went to build a new <strong>PC</strong><br />

recently I knew I wanted an NVME<br />

SSD as the primary storage device.<br />

With the way the market is currently I knew<br />

a drive with a capacity of around 256GB<br />

would be in the sweet spot for capacity<br />

versus price. Searching around, Intel’s<br />

600P 256GB model quickly came to my<br />

attention as the cheapest M.2 NVME SSD<br />

on offer. However, there was a problem,<br />

it was out of stock almost everywhere I<br />

looked!<br />

I ended up settling for a slightly more<br />

expensive and capable Samsung 960 EVO<br />

but this got me wondering, where are all<br />

the 256GB 600P’s?<br />

It seems that I’m not the only one who<br />

finds the 256GB 600P an attractive<br />

offering. As Jaimie and John both confirm<br />

in Shop Talk at the side of this page, Intel’s<br />

600P series is selling “like hotcakes” and<br />

with 256GB at the sweet spot and being<br />

the cheapest product on offer it would<br />

appear demand was outstripping supply.<br />

Intel’s design choice with this product<br />

was clearly a good strategy. Unlike the<br />

superior performing Samsung 960 EVO<br />

and other NVME<br />

products around<br />

at the moment<br />

which utilise MLC<br />

NAND flash for the<br />

entire drive which<br />

gives moderate<br />

chip level storage<br />

density and speeds,<br />

Intel’s 600P range<br />

uses TLC NAND<br />

with some of it<br />

partitioned off and<br />

used in SLC mode.<br />

The idea being that<br />

because TLC has<br />

the highest data<br />

storage density,<br />

fewer chip are<br />

needed or are<br />

simply smaller to<br />

produce at the<br />

same capacity,<br />

thus cheaper.<br />

The problem of<br />

course is that TLC<br />

is also slower to write to. So, by setting<br />

aside some TLC as faster but less dense<br />

SLC (4GB for 128GB, 8.5GB for 256GB,<br />

17.5GB for 512GB and 32GB for 1TB drives)<br />

to act as the drives write cache Intel can<br />

mask the real speed of the underlying<br />

TLC, so long as the cache doesn’t get full,<br />

whereupon you’ll be writing directly to TLC<br />

which is slower than most SATA MLC SSDs.<br />

Not something you want to advertise on an<br />

NVME M.2 SSD.<br />

But here is the genius of it; consumers<br />

will very rarely fill the cache during typical<br />

desktop usage. Often there’s enough time<br />

between large writes for the SLC cache to<br />

get flushed out to the TLC, so for the most<br />

part you’re always working with the fast<br />

SLC.<br />

This makes the 600P cheaper but<br />

also well suited to consumers and their<br />

typically bursty workloads.<br />

Could this style of NVME drive become<br />

more popular in the future? Intel has paved<br />

the way and proved the case, now it’s a<br />

question of whether Samsung, SanDisk<br />

and the like will follow suit with cheaper<br />

TLC NVME products too.<br />

SHOP TALK<br />

What are your thoughts on<br />

the Intel 600P series SSDs? Are<br />

they a popular product and is<br />

that why some stocks have<br />

been low recently?<br />

Jaimie, Leader Computers:<br />

“At Leader we have seen<br />

fantastic take up on the Intel<br />

NVME based 600P series, their<br />

price point put NVME within<br />

reach of the average punter<br />

for the first time, especially in<br />

the 128 and 256GB sizes. At<br />

the time they were released,<br />

all of the other brands were<br />

significantly more expensive<br />

and they have had to adjust<br />

their pricing substantially to<br />

compete. Along with Intel’s<br />

new Optane technology,<br />

the 600P is one of the best<br />

performance upgrades you can<br />

make for the money.<br />

There have been shortages<br />

on the 256GB, this is mainly<br />

due to their excellent value<br />

proposition, I don’t think Intel<br />

forecasted as well as they<br />

could have and there have<br />

been some NAND shortages<br />

in general which may also<br />

have contributed. The 250GB<br />

size was hard to source in<br />

several brands, both NVME<br />

and standard SATA SSD, so<br />

the Intel at only a small price<br />

premium sold extremely well.<br />

We sell as many 600P drives<br />

as we can get our hands on,<br />

definitely our top performer!”<br />

John, TI Computers:<br />

“Yes, the Intel 600P 256GB<br />

model is indeed very popular<br />

and were sold like hotcakes.<br />

It is hard not to use it in the<br />

system considering the<br />

significant performance gain at<br />

such tiny additional investment<br />

over SATA SSDs. We are<br />

however unsure whether this<br />

is the real reason behind the<br />

shortage. It can also just be a<br />

short supply before the end of<br />

financial year.”


SYSTEM NEWS<br />

Market snapshot<br />

A SAMPLING OF <strong>PC</strong> SYSTEMS AVAILABLE THIS MONTH<br />

BALANCED FORCE<br />

Scorptech Computers Venom<br />

1070 Quiet Gaming <strong>PC</strong><br />

$2,349 – http://tinyurl.com/lacenkr<br />

This is a great system. A top end speedy quad core CPU ideal<br />

for current games is paired with a capable GTX 1070 for solid<br />

high graphics quality 1440p gaming. Matched with a sizeable<br />

512GB NVME SSD and a comfortable amount of<br />

DDR4 memory is doesn’t get much better<br />

without breaking the bank. Really the<br />

only thing an owner would want<br />

to upgrade in a year or two is<br />

the graphics card, the rest of<br />

this system will easily handle<br />

the next three or more years of<br />

gaming with ease. Dropping in a<br />

hard drive for some extra mass<br />

storage down the track might<br />

also be worthwhile considering.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

CPU: Intel Core i7 7700K Cooler: Noctua NH-D14 Motherboard: Gigabyte GA-Z270X-<br />

Gaming K3 Graphics: Gigabyte GeForce GTX 1070 G1 Gaming, 8GB Memory: Corsair<br />

Vengeance LPX 16GB 2400MHz DDR4 Storage: Intel 600P Series 512GB SSD Power<br />

Supply: Corsair CX550M Bronze 550W Case: Fractal Design Define R5 Black<br />

LIGHT EM UP<br />

Mwave<br />

Aorus P3 Gaming <strong>PC</strong><br />

$2,060 – http://tinyurl.com/k4zy875<br />

This is pure eye candy. Utterly beautiful<br />

to look at with it’s see through acrylic<br />

housing and striking white back pane<br />

that everything attaches to and<br />

seemingly hangs suspended from with<br />

RGB lighting everywhere. It looks like<br />

an art installation. But like candy it’s<br />

also bad for you. For the price i5 7600K<br />

or even i7 7700 CPU systems can be<br />

had along with much faster GTX 1070 graphics cards. Oddly the<br />

PSU is rather over powered for this system’s requirements and<br />

unnecessarily adds to this overpriced system’s cost, likely done<br />

just to get extra RGB lighting in. Not that your friends and family<br />

will notice as they’ll be dazzled by all the RGB lighting.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

CPU: Intel Core i5 7500 Cooler: Thermaltake Water 3.0 Riing RGB 360 Motherboard:<br />

Gigabyte AORUS Z270X Gaming 5 Graphics: Gigabyte GeForce GTX 1060 Gaming G1 6GB<br />

Memory: G.Skill Trident Z RGB 16GB DDR4 2400Mhz Storage: WD Green 240GB M.2 SSD<br />

Power Supply: Thermaltake Toughpower Grand 750W RGB Case: Thermaltake Core P3<br />

Snow Edition<br />

NOT QUITE THE KING OF GODS<br />

GMR Zeus Advanced<br />

Gaming System V4<br />

$2,399 –http://tinyurl.com/kmnhyln<br />

This is a good example of a system that’s one step below the<br />

high end. The non-K 7700 CPU is 300MHz slower at peak than<br />

the 7700K and isn’t overclockable. The H<br />

series motherboard is a step below the top<br />

end Z series which also doesn’t allow<br />

overclocking. The GTX 1070 GPU is<br />

a step down from the top end GTX<br />

1080 series. With storage capacities<br />

of the RAM, SSD and HDD all in the<br />

sweet spot this is an ideal system for<br />

a serious gamer without blowing the<br />

budget.<br />

The problem is that this should<br />

be cheaper than the asking price. In<br />

this price bracket, there are better<br />

options around.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

CPU: Intel Core i7 7700 Cooler: OEM Motherboard: Intel H270 chipset based Graphics:<br />

Nvidia Geforce GTX1070 8GB Memory: 16GB DDR4 2400MHz Storage: 240GB SSD, 2TB<br />

HDD Power Supply: CoolerMaster B700v2 700W Case: In Win 303 Black + Tempered<br />

Glass<br />

THE BEAST HAS RYZEN<br />

<strong>PC</strong> Case Gear<br />

Ryzen 570 Gaming System<br />

$1349 – http://tinyurl.com/mwkdqsz<br />

A quad core CPU in this price bracket isn’t new,<br />

but one that also supports simultaneous<br />

multi-threading (or as Intel calls it,<br />

Hyperthreading) is quite refreshing<br />

and puts to shame Intel’s current<br />

budget quad core product line-up.<br />

So there’s a lot of multi-threaded<br />

power here. The RX 570 will satisfy<br />

most 1080p gaming requirements<br />

too.<br />

The only pinch point with this build is<br />

the SSD which is just enough for the OS,<br />

programs and perhaps one triple-A gaming<br />

title. Owners may find they’ll be using the HDD<br />

for installing games more than they might like.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

CPU: AMD Ryzen 5 1500X Cooler: OEM Wraith Spire Motherboard: ASUS Prime B350M-A<br />

Graphics: ASUS ROG Radeon RX 570 Strix Gaming 4GB Memory: Kingston HyperX Fury<br />

8GB DDR4 Storage: Kingston SSDNow UV400 120GB SSD, Seagate Barracuda 1TB Power<br />

Supply: Be Quiet! Pure Power 9 500W Case: Nanoxia Deep Silence 4 Claw


INVESTIGATOR TECHDESK<br />

Can you<br />

tell which<br />

one is an<br />

iPhone 4<br />

and which<br />

one is an<br />

iPhone 4s?<br />

CHECK BEFORE<br />

YOU LEAVE<br />

When you don’t get exactly what you paid for<br />

I<br />

t’s not uncommon – although it<br />

should never happen – that you buy<br />

an item from a retailer only to find,<br />

when you get home, that the wrong item<br />

was packed for you.<br />

This happened recently with a<br />

colleague who purchased a laptop from<br />

a large retail chain. He got home to find<br />

the model he was handed at the counter<br />

only had 4GB of memory and not the<br />

8GB he paid for.<br />

It was a straightforward exercise to<br />

correct the issue. All he had to do is<br />

return to the store with his receipt and it<br />

was all sorted out. Of course, this gets a<br />

little more complex with online retailers<br />

or when you make a special, long trip to<br />

buy something.<br />

But consumer protection laws are<br />

clear about getting what you paid for.<br />

So, spare a thought for Paul from<br />

Bendigo. Back in 2012, he purchased an<br />

iPhone 4s (or so he thought) from Dick<br />

Smith. He was after an unlocked model<br />

and found what he was looking for.<br />

Now, Bendigo is not just around the<br />

corner from suburban Melbourne so he<br />

Anthony Caruana<br />

has worked for almost every major<br />

masthead in the Australian IT press. As<br />

an experienced IT professional – having<br />

worked as the lead IT executive in<br />

several businesses, he brings a unique<br />

insight to his reporting of IT for both<br />

businesses and consumers.<br />

trekked into the city to make his purchase.<br />

Just recently he had cause to check<br />

some of the details on the phone - an<br />

unlocked 8GB iPhone 4s he bought for<br />

$520.00. On checking the model number<br />

on the back of the iPhone he discovered<br />

he’d been sold and iPhone 4 not a 4s.<br />

We’re in some pretty murky consumer<br />

protection waters here. This is a<br />

transaction that took place five years<br />

“It was a<br />

straightforward exercise<br />

to correct the issue”<br />

ago from a retailer who has failed with<br />

the brand name being the only survivor,<br />

purchased by a former competitor.<br />

To all intents and purposes, Paul doesn’t<br />

really have anyone to go to.<br />

One of the problems, says Paul, is the<br />

iPhone 4S came in an identical chassis<br />

to the iPhone 4. Sit them side by side<br />

and you’d be hard-pressed to tell the<br />

difference. And the model numbers on<br />

the back are extremely small. I know that<br />

when I’ve had to confirm a specific number<br />

that end up taking a photo and zooming in<br />

to be sure.<br />

According to the ACCC: “The retailer<br />

who sold you the product or service<br />

cannot refuse to help you by sending you<br />

to the manufacturer or importer. You can<br />

approach the manufacturer or importer<br />

directly, however, you will only be entitled<br />

to recover costs from them, which include<br />

an amount for reduction in the product’s<br />

value and in some cases compensation<br />

for damages or loss. You cannot demand<br />

a repair, replacement or refund from the<br />

manufacturer.”<br />

Paul’s problem is the retailer no longer<br />

exists. He could take the item to Apple and<br />

plead his case but given the time since the<br />

purchase it’s not clear whether Apple is<br />

obligated to do anything as they were not<br />

at fault or even part of the transaction.<br />

There is a lesson to learn from Paul’s<br />

experience. When you buy something, it is<br />

important to check the box carefully. Paul<br />

made some strong comments about what<br />

he thought Dick Smith’s motives might<br />

have been in selling him an older model<br />

that looked identical to a newer item.<br />

As there’s no evidence to support that<br />

supposition, I’ve not repeated them.<br />

My feeling is this was a genuine<br />

mistake made at the point of sale. If it<br />

was a decided course of action then I<br />

suspect we’d have heard of this being a<br />

widespread issue.<br />

The fact remains that there is a serial<br />

number printed on the device and the<br />

packaging also has a product serial<br />

number and the model and specification<br />

on it.<br />

Before you leave a store, make sure<br />

that what you ordered is what has been<br />

handed over the counter.<br />

NEED HELP? EVER HAD AN<br />

ISSUE AS A CONSUMER?<br />

INVESTIGATOR CAN HELP.<br />

If you’ve had an issue or had something<br />

happen and you think investigator<br />

could help, email your problem to<br />

investigator@pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

20 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


ACS TECHDESK<br />

BIGGER<br />

THAN BIG<br />

It’s exceedingly hard to envisage<br />

a data-driven future, but we are<br />

hurtling towards one none-the-less<br />

A<br />

popular stat repeated in<br />

recent times to help try and<br />

understand this comes from<br />

Monash University, stating that 90%<br />

of the world’s data was created in the<br />

last two years alone. And that was<br />

calculated in 2015 – imagine where we<br />

are today?<br />

Ever keen to try and help blow your<br />

mind, Monash also put it another way:<br />

that by next year, 2018, we will have<br />

stored more bytes of data than there<br />

are stars in the universe.<br />

And there’s a key word there – store. I<br />

highlight this not in the sense of merely<br />

having a place to put it – we don’t as<br />

a civilisation seem to have an issue<br />

with creating ever-denser storage<br />

mediums – but instead in terms of<br />

what we do with it. Just how do you<br />

manage and manipulate ever growing<br />

datasets on scales that are truly hard<br />

to comprehend?<br />

IBM is in on the game too, throwing<br />

out a stat that suggests that we<br />

already produce 2.5 quintillion bytes of<br />

data every day.<br />

Consider that today we already live<br />

lives that create a constant data trail<br />

– everything we do from browsing a<br />

website, to walking down the street<br />

with a GPS-enabled smartphone, to<br />

making purchases with credit cards<br />

– all of it is tracked. All of it leaves a<br />

trail. All of it builds a profile about you<br />

which companies around the world<br />

are scrambling to interpret into useful<br />

insights that can be utilised to raise<br />

profit margins, or deliver entirely new<br />

products.<br />

At the time of writing, Google<br />

announced a wonderful a new feature<br />

where it will track your shopping trips<br />

to allow advertisers to compare your<br />

credit card purchases matched against<br />

advertising, to see just how malleable<br />

Ashton Mills<br />

has been writing about technology for<br />

20 years and still gets excited for the<br />

latest techy gear. He’s also the Outreach<br />

Manager for the Australian Computer<br />

Society (www.acs.org.au), you can email<br />

him on ashton.mills@acs.org.au.<br />

22 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

– er, influenceable – people are to your<br />

advertising.<br />

But all this is dependent on making<br />

sense of all that data, and quite frankly<br />

no matter how beastly you consider that<br />

machine under your desk or the racks<br />

of servers in your server room, building<br />

“It’s not mind boggling.<br />

We’re well beyond<br />

being boggled”<br />

machines capable of processing it in<br />

a reasonable time is actually quite the<br />

challenge.<br />

Hence also at the time of writing HP<br />

had just unveiled The Machine, an aptly<br />

titled new type of computer that is<br />

designed to put memory first.<br />

Specifically built to store and process<br />

exceedingly large volumes of data in a<br />

single bank of memory – 160TB in its<br />

initial configuration, though HP says in<br />

future this will scale to exabytes and<br />

then that holy grail of computing metrics<br />

– yottabytes. Imagine addressing<br />

thousands of yottabytes of memory as<br />

a single bank – well, we can’t. It’s like<br />

trying imagine more bytes of data as<br />

Locutus, is that you?<br />

there are stars in the universe.<br />

But this is where we are heading. HP’s<br />

machine is a prototype, and while it’s<br />

easy to be a pundit on its future – as a<br />

new type of machine it requires a new<br />

operating system and new software,<br />

making it incompatible with everything<br />

existing today – it does point to a future<br />

where we are going to need new forms<br />

of technology to manage and process<br />

the multiples of quintillion of bytes of<br />

data produced and collected every day.<br />

And that’s just now – can you imagine<br />

the volumes of data produced in a<br />

future filled with even more data-driven<br />

products such as autonomous cars,<br />

drones, IoT and an ever-growing world<br />

population?<br />

It’s not mind boggling. We’re well<br />

beyond being boggled. It’s an entirely<br />

different concept of a digitally-driven<br />

humankind, and an entirely different<br />

concept of the value of data, how it is<br />

produced, how it is stored, and how it is<br />

used.<br />

Which, of course, speaks to nothing<br />

about privacy and just how much of the<br />

data trail you create every day is yours<br />

to own.<br />

But that’s a topic for another time.


AUSTRALIA 5.0<br />

WE MAKE <strong>PC</strong> TECH FUN WITH OUR SENSATIONAL FREE<br />

EVENT FEATURING COOL GEAR, FREEBIES AND LOADS OF<br />

FUN, FOOD AND MAYBE A COUPLE OF DRINKS, TOO<br />

Our fifth event was the best yet,<br />

with a record breaking number of<br />

stands all showing off lustworthy<br />

<strong>PC</strong> gear. As always, it was quite<br />

apparent that everyone who came along had<br />

a great time, with almost everyone leaving<br />

with free gifts. The biggest winner of the<br />

night was Alex Chong who took home the <strong>PC</strong><br />

PowerPlay Beast <strong>PC</strong> worth almost $7,000!<br />

Over the course of the night our master<br />

builder Josh Collins assembled the Beast using<br />

the very best components from In Win, AMD,<br />

Cooler Master, Aorus, MSI, G.Skill, Razer and<br />

Microsoft. This went down rather well, as you<br />

can imagine, so we’re looking at doing this at<br />

every Upgrade Event, evolving the Beast as<br />

technology marches along – so be sure to come<br />

to the next one, which will be in Sydney later<br />

this year, and you could win the mighty Beast.<br />

Case mods were a highlight, and their<br />

illustrious illumination and artisan<br />

craftsmanship dazzled the halls.<br />

Congratulations to Ethan, who won Best<br />

Case Mod, scoring the most votes from all<br />

attendees on the night. Ethan took home a<br />

Samsung 960 Evo 1TB SSD along with prizes<br />

from Eset including $1,250 in cash.<br />

It’s always a treat for us to meet and chat<br />

to readers, young and old. Thanks so much to<br />

everyone that came along it was thoroughly<br />

enjoyable to hang out and talk tech and hear<br />

about what you are most interested in.<br />

AMD attracted a lot of interest in the<br />

fabulous new Ryzen CPU, with staff fielding<br />

questions from attendees all night long.<br />

And of course we built a Ryzen-based <strong>PC</strong><br />

PowerPlay Beast <strong>PC</strong> on the night so there was<br />

no shortage of Ryzen excitement at Upgrade<br />

Australia!<br />

Asus showed off a wide range of gear<br />

including its legendary motherboards and<br />

monitors. Asus had its Aura Sync technology<br />

for all see, showing off a spectrum of RGB<br />

disco beyond anything else. MSI, too, dazzled<br />

with a huge array of booty, including a never<br />

PLATINUM<br />

SPONSORS


UPGRADE AUSTRALIA<br />

seen before unveiling of a very cool limited<br />

edition Camo Squad gaming laptop.<br />

Over at Seagate the company<br />

demonstrated its cracking range of high<br />

performance BarraCuda, IronWolf, SkyHawk<br />

and FireCuda drives. Razer had a great stand<br />

with loads of action and excitement, and we<br />

know people were keen to get their finger<br />

tips on the latest Blackwidow Chroma V2<br />

keyboard, plus the Deathadder Elite and<br />

Kraken Pro V2 as well as the OSVR VR HMD.<br />

Aorus had the latest high performance<br />

gear and the legendary Dino was up to his<br />

usual tricks, giving the audience a great<br />

show. We also had Rectron, which is one<br />

of the main distributors to <strong>PC</strong> shops in<br />

Australia and it was fantastic to see people<br />

try out new gear they wouldn’t otherwise be<br />

able to get their hands on. Rectron had the<br />

latest from Antec, Fractal Design, Galax and<br />

IG-Touch panel.<br />

In Win laid out its gorgeous range of cases,<br />

including the magical Infinity case and the<br />

new tou 2.0. A pro-modder for In Win was<br />

on hand to give modding demos, too. Cooler<br />

Master had its first Upgrade Australia stand<br />

and it was a great chance to see and play<br />

with the keyboards that are very high in our<br />

list of favourites, plus entries from the Cooler<br />

Master Case Mod World Series <strong>2017</strong>. PLE, as<br />

usual, brought something special along and<br />

it was a sim racing rig set up with an HTC<br />

Vive VR headset. Many tried VR for the first<br />

time that night and left with a smile. PLE also<br />

talked about its custom <strong>PC</strong> building services.<br />

Samsung owns the high performance<br />

SSD scene, so it was terrific to have<br />

Samsung experts there talking about how<br />

its technology achieves such breathtaking<br />

performance.<br />

Qnap had a top spread of NAS products for<br />

home and business, these guys are at the top<br />

of the game and we think everyone needs<br />

a NAS. Qnap’s Hybrid Private Cloud was also<br />

there. HyperX had a focus on gaming to<br />

show off gear including the fantastic Alloy<br />

FPS keyboard and Cloud Stinger headphones,<br />

plus it was nice to be able to sit down for a<br />

while and hit a few rounds of CS: GO.<br />

Another Upgrade Australia, another<br />

bunch of <strong>PC</strong> & <strong>Tech</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> and <strong>PC</strong><br />

PowerPlay readers we met, who came, saw<br />

and likely left with freebies. And of course<br />

another great opportunity for the leaders<br />

in <strong>PC</strong> tech to lay on an extravaganza for you<br />

to all enjoy. Thanks for coming, we hope to<br />

see see you at the next one so look out for<br />

announcements in the magazine and online<br />

at www.pcpowerplay.com.au and www.<br />

pcauthority.com.au – and subscribe to our<br />

free newsletter so you’ll be the first to hear<br />

about it.


UPGRADE AUSTRALIA<br />

GOLD<br />

SPONSORS


Best free<br />

software<br />

PART 2<br />

25 DOWNLOADS TO SECURE YOUR <strong>PC</strong>, HELP<br />

YOU CODE, AND KEEP YOU ENTERTAINED<br />

Here at <strong>PC</strong> & <strong>Tech</strong> <strong>Authority</strong><br />

we keep our promises, and<br />

in last month’s roundup of<br />

free software we gave you<br />

time-savers, delivered lots of great<br />

creative tools and offered utilities<br />

galore. But we promised you more,<br />

and here, in our second and final<br />

roundup of the best free software,<br />

we focus on three very different<br />

areas.<br />

First, a selection of nine brilliant<br />

tools for keeping your <strong>PC</strong> safe from<br />

threats. Then, Paul Ockenden gets<br />

personal and reveals his favourite<br />

free coding tools as part of our<br />

Coding & Productivity section.<br />

Finally, we go wild with a selection<br />

of Media & Entertainment apps.<br />

Enjoy!<br />

28 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

CONTRIBUTORS<br />

BARRY COLLINS,<br />

TIM DANTON, MAX<br />

FIGGETT, DARIEN<br />

GRAHAM-SMITH,<br />

PAUL OCKENDEN,<br />

DAVEY WINDER<br />

THEY’RE<br />

ALL ON<br />

THE DVD!<br />

CONTENTS<br />

Security<br />

AdwCleaner<br />

Avast Free Antivirus<br />

F-Secure Rescue CD<br />

Junkware Removal<br />

Tool<br />

KeePass<br />

RogueKiller<br />

Secunia PSI<br />

Unchecky<br />

VeraCrypt<br />

Coding &<br />

Productivity<br />

CodePen<br />

Google Chrome<br />

Google PageSpeed<br />

Insights<br />

LibreOffice<br />

Notepad++<br />

Opera<br />

Raspberry Pi<br />

Tawk.to<br />

Visual Studio Code<br />

Visual Studio<br />

Community<br />

Media &<br />

Entertainment<br />

Freemake Audio<br />

Converter<br />

Freemake Video<br />

Converter<br />

Kodi<br />

Plex<br />

Sonic Dash<br />

VLC Media Player


FREE SOFTWARE FEATURE<br />

AdwCleaner<br />

malwarebytes.com<br />

AdwCleaner was a popular tool long before it was swallowed<br />

up by Malwarebytes, and for good reason: similar to the<br />

Junkware Removal Tool, it’s a speedy way to check if adware<br />

has hooked its claws into your system. Its particular specialism<br />

is the sort of junk that’s installed when you download a piece<br />

of freeware: think browser toolbars and unwanted extra<br />

programs. It’s easy to use but, as with RogueKiller, you may be<br />

left wondering what to do with the information it provides –<br />

bleepingcomputer.com is your friend here.<br />

Security<br />

Avast Free<br />

Antivirus<br />

avast.com<br />

It may be free but, in AV-Test.org’s most<br />

recent round of tests, Avast achieved a<br />

perfect 100% protection rating against<br />

never-before-seen “zero-day” attacks,<br />

and a 99.8% rating against widespread<br />

threats. That puts it several points<br />

ahead of Windows’ built-in Defender<br />

tool, and on a par with the likes of<br />

Bitdefender and Kaspersky.<br />

Avast also wins points for its<br />

relatively unobtrusive design. Like<br />

all free security products, it does<br />

encourage you<br />

to upgrade<br />

to a paid-for<br />

subscription,<br />

but we found it<br />

less aggressive<br />

than rivals AVG<br />

and Avira. Once<br />

you’ve turned<br />

off unwanted<br />

notifications,<br />

and learnt<br />

which buttons in the interface open up<br />

adverts, it will rarely bother you.<br />

Avast Free Antivirus also comes with<br />

Avast’s SafeZone browser, a Chromium<br />

derivative that’s designed to protect<br />

you from hijacking and snooping. This<br />

includes an ad blocker, a password<br />

manager and a video downloader<br />

that you can use to save media from<br />

YouTube, Facebook and other sites.<br />

Junkware Removal Tool<br />

malwarebytes.com<br />

A 1.6MB download, the Junkware Removal<br />

Tool is so minimalist that most people simply<br />

refer to it as JRT. Press Enter and it will rapidly<br />

scan Windows for annoying malware and<br />

things such as unwanted browser extensions<br />

and PUPs – that is, potentially unwanted<br />

programs. It’s a fantastic little tool.<br />

EDITOR’S PICK<br />

KeePass<br />

keepass.info<br />

You need unique passwords for<br />

everything, and these need to be long<br />

(25 characters minimum), complex and<br />

random, in my opinion. Your brain can’t handle that;<br />

a password manager can. What puts off some folk is<br />

the annual subscription cost, and worries about the<br />

security of password databases in the cloud. So use<br />

a free one that bypasses the cloud for local database<br />

storage. In that regard, they don’t come better than<br />

KeePass.<br />

I keep my software-encrypted KeePass database<br />

on a hardware-encrypted USB stick, which doubles<br />

up the security layers. I access this using the free<br />

KeePass2Android app on my smartphone, which<br />

requires my fingerprint to turn on the device and<br />

again to access the app. Those security layers add up.<br />

KeePass supports the Advanced Encryption Standard<br />

(AES) with the SHA-256 hash. This encrypts the<br />

complete database, not just the password fields,<br />

including any notes.<br />

What else is great about KeePass? Well, it’s multi-platform, including Windows,<br />

macOS, Linux, iOS and Android. There’s a password generator included in the<br />

package, and the import function puts many competing products to shame.<br />

There’s no in-browser autofill by default, but thirdparty<br />

extensions are available. Its configuration options are many, but <strong>PC</strong>TA readers<br />

will have no issues stepping through them.


FEATURE FREE SOFTWARE<br />

F-Secure Rescue CD<br />

f-secure.com<br />

This tool was originally recommended by computer repair specialist<br />

Anthony Dowling: it’s a resource he often turns to when faced with<br />

an unbootable <strong>PC</strong>. Despite its name, it can be installed to either a CD<br />

or a USB drive.<br />

It’s essentially self-contained antivirus software, and on booting<br />

from the drive, you’re thrown into a simple text-based environment.<br />

From there, you scan for malware and then remove it. F-Secure does<br />

throw in some heavy caveats – that using it could break your install<br />

if it renames essential system files – so it’s more the battering ram<br />

of removing malware rather than the user-friendly sliding door.<br />

Secunia PSI<br />

flexerasoftware.com<br />

It hasn’t been updated for a<br />

while, but Secunia PSI remains<br />

an excellent way to keep all<br />

your software up to date<br />

automatically. And keep your<br />

system more secure by doing so.<br />

On first load, Secunia PSI scans<br />

your system to check which<br />

programs you’ve installed and<br />

then checks for updates against its database. You can control<br />

whether it installs updates automatically (the recommended<br />

option), in which case it does so in the background wherever<br />

it can. Where you have to log in – think paid-for software such<br />

as Adobe CC – it will let you know when a manual update is<br />

required.<br />

EDITOR’S PICK<br />

Unchecky<br />

unchecky.com<br />

Most of the programs in this security section are there<br />

to solve problems after the event, but Unchecky prevents<br />

all those unwanted “free extras” being downloaded in the<br />

first place. As such, it’s a wise program to install on family<br />

computers as well as your own.<br />

Its modus operandi is to flag a warning whenever you’re<br />

about to install something that might be unwanted – toolbars,<br />

browser extensions and the like – but the best thing is that,<br />

once you’ve installed Unchecky, you can forget about it. It just<br />

sits there, automatically updating itself. Exactly how I like<br />

my programs to behave.<br />

RogueKiller<br />

adlice.com<br />

If you’re worried that something might be lurking on your system,<br />

RogueKiller is an excellent first port of all. Like a Windowsequivalent<br />

of the Terminator, it hunts down and removes a wide<br />

range of malware, including rootkits. It’s more thorough than the<br />

Junkware Removal Tool, but that also means it takes longer to run<br />

a scan – almost an hour in the case of our 256GB system drive.<br />

It’s a little paranoid, so check files it flags before you delete them<br />

(bleepingcomputer.com is a great resource if you want to see if a<br />

file is worth keeping; check its “Am I infected?” forum at tinyurl.<br />

com/kpy9ltm).<br />

VeraCrypt<br />

idrix.fr/veracrypt<br />

While BitLocker is an excellent encryption tool, it does<br />

have one rather annoying problem: it’s only available to<br />

people running Pro or Enterprise versions of Windows<br />

(Ultimate and Enterprise, in the case of Windows 7). The<br />

free, open-source VeraCrypt steps into the gulf, and it’s<br />

packed with options. If nothing else, you should consider its<br />

full-disk encryption mode.<br />

If you just want to encrypt a folder, file or partition,<br />

though, then there are options to do just that. Heck, if recent<br />

headlines are pushing your paranoia levels into the red zone,<br />

then you can create a dummy Windows install disk and a<br />

totally hidden volume containing your “real” Windows.<br />

The final good news is that VeraCrypt won’t slow you<br />

down (you can even keep using Windows while your disk is<br />

being encrypted), meaning there really is no good reason not<br />

to add this cost-free extra level of security to your system.<br />

30 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


Google Chrome<br />

google.com/chrome<br />

Browser choices are as personal as fashion, but there are many<br />

reasons why Chrome remains our – and indeed, the world’s – default<br />

browser.<br />

Cross-platform sync is perhaps its chief attraction, with seamless<br />

password sharing between both Android and Windows browsers,<br />

and the ability to pick up tabs left open on other devices. Didn’t get<br />

a chance to finish reading that important report in the office? With<br />

Chrome, you can easily read it on the train on the way home using<br />

your smartphone.<br />

Chrome’s omnipotence hands it arguably the best library of<br />

extensions of any browser (Edge, for the record, has a mere 21).<br />

Pushbullet, Wikiwand and Social Fixer are among those we’d urge<br />

you to install.<br />

While Chrome certainly isn’t the sleek gazelle it lauded itself as at<br />

launch, now almost a decade ago, its reputation as a resource hog is<br />

over-cooked too. The fact that upcoming rivals such as Vivaldi are<br />

choosing the same Chromium engine indicate that Google’s browser<br />

technology is now seen as the industry standard.<br />

Coding &<br />

Productivity<br />

LibreOffice<br />

libreoffice.org<br />

LibreOffice is far more than a free alternative for people loathe to shell<br />

out for Microsoft Office – it’s a decent suite in its own right. Now at version<br />

5.3, the software includes old favourites Writer (for word processing), Calc<br />

(spreadsheets) and Impress (presentations), as well as Draw (design), Base<br />

(databases) and Math (for, quelle surprise, maths).<br />

Apart from the slightly cartoonish look of the icons, there’s little<br />

to distinguish the suite from Microsoft’s offerings. This extends to<br />

functionality, with powerful tools in place to improve the look of your<br />

document, keep your spreadsheet ticking over and make sure your<br />

presentations, if you’ll pardon the pun, impress. A favourite feature of<br />

ours is the smartphone-esque AutoCorrect function, which draws on<br />

previously typed words to bring up a suggestion after three letters.<br />

Compatibility is also good. For example, you can save a Writer document<br />

as a Microsoft Word DOCX or XML file, as well as in RTF, TXT and the<br />

standard OpenDocument formats. As a mini-test, we pasted in Edgar<br />

Allen Poe’s The Raven, formatted it, saved the document and watched<br />

as it opened intact in Word. Also note version 5.3’s new cloud capability,<br />

LibreOffice Online, allowing<br />

you to run it “on your own<br />

private cloud infrastructure”.<br />

If you want a hassle-free<br />

way of creating documents,<br />

tracking your expenses, or<br />

even tinkering with that<br />

pesky quadratic equation,<br />

LibreOffice is an excellent<br />

resource.<br />

Notepad++<br />

notepad-plus-plus.org<br />

Notepad++ was created for<br />

programmers, with some preferring<br />

its simplicity to full IDEs (integrated<br />

development environments) such<br />

as Visual Studio. Built on Windows’<br />

Notepad, the interface is a bit oldfashioned<br />

and the menu cluttered,<br />

but its sheer speed makes it a pleasure<br />

to use. Programmers particularly<br />

appreciate the code completion, the<br />

colour coding, and that they can switch<br />

to a different language so easily –<br />

although even non-coders should give<br />

it a whirl as a way to jot down notes and<br />

type up pieces without distraction.<br />

It’s also one of the most popular pieces<br />

of open-source software out there. With<br />

an active community behind it – and<br />

that’s understating things – there are<br />

so many plugins that one of the main<br />

complaints about the software is plugin<br />

management.<br />

Not that such things deter reader Dave<br />

Poyser, who recommended the software.<br />

“I use Notepad++ daily for all sorts of<br />

editing,” he told us. “It’s crammed full of<br />

features that I use whether I’m editing<br />

config files, or writing code. On a new<br />

build, this is a second install after Office<br />

for me.”<br />

32 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


FREE SOFTWARE FEATURE<br />

My favourite free<br />

programming tools<br />

We asked Paul<br />

Ockenden to share his<br />

personal picks based<br />

on years of experience<br />

Can you imagine how much a large software company would<br />

charge you for a code development system that supported<br />

programming languages such as C#, Visual Basic, F#, C++, HTML,<br />

JavaScript, TypeScript and Python, and allowed you to deploy<br />

your code onto Windows, Android, iOS or web servers? Such a tool<br />

sounds really expensive, doesn’t it?<br />

Well, as you’ve probably guessed it’s<br />

free, and the software I’m talking about is<br />

Visual Studio Community from Microsoft<br />

(visualstudio.com/vs/community). It’s<br />

a great mature platform, and for many<br />

programmers it provides everything they<br />

need without stumping up for the paidfor<br />

version of Visual Studio.<br />

Sharing a similar name, look and feel<br />

– but not much else – is Visual Studio<br />

Code (code.visualstudio.com), also from Microsoft. It’s a lean tool<br />

compared to the other Visual Studio offerings. This lack of bloat can<br />

be an advantage, especially for small teams and one-man bands – I<br />

find its fast turnaround can make the development process more<br />

productive.<br />

As well as having excellent source-code editing<br />

facilities, with code completion and colouring<br />

support for pretty much any language, it also offers<br />

an interactive debugger and version control via<br />

integrated Git support. But the best thing about<br />

Visual Studio Code is that it’s available for Linux and<br />

Mac, as well as Windows.<br />

My next free tool involves going outside the box<br />

slightly. I’m nominating the Raspberry Pi. Okay, so<br />

the hardware itself isn’t free (although the Pi Zero<br />

is astonishingly cheap – assuming you<br />

don’t get ripped off by resellers), but the<br />

ecosystem that surrounds it usually is.<br />

There are one or two paid-for tools, but<br />

they’re rare.<br />

The most common Pi OS package,<br />

Raspbian, comes with pre-installed<br />

versions of Python, C, C++, Java,<br />

Scratch, Perl and Ruby. Via the magic of<br />

the “apt-get install” command, there’s<br />

also a whole world of software, tools<br />

and libraries available, and “git clone”<br />

gives you access to code on GitHub. The Pi is a great introduction to<br />

free programming.<br />

With my web developer hat on, a real favourite free tool is CodePen<br />

(codepen.io). It’s an online playpen where you can try out HTML,<br />

CSS and JavaScript mini-projects, and see instant, live results. It runs<br />

in any web browser, and can be a quick way to mock up things such<br />

as how the navigation buttons on a website will work. There are<br />

paid-for plans available, but for smaller projects the free version is<br />

perfectly adequate.<br />

A free tool for web developers is Google’s<br />

PageSpeed Insights (tinyurl.com/m65jex6).<br />

This will analyse your website as both a desktop<br />

and mobile user see it, and suggest code and<br />

configuration improvements to make the site load<br />

faster – quicker websites encourage people to stay<br />

longer; faster-loading sites are also ranked higher<br />

by search engines. There’s an API that you can use<br />

to automate the tests, perhaps hooking them into<br />

your CMS.<br />

Opera<br />

opera.com<br />

Opera has long been the alt-browser, to use the modern<br />

vernacular. And while it might have changed hands (Opera’s<br />

original creator is now running interference with a browser<br />

of his own, Vivaldi), Opera continues to innovate.<br />

It’s the only faintly mainstream browser to come with a<br />

built-in VPN, for instance, although if you’re planning to use<br />

it to beat Netflix’s regional restrictions then think again:<br />

the streaming service spotted the proxy and blocked the<br />

stream in our tests.<br />

Perhaps more useful is Opera’s battery-saving mode.<br />

Yank the power cord out of your laptop and the browser<br />

enters a low-power mode that conserves juice by “reducing<br />

activity in background tabs, pausing plugins and animations,<br />

rescheduling JavaScript timers, and tuning video-playback<br />

parameters,” according to the company.<br />

That, combined with effective built-in ad-blocking, seemed<br />

to have some effect. With the exact same five tabs open,<br />

Chrome consumed around 1% of our CPU’s capacity and<br />

125MB of RAM, according to Windows Task Manager, while<br />

Opera was barely registering on the processor and required<br />

115MB.<br />

Tawk.to<br />

tawk.to<br />

In arguably the most interesting<br />

response to our plea for free software<br />

that readers love, Tim Parkinson<br />

suggested the messaging app tawk.<br />

to. It lets you communicate with your<br />

site’s readers in many ways.<br />

“I love tawk.to as it shows me instant<br />

activity on my website,” Tim wrote.<br />

“It shows me the immediate effects of<br />

social media posts or direct marketing.<br />

You can post something to Twitter and<br />

within seconds you can hear it pinging<br />

like a cash register when people read<br />

your blogs on your site. You can also see<br />

where they are, the referral page and<br />

what page they are on.<br />

“You can live chat to them or they can live chat to you. It has<br />

a mobile app as well, so you can do all of this via your mobile. All<br />

this from a simple piece of code that you add to the header of<br />

your pages.”<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 33


EDITOR’S PICK<br />

Freemake Video<br />

Converter<br />

freemake.com<br />

“The whole line of<br />

software from Freemake<br />

is brilliant,” Jake Harris<br />

told us, “but for me,<br />

the most useful of their<br />

applications is Freemake<br />

Video Converter. I’ve<br />

been using it for around five years now and it has become my go-to way of managing all<br />

the different video file types on my <strong>PC</strong>.<br />

“Freemake’s software can deal with almost any file format, as well as download<br />

and convert videos from places such as YouTube. There are very basic video-editing<br />

capabilities, such as being able to cut, join and rotate videos. The software is consistently<br />

updated to support new devices, meaning you can select the device you intend to play<br />

your video on and it will automatically know which format works best.<br />

“For me, Freemake Video Converter provides all the features I’d once use HandBrake<br />

for, whilst keeping to a clean and simple user interface.”<br />

Freemake<br />

Audio<br />

Converter<br />

freemake.com<br />

This is simplicity itself to use: select<br />

an audio or video file and choose to<br />

convert it to MP3, WMA, WAV, FLAC,<br />

AAC, M4A or OGG. It’s also speedy,<br />

taking just 25 seconds to convert<br />

a 6.4MB M4A song to crisp, highquality<br />

MP3, which we could then<br />

play directly in VLC Media Player<br />

(see opposite). Be warned, however,<br />

that Freemake cheekily tried to add<br />

an additional piece of software,<br />

Pro <strong>PC</strong> Cleaner, to the download – so<br />

you may want to install Unchecky<br />

first. For giving old songs new life in<br />

a different format, it’s ideal.<br />

Media &<br />

Entertainment<br />

Kodi<br />

kodi.tv<br />

Kodi is perhaps the most<br />

controversial choice on this<br />

list. Formerly known as XBMC<br />

Media Centre, Kodi is ostensibly<br />

a media entertainment hub,<br />

yet it’s now earned notoriety<br />

as a means to stream pirated<br />

content through a series of addons.<br />

We’ll let your conscience<br />

dictate whether that crosses<br />

any moral boundaries,<br />

never mind the legal ones.<br />

Kodi can be installed via<br />

the Windows Store, although<br />

beware that its ten-foot<br />

interface is designed to be<br />

viewed from distance, much like<br />

a Sky EPG, so everything seems<br />

enormous close-up. It can be a<br />

little intimidating to set up and<br />

you’ll need to learn how to install<br />

add-ons to get the most from<br />

Kodi.<br />

34 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


FREE SOFTWARE FEATURE<br />

Plex<br />

plex.tv<br />

If you just want to play the odd video file, VLC<br />

will do you fine (see below). For those with<br />

bigger ambitions, Plex is the way to go. It’s a<br />

complete media library system that can stream<br />

movies and music to any device in your house –<br />

or outside of it.<br />

It’s built on a client/server model, so you’ll<br />

need to configure one machine on your home<br />

network as a media server. This might be a <strong>PC</strong><br />

or a Mac; alternatively, you can run Plex on a<br />

Linux-based NAS appliance – check the website<br />

to see which brands are supported.<br />

Once this is done, the magic begins. Plex scans<br />

your video and music files and – based on filename<br />

recognition – organises them into a rich visual<br />

library, with preview images, episode information, subtitles and<br />

more, all automatically filled in from free online sources.<br />

You can then browse and play media using either the Plex client<br />

app or a smart web interface. Enable remote access and you can<br />

access your library even when you’re out and about, and if you pay<br />

for the optional Plex Pass you can open it up to friends and family<br />

too, with their own custom playlists and restrictions. It’s like your<br />

own personal Netflix, and it’s completely free.<br />

Sonic Dash<br />

Windows Store<br />

VLC Media Player<br />

videolan.org/vlc<br />

Do you like your games to be simple, colourful and with a hefty dollop of nostalgia?<br />

If so, Sonic Dash is the game for you. Now in its third year on Windows, its<br />

lurid visuals and worlds should put a smile on the face of anyone who fondly<br />

remembers Sega’s ring-collecting blue hedgehog from his beginnings in the<br />

1990s.<br />

But Sonic Dash isn’t just for diehard fans. It takes the tired Temple Run format<br />

and, well, runs with it, fleshing out a flimsy premise with additional content.<br />

This comes in the form of unlockable characters (including Knuckles and Tails),<br />

combos, power-ups and “boss levels” in which you can take on rotund adversary<br />

Doctor Eggman.<br />

As ever with free games, there are a couple of drawbacks. The first is a liberal<br />

smattering of adverts, but most of them can be promptly dismissed after a few<br />

seconds. The second is the looming presence of in-app purchases, which can<br />

become wearing.<br />

Nevertheless, Sonic Dash is ideal for anyone in need of a mindless break – just<br />

don’t blame us if you’re still playing it two hours later…<br />

The grande dame of the free media player<br />

world, VLC Media Player still has the same<br />

aim as when it launched in 2001: to easily<br />

play almost any audio or video format for<br />

free. And it does.<br />

Once set up as your default media player,<br />

bringing VLC Media Player to life is a silkysmooth<br />

process: pop in a DVD, click on a file,<br />

choose a stream or open your webcam and<br />

get started. If you’re playing a video, the<br />

software has a few neat tricks up its sleeve,<br />

such as setting the screen as your wallpaper<br />

so you can continue browsing, custom<br />

bookmarks, automatically saved snapshots<br />

and fun visual effects (our personal<br />

favourite is the trippy “Psychedelic” setting,<br />

which certainly breathed terrifying new life<br />

into Dad’s Army).<br />

Furthermore, the interface is fully<br />

customisable, allowing you to get rid of,<br />

for example, the loop or shuffle button<br />

when playing an album. Moreover, power<br />

users can make the most of VLC Media<br />

Player’s module for batch-converting media<br />

files into a different format, which can<br />

be used alongside Freemake’s software<br />

(see opposite). If that wasn’t enough, the<br />

developers have also thrown in a few treats<br />

for Windows 10 users, including Cortana voice<br />

commands (“Hey Cortana, play Slipknot”) and<br />

Live Tiles.<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 35


THE ESET<br />

ADVANTAGE<br />

STAY SAFE ONLINE WITH CONFIDENCE<br />

he Internet can be a dangerous place, full of<br />

malicious hackers trying to take advantage of<br />

T honest and innocent users. Hackers constantly<br />

pretend to be companies or websites they aren’t,<br />

attempting to fool you into clicking their deceiving<br />

links and giving them your personal information so<br />

your computer becomes a member of their robot army.<br />

Even the most attentive Internet user can slip up by<br />

clicking something they’re not supposed to and end<br />

up in a world of pain. Even a simple lapse in installing<br />

vital Windows updates that fix flaws leveraged by<br />

hackers can wreak havoc.<br />

That’s why anti-virus, or more<br />

accurately for <strong>2017</strong> – Internet security<br />

software, exists. Anti-virus programs sit<br />

in the background, valiantly monitoring<br />

your computer, on the hunt for activity<br />

that resembles something trying to ruin<br />

your day. It would be foolish not to have<br />

anti-virus software installed on your computer – just<br />

like you wouldn’t drive your car without wearing a<br />

seatbelt, you shouldn’t use the Internet without antivirus<br />

software.<br />

Dedicated anti-virus software is obsolete though,<br />

right? Microsoft has one built-in to Windows - for free!<br />

Who better to protect your computer than Microsoft,<br />

who know the operating system inside out and<br />

have a vested interest in ensuring your Windows<br />

experience is not sullied with malware and viruses?<br />

Sorry to break it to you, but that hasn’t been the case<br />

for years. Windows Defender is the bare minimum in<br />

protection against Internet nasties.<br />

In real-world<br />

detection tests from<br />

the respected AV-TEST<br />

outfit, ESET’s anti-virus<br />

software detected<br />

98.80% of threats,<br />

whereas Windows<br />

Defender managed a<br />

paltry 88%, putting<br />

it amongst the worst<br />

performers. Windows<br />

Defender’s false alarms<br />

rate is much higher too.<br />

In AV-Comparative’s<br />

March 2016 test,<br />

ESET didn’t present a<br />

single false alarm, yet<br />

Defender jumped the<br />

gun 13 times. Defender<br />

even has a higher<br />

impact on system<br />

performance.<br />

36 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

“ESET’s anti-virus<br />

software detected<br />

98.80% of threats”<br />

ESET Internet Security<br />

and ESET Smart<br />

Security Premium<br />

provide rock solid<br />

protection<br />

ESET INTERNET SECURITY<br />

Dedicated anti-virus software such as ESET<br />

Internet Security is not only better at basic<br />

protection, but offers levels of protection Windows<br />

Defender doesn’t, and never will. ESET implements<br />

various features to go the extra mile in protecting<br />

you online.<br />

Ransomware Shield: This monitors and evaluates<br />

all executed applications using behavioral<br />

heuristics and actively blocks known behaviors<br />

that resemble ransomware.<br />

Anti-Phishing: Thwarts attempts to acquire<br />

sensitive information such as<br />

usernames or passwords by<br />

fake websites masquerading as<br />

trustworthy ones.<br />

Banking & Payment Protection: A<br />

special secured browser through which<br />

you can safely pay online that protects<br />

you from keyloggers.<br />

Webcam Protection: Monitors all the processes<br />

and applications running on your computer, to see<br />

which ones want to use your webcam. It alerts<br />

you to any that unexpectedly try to access your<br />

webcam, and lets you block them.<br />

Small System Footprint: ESET is famous for<br />

having a small footprint that leaves more power to<br />

programs you use daily and extends the lifetime of<br />

hardware.<br />

ESET SMART SECURITY PREMIUM<br />

ESET’s Smart Security Premium offers more<br />

features than anyone serious<br />

about securing their computer even<br />

considers.<br />

Password Manager: Lets<br />

you safely store and prefill your<br />

passwords to avoid password reuse<br />

and create strong passwords.<br />

Secure Data: Encrypt files and<br />

removable media, such as USB keys so<br />

if someone does gain physical access<br />

to your data, they can’t do anything<br />

with it.<br />

Anti-Theft: Helps you track and<br />

locate your laptop in case it goes<br />

missing because of a loss or theft.<br />

Mark a device as lost and it activates<br />

the webcam and takes screenshots to<br />

see who’s got it.


ESET ADVERTORIAL<br />

THE ESET<br />

EXPERT<br />

We sat down with Nick FitzGerald, Senior Research<br />

Fellow at ESET to discuss the current threat landscape<br />

What are the latest trends in the type of<br />

threats and vulnerabilities ESET works<br />

to prevent? Is there a particular type of<br />

malware in fashion right now?<br />

Well, right when you asked, everybody<br />

was, and still is, talking about the<br />

WannaCryptor (aka WannaCry)<br />

ransomware worm. The reason<br />

WannaCryptor has received so much<br />

attention is that it combines one of the<br />

most common current forms of malware<br />

– ransomware – with fast-spreading<br />

network worm functionality. The worm<br />

also depended on an element of luck for its<br />

success. It used the so-called EternalBlue<br />

exploit from the recent Shadow Brokers<br />

leak of what are reputedly NSA hacking<br />

tools. EternalBlue exploits a vulnerability<br />

in a very old part of the Windows<br />

networking code that was present in<br />

all versions of Windows from at least<br />

Windows XP, and maybe even earlier.<br />

Despite all this though, I don’t think<br />

that WannaCryptor is the beginning<br />

of a trend. The worm functionality of<br />

WannaCryptor has seriously jarred quite<br />

a number of people out of what may<br />

have been an element of complacency.<br />

I strongly suspect that many network<br />

firewalls and other security perimeters<br />

and controls will have been checked a<br />

little more thoroughly than usual over<br />

the last few days.<br />

How does ESET stay on top of the<br />

constant malware and virus threats<br />

that seem to constantly be popping up?<br />

It may be rather anti-climactic, but the<br />

answer is that it’s ‘mostly done through<br />

automation’. The huge volume of samples<br />

of new malware and other “suspect”<br />

activity our products see<br />

and log is constantly being<br />

mined for interesting<br />

patterns and new developments. Of<br />

course, there are human researchers<br />

overseeing all this, as often their<br />

experience means they see things better<br />

or sooner than the automated systems.<br />

Further, human researchers oversee the<br />

testing and validation of new detection<br />

patterns and other technologies we<br />

deploy, either through the cloud or<br />

directly to the endpoint security<br />

software.<br />

What’s a typical malware analysis<br />

look like? How does ESET counter<br />

increasingly ambitious hackers?<br />

The new, possibly more challenging and<br />

interesting material tends to stick out like<br />

the proverbial “sore thumb”. Usually what<br />

follows is nothing like typical. Sometimes<br />

it takes thinking outside the square, such<br />

as how researchers thought to look for<br />

what turned out to be early IoT malware<br />

and such.<br />

Do you have a favourite piece of<br />

malware? Something nasty, but you<br />

kinda admire the ingenuity of it?<br />

Not that I’ll identify publicly! Seriously<br />

though, you do occasionally come<br />

across something whose elegance,<br />

or whose key ideas are so simple yet<br />

had not been thought of or tried before,<br />

gives you pause to admire the ingenuity<br />

or skill that resulted in this piece of<br />

malice being built. Mostly though, you<br />

just groan at the unending ordinariness<br />

of it all, or even have to laugh at the abject<br />

stupidity and you are left scratching<br />

your head wondering how many more<br />

errors and bugs would have been needed<br />

to render the code entirely useless, as<br />

opposed to its current state of nearuselessness.<br />

When ESET detects a vulnerability,<br />

what is the typical time frame from<br />

when the issue is detected and a<br />

response is released to customers?<br />

In the case that we become aware of<br />

vulnerabilities in our own products, we<br />

work as quickly as possible to remediate<br />

and release updates to fix the issue. As<br />

the complexity of vulnerabilities can vary<br />

greatly, it is very difficult to put a likely<br />

or typical timeframe on preparing and<br />

shipping such remediations, but in the<br />

few such cases since I have worked for<br />

ESET, our responses have been measured<br />

in days rather than weeks or longer<br />

timeframes. Further, it is often the case<br />

that we could ship detection updates<br />

to detect and block attempts to exploit<br />

such vulnerabilities, thus protecting our<br />

customers until we can ship a full repair.<br />

In the case that we become aware of<br />

vulnerabilities in the products of others,<br />

we work to responsibly disclose the<br />

vulnerability to the affected vendor<br />

and assist them in remediating the<br />

vulnerability if they wish to work with<br />

us. Again, it is likely that we could ship<br />

detection updates for exploitation<br />

attempts to help protect our customers<br />

until the affected can ship an update to<br />

fix the issue.<br />

WHAT ABOUT THE WANNACRY MALWARE SCARE?<br />

Ransomware is an insidious piece of<br />

software that finds its way on to your<br />

computer the same way as malware<br />

(i.e: downloading a dodgy program via<br />

an email link, banner ad or app that<br />

misrepresents itself), but instead of<br />

turning your computer into a hacker’s<br />

slave, every single file is encrypted.<br />

If you want your files unencrypted,<br />

you have to use Bitcoin (a relatively<br />

anonymous payment method) to pay the<br />

ransom and have your data released.<br />

Luckily, ESET Internet Security<br />

includes Ransomware Shield. When<br />

Ransomware Shield<br />

is enabled, all executed applications<br />

are monitored and evaluated using<br />

behavioural and reputation based<br />

heuristics. When behaviour that<br />

resembles ransomware is identified,<br />

such as trying to encrypt data<br />

unexpectedly, the process is blocked and<br />

you are notified of what’s going on. It’s<br />

not a total replacement for a solid backup<br />

of your important data, but another<br />

line of defence to ensure your normal<br />

activities are not disrupted.<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 37


DO<br />

SERVICES SUCH AS IF THIS THEN<br />

THAT (IFTTT), MICROSOFT FLOW<br />

AND ZAPIER CAN MAKE YOUR LIFE<br />

EASIER BY AUTOMATING DULL, TIME-<br />

CONSUMING TASKS. BARRY COLLINS<br />

AND MAX FIGGETT SHOW HOW TO<br />

MAKE THE MOST OF THEM<br />

MORE<br />

WORK<br />

LESS<br />

IFTTT PAGE 39<br />

MICROSOFT FLOW PAGE 43<br />

ZAPIER PAGE 46


DO MORE, WORK LESS FEATURE<br />

W<br />

e’re all plugged into dozens of<br />

different web services and devices<br />

– but all of them work in their<br />

own little silos. You might have an Android<br />

smartphone, Philips Hue lights, an Apple<br />

iPad, accounts with Dropbox, Gmail and<br />

Wunderlist, but making this diverse set of<br />

digital accoutrements work with one another<br />

is tough.<br />

Services such as If This Then That (IFTTT)<br />

are the glue that bind these services together.<br />

Using a simple web interface or app, you’ll find<br />

it’s possible to get your iPhone talking to your<br />

smart plug, your Spotify playlists backed up<br />

in a Google spreadsheet, your eBay listings<br />

automatically tweeted to potential buyers.<br />

Better still, it can make smart home devices<br />

even smarter. Alexa can be told to dim your<br />

lights, turn down the heating or lock the<br />

garage door, even though Amazon itself<br />

doesn’t support the smart devices. Someone<br />

ringing your smart door can trigger a hallway<br />

light to switch on, perhaps sufficient to<br />

convince a would-be burglar that someone<br />

really is home after all. Your neighbours could<br />

even be alerted to potential fires in your home<br />

while you’re sunning yourself on a beach.<br />

In this feature, we’ve delivered more than<br />

80 ways of making services IFTTT, Zapier<br />

and Microsoft Flow do the heavy lifting, to<br />

do the hard work while you get on with<br />

your life. We’ll show you how to automate<br />

a huge number of tasks, and how to create<br />

your own applets and make your devices do<br />

your bidding for you. It’s time to automate<br />

everything.<br />

I<br />

FTTT is powered by applets (previously<br />

called recipes), which are essentially<br />

user-defined scripts for particular<br />

services. Each applet needs a trigger (the<br />

“if” this happens) and an outcome (“then do<br />

that”). Applets can deal with a single service<br />

(for example, if I leave the office, unmute my<br />

Android phone), or bring together multiple<br />

services/devices (if I add a song to a Spotify<br />

playlist, tweet a link to the track).<br />

The IFTTT.com website contains many<br />

SAVE TIME WITH IFTTT<br />

pre-prepared applets for the dozens of<br />

different services and devices that IFTTT<br />

is compatible with. If you can’t find an<br />

applet to do what you want, you can<br />

create your own by clicking on My Applets<br />

| New Applets and follow the on-screen<br />

prompts.<br />

However, in our experience, IFTTT<br />

applets can be flaky. Some work<br />

flawlessly, others inconsistently, some<br />

not at all. If you find a pre-prepared applet<br />

doesn’t deliver the goods, it’s often worth<br />

trying to create a new applet with the<br />

same functionality yourself: a script that<br />

works for one person may not work in<br />

quite the same way for another.<br />

IFTTT’s site can also be temperamental.<br />

Users report problems activating applets<br />

in Google Chrome on an external display<br />

with a touchscreen laptop – a long-term<br />

bug. The site works fine in Microsoft’s<br />

Edge browser.<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 39


PHONE<br />

SILENCERS<br />

3 applets<br />

Let’s start with the basics – applets that<br />

stop you getting disturbed by pinging<br />

notifications in the middle of the night,<br />

or while you’re in important meetings at<br />

work. Unfortunately, IFTTT can only be<br />

used to control Android phones – iOS’s<br />

phone functionality is strictly locked<br />

down by Apple, denying third-party apps<br />

the ability to perform tasks such as mute/<br />

unmute the handset, log calls or access<br />

text messages.<br />

To silence your phone during the twilight<br />

hours and switch the ringer back on again<br />

in the morning, you<br />

will need two separate<br />

applets:<br />

To mute the phone at<br />

bedtime: tinyurl.com/<br />

kva7k43.<br />

To unmute your phone<br />

in the morning: tinyurl.<br />

com/m2z88u7.<br />

If you click on the<br />

settings cog on both<br />

applets, you’ll find<br />

options to adjust both<br />

your bedtime and the<br />

time you want the phone<br />

to wake up again, both<br />

rather awkwardly broken<br />

down into hours and<br />

minutes. The wake-up<br />

applet also lets you set<br />

the ringer volume as a<br />

percentage, for those<br />

who don’t like to be<br />

awakened by a 100% ringtone blast early<br />

in the morning. Note, even on silent, any<br />

alarm set on your phone should still work.<br />

What about preventing the constant<br />

chirping of Twitter<br />

or personal phone<br />

calls while you’re<br />

in meetings?<br />

The following<br />

applet will silence<br />

your phone<br />

whenever there’s<br />

an appointment<br />

in your Google<br />

Calendar: tinyurl.<br />

com/kjew8s6.<br />

The downside<br />

to this applet is<br />

that you’ll need<br />

to remember to<br />

unmute your<br />

phone manually<br />

after the meeting<br />

has finished.<br />

GET FREE<br />

STUFF!<br />

4 applets<br />

IFTTT is excellent at keeping an eye<br />

out for bargains. The service will<br />

trawl all manner of sites for free<br />

music, apps, games and other stuff.<br />

Here’s a selection of useful applets<br />

that will help ensure you never miss<br />

out on a bargain.<br />

Google releases a new song for free<br />

every day on Play Music. Get a daily<br />

email with a link to the song using<br />

the following applet: tinyurl.com/<br />

n7g4u78.<br />

If you use the Steam games service,<br />

you can be sent email notifications<br />

when free game keys are posted to<br />

Reddit using this applet: tinyurl.com/<br />

lfaj3cf.<br />

Want to make sure you don’t miss<br />

out when leading apps have their<br />

price dropped to zilch for promotional<br />

giveaways? iOS users<br />

should enable the<br />

following applet,<br />

which lets you<br />

adjust the country<br />

you’re living in, the<br />

category of apps<br />

you’re interested in,<br />

and which device you<br />

own (an iPad, say) in<br />

the settings: tinyurl.<br />

com/n2hzvfl.<br />

There’s also a<br />

similar applet for<br />

Android users:<br />

tinyurl.com/kfb4pf5.<br />

MANAGE YOUR<br />

STOCK PORTFOLIO<br />

4 applets<br />

If you haven’t got time to keep a beady eye<br />

on your stock portfolio, you can employ<br />

IFTTT to do it for you. There’s a slight catch<br />

here, with IFTTT betraying its American<br />

roots – only stocks listed on the NASDAQ<br />

and other US exchanges can be tracked.<br />

Still, if you’re an investor in the major tech<br />

firms, you’ll likely be covered.<br />

If you want to make sure you’re alerted<br />

to a sudden crash in a company’s share<br />

price, this applet will send an Android<br />

phone notification when a selected stock<br />

dips below a predetermined level: tinyurl.<br />

com/mgbuwyf.<br />

Alternatively, if you<br />

want to be alerted if the<br />

price falls by a certain<br />

percentage, activate<br />

this applet: tinyurl.com/<br />

m6yhcbq.<br />

Likewise, if you<br />

want to get out when a<br />

particular stock begins<br />

to peak, this applet is<br />

your friend: tinyurl.com/<br />

lrvfk58.<br />

If you’re more of a<br />

long-term investor, and<br />

just want to keep tabs on<br />

your portfolio in a Google<br />

spreadsheet, this applet<br />

will automatically update<br />

a sheet with each day’s<br />

closing price: tinyurl.com/<br />

mpo6y7a.<br />

There are many other<br />

applets for price falls or rises of particular<br />

stocks, exchange rate fluctuations and<br />

the price of commodities such as gold or<br />

bitcoins. Take a look at the many options<br />

available at ifttt.com/search/stocks.<br />

40 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


DO MORE, WORK LESS FEATURE<br />

MONITOR THE<br />

EBAY AUCTIONS<br />

4 applets<br />

You’ve got your eye on a Canon 1D, or a<br />

vintage ZX Spectrum, or a rare B-side by<br />

Squeeze. Whatever it is, it will likely end up<br />

on eBay, but trying to keep abreast of all<br />

the latest listings is a tricky manual job. Let<br />

IFTTT take the strain.<br />

The following applet lets you specify a<br />

search term, a maximum price and then<br />

saves all of the new listings to a Google<br />

spreadsheet: tinyurl.com/lkcu2bv. If<br />

you’re desperately seeking a rare item,<br />

IFTTT’s mobile app will ping an optional<br />

notification every time the applet is<br />

triggered, so you should be alerted to any<br />

new listings in short order.<br />

Google Sheets is only one of the many<br />

destinations that can log results for eBay<br />

searches. Check out the eBay channel (ifttt.<br />

com/ebay) and you’ll see options to ping<br />

results into OneNote, Slack, Pushbullet,<br />

and all manner of different services.<br />

What about if you’re selling gear? This<br />

applet automatically shares your new<br />

listings on Twitter, handy for power sellers<br />

who want to attract attention to listings on<br />

social media: tinyurl.com/lut2apa.<br />

There’s also a<br />

straightforward applet for<br />

people who want to keep all<br />

of their eBay orders, both<br />

incoming and outgoing,<br />

in one place: tinyurl.com/<br />

lkla8no. It scans your Gmail<br />

inbox for emails from eBay<br />

that contain the subject line<br />

shipped” or “order” and then<br />

automatically logs them in<br />

a Google spreadsheet. It’s a<br />

useful tool if you’re juggling<br />

multiple eBay transactions<br />

every week.<br />

MASTER<br />

YOUR MUSIC<br />

COLLECTION<br />

3 applets<br />

Spotify subscribers will be<br />

familiar with the often brilliant<br />

Discover Weekly playlist, an<br />

automatically generated two<br />

hours of new tracks every<br />

week that’s personalised<br />

to your music tastes. The<br />

problem is that every<br />

Monday that list regenerates,<br />

meaning it’s easy to lose<br />

that great track you<br />

listened to in the car last<br />

week. The following applet<br />

automatically creates a<br />

Discover Weekly archive<br />

playlist, meaning that all<br />

the tracks curated by Spotify<br />

are retained for future<br />

listening: tinyurl.com/<br />

ml9so6h.<br />

There’s a<br />

similar service for<br />

the Release Radar<br />

playlist, too: tinyurl.<br />

com/ltsylfc.<br />

Do you have<br />

Spotify playing in<br />

the office? Want<br />

to alert colleagues<br />

every time you’ve<br />

found a banging<br />

new tune? This<br />

is a very clever<br />

applet that sends<br />

a message to a<br />

specific Slack<br />

channel every<br />

time you add a<br />

song to a specified Spotify playlist.<br />

So you could have an #OfficeTunes<br />

Slack channel that’s updated with<br />

everyone’s recommendations, for<br />

instance. The applet can be found<br />

here: tinyurl.com/lejv8u4.<br />

STOP THE PIPES<br />

FREEZING!<br />

5 applets<br />

Anyone who uses a garden office or works<br />

from the conservatory will know that, no<br />

matter how good the insulation, the office<br />

will take a good hour or more to warm up on<br />

a cold winter’s morning. IFTTT can help you<br />

avoid an unwanted morning chill.<br />

The Weather Underground channel<br />

lets you set alerts based on the current<br />

temperature in your region. Consequently,<br />

if the mercury dips below, say 5°C, you can<br />

set IFTTT to switch on the heater connected<br />

to your WeMo smart plug or even your Nest<br />

thermostat. You’ll need to create the applets<br />

yourself, using the Weather Underground<br />

channel (ifttt.com/weather) and whatever<br />

smart plug/thermostat device you use.<br />

There are several from which you can<br />

choose.If you want something a little more<br />

low-tech, you can set Weather Underground<br />

to email you in advance if it’s going to rain<br />

tomorrow, or to automatically add a weather<br />

forecast to your Google Calendar at 6am<br />

every day (tinyurl.com/labj7p2). At the<br />

other extreme, you can get mobile alerts if<br />

the pollen count forecast is high (tinyurl.<br />

com/mn6e2uu), or the forecast UV index<br />

carries a high risk of sunburn, giving you<br />

time to slap some suncream on the kids<br />

before school (tinyurl.com/kyc2y8j).


MAKE ALEXA EVEN SMARTER 6 applets<br />

Amazon’s Alexa has taken homes<br />

by storm, either via Amazon’s<br />

own range of speakers or thirdparty<br />

products. However, the<br />

range of devices and services<br />

that Alexa plays nicely<br />

with by default is pretty<br />

limited. IFTTT provides<br />

the bridge between Alexa<br />

and a whole host of other<br />

smart home devices and<br />

services.<br />

First, a warning. Alexa<br />

support on IFTTT still<br />

seems patchy. We couldn’t<br />

get any of these services<br />

to work on one of our test<br />

devices, and readers have<br />

reported similar problems. It<br />

seems there are still kinks to<br />

be worked out. However, we’re<br />

assured that all of the following<br />

do work in some instances,<br />

meaning it’s a case of suck it and<br />

see.<br />

If you’re constantly asking Alexa<br />

to add items to your to-do list, you<br />

might be frustrated that it doesn’t<br />

integrate nicely with your chosen<br />

to-do list app: only Any.do and<br />

Todoist are supported by Amazon<br />

itself. With IFTTT, Alexa todos<br />

can be synced to Google<br />

Calendar (tinyurl.com/lc9jx5t) ,<br />

Wunderlist (tinyurl.com/kat97kw)<br />

and Evernote (tinyurl.com/<br />

lv6c6qp), among other services.<br />

Other smart home devices<br />

can also get the voice-control<br />

treatment. This applet (tinyurl.<br />

com/k77jdzb) lets you tell Alexa<br />

the precise temperature for your<br />

Nest thermostat; this one lets you<br />

switch off the Hue lights at bedtime<br />

(tinyurl.com/kzt6u7h); and if you<br />

have all the correct components,<br />

telling Alexa to “trigger lock-down”<br />

will switch off your Hue lights, shut<br />

your garage door and silence your<br />

Android phone with this recipe<br />

(tinyurl.com/mcvzchf).<br />

We suggest you test Alexa/<br />

IFTTT integration with some free<br />

software services before investing<br />

in any smart home hardware,<br />

however.<br />

MAKE A BUTTON 2 applets<br />

One of the newer features of IFTTT is<br />

the ability to create your own “buttons”<br />

on both smartphones and tablets.<br />

These buttons appear in the form of<br />

widgets (or icons) on your Android or<br />

iOS device’s homescreen, letting you<br />

perform reasonably complex tasks at,<br />

well, the press of a button.<br />

There’s a wide selection of pre-built<br />

button applets that you can use, once<br />

you’ve installed the IFTTT mobile app<br />

on your device. You can, for example,<br />

track the number of hours you’ve spent<br />

working on a spreadsheet (handy for<br />

billing purposes) by simply pressing the<br />

button when you start, and again when<br />

you clock-off (tinyurl.com/mntvvk3).<br />

Another sneaky option for Android<br />

users is the ability to press a button<br />

to make your phone ring, helping you<br />

get out of an awkward water-cooler<br />

conversation in the office, or escape<br />

when the Jehovah’s Witnesses come<br />

knocking at your front door (tinyurl.<br />

com/mgta945).<br />

However, the buttons are best<br />

deployed with your own recipes. We’ve<br />

set one up to send a text message<br />

saying “I’m on my way home” to the<br />

other half, for example, effectively<br />

creating an SMS macro. You could use<br />

a button to toggle a smart plug, switch<br />

lights on or off, or let your team know<br />

you’ve arrived in the office by posting<br />

a message to a Slack channel. The<br />

possibilities are almost endless.<br />

EMERGENCY<br />

SERVICES<br />

3 applets<br />

IFTTT isn’t all about showing off and<br />

convenience – it can actually be of genuine<br />

assistance in emergencies, too. A common<br />

mini-crisis can be averted by the applet that<br />

automatically sends a text message to your<br />

significant other if your phone battery is<br />

running low, for example, potentially avoiding<br />

a panic when they keep getting your voicemail.<br />

Thankfully, the applet (tinyurl.com/mxzrpcn)<br />

lets you edit the message sent, so you don’t<br />

have to use the decidedly cheesy: “Hi babe,<br />

this is an automated text letting you know my<br />

phone battery is almost dead.”<br />

If you have a Nest Protect smoke detector in<br />

your home, you’re probably already set up to<br />

receive phone messages if the device detects a<br />

fire while you’re out. But what if you’re away<br />

on holiday? With IFTTT, a Nest smoke alert can<br />

be used to send a text message to a friendly<br />

neighbour, who can perhaps enter the house<br />

and check if it’s a false alarm. The applet is here:<br />

tinyurl.com/lpfqvnz.<br />

How about deterring burglars? Owners of<br />

the Ring doorbell can already answer their door<br />

remotely, but it won’t be long before thieves get<br />

wise to smart doorbells and chance their arm<br />

anyway. But what if pressing the Ring doorbell<br />

also switched on a light in the hallway? That<br />

might be enough to convince a potential thief<br />

you’re home after all. There’s a recipe for Ring<br />

doorbells and WeMo light switches at tinyurl.<br />

com/lpdkxgw, with options for other smart<br />

home solutions such as Philips Hue.<br />

42 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


DO MORE, WORK LESS FEATURE<br />

GO WITH THE MICROSOFT FLOW<br />

Microsoft’s IFTTT rival may be the new kid on the block, but it has much to offer<br />

A<br />

s the name suggests, Microsoft Flow<br />

aims to smooth the automation of<br />

tasks, streamline communication<br />

between apps and, most importantly, make<br />

power users’ lives easier – without the need<br />

for time-consuming scripting.<br />

Released to take on established services<br />

such as IFTTT and Zapier, Microsoft Flow is<br />

designed to be implemented in businesses<br />

of all sizes. It can, therefore, automate<br />

jobs involving a wide range of services<br />

(110 to be precise), including big names<br />

such as SharePoint, Office 365, OneDrive,<br />

Dropbox, Gmail, Google Drive, MailChimp,<br />

Slack, Todoist, Twitter, Facebook, Pinterest<br />

and Instagram, as well as comparatively<br />

obscure choices such as Toodledo,<br />

Typeform, SendGrid and Redmine.<br />

As with IFTTT, you can create your own<br />

applets, unappealingly called “Flows”, by<br />

picking from a dropdown list of services<br />

and “triggers” (for instance, when a file<br />

is created in Dropbox) to put together a<br />

flow diagram of actions and conditions.<br />

To begin, head to flow.microsoft.com, sign<br />

up, click on the My Flows tab and select the<br />

“Create a Flow from blank” box. After that,<br />

sign in to your chosen services and get<br />

cracking.<br />

That said, while the process may sound<br />

intuitive and simple, in practice Flows<br />

can be somewhat buggy and sometimes<br />

leave you scratching your head – an issue<br />

compounded by the lack of advice on the<br />

website.<br />

Don’t despair: there’s a truckload of<br />

ready-made templates to save the day.<br />

Some are less useful than others, but they<br />

can be an invaluable resource for doing<br />

those small, annoying chores that eat into<br />

your day. For example, Microsoft Flow can<br />

create Google Calendar notifications for<br />

Slack, track your working hours, and let<br />

you know when your boss is trying to get<br />

in touch.<br />

Moreover, the free version of Flow is<br />

generous – 750 automations per month and<br />

unlimited Flow creation – although some<br />

services are locked off to non-premium<br />

users. The paid plan, which starts at US$5<br />

per user per month for 4,500 automations,<br />

contains Salesforce, Bitbucket, Eventbrite,<br />

Harvest, FreshBooks, Stripe and more.<br />

We’ve skimmed the cream of Flow’s<br />

template crop to help you forget about<br />

mundane digital tasks and focus on the<br />

important stuff.<br />

ABOVE: To create your<br />

own Flow, pick and mix<br />

from the list of services<br />

and triggers<br />

TOP RIGHT: There’s<br />

a wide selection of<br />

useful ready-baked<br />

templates to choose<br />

from<br />

RIGHT: The services<br />

that integrate with<br />

Microsoft Flow include<br />

most of the big names,<br />

as well as less wellknown<br />

choices<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 43


NEVER MISS AN EMAIL FROM YOUR BOSS 4 applets<br />

Have you ever missed a deadline because an email from<br />

your boss got lost in your cluttered inbox? Well, there’s<br />

a Flow for that (tinyurl.com/lqxlwrw). Working with<br />

Office 365’s Outlook and the Flow app, the template<br />

sends you a push notification every time your boss<br />

(or another VIP) sends you an email, meaning you can<br />

respond promptly and garner brownie points. No wonder<br />

it’s the fourth most used applet on the site.<br />

If you want to make doubly sure that nothing slips<br />

under the radar, Microsoft has crafted an applet (tinyurl.<br />

com/losey9u) that sends you a text when your boss gets<br />

in touch. The Flow utilises Twilio – a platform that uses<br />

web service APIs to send and receive SMS messages<br />

– meaning you can quickly hurry back from lunch to<br />

polish off that last-minute report. Speaking of which,<br />

there’s also a template that automatically saves Outlook.<br />

com attachments to a Google Drive folder (tinyurl.com/<br />

lzceudj), so you can plunge straight in.<br />

If that wasn’t enough, you can even instruct<br />

Microsoft Flow to notify you if the language in your<br />

boss’ missive is very negative: for example, “Why<br />

haven’t you brought me a coffee yet? You’re fired! :(”. The<br />

template (tinyurl.com/lq7h45f) uses “text analytics” to<br />

examine the content of the email, effectively giving you<br />

advance notice when bad news is on its way.<br />

COLLECT DATA FROM SOCIAL MEDIA 6 applets<br />

Keeping track of what people are saying<br />

about your company on social media<br />

can be difficult. Luckily, Microsoft Flow<br />

simplifies the process with a selection<br />

of handy tools that will alert you to<br />

mentions, store information, and provide<br />

a “troll warning”.<br />

First, you can choose to be alerted via<br />

email when a specific user – be they an<br />

important client, firm or even a celebrity<br />

– sends a tweet (tinyurl.com/kku7wzx).<br />

This applet is particularly useful for very<br />

active or popular Twitter profiles, saving<br />

you the hassle of wading through a long<br />

list of notifications or hashtags.<br />

Looking for a more user-friendly<br />

way of storing and reusing your<br />

Instagram snaps? There’s a Flow to help<br />

(tinyurl.com/mk4blop): the template<br />

automatically saves an image to a<br />

specific Google Drive folder when you<br />

post it on Instagram, avoiding the need<br />

to laboriously re-upload it.<br />

For a wider insight into how your<br />

product, service or campaign is being<br />

received on Twitter, use the “Log the<br />

latest tweets about your product in<br />

Excel” template (tinyurl.com/kt549yr).<br />

This records the tweet content,<br />

author, date sent and even the number<br />

of times it’s been retweeted in a<br />

spreadsheet. To get started, create an<br />

Excel file on your favoured cloud<br />

storage platform, follow the column<br />

instructions, set the keyword you wish<br />

to track, and watch the praise roll in.<br />

Similar tools exist for Facebook (tinyurl.<br />

com/k6jl8ba) and Instagram (tinyurl.<br />

com/m47jdl9).<br />

You can also be notified when someone<br />

is less than complimentary about a<br />

keyword – a kind of “troll klaxon”. The<br />

Flow (tinyurl.com/lkbktn3), which uses<br />

the Cognitive Services Text Analytics<br />

API, will detect a negative comment,<br />

translate it if necessary, and send a push<br />

notification to your Android or iOS device<br />

with a link to the tweet.


DO MORE, WORK LESS FEATURE<br />

MANAGE YOUR CALENDAR<br />

7 applets<br />

Keeping your digital calendar up to date can be a mind-numbing<br />

slog, fraught with potential pitfalls such as forgetting to jot<br />

down an important meeting, arrangements getting lost in<br />

the digital ether, and selecting the wrong day. Fortunately,<br />

Microsoft has constructed an assortment of Flow templates<br />

to lend you a helping hand when keeping on top of your<br />

commitments.<br />

A common business bugbear is that people or companies have<br />

multiple calendars on different platforms, ramping up the risk of<br />

double-booking. Don’t be one of them: using an applet, you can<br />

share events across Google Calendar and Outlook.com (tinyurl.<br />

com/lx23l4c), as well as between Google Calendar and Office 365<br />

(tinyurl.com/k2qsfv5).<br />

However, the Flows aren’t limited to just Google Calendar<br />

and Outlook: there are also applets that post in a Slack channel<br />

of your choice when a meeting is about to begin (tinyurl.com/<br />

mz58do5), create events for Todoist items (pcpro.link/273todo),<br />

open up a calendar task in Wunderlist (tinyurl.com/m7gbgk3),<br />

extract a deadline from a Trello card (tinyurl.com/lgryvxv), and<br />

automatically generate a OneNote page for a meeting (tinyurl.<br />

com/lx533s3) so you have somewhere to take notes.<br />

KEEP ON TOP OF<br />

SHAREPOINT<br />

7 applets<br />

As you’d expect, Microsoft Flow integrates<br />

well with SharePoint – the firm’s document<br />

storage and management app – offering an<br />

assortment of nifty reminders, alerts and<br />

time-savers that run in the background.<br />

First, there’s the ability to send a<br />

customised email to yourself or someone<br />

else whenever an item is added to a specific<br />

SharePoint list (tinyurl.com/ldk5s62),<br />

meaning there are no nasty surprises when<br />

you next peruse the archive. It’s a very neat<br />

utility – and the third most popular applet.<br />

Moreover, you can order Flow to notify you<br />

when a SharePoint item is modified via email<br />

(tinyurl.com/mxhbhhb) or Slack (tinyurl.<br />

com/mevycql), as well as easily copy files<br />

between SharePoint and Dropbox (tinyurl.<br />

com/krcz792), Box (tinyurl.com/k6ooxto),<br />

Google Drive (tinyurl.com/k4t94p4) and your<br />

Windows <strong>PC</strong> (tinyurl.com/mpxyq4h).<br />

PUSH FLOW’S BUTTONS 7 applets<br />

Like IFTTT, Microsoft Flow has reduced a<br />

number of tasks to a simple button press<br />

on your iOS or Android mobile device – and<br />

offers the opportunity to build your own.<br />

The pre-baked Flow templates include<br />

simple buttons for setting a reminder<br />

in ten minutes (tinyurl.com/klk8ryu),<br />

checking the weather (tinyurl.com/<br />

lr49ekw), and being emailed your own<br />

coordinates (tinyurl.com/lahw537), in<br />

case you’re being chased by a bear in<br />

the Tunbridge Wells wilderness (see<br />

screengrabs below).<br />

The more complex one-press actions<br />

include sending a simple “I’m working from<br />

home” email to your manager (tinyurl.<br />

com/kd8rrxw), tracking your working<br />

hours in an Excel spreadsheet (tinyurl.<br />

com/ksvwu3f), letting colleagues know<br />

that you’re ill (tinyurl.com/mpey7n3), and<br />

texting a contact that you’re late for a<br />

meeting (tinyurl.com/khwuesz).<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 45


ZAP YOUR WORKFLOW INTO LIFE<br />

With its built-in applets and Chrome extension, Zapier is a godsend for busy users<br />

implicity is the name of the game<br />

with Zapier. Released in 2012, the<br />

Sautomation service has become the<br />

go-to alternative to IFTTT, being rightly<br />

lauded for its clarity, ease of use and huge<br />

selection of apps.<br />

While Microsoft Flow can often feel<br />

unwieldy, Zapier – according to its<br />

website – wants to “empower businesses<br />

everywhere to create processes and<br />

systems that let computers do what they<br />

are best at doing and let humans do what<br />

they are best at doing”. It’s an admirable<br />

ambition that’s reflected in the speed with<br />

which its applet templates – satisfyingly<br />

called “Zaps” – can be modified: providing<br />

you’re signed up with the necessary web<br />

apps, the process can take under a minute.<br />

It’s really that simple.<br />

As with both IFTTT and Flow, you can<br />

also create your own Zaps from scratch.<br />

To begin, sign up at zapier.com and click<br />

the unmissable bright orange “Make a<br />

Zap!” button. You can then construct a<br />

recipe from a list of apps, triggers and<br />

actions, testing each stage as you go<br />

along to ensure that nothing goes awry –<br />

a useful fail-safe tool.<br />

And the list of supported apps<br />

is vast, with over 750 services<br />

to choose from. Apart from the<br />

usual suspects such as Gmail,<br />

Google Drive, Slack, Twitter,<br />

Facebook, WordPress, LinkedIn<br />

and so on, Zapier offers a<br />

selection of its own built-in “By<br />

Zapier” applets for, among other<br />

things, formatting, scheduling,<br />

parsing emails, coding and<br />

receiving SMS messages.<br />

All sound too good to be true?<br />

Well, the free version of Zapier<br />

is rather limited, restricting you<br />

to just 100 tasks per month and<br />

five Zaps at a time. Moreover,<br />

Zaps in the free plan can only<br />

work in 15-minute blocks – so<br />

if an applet springs to life at<br />

9am, you can’t run another until<br />

9.15. Naturally, these figures increase<br />

incrementally as you work up through the<br />

paid plans, which range from US$20 to a<br />

whopping US$250 per month for 50,000<br />

tasks.<br />

We’ve sifted through the hundreds of<br />

Zap templates to pick out the ones that<br />

TOP To begin crafting your own Zap, select a<br />

trigger app and set up an action<br />

ABOVE The choice of support apps is absolutely<br />

huge – over 750 by our reckoning – and includes<br />

crowd-pleasers such as Facebook and Gmail<br />

will become invisible digital butlers,<br />

working behind the scenes to make your<br />

life easier.<br />

GROW YOUR<br />

LINKEDIN<br />

AUDIENCE<br />

3 applets<br />

LinkedIn can often be treated as<br />

something of an afterthought, as less<br />

important than Facebook or Twitter,<br />

but keeping your business or personal<br />

profile updated with new content is key.<br />

Fortunately, there’s a range of Zaps to<br />

help keep your LinkedIn spick and span –<br />

and grow your audience.<br />

You can set WordPress posts to<br />

hit LinkedIn (tinyurl.com/lda3yb4),<br />

removing the need to copy and paste a<br />

link. To make life even simpler, there’s<br />

also an applet for sharing Twitter posts<br />

from a profile to LinkedIn (tinyurl.com/<br />

l9umjga).<br />

Another useful Zap integrates with<br />

Google Sheets, so you can post Google<br />

Slides presentations – be they about<br />

a new product or even a rebrand – to<br />

your firm’s LinkedIn page (tinyurl.<br />

com/k8znj8v). Simply update a row on<br />

Google Sheets<br />

and Zapier will<br />

find the relevant<br />

presentation on<br />

Google Slides.<br />

KEEP ON TOP OF<br />

FORMATTING<br />

3 applets<br />

Zapier’s own Formatter service irons out<br />

potential formatting issues between<br />

web apps, making sure that nothing is<br />

lost in translation between, for example,<br />

OneNote and Google Drive.<br />

For example, do you find yourself<br />

jotting down a note or idea in OneNote<br />

and then completely forgetting about<br />

it? If so, there’s a Zap (tinyurl.com/<br />

ml9fyrw) that will automatically create<br />

a Wunderlist task whenever a new note<br />

is added, preventing anything from<br />

slipping through the cracks.<br />

Similarly, if you use both Microsoft<br />

OneNote and Evernote, a Zap that<br />

shares data between the platforms is<br />

essential (tinyurl.com/myyxbq2). Every<br />

time a new note is added to a section<br />

in OneNote, it will pass over the title to<br />

Evernote – so you don’t have to enter the<br />

same data twice and can work across<br />

the apps.Another useful formatting<br />

time-saver is that, if you regularly post<br />

on a WordPress site, you can set up a<br />

Zap that immediately posts the link to<br />

Facebook with a shortened URL (tinyurl.<br />

com/nysocsb). It’s an easy way of keeping<br />

PUSH IT REAL GOOD<br />

3 applets<br />

Another of Zapier’s built-in apps, Push,<br />

reduces sometimes complicated tasks to<br />

a couple of clicks of its Chrome extension.<br />

For instance, you can add a text note to<br />

E vernote (tinyurl.com/m8phsxr), send<br />

yourself an email (tinyurl.com/lxokpfm),<br />

and quickly add a Google Calendar event<br />

(tinyurl.com/m7bf3mf) from a box in the<br />

browser.<br />

46 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


DO MORE, WORK LESS FEATURE<br />

DIGEST<br />

SOCIAL MEDIA<br />

1 applet<br />

If, like most of us, you don’t have a dedicated<br />

marketing team managing your social media<br />

and profiling new followers, Digest by Zapier<br />

is here to help. Working on either a daily,<br />

weekly or monthly basis, the Zap (pcpro.<br />

link/273digest) sends you a summary of<br />

your new Twitter followers via Slack, giving<br />

you an overview of who is interested in your<br />

business (or just you).<br />

QUICKLY ADD<br />

CONTACTS<br />

1 applet<br />

If your job involves coming into contact with a<br />

lot of new people, it’s worth investing in a Zap<br />

that allows you to speedily add new entries<br />

to Google Contacts (tinyurl.com/kwjk3lc). To<br />

do so, create a Google Sheet, enable the Zap,<br />

and every time you add or update a row with<br />

a name, email address and telephone number,<br />

Zapier will create a new Google Contact. It’s<br />

handy when you’re copying over large blocks of<br />

data.<br />

DELAY<br />

2 applets<br />

Picture the scene: you’re snowed<br />

under with a project ,or nearing a<br />

deadline, but keep getting distracted<br />

by less important things or wellmeaning<br />

colleagues. Sound familiar?<br />

Luckily, another of Zapier’s homemade<br />

apps is here to help: Delay. It’s an<br />

uncomplicated tool that works via a<br />

Google Chrome extension, allowing<br />

you to quickly prioritise time-sensitive<br />

tasks and put others on the back<br />

burner.<br />

First, using the Zapier Chrome<br />

extension and Slack, you can type in a<br />

message or job for your future self (for<br />

example, “feed the cat” or “remember<br />

to make lots of money”), set a delay<br />

and receive a Slack notification when<br />

the deadline expires (tinyurl.com/<br />

kpjdxjv). Think of it as a trusty digital<br />

Post-it note.<br />

Another Zap allows you to enter a<br />

note into the extension and then, after<br />

a delay, receive a reminder via SMS<br />

(tinyurl.com/lnpubls).<br />

ALWAYS BE AHEAD<br />

OF SCHEDULE<br />

4 applets<br />

Zapier offers a range of scheduling applets<br />

that take the pressure off and automate timeconsuming<br />

daily tasks.<br />

First, you can set Gmail to automatically<br />

fire off daily emails to yourself or others<br />

(tinyurl.com/kw77kav). It’s an excellent<br />

way of sending out reminders, sharing new<br />

information, and managing your firm’s<br />

workflow. You can also command Zapier to<br />

create a new Evernote note every morning<br />

(tinyurl.com/kpgofvs), and send an SMS to<br />

yourself at a certain time every day (tinyurl.<br />

com/m9zda8f).<br />

Lastly, and perhaps least usefully, there’s<br />

even a Zap that triggers a random “Good<br />

morning” GIF in your #general Slack channel<br />

at 8am every morning (tinyurl.com/mokaelg).<br />

So you can begin the day as you mean to go on…<br />

If something catches your eye while browsing, open the<br />

Chrome extension and type a note into the box<br />

Using Push by Zapier; the reminder can then be sent to your<br />

Gmail email<br />

A very simple Zap allows you to enter a note into the Zapier<br />

Chrome extension and then, after a delay of your choice,<br />

receive a timely reminder via SMS<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 47


IN THE LABS<br />

Our reviews are our pride, and our joy<br />

Testing times<br />

BENNETT RING EXPLAINS OUR UPDATED TESTING PROCESS THAT WE USE FOR MAINLY FOR GPUS AND CPUS<br />

We’re updating all of our benchmarks with<br />

the exception of the ever-reliable 3DMark.<br />

We’re sticking with 3DMark because it’s the<br />

most widely acknowledged, independent<br />

benchmark on the planet. While certain<br />

game engines are built closely with the<br />

assistance from AMD or Nvidia, 3DMark is<br />

built to give neither vendor an advantage.<br />

It’s been in use for over 15 years, and is<br />

built by a team who strive for one thing<br />

– repeatable, accurate tests that are as<br />

scientifically accurate as possible.<br />

The next test on our list is Rise of the<br />

Tomb Raider. We chose this test for several<br />

reasons. Firstly, it now officially supports<br />

DirectX12, an area that is becoming more<br />

important in the coming years. Secondly,<br />

it’s very GPU-centric when set to Ultra,<br />

with dozens of different shaders that tax<br />

GPUs incredibly. Finally, there are three<br />

built-in benchmarks, but we only use the<br />

result from the Geothermal Valley test,<br />

to keep things simple. We run the test<br />

three times, and then average the result.<br />

We also disable the Purehair technology<br />

included in the game that was built for<br />

AMD products, as this would put Nvidia<br />

products at a disadvantage.<br />

One game that is fantastic for putting<br />

CPUs through their paces is Total War:<br />

Warhammer. The Built-in Benchmarking<br />

feature contains hundreds of individual<br />

units, each with their own unique AI<br />

running. When lowering the GPU-intensive<br />

settings in the incredibly detailed options<br />

menu, we can put all of the load on the<br />

CPU, which is why you’ll see some very<br />

interesting results in the following<br />

benchmarks. It also has beta DX12 support,<br />

rounding out our reasons for making this<br />

our third benchmark. Like Rise of the Tomb<br />

Raider, we run it three times and average<br />

the result.<br />

Our final pick of the bunch is the latest<br />

in the Tom Clancy Ghost Recon series,<br />

Wildlands. Firstly, because it’s utterly<br />

beautiful. The huge amount of detail<br />

spreads across massive draw distances<br />

makes it one of the most demanding games<br />

currently on the market. By fiddling with<br />

the settings, we can put the strain on<br />

either the CPU or the GPU, or both. Again,<br />

we run the test three times to get the<br />

average score, as there is a slight amount<br />

of variance between each run.<br />

We also have a variety of other<br />

benchmarks up our sleeves for testing<br />

other components, such as Wi-Fi<br />

performance or SSD performance,<br />

including but not limited to SiSoft Sandra,<br />

Zoltán Pallagi’s WiFi Speed Test, and<br />

CrystalDiskMark. However, you’ll see the<br />

above four tests most commonly used.<br />

Note that we also reboot the <strong>PC</strong> between<br />

each and every benchmark, as well as<br />

update Windows and the graphics drivers<br />

prior to testing; this is why we have to<br />

retest older samples in comparison to new<br />

products, as driver improvements can<br />

change their performance over time (in<br />

some AMD cases, by up to 20%).<br />

So there you have it – our new range of<br />

cutting edge benchmarks. All designed to<br />

help us help you make the right buying<br />

decisions for your gear.<br />

PIONEER<br />

DREAMVISION<br />

58<br />

ASUS<br />

FX553VD<br />

59<br />

NETGEAR<br />

AC5300<br />

57<br />

EDITORlAL & PRODUCT SUBMISSION: <strong>PC</strong> & <strong>Tech</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> welcomes all information on new and upgraded products and services for possible coverage within the news or reviews pages. However, we respectfully point out that the magazine is not<br />

obliged to either review or return unsolicited products. Products not picked up within six months of submission will be used or donated to charity. The Editor is always pleased to receive ideas for articles, preferably sent in outline form, with details of author’s<br />

background, and – where available – samples of previously published work. We cannot, however, accept responsibility for unsolicited copy and would like to stress that it may take time for a reply to be sent out.<br />

WHAT OUR A-LIST MEANS WHAT OUR AWARDS MEAN WHAT OUR RATINGS MEAN<br />

Our A-List award is<br />

reserved for the best<br />

products in each category<br />

we review. With a winner<br />

and an alternative pick in<br />

each, that’s 92 products<br />

you know are first class.<br />

48 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

<strong>PC</strong> & <strong>Tech</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>’s<br />

comprehensive Real World<br />

testing sorts out the best<br />

products from the pack. Any<br />

product recommended by <strong>PC</strong><br />

& <strong>Tech</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> is well above<br />

average for features, value for<br />

money and performance.<br />

VERY POOR<br />

POOR<br />

ORDINARY<br />

VERY GOOD<br />

OUTSTANDING<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5


INTRO REVIEWS<br />

HOW WE TEST<br />

Our benchmarking tests are the best in the<br />

business. Read on to find how they work…<br />

2D TESTS<br />

Desktop <strong>PC</strong>s and laptops are tested using our own custom<br />

bench testing suite, which has been carefully designed to<br />

test all aspects of a system and rate them in a way that’s<br />

useful to you. Our benchtesting cover three main tests: a<br />

typical video editing test, a demanding 4K video editing<br />

test and a multitasking test that stresses all aspects of the<br />

system. We look at the time it takes for each test to run,<br />

which is then compared to our reference <strong>PC</strong> to produce a<br />

normalised result. This score is shown on a graph, and to<br />

help you understand just where the <strong>PC</strong> we’re reviewing<br />

sits in the grand scheme of things, we will often include<br />

other system’s scores.<br />

<strong>PC</strong>&TA LABS BENCHTEST <strong>PC</strong><br />

Intel Core i7-7700 CPU; 16GB of Corsair Vengeance LPX DDR4<br />

RAM; ASRock Fatal1ty Z270 Gaming K6 motherboard; Corsair<br />

Neutron XT SSD<br />

On occasion we will run publically available bench testing<br />

software, predominantly <strong>PC</strong>Mark 8 from Futuremark.<br />

This is run in the Home setting, in Accelerated mode. You<br />

can get <strong>PC</strong>Mark 8 as well as 3DMark (below) from www.<br />

futuremark.com<br />

3D TESTS<br />

For video cards, as well as Integrated Graphics Processing<br />

Units, we use:<br />

• 3DMark Firestrike<br />

• Rise of the Tomb Raider<br />

• Total War: Warhammer<br />

• Ghost Recon Wildlands<br />

3DMark is designed specifically to test video cards, and<br />

you can download and run the same tool as us to help you<br />

gauge where your own GPU ranks compared to what we<br />

are reviewing.<br />

The games were selected because they are relatively<br />

well balanced in performance between AMD and Nvidia,<br />

favouring neither. Rise of the Tomb Raider supports DX12.<br />

Ghost Recon Wildlands is a cutting edge 3D engine and<br />

can be optimised to stress either the CPU or GPU, while<br />

Total War: Warhammer is particularly good at stressing<br />

CPUs, and has beta DX12 support.<br />

Tests are run using three resolution ranges, depending<br />

on where the GPU sits in the market:<br />

Entry level: 1920 x 1080<br />

Mid-range: 1920 x 1080 – 2560 x 1440<br />

High-end: 2560 x 4K<br />

BATTERY TESTS<br />

Screen brightness is set to 120cd/m2, playing a 720p video<br />

on loop until the device runs out of power.<br />

REVIEWS<br />

INTEL<br />

OPTANE<br />

50<br />

<strong>PC</strong>S & LAPTOPS<br />

HP Pavillion Wave .........................53<br />

Gigabyte Aero 15 ............................54<br />

Asus VC66R ....................................55<br />

Pioneer Dreamvision 32” AIO<br />

<strong>PC</strong>7X ..................................................58<br />

Asus FX553VD ...............................59<br />

PERIPHERALS<br />

Netgear AD7200 ...........................56<br />

Netgear AC5300 ........................... 57<br />

Netgear S8000 media switch . 60<br />

Oculus Touch Controller ..............61<br />

GAMES<br />

Prey ................................................... 88<br />

Endless Space 2 ........................... 90<br />

HANDHELDS<br />

Apple iPhone SE ........................... 68<br />

Google Nexus 5X.......................... 69<br />

LG G4 ................................................70<br />

Motorola Moto G4 ........................ 72<br />

Motorola Moto G5 ........................ 73<br />

Motorola Moto Z Play .................. 74<br />

Oneplus 3T......................................76<br />

Samsung Galaxy A5 .....................77<br />

Samsung Galaxy A6 ....................78<br />

Samsung Galaxy S7 .....................79<br />

Sony Xperia X Compact ............ 80<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 49


Intel Optane<br />

Memory 32GB<br />

INTEL USHERS IN THE NEWEST TYPE OF DATA STORAGE IN<br />

OVER THIRTY YEARS, MARK WILLIAMS TAKES IT FOR A SPIN<br />

emory. Whether volatile or<br />

non-volatile, every computing<br />

M device needs some. From your<br />

bedside clock, to your car, microwave,<br />

smartwatch, phone and of course<br />

computer. Whether it’s to save your data,<br />

preferences, or to simply load basic<br />

operating code when powered on so the<br />

device knows how to work and behave<br />

to inputs, it’s necessary to our modern<br />

daily lives.<br />

Interestingly all of these devices use<br />

some form of storage first invented<br />

between thirty-three and seventy years<br />

ago! RAM has been around since the<br />

1940s, PROM the 1950s, SRAM and<br />

DRAM the 1960s, EPROM and lesser<br />

known bubble memory the 1970s, with<br />

NOR and NAND flash memories being<br />

the most recent from the 1980s.<br />

That’s right, the newest NVMe SSDs<br />

we love so much today has lineage going<br />

back over three decades. Current NAND<br />

based SSDs are great and the new NVMe<br />

protocol has helped to unleash this<br />

technology’s full potential, but the very<br />

nature of NAND flash memory has some<br />

innate problems. All of which come<br />

down to how data in NAND is stored.<br />

Intel and Micron teamed up in 2012<br />

to research and develop a new type of<br />

memory storage that removes the flaws<br />

that NAND flash has. What they came<br />

up with is something called 3D Xpoint<br />

(pronounced “crosspoint”).<br />

NAND FLASH REFRESHER<br />

Data is stored in NAND in a somewhat<br />

complex structure. Each physical NAND<br />

chip is logically divided into blocks, each<br />

containing pages, which in turn contains<br />

words which are a strings of several<br />

bits. To read a single bit of data, the<br />

chip needs to access the correct block,<br />

activate the page, target the correct<br />

word, activate the entire word then read<br />

the desired bit. When it comes to writing,<br />

things get more complicated. To write a<br />

single bit to a fresh unused NAND chip<br />

the drive controller needs to activate<br />

the pertinent block, then write the entire<br />

page including all words and bits to be<br />

contained within at once. This might be<br />

a surprise but NAND flash isn’t directly<br />

re-writeable. Whole pages must be first<br />

erased before the page and anything<br />

within it can be written to or updated.<br />

So, if you want to overwrite a single bit or<br />

word in an already used page the entire<br />

page needs to be read into the drive<br />

controllers memory temporarily, the<br />

whole page erased, the new data added/<br />

altered in the controller’s memory before<br />

the page then gets written back in its<br />

entirety to the chip.<br />

Therefore, read speeds are always<br />

faster than writes on NAND flash and<br />

is why TRIM was introduced early on to<br />

effectively self-defrag pages so whole<br />

clean pages are available to write<br />

without incurring the time penalty of<br />

reading to controller memory first and<br />

processing delay. It’s also why write<br />

amplification is a problem, with a finite<br />

number of erasures per bit before failure,<br />

just to re-write a single bit you must use<br />

an erasure cycle on all bits within the<br />

same page, wasting time and life span<br />

on bits you don’t want to touch.<br />

HOW 3D XPOINT WORKS<br />

Firstly, 3D Xpoint really is 3D, unlike 3D<br />

NAND or V-NAND as Samsung likes to<br />

call it which is just layers of 2D NAND<br />

stacked on top of each other allowing for<br />

denser packaging. In Xpoint wires form<br />

Optane’s internal structure is a true 3D lattice<br />

50 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


COMPONENTS REVIEWS<br />

a criss-cross lattice above and below a<br />

bulk material, with the top wires of the<br />

first layer acting as the bottom wires of<br />

the second layer. Increasing capacity can<br />

simply mean adding more layers on top.<br />

The advantage of this criss-cross<br />

wiring pattern is that is allows bit<br />

level access. Activate a wire and the<br />

associated cross wire above or below<br />

to access a single bit of storage. It’s that<br />

simple. This is why Xpoint is proving<br />

to be more than just mass<br />

storage. The simplicity of this<br />

design means the controller<br />

has far less work to do, greatly<br />

reducing response times. With<br />

no transistors required per cell<br />

Xpoint has roughly four times<br />

the density of DRAM, and due to the<br />

bit level access, write amplification is<br />

not an issue and is part of the reason<br />

why Xpoint has endurance ratings<br />

some threefold that of NAND at the<br />

same capacity. All this means Xpoint<br />

sits between DRAM and NAND in<br />

performance and effectively creates a<br />

new tier of storage/memory.<br />

OPTANE, INTEL’S FIRST XPOINT<br />

PRODUCTS<br />

Micron will be bringing Xpoint products<br />

to market soon too but Intel is the<br />

first from the partnership to release<br />

a product line dubbed Optane using<br />

this new technology. There’s only three<br />

products currently; the 375GB Optane<br />

DC P4800X <strong>PC</strong>IE card which is aimed<br />

solely at big data centres, and two<br />

Optane Memory products of 16GB and<br />

32GB capacities in the M.2 form factor<br />

using two <strong>PC</strong>IE 3.0 lanes.<br />

Intel isn’t letting tech reviewers get<br />

their hands on the P4800X yet, so we’ll<br />

make do with the consumer grade<br />

Optane Memory 32GB.<br />

OPTANE MEMORY<br />

Much like NAND SSDs in the early years<br />

when capacities were too small to<br />

be effectively used as a drive on their<br />

own, Optane Memory is likewise being<br />

marketed as drive caching devices to<br />

speed up hard drive usage. This didn’t<br />

“ Optane effectively creates a<br />

new tier of storage/memory<br />

performance”<br />

stop us running tests on the Optane<br />

Memory which when not configured as<br />

cache still shows as a normal storage<br />

device, to see what the underlying Xpoint<br />

technology is capable of on its own.<br />

Unfortunately, Optane Memory<br />

caching currently only works with the<br />

latest 200 series Intel motherboards<br />

paired with a 7th gen Core processor. We<br />

also had to update our test lab system’s<br />

BIOS to support Optane. On top of<br />

that the caching only works with the<br />

operating system drive, there’s no ability<br />

to choose which drive it caches.<br />

Setting up Optane Memory as a cache<br />

takes a little while but isn’t difficult.<br />

First make sure your OS drive is in AHCI<br />

mode, boot into Windows and install the<br />

Optane driver. The system restarts, sets<br />

the motherboard storage controller into<br />

a special Intel RST with Optane mode,<br />

then reboots into Windows. Part two<br />

of the setup formats the Optane drive<br />

ready for use, then reboots again. Before<br />

hitting the Windows welcome screen<br />

again Optane shows an enablement<br />

process (doesn’t happen with the<br />

smaller 16GB version). When that’s done<br />

you’re back to the desktop and ready to<br />

get going.<br />

Once activated we started to feel the<br />

caching influence. The Optane cache<br />

requires something to be run or accessed<br />

at least once to train it and start<br />

caching, so after launching programs or<br />

Windows a couple of times the<br />

speedup became noticeable.<br />

The Seagate 10TB hard drive we<br />

paired Optane with exhibited<br />

noticeably less disk thrashing<br />

when booting into Windows<br />

or loading a program. Not SSD<br />

levels of performance but the HDD was<br />

clearly getting a helping hand.<br />

RESULTS<br />

The start-up times graph shows what to<br />

expect when Optane Memory is paired<br />

with a hard drive. Windows booted 22%<br />

quicker, and with Anti-Virus and other<br />

services loading up in the background<br />

after that, Steam wound up auto<br />

launching some 28% faster too. Firefox<br />

with one hundred tabs open took the<br />

same amount of time to load the initial<br />

webpage on start (likely CPU limited)<br />

but waiting for Firefox to stop accessing<br />

the disk afterwards reduced by 14%.<br />

File access and game load times were<br />

impressively reduced too, with Ashes of<br />

the Singularity loading 44% quicker and<br />

waiting for Photoshop to start and load<br />

a 120MB 3D file was reduced by a most<br />

impressive 65%.<br />

Optane Memory caching clearly works<br />

well!<br />

At this stage Optane is being sold as a cache that sits between RAM and a HDD or SSD<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 51


REVIEWS COMPONENTS<br />

“Optane remains<br />

orders of magnitude<br />

more responsive and<br />

performant”<br />

But how does the underlying Xpoint<br />

perform compared to NAND? Digging<br />

into the graphs, with sequential reads<br />

Optane gets beaten simply because this<br />

product is hampered by only having two<br />

<strong>PC</strong>IE 3.0 lanes of connectivity versus<br />

the RD400 and 950 Pro’s four lanes.<br />

Sequential writes beat a heavily-used<br />

RD400 drive but gets slaughtered<br />

by a relatively unused 950 Pro drive.<br />

However, over time as the 950 Pro gets<br />

used that stat will decline down to<br />

nearer RD400 levels. Optane won’t.<br />

Once we go to random read/writes<br />

Optane starts to shine. With access<br />

times an order of magnitude faster<br />

than NAND, Optane blasts past the<br />

competition.<br />

NAND is great in straight line read/<br />

writes but once randomness kicks in<br />

(say as the drive gets filled) they slow<br />

down and is why the heavily used RD400<br />

shows some particularly bad write<br />

results compared to a near-fresh 950<br />

Pro.<br />

To illustrate this point, while<br />

duplicating over 14GB of 750,000 tiny<br />

files back onto each drive (so the drive<br />

is reading and writing already when<br />

the benchmark is run again), Optane<br />

remains orders of magnitude more<br />

responsive (ms) and performant<br />

(MB/s). Optane can multitask<br />

where NAND fears to tread.<br />

As a first product, the<br />

underlying 3D Xpoint tech<br />

is clearly already showing<br />

advantages over NAND.<br />

CONCLUSIONS<br />

So Optane Memory caching works<br />

well in making a HDD based <strong>PC</strong>s more<br />

responsive. However, there are some<br />

issues worth mentioning. The Optane<br />

driver cannot be uninstalled. Optane can<br />

be disabled afterwards but switching<br />

your storage controller back to AHCI<br />

causes Windows to not boot.<br />

While Optane caching was enabled<br />

we noticed the other NVME M.2 drive<br />

plugged into the system didn’t show as<br />

a device until the controller was reset to<br />

AHCI again.<br />

Every third boot or so caused<br />

the Optane drive to go through an<br />

“enablement” cycle before getting to<br />

Windows, adding another two minutes<br />

to the boot time, something the 16GB<br />

model apparently doesn’t suffer from.<br />

Finally, disabling Optane caching<br />

took some thirty minutes waiting for the<br />

drivers to finish the process.<br />

Optane Memory works, but with<br />

all these negatives it’s very hard to<br />

recommend its use. For laptops it’ll be<br />

great, paired with a HDD to get higher<br />

storage capacity and a more responsive<br />

system instead of a highly expensive high<br />

capacity NAND SSD. Low end desktops<br />

where money is of concern may also<br />

find Optane plus a HDD to be a good<br />

compromise.<br />

Outside of those situations it seems<br />

best to wait until larger Optane drives<br />

come and can be used as regular<br />

drives or the software integration gets<br />

better. For now, Optane Memory is very<br />

promising but this implementation of it is<br />

somewhat disappointing.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$129 • www.mwave.com.au<br />

32GB 8 M.2 • 2x 3.0 <strong>PC</strong>IE connectivity<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5


LAPTOPS & <strong>PC</strong>S REVIEWS<br />

HP<br />

Pavilion<br />

Wave<br />

600-a051a<br />

LOOKS GOOD FROM AFAR,<br />

BUT IS FAR FROM GOOD<br />

I<br />

f there’s another segment almost as<br />

popular as ultraportable convertibles,<br />

it’s mini-<strong>PC</strong>s. Both have been driven<br />

forth by the ever decreasing amount<br />

of power required by today’s CPUs, not<br />

to mention SSDs as small as a row of<br />

stamps. One of the more intriguing mini-<br />

<strong>PC</strong>s to cross our desk lately is the HP<br />

Pavilion Wave.<br />

The most interesting facet is the<br />

custom-case. It’s covered in ‘Audio fabric’,<br />

which makes it look more like a speaker<br />

than a <strong>PC</strong>. It’s also darned small, with<br />

a height of just 25.9cm, and a width of<br />

16.8cm. To be honest, it’s the sexiest,<br />

least-<strong>PC</strong> looking mini-computer we’ve<br />

ever seen. If only it wasn’t so damn slow…<br />

But before we get into the woeful<br />

performance, let’s take a closer look<br />

at that extraordinary design, which HP<br />

refers to as the ‘Tesla’ design. Thankfully<br />

HP has included a wireless mouse and<br />

keyboard with the <strong>PC</strong>, as the number of<br />

USB ports isn’t exactly prolific. There are<br />

twin USB 2.0, a single USB 3.0, and finally<br />

a USB 3.1 Type C on the rear of the case,<br />

along with a single USB 3.0 Type A on the<br />

front. There’s also a HP 3-in1 card reader.<br />

Tucked away at the rear are the video<br />

outputs as well, with a single HDMI and<br />

DisplayPort, though there’s no mention<br />

whether they can handle 4K at 60Hz.<br />

We tried watching several Sony sample<br />

4K videos, and the framerate hovered<br />

around 10fps. It’s no surprise really, given<br />

that they’re the visuals are powered by<br />

a rather lowly AMD R9 M470 with just<br />

2GB of dedicated memory. It’s also most<br />

definitely not up to the task of playing<br />

anything more demanding than Solitaire.<br />

Making matters worse, we couldn’t even<br />

run 3DMark, as the machine would crash<br />

every time, even after updating the AMD<br />

and HP drivers.<br />

The entire chassis operates as a<br />

speaker, with sound pumped out from<br />

the top vent. It use’s Bang and Olufsen<br />

‘Play’ internal speakers, and they’re not<br />

too shabby. The lack of subwoofer means<br />

it won’t be rattling any desks, but for<br />

integrated speakers they do a decent<br />

job. The 1x1 Wi-Fi antennae/receiver is a<br />

little disappointing, given that 2x2 is the<br />

standard these days, but there’s also<br />

a Gigabit Ethernet port on the rear to<br />

ensure fast file transfers.<br />

Given the interior capacity is so<br />

small, it’s no surprise that this unit isn’t<br />

upgradable. So you’re stuck with what<br />

your $999 gets you, which to be frank<br />

isn’t a whole lot. Intel’s Core i5 6400T is<br />

the beating heart of the system, though<br />

it’s more of a struggling pump than a<br />

healthy source of power. This chip design<br />

is almost two years old, though it is<br />

thankfully a quad-core design (there’s no<br />

HyperThreading though). The main issue<br />

is its frequency, with a base of 2.2GHz and<br />

a Turbo of just 2.8GHz. HP has endowed<br />

this with a mere 8GB of DDR4-2133MHz<br />

memory, but where things really slow<br />

down is the hard drive. Rather than go<br />

with the super-speed, ultra-small SSDs<br />

that are now commonplace in mini-<strong>PC</strong>s,<br />

HP has favoured quantity over quality.<br />

The Seagate ST2000DM001 2TB<br />

Barracuda Desktop drive is a scary<br />

throwback to the days before SSDs. Using<br />

the Wave is like going back in time three<br />

years, where it would take more than a<br />

few seconds to open even the simplest<br />

of applications. We’re positive that<br />

upgrading this to a snazzy NVMe would<br />

improve the speed of this unit no end, but<br />

alas instead you’ll spend most of your<br />

time admiring this machine’s stunning<br />

good looks as you patiently wait for it to<br />

do the simplest of tasks.<br />

One of <strong>PC</strong> & <strong>Tech</strong> <strong>Authority</strong>’s sister<br />

magazines, Hyper, recently showed<br />

that it’s possible to build a mini-<strong>PC</strong> that<br />

it at least five times faster than Wave<br />

for a cost that is just 40% more. What<br />

you’re paying for with the Wave is the<br />

immensely beautiful Tesla chassis… and<br />

that’s about it. We’re sorry, but when<br />

performance is this bad, we simply can’t<br />

recommend it, no matter how damn good<br />

it looks. Although, we do look forward to<br />

seeing what savvy modders will be able<br />

to build inside such a unique case once<br />

they gut it…<br />

Bennett Ring<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$999 • www.hp.com<br />

Intel Core i5 6400T (quad-core, Turbo 2.8GHz) • 8GB DDR4-<br />

2133MHz • AMD R9 M470 w/ 2GB GDDR5 GPU<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 53


“The chassis has been<br />

machined entirely from<br />

aluminium, and feels<br />

extremely well built”<br />

Gigabyte Aero 15<br />

A FULL-METAL POWERHOUSE<br />

U<br />

nlike other manufacturers who are<br />

making a beeline for ultraportable<br />

13 and 15-inch laptops, the new<br />

Aero 15 from Gigabyte is focusing more<br />

on high-end performance at the cost<br />

of slightly less mobility. That’s not to<br />

say that it’s behemoth; it’s still just 2.1kg<br />

and has a footprint of a 14-inch laptop,<br />

despite the larger 15.6-inch display,<br />

largely thanks to the tiny 5mm bezel.<br />

However, it’s definitely got more grunt<br />

than we’re accustomed to in this form<br />

factor, even including a discrete GPU for<br />

gaming.<br />

We were rather surprised to see<br />

that the display is a mere 1920 x 1080<br />

resolution, as it looks almost as crisp as<br />

some of the 4k displays we’ve seen in<br />

this size. It’s certified with X-Rite Pantone<br />

certification, ensuring that what you see<br />

on screen is what’s going to be printed,<br />

making this machine especially suitable<br />

for image designers and graphics workers.<br />

You’ll get good glances in the next boardroom<br />

meeting when you roll this funky unit out<br />

A 4K option will be available later in the<br />

year, which will likely see a sizable jump<br />

in price.<br />

The chassis has been machined entirely<br />

from aluminium, and feels extremely<br />

well built, with absolutely zero keyboard<br />

flex. If you’re feeling a little showy, there’s<br />

a bright orange option available; we’re<br />

quite happy to stick to the subtle black.<br />

Each key has its own RGB backlight, but<br />

we did find the resistance a little heavy<br />

for our liking. The touchpad is also a little<br />

iffy – sometimes it worked absolutely<br />

beautifully, other times it would skim and<br />

flick all over the place. It also didn’t seem<br />

to recognise basic Windows gestures,<br />

such as window scrolling. The keyboard<br />

supports macro recording, though there<br />

are no dedicated macro keys; thankfully<br />

there is a full numpad.<br />

Gigabyte has equipped the Aero 15<br />

with a solid range of connection options.<br />

On the right resides twin USB 3.0 Type A<br />

along with a single USB 3.1/Thunderbolt<br />

3 Type-C connection. There’s also an SD<br />

card reader on this side. Heading to the<br />

left reveals a single USB 3.0<br />

Type A connection, along with<br />

Ethernet, HDMI 2.0, Mini Display-<br />

Port and a combo headphone/<br />

mic 3.5mm minijack. It’s nice to see<br />

a machine this small with Ethernet,<br />

as it seems to be a dying feature as<br />

laptops become too thin for<br />

its dimensions. Integrated<br />

802.11ac Wi-Fi and Bluetooth<br />

v4.2 are included for wireless<br />

connectivity. We’re a little surprised<br />

at the placement of the cameras, which<br />

are at the bottom of the screen, so during<br />

voice chats you won’t be making eye<br />

contact with your correspondents.<br />

On to the hardware within, which<br />

is where the Aero 15 really takes off.<br />

Powering it all is Intel’s all-consuming<br />

i7-7700HQ CPU, a quad-cored,<br />

HyperThreaded beast that hits 3.8GHz<br />

when necessary. This has been paired<br />

with 16GB of DDR4-2400MHz, while<br />

storage is delivered via a sizeable<br />

Samsung 512GB M.2 SSD with NVMe<br />

support. However, we should point out<br />

that only 461GB of this is usable, and<br />

there’s no secondary drive included with<br />

this model.<br />

Rounding out the powerful hardware<br />

is Nvidia’s excellent GeForce GTX 1060<br />

GPU, which is adequate for a screen of<br />

this resolution. The overall high-level of<br />

interior specs goes a long way to explain<br />

the rather hefty price tag; it’s possible<br />

to get similar sized machines at more<br />

affordable prices, but they won’t have<br />

such a healthy spread of high-end specs.<br />

As our benchmarks show, they combine<br />

to deliver a powerful machine, with<br />

surprisingly lengthy battery life.<br />

We just wish the keyboard and<br />

touchpad were a little more fingerfriendly.<br />

Given how often you’ll be using<br />

the keyboard in particular, the fact it’s so<br />

stiff will give your hands a good workout<br />

whenever you use it.<br />

Bennett Ring<br />

BENCHMARKS (1080 ULTRA DETAIL) MINIMUM AVERAGE<br />

SHADOW OF MORDOOR<br />

GRID AUTOSPORT<br />

0 20 40 60 80 100<br />

<strong>PC</strong>Mark 8 Home accelerated: 217 minutes<br />

3DMark Cloud Gate: 25380<br />

3DMark Fire Strike: 9647<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$2,899 • www.gigabyte.com.au<br />

15.6-inch 1920 x 1080 Wide Angle Panel • Intel 7th<br />

Generation Core it-7700HQ (quad-cored, HyperThreaded,<br />

3.8GHz Turbo) • 16GB DDR4-2400; 512GB Samsung M.2<br />

NVMe SSD<br />

OVERALL<br />

66FPS<br />

74FPS<br />

90FPS<br />

99FPS<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

54 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


LAPTOPS & <strong>PC</strong>S REVIEWS<br />

Asus<br />

VivoMini<br />

VC66R<br />

SMALL FORM FACTOR;<br />

OVERSIZED PRICE TAG<br />

W<br />

elcome to Asus’ upgrade to its<br />

prior prosumer mini-<strong>PC</strong>, the<br />

VC65R. It’s slightly larger than<br />

your everyday NUC style <strong>PC</strong>, but Asus<br />

has upgraded nearly every component<br />

within. The result is a powerful media<br />

box, but one that comes with a price tag<br />

that is hard to swallow.<br />

The interior of the chassis is two litres,<br />

and squeezes in a standard Mini-STX<br />

motherboard based on the Intel H170<br />

chipset. It’s small enough to fit onto the<br />

back of most displays using the included<br />

VESA mounting kit, though it is 74.1mm<br />

deep, which will push your display<br />

further out from the wall.<br />

Asus is really pushing this as a 4K<br />

playback media device, and we found it<br />

played back 4K video files effortlessly.<br />

This is thanks to the Intel 7th Gen<br />

Core i5-7400 within, which features<br />

hardware acceleration thanks to the<br />

Intel HD Graphics 630 iGPU and media<br />

acceleration engine (note that this<br />

can up or downgraded at the time of<br />

purchase). This CPU can handle both<br />

VP9 and HEVC 10-bit acceleration,<br />

which is what makes it such a potent 4K<br />

playback device. Despite having a mere<br />

65W TDP, it’s a quad core chip that can<br />

Turbo all the way up to 3.5GHz. Asus<br />

claims that under normal operating<br />

modes it’ll only use around 19W of<br />

power, which probably explains why it’s<br />

so quiet, hitting a mere 19dB of fan noise<br />

when idling.<br />

It’s possible to install up to three<br />

different hard drives inside the chassis,<br />

though our version only had a single<br />

Despite its small size there’s no shortage of ports<br />

256GB Hynix SSD. With<br />

one M.2 drive in place, there’s<br />

room for two more 2.5 inch drives,<br />

or a single 2.5-inch drive and ultra-slim<br />

optical drive. Putting a Blu-ray drive in<br />

would make this a very capable media<br />

box indeed; it’s just a shame there aren’t<br />

any Ultra-slim Ultra HD Blu-ray players<br />

on the market yet, which would make<br />

this an all-rounder 4K playback box.<br />

Thanks to the H170 motherboard, the<br />

drives can be connected in RAID 0,1,5<br />

or 10 modes, which would make this a<br />

rather powerful – albeit expensive –<br />

NAS solution.<br />

A mere 8GB of DDR4-2400MHz of<br />

memory was included in our review<br />

sample, but this can be upgraded to<br />

32GB. Just bear in mind that it’ll have<br />

to be of the SO-DIMM form factor due<br />

to the small size of the memory slots.<br />

Intel’s integrated 802.11ac Wi-Fi 8260<br />

chipset is included, which is a dual band<br />

solution using 2x2 antennae, which also<br />

delivers Bluetooth 4.1.<br />

Up to three displays can be<br />

connected simultaneously to the<br />

VC66R thanks to the four different video<br />

outputs – DVI-D, HDMI, DisplayPort<br />

and VGA. Unfortunately we weren’t<br />

able to connect up three monitors<br />

simultaneously, but it’s highly doubtful<br />

the Intel iGPU would be able to run<br />

three independent 4K streams. As far<br />

as USB options go, there’s plenty here<br />

– two USB 3.0 Type-A on the rear, plus<br />

another three on the front, though only<br />

two of those are USB 3.0, one of which is<br />

Type-C.<br />

“Putting a Blu-ray drive<br />

in would make this a<br />

very capable media box<br />

indeed”<br />

Overall this is a very versatile mini-<strong>PC</strong>,<br />

able to operate as a standard desktop<br />

<strong>PC</strong>, media player or point of sale system.<br />

However, it does so at a very high price<br />

point when compared to the likes of<br />

Gigabyte’s Brix systems or even Intel’s<br />

NUC range, though these don’t include<br />

storage or memory. We appreciate just<br />

how much Asus has managed to fit<br />

into such a small form factor, it’s just a<br />

pity that the price is far too high for the<br />

hardware within.<br />

Bennett Ring<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$1,259 • www.asus.com.au<br />

Intel 7th Gen Core i5-7400 (quad-core, 3.5GHz Turbo) • 8GB<br />

DDR4 memory • 177.4 x 153 x 74.1 mm (WxDxH)<br />

BENCHMARKS<br />

<strong>PC</strong>Mark 8 Home accelerated: 3788<br />

3DMark Cloud Gate: 6841<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 55


Netgear<br />

Nighthawk X10<br />

AD7200 WiFi<br />

Router D8500<br />

A PREMIUM PRODUCT WITH A PRICE TO MATCH<br />

T<br />

he Nighthawk X10 WiFi router is by<br />

far and away the most technically<br />

advanced home Wi-Fi router I’ve<br />

had the pleasure of testing, with a futureproof<br />

feature set and capabilities normally<br />

reserved for enterprise-grade equipment.<br />

Let’s start with the design. This is a<br />

behemoth of a router, with piano black<br />

panels and a grilled façade that lets you<br />

see the cooling fan within. This thing looks<br />

reminiscent of a high-end graphics card<br />

with four antennas attached to it.<br />

Those antennas – although nonremovable<br />

– all have subtle blue LED edge<br />

lighting, further adding to the router’s<br />

space age sensibilities. These LEDs can<br />

be switched off with a toggle switch at<br />

the back, should you not want an ambient<br />

blue glow in the room.<br />

On the left are two USB 3.0 ports for<br />

plugging in storage or printers. If you<br />

choose to use the router as a Plex server,<br />

you’ll need one of those ports to install the<br />

app on a USB stick or similar.<br />

Around the back are six Gigabit Ethernet<br />

ports, with ports 1 and 2 serving as<br />

aggregation ports. This is great if you have<br />

a NAS or a network switch that can take<br />

advantage of the technology, feeding the<br />

network even more throughput than is<br />

usually possible with a single LAN port.<br />

For real speed-hungry users, a bit of<br />

enterprise-grade technology has made its<br />

way to the Nighthawk X10 in the form of<br />

a 10Gbps SFP+ port. This is the first time<br />

this connection has made its way into the<br />

home networking world.<br />

If you’ve got the equipment to use it,<br />

such as a high-end NAS, then you’ll have<br />

absolutely no issues pushing content<br />

through at speed. For 95 percent of the<br />

home user population, however, it’ll<br />

probably just sit there unused.<br />

Which leads me nicely into the X10’s<br />

wireless capabilities. Wireless N and AC<br />

are available, as you’d expect, and both<br />

provide solid – if not spectacular – speeds.<br />

Using quad-stream (4x4) and MU-<br />

MIMO, the router is more than capable of<br />

servicing multiple connections to multiple<br />

devices at multiple speeds with aplomb.<br />

I ran Netflix on a 12in iPad Pro, a Google<br />

Pixel XL streaming Stan, and Samsung<br />

Galaxy S7 streaming Extreme quality<br />

tracks on Spotify all on the 5GHz network,<br />

and all started and played without a<br />

hitch. Pretty impressive considering I’m<br />

encumbered with an ADSL2+ home<br />

internet connection that tops out at<br />

14Mbps.<br />

Wireless-N connectivity was also OK,<br />

with reliable connectivity achieved from<br />

one end of my three-bedroom house to<br />

the other, through several walls and a<br />

kitchen – an area notoriously difficult for<br />

Wi-Fi signals to penetrate in any home.<br />

One thing its wireless-N wasn’t though<br />

was fast – if you’re looking for speed,<br />

you’re best jumping onto one of the higherfrequency<br />

bands.<br />

Speaking of which, the X10’s party<br />

trick is the inclusion of 802.11ad, which<br />

promises theoretical throughput speeds<br />

of 4600Mbps on the 60GHz network. This<br />

would be just the thing to complement a<br />

dual-Gigabit or 10Gbps-connected NAS<br />

for streaming 4K content to a Wireless-AD<br />

capable device. Sadly, there is a catch,<br />

and it comes in the form of the laws of<br />

physics. You see, when it comes to radio<br />

frequencies, you can have long-range or<br />

you can have high-throughput, but not<br />

both. This is already evident when you<br />

compare wireless-N and wireless-AC.<br />

Wireless-N is a lower frequency, which<br />

makes it more capable of penetrating<br />

through walls and giving you greater range.<br />

Wireless-AC, at more than double the<br />

frequency of wireless-N, gives you much<br />

higher throughput but sacrifices range.<br />

Wireless-AD operates at a frequency<br />

five times that of wireless-AC, so as you’d<br />

expect, throughput is blisteringly fast<br />

when you’re up close and personal with<br />

the router. However, walk several metres<br />

away from the X10, and your connection<br />

drops off severely. Move into the next<br />

room, and connectivity is just about<br />

non-existent. This technology then is<br />

purely reserved for same-room network<br />

connectivity. When smart TVs and digital<br />

hubs eventually start adopting wireless-<br />

AD componentry, you’ll be one step closer<br />

to 4K video streaming nirvana.<br />

Sadly, wireless-AD capable devices<br />

are few and far between at this stage.<br />

What’s worse, 802.11ad is not backwardscompatible<br />

like its predecessor 802.11ac,<br />

but the recently announced 802.11ax by<br />

Qualcomm will be, and that standard<br />

promises not only multi-Gigabit<br />

connectivity but energy efficiency as well.<br />

So where does this leave the Nighthawk<br />

X10? If you have to be on the absolute<br />

bleeding edge of home networking<br />

technology – and have the latest and<br />

greatest high-end equipment to go with<br />

it – then it’s a great buy. If you want to<br />

future-proof your home Wi-Fi, then<br />

the X10 will gladly step up to the plate<br />

and knock it out of the park – provided<br />

802.11ad becomes widely adopted.<br />

However, $799 is a lot to ask for<br />

functionality you either won’t use<br />

or can’t use yet, making it a difficult<br />

recommendation for anyone except the<br />

earliest of early adopters.<br />

Peter Gutierrez<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$799 • www.netgear.com.au<br />

Quad-core 1.7GHz processor • 7 x Gigabit Ethernet ports (1 x<br />

WAN, 6 x LAN w. dual Gigabit aggregation), 1 x SFP+<br />

10Gbps port • Triband (1 x 2.4GHz @ 800Mbps, 1 x 5GHz @<br />

1733Mbps, 1 x 60GHz @ 4600Mbps)<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

56 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


PERIPHERALS REVIEWS<br />

Netgear Nighthawk<br />

X8 AC5300 VDSL/<br />

ADSL Modem Router<br />

D8500<br />

ONE OF THE BEST MODEM ROUTERS<br />

WE HAVE EVER TESTED<br />

etgear’s Nighthawk range of<br />

wireless routers have been among<br />

N the most technically advanced –<br />

and expensive – routers for power users,<br />

and the Nighthawk X8 AC5300 VDSL/<br />

ADSL Modem Router continues this proud<br />

tradition.<br />

While the design is a little more<br />

subdued that its wedge-shaped<br />

predecessor, the Nighthawk X8 is<br />

nonetheless a fetching bit of kit, with an<br />

undulating ventilation grid on the top, a<br />

column of white LEDs to signal internet<br />

connectivity, Wi-Fi channel status and<br />

Ethernet connectivity, and three buttons<br />

on the front to enable/disable the LEDs,<br />

WPS and Wi-Fi, respectively.<br />

Speaking of LEDs, the four external<br />

antennas possess their own blue LEDs<br />

that circle the tips. While dismissing<br />

them as a design touch at first, I came to<br />

appreciate them for signifying the status<br />

of the Wi-Fi at a glance, saving me an<br />

arduous walk across the living room.<br />

These external antennas have builtin<br />

amplifiers for the 2.4GHz and 5GHz<br />

networks, and complement the four<br />

internal 5GHz antennas nicely.<br />

USB 2.0 and USB 3.0 ports lie<br />

underneath a panel on the right side,<br />

enabling connectivity to printers, USB<br />

storage, and the like. If you download<br />

Netgear’s ReadySHARE Vault app, you<br />

can also turn the Nighthawk X8 into a file<br />

server and back up your connected <strong>PC</strong>s to<br />

any attached storage.<br />

This router is definitely for bandwidthhungry<br />

households, with theoretical<br />

Gigabit throughput for the wireless-N<br />

channel and 2.166 Gbps for each of the<br />

wireless-AC ones. Furthermore, the<br />

two 5GHz bands can be combined into<br />

a single 5GHz connection, providing as<br />

much bandwidth as you could possibly<br />

ask for (as long as you don’t stray too far<br />

away).<br />

MU-MIMO and beamforming tech<br />

come part and parcel with the router,<br />

and using tricky software smarts, is able<br />

to load-balance slower network devices<br />

on one 5GHz channel, leaving the other<br />

one for the gamers and streamers on the<br />

network.<br />

Setup on my ADSL2+ connection was a<br />

relatively quick and painless experience,<br />

and I was up and running in short order.<br />

That the wizard encourages first-time<br />

users to change the router’s password as<br />

part of its process was a welcome sight.<br />

Performance was, as you’d expect,<br />

blisteringly fast. While simultaneously<br />

streaming HD Netflix and Stan to a Google<br />

Pixel XL and a 12in iPad Pro respectively,<br />

streaming Spotify at Extreme quality to a<br />

Galaxy S7, and watching 1440p YouTube<br />

videos on an Ethernet-connected desktop<br />

<strong>PC</strong>, the Nighthawk X8 chugged along with<br />

nary a stutter, serving all devices with<br />

aplomb. Wireless range was impressive<br />

too. While the dual 5GHz channels<br />

predictably dropped off somewhat after<br />

moving a few rooms away, the 2.4GHz<br />

channel covered my entire three bedroom<br />

house and backyard with ease, even<br />

reaching my neighbour’s house 30 metres<br />

across the road.<br />

$699 may seem like an eye-watering<br />

amount for an ADSL modem router, but<br />

if you want a no-compromise device that<br />

will serve you well both now and into the<br />

future, the Nighthawk X8 is one of the<br />

very best.<br />

Peter Gutierrez<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$699 • www.netgear.com.au<br />

Dual-core 1.4GHz processor • 7 x Gigabit Ethernet ports (1 x<br />

WAN, 6 x LAN w. dual Gigabit aggregation) • Triband (1 x<br />

2.4GHz @ 1000Mbps and 2 x 5GHz @ 2166Mbps each)<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5


REVIEWS LAPTOPS & <strong>PC</strong>S<br />

Pioneer Computers<br />

Dreamvision 32”<br />

Gaming <strong>PC</strong> 7X<br />

AN AIO THAT PROMISES REAL GAMING PERFORMANCE<br />

T<br />

here was a time when only Apple<br />

could build a decent All-in-One,<br />

but those days are well and truly<br />

over. The miniaturisation of components<br />

for laptops has meant we can now have<br />

Windows-based AIOs that don’t overheat,<br />

aren’t ridiculously fat, or insanely priced.<br />

This 32-incher from Pioneer shows how far<br />

AIOs have come in recent years, but also<br />

highlights a few issues that they still need<br />

to work on.<br />

The large 32-inch screen means this is<br />

the perfect size for your office desktop or<br />

even bedside table, but we should point<br />

out just how fat it is. It’s approximately<br />

15cm deep, so mounting it on a wall isn’t<br />

possible, especially as the venting system<br />

would be blocked. Given the large number<br />

of vents on the rear, it’s not surprising to<br />

see that this machine is basically silent<br />

during our gaming tests, but there is one<br />

bug-bear – there’s a high-pitched whine<br />

that comes from within. We’re not sure if<br />

it’s from a fan or coil noise, but it’s always<br />

noticeable.<br />

The large size of the screen is<br />

appreciated, but it’s rather low resolution,<br />

at just 1920 x 1080, making the pixel<br />

structure extremely obvious. We’d have<br />

much preferred a higher resolution for a<br />

few hundred dollars more. At least it’s<br />

IPS though, so the colour, clarity and<br />

viewing angle are all very respectable.<br />

Unfortunately there’s no way to change<br />

the angle of the screen, as the two feet<br />

it’s mounted on aren’t flexible at all. One<br />

feature that would have really doubled the<br />

versatility of the screen is a TV tuner, but<br />

unfortunately there isn’t one included. It’s<br />

a strange oversight as many AIOs include<br />

this feature, though there’s always the<br />

option of buying a USB tuner.<br />

Unfortunately most of the USB ports<br />

are hard to reach though. They’re on the<br />

bottom, which means you have to lift it<br />

up every time you want to plug something<br />

in, along with the video outputs. There’s<br />

four USB 3.0 Type-A, Ethernet, three<br />

3.5mm minijacks for twin speakers and<br />

a microphone, DVI-I, VGA and two old<br />

school keyboard/mouse connections.<br />

Thankfully there are two more USB 3.0<br />

Type-A connections on the front along<br />

with two more 3.5mm minijacks, but<br />

there’s no sign of any USB 3.1 Type-C/<br />

Thunderbolt 3 connection. A two megapixel<br />

camera is included, but it’s on the<br />

bottom, so when used in a normal desktop<br />

setup your viewer will see your chest and<br />

neck; there’s no way to change the angle.<br />

Packed away inside the large plastic<br />

boxes on the rear is a decently specced<br />

up <strong>PC</strong>. Intel’s Core i5-7600 four cores<br />

boost all the way up to 4.1GHz under load,<br />

while a decent amount of DDR4 memory<br />

is included, at 16GB. An Asus Prime H270<br />

Plus motherboard is included; at this<br />

price we’d have preferred a Z270 based<br />

motherboard, but in reality there’s no<br />

performance difference, just fewer <strong>PC</strong>Ie<br />

lanes. A hefty 512GB Intel 600p Series M.2<br />

SSD is included, which supports NVMe<br />

though only 476GB of the space is usable.<br />

This is backed up by a mechanical WD 1TB<br />

HDD. Rounding out the technical goodies<br />

is an Nvidia GeForce GTX 1060 with 6GB<br />

of dedicated memory.<br />

As a result, this machine turned out<br />

some decent results in our benchmarks.<br />

However, it’s worth considering that it<br />

costs close to three grand – it’s possible to<br />

build a machine twice as fast for the same<br />

price, but it won’t be an All-in-One. There’s<br />

also the issue of the low resolution display<br />

and lack of TV tuner. Yet as far as AIO’s go,<br />

Pioneer has delivered a solid overall build.<br />

Bennett Ring<br />

BENCHMARKS (1080 ULTRA DETAIL) MINIMUM AVERAGE<br />

SHADOW OF MORDOOR<br />

GRID AUTOSPORT<br />

0 30 60 90 120 150<br />

<strong>PC</strong>Mark 8 Home accelerated: 10588<br />

3DMark Fire Strike: 10588<br />

3DMark Fire Strike Extreme: 5774<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$2,680 • www.pioneercomputers.com.au<br />

32-inch IPS panel • Intel Core i5-7600 (quad-cores, 4.1GHz<br />

Turbo) • 16GB DDR4 • 512GB Intel M.2 NVMe SSD; 1TB WD<br />

HDD.<br />

OVERALL<br />

64FPS<br />

95FPS<br />

95FPS<br />

126FPS<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

58 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


LAPTOPS & <strong>PC</strong>S REVIEWS<br />

Asus FX553VD<br />

NOT YOUR AVERAGE 15 INCHER<br />

F<br />

rom the exterior, and the price point,<br />

this looks like a rather standard<br />

productivity focused 15.6-inch<br />

based laptop. However, dig a little deeper<br />

and you’ll see that Asus has endowed<br />

this with some gaming prowess, despite<br />

it looking or costing nothing like your<br />

normal gaming laptop. If you just want<br />

a super-portable mobile laptop or<br />

convertible, this is not for you – but if you<br />

want something that is happy to run Excel<br />

during the day and Overwatch at night, it’s<br />

actually a rather interesting proposition.<br />

From the exterior, this looks like a<br />

relatively mid-range office productivity<br />

laptop. There are a few orange highlights<br />

that suggest it’s a bit more than that,<br />

but overall it doesn’t scream ‘Gamermachine’<br />

during your weekly meeting with<br />

the boss. That price might give it away a<br />

little though; if there wasn’t some kind of<br />

discrete gaming GPU within, you could<br />

easily pick up a competing model for<br />

$500 less. From what we can tell – and<br />

it’s getting harder and harder to tell every<br />

day due to various coatings – the entire<br />

chassis is made from a plastic exterior.<br />

Weighing in at 2.5kg with battery in place,<br />

it’s also rather heavy compared to the<br />

ultra-light weights we’ve seen in this form<br />

factor of late.<br />

The consolation for this is some rather<br />

beefy hardware within. The 15.6-inch IPS<br />

screen is a basic 1920 x 1080 model, and<br />

we really do mean average. Compared<br />

to other laptops in this price range, the<br />

colour quality and clarity of the screen is<br />

rather lacking. However, the darling of the<br />

laptop world is powering this machine,<br />

Intel’s 7th Generation Core i7-7700HQ<br />

CPU. With quad HyperThreaded cores<br />

that boost up to 3.8GHz, this machine<br />

has CPU cycles in spades. It’ll cut<br />

through anything you throw at it without<br />

a problem, a fact helped by the chunky<br />

16GB of DDR4 memory feeding it data at<br />

high speed.<br />

Unfortunately the main OS SSD is<br />

rather lacking. At just 128GB, with only<br />

118GB of that usable, you’ll be filling this<br />

M.2 SSD quicker than you can click on<br />

installing the Adobe suite installation<br />

button. We had to mount most of our<br />

benchmarks on the secondary drive, a 1TB<br />

mechanical drive, as it kept spitting up an<br />

error that there just wasn’t enough space,<br />

despite there being a healthy 75GB of free<br />

space on the main SSD; we’re guessing a<br />

BIOS update will fix this bug in the<br />

future.<br />

Making this a somewhat decent<br />

gaming machine is the inclusion<br />

of Nvidia’s entry-level GeForce<br />

GTX 1050 GPU. As our<br />

benchmarks show, it’s<br />

doesn’t really have the chops<br />

to play today’s latest games at<br />

Ultra detail, though it’s fine If you’re<br />

more of a casual gamer. Still, at this<br />

price it seems a little underpowered;<br />

a GeForce GTX 1060 would have<br />

delivered massively improved<br />

performance. At least it’s not<br />

too noisy, hitting the 50dB fan<br />

noise that seems to be the basis<br />

for all of the new Nvidia mobile GPUs.<br />

Unfortunately battery life was pretty<br />

abysmal, hitting just 129 minutes in our<br />

<strong>PC</strong>Mark 8 Home Accelerated battery test.<br />

If you’re expecting full-day performance<br />

from this machine, we’d suggest that<br />

you’re going to be disappointed.<br />

As far as other features go, things<br />

are pretty much par for the course.<br />

The inclusion of a Blu-ray drive is<br />

interesting, but comes at the cost of USB<br />

connectivity. There are just two USB 3.0<br />

and a single USB 2.0 Type A connection,<br />

along with a single USB 3.1 Type C<br />

connection. There’s also HDMI out and an<br />

Ethernet in, but that’s about it.<br />

Asus has tried to deliver a rather unique<br />

machine; with a business form factor but<br />

the inclusion of a GeForce GTX 1050 to<br />

give it a little gaming grunt. However, for<br />

the price we think you’re better off with<br />

something like an Alienware with external<br />

GPU accelerator, which will deliver a<br />

much more portable office machine, with<br />

real gaming performance when you get<br />

home.<br />

Bennett Ring<br />

BENCHMARKS (1080 ULTRA DETAIL) MINIMUM AVERAGE<br />

SHADOW OF MORDOOR<br />

GRID AUTOSPORT<br />

0 20 40 60 80 100<br />

<strong>PC</strong>Mark 8 Home accelerated: 129 minutes<br />

<strong>PC</strong>Mark 8 Home accelerated: 4113<br />

3DMark Fire Strike: 5426<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$1,999 • www.asus.com.au<br />

15.6-inch IPS panel • Intel’s 7th Generation Core i7-7700HQ<br />

CPU (quad-core, HyperThreaded, 3.8GHz Turbo) • 16GB<br />

DDR4 • Nvidia GeForce GTX 1050<br />

OVERALL<br />

30FPS<br />

43FPS<br />

68FPS<br />

81FPS<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 59


REVIEWS PERIPHERALS<br />

Netgear S8000 Switch<br />

NOT YOUR NORMAL SPLITTER<br />

A<br />

switch, is a switch, is a switch.<br />

These boring beige boxes<br />

generally do one thing, and<br />

one thing only – split a single Ethernet<br />

connection into multiple Ethernet<br />

connections. There’s been basically zero<br />

innovation of the field of these devices<br />

for many years, but Netgear is trying<br />

to change that with the S8000. Rather<br />

than a box that equally distributes your<br />

bandwidth amongst all of the connected<br />

devices, they’ve endowed it with Quality of<br />

Service (QoS) features to ensure that your<br />

most important traffic gets through first.<br />

But does it actually make a difference?<br />

Considering most routers these days<br />

already have QoS built into them, the<br />

S8000 isn’t really necessary unless you’ve<br />

got a multitude of Ethernet connected<br />

devices. It’s an 8-port switch; so you’ll be<br />

able to hook up seven discrete devices,<br />

as one of the ports will be used for your<br />

input connection. Even just looking at the<br />

design of this device shows that Netgear<br />

is trying to do something different. Where<br />

most switches are a simple little box,<br />

Netgear has instead gone for the styling of<br />

a stealth fighter. It’s surprisingly heavy as<br />

well; where most switches are built from<br />

basic plastic, Netgear has gone for a full<br />

metal jacket on this product.<br />

Unlike most switches, this one includes<br />

software to control the various settings<br />

that are included. We have to say that it’s<br />

not the most intuitive interface around;<br />

most network novices won’t understand<br />

the terms that it bandies about, such as<br />

flow control, IGMPv3 IP header support or<br />

multicasting. It’d be nice if the interface<br />

explained each of these terms in detail.<br />

However, it does make it simple to assign<br />

priorities to certain ports for gaming or<br />

media use. The Gaming pre-set mode<br />

allows the first port to be given the fastest<br />

access for gaming, while the Media<br />

Streaming option enables the second<br />

port to prioritise media streaming. But to<br />

configure the remaining five ports (port<br />

8 is used as the uplink port to your main<br />

Internet connection), you’re going to<br />

have to dig deeper into the configuration<br />

options, where things get a little more<br />

complex.<br />

This software can also be accessed<br />

via a Smartphone app, but digging into<br />

the more advanced options is far more<br />

complicated than necessary. For example,<br />

to give a certain port a boost in the priority<br />

list is not easy to figure out how to do at<br />

all. Apparently the built-in QoS support<br />

should do this automatically, but it’d be<br />

The included app sets it apart from most switches,<br />

allowing each port to be assigned a priority<br />

nice to be able to assign priority manually<br />

to each port, so that you can be sure you’re<br />

main <strong>PC</strong> is getting priority, while other<br />

devices are secondary. To do so you’ll need<br />

to dig into the Prioritisation menu, where<br />

you’re asked whether or not you’d like to<br />

use 802.1P/DSCP mode, or do it manually.<br />

Like we said, the terminology in use here is<br />

well above what most home users will be<br />

comfortable with. If you know what you’re<br />

doing though, it’s possible to limit the<br />

bandwidth per port, which means Mum<br />

and Dad can hog 90Mbps of their NBN<br />

connection, while leaving the little ones to<br />

survive on a mere 10Mbps.<br />

It’s possible to use Link aggregation to<br />

patch together up to four ports to deliver<br />

4Gbps of bandwidth to a certain device,<br />

which will come in handy with other<br />

devices that feature multiple Ethernet<br />

connections, such as Netgear’s very own<br />

ReadyNAS devices. There’s also a test<br />

feature that allows you to see if there are<br />

any issues with your cabling, which is most<br />

handy indeed – we would have saved<br />

many hours not having to disconnect every<br />

device just to find a faulty cable.<br />

As expected, speeds are bang on for a<br />

Gigabit Switch. Yet for most home users<br />

it’s probably total overkill, as their router<br />

undoubtedly has QoS already built in.<br />

On the other hand, if you’re managing a<br />

small office and need to precisely control<br />

the bandwidth available to each device,<br />

the $100 jump in price over a basic 8-port<br />

switch might just be worth it.<br />

Bennett Ring<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$149 • www.netgear.com<br />

8-port switch • integrated QoS features • manual port<br />

speed control • Link aggregation up to four ports<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

60 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


WEARABLES REVIEWS<br />

“we think the Rift may<br />

end up being the<br />

superior of the two<br />

products (HTC Vive)”<br />

Oculus Touch<br />

OCULUS IS BACK ON EQUAL FOOTING<br />

W<br />

hen the HTC Vive and Oculus Rift<br />

arrived, <strong>PC</strong>TA was lucky enough<br />

to be one of the first magazines<br />

in Australia to receive review samples.<br />

After a week of testing we came to the<br />

conclusion that the Rift was the superior<br />

HMD, while the Vive was the superior<br />

overall package, and it came down to one<br />

reason – the lack of motion controls for<br />

the Rift. Instead we had to make do with a<br />

crummy Xbox controller, and it really took<br />

away half of the VR equation. Well, we’re<br />

pleased to finally see Oculus’ motion<br />

solution arrive in the form of the Touch<br />

controller. The million dollar question is<br />

whether it brings the Rift platform up to<br />

the same level as the Vive?<br />

We expected Touch to cost around<br />

US$299, so the release price of a mere<br />

US$99 is simply astonishingly good value.<br />

For this you get two touch controllers and<br />

a second tracking camera, identical to the<br />

first. Now that your Rift has two cameras,<br />

Oculus suggests setting up a camera on<br />

each side of your display, but we found<br />

this to be a terrible suggestion. The<br />

problem is that unless your display is right<br />

at the front of your desk, your desktop will<br />

occlude tracking below desk level, which<br />

is a huge problem when you’re leaning<br />

down to pick things up.<br />

Thankfully the Rift community are a<br />

savvy bunch, and they’ve come up with a<br />

better solution – mount them the same<br />

way as the Vive’s. That is, diagonally<br />

opposite, at ceiling height, pointing<br />

downwards. This allows much better<br />

coverage, and also enables room-scale<br />

tracking, though it’s not the same size<br />

as the Vive, at around 7 feet diagonal.<br />

However, you can purchase a third<br />

camera (US$79), which will increase<br />

the play size to around 11.6 feet<br />

diagonally.<br />

Oculus really needs to<br />

work on their setup tutorial<br />

for the Touch controllers, as<br />

it’s confusing to say the least.<br />

Once again the community has<br />

saved the day, with third party<br />

software that show exactly<br />

where your controllers are being<br />

tracked, and any problem spots. Like<br />

the Vive, having room-scale tracking<br />

means that the Rift now displays a blue<br />

‘wall’ whenever you approach the edge of<br />

your play space.<br />

In terms of ergonomics, the Touch<br />

are hands-down the winners, no pun<br />

intended. They’re held like pistol grips<br />

instead of the wand-like design of the<br />

Vive controllers, which makes them far<br />

more suitable for pointing at things, and<br />

especially in games involving guns…<br />

which unsurprisingly is a large amount<br />

of titles. There are two triggers on the<br />

main grip, one for your pointing finger,<br />

the other for your middle finger. On top<br />

of each controller are two main buttons,<br />

along with a thumbstick that also clicks<br />

in. Finally there’s a menu/settings button<br />

each controller.<br />

Once we’d spent a few hours finally<br />

getting the tracking to work adequately,<br />

we have to admit that the Oculus tracking<br />

system doesn’t feel quite as accurate<br />

as the Vive. It’s not a night and day<br />

difference, but looking down the sights<br />

of guns or using bows and arrows shows<br />

they’re not quite as on point as the Vive.<br />

They also seemed prone to lose tracking<br />

a little more often, glitching out now and<br />

then. They’re also powered by nonrechargeable<br />

batteries, whereas the Vive<br />

controllers can be plugged into USB and<br />

recharged.<br />

Despite the quirks with losing tracking<br />

and the setup issues, we should take<br />

into account that Vive’s controllers had<br />

issues at first, and they’ve had a year of<br />

extra polish. Give Oculus some time to<br />

iron out the kinks, add a third camera and<br />

we think the Rift may end up being the<br />

superior of the two products, especially<br />

once price is factored into the equation.<br />

Bennett Ring<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

US$99 • www.oculus.com<br />

Kit includes two controllers and camera • IR-based tracking<br />

solution • single triple A battery for each controller.<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 61


ADVERTORIAL SEAGATE<br />

How to boost NAS health:<br />

Ironwolf health management<br />

and Synology NAS<br />

IRONWOLF HEALTH MANAGEMENT IMPROVES<br />

NAS SYSTEM RELIABILITY — WITH THE INDUSTRY’S<br />

MOST COMPREHENSIVE EMBEDDED ANALYSIS<br />

AND RECOVERY SOFTWARE<br />

W<br />

ant to be sure your NAS is<br />

running at peak performance?<br />

What if you could keep<br />

your NAS up and running simply, with<br />

powerful info on the health of your<br />

system and the status of the IronWolf<br />

hard drives inside? What if you could<br />

learn in real-time ahead of potential<br />

issues arising or know with a glance<br />

that an “Abnormally high operating<br />

temperature has been detected” — and<br />

even be advised to “Please make sure<br />

that the rear ventilation ports are<br />

not blocked, and please try to lower<br />

the ambient temperature.” Or what if<br />

“Excessive vibration has been detected”<br />

or “Excessive physical shock to the<br />

hard drive has been detected” in your<br />

NAS? Wouldn’t it be useful to know, so<br />

you could make sure your system is<br />

always in good health and at optimum<br />

performance?<br />

IRONWOLF HEALTH<br />

MANAGEMENT IS NOW<br />

EXCLUSIVELY AVAILABLE ON<br />

SYNOLOGY NAS<br />

Seagate’s IronWolf Health Management<br />

(IHM) is here to offer all this and more —<br />

and is now exclusively available on<br />

Synology NAS solutions, integrated<br />

natively in Synology’s DiskStation<br />

Manager (DSM) 6.1. It delivers powerful<br />

prevention and intervention, and IHM<br />

leverages the hardware sensors and<br />

software suite built into IronWolf drives<br />

to provide intelligent analysis of drive<br />

health that goes far beyond traditional<br />

diagnostic tools. With the introduction<br />

of IHM, IronWolf earns an even stronger<br />

claim as the hard drive most uniquely<br />

suited for NAS enclosures.<br />

62 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

IHM FOCUSES ON THREE KEY CAPABILITIES —<br />

PREVENTION, INTERVENTION AND RECOVERY:<br />

Prevention. IHM monitors the user<br />

environment and recommends preventative<br />

actions to enable a superior NAS experience.<br />

More effective prevention boosts<br />

performance and longevity by suggesting<br />

optimal workloads and environment tweaks.<br />

How? IHM keeps tabs on environmental<br />

and usage conditions, such as temperature,<br />

shock, vibration, intermittent connections,<br />

signal integrity and recommends<br />

preventative measures if necessary.<br />

Intervention. IHM provides faster<br />

intervention by monitoring hundreds of<br />

parameters of the drive to recommend<br />

backup ahead of catastrophic data loss<br />

events.<br />

How? Adaptive algorithms monitor<br />

critical drive health parameters related to<br />

overall performance and reliability. IHM will<br />

recommend if any further diagnostics and<br />

backup are necessary.<br />

Recovery. Ironwolf drives gives users<br />

an added peace of mind in the event of data<br />

loss.<br />

How? When disaster strikes, Seagate’s<br />

in-house data recovery services enjoy a 90%<br />

recovery rate. Seagate Rescue Services is<br />

complimentary for two years on IronWolf<br />

Pro drives, and can be added as an option on<br />

IronWolf drives for as little as US$5 per year.<br />

EVERY PRO NAS USER<br />

HAS QUESTIONS<br />

Of course, every pro NAS user has questions.<br />

“What does IronWolf Health Management<br />

mean for me?” “What about performance<br />

impacts, NAS configurations, hard drive<br />

choice?” So here are a few thoughts on some<br />

of the most common questions:<br />

Does running IHM impact my NAS IOPS or<br />

performance?<br />

Well, no. Logging of drive parameters on<br />

an ongoing basis has no impact on NAS box<br />

performance. Invoking the IHM command<br />

has negligible performance impact (similar<br />

to SMART).<br />

What Seagate drives support IHM?<br />

IHM is an exclusive feature of Seagate’s<br />

IronWolf and IronWolf Pro 4TB to 10TB<br />

drives only. Yes, I know people put a variety<br />

of drives into NAS boxes, but unlike other<br />

drives IronWolf is designed specifically for<br />

NAS performance, so you really should<br />

start sticking to that. These drives have 3x<br />

the workload capacity of a standard drive,<br />

they are 24 by 7 and are built with rotation<br />

vibration sensors that handle multi bay<br />

environments. Your Synology NAS system<br />

will auto-detect and indicate to you if IHM is<br />

supported.<br />

How frequently does a user run the IronWolf<br />

health test?<br />

It’s up to you — users are able to schedule<br />

the frequency of their IHM test using the<br />

Synology user interface. The out-of-box<br />

setting on Synology units is every 24 hours.<br />

We do recommend users not set the process<br />

to run more often than twice a day.<br />

Will I be able to read and act on the output<br />

codes IHM provides me?<br />

Yes — some of them. Certain output codes<br />

with suggestions for user action will be<br />

output for you in the user interface, so you’ll<br />

know what to do. On the other hand, certain<br />

codes that would require help from your<br />

customer technical support representative<br />

are sent from API to the NAS operating<br />

system, and you’ll be directed to contact<br />

support.<br />

Doesn’t every drive already have S.M.A.R.T.?<br />

How is IHM different?<br />

IronWolf Health Management<br />

complements other health test related<br />

features within the NAS operating system,<br />

such as Self-Monitoring, Analysis and<br />

Reporting <strong>Tech</strong>nology, or S.M.A.R.T.<br />

Clearly, the introduction of IHM enables<br />

IronWolf HDDs to bring even greater value to<br />

your Synology NAS. It improves the overall<br />

system reliability by displaying actionable<br />

prevention, intervention or recovery options<br />

for the user.


PREVENTION IS BETTER THAN CURE<br />

Keep your Ironwolf NAS drives healthy and your data safe<br />

with Ironwolf Health Management. Get notified ahead of<br />

failures and take preventative measures to reduce data loss<br />

through hard drive failures.<br />

FIND OUT MORE:<br />

seagate.com/ironwolf<br />

IRONWOLF PRO<br />

FOR AN AGILE NAS<br />

TOUGH • READY • SCALABLE<br />

LEARN MORE AT SEAGATE.COM<br />

in Synology NAS<br />

DS216J<br />

seagate.com<br />

© <strong>2017</strong> Seagate <strong>Tech</strong>nology LLC. All rights reserved.


POCKET<br />

VALUE<br />

64 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


SMARTPHONES GROUP TEST<br />

MONEY<br />

SMARTPHONES<br />

WITH FLAGSHIP PHONE PRICES GOING THROUGH THE ROOF, YOU COULD<br />

SAVE HUNDREDS OF DOLLARS BY HUNTING FOR A BETTER DEAL –<br />

WHETHER IT’S AN UP-TO-DATE BUDGET HANDSET THAT PUNCHES ABOVE<br />

ITS WEIGHT, OR A TOP-FLIGHT MODEL FROM YESTERYEAR. WE ROUND UP<br />

THE 11 HANDSETS THAT OFFER HIGH QUALITY AT A LOW PRICE POINT<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 65


I<br />

t seems almost churlish to complain<br />

that premium smartphones come<br />

with premium prices attached,<br />

especially when they do make an effort<br />

to earn it: to name just a few, there’s the<br />

new Samsung Galaxy S8, with its vast<br />

edge-to-edge display; the incredibly<br />

powerful iPhone 7; and the Google Pixel,<br />

which features the best rear camera on<br />

any handheld.<br />

And yet, for many appealing phones<br />

the costs are hard to stomach. The<br />

iPhone 7? Yours for<br />

$999, minimum.<br />

Google Pixel?<br />

A cool $900 for<br />

the base model.<br />

The Galaxy S8 is<br />

another offender,<br />

starting at $999.<br />

Fortunately, while the top end<br />

of the market is exploding, we’ve<br />

been consistently impressed by a<br />

lot of cheaper phones recently –<br />

specifically, how they deliver the kind<br />

of performance, display quality, battery<br />

life and build quality we’d expect from<br />

devices costing a lot more. For some, like<br />

the OnePlus 3T, this is a conscious design<br />

goal; others, like the Motorola Moto G4,<br />

just happen to be excellent pieces of<br />

hardware.<br />

We therefore wouldn’t hesitate to<br />

recommend a great lower- or mid-range<br />

smartphone over an overpriced flagship,<br />

66 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

but then, that’s not your only option.<br />

Even with the never-ending churn of the<br />

annual smartphone release cycle, you<br />

can still get older high-end models new<br />

and unwrapped, and the inevitable price<br />

drops that come with their age mean<br />

that it’s possible to find these premium<br />

products at heavily discounted rates.<br />

Therein lies the best thing about<br />

avoiding a smartphone rip-off: you’ve<br />

got a huge amount of choice when it<br />

comes to value handsets. Allow us to<br />

“Many cheaper phones now deliver the kind of<br />

performance, display quality, battery life and build<br />

quality we’d expect from devices costing a lot more”<br />

make things a bit easier with this test<br />

of 12 possible purchase candidates –<br />

we’ve skipped any duff phones and only<br />

included those that are at least very<br />

good, so you can be sure that with any of<br />

them, you’ll be getting a fair deal.<br />

CORE DRAW<br />

If pure performance is what you’re after,<br />

it’s generally better to go with an older<br />

flagship rather than a new budget phone;<br />

they might not be the fastest any more,<br />

but the best processors of 2015 and<br />

2016 can still easily outpace anything<br />

built to sell for peanuts, especially when<br />

it comes to games. For demanding 3D<br />

titles at their best, you’re looking at paying<br />

around $600 and up.<br />

Not that cheaper alternatives are<br />

necessarily slow. Hexa- and even octa-core<br />

processors aren’t uncommon even in the<br />

$300-$400 range, so it’s actually rather hard<br />

to find something that doesn’t stay slick and<br />

responsive throughout everyday multitasking.<br />

Special mention goes to the Apple A9 chip<br />

found within the iPhone SE; don’t be deceived<br />

by the fact that it’s dual-core, as Apple has<br />

somehow optimised it to run so well with iOS<br />

that it’s one of the bestperforming<br />

phones<br />

here.<br />

INCHING FORWARD<br />

It’s important that you<br />

choose a smartphone<br />

with your ideal screen size, as there’s no<br />

single ‘best’ spec here. The 4in iPhone SE is<br />

wonderfully portable but doesn’t offer nearly<br />

as much real estate as, say, the 5.5in Moto<br />

G5, which is arguably better for watching<br />

videos and web browsing but could prove<br />

uncomfortable for small hands.<br />

Otherwise, display quality can be measured<br />

in conveniently objective terms. We test<br />

for how much of the sRGB colour gamut<br />

a screen can cover (ideally, at least 90%),<br />

plus the contrast (higher is better) and peak<br />

brightness. A high brightness (over around<br />

400cd/m 2 ) will make the screen easier to<br />

read when exposed to direct daylight, though<br />

you can get away with a lower figure if you’ll


SMARTPHONES GROUP TEST<br />

and you’ll have to be very careful with<br />

saving music and movies.<br />

SENSOR SENSIBILITY<br />

Perhaps the most common pitfall for<br />

budget smartphones is the quality of the<br />

camera. Many models boast of having<br />

12-megapixel, 13-megapixel or even<br />

16-megapixel rear snappers, but image<br />

“It’s important you choose<br />

a smartphone with your<br />

ideal screen size”<br />

primarily be using your phone indoors.<br />

As for resolution, 1,920x1,080 is<br />

perfectly fine even on larger phablets;<br />

anything higher is nice to have, but it’s<br />

harder to tell the difference on such<br />

small screens compared to Full HD vs<br />

Quad HD monitors. That said, try not<br />

to settle for anything lower unless the<br />

screen is also smaller than average,<br />

as is the case with the Sony Xperia X<br />

Compact.<br />

ELECTRIC BOOGALOO<br />

Battery life is a no-brainer: the longer, the<br />

better. Naturally, a higher milliampere<br />

hour (mAh) count is preferable, but<br />

variables including the processor<br />

power, screen size, and brightness and<br />

frequency of use mean you shouldn’t rely<br />

on hard specs alone.<br />

That’s why we run a benchmark test,<br />

which involves looping a video file with<br />

the screen brightness set to 170cd/m 2<br />

and measuring how long this takes to<br />

run a full battery dry. Most phones fall<br />

around the 12-hour mark, which indicates<br />

the ability to make it through a full day of<br />

normal use on a single charge.<br />

LOST IN SPACE<br />

There was an odd period throughout late<br />

2015 and early 2016 in which smartphone<br />

manufacturers seemingly agreed that<br />

expandable storage wasn’t actually that<br />

important, and that they just wouldn’t<br />

bother with microSD slots – presumably<br />

another ‘brave’ decision along the lines<br />

of the iPhone 7’s missing headphone<br />

jack.<br />

Luckily, sanity has re-asserted itself,<br />

and most handsets these days adhere<br />

to the gold standard of expandable<br />

microSD compatibility. This is good<br />

because onboard storage can fill up<br />

at a surprising rate, particularly if it’s a<br />

relatively low capacity such as 16GB. Our<br />

advice would be to aim for a minimum of<br />

32GB of integrated memory, ideally with<br />

microSD support as a fallback; any lower<br />

THE BEST PHONES FOR…<br />

Got something specific in mind besides all-round quality? These are<br />

the great-value handsets that most effectively fill their niche<br />

…STYLE<br />

Samsung<br />

Galaxy S7<br />

It’s the most<br />

expensive<br />

smartphone in this<br />

group test, but not<br />

only is the Samsung<br />

Galaxy S7 still a<br />

sizable wad of cash<br />

less than the newer<br />

Galaxy S8, it’s also<br />

the most luxurious<br />

model here. From its<br />

glass and aluminium<br />

construction to its<br />

sleek, tapered edges<br />

and gorgeous display<br />

– which is almost<br />

bezel-less on the left<br />

and right edges – the<br />

S7 is a perfect showoff<br />

handset.<br />

It’s not just trading<br />

looks for practicality,<br />

either. That glass – on<br />

both sides – is highly damage-resistant<br />

Corning Gorilla Glass 4, and the handset<br />

meets the IP68 standard for dust- and waterproofing,<br />

so it will survive a dunk in any puddle<br />

or sink.<br />

size is only one aspect, and the ability<br />

to capture fine details and cut down on<br />

visual noise are even more important.<br />

Here, a lot of cheaper devices can<br />

struggle, especially indoors.<br />

We’ll cover each phone’s main camera<br />

in more detail in their respective reviews.<br />

To be fair, there are a few models that<br />

do manage to excel at photography: the<br />

Moto G4 is your best bet at the budget<br />

end, while the LG G4, Nexus 5X and<br />

Samsung Galaxy S7 all impress at higher<br />

price points.<br />

…CUSTOMISATION<br />

Motorola Moto Z Play<br />

The Moto Z Play’s versatility is mainly<br />

derived from its modular design. There<br />

are loads of clip-on attachments<br />

available, from simple expanded batteries<br />

to booming speakers and camera grips<br />

with added optical zoom capability.<br />

One – the Moto Insta-<br />

Share – even turns<br />

the handset into a<br />

projector.<br />

It’s all very<br />

impressive stuff,<br />

although it’s easily<br />

possible to spend<br />

more on these<br />

‘Moto Mods’ than<br />

you did on the<br />

actual phone.<br />

Luckily, you can<br />

still add a personal<br />

touch on the<br />

(relative) cheap with<br />

interchangeable<br />

backplates – these<br />

cost $20 and come<br />

in some unusual<br />

finishes, including<br />

nylon fabric and oak<br />

wood.<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 67


Apple iPhone SE<br />

WELL BUILT AND WITH A TOP CAMERA AND GREAT BATTERY<br />

LIFE, THE IPHONE SE IS THE BEST 4IN PHONE OUT THERE<br />

inding an affordable iphone is<br />

practically impossible if you stick<br />

F to the main series of handsets.<br />

Even the iPhone 6, which is now two<br />

generations old (having been replaced<br />

by the iPhone 6s and, most recently, the<br />

iPhone 7), goes for about $1,000 SIM-free.<br />

And that’s if you can actually find it new,<br />

among the far more prevalent refurbs.<br />

Hope remains with Apple’s smaller 4in<br />

models. For minimum expense, there’s<br />

the iPhone 5c, which has fallen well below<br />

the $250 mark, albeit at the cost of a<br />

plasticky build and slow performance.<br />

By contrast, the much more up-todate<br />

iPhone SE has nailed pretty much<br />

everything: it’s got the build quality, it’s<br />

got the processing power and it’s got<br />

the camera, all packed into a neat metal<br />

chassis.<br />

What’s more, on the same day we<br />

began work on this group test, Apple<br />

announced that the 16GB and 64GB<br />

storage options would be replaced by<br />

32GB and 128GB models respectively,<br />

addressing our previous criticism that the<br />

cheapest model’s capacity<br />

was too low. All other hardware<br />

remains the same.<br />

Weighing 113g and at 7.6mm<br />

thick, the iPhone SE is exactly<br />

the same size as the old<br />

iPhone 5s, and is compatible<br />

with the same range of cases<br />

and covers. While the SE is<br />

the lightest iPhone currently<br />

available, it’s actually the thickest of the<br />

current crop.<br />

This doesn’t particularly matter, as it<br />

makes the handset easier to grip, and it<br />

means that the camera sits flush with<br />

the rear of the case. Besides, overall the<br />

iPhone SE is comparatively tiny by today’s<br />

standards, slipping easily into any pocket.<br />

DENSITY SLICKER<br />

Moving back to a 4in screen, Apple has<br />

re-used the iPhone 5s’s resolution of<br />

1,136x640. This is one of the lowest-resolution<br />

phones here, not even hitting standard<br />

HD, but the pixel density of 326ppi<br />

actually matches that of the 2015 iPhone<br />

6s, which has a resolution of 1,334x750.<br />

Both phones are definitely sharp enough,<br />

and text looks clear and easy to read.<br />

Image quality isn’t quite as good as<br />

Apple’s pricier iPhones, but the iPhone<br />

SE’s screen performs better than stated:<br />

Apple claims maximum brightness<br />

68 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

of 500cd/m2 and a<br />

contrast ratio of 800:1,<br />

but we measured it at<br />

577cd/m2 with a contrast<br />

ratio of 892:1. While this<br />

contrast ratio still isn’t<br />

great, its colour accuracy<br />

coverage of 94.6% of<br />

the sRGB colour gamut<br />

goes some way to make<br />

up for it.<br />

Apple has fitted a<br />

12-megapixel camera<br />

into the iPhone SE, the<br />

same as in the iPhone 6s.<br />

It’s a great all-rounder,<br />

ably adapting to most<br />

situations to produce<br />

well-exposed shots with<br />

plenty of detail in them.<br />

The HDR mode captures a particularly<br />

excellent dynamic range, without overprocessing<br />

the final shots.<br />

There’s also a True Tone LED flash,<br />

which measures ambient light then fires<br />

the flash at the same colour temperature,<br />

“The iPhone SE has nailed pretty much<br />

everything: it’s got the build quality,<br />

it’s got the processing power and it’s<br />

got the camera, all packed into a neat<br />

metal chassis”<br />

reducing the tell-tale signs of a regular<br />

flash. You also get all the shooting<br />

modes that the iPhone 6s has, including<br />

panoramic shots and 4K video.<br />

CLOUD A9<br />

Performance is excellent, thanks to the<br />

iPhone SE having the same 1.8GHz A9<br />

processor and 2GB of RAM as the 6s lineup.<br />

In Geekbench, the iPhone SE scored<br />

2,550 in the single-core test – the same<br />

as the iPhone 6s and faster than the 2,115<br />

scored by the Samsung Galaxy S7. In the<br />

multicore test, the S7 takes the lead with<br />

a score of 6,437, but that’s a quad-core<br />

device: the iPhone SE has a dual-core<br />

processor and still scored 4,444.<br />

As with all of Apple’s phones, the slick<br />

combination of the processor, iOS and<br />

Safari makes web browsing a supersmooth<br />

experience: the Peacekeeper<br />

browser benchmark score of 4,761 is one<br />

of the best we’ve seen on a smartphone.<br />

The iPhone SE<br />

absolutely delivers<br />

on battery life, too.<br />

Its 1,624mAh battery<br />

might sound pretty<br />

tiny compared to the<br />

3,000mAh+ batteries<br />

found on Android phones,<br />

but its smaller screen<br />

requires a lot less power.<br />

As a result, it lasted an<br />

incredible 16h 46m at a<br />

brightness of 170cd/m2<br />

in our battery test. This<br />

is just shy of the Galaxy<br />

S7’s run time, and 1h 48m<br />

longer than the iPhone 6s<br />

lasted.<br />

Since launching with<br />

iOS 9.3, the iPhone SE has<br />

been updated all the way up to iOS 10.2<br />

– with 10.3 coming very soon, if it’s not<br />

out already by the time you read this.<br />

This means it’s been able to benefit from<br />

third-party integration for iMessage and<br />

Siri, redesigned Maps and Music apps<br />

and the Memories feature for<br />

sorting images in Photos. Apple<br />

Pay support remains, though<br />

the iPhone SE uses an older<br />

TouchID sensor, which isn’t<br />

quite as fast or error-proof as<br />

on pricier iPhones.<br />

MAKE ROOM<br />

As mentioned, the original 16GB<br />

and 64GB models have been discontinued,<br />

replaced by 32GB ($679) and 128GB<br />

($829) variants. The price bumps are a<br />

shame (bear in mind these are largely the<br />

same phones that launched back in March<br />

2016) but otherwise, that’s fine by us; 16GB<br />

isn’t much space at all, especially with the<br />

lack of expandable storage.<br />

The iPhone SE surpassed our<br />

expectations when it first came out, and<br />

now the minimum storage issue has<br />

been dealt with, it’s become even better.<br />

Really, the only thing it lacks compared<br />

to the iPhone 6s is 3D Touch. For anyone<br />

who still hankers after a powerful 4in<br />

smartphone, it’s an amazing choice.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$679 • www.apple.com/au<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5


SMARTPHONES GROUP TEST<br />

Google Nexus 5X<br />

IT’S OVER A YEAR OLD, BUT THE NEXUS 5X REMAINS A<br />

SUPERB ANDROID HANDSET FOR A REASONABLE PRICE<br />

W<br />

hile we’re fond of the Pixel and<br />

Pixel XL, Google’s most recent<br />

smartphones, they both went<br />

down the ultra-premium route, abandoning<br />

the surprising affordability of the previousgeneration<br />

Nexus 6P and Nexus 5X.<br />

Happily, the latter is still an excellent<br />

choice. It doesn’t make the best first<br />

impression; made of plastic, it looks like a<br />

budget handset, with utterly featureless<br />

side buttons that are so simple as to<br />

appear an afterthought.<br />

It’s great to hold, though. The plastic<br />

finish provides plenty of grip and, at 136g,<br />

it’s among the lightest phones around.<br />

The shape is good too, with the rear panel<br />

neatly meeting the front bezels. The frontfacing<br />

speakers provide better audio than<br />

any tiny port tucked away at the bottom<br />

of some flagship smartphones.<br />

POKE’S ON YOU<br />

Underneath the unassuming exterior<br />

lies a powerful smartphone packed with<br />

features. The circular rear fingerprint<br />

sensor is placed just below the rear<br />

camera, so you may have to adjust your<br />

grip if you’re used to holding your phone<br />

by the edges, but otherwise it’s easily<br />

accessible. Resting your finger on the<br />

sensor switches on and unlocks the phone<br />

almost instantly. It’s accurate too, learning<br />

fingerprints even quicker than the sensors<br />

in Samsung’s flagship phones, and<br />

recognising them more consistently.<br />

There’s also a USB Type-C port. It’s<br />

a little chunkier and feels sturdier than<br />

Micro USB, and the reversible design helps<br />

minimise fiddling. However, USB Type-C<br />

cables still aren’t exactly common, and<br />

Google includes only a Type-C to Type-C<br />

cable in the box. There’s no video output,<br />

and data transfer rates are only at USB2<br />

speeds. Wireless charging has been<br />

dropped, too, but Type-C allows for fast<br />

charging, reaching 50% from flat in just<br />

30 minutes.<br />

A 2,700mAh battery is par for the<br />

course, given this is a pretty slim 7.9mm<br />

handset. In our continuous video playback<br />

test, it lasted 10h 14m. This is one area<br />

where the 5X hasn’t aged well, as many<br />

more recent phones beat this by miles.<br />

Still, the Qualcomm Snapdragon 808<br />

chipset means the Nexus 5X is no slouch.<br />

It consists of two high-performance<br />

Cortex A57 cores running at 1.8GHz, and<br />

four power-efficient Cortex A53 cores<br />

running at 1.44GHz.<br />

A Geekbench<br />

multicore score of<br />

3,489 puts it alongside<br />

the similarly specified<br />

LG G4. It’s not the<br />

best, but in practice<br />

everything is quick<br />

and smooth. It’s well<br />

ahead of the Moto Z<br />

Play’s Snapdragon<br />

625, which scored<br />

only 2,599. In terms of<br />

gaming, it doesn’t run<br />

3D titles as smoothly<br />

as most high-end<br />

smartphones, but<br />

it played our usual<br />

selection of Android<br />

titles without a hitch.<br />

Amidst all that is a decent Full HD<br />

LCD screen. Even at 5.2in across it has<br />

a whopping pixel density of 424ppi<br />

and, despite higher resolutions being<br />

available, there’s no serious advantage<br />

in day-to-day use. In objective tests, the<br />

screen stood up well, covering 94.8% of<br />

the sRGB colour gamut, with 415cd/m2<br />

maximum brightness, a contrast level of<br />

1,309:1 and a black level of 0.32cd/m2.<br />

We’ve seen brighter LCDs at this price,<br />

but the Nexus 5X nails consistency. It<br />

also has a pleasingly flat colour output,<br />

without the boosted and garish shades<br />

seen elsewhere.<br />

In most areas, the Nexus 5X may<br />

be pretty good, but its camera is truly<br />

excellent, coming out on top against<br />

the very capable Samsung Galaxy S6.<br />

Twelve megapixels on a typically sized<br />

1/2.3in sensor sounds unremarkable, but<br />

each pixel is bigger than most, measuring<br />

1.55um. By comparison, the S6 reportedly<br />

has 1.12um pixels on its 16-megapixel<br />

sensor.<br />

The Nexus 5X’s photos were packed<br />

with detail, compared to the more<br />

smoothed off appearance of the Galaxy<br />

S6’s efforts. Outdoors, you can see great<br />

detail in brick walls and a sharper image<br />

overall. Colour balance was spot on, too,<br />

with the camera matching the output of<br />

the S6 almost exactly.<br />

It dealt well with higher-contrast<br />

scenes, eliminating noise from large<br />

areas of colour without removing detail<br />

elsewhere. Colours remained accurate<br />

indoors, with great detail in complex<br />

textures and well-balanced exposures<br />

across our various lighting setups.<br />

“In most areas, the Nexus<br />

5X may be pretty good,<br />

but its camera is truly<br />

excellent”<br />

The Nexus 5X was quick to shoot in<br />

HDR mode, and you can jump straight to<br />

the camera by double-clicking the power<br />

button. Google’s camera app is fine for<br />

basic snapping, but lacks any manual<br />

controls or fancy features.<br />

THE SWEETEST THING<br />

Being a Google device, the Nexus 5X<br />

was among the first smartphones to<br />

be updated to Android 7.0 Nougat. This<br />

adds a good few improvements and<br />

new functions to the already-great<br />

Android 6.0, such as native split-screen<br />

multitasking, bundled notifications and<br />

a Data Saver mode, which can block<br />

background apps from using data.<br />

The Nexus 5X isn’t the best-looking<br />

phone, nor the best designed. It isn’t the<br />

fastest, it doesn’t have the best battery<br />

life and the screen isn’t outstanding. Don’t<br />

be fooled by the lack of standout features,<br />

however – it also has a distinct lack of<br />

weaknesses, and few handsets can claim<br />

the 5X’s comprehensive competence. As<br />

such, it’s a device that’s far greater than<br />

the sum of its parts.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$429 • www.google.com.au<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 69


GROUP TEST SMARTPHONES<br />

LG G4<br />

WITH ITS VIBRANT SCREEN,<br />

VERSATILE CAMERA AND<br />

SURPRISINGLY COMFY LEATHER<br />

REAR, THE LG G4 STILL HOLDS<br />

ITS OWN<br />

A<br />

lthough lg didn’t stick with the g4’s<br />

leather backing for its G5 and G6<br />

handsets, it was still a fantastic<br />

flagship smartphone when it launched<br />

in 2015 – and now that it’s over $600<br />

cheaper than on release, it makes a great<br />

alternative to newer mid-rangers.<br />

Measuring 149x75x8.9mm, it’s not<br />

the slimmest of phones, but the leather<br />

cladding adds a real premium feel. The<br />

same goes for the 5.5in display, which has<br />

a 2,560x1,440 resolution producing a crisp<br />

534ppi. LG’s IPS Quantum panel helps out<br />

here, showing lovely rich, vibrant colours<br />

and eye-searingly bright whites. We<br />

measured peak brightness as 505.66cd/<br />

m2, so colours look just as punchy out in<br />

the sun as they do indoors.<br />

Blacks were deep at 0.27cd/m2, and<br />

the huge contrast ratio of<br />

1,715:1 stands up to <strong>2017</strong><br />

standards. Its sRGB colour<br />

gamut coverage of 96.3%<br />

is also respectable for an<br />

IPS screen, though this does<br />

point to LG overstating the<br />

G4’s capabilities somewhat – it was<br />

supposedly able to reach 98% of the<br />

wider Digital Cinema Initiative (DCI) colour<br />

gamut, which equates to about 120%<br />

sRGB coverage. This, evidently, was not<br />

backed up by our testing.<br />

The G4’s other headline feature is the<br />

16-megapixel camera, which makes it the<br />

first to have a colour spectrum sensor on<br />

the back, which LG says is able to read<br />

and interpret colours in exactly the same<br />

way as your own eyeballs. Indeed, colours<br />

looked very natural in outdoor shots.<br />

ABLE SETTINGS<br />

Manual mode is the star here, though.<br />

This gives you control over white balance,<br />

manual focus, shutter speed and ISO live<br />

onscreen, giving you plenty of flexible<br />

controls to be a little more creative with<br />

your photography. Photo enthusiasts will<br />

also appreciate the ability to save photos<br />

as Raw files.<br />

LG has also included a quick launch<br />

mode, so you can take instant snapshots<br />

without having to unlock the phone first.<br />

It’s certainly very handy, but we wish it<br />

hadn’t been mapped to the rear lower<br />

volume button, as this is possibly one of<br />

the least accessible buttons on the entire<br />

phone, particularly if you’re trying to shoot<br />

70 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

“The G4 has a colour spectrum sensor,<br />

which LG says is able to interpret colours<br />

in the same way as your own eyeballs”<br />

in landscape mode.<br />

Rather than the Qualcomm Snapdragon<br />

810 favoured by other 2015 flagship<br />

phones, the G4 contains the slightly<br />

slower hexa-core 1.8GHz Snapdragon<br />

808 chip, plus 3GB of RAM. This showed<br />

in our benchmarks: in Geekbench 3,<br />

the multicore result of 2,547 is a long<br />

way behind both old and new high-end<br />

smartphones, from the Galaxy S6 to the<br />

OnePlus 3T. Likewise, the G4’s single-core<br />

result of just 692 has even been surpassed<br />

by budget phones – hardly a ringing<br />

endorsement for something that cost<br />

$929 on its release.<br />

However, benchmarks are only part<br />

of the story, and the G4 feels beautifully<br />

smooth when multitasking with different<br />

apps or browsing media-heavy web<br />

pages. It also coped well with games, as it<br />

ran Hearthstone, Threes! and Alphabear<br />

perfectly well, despite its somewhat<br />

average benchmarking results: it only<br />

produced 921 frames in the offscreen<br />

GFXBench GL Manhattan test, which<br />

equates to 15fps.<br />

SWAP MEET<br />

The G4 has a few more advantages as<br />

well: it actually has removable storage<br />

(microSD support up to 128GB), which<br />

the Galaxy S6 and Nexus 5X neglected to<br />

include, and the battery can be removed<br />

and replaced, something you can’t do<br />

on metal unibody handsets. The G4’s<br />

battery benchmark result of 11h 58m isn’t<br />

amazing when compared to more recent<br />

alternatives, but you could carry around<br />

spares. We can also see the first glimpses<br />

of the LG G5 modularity in the G4’s ability<br />

to take larger, third-party battery packs.<br />

Following an update from Android 5.1,<br />

the G4 currently runs Android 6.0 – 7.0 (or<br />

more likely, 7.1) isn’t expected to roll out on<br />

this older model until later in <strong>2017</strong>, which<br />

is a shame. Whatever Android version is<br />

installed, it comes with LG’s UX interface<br />

over the top. Unlike most custom skins,<br />

we quite like this one; its Knock Code<br />

feature offers an effective alternative way<br />

to unlock your smartphone, by tapping out<br />

a specific pattern on the screen, while the<br />

Smart Settings menu can enable things<br />

such as changing the sound profile once<br />

you get home, or automatically opening<br />

Spotify when you plug in headphones.<br />

Meanwhile, Smart Power Saving will<br />

warn you when apps are using too much<br />

power, and create a Smart Notice prompt<br />

to let you shut them down in order to help<br />

save battery. Likewise, the G4 will put the<br />

CPU to sleep when there’s<br />

nothing happening on the<br />

display, helping you squeeze a<br />

few more hours out of it when<br />

the phone is locked.<br />

AGE BEFORE BEAUTY<br />

The G4 may not be as powerful as other<br />

flagship smartphones – especially<br />

those that have been released in the<br />

past two years – but it certainly has a<br />

wealth of features to help it stand out<br />

from the competition. The leather back<br />

is surprisingly elegant, and we definitely<br />

prefer it to the slippery glass of the<br />

Samsung Galaxy range. The G4 camera’s<br />

unique colour spectrum sensor also puts<br />

it neck-and-neck with the camera on the<br />

back of the S6, and its display looks just<br />

as sharp and punchy as Samsung’s Super<br />

AMOLED panels.<br />

It’s also an unusually flexible<br />

smartphone; not to the extent of<br />

modular devices such as the Moto Z<br />

Play (nor indeed its successor, the G5),<br />

but the inclusion of a microSD slot and<br />

a removable battery makes the G4 a<br />

very accommodating handset indeed.<br />

There are many faster and longer-lasting<br />

alternatives, but at less than $300 this is<br />

absolutely worth the cash.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$270 • From www.lg.com<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5


Motorola Moto G4<br />

FAST SPEEDS, AN EXCELLENT CAMERA, LONG BATTERY<br />

LIFE – THE MOTO G4 IS A BUDGET MASTERPIECE<br />

W<br />

e’ll get to the newer moto g5<br />

soon, but it’s worth noting that<br />

for over a year now, the Moto G4<br />

has been the yardstick by which all other<br />

budget smartphones have been judged.<br />

It’s only recently that genuine alternatives<br />

have arrived, such is its phenomenal<br />

balance of quality and thriftiness.<br />

In particular, its octa-core 1.5GHz<br />

Qualcomm Snapdragon 617 processor<br />

and 2GB of RAM give it serious power. In<br />

Geekbench 3, the Moto G4 scored 717 in<br />

the single-core test and a massive 3,107<br />

in the multicore test, about what we’d<br />

expect from a good mid-range device.<br />

Indeed, these scores are on a par with<br />

those of the HTC One A9, which costs<br />

twice as much.<br />

It’s lovely to use on a day-to-day basis,<br />

and it’s even a pretty capable gaming<br />

machine, too. While its GFXBench GL<br />

offscreen Manhattan 3.0 score of 412<br />

frames (around 6.6fps) can’t match, say,<br />

the Nexus 5X, we still managed to play<br />

Hearthstone without too much stutter,<br />

and simpler games such as Threes!<br />

worked like a dream.<br />

Web browsing has also been<br />

significantly improved over the 3rd Gen<br />

Moto G, its direct predecessor. Despite a<br />

curiously lower Peacekeeper score (632<br />

to the Moto G’s 731),<br />

scrolling through<br />

media-heavy<br />

pages was much<br />

smoother on the<br />

G4, and images,<br />

videos and adverts<br />

all loaded faster<br />

too.<br />

HOUR SURGE<br />

All this power<br />

doesn’t come at<br />

the cost of battery life, either, as the Moto<br />

G4’s large 3,000mAh battery lasted an<br />

impressive 13h 39m in our continuous<br />

video test. That’s fantastic for a budget<br />

smartphone, beating the much more<br />

expensive LG G4 and Samsung Galaxy<br />

S6 (although only by two minutes in the<br />

latter’s case).<br />

Be mindful, however, that the Moto G4<br />

is very much in phablet territory, with its<br />

screen measuring 5.5in diagonally. That<br />

makes it quite a handful, and the flat back<br />

makes it slightly less comfortable than<br />

the previous Moto G, at least in our hands.<br />

Fortunately, though, it didn’t take long to<br />

get used to.<br />

“Its octa-core processor<br />

and 2GB of RAM give the<br />

G4 serious power – it’s<br />

lovely to use on a day-today<br />

basis, and it’s even<br />

a pretty capable gaming<br />

machine”<br />

Still, the overall design<br />

could be better: the subtle<br />

crosshatch pattern on<br />

the rear isn’t particularly<br />

elegant and it’s lost the<br />

3rd Gen Moto G’s IP67<br />

waterproofing, though its<br />

water-repellent coating<br />

should still provide<br />

adequate protection from<br />

splashes or a light rain<br />

shower.<br />

Those who like to<br />

customise their handset<br />

using Motorola’s Moto<br />

Maker service might also<br />

be a little disappointed,<br />

as the G4’s options are<br />

decidedly less fun than<br />

those of its predecessors. It doesn’t cost<br />

any extra to change the colour of the back<br />

panel, but the shades on offer are rather<br />

more muted than the bright yellows and<br />

searing limes of yesteryear. The choice of<br />

metallic accents around the camera are<br />

also rather uninspiring, but considering<br />

it’s free, you may as well personalise it as<br />

much as you can to get the look you want.<br />

The only thing you do have to pay<br />

extra for on Moto Maker is if you want to<br />

upgrade the Moto G4’s storage to 32GB.<br />

This costs an extra<br />

$70 or so, but when<br />

the G4 comes with<br />

a microSD slot that<br />

takes cards up to<br />

128GB anyway, this<br />

seems like a bit of a<br />

waste of money.<br />

VISION<br />

ACCOMPLISHED<br />

It’s a shame the<br />

display (and by<br />

extension, the whole handset) isn’t a<br />

bit smaller, but at least Motorola has<br />

provided it with a 1,920x1,080 resolution,<br />

giving it a sharp pixel density of 401ppi.<br />

Our colour-calibration tests showed it<br />

was displaying a respectable 90% of<br />

the sRGB colour gamut, and its contrast<br />

ratio of 1,693:1 is most impressive as<br />

well. It’s also considerably brighter than<br />

its predecessor, as it’s able to reach a<br />

peak brightness of 539.51cd/m2, making<br />

it much easier to see outdoors in direct<br />

sunshine. These are, again, brilliant<br />

results for a budget smartphone, and<br />

its punchy colours look great regardless<br />

of whether you’re browsing the web or<br />

looking at photos in your<br />

gallery.<br />

Speaking of which, the<br />

G4’s rear 13-megapixel<br />

camera remains our<br />

favourite budget<br />

smartphone snapper<br />

– and that includes the<br />

one on the Moto G5.<br />

Despite sharing the same<br />

resolution as the 3rd Gen<br />

Moto G, the difference<br />

in quality is plain to see,<br />

as the Moto G4 captures<br />

far more detail, and<br />

everything looks that<br />

much sharper.<br />

Outdoors, for instance,<br />

colours looked accurate<br />

and its exposure was expertly judged. It<br />

blurred the occasional bit of brickwork,<br />

but overall it produced truly excellent<br />

photos. It looks as if Motorola has toned<br />

down its HDR mode this year as well, as<br />

rather than make images appear overly<br />

artificial, it simply makes them look richer<br />

and more vibrant, so you’ll probably want<br />

to leave it on to get the best exposures.<br />

CUT TO THE QUICK<br />

Motorola also simplified the camera<br />

app’s UI – an action reversed for the G5,<br />

in some ways – to give it a dedicated<br />

onscreen shutter button and easy<br />

shortcuts to toggle the flash, HDR and<br />

timer on and off. Tap the screen to<br />

focus, and you can easily adjust the lens<br />

aperture using the onscreen slider as well,<br />

which works brilliantly and shows you<br />

your results in real-time.<br />

The camera was also an excellent<br />

performer indoors, as noise was kept to<br />

a minimum even in low-light conditions,<br />

and detail levels were still pleasingly<br />

high. Some of the objects in our stilllife<br />

arrangement were a touch grainy in<br />

places, but switching on the excellent<br />

LED flash quickly sorted this out.<br />

We’ve covered the G5 in more detail<br />

on the next page, but in short we’d rather<br />

stick with the G4. That a smartphone<br />

can achieve so much for so little is as<br />

astounding today as it was in 2016.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$232 • www.motorola.com.au<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

72 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


SMARTPHONES GROUP TEST<br />

Motorola Moto G5<br />

THE HEIR TO THE KING OF BUDGET SMARTPHONES<br />

ISN’T AS GOOD AS WE’D HOPED<br />

T<br />

his should be an exciting occasion:<br />

the follow-up to 2016’s best budget<br />

phone by a mile, the Moto G4,<br />

updated with stylish metal bodywork<br />

and the latest Android 7.0 Nougat. Sadly,<br />

though, the new Moto G5 is a device we<br />

can only appreciate with caveats.<br />

Let’s start with the good. As mentioned,<br />

both this and the larger Moto G5 Plus<br />

(which we’ll cover in more detail in a<br />

future issue) have ditched the plastic<br />

backplates of previous Moto G handsets<br />

in favour of a sleeker, slinkier metal design.<br />

Although there’s the risk that this will<br />

scuff, scratch and dent rather more easily<br />

than the textured plastic rear of previous<br />

generations, out of the box the Moto G5<br />

looks very fine indeed.<br />

In fact, this is a lovely phone to hold<br />

– not slippery, and with just the right<br />

amount of grip – and the fine-grained<br />

matt finish on the rear is a big step<br />

forward in terms of sophistication. Note,<br />

however, that the phone isn’t all metal<br />

– only the rear panel is. The edges are<br />

constructed from plastic just as they were<br />

before.<br />

DOWNSIZING MEASURES<br />

The Moto G5 is also a little more practical<br />

than its pricier brother, with a removable<br />

battery, microSD card support (up to<br />

128GB) and dual-SIM support. The Moto<br />

G5 Plus has both a microSD slot and<br />

dual-SIM support, but you can’t replace<br />

the battery.<br />

Both phones now include a new<br />

front-mounted fingerprint reader and,<br />

thankfully, have Android 7.0 Nougat preinstalled.<br />

There’s also NFC, so you can<br />

finally use Moto’s cheapest handset to<br />

pay for goods.<br />

One key thing to note with the Moto G5,<br />

however, is that the screen is 0.5in smaller<br />

than on the Moto G4. It’s a surprising<br />

downgrade but on the plus side there’s no<br />

denying the Moto G5 is more pocketable<br />

and easier to use one-handed.<br />

Since the resolution has stayed the<br />

same, at 1,920x1,080, it also looks just<br />

as sharp. Alas, along with the reduction<br />

in size, our testing reveals the Moto G5’s<br />

screen has also taken a hit on quality.<br />

Peak brightness is down from the G4’s<br />

539.51cd/m2 to 471cd/m2, and sRGB<br />

colour coverage is also down to 85.8%.<br />

The result is a slightly duller, less vibrant<br />

display, and while the difference between<br />

the two phones isn’t night and day, it’s still<br />

disappointing that the Moto G5 is inferior.<br />

Under the hood, it’s<br />

a similar story. The<br />

base Moto G5 comes<br />

with a Qualcomm<br />

Snapdragon 430<br />

and 2GB of RAM;<br />

we tested the<br />

slightly higher-spec<br />

3GB version, but<br />

this didn’t prevent<br />

it landing slightly<br />

behind the Moto<br />

G4 in Geekbench<br />

benchmarks, with<br />

scores of 578 in the<br />

single-core test and<br />

2,379 in the multicore<br />

test. It also merely<br />

matches the G4’s<br />

7fps average in both<br />

GFX Manhattan’s<br />

onscreen and<br />

offscreen tests, so<br />

it’s no better for<br />

gaming.<br />

So, not only does<br />

the Moto G5 fail<br />

to improve on its<br />

predecessor, but it<br />

lags even further<br />

behind newer<br />

budget challengers.<br />

We were hoping<br />

that the trade-off for this would be<br />

improved battery life, but in our video test,<br />

the Moto G5 achieved a time of 11h 51m,<br />

which is 1h 48m short of the Moto G4. This<br />

isn’t disastrous, of course, but heavy users<br />

may well find that they need to top up<br />

the phone’s charge more often that they<br />

would the G4 – another disappointment.<br />

FOCUS POCUS<br />

Motorola says it has improved the camera<br />

over the G4, though, adding phase-detect<br />

autofocus to speed up capture. However,<br />

the snapper’s core specifications remain<br />

the same, with an aperture of f/2 and<br />

resolution of 13 megapixels.<br />

These look to be impressive<br />

specifications on a sub-$300 phone.<br />

They were last year, and the Moto G4’s<br />

camera was very good indeed at the price.<br />

However, on the evidence of our tests the<br />

new camera module in the G5 isn’t all that<br />

wonderful.<br />

Outdoors, in brightly lit conditions, the<br />

Moto G5’s rear camera does perform<br />

splendidly, capturing photographs with<br />

even crisper details and richer colours<br />

“Not only does the Moto<br />

G5 fail to improve on<br />

its predecessor, but it<br />

lags even further behind<br />

newer budget challengers,<br />

namely the Honor 6X and<br />

Lenovo P2”<br />

than the G4. Exposures<br />

are balanced and focus<br />

assured.<br />

It’s an accomplished<br />

snapper and the<br />

improved camera<br />

software is a bonus, too.<br />

We particularly like its<br />

ability to automatically<br />

detect hand shake and<br />

snap multiple frames,<br />

upon which it offers you<br />

the choice between two<br />

frames, the second of<br />

which is often sharper<br />

than the first you fired off.<br />

In the low light of<br />

indoor scenes, however,<br />

images aren’t great.<br />

Photographs of our stilllife<br />

scene exhibited<br />

significantly higher<br />

levels of noise,<br />

smearing and handshake<br />

induced blur<br />

than on the Moto<br />

G4, and enabling<br />

the flash doesn’t<br />

help much either.<br />

Although it doesn’t<br />

wash out the image,<br />

it does add an<br />

unnatural orangeypink<br />

tinge to the whole scene that looks<br />

far from attractive.<br />

ECONOMIC WARFARE<br />

One thing we can’t fault is the price. This<br />

sub-$300 device packs a punch for that<br />

kind of money, and as it turns out, you can<br />

take a few steps back from something as<br />

excellent as the Moto G4 and still be left<br />

with a pretty good handset.<br />

That, however, is also the issue. The<br />

Moto G5 only makes improvements in<br />

a few minor ways, and has got worse in<br />

others. That’s not a recipe for a must-have<br />

device when the Moto G4, are readily<br />

available as alternatives.<br />

As such, the only way we can<br />

recommend the Moto G5 is if you’re<br />

utterly determined to have the very latest<br />

product.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$399 17GB, $449 32GB • www.motorola.com.au<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 73


GROUP TEST SMARTPHONES<br />

Motorola Moto Z Play<br />

THE MOTO Z PLAY’S STUPENDOUS BATTERY LIFE AND MODULAR DESIGN MAKE IT A GREAT BUY<br />

ike the Oneplus 3t, the Moto z play<br />

aims to provide flagship-quality<br />

L features while undercutting them on<br />

price. Take, for example, the big 3,510mAh<br />

battery inside – that even dwarfs the<br />

2,600mAh of its own bigger brother, the<br />

Moto Z. It thus lasted almost twice as long<br />

in our continuous video loop benchmark,<br />

clocking in at an outstanding 23h 45m.<br />

It’s clear where Motorola has stashed<br />

all those extra milliampere hours in the<br />

Moto Z Play. Measuring a sizable 6.9mm<br />

at its thinnest point, the phone feels<br />

positively behemoth-like compared with<br />

the svelte 5.2mm Moto Z, and its lightly<br />

chamfered edges are sharper and harder<br />

against your palm. That’s not to say the<br />

Moto Z Play is uncomfortable to hold, but<br />

it definitely feels a little gawky compared<br />

to its luxuriously slim stablemate.<br />

Girth aside, however, the Moto Z Play<br />

looks every bit the top-end smartphone.<br />

Its front-facing fingerprint sensor is every<br />

bit as quick when it comes to unlocking<br />

your phone, and its glass rear and metal<br />

frame represent a huge leap forward in<br />

overall build quality compared to the<br />

rubberised rear of last year’s Moto X Play.<br />

It also shares the Moto Z’s main<br />

party trick: its modularity. While its rear<br />

connection point might not look quite as<br />

elegant as its big brother’s, it supports all<br />

the same Moto Mod<br />

accessories, allowing<br />

you to augment your<br />

smartphone with<br />

stereo speakers, an<br />

upgraded camera or<br />

just even more battery<br />

life.<br />

RULE THE BOOST<br />

It’s all easily done<br />

– each mod simply<br />

snaps on to the back<br />

of the phone with<br />

strong connecting<br />

magnets. You might<br />

need to dig your nails<br />

in to prise them off,<br />

but it’s definitely less<br />

hassle than the system<br />

on the modular LG<br />

G5. Motorola is also<br />

planning on making<br />

these mods compatible<br />

with at least two<br />

more generations of<br />

Moto Z phones, so<br />

you should be able to<br />

carry on using them<br />

74 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

even if you upgrade. Our favourite mod<br />

so far is the JBL SoundBoost speaker,<br />

which is a massive improvement on the<br />

handset’s own tinny speaker, and includes<br />

its own 1,000mAh battery.<br />

Where the Moto Z Play starts to deviate<br />

from the Moto Z is its internal hardware;<br />

the former has to make do with the midtier<br />

octa-core 2GHz Snapdragon 625.<br />

It also has 3GB of RAM, rather than the<br />

Moto Z’s 4GB. This is still a pretty potent<br />

combination for everyday tasks, but the<br />

difference showed in our benchmarks. In<br />

Geekbench 4, the Moto Z Play scored only<br />

798 in the single-core test and 2,599 in<br />

the multicore test, making it almost half<br />

as fast as the Moto Z overall.<br />

To be fair, this is to be somewhat<br />

expected for a mid-range phone, but<br />

when you consider the OnePlus 3T also<br />

has a Snapdragon 821 chip, the Moto Z<br />

Play starts to look slightly less special.<br />

The same goes for graphics<br />

performance: it achieved a mere 636<br />

frames (an average of 10fps) in GFXBench<br />

GL’s onscreen Manhattan 3.0 test. The<br />

OnePlus 3T, by comparison, achieved a<br />

47fps average.<br />

BLANKET COVERAGE<br />

The Moto Z Play shares the Moto Z’s 5.5in<br />

AMOLED panel, but with a 1,920x1,080<br />

resolution, rather than<br />

2,560x1,440. In the<br />

cheaper phone’s defence,<br />

we were hard-pressed<br />

to tell the difference<br />

in terms of overall<br />

sharpness. The Moto Z<br />

Play’s vanilla version of<br />

Android 6.0 looks just<br />

as crisp as it does on the<br />

Moto Z.<br />

More importantly,<br />

the quality of the Moto<br />

Z Play’s display hasn’t<br />

diminished in the<br />

slightest: it still covers<br />

a fantastic 100% of the<br />

sRGB colour gamut,<br />

produces perfect blacks<br />

and has superb contrast.<br />

Its maximum brightness<br />

only peaks at 355cd/<br />

m2, but this will only be<br />

a problem on the very<br />

sunniest of days.<br />

The Moto Z Play<br />

actually has a higherresolution<br />

camera than<br />

the Moto Z, producing<br />

16-megapixel images rather than 12. You<br />

won’t find any optical image stabilisation<br />

here, sadly, but you do get a hybrid laser<br />

and phase detection autofocus, a wide<br />

f/2.0 aperture and a colour-balancing<br />

dual LED flash. Shots turned out sharper<br />

and more defined on the Moto Z Play;<br />

there was perhaps a fraction more<br />

grain and noise than on the Moto Z, but<br />

we’d rather have a bit of grit than have<br />

everything smoothed over.<br />

Colour reproduction was top notch,<br />

even in gloomy, overcast weather<br />

conditions. Indoors, shots were once<br />

again a little grainy and mottled in<br />

“The Moto Mod<br />

accessories allow<br />

you to augment your<br />

smartphone with stereo<br />

speakers, an upgraded<br />

camera or even more<br />

battery life”<br />

places, but there was very little noise,<br />

and artefacts were kept to a minimum.<br />

Colours were pleasingly punchy and<br />

contrast levels remained solid across all<br />

lighting conditions. We’d recommend<br />

sparing use of the flash, however, as<br />

this tended to turn everything rather<br />

warm and orange rather than correctly<br />

balancing out white.<br />

PLAY TIME<br />

As with last year’s Moto X Play and Moto<br />

X Style, it’s Motorola’s mid-range phone<br />

that takes the crown here. The Moto<br />

Z might be faster, slimmer and have a<br />

higher-resolution display, but the Moto<br />

Z Play is better value. You not only get<br />

stonking battery life, but also a great<br />

camera and equal access to Lenovo and<br />

Motorola’s new Moto Mods.<br />

It’s arguably worth paying extra for the<br />

OnePlus 3T’s superior performance, but if<br />

you’re looking for something a bit different<br />

that can turn its hand to any task, you<br />

won’t be disappointed with the Moto Z<br />

Play.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$450 • From www.motorola.com.au<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5


OnePlus 3T<br />

THE ONEPLUS 3T IS A SMALL<br />

UPGRADE WITH A BIG PRICE<br />

INCREASE, BUT IT’S STILL FANTASTIC<br />

VALUE<br />

he arrival of the OnePlus 3T at<br />

the end of 2016 was a bittersweet<br />

T occasion. This was an update to<br />

one of our favourite high-end phones,<br />

the OnePlus 3, and made several small<br />

but welcome changes to the processor<br />

and battery – yet these incremental<br />

improvements came with a steep price<br />

increase, which seemed antithetical to<br />

the OnePlus ethos of creating flagshipstandard<br />

devices at knockdown prices.<br />

You couldn’t even get the older model<br />

for less, as it was canned with such<br />

remarkable speed and force that it<br />

disappeared from all but the shadiest of<br />

grey market stores.<br />

That said, by any reasonable measure<br />

the OnePlus 3T is still a bargain. Going<br />

in at $539 for the 64GB model, or $709<br />

for the 128GB model, it packs a 2.35GHz<br />

Qualcomm Snapdragon 821 processor,<br />

which is a straight upgrade from the<br />

OnePlus 3’s Snapdragon 820, and a<br />

convincing statement that the 3T is<br />

still looking to compete with top-tier<br />

smartphones on performance while<br />

severely undercutting them on cost.<br />

Battery size has also grown from<br />

3,000mAh to 3,400mAh, complemented<br />

by the new Dash Charge system, which<br />

promises “a day’s charge in half an hour”.<br />

SNAP HAPPY<br />

Along with the processor upgrade, the<br />

OnePlus 3T inherits its predecessor’s<br />

impressive list of core specifications.<br />

Namely, that Qualcomm Snapdragon 821<br />

is backed up by 6GB of RAM and includes<br />

Qualcomm’s Adreno 530 graphics<br />

processing unit. As you’d imagine, these<br />

top-of-the-range specifications result in a<br />

smartphone that’s an absolute pleasure<br />

to use, and one that comfortably handles<br />

anything you throw its way.<br />

In Geekbench 4, it scored 1,903 in the<br />

single-core test and 4,273 in the multicore<br />

test. Besides being clear – if moderate –<br />

improvements over the OnePlus 3, which<br />

scored 1,689 and 4,026 respectively, these<br />

also show the OnePlus 3T holding its own<br />

against the Samsung Galaxy S7, which<br />

remains significantly more expensive even<br />

now that the Galaxy S8 has arrived.<br />

Graphics performance is unchanged<br />

from the 3, as you’d expect from the two<br />

OnePlus handsets sharing a GPU. The<br />

OnePlus 3T matches its predecessor with<br />

a superb 47fps average in the GFXBench<br />

GL onscreen Manhattan 3.0 test. That’s<br />

actually 9fps better than the Galaxy S7, so<br />

you’ll have no problems running intensive<br />

3D titles.<br />

Weirdly, however, the larger 3,400mAh<br />

battery actually fared worse in our video<br />

loop test (running at the usual 170cd/m2<br />

brightness). The OnePlus 3T lasted 13h<br />

22m, compared to the OnePlus 3’s 16h<br />

56m. That said, anecdotally we seemed<br />

to get slightly better longevity out of the<br />

newer phone in normal day-to-day use.<br />

DASH BLAST<br />

The Dash Charge tech is also impressive,<br />

though the claims of “a day’s power in half<br />

an hour” need a little extra scrutiny. While<br />

it’s true we were able to jump from 49% to<br />

92% battery in 30 minutes (it took another<br />

24 minutes to hit 100%), not everyone<br />

would find 43% capacity enough to get<br />

them through a day – especially if they’re a<br />

power user. Your mileage may vary.<br />

The OnePlus 3T’s rear camera is great<br />

as well. It’s a 16-megapixel snapper with<br />

an f/2.0 aperture, phase-detect autofocus<br />

and optical image stabilisation. It’s short<br />

of laser autofocus for optimal low-light<br />

performance, but it’s generally solid.<br />

You might think that bringing the front<br />

camera up to the same 16-megapixel<br />

count would produce similarly good<br />

selfies, but sadly that isn’t the case. We<br />

found that shots taken on the frontfacing<br />

camera had a nasty combination<br />

of overexposure and unimpressive colour<br />

balance, whether they were taken in or<br />

outdoors. It’s not a patch on the Google<br />

“Top-of-the-range<br />

specifications result in<br />

a smartphone that’s an<br />

absolute pleasure to use”<br />

Pixel XL’s 8-megapixel snapper, proving<br />

that pixel count isn’t everything.<br />

That’s about it for the new additions;<br />

now we turn to the design and display,<br />

which remain largely unchanged from<br />

the OnePlus 3. <strong>Tech</strong>nically the 3T’s rear<br />

panel is slightly flatter, but only hardcore<br />

OnePlus fans are likely to notice that at a<br />

glance. The anodised metal chassis looks<br />

the same, and it still feels comfortably<br />

secure in the hand, even one-handed. It<br />

has support for dual SIMs, meaning this<br />

can be your work and home phone, and it<br />

still charges via USB Type-C.<br />

PIXEL OF HEALTH<br />

At 5.5in, it remains a big beast of a phone,<br />

although that screen is still a 1,080x1,920<br />

AMOLED panel. That’s a lower resolution<br />

than some of its pricier peers, and<br />

undoubtedly where some of the cost<br />

savings are made, but unless you plan<br />

on using this for virtual reality, then it’s a<br />

sacrifice worth making. On a screen this<br />

size, diminishing returns tends to kick in, so<br />

most 1080p content is tough to tell apart<br />

from that shown on a QHD or 4K display.<br />

For everyday usage, the OnePlus 3T’s<br />

screen is just fine. We measured a good<br />

maximum brightness of 421cd/m2 and<br />

perfect contrast. Switch to sRGB mode<br />

and the screen covers 93.2% of the colour<br />

gamut, and it does so while looking sharp<br />

and vibrant.<br />

The OnePlus 3T is a brilliant<br />

smartphone, and objectively improves<br />

upon the amazingly good OnePlus 3 in<br />

a couple of small but significant ways:<br />

namely the processing performance<br />

and charging speed. It’s not ideal that<br />

these tweaks have resulted in a price rise,<br />

especially since one of the other hardware<br />

upgrades – the bigger battery – has such<br />

mixed results, but that’s not to say that the<br />

OnePlus 3T is a rip-off.<br />

In fact, while it’s not quite as incredible<br />

a bargain as the OnePlus 3, it still gives<br />

you demonstrably more bang for your<br />

buck than anything in and above its price<br />

range. It is, once again, a flagship-killer.<br />

With the OnePlus 3 having vanished from<br />

mainstream sellers, the OnePlus 3T is an<br />

easy endorsement.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$539 • oneplus.net<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

76 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


SMARTPHONES GROUP TEST<br />

Samsung Galaxy A5 (<strong>2017</strong>)<br />

SAMSUNG HEADS IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION WITH THE KEENLY PRICED GALAXY A5<br />

his isn’t nearly the cheapest<br />

Samsung handset around, but the<br />

T latest Galaxy A5 is appealing as a<br />

value purchase because it has much more<br />

in common with the Galaxy S7 than it does<br />

the budget Galaxy J series.<br />

For starters, there’s the flagshipbothering<br />

build quality. The Galaxy A5’s<br />

clean metal frame and all-glass front<br />

are incredibly handsome for a sub-$600<br />

smartphone, and its tapered back helps<br />

it fit snugly into the palm of your hand. It’s<br />

also the first iteration of the A5 where the<br />

rear camera is totally flush with the body.<br />

It’s a lovely phone to hold and behold,<br />

then, but then last year’s Galaxy A5 was<br />

pretty nice, too. The key differences lie<br />

beneath the phone’s glossy exterior, with a<br />

new processor, more RAM and a higherresolution<br />

camera.<br />

GLASS WITH FLYING COLOURS<br />

More similarly to last year’s model, the<br />

new A5 comes equipped with a 5.2in,<br />

Full HD, Super AMOLED display, racking<br />

up a pixel density of 424ppi. That’s not<br />

sharp enough for it to be compatible<br />

with Samsung’s Gear VR headset, but<br />

there’s nothing stopping you using Google<br />

Cardboard instead.<br />

More importantly, it looks superb in<br />

everyday use. Colours are striking, covering<br />

a perfect 100% of the sRGB gamut, and<br />

while our X-Rite colour calibrator did spot<br />

some slight inaccuracies<br />

in some of the darker<br />

shades of green, it’s so<br />

marginal that you won’t<br />

spot this with the naked<br />

eye.<br />

It’s also a reasonably<br />

bright Super AMOLED<br />

screen, too, with the<br />

calibrator picking up<br />

a peak brightness of<br />

355cd/m2. It’s not<br />

as dazzling as, say,<br />

the Sony Xperia X<br />

Compact or OnePlus<br />

3T, and you’ll need<br />

to shade the screen<br />

to read it in really bright<br />

conditions, but for the<br />

most part it’s adequate<br />

for outdoor viewing.<br />

The adaptive light<br />

sensor on the top of<br />

the phone also bumps<br />

up brightness to a<br />

maximum of 451cd/m2,<br />

should the need arise.<br />

When it comes to performance, the<br />

Galaxy A5’s octa-core Exynos 7880<br />

(clocked at 1.9GHz) and 3GB of RAM keeps<br />

Android feeling snappy. It does fall behind<br />

the OnePlus 3T in our benchmarks, scoring<br />

767 in the Geekbench single-core test and<br />

4,054 in multicore (compared to the 3T’s<br />

1,903 and 4,274). The multicore score in<br />

particular is a great showing.<br />

“The A5 is just the ticket<br />

if you’re not fond of<br />

handing over flagshipsized<br />

sums of cash but<br />

want something sleek”<br />

The phone’s graphics performance<br />

is somewhat less impressive. Running<br />

GFXBench’s onscreen Manhattan 3.0 test,<br />

it gained an average frame rate of 14fps,<br />

which is 33fps slower than the OnePlus<br />

3T. It’s not so bad in practice – Sky Force:<br />

Reloaded ran with minimal hiccups, even<br />

when there was lots happening on the<br />

screen, but we’re concerned about how<br />

it might handle more intensive games<br />

that might come out in the next couple of<br />

years.<br />

ALL-NIGHTER<br />

Battery life is much better. This year’s<br />

Galaxy A5 ships with a<br />

3,000mAh power pack, and it<br />

put in a sterling performance<br />

in our video playback tests.<br />

With the phone in flight mode<br />

and the screen calibrated<br />

to 170cd/m2, the Galaxy<br />

A5 lasted 22h 5m before<br />

giving up and shutting down,<br />

handily beating the Galaxy S7<br />

and OnePlus 3T and coming<br />

fairly close to the Motorola<br />

Moto Z Play. There’s fast<br />

charging via USB Type-C, too.<br />

As for software, we<br />

were more than a little<br />

disappointed to find that<br />

Samsung Galaxy A5 isn’t<br />

powered by Android 7.0<br />

Nougat straight out of the<br />

box. While we’ve been<br />

assured there’ll be an overthe-air<br />

update in the near<br />

future, you’ll have to wait a<br />

little longer for the latest,<br />

greatest version of Google’s<br />

OS.<br />

Returning our attention to that newly<br />

flush rear camera, Samsung has boosted<br />

the resolution to 16 megapixels, and done<br />

the same to the front-facing camera –<br />

that’s a sizable improvement over the 2016<br />

Galaxy A5’s 13- and 5-megapixel cameras.<br />

Using the rear camera, we were able to<br />

capture some very detail-rich shots of the<br />

streets outside our office on a clear day.<br />

Switching on HDR didn’t yield massive<br />

improvements, even if the image was<br />

already well exposed to begin with. A tad<br />

more cloud detail could be spotted in the<br />

HDR shot, but not much else.<br />

Indoor snaps weren’t a problem, with<br />

shots of our low-light still-life arrangement<br />

picking up an abundance of vibrant colour.<br />

Visual noise is kept at bay as well, and<br />

there’s no muddying of the finer details.<br />

Samsung’s camera software has seen<br />

a bit of an update, too. In a similar move<br />

to Huawei’s slick Camera app, specific<br />

shooting modes can be accessed via quick<br />

swipes to the left and right, rather than<br />

having to navigate through convoluted<br />

menus. It’s the almost-perfect onehanded<br />

experience – especially with the<br />

new movable virtual shutter button, and<br />

especially handy for selfie enthusiasts.<br />

FOOD FOR THOUGHT<br />

There’s also Samsung’s new Food Filter,<br />

which applies a basic depth-of-field effect<br />

and some colour tinkering to supposedly<br />

make your food photos look their<br />

Instagram-worthy best. Photos with this<br />

filter applied were a tad oversaturated,<br />

though, and we weren’t keen on the<br />

extreme background blur. It’s a frivolous<br />

and ultimately ignorable inclusion.<br />

The Samsung Galaxy S8 might be<br />

grabbing all the headlines at the moment,<br />

but that doesn’t mean the Galaxy A5<br />

should be overlooked. It’s just the ticket if<br />

you’re not fond of handing over flagshipsized<br />

sums of cash.<br />

The OnePlus 3T looms large as an<br />

alternative, but its battery life isn’t nearly<br />

as good. As such, the Galaxy A5 takes a<br />

well-deserved place as one of the best<br />

mid-range handsets you can buy today,<br />

and has enough premium touches to<br />

make it worth considering alongside older<br />

flagships that have come down in price.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$584 • www.samsung.com.au<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 77


Samsung Galaxy S6<br />

WHAT WAS AN IMPRESSIVE STEP FORWARD IN 2015 IS<br />

STILL A HIGHLY COMPETITIVE SMARTPHONE TODAY<br />

E<br />

ven at the ripe old age of two years<br />

old, the Galaxy S6 still impresses<br />

– after all, it was the first Samsung<br />

smartphone to look and feel like a truly<br />

premium product, without the plasticky<br />

panels of what came before.<br />

It’s not as eye-catching as the S6<br />

Edge, with its tapered screen, and also<br />

doesn’t feel as grippy in the hand, due to<br />

the S6 having smoother, more rounded<br />

edges. Still, these are minor quibbles,<br />

and there’s much more to like about the<br />

design than not. It only weighs 138g, for<br />

starters – that’s a good 17g less than<br />

the LG G4, which is also 1.9mm fatter –<br />

and while the glass backplate attracts<br />

fingerprints, it and the aluminium frame<br />

make for a vastly better-looking device<br />

than the old Galaxy S5.<br />

There’s also the matter of the stunning<br />

5.1in Super AMOLED display. The<br />

2,560x1,440 resolution gives it a pixel<br />

density of 577ppi, which remains among<br />

the highest you’ll see on any smartphone<br />

outside of certain 4K outliers. Colour<br />

accuracy and contrast were through the<br />

roof, with sRGB colour gamut coverage<br />

of 100% and an Infinity:1 contrast ratio.<br />

We measured a so-so peak brightness<br />

of 346.49cd/m2 indoors, but the Galaxy<br />

S6 has the same automatic brightness<br />

mode as later Galaxy phones, allowing it<br />

to reach a massive 577cd/m2 outside.<br />

CARDS NOT ACCEPTED<br />

Unlike the S5, the S6 doesn’t have a<br />

replaceable battery. To be fair, this is<br />

something that could be said of the<br />

vast majority of flagships (as well as<br />

most mid-range and cheaper handsets),<br />

but it’s still a mild shame. As some<br />

recompense, the S6 supports W<strong>PC</strong> (Qi)<br />

and PMA (Powermat) wireless charging.<br />

The Micro USB port on the bottom of<br />

the phone also supports fast-charging,<br />

which gave us about four hours of use<br />

from 10 minutes attached to the mains.<br />

We do prefer the reversible USB Type-C<br />

port on the Galaxy S8, for convenience’s<br />

sake, though it should be easier to find<br />

spare cables for the S6.<br />

Battery size is also down from the S5,<br />

but this shouldn’t be too much of an<br />

issue. The Galaxy S6 lasted 13h 37m in<br />

our battery benchmark, a performance<br />

which may have been thoroughly<br />

outdone by the Galaxy S7, but still<br />

translates into a good day’s worth of<br />

regular use.<br />

There’s a decently fast, thumboriented<br />

fingerprint scanner<br />

built into the home button –<br />

you can use this with Samsung<br />

Pay, to make payments with<br />

the phone instead of having<br />

to pull out a contactless<br />

bank card – but sadly other<br />

creatures comforts, such as<br />

waterproofing and a microSD<br />

slot, are missing as well. You’re<br />

therefore limited to whatever<br />

amount of onboard storage<br />

you choose, from 32GB, 64GB<br />

and 128GB flavours.<br />

WIZ KID<br />

On the plus side, Samsung’s<br />

64-bit, octa-core Samsung<br />

Exynos 7420 processor<br />

makes the S6 very snappy<br />

indeed. It scored 1,427 in the<br />

Geekbench single-core test<br />

and 4,501 in the multicore test,<br />

so remains among the best of<br />

the best even in <strong>2017</strong>, and while the S7<br />

and OnePlus 3T are more future-proofed<br />

for gaming performance, you can still run<br />

“We hear a lot about<br />

‘flagship killers’. Well,<br />

here’s a genuine<br />

flagship that costs even<br />

less than the best ‘killer’<br />

on the market”<br />

any intensive 3D title on the S6 with ease.<br />

TouchWiz, Samsung’s Android skin,<br />

is more streamlined than it has been in<br />

previous versions; there are still about<br />

two screens’ worth of pre-installed<br />

apps, but it’s cut back on the bloatware.<br />

The main issue is that, like most custom<br />

skins, it seems to delay Android updates.<br />

The S6 has long been running 6.1<br />

Marshmallow, having launched with<br />

5.0 Lollipop, but a timeframe for the<br />

supposedly upcoming 7.0 Nougat update<br />

has been left vague.<br />

The Galaxy S6 includes a 16-megapixel<br />

rear camera, which protrudes slightly<br />

outwards from the back of the handset.<br />

This is the same resolution as the<br />

Galaxy S5’s camera, but there’s now<br />

a brighter f/1.9 aperture lens, which<br />

Samsung claims lets in 34% more light<br />

than the S5’s f/2.2 lens. Optical image<br />

stabilisation reduces blur in low-light<br />

shooting, and a<br />

double-click of<br />

the home button<br />

activates the<br />

camera in under a<br />

second, ensuring<br />

you’ll never miss<br />

a shot.<br />

We were<br />

pleased with<br />

the quality of<br />

our test photos,<br />

as colours were<br />

bright and vibrant<br />

with plenty of fine<br />

detail on show.<br />

A few patches of<br />

bright sky were<br />

overexposed, but<br />

turning on HDR<br />

mode instantly<br />

fixed the problem.<br />

HDR also left the<br />

rest of the picture<br />

intact, keeping the high level of detail and<br />

accurate colours we saw in Auto mode<br />

without making it seem unnaturally harsh<br />

or artificial.<br />

RETURN OF THE KING<br />

There’s no doubting that the Galaxy S6<br />

is a much better phone, both in terms<br />

of features and build quality, than the<br />

Galaxy S5 – and, more pertinently, it<br />

remains a great device by more recent<br />

standards.<br />

There is the question, however, of<br />

whether it’s worth opting for a twogenerations-old<br />

handset when not only<br />

is there a newer, even better model<br />

available, but that the later version – the<br />

Galaxy S7 – has benefited from a big<br />

price drop thanks to the Galaxy S8. The<br />

most obvious answer to that is, of course,<br />

that the Galaxy S6 is even cheaper.<br />

We hear a lot about ‘flagship killers’,<br />

phones that make a few compromises<br />

here and there to offer premium<br />

performance at a mid-range price. Well,<br />

here’s a genuine flagship that costs even<br />

less than the best ‘killer’ on the market<br />

– and there’s definitely some appeal in<br />

that.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$369 • www.samsung.com.au<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

78 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


SMARTPHONES GROUP TEST<br />

Samsung Galaxy S7<br />

THE SAMSUNG GALAXY S7 IS STILL ONE OF THE BEST SMARTPHONES<br />

OUT THERE, NOW WITH ANDROID NOUGAT AND A LOWER PRICE<br />

Y<br />

ou might be wondering what the<br />

Galaxy S7 is doing here – aren’t<br />

we meant to be looking at more<br />

affordable current phones and older<br />

classics? Well, you’d be right in that the S7<br />

isn’t exactly chump change, but then by<br />

the time you read this, the Galaxy S8 will<br />

have arrived to replace it as Samsung’s<br />

premier smartphone. That means price<br />

drops for last year’s model.<br />

This is great news for bargain hunters, as<br />

the S7 quickly became our favourite-ever<br />

Android handset when we first reviewed it.<br />

Not that first impressions were that great:<br />

our testing sample had fine scratches in<br />

numerous places on the display and the<br />

fingerprint sensor, and while the glass<br />

back was in better conditions, it was and<br />

remains an absolute fingerprint magnet.<br />

RESISTANCE MOVEMENT<br />

The S7 is 1.1mm thicker than the Galaxy<br />

S6 and, at 152g, is 20g heavier, but neither<br />

are things you’ll notice in everyday<br />

use. Samsung has also made some<br />

big improvements in the form of IP68<br />

waterproofing and a microSD slot for<br />

expandable storage. The S6 was sorely<br />

missing both, and the S7 is far more<br />

flexible and durable for it.<br />

Our only major quibble is with the<br />

front-mounted fingerprint sensor. It’s<br />

much lower down than where our thumbs<br />

and fingers would normally rest, and it<br />

will only unlock the phone once you’ve<br />

pressed the home<br />

button or woken it<br />

up with the power<br />

button. It didn’t<br />

always recognise<br />

our fingerprints<br />

successfully, either.<br />

Samsung’s<br />

Super AMOLED<br />

displays have<br />

always been one of the highlights of<br />

its S-series smartphones, and the S7’s<br />

screen is no exception. It may not have<br />

the curved sides of the S7 Edge, but this<br />

5.1in, 2,560x1,440-resolution display has a<br />

super-sharp pixel density of 577ppi and its<br />

quality is top notch. Covering a full 100%<br />

of the sRGB colour gamut, it can produce<br />

pitch perfect 0.00cd/m2 blacks, and a<br />

super-high contrast ratio makes it lovely to<br />

look at, whatever the task.<br />

With a peak brightness of 353.74cd/<br />

m2, it’s not as bright as most LCDbased<br />

smartphones, but switch to<br />

Auto brightness and shine a torch on<br />

its adaptive light sensor and<br />

the brightness will shoot up to<br />

around 470cd/m2. It’s the same<br />

thing Samsung did with the<br />

S6, and it makes using the S7<br />

in sunshine much easier than<br />

some of its other Super AMOLED<br />

handsets.<br />

It also has the added benefit<br />

of Samsung’s Always On<br />

Display technology, which can<br />

be used to display information<br />

such as the date, time and the<br />

phone’s battery status when<br />

the screen is turned off. It can<br />

also show calendar information,<br />

but it’s a shame this widget<br />

isn’t actionable like traditional<br />

Android notifications.<br />

This drains a little under 1%<br />

of the battery per hour, but you<br />

won’t have to worry about the<br />

S7’s overall stamina – it lasted<br />

17h 48m in our continuous video playback<br />

test, an exceptional performance which<br />

puts the S6’s 13h 37m to shame. Fastcharging<br />

has also been improved, allowing<br />

us to regain 50% charge in just 10 minutes,<br />

and it supports wireless charging via the<br />

usual Qi standard.<br />

DRAGON SLAYER<br />

In some territories, the S7 runs off<br />

Qualcomm’s Snapdragon 820, but in<br />

the UK and Europe this is replaced by<br />

Samsung’s own<br />

“The Galaxy S7 is far more<br />

flexible and durable than<br />

the S6 thanks to IP68<br />

waterproofing and a<br />

microSD slot”<br />

octa-core Exynos<br />

8890 processor.<br />

This makes it one<br />

of the slickest and<br />

most responsive<br />

smartphones<br />

around, scoring<br />

a massive 2,115 in<br />

Geekbench’s singlecore<br />

test and 6,437 in the multicore test.<br />

Samsung’s TouchWiz interface (laid over<br />

Android 7.0 Nougat) simply flies, and apps<br />

loaded almost instantly. Web browsing<br />

is similarly quick, with the S7 scoring an<br />

impressive 1,882 in Peacekeeper and<br />

coping extremely well when scrolling<br />

through media-heavy pages.<br />

The Exynos 8890’s graphics capabilities<br />

are equally impressive. In the offscreen<br />

Manhattan test of GFXBench GL 3.0, the<br />

S7 managed a score of 2,336 frames,<br />

which equates to around 38fps. The<br />

cheaper OnePlus 3T beats it with 47fps,<br />

but this still demonstrates the S7’s ability<br />

to run demanding<br />

games without<br />

hitches. Samsung’s<br />

added Game Launcher<br />

comes in handy<br />

as well, as it can<br />

disable notifications,<br />

capture footage and<br />

screenshots or lock<br />

the Back and Recents<br />

buttons while you play.<br />

The Galaxy S6 came<br />

with an excellent<br />

camera, but for the S7,<br />

Samsung took a risk<br />

in order to improve<br />

image quality further,<br />

reducing the main<br />

snapper’s resolution to<br />

12 megapixels instead<br />

of sticking with the<br />

S6’s 16-megapixel<br />

sensor.<br />

That may sound like a step backwards,<br />

but each individual pixel is bigger, up from<br />

1.12um on the S6 to 1.4um on the S7.<br />

LUCKY NUMBER SEVEN<br />

As a result, the S7 takes very similarly<br />

high-quality shots to the S6, both indoors<br />

and outdoors. Detailing is excellent,<br />

there’s plenty of contrast, and colours are<br />

lovely and bright. It tends toward a slight<br />

overexposure in shots with a challenging<br />

dynamic range, but that’s preferable to the<br />

alternative of darker shots, and we could<br />

rectify it by switching to HDR mode when<br />

possible. It’s mainly in the shutter speed<br />

that the S7 proves itself superior. For<br />

instance, in a low-light shot, the S7 took<br />

the photo at 1/25 sec, whereas the S6 shot<br />

at 1/15 sec. This means the S7 will be more<br />

reliable in low-light situations and less<br />

likely to blur moving subjects, making it the<br />

better camera overall.<br />

Our only remaining issue with the<br />

Galaxy S7 was its price, but now it can<br />

be picked up for not much more than a<br />

OnePlus 3T. It’s certainly better value<br />

than the Galaxy S8, which will leave a<br />

$1,200-sized crater in your bank account.<br />

Proof that a bit of patience can net you a<br />

top-tier smartphone at middling prices.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$900 • www.samsung.com.au<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 79


Sony Xperia<br />

X Compact<br />

SONY’S 4.6IN HANDSET BOTH IMPROVES ON AND<br />

STEPS BACK FROM THE LUXURY Z5 COMPACT<br />

ince the next cheapest option in<br />

sony’s smartphone range is the<br />

S rubbish Xperia XA, the dinky Xperia<br />

X Compact looks like the family’s best<br />

balance of affordability and quality.<br />

It is, however, something of a<br />

Frankenphone, combining some features<br />

from the top-of-the-line XZ with some<br />

from the older Xperia X, all in its 4.6in<br />

chassis. So instead of the octa-core<br />

Qualcomm Snapdragon 820 processor<br />

from the XZ, the X Compact has the hexacore<br />

Snapdragon 650 from the X – yet it<br />

inherits its camera lock, stock and barrel<br />

from the XZ.<br />

Honestly, this is a slightly disappointing<br />

departure from Sony’s previous Compact<br />

models, which were typically just as<br />

powerful as their flagship brethren, just in<br />

a smaller body.<br />

SQUARE’S BREADTH<br />

The fit-and-finish isn’t great either, with<br />

unsightly gaps at the top and bottom of<br />

the rear panel ready to gobble up unsightly<br />

pocket fluff. It might be less fragile than<br />

the Z5 Compact but surely Sony could<br />

have found a way to make its replacement<br />

look nicer than this. There’s no<br />

dust- or water-proofing, either.<br />

The phone does at least<br />

fulfil its principal raison d’être:<br />

it’s both more pocketable and<br />

easier to use one-handed<br />

than most of the 5.5in-plus<br />

behemoths favoured by manufacturers for<br />

their mid-range and higher smartphones<br />

these days. It’s also good to see that Sony<br />

has kept both the dedicated camera<br />

shutter button and the fingerprint reader,<br />

which is once again integrated with the<br />

side-mounted power button.<br />

As for the main camera, the sensor<br />

size, pixel count and aperture all remain<br />

unchanged from the Z5 Compact,<br />

but Sony has made a few minor<br />

improvements. First up is ‘laser-assisted’<br />

infrared autofocus, which Sony says helps<br />

the camera to focus more accurately in<br />

low light. In good light, the hybrid phase<br />

and contrast-detect autofocus system<br />

(again, copied from the Z5 Compact)<br />

takes over. This seems to work reasonably<br />

well, but then we didn’t particularly have<br />

any problems with the way the focus<br />

worked on the Z5 Compact, so we’re not<br />

80 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

convinced it’s a<br />

huge leap forward.<br />

Next up is a<br />

colour sensor,<br />

similar to the one<br />

introduced by<br />

the LG G4. This is<br />

supposed to deliver<br />

more accurate<br />

colours under a<br />

wider variety of<br />

lighting conditions,<br />

and does indeed<br />

seem to work<br />

pretty well. Under<br />

fluorescent office<br />

strip lights, halogen<br />

and LED lighting, the X Compact’s camera<br />

always seemed to get the colour balance<br />

spot on where others, even the Samsung<br />

Galaxy S7, would veer a little off base.<br />

BLAME TO FRAME<br />

Despite these improvements, Sony’s<br />

smartphones continue to be plagued by<br />

the same old problems. Even with the<br />

camera’s manual mode enabled – which<br />

is the only way of getting 23-megapixel<br />

“The screen is only a Standard HD panel,<br />

but that’s sharp enough considering its<br />

size. Photos and video look superb”<br />

images out of the camera, by the way –<br />

fine details are lost in a storm of grain and<br />

JPEG compression.<br />

We’re not huge fans of the X Compact’s<br />

wide-angle 24mm lens, either. On the<br />

positive side, it lets you cram much<br />

more into your photographs than most<br />

smartphones, whose lenses are typically<br />

closer to 28mm. But the downside is<br />

noticeable optical distortion, where<br />

buildings and straight lines look warped at<br />

the edges of the frame.<br />

Fortunately, the move to a Snapdragon<br />

650 CPU hasn’t had too much of an<br />

adverse effect on performance. It’s no<br />

slowpoke, that much is clear from using<br />

the phone from day to day – launching<br />

apps, flicking between them and<br />

navigating around feels slick and quick.<br />

The fact that the screen is limited to<br />

a resolution of 1,280x720, rather than<br />

the Full HD favoured by most<br />

other mid-range devices, might<br />

be off-putting to some, but it<br />

does have the positive effect<br />

of helping games to run better.<br />

Here, the X Compact performs<br />

well, even with demanding<br />

games such as Sky Force<br />

Reloaded.<br />

Indeed, in the GFXBench<br />

Manhattan 3 onscreen test,<br />

which is run at the phone’s<br />

native resolution, the X<br />

Compact’s Adreno 510 GPU<br />

gains an average frame rate<br />

of 32fps, which is only a little<br />

less than what the Galaxy S7<br />

managed. Sadly, though, this is<br />

one area in which the older Z5<br />

Compact trounces it, scoring<br />

47fps in the same test.<br />

At least the X Compact puts<br />

up more of a fight in Geekbench,<br />

scoring 1,445 in the single-core<br />

test and 3,778 in the multicore<br />

test – competitive with the Z5<br />

Compact’s respective scores of<br />

1,369 and 3,795. These also put it ahead<br />

of Google’s Nexus 5X and the Moto Z Play,<br />

though it’s still some way off the OnePlus<br />

3T in terms of horsepower.<br />

SMALL WONDER<br />

The screen is, as mentioned, only a<br />

Standard HD panel, but that’s sharp<br />

enough considering its small size. What’s<br />

more, photos and video look superb on<br />

it, whether you have Sony’s X-Reality<br />

image turned on or not, and<br />

measurements with our<br />

colourimeter suggest that it’s<br />

an excellent screen as well.<br />

Contrast, maximum brightness,<br />

and colour reproduction are<br />

all top notch. Indeed, the<br />

X Compact manages to outdo the Z5<br />

Compact, with a maximum brightness of<br />

535cd/m2 to the Z5 Compact’s 461cd/m2.<br />

Battery life has improved as well. In our<br />

video benchmark, the X Compact lasted<br />

a strong 14h 41m, which is a full 1h 20m<br />

longer than the Z5 Compact.<br />

It may be a disappointment in some<br />

areas, then, but with its enhanced camera,<br />

longer battery life and still-respectable<br />

performance, the Xperia X Compact is still<br />

a good phone overall, and will particularly<br />

suit Android fans who want to stick to a<br />

smaller form factor.<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

$480 • www.sonymobile.com/au<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5


SMARTPHONES GROUP TEST<br />

AWARD RECOMMENDED BEST BUY RECOMMENDED BEST BUY<br />

MANUFACTURER APPLE GOOGLE LG MOTOROLA<br />

MODEL iPhone SE Nexus 5X G4 Moto G4<br />

RATING<br />

HARDWARE<br />

PROCESSOR<br />

Dual-core 1.8GHz Apple<br />

A9<br />

Hexa-core 1.8GHz<br />

Qualcomm Snapdragon<br />

808<br />

Hexa-core 1.8GHz<br />

Qualcomm Snapdragon<br />

808<br />

Octa-core 1.5GHz<br />

Qualcomm Snapdragon<br />

617<br />

RAM 2GB 2GB 3GB 2GB<br />

SCREEN SIZE 4in 5.2in 5.5in 5.5in<br />

SCREEN<br />

RESOLUTION<br />

1,136x640 1,920x1,080 2,560x1,440 1,920x1,080<br />

SCREEN TYPE IPS IPS IPS Quantum IPS<br />

FRONT CAMERA 5 megapixels 5 megapixels 8 megapixels 5 megapixels<br />

REAR CAMERA 12 megapixels 12.3 megapixels 16 megapixels 13 megapixels<br />

FLASH LED (True Tone) Dual LEDs LED LED<br />

GPS Yes Yes Yes Yes<br />

COMPASS Yes Yes Yes Yes<br />

STORAGE 16GB/64GB 32GB/128GB 32GB 16GB/32GB<br />

MEMORY CARD<br />

SLOT<br />

None None MicroSD MicroSD<br />

WI-FI 802.11ac 802.11n 802.11ac 802.11ac<br />

BLUETOOTH Bluetooth 4.1 Bluetooth 4.0 Bluetooth 4.0 Bluetooth 4.2<br />

NFC Yes Yes Yes No<br />

WIRELESS DATA 4G 4G 4G 4G<br />

DIMENSIONS 124x59x7.6mm 147x73x7.9mm 149x75x8.9mm 153x77x7.9mm<br />

WEIGHT 112g 136g 155g 155g<br />

FEATURES<br />

OPERATING<br />

SYSTEM<br />

iOS 10 Android 7.0 Android 7.0 Android 6.0<br />

BATTERY SIZE 1,624mAh 2,700mAh 3,000mAh 3,000mAh<br />

BUYING INFORMATION<br />

PRICE $679 $429 $270 $232<br />

WARRANTY One year RTB One year RTB One year RTB One year RTB<br />

DETAILS www.apple.com/au www.google.com.au www.lg.com www.motorola.com.au<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 81


AWARD RECOMMENDED BEST BUY RECOMMENDED<br />

MANUFACTURER MOTOROLA MOTOROLA ONEPLUS SAMSUNG<br />

MODEL Moto G5 Moto Z Play 3T Galaxy A5 (<strong>2017</strong>)<br />

RATING<br />

HARDWARE<br />

PROCESSOR<br />

Octa-core 1.4GHz<br />

Snapdragon 430<br />

Octa-core 2.0GHz<br />

Snapdragon 625<br />

Quad-core 2.45GHz<br />

Qualcomm Snapdragon<br />

821<br />

Octa-core 1.9GHz<br />

Samsung Exynos 7880<br />

RAM 2GB/3GB 3GB 6GB 3GB<br />

SCREEN SIZE 5in 5.5in 5.5in 5.2in<br />

SCREEN<br />

RESOLUTION<br />

1,920x1,080 1,920x1,080 1,920x1,080 1,920x1,080<br />

SCREEN TYPE IPS Super AMOLED AMOLED Super AMOLED<br />

FRONT CAMERA 5 megapixels 5 megapixels 16 megapixels 16 megapixels<br />

REAR CAMERA 13 megapixels 16 megapixels 16 megapixels 16 megapixels<br />

FLASH LED Dual LED LED LED<br />

GPS Yes Yes Yes Yes<br />

COMPASS Yes Yes Yes Yes<br />

STORAGE 16GB/32GB 32GB 64GB 32GB<br />

MEMORY CARD<br />

SLOT<br />

MicroSD MicroSD No Yes<br />

WI-FI 802.11n 802.11n 802.11ac 802.11ac<br />

BLUETOOTH Bluetooth 4.2 Bluetooth 4.0 Bluetooth 4.2 Bluetooth 4.2<br />

NFC Yes Yes Yes Yes<br />

WIRELESS DATA 4G 4G 4G 4G<br />

DIMENSIONS 144x73x9.5mm 156x76x6.9mm 153mmx75x7.4mm 146x71x7.9mm<br />

WEIGHT 145g 165g 158g 157g<br />

FEATURES<br />

OPERATING<br />

SYSTEM<br />

Android 7.0 Android 6.0 Android 7.0 Android 6.0<br />

BATTERY SIZE 2,800mAh 3,510mAh 3,400mAh 3,000mAh<br />

BUYING INFORMATION<br />

PRICE $280 $370 $539 $584<br />

WARRANTY One year RTB One year RTB One year RTB One year RTB<br />

DETAILS www.motorola.com.au www.motorola.com.au oneplus.net www.samsung.com/au<br />

82 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


SMARTPHONES GROUP TEST<br />

RECOMMENDED<br />

BEST BUY<br />

SAMSUNG SAMSUNG SONY<br />

Galaxy S6 Galaxy S7 Xperia X Compact<br />

Octa-core 2.1GHz Samsung<br />

Exynos 7420<br />

Octa-core 2.3GHz<br />

Samsung Exynos 8890<br />

Hexa-core 1.8GHz<br />

Snapdragon 650<br />

3GB 4GB 3GB<br />

5.1in 5.1in 4.6in<br />

2,560x1,440 2,560x1,440 1,280x720<br />

Super AMOLED Super AMOLED IPS<br />

5 megapixels 5 megapixels 5 megapixels<br />

16 megapixels 12 megapixels 23 megapixels<br />

LED LED LED<br />

Yes Yes Yes<br />

Yes Yes Yes<br />

32GB/64GB/128GB 32GB 32GB<br />

N/A MicroSD MicroSD<br />

802.11ac 802.11ac 802.11ac<br />

Bluetooth 4.0 Bluetooth 4.2 Bluetooth 4.2<br />

Yes Yes Yes<br />

4G 4G 4G<br />

143x70x6.8mm 142x70x7.9mm 129x65x9.5mm<br />

132g 152g 135g<br />

Android 6.1 Android 7.0 Android 7.0<br />

2,550mAh 3,000mAh 2,700mAh<br />

$369 $900 $480<br />

One year RTB One year RTB One year RTB<br />

www.samsung.com/au www.samsung.com/au www.sonymobile.com<br />

Verdict<br />

E<br />

very single device here will serve you well, even<br />

the comparatively disappointing Moto G5. Still,<br />

a few models stand out as particularly greatvalue<br />

buys.<br />

Google’s Nexus 5X, released in 2015, also<br />

distinguishes itself as a powerful mid-range phone<br />

with a great camera, now at a price that makes<br />

it an even better choice. We can say something<br />

similar about the LG G4, which offers true flagship<br />

credentials for only $230. We’d have liked another<br />

price drop for the iPhone SE, but considering it’s<br />

been upgraded with superior storage, it remains the<br />

best Apple smartphone for the money.<br />

Creeping further up the price brackets, the<br />

OnePlus 3T is a superb combination of value,<br />

newness and genuine top-end hardware, though if<br />

you don’t mind an older model, the Samsung Galaxy<br />

S6 performs as well or better for a few pounds<br />

less. Speaking of Samsung, it’s worth mentioning<br />

the Galaxy S7, 2016’s most capable Android phone,<br />

which is now less expensive than the one replacing it.<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 83


DEEP LEARNING<br />

AND HEALTH<br />

THE HURDLES<br />

MACHINE<br />

LEARNING<br />

MUST LEAP<br />

Startups and Silicon Valley giants are pushing<br />

into medicine with artificial intelligence and<br />

deep learning. Nicole Kobie reveals how smart<br />

use of data could save your life<br />

D<br />

ata is important in healthcare.<br />

How a chart is read, if a doctor has<br />

time to take a second look at that<br />

scan of your chest, and whether there’s<br />

enough evidence to make you book an<br />

appointment with your GP could mean<br />

the difference between life and death<br />

for you — and of lower-cost preventative<br />

measures and expensive treatments for<br />

insurance companies.<br />

Currently, we rely on doctors and<br />

nurses to interpret key information — but<br />

machines are already coming to their<br />

aid, scanning images for signs of cancer,<br />

analysing data for symptoms of kidney<br />

failure, and more. In the future, apps will<br />

allow you to ask Alexa for medical advice,<br />

tools will assist GPs with triage and hunt<br />

for signs of cancer in medical scans, and<br />

chatbots could help treat mental illness.<br />

Google-owned DeepMind is working on<br />

projects to analyse patient data to predict<br />

kidney failure, spot head and neck cancers,<br />

and to read complicated eye images.<br />

However, those projects are under scrutiny<br />

because of data-sharing agreements with<br />

Google’s parent firm Alphabet, problems<br />

that could delay the life-saving — and<br />

budget-rescuing — potential of deep<br />

learning and other forms of machine<br />

learning.<br />

NECESSARY DATA<br />

The coding and engineering that goes into<br />

deep learning is only the start. No matter<br />

how a machine-learning system operates,<br />

it follows the old IT axiom: garbage in,<br />

84 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

garbage out. They need to be trained on<br />

high-quality, accurate data before they<br />

can read our medical charts and interpret<br />

images.<br />

“Without data there can be no<br />

application,” explained Natalia<br />

Simanovsky, business development lead<br />

at data management platform Cvedia,<br />

speaking at ReWork’s Deep Learning in<br />

Healthcare Summit. “You need lots of<br />

data.”<br />

That’s complicated by privacy concerns<br />

— and not helped by previous missteps<br />

by technology companies entering<br />

healthcare, which have had a chilling<br />

effect on the ease of getting data. Plus,<br />

when data is made available, it’s often in<br />

legacy formats that must be converted,<br />

which adds yet another barrier.<br />

Even when data is accessible<br />

and properly formatted, it<br />

needs to be of good quality.<br />

Simanovsky noted that<br />

training a skin-scanning<br />

system requires not only<br />

a large number of highquality<br />

medical images, but<br />

correct labelling to avoid<br />

passing mistakes on to<br />

machine-learning apps.<br />

“We need to work with<br />

dermatologists to ensure<br />

these images are<br />

correct,” she said. If an<br />

image is<br />

labelled incorrectly, the mistake could be<br />

learned by the algorithm — which means<br />

doctors’ errors are passed on to the<br />

machines.<br />

ALGORITHMIC ASSESSMENT<br />

Diagnosing disease will remain the job<br />

of human doctors for a long time to<br />

come, but AI could help narrow down<br />

potential causes of symptoms, acting<br />

as an assistant to human physicians,<br />

explained Daniel Nathrath, co-founder and<br />

CEO of Ada Health, speaking at ReWork.<br />

Doctors have the disadvantage of being<br />

human, meaning they have biases, make<br />

mistakes and suffer limited brain capacity.<br />

Trust<br />

me, I’m a<br />

doctor


FUTURES<br />

“It’s impossible to have it all in your head;<br />

there’s where AI has an advantage,” said<br />

Nathrath. “We’re not replacing doctors;<br />

we’re augmenting the intelligence of a<br />

doctor.”<br />

Machine-learning analysis is particularly<br />

useful for people with multiple health<br />

issues – known as comorbidities – and<br />

that’s applicable to most older people,<br />

notes Marzieh Nabi, director of business<br />

strategy at Xerox PARC. Doctors aren’t<br />

diagnosing your complaints one by one:<br />

they need to consider multiple causes<br />

DEEPMIND’S DATA USE<br />

DeepMind’s work with kidney patients is<br />

perhaps the best-known example of deep<br />

learning or artificial intelligence used in<br />

medicine – not because of the project itself,<br />

but because of the criticism it sparked on<br />

data management.<br />

Owned by Google’s parent firm<br />

Alphabet, DeepMind is a British<br />

deep-learning startup,<br />

which in 2015 announced<br />

it was working with the<br />

Royal Free Trust in London<br />

on a kidney disease<br />

monitoring app called<br />

Streams; the app would<br />

analyse data and suggest<br />

interventions to avoid kidney<br />

failure.<br />

Shortly after the trial kicked off, a<br />

report in New Scientist revealed that the<br />

hospitals had shared a wider range of<br />

patient data than expected, across 1.6<br />

million patients. The NHS and DeepMind<br />

responded by tweaking the data-sharing<br />

agreement, but an academic report from<br />

the New Scientist reporter, Hal Hodson,<br />

and a Cambridge researcher, Julia Powles,<br />

said the “inexcusable” use of data should<br />

offer lessons for future projects.<br />

What could DeepMind have done better<br />

to avoid such criticism? “At the foundation<br />

level, no patient was contacted and<br />

no effort was made to address the pivotal<br />

consideration in use of health data: that<br />

What seems to<br />

be the problem<br />

Dave?<br />

of symptoms and think about<br />

how medications will interact<br />

– something that isn’t often<br />

tested in drug trials. Deeplearning<br />

tools could be<br />

applied to pre-existing data<br />

sets to analyse how drugs<br />

interact and how diseases<br />

progress, Nabi noted,<br />

making it easier for doctors<br />

to decide how to address<br />

all that’s wrong with your<br />

health– without the treatments<br />

conflicting.<br />

Such diagnostic support could<br />

help health services with stretched<br />

budgets, assisting medical staff to<br />

patients understand when and why their<br />

data is used, and they have realistic options<br />

for effective choice,” said Powles.<br />

She called for other NHS health projects to<br />

consider consent and value before starting<br />

work. “[Our] paper talks about<br />

here-and-now issues, such as<br />

patient autonomy, confidentiality<br />

and legal compliance,”<br />

she said. “We also<br />

talk about the essential<br />

keys to innovative healthcare<br />

advances that work<br />

for everyone, such as ensuring<br />

that the public gets<br />

value for data, that there<br />

is effective oversight and accountability,<br />

and that egalitarian,<br />

public interests are preserved<br />

over purely commercial ones.”<br />

Failures to get data sharing right only delay<br />

the use of the technologies – problematic<br />

when they could be helping improve<br />

people’s health. Powles pointed to the Connecting<br />

Care project in Bristol, Somerset<br />

and Gloucestershire hospitals in 2015 as<br />

a better example. That saw third-party<br />

providers linked to an electronic patient<br />

record, but first mass-mailed all patients<br />

to explain why the data processing was<br />

happening, allowing people to opt out if<br />

they so wished. That case shows deep<br />

learning and data protection don’t need to<br />

be in opposition.<br />

work faster and better, but it could also<br />

help people in areas where doctors are<br />

scarce. “There are one billion people with<br />

no access to doctors,” Nathrath said.<br />

“Even in developed countries, people wait<br />

weeks.”<br />

TREATMENT TECHNIQUES<br />

We often judge doctors on their bedside<br />

manner — on how well they listen and<br />

communicate in return, and how they<br />

make us feel. It’s one area machines<br />

struggle, since understanding natural<br />

language isn’t easy. “One thing human<br />

doctors are still better at is empathy,” said<br />

Valentin Tablan, principal scientist at Ieso<br />

Digital Health. “This will be something<br />

good doctors do more of in the future.”<br />

But, once speech is unpicked, deeplearning<br />

tools could also be used to offer<br />

treatment to those suffering with mental<br />

health issues — and that’s as many as<br />

a quarter of us, with suicide the leading<br />

cause of death for younger men, noted<br />

Tablan. “Unlike cancer, which we don’t<br />

always know what to do about, we do<br />

know what to do with mental health,”<br />

he explained, as cognitive behavioural<br />

therapy (CBT) is proven to offer respite for<br />

many people.<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 85


FUTURES<br />

Get better,<br />

or there will<br />

be...trouble<br />

HOW MACHINE LEARNING<br />

HELPS HEALTH<br />

There are numerous ways that deep learning, AI<br />

and machine learning can boost health, from<br />

diagnosis to treatment. Here are five projects that<br />

could change how we identify and treat illness.<br />

However, it’s a human-intensive process<br />

that’s high cost, leaving those in rural or<br />

poor areas unable to access the therapy.<br />

Furthermore, the remaining stigma<br />

surrounding mental health issues means<br />

some people fail to seek treatment in<br />

person.<br />

Tablan said deep-learning systems are<br />

already assisting with triage, by suggesting<br />

diagnoses and tracking indicators to<br />

prevent relapses. Following recent trials,<br />

his firm has posted a 44% accuracy rate<br />

in triage — which is on par with human<br />

doctors. The aim is to extend such<br />

technologies beyond diagnosis into digital<br />

therapists, with patients speaking to bots<br />

as part of their treatment.<br />

DOCTORS’ JOBS<br />

Medical staff have difficult jobs — and<br />

that’s even before budgets start shrinking.<br />

“It’s not about replacing doctors; it’s about<br />

helping them do tough jobs,” said Tablan.<br />

<strong>Tech</strong>nology such as deep learning<br />

could help them work more quickly and<br />

accurately, but it remains early days. The<br />

companies and research mentioned here<br />

are discussing trials; they’re not finished,<br />

usable products. That’s partly because<br />

the data to train deep-learning systems<br />

isn’t easily available, with privacy a key<br />

concern, but also because the technology<br />

is still imperfect — for example, anyone<br />

with an Amazon Echo in their home will<br />

be aware of the limits of AI for nuanced<br />

conversation, which is at the heart of any<br />

diagnosis.<br />

“It’s important not to oversell what AI is<br />

able to do,” explained Aureli Soria-Frisch,<br />

head of R&D for AI firm Starlab. “Any kind<br />

of mechanical, artificial system makes<br />

errors. 100% performance doesn’t exist in<br />

any system.”<br />

ADA<br />

Ada is a<br />

smartphone app<br />

that “talks to<br />

you like a really<br />

good doctor<br />

would,” taking<br />

into account your<br />

history and symptoms.<br />

It’s now being ported to Amazon’s Echo,<br />

so you can ask such questions to the Alexa<br />

voice assistant, too. Rather than act like<br />

a symptom checker online, each aspect<br />

of a question is actually computed for<br />

results, offering advice and next steps –<br />

including whether you should go and see<br />

your human doctor. Naturally, there are<br />

disclaimers: Ada is not a medical diagnosis,<br />

so see a doctor if you’re worried.<br />

DEEPMIND AND MOORFIELDS<br />

DeepMind’s kidney app was its first<br />

project; the second is a partnership with<br />

Moorfields Eye Hospital, which aims to<br />

help optometrists detect common eye<br />

disorders by letting deep-learning systems<br />

look at scans. It takes a long time for<br />

humans to read the complex eye scans,<br />

but<br />

DeepMind’s system will<br />

train using a million<br />

images, with the<br />

aim of reducing<br />

the time doctors<br />

spend staring at<br />

images, instead<br />

boosting their time<br />

with patients.<br />

OXSIGHT<br />

OxSight pairs<br />

augmented reality<br />

and machine<br />

learning to help<br />

people with a<br />

residual level of<br />

sight, “offering a<br />

simplistic view of the<br />

world,” said Stephen<br />

Hicks, founder and head of innovation at<br />

OxSight. That lets people with reduced<br />

vision see shapes and movement, helping<br />

them to make their way around the world.<br />

Since everyone’s sight is different, OxSight<br />

uses machine learning to help customise<br />

the experience and learn the best way of<br />

displaying information.<br />

BABYLON HEALTH<br />

Babylon makes AI-driven chatbots using<br />

the smart app as a digital 999 system.<br />

Patients enter their symptoms into<br />

the app, which analyses the data and<br />

asks for more information if necessary,<br />

helping to decide the seriousness of the<br />

illness or injury. The app isn’t for extreme<br />

emergencies, but rather<br />

smaller queries, with<br />

Babylon claiming<br />

that the system<br />

takes an average<br />

of a dozen<br />

messages over a<br />

minute and a half<br />

to come to a decision.<br />

ARTERYS<br />

This medical<br />

imaging analysis<br />

tool is the<br />

first machinelearning<br />

app to be<br />

approved by the<br />

US Food and Drug<br />

Administration (FDA).<br />

Arterys learns as it goes, helping doctors<br />

examine heart images and data for<br />

diagnosis. To get FDA approval, it needed<br />

to post results on par with humans – and<br />

it does so in seconds; human experts can<br />

take as long as 30 m inutes on the same<br />

task, the company said.<br />

86 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


Prey<br />

FLY ME TO THE MOON…<br />

LET ME DIE AMONG THE STARS…<br />

rkane Studios, the developer<br />

behind Prey, is best known for its<br />

A Dishonored series – a game where<br />

you get to explore fantastic-yet-discrete<br />

locations, develop mystical abilities<br />

that let you manipulate each level, and<br />

discover a rich world and its backstory.<br />

Prey is cut from very similar cloth; but<br />

whereas Dishonored has a very worn,<br />

medieval feel, Prey looks to a future built<br />

upon an alternate historical timeline. In<br />

this world, JFK lived, the US joined with<br />

the USSR to explore space together, and<br />

contact was made with a mysterious<br />

alien presence, the Typhon.<br />

Now, in the game’s present time<br />

of 2032, the Transtar corporation is<br />

operating out of a vast space station,<br />

and trying to monetise the aliens by<br />

combining their unique talents with<br />

human DNA. If this sounds like a really,<br />

really bad idea, congratulations, you are<br />

correct – this is a terrible idea that, before<br />

the game even starts, as started to go<br />

terribly wrong.<br />

The game also comes with a literal<br />

false start, that’s more than a little<br />

reminiscent of the opening of Half Life<br />

– budding scientist goes to work for<br />

some lab experiments, and things… well,<br />

another scientist gets kind of killed by<br />

a shape-changing alien beasty. Then…<br />

you wake up again, at the start of that<br />

seeming same day… Turns out – and<br />

you learn this very early – you’ve been<br />

experimenting upon yourself and now<br />

your memory is effectively shot.<br />

As set ups go, it’s very strong. You’re<br />

obviously a person of some importance,<br />

a member of the family that runs the<br />

company in fact, but you still don’t have<br />

any backstory – you’re a blank slate. As<br />

you explore the station – in between<br />

sneaking past strange aliens, or having<br />

nerve-wracking fights with them – you<br />

pick up recordings, books, notes, and all<br />

manner of other details that fill in the<br />

world and how it’s gotten to this rather<br />

spectacularly crappy point.<br />

Which is, you, alone, on an alieninfested<br />

space station filled with<br />

malfunctioning equipment and dead<br />

people.<br />

Thankfully, you’ve got a lot of rather<br />

cool toys at your disposal. There are<br />

guns, but while Prey is a first person<br />

game, shooting isn’t what it’s about.<br />

Ammunition is limited, and your enemies<br />

88 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


GAMES REVIEW<br />

rather tough - this is a game about<br />

outwitting your enemies, rather than<br />

blowing them away. Combat is possible,<br />

but you’ll have to pick and choose your<br />

targets. Each level is also complex<br />

enough that there are multiple paths to<br />

each objective; you can use the awesome<br />

GLOO gun to not only stick enemies to<br />

the spot, but also to build impromptu<br />

stairs to hard to reach places, or you can<br />

mod yourself for boosted strength, and<br />

move crates and other gear around. Or<br />

you can just explore, and find not only<br />

extra gear and loot, but also service<br />

passages that might bypass doors and<br />

enemies completely.<br />

The modding system is based around<br />

neuromods – alien-DNA-powered<br />

changes to your physical self, and the<br />

“this is a game about<br />

outwitting your enemies,<br />

rather than blowing<br />

them away”<br />

main product of Transtar. That they’re<br />

also super-unstable is kind of beside the<br />

point. But they let you unlock three trees<br />

of cool skills, from being able to slow<br />

down time to run rings around badguys,<br />

to advanced hacking and repair skills that<br />

let you unlock doors or fix up busted gear.<br />

The game also features a crafting<br />

system, which breaks down junk loot<br />

into basic components, which you can<br />

then build into more advanced gear,<br />

ammunition, or even weapons. New<br />

blueprints are littered around each level,<br />

and as you gain neuromods, there’s<br />

always new skills to unlock. Combining<br />

all of this together to get past each<br />

challenge is rewarding, and offers some<br />

impressive replay value. Not as much,<br />

perhaps, as Dishonored, where each level<br />

is more based on a singular challenge,<br />

but there’s still a lot of different ways to<br />

play Prey.<br />

Inspired as it is by games like Half<br />

Life and System Shock, if Prey has one<br />

flaw it’s that it feels like ground already<br />

trodden, but it least it’s still very solid<br />

ground, and Prey is a fine game, with a<br />

look and feel all its own.<br />

David Hollingworth<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

https://prey.bethesda.net<br />

Genre: FPS • Developer: Bethesda Softworks • Publisher:<br />

Arkane Studios • Platform: <strong>PC</strong>, PS4, XBox One<br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 89


Endless Space 2<br />

RARE EARTH FOAMS OR ASTROFINANCE? CHOOSE NOW!<br />

A<br />

developer that wants you to<br />

buy its new space-themed 4X<br />

strategy game faces a unique<br />

challenge. Because these games are all<br />

the same. No really - 4X (explore, expand,<br />

exploit, exterminate) games set in space<br />

have no distinguishing characteristics<br />

whatsoever. You can’t tell them apart.<br />

Calm your space-jets, Ouroboran<br />

Apostles of the End Turn, I’m wasn’t<br />

talking to you, I was talking to the<br />

underpeople. The ‘normies’. YOU, as 4X<br />

fans and veterans, can absolutely identify<br />

the subtle nuances in each title, and<br />

know that 150 hours in Distant Worlds is a<br />

profoundly different experience from 150<br />

hours in Stellaris. If you’re Zen about it,<br />

anyway.<br />

Ever since Australia’s own Roger Keating<br />

and Ian Trout wrote Reach for the Stars<br />

way back in 1983, 4X has remained not<br />

so much hostile to new converts, as it is<br />

brutally indifferent to their confusion and<br />

flailing attempts to get a grip on all that<br />

hypercomplexity. These normies, they<br />

lack the specialised adaptations in the left<br />

fusiform gyrus of their brains, is what I’m<br />

saying. Don’t hate them. Pity them.<br />

Endless Space 2 begins as all spacebased<br />

4X begins: you get a single star<br />

system, a single homeworld, a single<br />

colony ship, a single scout, (sometimes<br />

a single attack ship, depending on race),<br />

and a single-minded mission to dominate<br />

the galaxy. Lesser gamers pursue victory<br />

by military conquest, by technological<br />

advancement, by even, perhaps, the<br />

rather reductive accumulation of mere<br />

points, but we Ultranauts of Iterated<br />

Fate, we prefer the diplomatic victory,<br />

don’t we? Because we always want what<br />

we can’t have. Which means, of course,<br />

diplomacy in ES2 sucks.<br />

Seriously, we’d happily eschew racial<br />

sub-factions or five types of resources, or<br />

even these hand-drawn heroes and their<br />

milquetoast buffs. We just need - NEED<br />

- an incredible self-learning AI, diligently<br />

programmed by, like, the guys who did<br />

IBM’s Watson, to mess with our heads. To<br />

break us, to stomp us, and then to mock<br />

us.<br />

When an alien pops up on your screen<br />

and demands cash money lest it unleash<br />

its three rusty corvettes against your 25<br />

gleaming battleships... wouldn’t it be<br />

great to spend forty minutes wondering<br />

just what the hell this AI’s long game<br />

is, wondering what you’re not seeing,<br />

because attacking a battlefleet with three<br />

garbage scows... there HAS to be a plan<br />

right? Alas, in ES2 there is no wonder,<br />

and there is no plan. The AI is doing this<br />

because the AI is dumb.<br />

Still, let us put aside our<br />

disappointment, and cleanse the bile<br />

from our palates with the refreshing<br />

sorbet of ES2’s Major Factions. Far from<br />

mere Humans of Different Hues, each<br />

is properly different. The Unfallen are<br />

basically ents, you know, tree people.<br />

The Riftborn are refugees from an<br />

orthogonally-alternate universe. The<br />

Horatio are billions of clones of one crazy<br />

hyperbillionaire. And so on.<br />

90 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


GAMES REVIEW<br />

It all goes into the mix, and that mix is<br />

further enhanced with sub-factions and<br />

different population types on the one<br />

planet, and bonuses for encouraging<br />

population diversity, and intra-factional<br />

politics, and being overridden by your<br />

own senate, and possible descent into<br />

anarchy, and... and this does indeed result<br />

in a game of considerable complexity.<br />

Because you, you plucker of Fractal Fruit<br />

from the Great Decision Tree, you want<br />

this complexity. You demand it!<br />

And to support it, Amplitude has<br />

crafted a beautiful, elegant interface.<br />

A skinny-fonted sanctum sanctorum, in<br />

which you hold the fate of billions. No,<br />

trillions. Icons and numbers float in the<br />

darkness of deep space. Each is familiar,<br />

yet also unfamiliar. What devilry is this?<br />

You flail, mouse-pointer flicking to reveal<br />

tooltip after tooltip. And then you realise:<br />

even as a Master you must learn, and<br />

again you must learn...<br />

ES2 was in Early Access for a year or<br />

so, so others have come before you and<br />

learned already. They played a thousand<br />

games, and made YouTube videos where<br />

they break ES2 down into its component<br />

parts and answer important, stat-based<br />

questions like: “Given that it costs me<br />

fewer command points to build three<br />

small ships with 400HP each, than it does<br />

“You, you plucker of<br />

Fractal Fruit from the<br />

Great Decision Tree”<br />

a big ship with 1200HP, and overall fleet<br />

strength remains the same, why would I<br />

bother spending 30 turns researching the<br />

big ship when I can just spam these little<br />

ones?”<br />

ES2’s complexity invites these<br />

questions, as well as questions about<br />

resource levels, population levels,<br />

population happiness, population<br />

political identity, which anomalies are<br />

worth analysing, the value of ancient<br />

artefacts from the eponymous Endless<br />

precursor race, upgrades, ship formations,<br />

the battleplan system, terraforming,<br />

optimised resource extraction...<br />

Does any of this even matter? Look, as<br />

a wanderer among the Nested Always-<br />

Futures of One More Turn, you know that<br />

the next 4X game you sink 1000 hours<br />

into won’t win your favour with a sleek<br />

interface, nor will you spurn it because of<br />

the nuanced stupidity of its rock/paper/<br />

hyperkinetic-darkmatter-quantumtorpedo<br />

combat system. It’s more subtle<br />

than that, a feel, a vibe. ES2 is hard to<br />

score, because to the 4X casual (does<br />

this person even exist?) it works no better<br />

or worse than any other 4X game. But<br />

for you, an Antimatutinal Arbiter of the<br />

Quadridimensional Irrealis, can Endless<br />

Space 2 ever hope to join the ranks of the<br />

greats like Galactic Civilizations II, Master<br />

of Orion 2, or even Distant Worlds?<br />

Alas, despite its many interesting<br />

aspects of newness, I suspect the answer<br />

is no. ES2 is beautiful, it is sleek, but it<br />

joins a genre stuffed with exemplary<br />

achievements in gameplay design, and it<br />

is remarkable only for being new.<br />

Besides, playing Endless Space 2 is, like<br />

all new 4X games, just another excuse.<br />

An excuse we Philosophers-Militant of<br />

Stepwise History keep making, to avoid<br />

that ultimate test of our faith: Aurora. The<br />

Most Insanely Complex 4X Game Ever<br />

Made. I’m told it’s not so bad. They say<br />

after 100 hours, you’ll have almost learned<br />

how to read the system map...<br />

Anthony Fordham<br />

KEY SPECS<br />

www.endless-space.com<br />

Genre: 4X turn-based strategy • Developer: Amplitude<br />

Publisher: SEGA • Platform: <strong>PC</strong><br />

OVERALL<br />

0 1 2 3 4 5<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 91


The A-List<br />

THE VERY BEST GEAR YOU CAN BUY<br />

THE BEST <strong>PC</strong> IS A MAC?<br />

The fact that our best desktop <strong>PC</strong><br />

here has long been a Mac bothers us,<br />

and maybe some of you, too. We’re<br />

not saying that this particular Mac<br />

is the best computer you can put on<br />

your desktop, because we all know<br />

that you can shop at any of the terrific<br />

Australian online or physical shops<br />

and spec-up a machine that leaves<br />

this in the dust. But the reason we<br />

don’t select a machine from any of<br />

these places is due to several factors.<br />

First, there’s tremendous variability<br />

– most of these boxes are intended<br />

for customisation when you place the<br />

order, sometime with many things<br />

changed. It’s also true that many<br />

advertised <strong>PC</strong>s don’t exist other than<br />

on paper until the orders start coming<br />

in. Things change quickly, too, with<br />

models constantly updated – and<br />

that’s a big advantage the <strong>PC</strong> has over<br />

the Mac. So we worry that a particular<br />

model may no longer be sold after just<br />

a couple of months.<br />

The other thing is that we could put<br />

in any of the good All-In-One machines<br />

from the likes of Dell and HP, but the<br />

iMac we have on the right is simply<br />

better than any of them, that’s why it’s<br />

here.<br />

I hope that’s cleared things up a bit<br />

for you. As always, check our Market<br />

Snapshot on page 19 every issue<br />

for the latest on the best and most<br />

interesting <strong>PC</strong>s you can buy this right<br />

now.<br />

<strong>PC</strong> DESKTOP<br />

ALL-IN-ONE<br />

Apple iMac 27in with Retina 5k display<br />

<br />

PRICE $2,799<br />

SUPPLIER www.apple.com/au<br />

The Apple 27in iMac with Retina 4K display is great. The best<br />

all-in-one computer around, and by a furlong.<br />

SPECIFICATIONS Quad-core 3.1GHz Intel Core i5 processor; Intel Iris Pro graphics<br />

6200; • 8GB RAM • 1TB HDD • 27in 4096 x 2304 Retina 5K IPS display • SDXC card slot • 4<br />

x USB 3 • 2 x Thunderbolt 2 • Gigabit Ethernet • 802.11ac Wi-Fi<br />

PERIPHERALS<br />

WIRELESS ROUTER Synology<br />

RT2600ac Wi-Fi Router<br />

<br />

SUPPLIER www.synology.com<br />

This router really does do it all, and at a great price<br />

point. We’d go so far as to say it’s the best 2600AC<br />

router on the market, with blazing speeds, a rich feature<br />

set and that oh-so-amazing interface. Highly recommended<br />

for both novices and network engineers alike.<br />

SPECIFICATIONS dual channel<br />

(2.4GHz – 800Mbps; 5GHz –<br />

1.73Gbps); EEE 802.11a/b/g/n/<br />

ac; twin USB ports (1 x 2.0, 1 x<br />

3.0); MU-MIMO compatible;<br />

beamforming<br />

NAS Synology<br />

Diskstation DS216+<br />

<br />

SUPPLIER www.synology.<br />

com<br />

For most people the Synology<br />

DS216+ is all the NAS they’ll<br />

ever need.<br />

SPECIFICATIONS 2x SATA 3 2.5”/3.5” drive<br />

bays • Intel Celeron Dual Core 1.6GHz CPU • 1GB DDR3 RAM • eSata, 2x USB 3.0 & 3x<br />

USB 2.0 • 1x Gigabit Ethernet<br />

LASER PRINTER Dell B1160w<br />

<br />

SUPPLIER www.dell.com.au<br />

The best all-rounder in our printer grouptest, with excellent<br />

text printing and decent costs.<br />

SPECIFICATIONS 1800 x 600dpi resolution; USB 2; Wi-Fi; 150-sheet input<br />

trays; 331 x 215 x 178<br />

ALL-IN-ONE PRINTER<br />

EPSON WF-3620<br />

<br />

SUPPLIER www.epson.com.au<br />

It’s a near-perfect MFP for home or small-office use,<br />

and a cut above the cheap MFPs you’ll find on the office<br />

supplier shelves.SPECIFICATIONS 4,800 x 2,400dpi A4 inkjet • 2,400 x<br />

1,200dpi colour scanner • claimed 33/20ppm mono/colour printing • 6.8cm touchscreen<br />

• 802.11n Wi-Fi • 10/100 Ethernet • USB 2 • fax modem • SD card slot<br />

92 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


A-LIST REVIEWS<br />

LAPTOPS<br />

VALUE<br />

Asus T100HA<br />

<br />

PRICE $399<br />

SUPPLIER www.asus.com.au<br />

Performance that delivers everything<br />

typical day to day computing demands<br />

short of intense gaming, combined<br />

with a fantastic screen and a solid and<br />

we think, rugged design makes this the<br />

value king.<br />

SPECIFICATIONS 10.1in IPS panel • Intel Quad-Core x5-<br />

Z8500 processor • 64GB eMMC SSD • 2GB LPDDR3 memory<br />

HANDHELDS<br />

SMARTPHONE<br />

OnePlus3<br />

<br />

PRICE $432<br />

SUPPLIER<br />

www.oneplus.net<br />

Quick, beautiful,<br />

long-lasting and an<br />

incredible price; you<br />

won’t find a better<br />

phone for the money.<br />

SPECIFICATIONS Quad-core<br />

2.2GHz Qualcomm Snapdragon 820<br />

processor • Adreno 530 graphics • 6GB RAM •<br />

5.5in 1,080 x 1,920 AMOLED display • 64GB storage • dual SIM<br />

• 16MP/8MP rear/front camera • 802.11ac Wi-Fi<br />

EBOOK READER<br />

Kindle Paperwhite<br />

<br />

PRICE $119<br />

SUPPLIER<br />

www.amazon.com<br />

The premium<br />

Kindle goes the<br />

extra mile, with a<br />

more attractive<br />

design, lower<br />

weight, and better<br />

contrast.<br />

SPECIFICATIONS 6in 1,072 x 1,448 E Ink Carta display •<br />

4GB storage • single-band 802.11n Wi-Fi • optional 3G • 1yr<br />

RTB warranty • 117 x 9.1 x 169mm (WDH)<br />

GAMING<br />

Asus GL502VS<br />

<br />

PRICE $2,995<br />

SUPPLIER www.asus.com.au<br />

Asus has built a very solid machine<br />

around an incredible new GPU. This has<br />

totally revolutionised the performance<br />

we can expect from a laptop, putting<br />

many regular desktops to shame.<br />

SPECIFICATIONS GeForce GTX 1070 GPU • Intel<br />

i7-6700HQ CPU • 8GB DDR4 • 15.6-inch IPS display • 1TB<br />

HDD • 256GB SSD<br />

TABLET<br />

Apple iPad Pro 9.7in<br />

<br />

PRICE $849 (32GB, Wi-Fi)<br />

SUPPLIER www.apple.com/au<br />

This is a tablet you’ll<br />

want to use all the<br />

time, and there’s no<br />

higher praise for any<br />

piece of technology<br />

than that.<br />

SPECIFICATIONS 64-bit<br />

Apple A9X custom processor with<br />

M9motion coprocessor • 2GB RAM •<br />

32/128/256GB storage • 9.7in 2,048<br />

x 1,536 IPS display<br />

SMARTWATCH<br />

Apple Watch 2<br />

<br />

PRICE $529<br />

SUPPLIER<br />

www.apple.com/au<br />

The Apple Watch<br />

is the best<br />

smartwatch on the<br />

market – and the<br />

Series 2 can now<br />

claim to be among<br />

the best fitness<br />

trackers too.<br />

SPECIFICATIONS<br />

340 x 272 AMOLED • GPS • heart rate sensor<br />

PROFESSIONAL<br />

Microsoft<br />

Surface Book<br />

<br />

PRICE $2,299 – $4,206<br />

SUPPLIER www.microsoft.com.au<br />

Truly beautiful, undeniably powerful<br />

and without doubt the best<br />

professional laptop you can buy.<br />

SPECIFICATIONS 13.5in 3000x2000 IPS display • Intel<br />

i5-6300U/i7-6600U CPU • 8/16GB RAM, optional Nvidia<br />

GPU • 256/512GB <strong>PC</strong>Ie SSD • 802.11ac Wi-Fi • Bluetooth 4.0,<br />

2x USB 3.0 • Mini DisplayPort<br />

SOFTWARE<br />

SECURITY Kaspersky<br />

Total Security<br />

<br />

SUPPLIER www.kaspersky.com<br />

Kaspersky Total Security is the only<br />

security package on test that achieved<br />

both perfect protection and falsepositives<br />

scores.<br />

BACK UP Acronis<br />

True Image 2015<br />

<br />

SUPPLIER www.acronis.com.au<br />

The 2015 version adds full-system<br />

backup and dual backup.<br />

OFFICE<br />

SUITE<br />

Microsoft<br />

Office<br />

365 Home<br />

Premium<br />

<br />

SUPPLIER<br />

www.microsoft.<br />

com.au<br />

The easiest to use Office to date.<br />

WEB DEV Adobe<br />

Dreamweaver CS6<br />

<br />

SUPPLIER www.adobe.com.au<br />

This edition makes PHP and CMS its<br />

core focus.<br />

ULTRA PORTABLE<br />

Dell XPS 13<br />

<br />

PRICE $2,499<br />

SUPPLIER www.dell.com<br />

There’s no denying how sexy Dell’s<br />

latest XPS is. Premium. Sexy. Stylish.<br />

Lightweight. Damn does this Ultrabook<br />

impress. Along with a multitude of ports,<br />

the extra battery life is a very pleasing<br />

bonus.<br />

SPECIFICATIONS Intel 7th Generation Core i7-6500 •<br />

8GB memory • 256GB SSD • 13.3-inch QHD+ with Touch<br />

AUDIO Cubase 7.5<br />

<br />

SUPPLIER www.steinberg.net<br />

The addition of better filters solidifies<br />

this program’s continued place on the<br />

A-List.<br />

VIDEO Sony Vegas Movie<br />

Studio HD Platinum 11<br />

<br />

SUPPLIER www.sony.com.au<br />

May not have the bells and whistles of<br />

other consumer editing packages, but<br />

its tools are efficient.<br />

PHOTO Adobe<br />

Photoshop Lightroom 6<br />

<br />

SUPPLIER www.adobe.com.au<br />

Lightroom 6 doesn’t add up to a<br />

revolutionary update, but it improves<br />

on what was already an exceptional<br />

piece of software.<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 93


The Kitlog<br />

THE GAME BOX<br />

AMD GPU UPGRADE<br />

As AMD does, a new year brings a slightly<br />

tweaked set of GPUs. <strong>Tech</strong>nically it’s not a<br />

new family of GPUs, but the improvements<br />

we see in the 500-series make it the<br />

sensible choice to replace the AMD RX 480<br />

we’ve had in the Game Box.<br />

We’re jumping straight from the 480 to<br />

the 580, and sticking with the 8GB variant.<br />

When matched with the LG UC79C (or a<br />

similar resolution monitor), the 8GB of<br />

memory is ample to hold textures and<br />

there should be no symptoms of running<br />

short of memory.<br />

Best of all these improvements in the<br />

GPU come at the same price as the 480, so<br />

with that comes better overclocking, lower<br />

power consumption and slightly higher<br />

performance.<br />

VIDEOCARD MEMORY MOTHERBOARD CPU<br />

INTEL CORE I5 6600K<br />

PRICE $319<br />

Gaming generally doesn’t make use<br />

of hyper-threading which makes<br />

this the CPU of choice for this box.<br />

ASUS Z170 PRO GAMING<br />

PRICE $229<br />

Our Skylake Value Award winner, it packs<br />

in a complete set of features yet is priced<br />

reasonably. Good audio also means we don’t<br />

need a sound card.<br />

AMD RX 580 8GB<br />

PRICE $380<br />

More than enough power to run our<br />

chosen monitor and with FreeSync<br />

working, at a very reasonable price.<br />

8GB OF DDR4<br />

PRICE $65<br />

The speed and brand makes so little<br />

difference to performance we can’t<br />

recommend one over another.<br />

THE PERFECT <strong>PC</strong><br />

VIDEOCARD MEMORY MOTHERBOARD CPU<br />

INTEL CORE I7 6700K<br />

PRICE $459<br />

Intel’s top-shelf unlocked i7 CPU.<br />

GIGABYTE<br />

GA-170X GAMING G1<br />

PRICE $715<br />

The most complete<br />

100-series motherboard<br />

you can buy today.<br />

NVIDIA GTX 1080 TI<br />

PRICE $1,189<br />

The fastest graphics card of them all.<br />

32GB OF DDR4<br />

PRICE $200<br />

For a general-purpose build 16GB is<br />

all you need, but go big if you know<br />

you need more.<br />

94 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


KITLOG REVIEWS<br />

TOTAL: $2,932 RIG ONLY: $1,661<br />

AUDIO DISPLAY SYSTEMDRIVES COOLER<br />

SAMSUNG 850 PRO 512GB<br />

PRICE $319<br />

This SSD offers greatly improved<br />

durability. Supplement it with a hard<br />

drive of your choice if needed.<br />

LG UC79G<br />

PRICE $940<br />

Ultrawide 2560x1080, curved, 144Hz with<br />

FreeSync, this is the gaming screen to<br />

bury your head in.<br />

HYPERX<br />

CLOUD REVOLVER<br />

PRICE $119<br />

For the price they sound<br />

almost as good as $500<br />

audiophile cans<br />

COOLERMASTER<br />

NEPTON 140XL<br />

PRICE $85<br />

Easy to install AIO CPU cooling,<br />

relative quiet and performance to<br />

rival twin-radiator units.<br />

POWER SUPPLY MOUSE KEYBOARD CASE<br />

COOLER MASTER<br />

QUICKFIRE XTI<br />

PRICE $149<br />

Good looks, solid and reliable<br />

build and many gaming features.<br />

COOLER MASTER G750M<br />

PRICE $129<br />

Outstanding value for money, it’s<br />

powerful enough for even performance<br />

<strong>PC</strong>s packing twin GPUs.<br />

BITFENIX RONIN<br />

PRICE $106<br />

Bitfenix continues to deliver great<br />

budget cases that look terrific and<br />

are easy to build in.<br />

TT ESPORTS LEVEL 10 M<br />

PRICE $85<br />

Mouse perfection. Lovely on-screen<br />

and on-pad movement, super<br />

accurate and delightful to use.<br />

TOTAL: $7,366 RIG ONLY: $5,179<br />

AUDIO HDDS SSDS COOLER<br />

SAMSUNG 960<br />

PRO 2TB SSD<br />

PRICE $1,799<br />

Significantly faster than any<br />

other SSD on the market.<br />

ANY HDD<br />

PRICE $99 (2TB)<br />

Supplement the SSD<br />

with cheap HDD storage.<br />

CORSAIR H100IGTX<br />

WATER COOLER<br />

PRICE $159<br />

Excellent cooling that is easy<br />

to install with advanced<br />

monitoring.<br />

ASUS PA329Q<br />

PRICE $1,999<br />

32-inches of 10-bit colour at 4k res, 100%<br />

RGB for professionals, and a luxurious<br />

delight for gaming and general use.<br />

POWER SUPPLY MOUSE KEYBOARD CASE<br />

LOGITECH G610 PRICE $139<br />

Stunning looks and a delight to type on.<br />

STEELSERIES APEX M500<br />

PRICE $135<br />

A similar alternative to the G610.<br />

CORSAIR HX1000I<br />

PRICE $305<br />

Corsair’s mighty HX1000i<br />

pumps out extremely reliable<br />

power, even when under<br />

full loads.<br />

ANTEC S10<br />

PRICE $255<br />

If you absolutely must have what is<br />

very nearly the best case we’ve seen,<br />

this is the one.<br />

CM STORM REAPER<br />

PRICE $49<br />

Very solid and feels fantastic under<br />

the hand with sweet on-screen<br />

movement.<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 95


SUBSCRIBE<br />

OR RENEW TO<br />

WIN<br />

A GALAX<br />

GTX 1070<br />

EXOC SNIPER WHITE<br />

GRAPHICS CARD<br />

WORTH $659!<br />

VALUED<br />

AT<br />

$659<br />

Is it time to upgrade your graphics card? Subscribe or<br />

renew and you could win a mighty Galax GTX 1070 Exoc<br />

Sniper White, which has the power to run games at ultra<br />

detail, even at extreme resolutions.<br />

It features a beautiful white anodized aluminium<br />

backplate, and comes factory overclocked to a 1594MHz<br />

Base clock speed. Dual 100mm LED cooling fans provide<br />

efficient cooling with low noise, and a unique RGB<br />

backplate adds a bit of magic to your case.<br />

WWW.GALAX.COM<br />

If you’d prefer to read us<br />

on your mobile, tablet or<br />

computer, purchase a digital<br />

edition of the magazine! Visit<br />

www.mymagazines.com.au.<br />

Digital editions available<br />

from the App Store, Zinio<br />

and Google Play.


Subscribe to <strong>PC</strong> & <strong>Tech</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> today and you’ll receive 12<br />

issues for only $85 – THAT’S JUST $7.90 AN ISSUE (RRP $9.99)!<br />

You’ll have a year’s worth of magazines delivered FREE direct to<br />

your door, and SAVE OVER $34 ON THE COVER PRICE!<br />

Subscribe online at<br />

www.mymagazines.com.au<br />

or call 1300 361 146<br />

Price offer available to Australian residents only ending 9/7/17. All rates include GST. Savings based on total cover price. NZ Airmail: 1yr/12 issues A$89.95.<br />

Overseas Airmail: 1yr/12 issues A$159. Subscriptions commence with the first available issue, please allow 6–8 weeks for delivery of your magazine<br />

and separate delivery of your prize (after 11/7/17). Competition open to Austtralian and NZ residents subscribing or renewing to <strong>PC</strong> & <strong>Tech</strong> <strong>Authority</strong><br />

for a minimum of 1 year. Competition opens 12/6/17 at 12:01AM and closes 9/7/17 at 11:59PM. One (1) subscriber will win a Galax GTX 1070 Exoc Sniper<br />

White Graphics Card valued at $659. Total prize pool valued at $659 (incl. GST). Prize is not transferable or exchangeable. Winner will be drawn 11/7/17<br />

at nextmedia P/L, St Leonards NSW. The Promoter is nextmedia P/L, ABN 84 128 805 970; L6, Building A, 207 Pacific Highway, St Leonards NSW 2065.<br />

Authorised Under: NSW Permit LTPM/17/01661, ACT Permit No. TP 17/00650. For full competition terms and conditions go to mymagazines.com.au. Our<br />

Privacy Notice can be found at nextmedia.com.au. If you would prefer to receive communication electronically, please ensure we have your current email<br />

address.<br />

MA/<strong>PC</strong>A236


DVD CONTENTS<br />

WE HAVE A SPECIAL FEATURED APPS SECTION THIS MONTH! CHECK IT OUT!<br />

FEATURES<br />

+ ASHAMPOO UNINSTALLER <strong>2017</strong> +<br />

ABELSSOFT ANTIRANSOMWARE <strong>2017</strong> +<br />

ASCOMP BACKUP MAKER + NOVAPDF<br />

LITE 8<br />

FEATURED APPS<br />

+ SECURITY + CODING &<br />

PRODUCTIVITY + MEDIA &<br />

ENTERTAINMENT<br />

DRIVERS<br />

+ ATI CATALYST + NVIDIA FORCEWARE<br />

HELP<br />

+ DISCLAIMER + DAMAGED OR FAULTY<br />

DVDS + USING THIS DVD + INSTALLING<br />

SOFTWARE<br />

EDITORIAL<br />

+ BURNING AN ISO IMAGE<br />

+ <strong>PC</strong>&TA EDITORIALS<br />

TROUBLESHOOTING<br />

+ SERIAL CODES + BLANK<br />

REGISTRATION WEBSITE + CAN’T FIND<br />

A FILE? + INSTALLATION ERROR<br />

WINDOWS<br />

+ 7ZIP + CCLEANER + CLASSIC<br />

SHELL + CUTEPDF + DEEPBURNER +<br />

DEFRAGGLER + FLUX + FOXIT READER<br />

+ GREENSHOT + APPLE ITUNES<br />

+ LIBRE OFFICE + OPEN OFFICE +<br />

MALWAREBYTES’ A/M + SANDBOXIE<br />

+ VLC MEDIA PLAYER<br />

MAC<br />

+ ALFRED + BETTERTOUCHTOOLS +<br />

APPLE ITUNES + DROPBOX + FLUX +<br />

GOOGLE CHROME + MOZILLA FIREFOX<br />

+ PLEX + SKYPE + TEAMVIEWER + VLC<br />

INTERNET<br />

+ VUZE + DROPBOX + GOOGLE<br />

CHROME + MOZILLA FIREFOX + MOZILLA<br />

THUNDERBIRD + SKYPE + STEAM<br />

INSTRUCTIONS: Open Windows Explorer,<br />

navigate to your DVD drive and doubleclick<br />

Index.html in the root directory. DISC<br />

PROBLEMS: To replace faulty DVDs, please<br />

send the discs to: <strong>PC</strong>&<strong>Tech</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> DVD<br />

Replacements, Level 5, Building A, 207 Pacific<br />

Highway, St Leonards NSW 2065<br />

Make sure to include your name and postal address on the back of<br />

the package so that we know where to send the replacements. For<br />

all other DVD related issues email dvd@pcauthority.com.au. As<br />

the delivery platform only, <strong>PC</strong>&TA and nextmedia cannot and will not<br />

provide support for any of the software or data contained on these<br />

discs. Although all discs are virus scanned, nextmedia cannot accept<br />

any responsibility for any loss, damage or disruption to your data or<br />

computer system that may occur while using the discs, the programs<br />

or the data on them. There are no explicit or implied warranties for<br />

any of the software products on the discs. Use of these discs is strictly<br />

at your own risk.<br />

98 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

FULL VERSION<br />

ASHAMPOO UNINSTALLER <strong>2017</strong><br />

Ashampoo Uninstaller is a powerful<br />

program which can fully remove stubborn<br />

applications from your system. And<br />

despite its name, that’s not all - it also<br />

has a very full set of <strong>PC</strong> maintenance<br />

tools.<br />

Select an installed program and<br />

Ashampoo Uninstaller goes to work,<br />

locating and deleting any associated files<br />

and Registry keys.<br />

There are free tools which do the<br />

same, but Ashampoo also has the ability<br />

to monitor programs as they’re being<br />

installed. This enables it to detect all the<br />

changes made, and ensures far more<br />

accurate removals later.<br />

You also get the ability to create and<br />

compare snapshots of your system.<br />

These can’t be used for uninstalling, but<br />

do have other uses, such as showing<br />

the changes made by an application<br />

whenever if runs.<br />

Most of the competition don’t even<br />

have this much functionality, but<br />

Ashampoo Uninstaller keeps going<br />

with more <strong>PC</strong> optimization tools than<br />

many suites. There are disk and Registry<br />

cleaners, an internet history wiper, a<br />

defrag tool, individual startup program/<br />

Windows service/ font/ system restore<br />

point managers, an undelete tool, a<br />

secure file wiper, duplicate file/ invalid<br />

shortcut finders, and more.<br />

REQUIREMENTS:<br />

- Windows 7, 8, 10 32/64-bit<br />

- 50 MB hard drive space<br />

LIMITATIONS:<br />

- Registration Required<br />

- http://www.ashampoo.com/<br />

REGISTRATION & INSTALLATION:<br />

Download and run ashampoo_<br />

uninstaller_<strong>2017</strong>_25961.exe<br />

You will reach a prompt asking you to<br />

enter your license key. On the same<br />

screen, click the “Get a free activation<br />

key” button.<br />

A webpage will appear asking for your<br />

email. Please fill in accordingly.<br />

After you have followed the instructions<br />

on the website, you will be presented with<br />

your license key. Copy and paste this back<br />

into the installer program.<br />

Congratulations! You have unlocked<br />

Ashampoo Uninstaller <strong>2017</strong>!<br />

For support of this software, please<br />

direct your queries to: https://www.<br />

ashampoo.com/en/aud/sup<br />

FULL VERSION<br />

ABELSSOFT<br />

ANTIRANSOMWARE <strong>2017</strong><br />

Abelssoft AntiRansomware <strong>2017</strong> is a<br />

program designed to constantly monitor<br />

your computer for ransomware, and<br />

raise the alarm as soon as any suspicious<br />

activity is detected.<br />

The package works by scanning the key<br />

folders where your data files are stored.<br />

You can tell it to watch any or all of the<br />

four main user folders - Documents,<br />

Pictures, Music, Videos - or add custom<br />

folders of your own.<br />

If AntiRansomware <strong>2017</strong> spots<br />

potentially dangerous activity it’ll<br />

display a warning and recommend<br />

that you reboot. If you’re very sure it’s a<br />

false alarm, this can be dismissed, but<br />

otherwise the system will automatically<br />

reboot into Safe Mode after a countdown.<br />

Rebooting may sound drastic, and it<br />

could mean that you lose unsaved work.<br />

But if you really have been infected by<br />

ransomware, it could save hundreds or<br />

even thousands of files from encryption--<br />

and rebooting automatically protects you<br />

even if you’re not at the computer.<br />

Abelssoft AntiRansomware <strong>2017</strong><br />

restarts your computer in Safe Mode,<br />

which should prevent the ransomware<br />

from operating. It sends an email to your<br />

registered address to act as a warning,<br />

just in case you’re not around, and opens<br />

an assistant to advise you of the next<br />

steps and help you recover your data.<br />

The program can’t remove the<br />

ransomware, unfortunately, so it’s not<br />

a substitute for a full antivirus package.<br />

But you can run it alongside your existing<br />

package without conflicts, and it just<br />

might give you a valuable early alarm of<br />

problems.<br />

REQUIREMENTS:<br />

- Windows 7, 8, 10 32/64-bit<br />

- 20 MB hard drive space<br />

LIMITATIONS:<br />

- Registration required.<br />

- https://www.abelssoft.de/<br />

REGISTRATION & INSTALLATION:<br />

- Download and install AntiRansomware_<br />

cs_uk_08_<strong>2017</strong>.exe<br />

- A prompt will appear when you first run


CONTENTS DVD<br />

the application, the prompt will detail<br />

on how to register the application.<br />

- For support of this software, please<br />

direct your queries to: https://www.<br />

abelssoft.de/en/contact<br />

FULL VERSION<br />

ASCOMP BACKUP MAKER<br />

ASCOMP BackUp Maker is an easyto-use<br />

and highly configurable tool for<br />

backing up all your most important<br />

personal files.<br />

Simple backups can be set up in<br />

seconds. Choose a few items you’d like<br />

to protect (Chrome, Internet or Firefox<br />

bookmarks, your Documents, Pictures<br />

or Music folders), click Next a few times,<br />

pick a destination drive and you’re done.<br />

ASCOMP BackUp Maker gets more<br />

interesting as you start to explore its<br />

options. The Scheduler can run backups<br />

daily, at regular intervals (every x<br />

minutes), on specific days of the week or<br />

month, when you connect a particular<br />

USB device, when a certain drive is<br />

mapped, when Windows starts, or you<br />

log off.<br />

That’s just the beginning. You can use<br />

a combination of these events, maybe<br />

automatically running backups once a<br />

day and when Windows starts. It’s also<br />

possible to limit operations, perhaps<br />

running backups only within a certain<br />

timeframe, or if your computer is idle.<br />

The program scores bonus points<br />

elsewhere, too. Many backup programs<br />

enable running a custom command<br />

before or after your backup, but BackUp<br />

Maker can run multiple actions, and has<br />

built-in commands to get you started.<br />

You’re able to run a program, close or<br />

restart Outlook (handy if you need to<br />

back up a PST file), show a message,<br />

connect or disconnect a network drive,<br />

print or email a backup report, reboot or<br />

shut down Windows, and more. Set this<br />

up and it all works entirely automatically,<br />

with nothing else for you to do.<br />

ASCOMP BackUp Maker has plenty<br />

of standard features, too: include and<br />

exclude filters, optional encryption and<br />

password protection, disk spanning,<br />

remote and optional local backups, and<br />

saving to CD/ DVD or remote FTP servers.<br />

Create one backup job, and add more<br />

as required. They’ll all run automatically<br />

if you’ve set up the scheduler, but you can<br />

also launch them from the program or<br />

optionally via a system-wide hotkey.<br />

REQUIREMENTS:<br />

- Windows 7, 8, 10 32/64-bit<br />

- 20 MB hard drive space<br />

LIMITATIONS:<br />

- Registration required.<br />

- https://www.ascomp.de/en/<br />

REGISTRATION & INSTALLATION:<br />

- Download and install bkmaker.exe<br />

- When you run the software, click on the<br />

“REGISTER NOW” text located on the<br />

bottom of the application main screen.<br />

- For support of this software, please<br />

direct your queries to: https://www.<br />

ascomp.de/en/company/imprint<br />

FULL VERSION<br />

NOVAPDF LITE 8<br />

NovaPDF is a powerful commercial tool<br />

for creating PDF files.<br />

Install the program and it equips your<br />

<strong>PC</strong> with a virtual printer driver, enabling<br />

you to create PDFs from any Windows<br />

application. Just open your target<br />

document, choose the Print option, select<br />

the novaPDF printer, and the program will<br />

convert it for you.<br />

The program also provides its own<br />

console where you can choose a<br />

document, and convert it to PDF directly.<br />

NovaPDF directly integrates with<br />

Microsoft Office applications, too. Open<br />

a document, click the novaPDF tab, and<br />

again you can have it converted to PDF in<br />

a couple of clicks.<br />

However you start the conversion<br />

process, your finished document can<br />

be customised in many different ways.<br />

Bookmarks, metadata, font embedding,<br />

link detection, text optimisation, layout<br />

PDF/A and Linear PDF options are all<br />

customisable, while a smart Profile<br />

AUTHORITY<br />

system makes it easy to group particular<br />

settings together (you might have one<br />

profile for home documents, the other for<br />

work, then change between the two as<br />

required).<br />

REQUIREMENTS:<br />

- Windows 7, 8 or 10 64Bit<br />

- 50 MB hard drive space<br />

LIMITATIONS:<br />

- Registration required<br />

- http://www.novapdf.com/<br />

REGISTRATION & INSTALLATION:<br />

- Download and install novaPDFcreativemark.exe<br />

- To obtain your serial code, fill out form<br />

on http://www.novapdf.com/free/<br />

creativemarkn17.html<br />

- For support of this software,<br />

please direct your queries to:<br />

http://www.novapdf.com/<br />

search?q=novapdf&commit=Search<br />

FREE FULL VERSIONS: Each<br />

month, we offer <strong>PC</strong> & <strong>Tech</strong><br />

<strong>Authority</strong> readers full registrable<br />

versions of some software on<br />

the DVD. See the installation<br />

instructions in the DVD menu<br />

to complete registration, if<br />

applicable. IMPORTANT: Full<br />

product registration closes on<br />

21/07/17<br />

DVD CONTENTS<br />

FEATURES + ASHAMPOO UNINSTALLER <strong>2017</strong> + ABELSSOFT ANTIRANSOMWARE <strong>2017</strong> +<br />

ASCOMP BACKUP MAKER + NOVAPDF LITE 8 FEATURED APPS + SECURITY + CODING &<br />

PRODUCTIVITY + MEDIA & ENTERTAINMENT HELP + DISCLAIMER + DAMAGED OR FAULTY<br />

DVDS + USING THIS DVD + INSTALLING SOFTWARE EDITORIAL + BURNING AN ISO IMAGE<br />

+ <strong>PC</strong>&TA EDITORIALS TROUBLESHOOTING + SERIAL CODES + BLANK REGISTRATION<br />

WEBSITE + CAN’T FIND A FILE? + INSTALLATION ERROR WINDOWS + 7ZIP + CCLEANER<br />

+ CLASSIC SHELL + CUTEPDF + DEEPBURNER + DEFRAGGLER + FLUX + FOXIT READER<br />

+ GREENSHOT + APPLE ITUNES + LIBRE OFFICE + OPEN OFFICE + MALWAREBYTES’ A/M<br />

+ SANDBOXIE + VLC MEDIA PLAYER MAC + ALFRED + BETTERTOUCHTOOLS + APPLE<br />

ITUNES + DROPBOX + FLUX + GOOGLE CHROME + MOZILLA FIREFOX + PLEX + SKYPE<br />

+ TEAMVIEWER + VLC INTERNET + VUZE + DROPBOX + GOOGLE CHROME + MOZILLA<br />

FIREFOX + MOZILLA THUNDERBIRD + SKYPE + STEAM<br />

INSTRUCTIONS: Open Windows Explorer, navigate to your DVD drive and double-click Index.html<br />

in the root directory. DISC PROBLEMS: To replace faulty DVDs, please send the discs to: <strong>PC</strong>&<strong>Tech</strong><br />

<strong>Authority</strong> DVD Replacements, Level 5, Building A, 207 Pacific Highway, St Leonards NSW 2065<br />

Make sure to include your name and postal address on the back of the package so that we know where to send the replacements. For all other DVD related<br />

issues email cd@pcauthority.com.au. As the delivery platform only, <strong>PC</strong>&TA and Haymarket Media cannot and will not provide support for any of the<br />

software or data contained on these discs. Although all discs are virus scanned, Haymarket Media cannot accept any responsibility for any loss, damage<br />

or disruption to your data or computer system that may occur while using the discs, the programs or the data on them. There are no explicit or implied<br />

warranties for any of the software products on the discs. Use of these discs is strictly at your own risk.<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 99


JON HONEYBALL<br />

“THIS IS A CRITICAL STEP<br />

FORWARD FOR PERSONAL DATA<br />

SECURITY – AND A BLOW TO<br />

INTELLIGENCE AGENCIES”<br />

Jon explores the advantages of Apple’s new file system, before explaining<br />

why we all need to sit up and listen when it comes to surround sound for VR<br />

T<br />

he launch of a new file system is a<br />

rare event. There are good reasons<br />

for this: moving over an entire<br />

community of users from one file system<br />

format to another is a big deal. No,<br />

scratch that – it’s a huge deal. And it’s the<br />

sort of hugeness that means you can do<br />

this only once a decade. Even that would<br />

be considered almost rashly hasty.<br />

If you think about it, the <strong>PC</strong>/Windows<br />

world has seen remarkably few file<br />

systems over the history of the <strong>PC</strong>.<br />

We started with MS-DOS, and then<br />

subdirectories were added – oh, the<br />

naughty radicalism of that move! MS-<br />

DOS evolved from FAT to FAT32, and then<br />

stopped. NTFS came with Windows NT in<br />

1992, and it had tiny evolutions in the first<br />

decade, before it also stopped.<br />

Then Microsoft came up with ExFAT,<br />

which can be described as FAT64, or<br />

“FAT-with-some-NTFS-bits-added”,<br />

depending on whether your view is topdown<br />

or bottom-up. ExFAT has been fairly<br />

successful, although take-up by third<br />

parties remains slow, no doubt as a result<br />

of the licensing cost that Microsoft applies<br />

for ExFAT inclusion in your product.<br />

So the news that Apple is moving to<br />

the new Apple File System (APFS) is<br />

significant, simply because it’s such a rare<br />

event. Apple has decided that the existing<br />

one is old and tired, coming as it does<br />

from the era of the floppy disk drive. All<br />

this is true, but Apple has tweaked it into<br />

multiple versions targeted at its different<br />

platforms. So there’s an APFS for macOS.<br />

One for iOS. Another for Watch (yes, the<br />

Watch needs to have a file system, even if<br />

you can’t directly access it yourself).<br />

By moving to APFS, Apple has brought<br />

together all the capabilities required into<br />

JON HONEYBALL<br />

Jon is the MD of an IT consultancy<br />

that specialises in testing and<br />

deploying hardware<br />

@jonhoneyball<br />

100 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au<br />

a single platform – and has strengthened<br />

and extended it significantly. One notable<br />

move is in the handling of encryption.<br />

iOS supported full disk encryption, which<br />

was a good thing. APFS goes further and<br />

allows for full disk encryption of both<br />

files and metadata, and also allows for<br />

multi-key encryption with per-file keys for<br />

file data and a separate key for sensitive<br />

metadata. This is a critical step forward<br />

for personal data security, and somewhat<br />

of a blow to the intelligence agencies that<br />

want access to everything right now.<br />

“The news that Apple<br />

is moving to the new<br />

Apple File System<br />

(APFS) is significant,<br />

simply because it’s such<br />

a rare event”<br />

What’s interesting about APFS is that<br />

Apple is making very little noise about<br />

it. It isn’t even mentioned in the release<br />

notes for 10.3, which is odd given how<br />

significant the change is. It might explain<br />

why the 10.3 update takes some time to<br />

process, because it has to trundle through<br />

the file system and change all the AFS<br />

stuff to APFS. This isn’t the first time<br />

such changes have been done on the<br />

fly – readers with long memories will<br />

recall how Microsoft originally hadn’t<br />

written an NTFS formatter program,<br />

but had a tool that converted FAT<br />

format to NTFS, using the infamous<br />

“convert d: /fs:NTFS” command.<br />

Part of getting users onto APFS is<br />

that the transition has to be totally<br />

seamless.<br />

Last time I checked, the APFS<br />

support in macOS betas was for<br />

data volumes only – you couldn’t<br />

boot from it. Clearly, this isn’t<br />

acceptable for a mass rollout of<br />

APFS in the forthcoming autumn update<br />

to macOS, so I’m sure Apple is quickly<br />

fixing this limitation. But be clear that<br />

macOS will be changing from AFS to<br />

APFS this year.<br />

Some are claiming that their iPhone<br />

runs longer on battery using the APFS<br />

file system, because it’s faster and more<br />

efficient. I think it’s much too early to have<br />

a view on this, but it’s possible that it<br />

will speed up older iPhones (and related<br />

devices).<br />

COLOUR SPACE OF<br />

AMOLED DISPLAY<br />

Here’s an interesting problem. I’ve<br />

recently been conducting various<br />

measurements of tablet screens.<br />

The tools I use are about the best<br />

that money can buy – the Klein meter<br />

(kleininstruments.com/k-80) feeding<br />

into the excellent CalMAN software from<br />

SpectraCal (calman.spectracal.com).<br />

I measured the iPhone 7 Plus, which<br />

displayed truly superb performance. Its<br />

accuracy to the sRGB colour space is so<br />

good that you can carry out colour-correct<br />

work onscreen with high confidence that<br />

Some claim<br />

Apple’s new file<br />

system speeds up<br />

their older<br />

devices


JON HONEYBALL REAL WORLD COMPUTING<br />

your edits will reflect in the final output<br />

correctly. If you use a screen with poor<br />

colour accuracy, then you’ll make changes<br />

but have no idea if they’re correct or even<br />

appropriate to the underlying desired<br />

modification. It truly is a case of the blind<br />

leading the blind.<br />

So colour accuracy matters. Normally,<br />

you could measure the performance of<br />

a screen, then generate a new ICC file<br />

that contains details of the colour errors<br />

and how to correct them. Then you apply<br />

this ICC file to the display and it displays<br />

colours correctly.<br />

Unfortunately, Apple doesn’t allow<br />

you to rewrite the ICC file for the iPhone<br />

or iPad screen. While this is of itself<br />

somewhat disappointing, the reality is<br />

that the screen is normally sufficiently<br />

close to the correct colour that tweaking<br />

isn’t really needed. I say “normally”<br />

because Apple, like any large-scale<br />

manufacturer, has to use multiple<br />

suppliers to satisfy the mind-bending<br />

“Until we have a known<br />

and defined colour<br />

space for domestic still<br />

images, we’re left with<br />

a problem”<br />

production numbers that are demanded<br />

by customers, especially in the initial few<br />

months when the New Shiny has just<br />

landed and everyone wants to be seen<br />

holding it.<br />

So Apple buys screens from multiple<br />

sources, and they don’t always agree<br />

in terms of colour accuracy and even<br />

maximum brightness. The differences<br />

aren’t huge, and I’m not convinced that<br />

they would justify the creation of a<br />

custom ICC profile for a typical “man in<br />

the street” user. But it would be nice for<br />

the professional, finicky user who wants<br />

to know that it’s correct.<br />

I then put a Samsung tablet onto<br />

the test rig – a Galaxy Tab S2, which is<br />

quite rightly a highly regarded product.<br />

I fired up the meter and CalMAN again,<br />

and measured the display accuracy.<br />

It was all over the place. I mean, truly<br />

horribly wrong. This caused much headscratching,<br />

until I realised that this tablet<br />

uses the current state-of-the-art Super<br />

AMOLED display, which claims to offer a<br />

bigger colour range than a normal display.<br />

I dug into the display settings, and<br />

found that I could set it to Basic mode.<br />

This was almost spot on to the sRGBexpected<br />

colours. But when I went back<br />

to normal, default mode, the colours<br />

were wrong. “Wrong” as in “much<br />

Klein’s K-80 colorimeter is my tool of choice for measuring colour accuracy of screens<br />

too shouty and loud”, if I can use the term<br />

we use here in the lab. Super-saturated,<br />

bold and bright colours. It certainly looks<br />

impressive, but it isn’t correct.<br />

Now this does matter, because an RGB<br />

value of 255.0.0 has an expected red<br />

performance when displayed. It maps<br />

through to the original colour value that<br />

the camera saw. Take 255.0.0 and apply<br />

it to a Super AMOLED display, and you’ll<br />

get a very strong red. It will be punchy.<br />

It’s correct in that it is indeed a supersaturated<br />

red. But it isn’t the same red<br />

that was intended when the camera took<br />

the photo.<br />

Herein lies the problem. In the film/<br />

video world, we’ve known about colour<br />

issues for years, and there’s even a<br />

specialised step in the production process<br />

that exists to handle colour imbalances,<br />

called “grading”. We have multiple colour<br />

spaces to choose from in the high-end<br />

film/video world and we know that we<br />

need to take control of it. However, this<br />

isn’t true when it comes to photography,<br />

and especially not in the world of the<br />

smartphone camera, where the user<br />

simply points and shoots.<br />

Until we have a known and defined<br />

colour space for domestic still images<br />

that encompasses the enhanced colour<br />

space of Super AMOLED, we’re left with<br />

a problem. Do we set the display to the<br />

sRGB colour space and disallow the<br />

enhanced colour space that the display<br />

can stretch to? Or do we show enhanced<br />

colour, knowing that it’s incorrect,<br />

however nice it might be to look at?<br />

Then, another question: how should we<br />

report on such a display? Do we measure<br />

it in “default user mode”, in which case<br />

it’s wrong, despite it just looking like “very<br />

loud” colour. Or do we switch it down<br />

to sRGB mode and report on its fine<br />

performance, clear in the knowledge that<br />

almost no user will switch away from<br />

Super AMOLED mode?<br />

It’s certainly a quandary, and one to<br />

be aware of when considering all the<br />

pathway components used in a colour<br />

film and stills environment. Don’t assume<br />

that things are as you might want, out of<br />

the box.<br />

SURROUND SOUND STUFF<br />

Back in the 1970s, Peter Craven and<br />

Michael Gerzon developed the Soundfield<br />

microphone. This is essentially a singlepoint<br />

microphone array, comprising<br />

four capsules in a tetrahedron array.<br />

The output from this array, known<br />

as “A-format”, is processed via some<br />

straightforward maths to generate a<br />

four-channel signal called “B-format”.<br />

The channels on B-format are named<br />

X, Y, Z and W. X is front to back; Y is left<br />

to right; Z is the up to down; and W is an<br />

omnidirectional signal.<br />

Once you have a B-format feed, either<br />

live or recorded, you effectively have the<br />

data necessary to create a virtual sphere<br />

of sound, representing all the sound<br />

sources around you – whether they be<br />

Are the colours of your tablet screen accurate enough<br />

for colour correction work?<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 101


Rode’s first VideoMic Soundfield mic will be released later this year<br />

behind, up, left, or in the top-right corner<br />

of your perspective.<br />

Now things get really fun. From the<br />

B-format feed that creates a virtual<br />

sphere, you can place virtual loudspeakers<br />

into that sphere and then map them to<br />

real, physical speakers that are mounted<br />

around you. It might be an eight-speaker<br />

cube. Or a 12-speaker array. Or some other<br />

custom array. Providing you have a way<br />

of mapping the virtual speakers to the<br />

array, you have a way of recreating the<br />

physical sound field that was present at<br />

the Soundfield microphone.<br />

And, of course, if you have a highquality<br />

digital recorder, then recording<br />

the four channels of B-format means you<br />

can play it back later, and resynthesise<br />

the sound field. Or fiddle with it to your<br />

heart’s content. There’s superb software<br />

available for working with B-format; my<br />

favourite is from Harpex (harpex.net). It<br />

allows me to take B-format and output<br />

to binaural, which is surround sound<br />

optimised for headphones. Or even<br />

to Dolby Atmos format. Noisemakers<br />

(noisemakers.fr) from France has a full<br />

suite of fascinating plugins too, some of<br />

which are pay-for and others are free.<br />

Calrec productionised the Soundfield<br />

microphone in the late 1970s, and it’s<br />

been a stalwart of the surround sound<br />

world ever since. I remember using one<br />

for recordings throughout my undergrad<br />

years, from 1982 to 1986. Indeed, I wanted<br />

my final year research project to be a way<br />

of capturing head movement such that I<br />

could then post-process the virtual sphere<br />

in a way to handle the head movement.<br />

So if you were listening on headphones,<br />

which is vastly easier than a huge<br />

arrangement of a dozen or more speakers<br />

mounted on a framework, moving your<br />

head would allow the sound field to stay<br />

correctly orientated in space, irrespective<br />

of your head movement. Unfortunately,<br />

at the time, the accelerometers and<br />

processing necessary was simply beyond<br />

what was achievable for a reasonable<br />

cost.<br />

But times change. Roll forward to a<br />

few months ago, and the Soundfield<br />

platform was sold to Rode microphones<br />

in Australia, as I mentioned in this column<br />

two months ago. Rode is world-renowned<br />

for its high-quality microphones, sold<br />

at reasonable prices. Its engineering<br />

is absolutely state-of-the-art for the<br />

complex process of making microphones.<br />

It has made a fortune from selling mics<br />

that go on top of cameras to accurately<br />

capture the sound for news, interviews<br />

and so forth, and also makes a range of<br />

top-notch sound recording mics.<br />

It has already announced a VideoMic<br />

Soundfield for release later in the year.<br />

I couldn’t be more excited by the news,<br />

because it will bring B-format to a far<br />

wider range of customers. Soundfield<br />

mics have been the playthings of the<br />

wealthy – the need for four channels to<br />

store B-format was quite a pain in the<br />

Harpex’s software allows me to optimise B-format<br />

for headphones<br />

early days, because four-channel digital<br />

recorders were rare. And the mics weren’t<br />

cheap – around $10,000 for one isn’t a<br />

price to be sniffed at.<br />

So why am I discussing this once again?<br />

Because surround sound is becoming<br />

increasingly important. There’s a big push<br />

towards VR now, whether you’re working<br />

at the cheap end of the market using a<br />

smartphone and a cardboard headmount<br />

from Google, or you have the money to<br />

pay for an Oculus Rift. But be in no doubt<br />

that VR is pushing full surround sound<br />

to centre-stage, and that means that<br />

B-format’s time has really come.<br />

Still don’t believe me? Just look at all<br />

the work broadcasters are doing with<br />

VR with binaural fed from microphone<br />

arrays, including B-format. Or Google’s<br />

work with its Spatial Audio system<br />

(https://developers.google.com/vr/<br />

concepts/spatial-audio) and its support<br />

on YouTube. If you just want surroundsound<br />

playback, you can use YouTube/<br />

Google on headphones from a computer<br />

running Chrome, Firefox, Opera or Edge.<br />

On Android and iOS, you can use the<br />

appropriate YouTube app.<br />

With the cost of entry collapsing, the<br />

desire to capture full surround sound with<br />

orientation information is growing. This<br />

is a true resurgence of the work done by<br />

Gerzon and Craven all those years ago,<br />

and it’s certainly worthy of your attention.<br />

STORAGE STORIES<br />

My plans for a second Synology NAS<br />

came to fruition with the purchase of<br />

a 2415+ 12-bay monster. I started off by<br />

fitting it with ten Seagate SkyHawk 8TB<br />

drives, along with two Samsung 850 Evo<br />

250GB SSDs for cache. I should have<br />

known I was in trouble when I powered it<br />

up for the first time.<br />

Two of the drives failed. I returned them<br />

to Amazon and received replacements.<br />

Then another two failed. At that point,<br />

I contacted Amazon and returned the<br />

entire stack of Seagate drives for a full<br />

refund. I replaced them with trusty WD<br />

Red drives from another supplier. Since<br />

then it has been trundling along just fine.<br />

My plan is to use the built-in Synology<br />

Hyper Backup tool between the two large<br />

arrays, with one array held in the lab and<br />

the second over the courtyard at my ISP<br />

on the other end of the Gigabit fibre link I<br />

mentioned a few months ago.<br />

Am I worried about the drive failures?<br />

No, because the whole point about<br />

redundant systems is that they are<br />

redundant. I have no idea why I had<br />

a bad batch of Seagate SkyHawks<br />

from Amazon, but having got to four<br />

failures out of 12 drives (ten plus the two<br />

replacements), I decided it was time to<br />

walk away.<br />

102 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


PAUL OCKENDEN REAL WORLD COMPUTING<br />

PAUL OCKENDEN<br />

“THE ADDITION OF WIRELESS<br />

SUDDENLY MAKES THIS A<br />

FAR MORE USEFUL LITTLE<br />

BOARD FOR IOT PROJECTS”<br />

Paul finds the new Raspberry Pi Zero W is an excellent platform<br />

for creating a “thing”, and provides a tip for Netgear Orbi owners<br />

I<br />

thought I’d follow on from last<br />

month’s column by starting to show<br />

you how to build a genuinely useful<br />

Internet of Things (IoT) “thing”. And<br />

to prove there’s plenty of choice in the<br />

marketplace when it comes to ultracheap<br />

wireless platforms, I’m going to<br />

change boards. Last month was mostly<br />

about the ESP8266-based NodeMCU<br />

development kit; this month I’ll focus<br />

on the Raspberry Pi Zero W. Why? Well,<br />

because it’s fairly new (the “W” wireless<br />

variant first went on sale at the end of<br />

February).<br />

I’m sure many of you already know<br />

this, but the Raspberry Pi Foundation<br />

is a charity, founded in Cambridge, and<br />

its stated aim is to “promote the study<br />

of computer science and related topics,<br />

especially at school level, and to put the<br />

fun back into learning computing”.<br />

The foundation is primarily<br />

supported by Cambridge University’s<br />

Computer Laboratory and hardware<br />

manufacturer Broadcom – whose<br />

chips you’ll find at the heart of the<br />

device.<br />

There have been several Raspberry<br />

Pi models over the past four years, but<br />

there was a real buzz in late 2015 when<br />

the Pi Zero hit the streets. It was small,<br />

and low cost – about $12. It wasn’t as<br />

powerful as the Raspberry Pi 3, but with<br />

a single-core 1GHz processor it was no<br />

slouch, either.<br />

It was missing wireless, however.<br />

The board had only a single USB port,<br />

so if you added a USB wireless dongle<br />

it meant you’d effectively cut the Pi off<br />

from any other communication. You<br />

could add a USB hub, of course, but then<br />

the whole “small and cheap” ethos was<br />

PAUL OCKENDEN<br />

Paul owns an agency that helps<br />

businesses exploit the web, from<br />

sales to marketing and everything<br />

in between @PaulOckenden<br />

out of the window.<br />

Which all goes to explain my<br />

excitement over the launch of the Pi<br />

Zero W. It’s essentially the Pi Zero with<br />

added Wi-Fi and Bluetooth. The Wi-Fi<br />

is 802.11bgn; no 802.11ac and no 5GHz,<br />

but given its price is less than a tenner, I<br />

don’t think anyone will be surprised. The<br />

on-board Bluetooth is 4.1 with low energy<br />

(BLE) support. The addition of wireless<br />

functionality suddenly makes this a far<br />

more useful little board for IoT projects,<br />

and puts it on a par with the NodeMCU<br />

development board, for example.<br />

I want to get a little nerdy for a<br />

moment about the Pi Zero W’s onboard<br />

2.4GHz antenna. Normally you’d expect<br />

this to be a track on the PBC with a<br />

length that’s an exact fraction of the<br />

12.5cm wavelength<br />

found with 2.4GHz radio signals.<br />

This makes use of the fact that since<br />

resonance occurs at whole number<br />

fractions of the wavelength (1/2, 1/3,<br />

1/4 and so on), shorter antennas can be<br />

used. They aren’t as efficient as full-wave<br />

antennas, but without such fractional<br />

antennas many electronic gadgets<br />

would have to be bigger. For example,<br />

an 800MHz mobile phone signal would<br />

need an antenna that’s 37.5cm long!<br />

Fractional wavelength <strong>PC</strong>B tracks<br />

aren’t the only option, however – the<br />

other major player is the ceramic chip<br />

antenna. There are several types, but<br />

the common factor is that they use a<br />

material with a high permittivity (which<br />

my dictionary defines as “the ability of a<br />

substance to store electrical energy in an<br />

electric field”.) The key is that in highpermittivity<br />

materials the wavelength of<br />

a radio signal is reduced, so the antenna<br />

can be made smaller as a result.<br />

Until now, those have been the<br />

only two choices, but the Pi Zero W<br />

introduces a third type of antenna. If you<br />

look carefully at a photo of the board,<br />

you may notice a tiny triangular shape<br />

etched into the copper of the <strong>PC</strong>B. This is<br />

an amazing new type of 2.4GHz antenna.<br />

It acts as a tuned resonant cavity, and<br />

the geometric shape, together with a<br />

couple of associated capacitors, allow<br />

the structure to capture Wi-Fi and<br />

Bluetooth radio traffic. The technology<br />

is licenced from Swedish company<br />

Proant, and is similar in concept to the<br />

traditional “slot” or “notch” antenna –<br />

but in this case it’s so small that Proant<br />

has called the product design “niche”<br />

rather than notch. I suspect that<br />

probably passes for a joke in Sweden!<br />

I was sceptical at first, but it works<br />

well. And, more importantly, it keeps<br />

the board small and cheap. Signal<br />

strength is decent, but if you need<br />

The Raspberry Pi Zero, now with Wi-Fi and<br />

Bluetooth


more you’ll find there are pads on the<br />

board onto which you can solder a<br />

standard U.FL RF connector, for use of an<br />

external antenna. For most folk, the little<br />

triangle will be adequate.<br />

IT’S A SETUP<br />

The kit I looked at last month was<br />

configured by loading firmware and/or<br />

code via the USB connection. The normal<br />

Raspberry Pi setup is different to this.<br />

Since the device is actually a computer<br />

running an OS, the usual way to get things<br />

running is to connect a USB mouse and<br />

keyboard (because there’s only one<br />

socket on the Pi Zero boards, a wireless<br />

“desktop” combo is the easiest option),<br />

with a monitor connected to the HDMI<br />

port. It isn’t dissimilar to setting up a new<br />

desktop computer.<br />

The thing is, unless you have a suitable<br />

mouse, keyboard and screen lying<br />

around, plus the various connectors/<br />

converters to plug into the micro-<br />

USB and mini-HDMI, you could easily<br />

find yourself spending far more on<br />

peripherals and leads than you did on<br />

the Pi itself. Also, because we’re going to<br />

set it up as an IoT “thing”, the keyboard,<br />

mouse and monitor won’t be needed<br />

beyond the initial setup.<br />

Luckily, with some fiddling it’s possible<br />

to configure the board without using a<br />

keyboard and screen. There are just two<br />

things we need to do: the first is to get<br />

the onboard Wi-Fi connected to your<br />

network; the second is to enable SSH, so<br />

we can open a remote command prompt.<br />

But I’m jumping ahead of myself here.<br />

The very first thing you’ll need to do is<br />

to create a microSD card containing<br />

the OS for the Pi. There are several<br />

options available (see raspberrypi.<br />

org/downloads), including a version<br />

of Windows 10. However, for most<br />

people, the most sensible option will be<br />

Raspbian – a flavour of Debian Linux.<br />

If you look at the download page<br />

(raspberrypi.org/downloads/raspbian),<br />

you’ll see two versions listed – one with<br />

PIXEL, and a “Lite” version. PIXEL is the<br />

Raspberry Pi desktop environment,<br />

and since we’ll be operating without a<br />

monitor, there simply isn’t a need for that.<br />

Download the Lite version.<br />

It will be easiest to download the ZIP<br />

version. Once unzipped, you’ll see an<br />

IMG file, just under 1.5GB in size. Flash<br />

that onto a microSD card. Even if you<br />

don’t have one kicking around, they’re<br />

incredibly cheap. If your card reader only<br />

has a full-sized SD card slot, you’ll also<br />

need an adapter.<br />

If you’re using Windows then the<br />

recommended flashing tool is Win32 Disk<br />

Imager (tinyurl.com/odxlnmf), whereas<br />

Mac users can either use dd from the<br />

command line, or use Etcher (etcher.io),<br />

which will be easier for novices. However<br />

you do it, you’ll end up with a microSD<br />

that can be used to boot the Pi Zero W.<br />

But we’re not done yet. First we<br />

need the board to hop onto your Wi-Fi<br />

network, and to do that it will need to<br />

know your network name and password.<br />

Now if you were using a keyboard, mouse<br />

and screen, this would be easy: you could<br />

simply select the network using the Pi’s<br />

GUI. But since we’re doing this using a<br />

headless setup, you’ll need to add the<br />

details manually. Eject the card from<br />

your card reader (using the OS tools,<br />

rather than just pulling out the card) then<br />

re-insert it. It should mount like a normal<br />

disk, and you’ll see a file system in place.<br />

The card has two partitions: one called<br />

boot, the other root. The root partition<br />

uses an ext4 file system and contains<br />

the normal Linux file structure, which is<br />

mounted as “/” once the Pi boots – it’s<br />

where pretty much everything to do with<br />

the Pi lives. The boot partition is a FAT file<br />

system and is used only during booting.<br />

You’ll see it mounted as /boot once you<br />

have the Pi up and running.<br />

When you insert a Pi microSD card into<br />

the card reader on a <strong>PC</strong> or a Mac, you’ll<br />

see this boot partition is visible with full<br />

read/write access. But the main root


PAUL OCKENDEN REAL WORLD COMPUTING<br />

There are a few OSes available for the Raspberry Pi,<br />

but Raspbian is the best place to start<br />

The antenna is that little triangle between the HDMI<br />

and USB sockets<br />

partition normally isn’t accessible – you’ll<br />

need to install additional software to<br />

view it. Luckily, we don’t have to do that.<br />

The designers of Raspbian have created<br />

a facility where if you put certain files in<br />

the boot partition, they’re copied over<br />

to root when the Pi starts up (and then<br />

deleted from boot).<br />

To get your Pi Zero W connected to<br />

your wireless network, you’ll need to<br />

place a file called wpa_supplicant.conf in<br />

the root folder of the boot partition, and<br />

in that text file include the following text:<br />

network={<br />

ssid=“Your_wifi_network_name”<br />

psk=“Your_wifi_password”<br />

key_mgmt=WPA-PSK<br />

}<br />

Then plug the Pi Zero W into a USB<br />

power supply (or a USB port on your<br />

computer, which should have enough<br />

power to drive it) and you should see the<br />

green LED flash for a while, and then stay<br />

lit green.<br />

Next go to your wireless router and<br />

view the list of connected devices. If<br />

everything has gone to plan, you’ll see<br />

your Raspberry Pi listed, along with its<br />

IP address (it will have a MAC address<br />

starting with B8:27:EB). If you don’t have<br />

admin access to your wireless router,<br />

just run a network scan – it’s easiest to<br />

do this from an app on your phone – and<br />

you’ll see the Pi listed as “raspberrypi”.<br />

Once you know the IP address you’ll<br />

find you can ping it, but you won’t be<br />

able to open an SSH connection – that’s<br />

because SSH is disabled by default in the<br />

latest versions of Raspbian. This change<br />

was made shortly after the tech world<br />

became paranoid about IoT devices<br />

being taken over and used as part of a<br />

botnet.<br />

To enable SSH, at least initially, simply<br />

power down the Pi, plug the SD card<br />

back into your <strong>PC</strong>, and create a blank file<br />

called ssh (with no extension) in the root<br />

of the /boot partition. Then pop the card<br />

back into the Pi and reboot it.<br />

Incidentally, you’ll probably see that<br />

the green LED continues to flash, rather<br />

than appearing solid after a minute or so.<br />

It’s because you pulled the power, rather<br />

than performing a clean shutdown.<br />

Don’t worry, though – everything is fine.<br />

Just give it a few more minutes and the<br />

flashing will stop once the system has<br />

checked that the file system is clean.<br />

You should see a solid green LED once<br />

it has booted, and not only be able to<br />

ping the device (its IP address may have<br />

changed) but also connect to it via SSH.<br />

The username is “pi” and the password<br />

“raspberry”. It’s important to remember<br />

that the ssh file gets deleted, so you get<br />

only one shot. If you reboot the Pi, you’ll<br />

need to add the ssh file again.<br />

Incidentally, if you don’t have an SSH<br />

client then I recommend PuTTY for<br />

Windows users (tinyurl.com/mgyxbev)<br />

and vSSH for those of you on a Mac<br />

(tinyurl.com/ovetpzl). Both are excellent.<br />

Once you can access the Pi’s<br />

command line you’ll be able to do things<br />

like “ping www.google.co.uk” to test<br />

connectivity. Unlike ping on a Windows<br />

<strong>PC</strong>, it just keeps going, so you’ll need to<br />

use Control+C to stop it.<br />

Rather than messing around with<br />

ssh files, we can configure the Pi to<br />

have SSH permanently enabled. Type<br />

sudo raspi-config, go into Interfacing<br />

Options, select SSH and then the option<br />

to enable it. While you’re there make<br />

sure IC2 is enabled, too, as we’ll need<br />

that in a moment. You can also change<br />

the password for the pi account from<br />

“raspi-config” – and that’s probably a<br />

good idea. Then select Finish to exit<br />

raspi-config. Incidentally, “sudo” is a little<br />

like running something as administrator<br />

on a <strong>PC</strong>. The Pi login doesn’t have access<br />

to write these configuration changes,<br />

but preceding the command with sudo<br />

A quick hack allows you to see which Orbi unit your<br />

devices are connected to<br />

means to run it as a “super-user”.<br />

Now you can reboot the Pi as often<br />

as you like, and it will hop onto your<br />

wireless network and enable SSH access.<br />

No more messing around with files in<br />

the boot partition. Incidentally, rather<br />

than just pulling the plug, the correct<br />

way to shut down the Pi is by using<br />

sudo shutdown – by default, it will take<br />

a minute. Or you can reboot by using<br />

sudo reboot. This way, you won’t get the<br />

flashing green LED mentioned earlier,<br />

while the device scans the file system for<br />

errors.<br />

Next month, I’ll show you how to turn<br />

your newly configured Raspberry Pi Zero<br />

W into a useful IoT thing.<br />

INTO ORBI<br />

I continue to be impressed by Netgear’s<br />

Orbi “whole house” Wi-Fi system. It’s<br />

incredibly fast and bathes the whole area<br />

in a really strong Wi-Fi signal. As I move<br />

around the house, I find my gadgets hop<br />

instantly and seamlessly between the<br />

main router and the satellite. It’s so much<br />

better than using conventional Wi-Fi<br />

extenders and boosters. And the latest<br />

firmware update offers a guest access<br />

facility (addressing one of my complaints<br />

the last time I wrote about Orbi). It’s<br />

fantastic kit, but a real shame that there<br />

isn’t a xDSL version, so you still need a<br />

separate modem if you have a telephone<br />

line-based internet connection.<br />

One little tip. If you have an Orbi, go<br />

to orbilogin.com/debug.htm and enable<br />

telnet (note that this link only works if<br />

you have an Orbi setup). Then telnet into<br />

the router and execute the following<br />

commands:<br />

nvram set enable_adv_attached=1<br />

nvram commit<br />

Don’t forget to go back to the<br />

debug page and switch telnet back<br />

off afterwards! Now when you view<br />

the attached devices in the Orbi user<br />

interface, you’ll be able to see whether<br />

they’re connected to the main router<br />

or the satellite. This is incredibly useful<br />

when it comes to finding the best<br />

position for each unit, and I’m surprised<br />

that it isn’t enabled by default.<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 105


DR LARISSA ROMUALDO SUZUKI<br />

“UNLESS CITIES CHANGE<br />

THE WAY THEY DESIGN, WE’LL<br />

NEVER DELIVER ON THE TRUE<br />

PROMISE OF SMART CITIES”<br />

How do you design a smart city? Dr Larissa Suzuki shares insights from her PhD thesis<br />

E<br />

very day nearly 180,000 people<br />

move to cities, resulting in more<br />

than 60 million new urban dwellers<br />

each year.<br />

Such rapid growth puts pressure on a<br />

city’s infrastructure (transport, energy,<br />

water, housing), and scarce infrastructure<br />

aggravates civil issues such as law and<br />

order and the delivery of basic services.<br />

For instance, studies suggest a typical<br />

driver spends 106 days of his/her life<br />

looking for parking spaces. In response to<br />

pressure from organisations and citizens,<br />

“smartening up” cities has become a<br />

priority for policy makers.<br />

The “smart city” label has been applied<br />

to a range of technology developments<br />

powered by city data and digital<br />

technologies. It’s hoped these will<br />

help cities plan for population growth,<br />

introducing a more sustainable model for<br />

urban development.<br />

We’ve already seen progress. Smart<br />

electricity grids, energy-efficient buildings<br />

and intelligent road crossings are<br />

examples of existing solutions. These are<br />

powered by data collected from many<br />

systems and stakeholders; matching<br />

high-quality data with digital services has<br />

the potential to drive economic growth,<br />

improve government transparency, and<br />

create innovative city services.<br />

TRUE SMART CITIES<br />

I’m a computer scientist and am<br />

passionate about how technology can<br />

benefit mankind. However, it’s tempting<br />

to fall into the trap of simply focusing<br />

on infusing technology in cities and<br />

disregarding true societal needs.<br />

Despite the potential of smart cities,<br />

there are no fully implemented smart city<br />

initiatives, and unless cities change the<br />

way they design, we’ll never deliver on<br />

the true promise of smart cities. This is<br />

because smart cities have been designed<br />

mainly as centralised technology topdown<br />

projects led by corporations, which<br />

put municipalities under pressure to<br />

deploy their projects and in which citizens<br />

appear as consumers at best.<br />

A true smart city is one where efficient<br />

urban services are available to all –<br />

including the disabled, senior, visually<br />

impaired and children. Our societies are<br />

stratified, and too many of the planned<br />

“smart” services (smart cars, for example)<br />

will probably only be available – in<br />

the next few decades, at least – for a<br />

privileged few. There are one billion people<br />

with some form of disability, and despite<br />

this huge demand, cities haven’t tailored<br />

their “smart services” to them.<br />

Adopting a more disciplined and<br />

societal-needs orientated approach can<br />

give cities the clarity they need to think<br />

strategically about how they can function<br />

better. My PhD research provides a<br />

framework that helps cities on this journey.<br />

CORE PRINCIPLES OF DESIGN<br />

To unlock smart services for all, cities need<br />

to embrace not only technology but many<br />

other non-technological elements. They<br />

must address the needs and expectations<br />

of all users of services, reduce the digital<br />

divide, and build public trust around new<br />

services and data sharing. Therefore, a<br />

one-size-fits-all approach will never work.<br />

My PhD research framework – named<br />

SMARTify – is built around five core<br />

domains, all of which are designed to<br />

support the delivery of a city’s own smart<br />

cities vision.<br />

1 SERVICES DESIGN<br />

Providing access to “smart things”<br />

designed without all society in mind isn’t<br />

providing access at all. To design services,<br />

you must understand the unique needs<br />

and expectations of all users, including<br />

senior citizens, disabled people and<br />

children.<br />

We must establish which infrastructure<br />

and datasets are subject to greatest<br />

demand, and use them for the trial of new<br />

technologies and services.<br />

Enabling integrated and responsive<br />

urban services often involves joining up<br />

data silos. It raises many security and<br />

privacy concerns around personal data<br />

(social media, GPS traces in phones),<br />

smart cards (transport usage patterns)<br />

and smart metering (lifestyle patterns).<br />

When designing services, cities must<br />

address the privacy aspects of personal<br />

data, and define data management<br />

Rapidly increasing numbers of city dwellers are<br />

driving the need for smarter cities<br />

DR LARISSA ROMUALDO SUZUKI<br />

now oversees the tool designed<br />

to improve coordination of<br />

infrastructure planning and delivery<br />

106 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


DR LARISSA ROMUALDO SUZUKI REAL WORLD COMPUTING<br />

strategies to ensure compliance<br />

with national and international<br />

data protection regulations.<br />

2 TECHNOLOGY DESIGN<br />

The main technological<br />

challenge in smart city design<br />

is the fragmentation in urban<br />

services, infrastructure and data<br />

provision. City data and digital<br />

services are provided by many<br />

stakeholders, systems and<br />

applications. This fragmentation<br />

creates a range of technical,<br />

strategic and organisational<br />

issues around interoperability,<br />

cross-domain data exploitation,<br />

and policies and regulations<br />

in data-orientated business<br />

models.<br />

The economic benefits and<br />

potential of smart cities relies<br />

upon the delivery of service innovation<br />

powered by interoperable technology.<br />

It can be facilitated by organising cities’<br />

technological assets around a common<br />

platform that can manage data and<br />

services, and physical assets.<br />

An initial step towards this endeavour is<br />

performing a city data-mapping exercise<br />

for a detailed picture of existing data and<br />

digital services. It includes identifying<br />

current and future:<br />

Data sources, volume, variety, temporal<br />

factors and security sensitivities<br />

(personal/private data);<br />

Processes and resources needed to<br />

manage data/services (computer and<br />

network power to respond to data<br />

requests, data storage requirements).<br />

Once a data and services inventory<br />

is created, it’s time to review existing<br />

metadata schema for each data type<br />

to identify standards with the greatest<br />

potential for reuse, and fill any gaps.<br />

Reducing technology and data<br />

friction using reliable standards for<br />

interoperability can help create new<br />

integrated urban services.<br />

3 VALUE NETWORK DESIGN<br />

Cities find it tremendously difficult<br />

to specialise in all the competencies<br />

involved in designing smart city services.<br />

Even powerful organisations such as<br />

Google and Apple need to collaborate<br />

with members of their value network<br />

(developers) to provide inventive<br />

applications to end users.<br />

Adopting the concept of data-driven<br />

value networks (DDVN) helps cities to<br />

decentralise their data and technology<br />

infrastructures and form an ecosystem of<br />

expert collaborators.<br />

There are three types of partners in a<br />

DDVN. Partners should be chosen based<br />

Tailor-made and<br />

useful data and<br />

digital servies<br />

to all<br />

Maximisation<br />

of the efforts<br />

of all society<br />

Services<br />

Value<br />

Network<br />

Governance<br />

<strong>Tech</strong>nology<br />

Value<br />

Design<br />

The SMARTify framework is designed to support the<br />

delivery of a smart city vision<br />

on the specialisation they can bring,<br />

whereas cities should deeply specialise<br />

in their core competence – governance of<br />

the DDVN.<br />

Supporting partners specialise in<br />

managing data and digital services, and<br />

making resources available to contributing<br />

partners. Disclosing technical blueprint<br />

details, for example, encourages open<br />

innovation, and enables partners to openly<br />

utilise resources.<br />

A DDVN enables cities to become a<br />

platform for the dissemination and active<br />

consumption of services that will provide<br />

society with a high quality of life, while<br />

also meeting their ambitious sustainability<br />

agenda. The success in designing smart<br />

cities will be co-determined by the way<br />

cities nurture, incentivise and coordinate<br />

this network.<br />

4 VALUE DESIGN<br />

Smart cities’ data and services have<br />

social, economic, environmental and<br />

financial value. It can be generated<br />

through the independent use or reuse of<br />

data and services, or by combining them<br />

with other sources to become inputs<br />

into applications, services and decisionmaking.<br />

For instance, city data can be input<br />

into complex algorithms and analysis to<br />

create insights through dashboards or<br />

visualisations. Cities must explore the<br />

value cases for the exploitation of data<br />

and services.<br />

On the flip side, the provision of digital<br />

services and data isn’t free. Understanding<br />

the associated cost entails engaging<br />

with existing and potential publishers,<br />

so that effective ways of recovering such<br />

costs can be explored. In some instances,<br />

City-wide exploitation<br />

of data<br />

Transformational<br />

business models<br />

and innovation<br />

charging users to utilise<br />

premium services and data<br />

may help recover such costs<br />

and fund the release of data<br />

and services.<br />

Structural partners can<br />

support the development<br />

of practical and diverse<br />

business models for data and<br />

digital services. Establishing<br />

business models and licencing<br />

agreements, including the<br />

Open Government Licence<br />

(OGL), can maximise the use of<br />

data and services. It may even<br />

increase competition on the<br />

platform as data providers fight<br />

(and collaborate) to provide the<br />

best-quality data and services<br />

to citizens.<br />

5 GOVERNANCE DESIGN<br />

A strong leadership strategy can enable<br />

technology, data and digital assets to be<br />

exploited to its full effect to deliver smart<br />

city design and planning.<br />

Designing smart cities as open<br />

platforms can create governance<br />

arrangements that provide a context in<br />

which distributed innovation, driven by the<br />

members of the platform ecosystem in<br />

the smart cities, can emerge.<br />

Open and transparent engagement<br />

with partners on the strategic direction<br />

of the smart cities vision can guarantee<br />

the delivery of the actions and prevent<br />

regulation problems during rollout. The<br />

intended benefits of the smart city vision<br />

should be clearly articulated, measured,<br />

managed, delivered and evaluated in<br />

practice by all partners.<br />

Besides working closely with the<br />

members of the DDVN, cities should<br />

actively promote services and innovation<br />

to demonstrate the value of smart cities.<br />

This can be achieved through government<br />

websites, hackathons, engagement with<br />

community groups and addressing digital<br />

literacy to drive uptake of services.<br />

MEASURING SUCCESS<br />

So how do you know you’ve built a smart<br />

city? First, cities must keep their smart<br />

city vision in mind, and continuously<br />

assess their progress using critical success<br />

factors. For instance, wider participation<br />

among all the population, a reduction<br />

in pollution-triggered deaths, increased<br />

innovation. Based on those assessments,<br />

they can then amend and improve their<br />

“smart city” design.<br />

Ultimately, a smart city design that’s<br />

aligned with a city’s own “smart vision”<br />

will provide it with a balance between<br />

social, environmental and economic<br />

opportunities.<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 107


DAVEY WINDER<br />

“THE US GOVERNMENT HAS COME<br />

CLOSE TO MAKING IT ILLEGAL TO USE<br />

SECURE COMMUNICATIONS ONLINE”<br />

Davey delves deep into the world of encryption. First, remembering how PGP<br />

began, and then through a service that promises to secure your email<br />

W<br />

ay back at the start of the<br />

1990s, Phil Zimmerman<br />

wrote an essay displaying<br />

remarkable perception of what was to<br />

come as the internet matured. “Email<br />

messages are just too easy to intercept<br />

and scan for interesting keywords,”<br />

Zimmerman wrote. “This can be done<br />

easily, routinely, automatically and<br />

undetectably on a grand scale.”<br />

Remember that this was almost 20<br />

years before Edward Snowden blew<br />

his snooping whistle loudly – and with<br />

such reverberations within the world of<br />

cryptology. Zimmerman then stated:<br />

“The government will protect our email<br />

with government-designed encryption<br />

protocols. Probably most people will<br />

acquiesce to that. But perhaps some<br />

people will prefer their own protective<br />

measures.” Phil Zimmerman was, in case<br />

you need reminding, the creator of Pretty<br />

Good Privacy (PGP).<br />

His journey towards fame – or<br />

infamy, dependent upon your views<br />

of government and privacy – began<br />

in 1991, when the US Senate had<br />

added a resolution to a bill that would<br />

“encourage” the industry to add<br />

backdoors to networking (including<br />

the emerging internet) equipment. The<br />

wording of that resolution resonates<br />

with more recent – and, sadly, more<br />

successful – attempts to blow the doors<br />

off the privacy of communications. “…<br />

providers of electronic communications<br />

services and manufacturers of electronic<br />

communications service equipment<br />

shall ensure that communications<br />

systems permit the government to<br />

obtain the plain-text contents of voice,<br />

data, and other communications when<br />

appropriately authorised by law.”<br />

DAVEY WINDER<br />

Davey is an award-winning<br />

journalist and consultant<br />

specialising in privacy and security<br />

issues @happygeek<br />

CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS<br />

Scary stuff, huh? And it’s worth repeating<br />

that this was 26 years ago. That US<br />

bill didn’t succeed, but it sure caught<br />

the attention of computer science<br />

graduate and software engineer Mr<br />

Zimmerman, who realised how close the<br />

US government had just come to making<br />

it illegal to use secure communications<br />

online. He wasn’t wrong, either: soon<br />

afterwards, public key cryptography<br />

had become a protected weapon<br />

(“munitions” was the term used in law)<br />

with strict export controls.<br />

Zimmerman had the foresight to get<br />

his PGP software, based around the RSA<br />

public key crypto algorithm, released as<br />

freeware. Along with the source code and<br />

documentation, he sent a copy of it to his<br />

friend Kelly Goen, who in turn uploaded<br />

the source to Usenet and a whole bunch<br />

of bulletin-board systems. The code, like<br />

the truth, will out – and out it was.<br />

Within a couple of years the<br />

government came calling; not the FBI,<br />

but US Customs. Zimmerman and Goen<br />

were charged with exporting protected<br />

munitions without the appropriate<br />

licence, and a federal grand jury<br />

indictment followed. In fact, it followed<br />

them for three years until the powers<br />

that be realised that the duck they had<br />

been chasing had died a long time ago.<br />

Not that this stopped the US government<br />

from starting a criminal investigation,<br />

which also failed to produce charges that<br />

stuck.<br />

Things went a little downhill from<br />

there with regards to the romance of<br />

the privacy defender story (if you see it<br />

through nerd-tinted spectacles like me).<br />

Zimmerman founded a company called<br />

PGP, which was acquired by Network<br />

Associates, which was acquired by<br />

McAfee, and which sold a commercial<br />

application of PGP. It gets even messier if<br />

you delve into licensing agreements and<br />

legal agreements between RSA (which<br />

owned the algorithm that PGP was<br />

based upon) and Zimmerman. The story<br />

kind of ends with Zimmerman agreeing<br />

not to distribute PGP any longer and RSA<br />

agreeing not to sue him as a result.<br />

As one story ends, another begins.<br />

That code, the PGP version 1.0 software<br />

that was pushed out into the public<br />

domain, had developed an organic<br />

momentum all of its own. Helped by<br />

MIT, PGP 2.5 eventually emerged from<br />

the ether and RSA became annoyed,<br />

but legal complications over interests in<br />

the algorithm patent meant that legal<br />

actions weren’t taken. It also meant<br />

that PGP could take on a new life, and<br />

Zimmerman was once again at the<br />

forefront of it.<br />

He published a book with the<br />

source code of the new PGP version<br />

programmed in C and printed it in a<br />

font designed to be scanner friendly.<br />

The US had made it quite clear, all the<br />

way to the Supreme Court and on many<br />

an occasion, that “written expression”<br />

couldn’t be against the law. Zimmerman<br />

had got another one-up on the man, as<br />

it were. Apart from the fact that it was<br />

actually still illegal to export PGP 2.5,<br />

thanks to that munitions classification.<br />

Thankfully, a European privacy-friendly<br />

programmer, Ståle Schumacher, adapted<br />

the code enough to make version 2.6xi<br />

legal anywhere in the world.<br />

Which is where we find ourselves<br />

today. Now there’s something called the<br />

OpenPGP standard via the Free Software<br />

Foundation, as the original source code<br />

is currently owned by Symantec, and<br />

most folk will use the GNU Privacy Guard<br />

(GnuPG) along with an email client such<br />

as Mozilla Thunderbird. Or they would<br />

if it were easier to install and configure.<br />

It involves getting on very friendly terms<br />

with the command line interface, or<br />

investing time to learn how a PGP client<br />

with a graphical UI works under the<br />

bonnet, or flashing the cash to subscribe<br />

to a service that does most of the dirty<br />

work for you.<br />

A NERDY NICETY?<br />

And now we stumble upon the real<br />

problem with PGP, or rather the real<br />

problem with encrypted emails and<br />

encrypted messaging in general. If it’s too<br />

108 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


DAVEY WINDER REAL WORLD COMPUTING<br />

Swiss servers and company incorporation mean data<br />

sovereignty isn’t an issue for SecureMyEmail<br />

complicated, only geeks will use it to talk<br />

to other geeks. I want to talk to my family,<br />

friends and assorted non-geek contacts.<br />

If it’s too expensive, only those who really<br />

want it and can afford it will use it. Endto-end<br />

email encryption is great in theory,<br />

but in practice it only works if both sender<br />

and recipient are using the same secure<br />

application. That’s where it’s always been<br />

a busted flush for becoming anything<br />

other than a nerdy nicety.<br />

If Bob wants to send Alice an<br />

encrypted message, he first has to<br />

send one saying: “I want to send you an<br />

encrypted message, to do so you need<br />

to download and use this app.” If Alice<br />

discovers that the app is too complicated<br />

or not to her liking, she won’t bother;<br />

ditto if that app costs a few quid a month<br />

to use or demands she opens up a new<br />

email account with some weird address.<br />

It has to be simple to set up, easy and<br />

functional enough to accompany, if not<br />

entirely replace, her email client of choice<br />

– and it needs to be free, or as good as.<br />

SecureMyEmail (SME) is the closest I’ve<br />

come across so far to meeting these<br />

requirements.<br />

SME comes in a number of OS flavours,<br />

including both Windows and Mac via a<br />

version of Mozilla Thunderbird with the<br />

SME plugin already installed. However,<br />

I’ve been testing the Android app, so for<br />

the purposes of this review that should<br />

be borne in mind. iOS users will have to<br />

wait, I’m afraid, although I’m assured<br />

that there is a version in the pipeline. The<br />

same goes for email clients other than<br />

Thunderbird, with Apple Mail already<br />

underway and Outlook in the planning<br />

stage.<br />

Back to Android, where the app is<br />

a doddle to install and configure. And<br />

if you’re an old hand at this PGP thing<br />

then you can use it with your existing<br />

keys easily enough. Again, I’m writing<br />

this overview from the perspective of a<br />

user that’s new to the encryption world,<br />

and for them there really is nothing to<br />

be afraid of. I’d happily invite my mum<br />

or eldest grandchild to use SME, safe in<br />

the knowledge that they could follow the<br />

instructions without fear of failure.<br />

I like the fact that it doesn’t require<br />

you to register a new email address at<br />

securemyemail.com; you simply use your<br />

existing email address, be that with a<br />

mail provider or your own mail server. I<br />

also like the fact that, while not free, it’s<br />

close at 99 cents per email address per<br />

year. There are lifetime subscription plans<br />

for the more adventurous, but for most<br />

why worry when you’re “risking” only 7p<br />

per month?<br />

I also like the fact that it allows the<br />

more advanced user to exploit the full<br />

functionality of PGP crypto. So, the<br />

SME client app is fully PGP compatible<br />

in that it creates real PGP keys that you<br />

can use wherever other software or<br />

services require them. Hit the Advanced<br />

Settings option and you’ll find all the<br />

key management, on-demand key<br />

regeneration, importing and exporting<br />

tools that the crypto-savvy user could<br />

want.<br />

Those among you who are privacy<br />

savvy can also rest assured that the SME<br />

creators have given proper thought to<br />

data sovereignty issues. The company<br />

behind SME has a Swiss incorporated<br />

management company and data is<br />

housed in Swiss data centres. The<br />

encryption happens on your device,<br />

before any data – including attachments<br />

(which are also encrypted) – are sent.<br />

This means your data will remain<br />

encrypted in transit and at rest on your,<br />

or your email service provider’s, servers.<br />

By using native software – rather than<br />

a webmail client, for example – your<br />

private key isn’t only generated on your<br />

device, but it remains there. Decryption,<br />

likewise, is done on the recipient’s device.<br />

SECURITY CONCERNS<br />

Without getting too deep into the math,<br />

during the initial setup of SecureMyEmail,<br />

a unique 4,096-bit key pair and<br />

passphrase will be generated. How<br />

secure is all that? Good question, and the<br />

answer – if we accept that there are no<br />

known backdoors, side-channel attacks<br />

or quantum computers to take into<br />

consideration – is long enough to futureproof<br />

it for the foreseeable future.<br />

The connections between my Android<br />

device and the SME servers in Geneva<br />

haven’t been forgotten either, which<br />

comes as no great surprise to me, since<br />

the people behind SME also run a VPN<br />

business. This translates into multiple<br />

layers of this particular security onion:<br />

the APIs are set to opt for Transport Layer<br />

Security 1.2 in preference; ephemeral key<br />

support is deployed to enable perfect<br />

forward secrecy (compromise of longterm<br />

keys doesn’t compromise past<br />

session keys in effect); and HTTP Strict<br />

Transport Security (HSTS) protects<br />

against protocol downgrade attacks,<br />

among other things.<br />

What else do I like about SME? Well,<br />

there’s the easy method of using your<br />

private key to sign and verify your email,<br />

so the recipient can be sure it has come<br />

from you and not a man-in-the-middle<br />

attacker pretending to be you.<br />

Talking of identity verification, I like<br />

the novel approach SME has taken<br />

with the use of a more modern version<br />

of the PGP web of trust by employing<br />

your social media networks. Using the<br />

OAuth authentication functionality of the<br />

social network itself, the user can opt to<br />

“SME is easy to use, but<br />

also allows the more<br />

advanced user to exploit<br />

the full functionality of<br />

PGP crypto”<br />

allow authentication against your social<br />

network account. Again, it’s another neat<br />

way of allowing your contacts to ensure<br />

you are who you say you are; they click on<br />

the Facebook, LinkedIn or Twitter button,<br />

and can immediately see if the account<br />

matches up with you.<br />

I’m not a huge fan of the Thunderbird<br />

mail client, for reasons going back<br />

many years, so I probably should give<br />

it a try. For now, though, I’m just using<br />

SME on Android – and the client isn’t<br />

bad, although it could still do with<br />

some polishing. It does the basics, plus<br />

incorporates encryption almost invisibly.<br />

It won’t replace my Android mail app<br />

of choice, but it doesn’t have to – and<br />

that’s the beauty of SME. Since the<br />

service doesn’t require you to register<br />

a new email address, or otherwise<br />

interfere with your existing email, you<br />

can continue using your mail client or<br />

app of choice. Nothing changes, apart<br />

from when you want to send or read a<br />

received encrypted email and you fire up<br />

the client. If you do fancy giving SME a<br />

try – and there’s a 30-day free trial before<br />

you’re asked for your 99 cents – feel free<br />

to start a secure conversation with me<br />

using my happygeek@gmail.com address<br />

to see how it all works.<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 109


STEVE CASSIDY<br />

“WHEN THINGS GET EXTRA<br />

TURBULENT, THE SILLY<br />

QUESTION MOVES THE<br />

CONVERSATION FORWARD”<br />

Robot cheerleaders fail to excite Steve on a visit to trade show CeBIT,<br />

but a plea for more open standards in IoT does set his pulse racing<br />

I<br />

f there’s a single measure to apply<br />

to modern businesses then this year<br />

is all about agility. Despite the fact<br />

that nobody has standardised the unit<br />

of agility, everybody thinks they can<br />

measure it and demonstrate what it<br />

means. When trying to make sense of this<br />

type of problem, I fall back on a simple<br />

technique known as derailing someone’s<br />

smooth sales presentation with a silly<br />

question.<br />

You see, silly questions are much more<br />

powerful than sensible ones. Especially<br />

when someone agile has been through<br />

and whipped up a show, a market, an<br />

economy, or the whole world into a<br />

turbulent mess in their passing wake.<br />

When things get extra turbulent, the<br />

silly question moves the conversation<br />

forward, by reminding us that there really<br />

are no sensible anchors in R&D, other<br />

than the ones we make for ourselves.<br />

The same goes for silly topics. One of<br />

my invitations for this year’s CeBIT show<br />

in Hannover made mention of “robot<br />

cheerleaders”. As neither robots, nor<br />

cheerleaders, form part of my natural<br />

bailiwick, I was more than happy to have<br />

a look – which is the reason for the hastily<br />

snatched screenie of my heartbeat ECG<br />

(below).<br />

Even without cheerleaders, I was mildly<br />

excited – mostly because the last time I<br />

saw this data it involved some translucent<br />

gel and a young chap nervously shaving<br />

my chest.<br />

It’s difficult to get clear electrical data<br />

such as this without those precursors,<br />

so the device I was holding that looked<br />

like a gamer’s steering wheel controller<br />

was quite the breakthrough in wearable,<br />

touchable contact sensors. The<br />

cheerleaders I mention were part of a<br />

video showing two exceedingly deadpan<br />

gentlemen, both wearing fleshy-looking<br />

flexible biosensors; as they stood up,<br />

little robots in front of them stood up too.<br />

There was a lot of late 20th-century pop<br />

video surrealness about it all – and for<br />

me, the killer problem was the overreach.<br />

Nothing in the video proved that the<br />

movements of the little plastic homunculi<br />

were triggered by the fleshy plastic things<br />

stuck on the humans’ heads. There<br />

wasn’t a choreographic link. The humans<br />

got up and sat down in a very Daft Punk<br />

way, careful and rigid – they behave more<br />

like toddlers, clambering on and off their<br />

feet.<br />

Nobody – robot or human – ever<br />

made any moves I’d associate with a<br />

cheerleader. I’ve included a picture of<br />

the video screen, but I wouldn’t blame<br />

the editor if he threw it out: it was a bad<br />

picture in a bad situation. [Fear not, it’s on<br />

the opposite page – Ed.]<br />

Which brings me on to the more<br />

obvious robots, and indeed those that<br />

we’re being told to expect great things<br />

from in the near future. Cast your gaze<br />

to SoftBank’s Pepper, opposite, which<br />

was originally developed by Aldebaran<br />

(softbank.jp/en/robot). It’s looking at<br />

machines such as this that devalues<br />

the achievement of the guys producing<br />

the ECG electrodes, because Pepper<br />

is meant to be programmed cute.<br />

Cuteness isn’t on my radar. When<br />

I want to think about how a system<br />

works overall, I don’t add “cute” to my<br />

list of tests – but Pepper is all about the<br />

cutes. I found the various Peppers on<br />

the SoftBank stand in a series of strange<br />

postures, something that also seemed<br />

to rather badly affect the attending<br />

technical team. Pepper, you see, is a<br />

curious combination of attributes, with<br />

a surface a bit like a washing machine,<br />

big doe-like eyes, a wasp waist and<br />

hourglass figure, a huge touchscreen on<br />

its upper chest, and very human-looking<br />

ribbed plastic hands. Oh, and it’s short.<br />

To my mind, Pepper is about the size of a<br />

seven-year-old girl.<br />

I think I could have found this<br />

disturbing, had the Peppers been<br />

There’s clearly something about CeBIT that sets my pulse racing<br />

STEVE CASSIDY<br />

Steve is a consultant who<br />

specialises in networks, cloud, HR<br />

and upsetting the corporate apple<br />

cart @stardotpro<br />

110 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


STEVE CASSIDY REAL WORLD COMPUTING<br />

The robots were out at this year’s CeBIT...<br />

operational. There was much work-inprogress,<br />

with actual engineers doing<br />

stuff. I was naughty and sneaked a<br />

snap of the laptop that appeared to be<br />

responsible for Pepper programming.<br />

It was a very strange display, especially<br />

sat alongside the dancing assembly-line<br />

arms of Epson’s stand, where cuteness<br />

and the accompanying exploitation of<br />

humanity’s Skinnerian response takes<br />

a total backseat against the speed-ofmovement,<br />

force-applied, jobs-done<br />

world of industrial robotics. Not that<br />

Epson’s team was therefore brutalist<br />

or uncaring: I asked about the power<br />

consumption of its huge paper recycling<br />

device (the PaperLab), and they were<br />

happy to inform me this was a staggering<br />

6.5kW. Not great news for PaperLab<br />

fans, but the news was a lot better on the<br />

current-generation office-sized inkjets,<br />

which squirt on the ink that PaperLab<br />

removes at a much more liveable 140W<br />

power draw.<br />

The absolute top mark for me on the<br />

“intrusive, transformative, personal”<br />

front in technology came during a short<br />

appointment pause, waiting to see<br />

Fujitsu’s Dr Joseph Reger. He and I are<br />

somewhat like the good and bad Jedi<br />

knights of the press Q&A session; there’s<br />

no question I can think up that he can’t<br />

answer. He got an easy ride from me that<br />

day, because while waiting for him I was<br />

suckered into trying out the 3D glasses<br />

... including<br />

Pepper, a robot<br />

with added<br />

cuteness<br />

developed by a spinoff/joint venture<br />

of Fujitsu, with a name so thoroughly<br />

Japanese that I now can’t read back the<br />

business card I was given.<br />

And I really wanted to follow up,<br />

because these glasses use a full-colour<br />

laser to paint the virtual screen you see,<br />

directly on the back of your eyeball. As a<br />

result, the dangling lens in front of your<br />

eye is super-tiny, only really needing<br />

to bend the laser’s beam as it scans<br />

across the presented image. And since<br />

it’s a laser, and at any one moment a<br />

single point of light, it doesn’t need to be<br />

corrected for any faults in your eyeball. I<br />

find most VR headsets a pain, because I<br />

first wore glasses at the age of six; these<br />

are revelatory. Take my glasses off and<br />

I can’t see ten inches – but I can see the<br />

virtual display of the Fujitsu glasses, in<br />

gloriously clear and focused HD.<br />

The barriers between me and a<br />

perfectly tailored VR display are still<br />

difficult to overcome, however, because<br />

this system requires that you keep your<br />

eyes fairly still, and I already know from<br />

my frazzled optician and a professor that<br />

I’m an “eye mover”, not a “head mover”.<br />

When this technology catches up with<br />

people like me, though, there’s a distinct<br />

chance I’ll be a near-instant convert. All it<br />

would take would be a high-performance<br />

camera, some additional processing of<br />

the visual field for reality augmentation,<br />

and I’d be completely sold on doing<br />

without cumbersome lenses, awkward<br />

contacts and the like.<br />

Which isn’t where I expected to<br />

be taken with an investigation that<br />

began with the teasing proposition<br />

of robot cheerleaders. However, it’s<br />

a measure of how far the entire IT<br />

business has come in just the past<br />

few years. I can remember walking<br />

around earlier CeBITs and losing count<br />

of all the laptops and servers, even the<br />

server racks. This year has seen a change<br />

to a selection of machinery that uses<br />

computers to get stuff done, rather than<br />

being computers that can run anything<br />

you care to put on them. All that said, I<br />

think the claims being made for robotics<br />

are at least five years too soon, before<br />

we even starting to look at the social<br />

implications.<br />

AGILITY VS OPENNESS<br />

I was sitting in the press pack seats on<br />

the Software AG stand when the bigwigs<br />

swung past. It’s normal to have at least<br />

Angela Merkel come by and say a few<br />

things. This time we had one of her<br />

ministers, who had a lot to say about<br />

the wonders of the software integration<br />

and services sector. I wasn’t there for the<br />

politicians – the media circus surrounding<br />

Ms Merkel this year was boosted by the<br />

www.pcandtechauthority.com.au <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> 111


REAL WORLD COMPUTING STEVE CASSIDY<br />

presence of the Japanese prime minister,<br />

which made it even more difficult to stick<br />

to any appointment on the sprawling<br />

fairgrounds of Hannover Messe.<br />

I was there for the speeches of the<br />

people doing the work: there’s something<br />

about the presence of a few world<br />

leaders that makes these chaps raise<br />

their game. Perhaps because that huge<br />

rugby scrum of mainstream media<br />

reporters and camera crews might sit<br />

down for a rest now and again, and the<br />

right soundbite is gold for those guys.<br />

This year’s surprise for me, apart from<br />

the abrupt shift from <strong>PC</strong> makers and<br />

devices, over to device makers who might<br />

occasionally use a <strong>PC</strong>, was a closing<br />

comment from Karl-Heinz Streibich,<br />

Software AG’s CEO.<br />

Looking out across the hall of stands,<br />

he’d had time to understand something<br />

that I’ve been struggling with for some<br />

time when looking at the world of<br />

small, simple computers now intended<br />

to control or report on just one or two<br />

physical sensors: the vast array of the<br />

Internet of Things. My problem has long<br />

been that being able to miniaturise a<br />

complete <strong>PC</strong> leaves far too many holes<br />

open in the whole system– holes that<br />

we’re really only learning to plug now,<br />

as the risk level of unintended breaches<br />

or uses for all those tiny little generalpurpose<br />

computing devices rises.<br />

I thought I’d understood what the<br />

industry would do about this during<br />

a visit to the IoT World Congress last<br />

year in Barcelona. There, the exhibits<br />

were all about diverse sets of sensors<br />

and components, jointed together in<br />

a noticeably proprietary and often noteven-Ethernet<br />

network, then brought<br />

together and made IoT-friendly by a<br />

gateway device, sitting between their<br />

proprietary world and a general-purpose<br />

WAN or LAN.<br />

Herr Streibich doesn’t like this<br />

approach. He made an impassioned plea<br />

that IoT implementers should always go<br />

for the most open hardware they can<br />

find to populate their estate of sensors,<br />

cameras, connections and actuators.<br />

Open wins over proprietary, he said – a<br />

strange viewpoint from a business whose<br />

lifeblood is the proprietary nature of its<br />

software product portfolio.<br />

So I waited until the Q&A and gave<br />

him a second go at this topic. As I<br />

understand the current state of play in<br />

IoT, the biggest successes are found in<br />

the one-trick ponies: businesses that can<br />

take advantage quickly, because their<br />

grasp of their own equipment and what<br />

that means for their IT is pretty much<br />

underwritten by proprietary control of<br />

the entire hardware and software stack.<br />

Lexmark is a good example of this.<br />

German chancellor Angela Merkel and Japanese<br />

prime minister Shinz Abe walk the floor<br />

By owning all the printer firmware, it can<br />

control exactly how it works as a plain<br />

IoT equal-status internet member device,<br />

even though all it does with that lofty<br />

status is to ask for new toner cartridges.<br />

Surely, I asked, there has to be some<br />

proprietary-ness in the mix, to make such<br />

deployments really work?<br />

His response confirmed something<br />

that I’ve been quietly thinking for some<br />

time. All the problems with IoT – even the<br />

“Being able to miniaturise<br />

a complete <strong>PC</strong> leaves far<br />

too many holes open in<br />

the whole system”<br />

daft ones that come up around gussiedup<br />

consumer devices – are failures in<br />

transparency. You can’t interrogate your<br />

poorly coded, insecure IoT fridge over<br />

your own network because it isn’t an<br />

open standard with a neat walkthrough<br />

somewhere on the web.<br />

It’s pretty simple to be transparent in<br />

software, with debuggers and compilers<br />

and the like, but the R&D houses have<br />

been concentrating so hard on getting<br />

anything with an “IoT” badge on it out<br />

of the door, they’ve barely thought<br />

Open hardware is the key to IoT success, according<br />

to Software AG’s CEO<br />

about how to allow the purchasers and<br />

operators of their kit to snoop around on<br />

the inside of the tiny computer they’ve<br />

co-opted to some incredibly boring job.<br />

Take a look at the NAS box market. I<br />

think of NASes as the precursors of the<br />

IoT: they’re computers and they started<br />

out doing just one job – handing out<br />

files. It didn’t take long for that list of<br />

jobs to expand, and the software writers<br />

wasted no time in making it easy for the<br />

enthusiast or home user to get inside the<br />

box and take a look around.<br />

It needn’t be all that easy – SSH shells<br />

and telnet access require jumping through<br />

a small number of hoops before access<br />

is allowed – but that’s okay too, as a way<br />

of keeping out the idle and destructive<br />

fiddler. Once inside and working with a<br />

command line, even a humble NAS can<br />

be made to do all sorts of useful things,<br />

such as adding on background file sync<br />

services, or getting the machine to work<br />

as a media file server as well as just a<br />

plain old file server. (Okay, so maybe I was<br />

being harsh, criticising IoT for only giving<br />

decent CPUs boring jobs to do; described<br />

this way, the life of a NAS box sounds<br />

pretty boring too.)<br />

The point here is the open-ness. As<br />

Herr Streibich was insisting, you can<br />

see the advantage to being able to<br />

completely describe what that little lump<br />

of chips and LEDs in the corner of the<br />

room is up to, and the more proprietary it<br />

gets, the less likely it is to be successful.<br />

The next time you’re considering an<br />

apparently IoT CCTV system, or a flashily<br />

not-quite-IoT home heating controller,<br />

see what happens when you ask the<br />

vendor if the system is based on any<br />

recognised, open standards, and how<br />

open it is to you taking a good look around<br />

inside the tiny little OS and filesystem it<br />

comes with. If you’re told this isn’t needed<br />

or not normal, maybe make a different<br />

purchase. Openness and transparency<br />

are the only good defences we have.<br />

112 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au


EPILOG<br />

IF YOU’RE SURPRISED THE NSA CAN HACK<br />

YOUR COMPUTER, SAYS JON HONEYBALL,<br />

YOU NEED A REALITY CHECK<br />

Colour me shocked. It appears<br />

the NSA has been collecting a<br />

treasure trove of hacks for Windows,<br />

both desktop and servers, covering all<br />

versions of the OS bar Windows 10. And<br />

this toolbox of capabilities, which also<br />

included ways to get into banking and<br />

other related systems, has leaked to the<br />

public.I suspect your jaw isn’t gaping in<br />

surprise. What’s followed has been just<br />

as predictable.<br />

First, there’s shock that the NSA<br />

might have built such a collection of<br />

exploits. Sorry, what do you expect<br />

the NSA to be doing? Creating toolkits<br />

that can be used against undesirables<br />

is what it exists for. Injecting custom<br />

spyware onto the laptop of a terrorist<br />

could bring up incredibly useful<br />

intelligence information, after all.<br />

Then there’s the public horror that<br />

the NSA didn’t tell Microsoft about<br />

the exploits. Why is anyone surprised?<br />

Sure, it’s good practice for security<br />

researchers to tell Microsoft (or Apple,<br />

Facebook, Google, whoever) that<br />

they’ve uncovered a security hole.<br />

There are processes in place by which<br />

such reports are made, the vendor is<br />

given time to patch things and issue an<br />

update, and then the exploit is made<br />

public once the patch has been issued.<br />

It’s all very gentlemanly, and some<br />

companies even offer financial rewards.<br />

Would I expect the NSA to tell<br />

Microsoft about the exploits? Of course<br />

not. Keeping such flaws hidden from<br />

Microsoft meant they were exploitable<br />

for as long as possible.<br />

No-one is suggesting the NSA, or<br />

any other equivalent organisation,<br />

is using these tools against the<br />

wider population. I don’t think there<br />

have been mass deployments of<br />

EmeraldThread or EternalRomance or<br />

EclipsedWing or any of the other rather<br />

charming codenames. (Nasty1 and<br />

Nasty2 and ReallyNasty3 just don’t have<br />

the same ring to them.)<br />

But then we come onto the real<br />

problems. The tools have now been<br />

released into the wild, and it doesn’t<br />

take much effort to download them.<br />

This means there will be a flood of script<br />

kiddies trying them out and targeting<br />

everyone from NASA to the takeaway<br />

down the street. That’s a whole pile of<br />

grief no-one needed.<br />

“There will be a flood<br />

of script kiddies trying<br />

them out and targeting<br />

everyone from NASA<br />

to the takeaway down<br />

the street”<br />

It would be interesting to analyse<br />

which antivirus packages would protect<br />

you against these exploits. My hunch,<br />

backed by discussions with friends in the<br />

industry, is almost none.<br />

Even so, now the toolkit has leaked,<br />

it’s of much less use to the NSA, and any<br />

other organisations that might have had<br />

access to it. That can’t be a good thing.<br />

Don’t confuse that statement with any<br />

desire on my part to see governmentmandated<br />

encryption backdoors being<br />

forced into end user applications. I see a<br />

difference between what an organisation<br />

such as the NSA or ASIO does and the<br />

far more widespread misuse of datasnooping<br />

that we have seen.<br />

Then we come to Microsoft’s<br />

interesting claim that these exploits<br />

have been patched already, but only<br />

very recently. One wonders whether the<br />

NSA told Microsoft about the leak once<br />

it knew its toolkit was compromised and<br />

Microsoft went into top gear to get fixes<br />

out as soon as possible.<br />

It does mean, of course, that the old<br />

mantra about running only the most<br />

current and fully patched versions of<br />

applications and operating systems is as<br />

true today as it has ever been. Microsoft<br />

rather coyly states that “Of the three<br />

remaining exploits, ‘EnglishmanDentist’,<br />

‘EsteemAudit’, and ‘ExplodingCan’, none<br />

reproduces on supported platforms,<br />

which means that customers running<br />

Windows 7 and recent versions of<br />

Windows or Exchange 2010 and newer<br />

versions of Exchange are not at risk.” So if<br />

you’re on XP, you’re on your own.<br />

It’s also true that we’ve managed to<br />

get ourselves into a situation where OSes<br />

are so complex that it is now effectively<br />

impossible to ensure they are secure.<br />

The approach taken by Apple’s iOS,<br />

forcing a walled garden approach on the<br />

developers and the execution of code,<br />

is arguably the most secure widespread<br />

end user platform available. But that<br />

still doesn’t mean that the core OS itself<br />

is secure. Is open source the answer?<br />

Maybe, but exploits are found there too.<br />

You may be thinking I’ll use this final<br />

paragraph to deliver the answer. Sadly,<br />

there isn’t one. If ASIO or the NSA want<br />

to access my computers, they will either<br />

hack their way in, use a backdoor that we<br />

don’t know about, or just turn up with a<br />

warrant and remove every device fitted<br />

with a mains plug. And there is nothing I,<br />

or you, can do.<br />

Level 6, Building A, 207 Pacific Highway,<br />

St Leonards NSW 2065<br />

Locked Bag 5555 St Leonards NSW 1590<br />

Chief Executive Officer David Gardiner<br />

Commercial Director Bruce Duncan<br />

This magazine is published by nextmedia Pty Ltd ACN: 128 805 970,<br />

Level 6, Building A, 207 Pacific Highway, St Leonards NSW 2065 © 2014.<br />

All rights reserved. No part of this magazine may be reproduced, in<br />

whole or in part, without the prior permission of the publisher. Printed<br />

by Bluestar WEB Sydney, distributed in Australia and NZ by Gordon and<br />

Gotch. The publisher will not accept responsibility or any liability for the<br />

correctness of information or opinions expressed in the publication. All<br />

material submitted is at the owner’s risk and, while every care will be<br />

taken nextmedia does not accept liability for loss or damage.<br />

Privacy Policy<br />

We value the integrity of your personal information. If you provide<br />

personal information through your participation in any competitions,<br />

surveys or offers featured in this issue of Inside Sport, this will be used<br />

to provide the products or services that you have requested and<br />

to improve the content of our magazines. Your details may be<br />

provided to third parties who assist us in this purpose. In the event<br />

of organisations providing prizes or offers to our readers, we may<br />

pass your details on to them. From time to time, we may use<br />

the information you provide us to inform you of other products,<br />

services and events our company has to offer. We may also give<br />

your information to other organisations which may use it to inform<br />

you about their products, services and events, unless you tell us not<br />

to do so. You are welcome to access the information that we hold<br />

about you by getting in touch with our privacy officer, who can be<br />

contacted at nextmedia, Locked Bag 5555, St Leonards, NSW 1590<br />

PERMISSIONS & REPRINTS: Material in <strong>PC</strong> & <strong>Tech</strong> <strong>Authority</strong><br />

may not be reproduced in any form without the written consent of<br />

the Commercial Director of nextmedia. Quotations for reprints are<br />

available from the Production Manager. <strong>PC</strong> & <strong>Tech</strong> <strong>Authority</strong> logos<br />

are trademarks of nextmedia Pty Ltd. This magazine contains content<br />

that is published under license from and with the permission of<br />

Dennis Publishing Limited. All rights in this material belong to Dennis<br />

Publishing Limited absolutely and may not be reproduced, whether in<br />

whole or in part, without its prior written consent.<br />

EDITORIAL<br />

Editor, <strong>Tech</strong> and Gaming Group Editor:<br />

Ben Mansill: bmansill@nextmedia.com.au<br />

Art Director: Tim Frawley<br />

Digital Editor, <strong>Tech</strong> and Gaming:<br />

David Hollingworth:<br />

dhollingworth@nextmedia.com.au<br />

REGULAR CONTRIBUTORS<br />

Jon Honeyball, Paul Ockenden, Davey Winder,<br />

Steve Cassidy, Sasha Muller, Darien Graham-Smith,<br />

Nicole Kobie, Tim Danton, Jonathan Bray, Anthony<br />

Caruana, Daniel Wilks, Mark Williams. Anthony<br />

Fordham<br />

PUBLISHING<br />

Advertising Director B2B & B2C <strong>Tech</strong>nology<br />

Group: Lee De La Rue Browne<br />

ldelaruebrowne@nextmedia.com.au<br />

Printed on paper sustainably sourced<br />

from PEFC certified forests<br />

PRODUCTION<br />

Advertising Coordinator: Charles Balyck<br />

Circulation Director Carole Jones<br />

Printed by: Bluestar WEB Sydney<br />

Distributed by: Distributed in Australia and NZ<br />

by Gordon & Gotch.<br />

ADVERTISING<br />

Phone: (+61 2) 9901 6348<br />

Group Advertising Manager <strong>Tech</strong> & Gaming:<br />

Cameron Ferris: cferris@nextmedia.com.au<br />

Account Manager <strong>Tech</strong> & Gaming:<br />

Sean Fletcher: sfletcher@nextmedia.com.au<br />

SUBSCRIPTIONS<br />

1300 361146<br />

or subscribe@mymagazines.com.au<br />

Please recycle<br />

this magazine<br />

114 <strong>July</strong> <strong>2017</strong> www.pcandtechauthority.com.au

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!