Calgary Winter 2024

The Perils of Over-Insulating
Attics: Striking the Right Balance
for a Healthy Home
In the pursuit of energy efficiency and
reduced utility bills, many homeowners
are turning to the benefits of insulation,
especially in their attic spaces. While a wellinsulated
attic can contribute significantly
to a comfortable and energy-efficient
home, the concept of “more is better” does
not always hold true. Over-insulating an
attic without proper consideration for air
flow can lead to a myriad of problems,
jeopardizing both the structural integrity of
the home and the health of its occupants.
One of the primary issues associated with
over-insulation is the compromise of
proper ventilation. Attics require a delicate
balance between insulation and ventilation
to ensure a healthy and functional living
space. Insulating to the extreme can impede
the natural flow of air, leading to a host of
problems that can affect both the attic and
the entire home.
One critical aspect of attic ventilation is
moisture control. Over-insulating without
proper ventilation can trap moisture
inside the attic, creating an environment
conducive to mold and mildew growth.
Mold not only poses a threat to the
structural integrity of the home but
also presents serious health risks to its
occupants. Respiratory issues, allergies, and
other health problems can arise when mold
spores are released into the indoor air.
Moreover, excessive insulation can cause
the attic temperature to rise significantly
during warmer months. Without adequate
ventilation to expel this heat, the attic can
become a breeding ground for another
common problem – ice dams. These ice
dams form when warm air from the living
spaces below rises into the attic, causing
snow on the roof to melt and then refreeze
at the eaves. The resulting ice buildup can
lead to water damage, compromising the
roof ’s integrity and potentially causing
leaks.
Proper air flow is also crucial for regulating
temperature extremes in the attic space.
Over-insulation can create a superinsulated,
sealed environment, causing
the attic to become excessively hot in the
summer and extremely cold in the winter.
This temperature fluctuation not only
affects the overall comfort of the home
but can also lead to increased energy
consumption as homeowners struggle to
maintain a consistent indoor temperature.
To strike the right balance between
insulation and ventilation, homeowners
should consider consulting with insulation
professionals who can assess their specific
needs and recommend appropriate
solutions. One effective strategy is to use
a combination of insulation materials that
provide both thermal resistance and allow
for proper air circulation. Additionally,
installing vents, soffit vents, and roof
vents can facilitate the movement of air,
preventing the buildup of moisture and
regulating temperature.
In conclusion, while the benefits of attic
insulation are undeniable, the key lies
in finding the optimal balance between
insulation and ventilation. Over-insulating
without considering air flow can lead to
a host of problems, ranging from mold
and ice dams to compromised structural
integrity and health risks for occupants.
Homeowners must prioritize a holistic
approach to attic insulation, consulting with
professionals to ensure that their homes
remain energy-efficient, comfortable, and
safe for years to come. In the quest for an
energy-efficient home, striking the right
balance is paramount – more insulation is
not always better if it comes at the expense
of proper air flow.
- Dennis Begin
HOMEADVICE
29