Hansard - United Kingdom Parliament
Hansard - United Kingdom Parliament
Hansard - United Kingdom Parliament
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
5 Oral Answers<br />
20 JUNE 2011<br />
Oral Answers<br />
6<br />
Will the Minister at least go as far as advising that rogue<br />
council not to proceed with those closures until the<br />
courts and the parents have had their fair say?<br />
Greg Clark: That is a superb council, and it certainly<br />
does not need any advice from me. In fact, I am astonished<br />
that the hon. Gentleman has not taken the opportunity<br />
to congratulate his council on saving every library in the<br />
borough, by merging the service with neighbouring<br />
boroughs, and on saving £1 million. When he was<br />
leader of the council, he doubled the council tax and his<br />
Labour administration was booted out at the election.<br />
The current, Conservative administration was returned<br />
with a healthy majority at the last council election.<br />
Mrs Glindon: As a result of the Government’s decision<br />
to impose huge, front-loaded cuts on local authorities,<br />
many councils are increasing charges for social care,<br />
hitting the elderly and the vulnerable. Will the Minister<br />
join me in condemning Tory councils such as North<br />
Tyneside council, which has increased its home care<br />
charges by more than 50%, from £99 to a maximum of<br />
£150 a week?<br />
Greg Clark: We still have not had an answer—perhaps<br />
we will shortly—to the question of how the extra black<br />
hole that has opened up will be funded, and whether<br />
that will come from local government, but I will answer<br />
the hon. Lady’s question. Three years ago, one of the<br />
predecessors of the right hon. Member for Don Valley<br />
(Caroline Flint) as Minister for local government, the<br />
right hon. Member for Wentworth and Dearne (John<br />
Healey), complained that only one in five councils was<br />
using charging to its full potential. Indeed, the last<br />
Government issued statutory guidance to force councils<br />
to charge more for parking, for example. Council charging<br />
doubled under Labour. Unlike the last Government, we<br />
will not force councils to increase their charging.<br />
Sir Paul Beresford (Mole Valley) (Con): Does my<br />
right hon. Friend agree that there is great cost variation<br />
in like-for-like authority provision? Therefore, it is<br />
inappropriate to judge the quality of services by the<br />
amount of other people’s money—that is, taxpayers’<br />
money—spent on them.<br />
Greg Clark: My hon. Friend is absolutely right. His<br />
record in leading Wandsworth, which was transformed<br />
under his leadership—I am pleased to say that that<br />
transformation has continued under the leadership of<br />
Sir Edward Lister, whom I am sure the House will<br />
congratulate on his knighthood—shows what can be<br />
done when there is a Conservative council that takes the<br />
economies seriously.<br />
Henry Smith (Crawley) (Con): Does my right hon.<br />
Friend agree that, now that the Government have introduced<br />
greater transparency in relation to any amounts over<br />
£500 that local authorities spend, our constituents will<br />
be far better informed about the politics involved in the<br />
reduced budgets for local authorities?<br />
Greg Clark: My hon. Friend is another distinguished<br />
former leader of a local authority, and he is absolutely<br />
right. We still have not heard whether those on the<br />
Opposition Front Bench think that it is a good idea for<br />
councils to have full transparency. I think that Nottingham<br />
city council is still holding out, but perhaps we shall be<br />
enlightened on that matter soon.<br />
Jack Dromey (Birmingham, Erdington) (Lab): Today’s<br />
report from the Equality and Human Rights Commission<br />
demonstrates that Britain’s pensioners are not receiving<br />
the care that they deserve. In Birmingham, the coalition<br />
council’s cutting of care to 4,100 of the most vulnerable<br />
has been branded unlawful by the High Court. Having<br />
imposed the biggest cuts in local government history,<br />
does the Secretary of State take any responsibility? Will<br />
he intervene in this matter, or does he share the view of<br />
the Prime Minister that the actions of Birmingham city<br />
council were “excellent”?<br />
Greg Clark: The problem with Birmingham is that it<br />
has a legacy of mismanagement and waste from the<br />
days of Labour control, which lasted quite a long time.<br />
If the hon. Gentleman is interested in the economies, as<br />
I am, will he tell us his position and that of the right<br />
hon. Member for Don Valley (Caroline Flint)? He is the<br />
Rasputin of the Labour party, the power behind the<br />
throne of Edward Miliband. I have to warn the Leader<br />
of the Opposition, however, that the hon. Member for<br />
Derby North (Chris Williamson) is an acolyte of the<br />
shadow Chancellor. In Wimbledon fortnight, it would<br />
perhaps be appropriate to say that he is one of Balls’<br />
boys. Is it the shadow Secretary of State’s policy to add<br />
an extra £13 billion of cuts? Yes or no? And would that<br />
come from borrowing, or would it yet again come from<br />
local government? Will she tell us what her policy is? In<br />
the week that—<br />
Mr Speaker: Order. I am grateful to the Minister, but<br />
he must now resume his seat. In the name of utilising<br />
our time properly—I use the word “properly”advisedly—we<br />
must focus questions and answers on the policies of the<br />
Government.<br />
New Homes Bonus<br />
5. Eric Ollerenshaw (Lancaster and Fleetwood) (Con):<br />
How much funding his Department has allocated from<br />
the New Homes Bonus scheme (a) to Lancaster and<br />
Fleetwood constituency and (b) in total since the<br />
scheme’s inception. [60277]<br />
The Minister for Housing and Local Government (Grant<br />
Shapps): The first New Homes Bonus allocations were<br />
made in April. Over six years, Lancaster will receive<br />
some £1.4 million and Wyre some £1.6 million. Across<br />
England, the allocations will total almost £1 billion<br />
during the spending review period. The next allocations<br />
will take place next April.<br />
Eric Ollerenshaw: I thank my right hon. Friend for<br />
that reply on behalf of the two district councils. How<br />
long will it be before this policy and others of the new<br />
Government begin to address the failure over the past<br />
13 years to get the right number of new houses that we<br />
need?<br />
Grant Shapps: The policies are already having some<br />
impact. In the first year of this new Government, house<br />
building starts were up 22%. That compares rather<br />
favourably with the period during which the right hon.<br />
Member for Don Valley (Caroline Flint), who is now<br />
the shadow Secretary of State, was housing Minister,<br />
when house building starts were a third lower than they<br />
are today.