Cable Fights and SwitchesCable providers have been publicly skeptical about FTTH, but they’rebeginning to admit it has a place in their universe.By Masha Zager ■ <strong>Broadband</strong> <strong>Properties</strong>“Us Tareyton smokers would rather fight than switch,” was the tagline of a cigarette ad remembered fondly bymany of us of a certain age. The photo in the ad showed a man proudly displaying a black eye. The cable industry’santi-fiber rhetoric, with its unswerving loyalty to coaxial cable and DOCSIS technology, at times evokesthe Tareyton man’s fighting spirit, if not his dubious grammar or unhealthy habits.But at a certain point reality sets in. The reason nearly all of the major FTTH electronics vendors are announcing cableorientedPON products (see “Cable Industry Signals Move to FTTH” in this issue) is that they know – and they know theMSOs know – FTTH is the endgame for cable. Not only is it the endgame, it’s a small but growing part of the midgame,too, with advantages in greenfield and commercial deployments.So while the rhetoric continues unabated, cable companies have been quietly experimenting with fiber, in trials or in smallpilot projects. We note three of them in this month’s roundup. Some are deploying fiber only when a developer insists on it;others are using fiber proactively to pursue new markets. But reluctant or not, the cable companies appear to have arrived atthe point where the question about fiber is no longer “Yes or no?” but rather “How and when?”– MZINDEPENDENTTELCOSSureWest Brings FTTH to KansasCalifornia competitive providerSureWest Communications,which pioneered FTTH andIPTV in the Sacramento area, acquiredKansas’ Everest <strong>Broadband</strong> in February.Recently SureWest announced thatEverest (which will now operate underthe SureWest name) will be adding10,000 new homes in the greater KansasCity area in 2008, including an expansioninto several Kansas communitiesthat have requested Everest services.As many as 8,000 of the new residentialadds will be served by fiber-to-thehome,with broadband speeds up to 50Mbps symmetrical.Oxford Networks, a CLEC inMaine, recently reported on its fiber-tothe-businessbuildout: In Bangor andBrewer, its first deployments, Oxford isnearing completion of a fiber network tothe business corridors that will pass 1,200potential business customers. By the endof the summer, builds passing 1,900 businessesthrough Topsham, Brunswick,Freeport, Yarmouth, Falmouth and Portlandare expected to be completed. Andby year’s end, Oxford will complete additionalfiber networks in South Portland,Scarborough and Waterville.Marquette-Adams Telephone Cooperative,based in Oxford, Wisconsin,currently provides triple play servicesover Occam Networks’ ADSL2Plusplatform, but the rising demand forbandwidth led the company to deployOccam’s GPON solution. Marquette-Adams, which operates 3,500 accesslines, plans to achieve its goal of 100percent deployment of FTTH in thenext three to four years.“As we developed plans to advanceour triple play service offerings to our subscribers,we determined that a GPON sol-ution made strategic and economic sensefor the future of our access network,” saysBryan Amundson, Marquette-AdamsCEO. “After a thorough review process,Occam Networks’ GPON products roseabove competing solutions based on itsease of deployment, rapid turn-up andinnovative suite of features.”D&P Communications, a Michigantelco that also delivers broadbandInternet access and video overcable, has selected Motorola’s GPONsolution to build out all-fiber networksfor delivery of triple play entertainmentand broadband services.D&P Communications will deploy theMotorola AXS2200 Optical Line Terminaland new ONT1400GT opticalnetwork terminal that are optimized forthe delivery of IP and RF video entertainmentand broadband services. BecauseGPON supports RF video, D&P18 | BROADBAND PROPERTIES | www.broadbandproperties.com | July 2008
will be able to reuse existing video networkingand RF set-top boxes.PBT Communications in SouthCarolina, which began installing MotorolaBPON networks in greenfieldbuilds in 2005, is now deploying Motorola’sGPON solution, using the sameequipment that D&P Communicationsis using.Lincoln County Telephone System(LCTS), an independent carrierin Pioche, Nevada, will deploy Alcatel-Lucent’s Triple Play Service Delivery Architecture,including GPON and servicerouting technologies. Lincoln Countyplans to offer high-speed data, voice,video and security services, to its customersin Lincoln County. In the newtown of Coyote Springs, Nevada, LCTSwill lease capacity to Coyote <strong>Broadband</strong>,which will provide Internet, video anddata services to all residential and commercialcustomers. Coyote Springs is anew community under development 50miles northeast of Las Vegas, spanningClark County and Lincoln County.The Coyote Springs Land DevelopmentCorporation is developing golf resortsand commercial properties there, whilePardee Homes is the master residentialdeveloper. Klif Andrews, presidentof Pardee’s Southern Nevada Division,describes Coyote Springs as a “technologicallyadvanced town that will offer amodern Western lifestyle.”LCTS’ broadband access solution isbased on the Alcatel-Lucent 7342 ISAMFTTU, and the 5526 Access ManagementSystem for element management.LCTS will also deploy Alcatel-Lucent’sIP/MPLS infrastructure including the7750 Service Router, 7450 Ethernet ServiceSwitch, 5620 Service Aware Manager,and 5750 Subscriber Service Controller.Alcatel-Lucent will also provideprofessional engineering services.Update on Broadweave, the CLECthat is purchasing the municipal networkin Provo, Utah: While the closing did nottake place on July 1 as scheduled, Broadweavesays it has taken over operation ofthe system and is making payments tocover the city’s bond obligations. Duediligence is still proceeding and finalclosing is expected to occur by September1. Broadweave also announced thatit would not purchase Veracity, the serviceprovider on iProvo that it had previouslyannounced it would acquire. Thetwo companies are “working together …on iProvo’s commercial customers,” butthe details of their arrangement have notbeen finalized.CABLECOMPANIESIs Fiber a Threat or an Opportunity?#3: Fiber is the latestand greatest technology“Mythfor accessing the Internet,”says the Web site of Cox Communications,which then proceeds to debunkthat “myth.” But last month, cable industrynews media reported that Cox, one ofthe largest North American MSOs, hasissued a Request for Information for fiber-to-the-premisestechnologies includingboth RFOG (radio frequency overglass) and standards-based PON. Coxis reportedly investigating its options forproviding services in new developments.While the company declined to commenton the RFI, it said it had alreadybuilt FTTP networks for some plannedcommunities, schools and business parksthat insisted on all-fiber solutions.Some cable companies are beginningto see fiber more as an opportunity thana threat. In a third win for Motorolathis month, Ontario-based ComptonCommunications selected Motorola’sfiber-to-the-home solution forthe launch of its all-fiber network andnew commercial service offerings. Thisis the first deployment of Motorola’sGPON technology in the cable industryand in the Canadian market. ComptonCommunications will use the MotorolaAXS1800 Optical Access Platform andONT1400GT Optical Network Terminalto expand its market opportunityand join the competitive arena of ultrabroadbandcommercial service delivery.GPON gives cable companies an opportunityto target commercial applications requiringhundreds of Mbps or even 1 Gbps throughput.“Cable operators have long beenassociated with the delivery of residentialservices,” says Brendan O’Hara ofCompton Communications. “However,with the services capabilities providedby GPON, and specifically Motorola’sproven Cable PON portfolio, we havean opportunity to target commercialservice applications where hundreds ofmegabits or even gigabit throughput isrequired. It’s a new and important marketfor us with promising revenue potential.”Dr. George Simmons, Motorola’scorporate vice president and generalmanager for access network solutions,says the company has seen interest fromseveral cable companies in using GPONfor business services.Calix, another GPON leader, reportsthe same trend. Its most recentlyannounced GPON sale was to WOWInternet, Cable and Phone, the 11thlargest cable MSO in the United States,which intends to use GPON for commercialservice. Ron Mattingly, WOW’sengineering manager, says the companyhas already been providing businessservices via FTTP in several Midwesternmarkets, and that GPON offers anopportunity to improve on that servicewith more bandwidth, increased flexibilityand lower operational expenses.July 2008 | www.broadbandproperties.com | BROADBAND PROPERTIES | 19