10.01.2013 Views

UMA CHIDUN current - The Knowledge Base

UMA CHIDUN current - The Knowledge Base

UMA CHIDUN current - The Knowledge Base

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

DE LA DNGOS PO RANG BZHIN GYIS GRUB PA'I KHAS LEN DANG<br />

DAM BCA' YOD NA, DE LTA BU'I DGAG SGRUB KYI RNAM GZHAG MI<br />

'THAD KYANG DE 'DRA'I KHAS LEN DANG DAM BCA' MED PAS DGAG<br />

SGRUB KYI RNAM GZHAG MI 'THAD PA'I SKYON MED PA'I LAN<br />

MDZAD PA YIN TE,<br />

<strong>The</strong> reply given to this objection goes as follows. “If I had made any<br />

statement or assertion in favor of working things existing through some<br />

nature of their own, well then it’s true that the entire way in which I’ve<br />

disproved one thing and proven another here would be incorrect. But the<br />

fact is that I have never made any such statement or assertion. As such, I<br />

am free of this problem you’ve posed, that my disproving the one thing and<br />

proving the other cannot be correct.”<br />

RTZOD BZLOG LAS,<br />

,GAL TE NGAS DAM BCAS 'GA' YOD,<br />

,DES NA NGA LA SKYON DE YOD,<br />

,NGA LA DAM BCAS MED PAS NA,<br />

,NGA NI SKYON MED KHO NA YIN,<br />

,ZHES GSUNGS PA'I PHYIR,<br />

And this is true because <strong>The</strong> Refutation of Argument itself says,<br />

If I had made any such assertion,<br />

<strong>The</strong>n that problem would apply to me.<br />

But since I have made no such assertion,<br />

It doesn’t apply to me at all.<br />

LAN LHAG MA RNAMS RTZOD BZLOG GI GZHUNG LHAG MA<br />

RNAMS KYIS 'CHAD PAR BYED PA'I PHYIR,<br />

And it is further true because the remaining sections of <strong>The</strong> Refutation of<br />

Argument continue on to explain the remainder of the response here.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!