30.04.2013 Views

GMO Myths and Truths

GMO Myths and Truths

GMO Myths and Truths

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

at lower doses. Interestingly, these effects<br />

were discounted by regulators, who approved<br />

glyphosate for use in food production. 10<br />

● Roundup caused liver <strong>and</strong> kidney toxicity in fish<br />

at sublethal doses. Effects in the liver included<br />

haemorrhage <strong>and</strong> necrosis (death of cells <strong>and</strong><br />

living tissue). 21<br />

● Roundup caused total cell death in human cells<br />

within 24 hours at concentrations far below<br />

those used in agriculture <strong>and</strong> corresponding to<br />

levels of residues found in food <strong>and</strong> feed. 13<br />

● Roundup caused death of human cells <strong>and</strong><br />

programmed cell death at a concentration of<br />

50 parts per million, far below agricultural<br />

dilutions. 16<br />

● Roundup was a potent endocrine disruptor at<br />

levels up to 800 times lower than residue levels<br />

allowed in food <strong>and</strong> feed. It was toxic to human<br />

cells <strong>and</strong> caused DNA damage at doses far<br />

below those used in agriculture. 17<br />

● Glyphosate was toxic to human placental cells<br />

<strong>and</strong> is an endocrine disruptor in concentrations<br />

lower than those found with agricultural use.<br />

Roundup adjuvants amplified glyphosate’s<br />

toxicity by enabling it to penetrate cells more<br />

easily <strong>and</strong> to bioaccumulate in cells. 15<br />

● Glyphosate <strong>and</strong> Roundup damaged human<br />

embryonic <strong>and</strong> placental cells at concentrations<br />

below those used in agriculture, suggesting that<br />

they may interfere with human reproduction<br />

<strong>and</strong> embryonic development. 14<br />

● Glyphosate’s main metabolite (environmental<br />

breakdown product), AMPA, altered cell cycle<br />

checkpoints by interfering with the cells’ DNA<br />

repair machinery. 22,23,19,24 The failure of cell<br />

cycle checkpoints is known to lead to genomic<br />

instability <strong>and</strong> cancer in humans.<br />

● Glyphosate <strong>and</strong> AMPA irreversibly damaged<br />

DNA, suggesting that they may increase the<br />

risk of cancer. 25,26<br />

● Glyphosate promoted cancer in the skin of<br />

mice. 27<br />

● Roundup caused cell <strong>and</strong> DNA damage to<br />

epithelial cells derived from the inside of the<br />

mouth <strong>and</strong> throat, <strong>and</strong> glyphosate alone caused<br />

DNA damage, raising concerns over the safety<br />

of inhaling the herbicide, one of the most<br />

common ways in which people are exposed.<br />

Importantly, both glyphosate <strong>and</strong> Roundup<br />

caused DNA damage at concentrations<br />

below those required to induce cell damage,<br />

suggesting that the DNA damage was caused<br />

directly by glyphosate <strong>and</strong> Roundup instead of<br />

being an indirect result of cell toxicity. 28<br />

4.1.4. Epidemiological studies on<br />

Roundup show links with serious<br />

health problems<br />

Epidemiological studies show a link between<br />

Roundup/glyphosate exposure <strong>and</strong> serious health<br />

problems, including:<br />

● DNA damage 27<br />

● Premature births <strong>and</strong> miscarriages 28,29<br />

● Birth defects including neural tube defects <strong>and</strong><br />

anencephaly (absence of a large part of the<br />

brain <strong>and</strong> skull) 32,33<br />

● Multiple myeloma, a type of cancer 34<br />

● Non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, a type of<br />

cancer 35,36,37<br />

● Disruption of neurobehavioral development in<br />

children of pesticide applicators – in particular,<br />

attention-deficit disorder (ADD) <strong>and</strong> attentiondeficit<br />

hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). 38<br />

Epidemiological studies cannot prove a cause-<strong>and</strong>effect<br />

relationship between exposure to a suspect<br />

substance <strong>and</strong> a health effect. However, in the<br />

case of glyphosate/Roundup, toxicological studies<br />

carried out under controlled laboratory conditions<br />

confirm the causal relationship to health problems<br />

(see 4.1.3).<br />

4.1.5. People are widely exposed to<br />

glyphosate<br />

Glyphosate-based herbicides are widely used<br />

outside of the farm environment – for example,<br />

by municipal authorities to control weeds on<br />

roadsides <strong>and</strong> in parks <strong>and</strong> school grounds, as<br />

well as by home gardeners. So even when farm<br />

use is excluded, people’s exposure to glyphosate<br />

is significant. In agricultural areas where GM<br />

glyphosate-resistant crops are grown, exposure is<br />

likely to increase exponentially.<br />

Study findings on human exposures <strong>and</strong> body<br />

burdens include:<br />

● Glyphosate was detected in between 60 <strong>and</strong><br />

<strong>GMO</strong> <strong>Myths</strong> <strong>and</strong> <strong>Truths</strong> 66

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!