GMO Myths and Truths

5.2 Myth: GM crops decrease pesticide use
Truth: GM crops increase pesticide use
“GE crops have been responsible for
an increase of 383 million pounds of
herbicide use in the US over the first
13 years of commercial use of GE crops
(1996–2008). This dramatic increase
in the volume of herbicides applied
swamps the decrease in insecticide use
attributable to GE corn and cotton,
making the overall chemical footprint of
today’s GE crops decidedly negative…
The primary cause of the increase [is] the
emergence of herbicide-resistant weeds.”
– Dr Charles Benbrook, agronomist 9
“The promise was that you could use less
chemicals and produce a greater yield. But
let me tell you none of this is true.”
– Bill Christison, president of the US National
Family Farm Coalition 10
GM crops are claimed by proponents to reduce
pesticide use (the term “pesticide” includes
herbicides, which technically are pesticides). But
this is untrue. Herbicide-tolerant crops have been
developed by agrochemical firms specifically to
depend upon agrochemicals and have extended
the market for these chemicals. Far from weaning
agriculture away from environmentally damaging
chemicals, GM technology has prolonged and
extended the chemically-based agricultural model.
The adoption of GM Roundup Ready crops,
especially soy, has caused massive increases in the
use of glyphosate worldwide. 9,11,12,13,14
A report by agronomist Dr Charles Benbrook
using official US Department of Agriculture data
looked at the effects on pesticide use of the first
thirteen years of GM crop cultivation in the
United States, from 1996 to 2008. 9 Crops taken
into account were GM herbicide-tolerant and GM
Bt maize varieties, GM Roundup Ready soy, and
GM herbicide-tolerant and GM Bt cotton varieties.
The report found that Bt maize and cotton
delivered reductions in chemical insecticide use
totalling 64.2 million pounds (29.2 million kg) over
the thirteen years – though even the sustainability
of this trend is questionable, given the emergence
of Bt-resistant pests and the changes in insecticide
use patterns (see 5.3, below).
But herbicide-tolerant maize, soy, and cotton
caused farmers to spray 383 million more
pounds (174 million kg) of herbicides than they
would have done in the absence of herbicidetolerant
seeds. This massive increase in herbicide
use swamped the modest 64.2 million pound
reduction in chemical insecticide use attributed to
Bt maize and cotton.
The report showed that recently, herbicide use
on GM fields has veered sharply upward. Crop
years 2007 and 2008 accounted for 46% of the
increase in herbicide use over thirteen years across
the three herbicide-tolerant crops. Herbicide use
on GM herbicide-tolerant crops rose 31.4% from
2007 to 2008.
The report concluded that farmers applied 318
million more pounds of pesticides as a result of
planting GM seeds over the first thirteen years of
commercial use. In 2008, GM crop fields required
over 26% more pounds of pesticides per acre (1
acre = 0.4 hectares) than fields planted to non-GM
varieties.
The report identified the main cause of
the increase in herbicide use as the spread of
glyphosate-resistant weeds.
5.2.1. Glyphosate-resistant
superweeds
The widespread use of Roundup Ready crops
has led to over-reliance on a single herbicide –
glyphosate, commonly sold as Roundup. This
has resulted in the rapid spread of glyphosateresistant
weeds in countries where GM crops are
planted. 15 Resistant weeds include pigweed, 16
ryegrass, 17 and marestail. 18
The Herbicide Resistance Action Committee
(HRAC), financed by the pesticide industry, lists
21 glyphosate-resistant weeds around the world.
In the United States, glyphosate-resistant weeds
have been identified in 22 states. 19
When resistant weeds first appear, farmers
GMO Myths and Truths 74