Table 1b. Liquid tracers.- Field of applications: Central collection network, Equalization tank, Flash mixer,Clarifier, Aeration vessel, Anaerobic digester, Dispersion of discharge in waterTracers usedAdvantageConventional tracersElectrolytes (NaCl solution):conductivityDyes (Rhodamine, Fluorescence):colorAcids & Alkali: pHEasy availabilityCheapDisadvantage Not suitable for colour,conducting liquidsStratification due to <strong>de</strong>nsitydifferenceLarge threshold <strong>de</strong>tectionconcentrationPossible interference withWWTP treatment operationsRadioactive tracersK 82 Br, NH 82 3 Br, 99m Tc 2 O - 4 , 113m In-EDTA, 46 Sc-EDTA, Na 131 I - , 24 Na 2 CO 3, etc.No interaction with WWTP treatmentLow <strong>de</strong>tection thresholdOn-line measurementNo limitations due pH, conductivity and colourSome radiotracers are readily available andinexpensiveStrict radiation safety regulationsRelatively expensive <strong>de</strong>tection equipmentTable 1c.Solid tracers.- Field of applications: Collection networks, Sand and grit removal, Clarifiers, Biologicalreactors (aerobic and anaerobic), Discharge networksTracers usedAdvantageConventional TracersNo known solid tracersCurrent method: sampling,filtering, drying, weighingDisadvantage TediousDifficult to get statisticallyrepresentative sampleRadioactive Tracers113m In, 99m Tc, 198 Au, 140 La, etc.Same as in case of liquid phase radiotracersIn<strong>de</strong>pen<strong>de</strong>nt <strong>de</strong>tection without interference withgas and liquid <strong>de</strong>tectionStrict radiation safety regulationsRelatively expensive <strong>de</strong>tection equipment3.1. SELECTION OF RADIOTRACERS FOR INVESTIGATION OF WASTEWATERTREATMENT PLANTS3.1.1. Type of radiotracersSelection of a suitable radiotracer is very important for the success of every radiotracerexperiment. Factors that are important in the selection of a radiotracer are given as follows:• Physical/chemical form and properties of a tracer with respect to the material to be traced.• Half-life of a tracer with respect to the theoretical MRT of the system to be investigated.• Type and energy of radiation emitted with respect to the <strong>de</strong>tection geometry (thickness of a wall)• Method of measurement (sampling or in-situ measurement)• Handling of radioactive materials, radiological protection/regulations.• Availability and cost of tracerA tracer has to be chemically i<strong>de</strong>ntical with the substance to be traced when studying chemicalreaction kinetics, solubility, vapor pressure, processes dominated by atomic and molecular diffusion,and others. Radioactive isotopes of the traced elements and labeled molecules are used as intrinsictracers, for example, H 3 HO for H 2 O, 24 NaOH for NaOH or 14 CO 2 for CO 2 , etc.27
When tracing water and solids in WWTP processes where no chemical changes occur, theradiotracer does not have to be chemically representative of the element or compound. For example,when water is being traced, the only requirement of the tracer is that it behaves as the water behavesun<strong>de</strong>r the conditions of the WWTP. Some of extrinsic radiotracers that have been successfully used inaqueous solutions are 51 Cr-EDTA, 113m In-EDTA, Na 131 I, K 131 I, 24 Na 2 CO 3 , 24 NaHCO 3 , NH 4 82 Br,H 198 AuCl 4 and 99m TcO 4 - . EDTA (ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid) embraces the tracer cation andshields it from negative charges present in environment that otherwise would somehow interfere in itstracer performance.Extrinsic tracers wi<strong>de</strong>ly used for tracing organic fluids are dibromobenzene (C 6 H 4 82 Br 2 ), 131 I-kerosene and iodobenzene (C 6 H 5 131 I), 113m In in oleate or stearate form. Gas radiotracers commonlyused are 41 Ar, 79 Kr, H 3 82 Br and 133 Xe. Surface labeled sand and silt with 198 Au, 113m In, 51 Cr, 46 Sc and175 Hf have been wi<strong>de</strong>ly used in sediment transport studies in WWTP. Specially produced glassescontaining elements that can be activated by (n, γ) reactions are used as sand tracers. 198 Au, 51 Cr, 192 Irand 46 Sc are the radioactive nucli<strong>de</strong>s often induced by neutron activation.3.1.2. Radiotracers from radioisotope generatorsRadioisotope generators are very important in radiotracer work in <strong>de</strong>veloping countries withoutnuclear reactors. There are three useful radioisotope generators for remote radiotracer applicationsmostly in liquid phase: 99 Mo/ 99m Tc, 113 Sn/ 113m In, 137 Cs/ 137 Ba. Only 99 Mo/ 99m Tc, which is largely used innuclear medicine, is available in the market with reasonable price. It has several applications ininvestigating various WWTP units and processes in laboratory, pilot and industrial scales.113 Sn/ 113m In generator can be found from few suppliers. The gamma-ray energy of 390 keVtogether with the useful half-lives of the 113 Sn parent (115 d) and 113m In daughter (100 min) makes thisgenerator suitable for some applications, in particular for solid phase tracing.137 Cs/ 137 Ba generator produces very short live radiotracer but has practically very long life(several years at least). This is a useful radiotracer generator for routine service to end users, inparticular for liquid flow rate measurement and flowmeter calibration in WWTP processing units,because of its high gamma energy which can be easily <strong>de</strong>tected from outsi<strong>de</strong> pipes. The 137 Cs/ 137 Bagenerator is not available in the market. There are some tracer companies that produce home-ma<strong>de</strong>137 Cs/ 137 Ba generator for their own use.Commercially available generators are generally eluted using aqueous liquids or diluted solutionof HCl, so that the eluates are compatible with the water or water-like flows. Some typical applicationsof radionucli<strong>de</strong> generator-based radiotracers can be summarized as follows:•99m Tc in sodium pertechnetate form: Water tracing in wastewater treatment plants for RTDmeasurement.•99m Tc in reduced SnCl 2 medium: Sludge labelling-tracing in wastewater treatment plants for RTDmeasurements.•113m In in chlori<strong>de</strong> solution: Sludge labelling-tracing in wastewater treatment plants for RTDmeasurements.•113m In in EDTA complex: Water tracing in various hydraulic pilot plants and laboratory facilities.3.1.3. Radiotracers for water tracingTritiated water (H 3 HO) is the only intrinsic radiotracer for water. One has to use it very carefully dueto possible interfering exchange of 3 H with hydrogen in other molecules, evaporation, or exchangewith atmospheric moisture. Measurement of 3 H requires sampling and laboratory measurements byliquid scintillation.Gamma emitting tracers commonly used in water tracing are listed in Table 2:28