26.11.2019 Views

Jeweller: The Great Diamond Debate - Round II

Facts Vs Marketing: In 2019, both natural and man-made diamonds battled for the hearts and minds of consumers – and the gloves came off. While the dust is far from settled, the question remains: can consumers really make an informed choice in the midst of a marketing barrage and an increasingly confused industry?

Facts Vs Marketing: In 2019, both natural and man-made diamonds battled for the hearts and minds of consumers – and the gloves came off. While the dust is far from settled, the question remains: can consumers really make an informed choice in the midst of a marketing barrage and an increasingly confused industry?

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

SPOIL DAD THIS<br />

FATHER’S DAY<br />

WITH A RINGERS WESTERN<br />

OUTBACK WATCH FOR<br />

ONLY RRP $119 .00<br />

TOTAL VALUE<br />

RRP $203 .95<br />

• 100m Water Resistant<br />

• Screw In Crown<br />

• Screw Down Back<br />

• Stainless Steel<br />

• Day / Date Indicator<br />

• Anti Smash Glass Protection bezel<br />

@RingersWestern<br />

(normal RRP $169)<br />

And receive a<br />

Trucker hat for free<br />

VALUED AT RRP$34.95<br />

www.RingersWestern.com<br />

@ringerswestern<br />

trepidation. It seems more lab-grown suppliers<br />

and retailers are popping up monthly and we<br />

know, based on other items such as televisions,<br />

computers and smartphones, that the more<br />

ubiquitous the supply, the lower the prices.<br />

Nevertheless, once a customer knows about<br />

the benefit of a lab-grown diamond – a larger<br />

diamond that looks beautiful and has a lower price<br />

point – that option becomes very enticing.<br />

<strong>The</strong> instant gratification of the purchase and<br />

excitement of the moment will most likely prevail<br />

over their other considerations, such as the future<br />

value of the diamond.<br />

You respond: “I offer both natural and labgrown<br />

diamonds – what are you looking for in<br />

a stone?” – This is the camp within which I find<br />

an increasing number of jewellers. Some show<br />

their natural products first and ‘hide’ the lab-grown<br />

diamonds under the counter until the customer<br />

asks for them; others display natural and lab-grown<br />

diamonds next to each other.<br />

Most members of the ‘both’ group don’t maintain a<br />

large stock level of lab-grown diamonds but they<br />

do occasionally mention them in advertising and<br />

marketing materials.<br />

Often the customer who visits the store<br />

specifically asking about lab-grown diamonds<br />

ends up purchasing one. If there are no lab-grown<br />

diamonds in stock, the customer goes elsewhere<br />

– they do not consider a natural diamond as<br />

an alternative because they are attracted to the<br />

specific attributes of a lab-grown stone.<br />

If the jeweller has developed a relationship with<br />

the customer, that opens the door to order<br />

diamonds on memo/consignment.<br />

<strong>The</strong> customer relationship and, again, asking<br />

the question – ‘What matters to you?’ – are key;<br />

without these elements, retailers are dealing at a<br />

transactional level rather than a relational level,<br />

making sales success less likely.<br />

THE COMPLEX QUESTION OF ‘VALUE’<br />

Often, jewellers are asked questions about buyback<br />

or future trade-in of lab-grown diamonds and<br />

their answer has to be: the future is unknown. It is<br />

an evolving technology, so at this time jewellers<br />

may decide not to offer buy-back or guarantee<br />

trade-in value for lab-grown diamonds.<br />

For the most part, customers willingly agree to<br />

those terms, because they want to buy a beautiful<br />

piece of jewellery for their loved one. <strong>The</strong> purchase<br />

is purely emotional, not based on a future value<br />

or investment. Just like with natural diamonds,<br />

customers fall in love with lab-grown diamonds in<br />

the moment.<br />

<strong>The</strong> thought of returning the jewellery in the<br />

future – or the relationship with their loved one<br />

ending – is the furthest thing from their mind.<br />

Additionally, when it comes right down to it, at<br />

what price would most jewellers offer to buy back<br />

a natural diamond sold to the customer eight years<br />

ago? In general, jewellers offer a similar trade-in<br />

value to the purchase price – if the customer<br />

agrees to buy a significantly larger stone.<br />

As an outright purchase, however, jewellers usually<br />

offer cents on the dollar. When we look at it this<br />

way, we are truly comparing apples to apples.<br />

Some have argued that the lower price point<br />

or ‘lack of resale value’ precludes lab-grown<br />

diamonds from the engagement ring category.<br />

Yet for a jeweller to determine the unsuitability of<br />

any gemstone for use in an engagement ring is<br />

short-sighted and shows a lack of attention to the<br />

customer’s desires.<br />

I’ve seen engagement rings set with opals,<br />

iolite and even citrine, because that was what<br />

the customer wanted. In the end, a jeweller is a<br />

businessperson; they are in business to make a<br />

profit. Supplying customers with what they want<br />

provides that profit.<br />

Some customers are adamant about wanting<br />

natural diamonds in every piece, from fashion<br />

jewellery to their engagement ring, and they<br />

will happily pay the higher price natural<br />

diamonds command.<br />

Others strictly want fashion jewellery pieces that<br />

are more affordable. Give it to them!<br />

Finally, if a customer requests a specific stone<br />

for any reason – be it environmental, cost or<br />

another factor – a jeweller that values life-long<br />

customers would do well to provide them with<br />

what they want.<br />

It’s wise for jewellers to consider how they can<br />

offer customers exactly what they’re after, enjoy a<br />

healthy margin and keep them from purchasing<br />

elsewhere. Think about it. i<br />

ABOUT THE AUTHOR<br />

Jimmy DeGroot is a jewellery retail training<br />

specialist and speaker. He shares his sales and<br />

marketing techniques, developed over 20<br />

years, at jewelrystoretraining.com.<br />

E orders@samsgroup.com.au<br />

W samsgroup.com.au P 02 9290 2199

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!