29.03.2013 Views

Vatican II ABOUT FACE! - Chiesa viva

Vatican II ABOUT FACE! - Chiesa viva

Vatican II ABOUT FACE! - Chiesa viva

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

into consideration and condemned by Paul VI in his “Mysterium<br />

Fidei”) that the dogmatic formulas of the Ecumenical<br />

Councils and others “are no longer appropriate for the men<br />

of our time (…)”<br />

It is clearly evident that Pope John firmly believed in this<br />

statement, condemned by Paul VI, in his incredible insistence<br />

on hammering the same point (“presenting the doctrine in a<br />

way that it addresses the needs of our time”) that can be read<br />

between the lines at Number 55+:<br />

42<br />

«It will be necessary (?) to give much importance<br />

to this way (that is, the new way of presenting<br />

the doctrine) and if necessary, it will require<br />

to patiently insist on its elaboration and<br />

to find a way to present things more in line with<br />

the teachings (…) of a predominantly pastoral<br />

nature (…)»<br />

How can we put this? Paul VI, in his “Mysterium Fidei”,<br />

clearly condemns as a daring idea the thought of subjecting<br />

other formulas to the dogmatic Conciliar formulas of the<br />

Council and also the pretext (albeit inconsistent) that the formulas<br />

“are deemed no longer appropriate to men of our<br />

time (…)”<br />

If we are not mistaken, in his speech to reopen the Council<br />

of September 29, 1963, Paul VI, in the section dedicated<br />

to the Homage to the Memory of Pope John, referring<br />

specifically to his Council opening speech of October 11,<br />

1962 and unconditionally praising its tone and goal, continued<br />

to worsen all the colossal paradoxes found in the speech, in<br />

the above-mentioned No. 55+ of the Dehonian and that which<br />

Paul VI condemned in his “Mysterium” as we have just mentioned!!!<br />

Yes, we repeat, Paul VI, by compounding things, made all<br />

the directives from Pope John in the Second <strong>Vatican</strong> Council<br />

his own, steering it towards the disaster that we now have<br />

in front of our still incredulous eyes.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!