Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Appendix C C-105<br />
PROJECT<br />
Two Methods for Solving Certain Cubic Equations<br />
The first person known to have solved cubic equations algebraically was del Ferro but<br />
he told nobody of his achievement. On his deathbed, however, del Ferro passed on the<br />
secret to his (rather poor) student Fior. Fior began to boast that he was able to solve<br />
cubics and a challenge between him and Tartaglia was arranged in 1535.—From the<br />
MacTutor History of Mathematics website: http://www-groups.dcs.st-and.ac.uk/<br />
~history. The site is maintained by the University of St. Andrews, Scotland.<br />
Stated in modern language, one of the problems that Fior challenged Tartaglia<br />
to solve in 1535 was essentially as follows.<br />
A Restatement of One of Fior’s Challenge Problems for del Ferro<br />
A tree is 12 units high. At what height<br />
should it be cut so that the length of the<br />
portion left standing equals the cube<br />
root of the length of the portion cut off?<br />
12<br />
12-x<br />
x<br />
In this project you’ll learn two different methods that can be used to determine<br />
the root of the cubic equation that solves Fior’s tree-cutting problem. As is indicated<br />
in the figure above, we let x denote the length of the part of the tree left<br />
standing. The condition stated in the problem then gives us x 1 3 12 x.<br />
After cubing both sides and rearranging, we have the cubic equation to be<br />
solved:<br />
x 3 x 12 0<br />
(1)<br />
Method 1 To find a root of an equation of the form x 3 ax b 0, when<br />
a<br />
a 0, make the substitution x y After simplifying, this will produce a<br />
3y .<br />
sixth-degree equation that is of quadratic type and that therefore can be solved<br />
as in Section 2.2.* Apply this strategy to solve equation (1). Hints: At the beginning,<br />
you have a 1, and so the substitution to make in equation (1) is<br />
1<br />
x y After simplifying and then solving the resulting equation of quadratic<br />
type, you should obtain y 16 236 1 272 13 . Then, choosing the pos-<br />
3y .<br />
itive square root for the moment, you’ll obtain the required value for x:<br />
x y 1 3y 16 236 1 27 2 13 1<br />
<br />
316 236 1<br />
27 2 13<br />
2.14404 using a calculator<br />
What value do you obtain for x if you use the negative square root, that is,<br />
y (6 ) 13 ?<br />
236 1 27<br />
*Precalculus: A Problems-Oriented Approach, 7th edition