04.04.2014 Views

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

Child Support Enforcement - Sarpy County Nebraska

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

[O]nly civil contempt orders issued before a final judgment in the main action are<br />

interlocutory (and unappealable).<br />

A court that has jurisdiction to issue an order also has the power to enforce it. A<br />

court can issue orders that are necessary to carry its judgment or decree into effect.<br />

<strong>Nebraska</strong> courts, through their inherent judicial power, have the authority to do all<br />

things reasonably necessary for the proper administration of justice. And this<br />

authority exists apart from any statutory grant of authority. The power to punish for<br />

contempt is incident to every judicial tribune. It is derived from a court’s constitutional<br />

power, without any expressed statutory aid, and is inherent in all courts of record.<br />

A court of equity has the power to interpret its own injunctive decree if a party later<br />

claims that a provision is unclear. The critical question for appeal purposes is<br />

whether a clarification order merely interprets an injunctive decree or whether it<br />

modifies the decree in a way that affects a party’s substantial right.<br />

An appellate court, reviewing a final judgment or order in a contempt proceeding,<br />

reviews for errors appearing on the record. When reviewing a judgment for errors<br />

appearing on the record, the inquiry is whether the decision conforms to the law, is<br />

supported by competent evidence, and is neither arbitrary, capricious, nor<br />

unreasonable.<br />

Under <strong>Nebraska</strong> law, an order of contempt in a postjudgment proceeding to enforce<br />

a previous final judgment is properly classified as a final order; the contempt order<br />

affects a substantial right, made upon a summary application in an action after<br />

judgment.<br />

For appeal purposes, the distinction between criminal and civil contempt sanctions<br />

has no relevance to whether a party may appeal from a final order in a supplemental<br />

postjudgment contempt proceeding.<br />

A trial court’s factual finding in a contempt pro eding will be upheld on appeal<br />

unless the finding is clearly erroneous.<br />

When a party to an action fails to comply with a court order made for the benefit of<br />

the opposing party, such act is ordinarily a civil contempt, which requires willful<br />

disobedience as an essential element. “Willful” means the violation was<br />

committed intentionally, with knowledge that the act violated the court order.<br />

A court cannot hold a person or party in contempt unless the order or consent<br />

decree gave clear warning that the conduct in question was required or proscribed.<br />

In civil cases, when a party’s interests are substantial and involve more than the<br />

mere loss of money, but obviously do not involve a criminal conviction, due process<br />

is satisfied by an intermediate “clear and convincing” standard of proof. Proof<br />

beyond a reasonable doubt is a criminal trial protection that does not apply to civil<br />

contempt proceedings.<br />

As of the date of this opinion (April 16, 2010), outside of statutory procedures<br />

imposing a different standard, it is the complainant’s burden to prove civil contempt<br />

by clear and convincing evidence.<br />

State v. Collins, 281 Neb. 927, 799 N.W.2d 693 (2011)<br />

[A]n issue not presented to or decided on by the trial court is not an appropriate<br />

issue for consideration on appeal. [W]e have applied those principles to find waiver<br />

of statutory and even constitutional rights when a defendant fails to raise them.<br />

Szawicki v. Szawicki, 17 Neb. App. 820, 770 N.W.2d 676 (2009)<br />

Briefly speaking….<br />

- 13 -

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!