Nuts & Volts
Nuts & Volts
Nuts & Volts
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
■ WITH TJ BYERS<br />
Q & A<br />
In this column, I answer questions about all<br />
aspects of electronics, including computer<br />
hardware, software, circuits, electronic theory,<br />
troubleshooting, and anything else of interest<br />
to the hobbyist.<br />
Feel free to participate with your questions,<br />
comments, or suggestions.<br />
You can reach me at: TJBYERS@aol.com<br />
✓<br />
✓<br />
✓<br />
✓<br />
WHAT’S UP:<br />
APPLICATIONS<br />
This month’s Q&A — some<br />
new and unusual questions<br />
and answers!<br />
● Why loudspeakers are different.<br />
● Phone busy alert.<br />
● Two optical switching circuits.<br />
● T-Bird tail lights.<br />
SO MANY TO<br />
CHOOSE FROM<br />
QI have noticed a large variety<br />
of “impedance” ratings for<br />
speakers; such as four ohms,<br />
eight ohms, 16 ohms, and<br />
others. Why so many Is it just to make<br />
the design of the power amplifier easier<br />
by matching the output impedance<br />
— Jeff Dunker<br />
■ FIGURE 1<br />
20 March 2006<br />
AWell, that’s part of the answer<br />
— but it’s not the whole<br />
story. Let’s begin with the<br />
physical construction of a<br />
loudspeaker, as shown in Figure 1.<br />
Basically, a loudspeaker consists<br />
of a voice coil (electromagnet)<br />
suspended in a magnetic field. When a<br />
current is run through the coil, it<br />
creates a magnetic field that forces the<br />
coil inside or outside the magnetic field<br />
— according to the strength of the current<br />
and its polarity. The stronger the<br />
electromagnetic field, the farther the<br />
displacement (throw) of the voice coil<br />
with respect to the permanent magnet.<br />
If an AC voltage is applied across<br />
the voice coil, it will move in and out<br />
as the field changes polarity. The voice<br />
coil is glued to a paper or plastic cone<br />
that moves in step with the voice coil.<br />
This movement translates the electron<br />
flow into air movement — a.k.a., sound.<br />
Early on in the development of<br />
audio amplifiers, many methods were<br />
used to produce this movement. The<br />
most feasible was and is the voice-coil<br />
loudspeaker described above. The critical<br />
element of this design is the voice<br />
coil itself. It is nothing more than many<br />
turns of copper wire — wire that has<br />
resistance that’s measured by the foot.<br />
For example, a typical eight-ohm,<br />
four-layer woofer voice coil contains<br />
about 120 feet of number 28 solid<br />
copper wire. That’s a lot of wire to<br />
shove into the small gap between the<br />
north and south poles of the permanent<br />
magnet. Consequently, it’s physically<br />
more practical to use a smaller<br />
wire with more resistance than it is to<br />
use larger wire, which is harder to<br />
work with when forming a rigid voice<br />
coil destined for a small space.<br />
But here comes a trade-off. Current<br />
times voltage makes watts. So voice<br />
coils with more resistance require more<br />
voltage to produce the same wattage.<br />
In the days of vacuum tubes, this<br />
wasn’t a problem. They required hundred<br />
of volts on the plate and an output<br />
transformer in their design, so loudspeakers<br />
of that era were typically 16 to<br />
32 ohms because the value best fit<br />
the tube to transformer coupling —<br />
and the materials and manufacturing<br />
methods of the time.<br />
With the advent of semiconductors,<br />
voltages decreased and currents<br />
increased. That coupled with the discovery<br />
of rare-earth permanent magnets<br />
with stronger magnetic fields<br />
(versus Alnico) made it realistic to<br />
use lower resistance coils. For example,<br />
the car stereo market uses almost<br />
nothing but four-ohm speakers due to<br />
voltage limitations available in cars<br />
(specifically 12 volts). More power can<br />
be driven into a four-ohm speaker<br />
than an eight-ohm speaker (assuming<br />
the same driving signal).<br />
Are four-ohm speakers better than<br />
eight-ohm speakers Absolutely not!<br />
The ohm rating of a speaker has<br />
nothing to do with the quality of the<br />
speaker. But it has a lot to do with the<br />
way you wire an array of speakers<br />
together. Is an eight-ohm speaker<br />
really eight ohms Not likely. Due to<br />
the highly complicated nature of a<br />
loudspeaker, its impedance is not a<br />
simple number, but an AC reactive<br />
value that changes with frequency and<br />
loading that can vary between six and<br />
20 ohms. But that’s a story for another<br />
day. For now, when a speaker is said to<br />
be four or eight ohms, this is understood<br />
to be its nominal impedance.