13.07.2015 Views

Deep Panuke Project Description - Encana

Deep Panuke Project Description - Encana

Deep Panuke Project Description - Encana

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Table 2.10Centre Substructure Type AlternativesAlternativeNew buildjack upTechnical SuitabilityExisting proven designs are available forthe <strong>Deep</strong> <strong>Panuke</strong> site conditionsCost/Lease Commercial Risk Technically and ConceptEconomically Feasible DeliverabilitySafetyCapital cost slightlyLow Yes Best No specifichigher than jacketsconcernsEnvironmental ImpactLow/negligible similar toother alternativesLease availableRefit existingjackupExisting harsh environment drill rigs exist,although none presently identified asavailable.Capital cost higherthan new buildjackupLease not availableHigh cost & schedule overruns tobe expectedYes Poor Existing rig mayrequire significantupgrades to meetregulationsLow/negligible similar toother alternativesJackdeckRelatively new concept, no provenexperience in these environmentalconditionsCapital cost higherthan new build jackupMedium (new design could leadto overruns, potentially singlesource supplier)Yes Risk involved No specificconcernsLow/negligible similar toother alternativesTechnically acceptable , with riskJacket Proven for <strong>Deep</strong> <strong>Panuke</strong> site conditions Lease option notavailableLowTechnically feasible; noteconomically feasibleSteel Semi-SubmersibleHullTechnical concerns related to riser designand mooring, adjacent to other platformsand riser designLack of experience in shallow/harshconditionsOnly one semi in use for gas production(deeper water)Slightly higher thanjacket optionGreater than jacket NoConcrete GBS Gravity based system (GBS) widely used –six examples in water this shallowMost expensiveSingle source of supply couldlead to high costsNoInshore topside analysis avoids large cranerequirement<strong>Deep</strong> <strong>Panuke</strong> Volume 4 (Environmental Assessment Report)• November 2006 2-64

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!