Clusters and competitiveness - PRO INNO Europe
Clusters and competitiveness - PRO INNO Europe
Clusters and competitiveness - PRO INNO Europe
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
attractive for entrepreneurs. And they can play a role in the diversification towards new<br />
clusters through targeted FDI attraction <strong>and</strong> facilitating collaboration in existing clusters.<br />
Whereeffortsaimtofacilitatetheevolutionofnewclusters,theyneedtoidentifywhichnew<br />
clusters have a reasonable probability of developing. Two new approaches have recently<br />
beensuggestedtosupportthisselection,bothbasedonidentifyingareasthatarerelated<br />
tocurrentstrengths.Thesecurrentstrengthsareseenpartlyasasourceofexistingcompany<br />
capabilitiesthatcanalsobeusedinthenewfield,<strong>and</strong>partlyasanindicationofexisting<br />
businessenvironmentstrengthsthatarealsorelevantthere.Oneapproachlooksatthe<br />
typesofproducts <strong>and</strong> services that countries at a given level of economic development<br />
tend to export (Hausmann/Klinger, 2007).<br />
As countriesdevelop,itturnsoutthattheymovesequentiallyintonewexportsof<br />
relatedgoods<strong>and</strong>services,ratherthan’jumping’intoverydistantareasoftheproduct<br />
space.Anotherapproachlooksatthelinkagesbetween<strong>and</strong>withinclustersrevealedin<br />
employment,<strong>and</strong>takesthatasastartingpointtoanalyzethepotentialtodevelopan<br />
existing portfolio of exports (Porter/Ketels, 2007). Growth can be generated from increasing<br />
thevalueperunitofexportsinexistingclusters,growingexportsinsofarweakerindustries<br />
within strong export clusters, developing related clusters, <strong>and</strong> turning exports positions in<br />
narrow niche industries into broader cluster strengths. These findings are relevant not only<br />
for exports but also more generally for economies’ changing patterns of specialization.<br />
3. Cluster policy<br />
Cluster researchoverthelasttwentyyearshastoalargedegreefocusedonestablishing<br />
clusters’ role for the market success of companies <strong>and</strong> the performance of regions. Not<br />
surprisingly, the evidence that clusters are important for economic success has attracted<br />
theinterestofpolicymakers.Butwhilethereisanemergingconsensusontheusefulness<br />
ofclusters as an analytical tool, at least the academic discussion on cluster policy remains<br />
far from agreement.<br />
Practitioners, meanwhile,haveoverthelastfewyearslaunchedanimpressivenumber<br />
ofcluster policy programs. Catalonia was among the first economies globally that launched<br />
cluster efforts around the time when Porter’s “Competitive Advantage of Nations” was<br />
published (other “early adopters” where the Basque country (Aranguren et al., 2006)as<br />
wellDenmark, Finl<strong>and</strong>, <strong>and</strong> the Netherl<strong>and</strong>s). The experience with this first wave of cluster<br />
policies wasmixed,<strong>and</strong>therewasaperiodoflessactivitythatlastedupuntiltheearly<br />
2000s.Cataloniawasamongthefewregionsthatcontinueditsclusterprogramsover<br />
time.Sincethen,therehasbeenamarkedrevivalofclusterefforts,especiallysince2005.<br />
Thisrevivalwasdrivenlargelybyagrowingfrustrationofpolicymakerswithtraditional<br />
approachesatatimewhenpressuretoincrease<strong>competitiveness</strong>wasgrowing(Davies,<br />
2007;Freser,2005).Thenewpolicies<strong>and</strong>programscoulddrawonthelearningsfromearlier<br />
efforts.Buttheycouldstillnotbuildonaconsensusmodelofclusterpolicythatwouldhave<br />
converted the skeptics.<br />
ANNEX: CLUSTERS AND COMPETITIVENESS: FLORENCE, BOSTON, BARCELONA<br />
135