Karen Bedard and Karl-Heinz Krause
Karen Bedard and Karl-Heinz Krause
Karen Bedard and Karl-Heinz Krause
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
252 KAREN BEDARD AND KARL-HEINZ KRAUSE<br />
TABLE 2. Tissue distribution of NOX enzymes<br />
High-Level Expression Intermediate- to Low-Level Expression Reference Nos.<br />
NOX1 Colon Smooth muscle, endothelium, uterus, placenta,<br />
prostate, osteoclasts, retinal pericytes<br />
NOX2 Phagocytes B lymphocytes, neurons, cardiomyocytes,<br />
skeletal muscle, hepatocytes, endothelium,<br />
hematopoietic stem cells, smooth muscle<br />
factors (107). Constitutive expression of NOX1 in intestinal<br />
epithelial cells depends on the GATA-binding sites<br />
(107), while interferon-�-enhanced expression is regulated<br />
by the binding of activated STAT1 dimers to the<br />
�-activated sequence (GAS) element (498). Note that the<br />
GATA sites are within the 520-bp region upstream of the<br />
transcription initiation site, while the GAS elements is<br />
located at �3818 to �3810 bp (498). In the mouse NOX1<br />
gene, additional promoters up to 110 kb upstream from<br />
the transcription initiation site give rise to NOX1 splice<br />
variants (29). Within the colon, there is a gradient of<br />
NOX1 expression with levels being low in the proximal<br />
<strong>and</strong> high in the distal colon (302, 854). However, at this<br />
point, it is not clear whether this gradient is constitutive<br />
or secondary to bacterial colonization.<br />
Data on the subcellular localization of NOX1 are<br />
scarce, mainly because the generation of high quality<br />
antibodies against NOX1 (<strong>and</strong> other NOX isoforms)<br />
turned out to be a challenge <strong>and</strong> some of the antibodies<br />
used were not subjected to rigorous validation protocols.<br />
With this limitation in mind, there are several studies<br />
reporting a subcellular localization of NOX1; in keratinocytes,<br />
there was a weak cytoplasmic <strong>and</strong> a strong nuclear<br />
staining (134). One study in vascular smooth muscle suggests<br />
an ER pattern (425), while another describes punctate<br />
patches along cell surface membranes, possibly corresponding<br />
to a caveolar localization (378).<br />
In studies using a cell-free system, NOX1 is selective<br />
for NADPH over NADH as a substrate (977).<br />
After the initial discovery of NOX1, it was not immediately<br />
obvious whether NOX1 was indeed a superoxide<br />
generating enzyme. While one group reported a very low<br />
level of superoxide generation in NOX1-transfected cells<br />
14, 53, 55, 178, 473,<br />
510, 516, 576, 841,<br />
without the need of a stimulus (841), other groups did not<br />
observe such ROS generation by NOX1 alone (53, 295,<br />
297). The discovery of colon homologs of the cytosolic<br />
subunits of the phagocyte NADPH oxidase resolved the<br />
issue (53, 146, 297, 857): superoxide generation by NOX1<br />
depends on cytosolic subunits. The novel cytosolic subunits<br />
were named NOXO1 (NOX organizer 1 � p47 phox<br />
homolog) <strong>and</strong> NOXA1 (NOX activator 1 � p67 phox homolog).<br />
Details concerning these proteins are discussed<br />
below. The discovery of the subunit dependence of NOX1<br />
introduced new complexities. First, in transfected cells,<br />
NOX1 is also able to use the p47 phox <strong>and</strong> p67 phox subunits,<br />
suggesting that cytosolic subunits are not specific for a<br />
given NOX protein (53). For example, it might be possible<br />
that p47 phox acts as a subunit of NOX1 in the vascular<br />
system (see below). Second, while expression systems<br />
using the mouse proteins suggest a constitutive activity of<br />
the NOX1/NOXO1/NOXA1 system, studies using human<br />
proteins show only a weak constitutive activity, <strong>and</strong> full<br />
activation depends on activation through the PKC activator<br />
phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA) (297, 857).<br />
There are indeed significant differences between the<br />
mouse <strong>and</strong> the human proteins, in particular, in the region<br />
of the phox homology domain which is distinct in human<br />
NOXO1. Yet, at this point, it is not clear whether the<br />
difference in PKC dependence is really due to a difference<br />
between the mouse <strong>and</strong> human NOX1/NOXO1/NOXA1<br />
system or whether this reflects some experimental details,<br />
such as cell lines or the use of transient versus stable<br />
expression systems.<br />
In addition to its dependence on cytosolic subunits,<br />
NOX1 requires the membrane subunit p22 phox (24, 446).<br />
The p22 phox dependence of NOX1 might be less stringent<br />
854<br />
143, 313, 372, 426, 434,<br />
538, 704, 739, 806,<br />
844<br />
NOX3 Inner ear Fetal kidney, fetal spleen, skull bone, brain 54, 143, 454, 677<br />
NOX4 Kidney, blood vessels Osteoclasts, endothelium, smooth muscle,<br />
hematopoietic stem cells, fibroblasts,<br />
keratinocytes, melanoma cells, neurons<br />
NOX5 Lymphoid tissue,<br />
testis<br />
Endothelium, smooth muscle, pancreas,<br />
placenta, ovary, uterus, stomach, various<br />
fetal tissues<br />
DUOX1 Thyroid Airway epithelia, tongue epithelium,<br />
cerebellum, testis<br />
DUOX2 Thyroid Salivary <strong>and</strong> rectal gl<strong>and</strong>s, gastrointestinal<br />
epithelia, airway epithelia, uterus, gall<br />
bladder, pancreatic islets<br />
14, 105, 135, 170, 176,<br />
211, 247, 294, 383,<br />
392, 425, 510, 699,<br />
704, 813, 836, 900,<br />
901, 969, 973<br />
56, 143, 770<br />
189, 229, 271, 299, 794,<br />
931<br />
189, 229, 230, 246, 271,<br />
299, 794, 931<br />
NOX enzymes are expressed in a small number of tissues at high levels (readily detected by Northern blotting) but show intermediate- to<br />
low-level expression in many other tissues.<br />
Physiol Rev VOL 87 JANUARY 2007 www.prv.org<br />
Downloaded from<br />
physrev.physiology.org<br />
on February 2, 2010