28.06.2013 Views

Review - American Jewish Archives

Review - American Jewish Archives

Review - American Jewish Archives

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Book <strong>Review</strong>s 253<br />

their days in poverty, they were able to put their descendants on<br />

the way to a better life in this New World.<br />

If seen this way, this whole historic chapter gets a very different<br />

evaluation. However, we still know little about these women. Baile<br />

de Mascaras includes long lists of all the members of the different<br />

boards that took care of the affairs in the thee major Brazilian cities<br />

surveyed in the book. Their names have been now made public, yet<br />

Kushnir didn't have access to many primary sources. There are the<br />

incomplete protocols of the meetings, police forms filled out about<br />

many of the women involved in prostitution, and some (very few)<br />

personal testimonies. Somehow one can feel the author's anguish<br />

about this shortage of information.<br />

Be that as it may, she has been able to put the story of <strong>Jewish</strong><br />

prostitution in Brazil in a certain perspective, shedding more light<br />

on the subject than previously existed. However, a fuller account of<br />

who these women were remains, maybe forever, in the dark, the<br />

same darkness in which they worked. This probably should put<br />

present-day members of the Latin <strong>American</strong> <strong>Jewish</strong> community at<br />

ease. Not much else besides a name will be there to connect these<br />

people to them. It's true that prostitutes are mentioned in the Bible.<br />

But after all, those were somebody else's distant relatives.<br />

- Alejandro Lilienthal<br />

Rabbi Alejandro Lilienthal is a native of Montevideo, Uruguay, and before his re-<br />

cent move to Waco, Texas, served congregations in Brazil for nearly ten years.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!