ILCD Handbook: Framework and requirements for LCIA models and ...

More documents

Recommendations

Info

ILCD Handbook: Framework and requirements for LCIA models and indicators First edition Toxicity Bioaccumulation/magnification Effects on biodiversity Table 4-7 presents the general and specific criteria for eco-toxicity, identifying the minimum score to be met (threshold value) and the most relevant criteria for the impact category (importance). Table 4-7 General and specific criteria for eco-toxicity with threshold value and importance. ECOTOXICITY Check the following: Introduction Completeness of scope Environmental relevance Overall evaluation • Timeframe, discounting, etc. • Marginal (M) or Average (A) defined, if not described (ND) Total number of substances covered by the provided characterisation factors • The impact indicator covers the majority of impact mechanisms and relevant elementary flows for the AoP Human Health • The impact indicator covers the majority of impact mechanisms and relevant elementary flows for the AoP Natural Environment? • The impact indicator covers the majority of impact mechanisms and relevant elementary flows for the AoP Natural Resources • The midpoint indicator is chosen in a way that all LCI are appropriately aggregated as early as possible in the cause effect chain • The characterisation model is adaptable to spatial and temporal explicit evaluation • Global geographical validity preferable, separate validity for Europe beneficial • The method is compatible with, or developed specifically for, the comparative assessment scope of LCA (e.g. factors do not include security factors / precautionary principle) • When empirical data is used, double counting is avoided The following critical parts of the environmental mechanism describing the cause-effect chain are included with acceptable quality: • Advection out of a region or of a continent is not considered a final loss. • Marine environment and coastal zone are differentiated • Influential fate processes are considered (classic - volatilization, deposition/sedimentation, intermittent rain) • The effect factors are derived from the average toxicity over all species instead of the most sensitive species • Direct effects on species diversity of toxicants are considered Threshold (Minimum score) B H B H C H C H C H Importance (H-N) 4 Requirements for specific impact categories 70
ILCD Handbook: Framework and requirements for LCIA models and indicators First edition ECOTOXICITY Check the following: Scientific robustness & Certainty Documentation & Transparency & Reproducibility Applicability Overall evaluation Scientific robustness Certainty • Indirect effects on species diversity of toxicants via food web changes are included in the endpoint assessment • Chronic toxicity data are considered preferable to acute data as a basis for toxicity effect factors • EC50 data are considered preferable to NOEC data as a basis for toxicity effect factors • Effect factors are available for all environmental compartments • The critical part of the model including the input data have been peer reviewed (journal, panel, book, etc.) The model reflects the latest stage of knowledge for the cause-effect chain, i.e. the following critical links are covered: • Fate Overall evaluation Overall evaluation • Bioavailability Threshold (Minimum score) B H C N • Toxicity C N • Effects on biodiversity • The model including the underlying data have a good potential for being consistently improved and further developed including regarding geographical/emission situation and temporal differentiation • Indicators can be confirmed and verified against monitoring data, if available • Uncertainty estimates of the indicators are provided, justified and reported in statistical terms • Scenario and model uncertainty are taken into account • The model documentation is published and accessible (incl. description of the mechanism, the model, temporal and spatial scale, etc.)? • The set of characterisation factors/models is published and accessible • The input data are published and accessible • The characterisation model is published and accessible • Ability for third parties to freely generate additional, consistent factors and to further develop models e.g. incorporating further geographical/emission situation, temporal and speciation differentiation • Value choices are explicitly stated • Coverage of impacting single substance/resource elementary flows of the ELCD database (version October 2007) • Ease to update to conform e.g. with the ILCD nomenclature and units C N B H B H B H C H Importance (H-N) 4 Requirements for specific impact categories 71
Page 1 and 2:
ILCD Handbook: Framework and requir
Page 3 and 4:
Page 5 and 6:
Page 7 and 8:
Page 9 and 10:
Page 11 and 12:
Page 13 and 14:
Page 15:
Page 18 and 19:
Page 20 and 21:
Page 22 and 23:
Page 25 and 26:
Page 27 and 28:
Page 29 and 30: ILCD Handbook: Framework and requir
Page 79: ILCD Handbook: Framework and requir
Page 115 and 116: How to obtain EU publications Our p
show all

ILCD Handbook: Framework and requirements for LCIA models and ...

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

Delete template?

Save as template?