16.01.2013 Views

Social Work with People Practicing Same-Sex ... - ILGA Europe

Social Work with People Practicing Same-Sex ... - ILGA Europe

Social Work with People Practicing Same-Sex ... - ILGA Europe

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Quantitative methods are particularly widespread in the implementation of studies on<br />

risky behaviours, related to HIV epidemic (especially behaviours of MSM 1 ). Among new<br />

works in this area, three attract a particular attention. The fist one is monitoring of<br />

sexual behaviour of MSM (2007), developed <strong>with</strong> active involvement and participation<br />

of LGBT community representatives 2 . The second and the third ones concern men in<br />

armed forces 3 and in confinement 4 (they are noteworthy due to the fact, that compared<br />

to similar 2004 surveys among representatives of such closed collectives, one can<br />

observe statistically meaningful growth of the percentage of men who have ever had<br />

sex <strong>with</strong> other men 5 ).<br />

Speaking about content analysis, we found only one short article by Ruslan Kukharchuk,<br />

ardent opponent of LGBT community 6 . Unfortunately, works of LGBT themselves in this<br />

area are still non-existent.<br />

Another study, based on the quantitative methodology, was completed in mod-2008 —<br />

analysis of lonely hearts ads, submitted by MSM of the Donetsk oblast during the 12 years<br />

of existence of printed M+M ads in Ukraine. Key results are briefly presented in the<br />

Internet 7 ; full results were submitted to the academic journal “Ukrainian Socium” as an<br />

article. Unfortunately, no similar studies of F+F or F+M ads have been conducted — it<br />

would be extremely valuable for the comparative analysis.<br />

Gaps and perspectives<br />

This review is not exhaustive, of course. In conclusion I would like to mention several<br />

issues that need to be addressed.<br />

I believe that the most important issue is the problem of methodology. We need to<br />

identify one or several sociological methods that will guarantee that collected figures<br />

are representative for the entire group (instead of characterizing only limited segment<br />

of individuals available for research). The second issue relates to conceptual and<br />

terminology basis, when our objective is to define a specific group. Who are MSM<br />

and FSF? Do they identify themselves as homosexuals or bisexuals, or these are just<br />

behavioural practices? It is very important, because identity affects their access to<br />

social and health services, and so on. It will also influence the ultimate results of the<br />

study.<br />

Speaking about qualitative phenomena, related to identity of gay men and MSM,<br />

right now we only make notice of those who are left out of traditional institutions —<br />

economic, political, family and so on. As a rule, they do not have this internal sanction<br />

“to be a stud” (e.g. to stand for himself). The other part is heterosexuals, for who<br />

adventures <strong>with</strong> the same-sex love is a kind of fun — it does not influence their<br />

self-perception as normal men. Naturally, they stay <strong>with</strong>in the system of traditional<br />

relations. However, there exists this intermediate group of those who can be conscious<br />

homosexuals or bisexuals (that is, they recognize the same-sex relations as systembuilding<br />

factor), at the same time being men in the traditional sense. This third group<br />

only starts to emerge. In contrast to the first group, it is not marginal and it does not<br />

impose homosexuality. Instead, it views it as an option. And this is not a tradition, but<br />

rationally developed role.<br />

Since people tend to select like-minded persons for communication (this especially<br />

concerns communication on the basis of stigmatizing characteristics), peculiarities of<br />

the abovementioned groups will be substantially different.<br />

We should emphasize that lesbian issues continue to constitute a huge gap in Ukraine.<br />

By now there was NOT A SINGLE serious quantitative study conducted in Ukraine,<br />

dedicated to the issues of female homosexuality and behavioural practices. Several<br />

early publications, mentioned at the beginning of this section, are purely qualitative<br />

studies that reflect opinions of their authors. They cannot be considered valid for the<br />

entire country and be projected on all lesbian subgroups.<br />

1 Касянчук М., Лещинський Є.,<br />

Шеремет-Шереметьєв С. Чоловіки,<br />

що мають секс із чоловіками, у<br />

дзеркалі соціолоґічних досліджень<br />

проблеми поширення ВІЛ/СНІДу<br />

(огляд досліджень, проведених в<br />

Україні в 1997–2006 рр.) // Укр.<br />

соціум. — 2007. — №3(20). —<br />

С.32-43.<br />

2 Касянчук М., Лещинський Є.,<br />

Шеремет-Шереметьєв С. Чоловіки,<br />

що мають секс із чоловіками, у<br />

дзеркалі соціолоґічних досліджень<br />

проблеми поширення ВІЛ/СНІДу<br />

(огляд досліджень, проведених в<br />

Україні в 1997–2006 рр.) // Укр.<br />

соціум. — 2007. — №3(20). —<br />

С.32-43.<br />

3 Дієва С. В., Пашкович В.<br />

Л. Моніторинг поведінки<br />

військовослужбовців як компонент<br />

епіднагляду за ВІЛ другого<br />

покоління. Аналітичний звіт<br />

за результатами дослідження<br />

2007 року / Мін. оборони України,<br />

ТОВ “Соціс — ЦСПД”. — К.: МБФ<br />

“Міжнародний Альянс з ВІЛ/СНІД в<br />

Україні”, 2008. — 48 с.<br />

4 Моніторинг поінформованості та<br />

поведінки засуджених як компонент<br />

епіднагляду за ВІЛ другого<br />

покоління. Аналітичний звіт за результатами<br />

дослідження 2007 року<br />

/ І. Л. Демченко, К. С. Костенко,<br />

Н. Є. Кожан, С. Б. Живаго (Держ.<br />

департ. України з питань виконання<br />

покарань; Аналітичний центр<br />

“Соціоконсалтинг”); під загал. ред.<br />

І. Л. Демченко, Н. Г. Калашник. —<br />

К.: МБФ “Міжнародний Альянс з<br />

ВІЛ/СНІД в Україні”, 2008. — 60 с.<br />

5 Касянчук М. Гомосексуализм в местах<br />

не столь отдалённых: несколько<br />

интересных цифр // Симона. —<br />

2008. — №24. — С.24.<br />

6 Кухарчук Р. Медиа-холдинг “КП-<br />

Пабликейшнс” пропагандирует<br />

гомосексуализм в Украине / Сайт<br />

“Новости христианского мира”,<br />

16.07.2008, http://prochurch.info/<br />

index.php/news/print/12843<br />

7 Касянчук М. Социология Бабы-Яги<br />

или сколько голубых в Донбассе<br />

// Симона. — 2008. — №13. —<br />

С.24-25; №14. — С.24-25. —<br />

http://donbas-socproject.blogspot.<br />

com/2008/09/13-14-2008.html<br />

119

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!