17.07.2013 Views

kap. 5 - Stine Gotved

kap. 5 - Stine Gotved

kap. 5 - Stine Gotved

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

- 137 -<br />

my journal and via my online list of resources. If not, it will be my avocational duty to point out Mr.<br />

Allman's mistakes. Hence Mr. Allman has nothing to fear from me, save the truth.<br />

Jason anvender her en ekstrem høflighed, der samtidig virker som ironisk distancering - i gruppen,<br />

der normalt er på fornavn, er brugen af Mr. plus efternavn særdeles iøjenfaldende. Efter dette<br />

brev tog adskillige andre benævnelsen til sig - en indledende, symbolsk orienteret udgrænsning<br />

fra gruppens fællesskab. Donald - Mr. Allman - (290296) reagerede offensivt, med mistænkeliggørelse<br />

af andres kvalifikationer:<br />

Do any of your guys have any credentials? Tolkien was a big-shot professor, and he only got one or<br />

two words in the Oxford English Dictionary. What makes you guys so special?<br />

Peter (290296) prøvede i sit svar at mildne tonen ved endnu engang at bruge humoren:<br />

Well, *they* may not have credentials, but I got my Tolkien secret decoder ring from a box of breakfast<br />

cereal, and I passed the hobbit-backseat-driver test when I was a kid.<br />

So, I think that pretty much qualifies me for any serious discussion.<br />

Dette forsøg på at tilføre sprogkrigen lidt lethed og indirekte minde både Jason og Donald om<br />

nyhedsgruppens egalitære konstruktion lykkedes ikke, og fronterne blev trukket hårdere op i løbet<br />

af den følgende måned. Her nærmer vi os afslutningen, hvor de lingvistiske detaljer forlængst er<br />

glemt, og diskussionen for alvor er blevet personcentreret - det er stilen, der lægges vægt på nu<br />

(igen er der tale om uddrag):<br />

Donald (010496):<br />

Does 'spam' describe my books, that required labor upon labor?<br />

You have never ever seen them and you would judge this way?<br />

Do you think that this doesn't insult me?<br />

This is what I've had to put up with from day one.<br />

It's true that my ad was arrogant (not abusive), but it pales in comparision to the arrogance and abuse<br />

I've met in response.<br />

Tom (010496):<br />

Mr. Allman,<br />

Several people have tried very patiently to explain *why* your postings rub many subscribers to this<br />

group the wrong way. Your potential market is giving you some feedback.Listen to it; don't attack the<br />

messengers.<br />

Jason (040496):<br />

Mr. Allman, I have tried. I was hoping at the beginning of this that you migth find a way to fit into this<br />

newsgroup, and that you, as well as the rest of us, would benefit from the association. I still hope that.<br />

Donald (040496):

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!