31.05.2013 Views

jbgotmar

jbgotmar

jbgotmar

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

More oxford books @ www.OxfordeBook.com<br />

BIG SISTER IS WATCHING YOU 183<br />

therapy. As a condition of his therapy Rothbard was required to take the<br />

Principles of Objectivism course. He and his wife, Joey, began socializing<br />

on a regular basis with Rand and the Collective.<br />

Before long Rothbard tired of the Randian routine. He was annoyed<br />

when others questioned him after he skipped an occasional Objectivist<br />

gathering. He began to doubt Nathan’s effectiveness as a therapist, especially<br />

after Nathan criticized his marriage to Joey, a Christian. A union<br />

of two people who held confl icting premises was inherently unstable,<br />

Nathan lectured Rothbard. He should seek a partner who held rational<br />

premises instead. Still hoping that his travel phobia could be overcome,<br />

Rothbard stayed in therapy even as he wondered whether Nathan<br />

could really help him. Nathan promised the two of them would venture<br />

outside city limits together, but the trip never materialized. Meanwhile<br />

Rothbard signed up to deliver an academic paper in Georgia, believing<br />

he would be cured by the time of the conference.<br />

Instead, the academic conference became the grounds for a bitter<br />

fi nal breakup between Rothbard and the Rand circle. Tensions had<br />

been building over Rothbard’s stubborn allegiance to anarchism. After<br />

almost six months of regular contact Rand and the Collective expected<br />

Rothbard to be convinced that anarchism was unworkable. In July 1958<br />

a special Saturday night session was scheduled for Rothbard and Rand<br />

to debate. By then Rothbard had realized, “I hated the guts of [Nathan]<br />

and Ayn and the rest of the gang.” After a stormy appointment with<br />

Nathan he decided to terminate therapy and all relations with Rand’s<br />

group. The next day Nathan called to summon him to another meeting,<br />

this time with Rand alone. At issue was the paper Rothbard had written<br />

for his upcoming conference, which Nathan accused him of plagiarizing<br />

from both Rand and Barbara Branden. Outraged, Rothbard hung<br />

up the phone “on that tin Jesus.” 29 That evening’s mail brought a special<br />

delivery letter from Rand’s lawyer, outlining in detail the accusation<br />

of plagiarism and threatening a lawsuit against both Rothbard and the<br />

conference organizer, the German sociologist Helmut Schoeck.<br />

The confrontation soon spilled out into open warfare between the<br />

Collective and the Circle Bastiat. George Reisman and Robert Hessen,<br />

formerly Rothbard loyalists, took Rand’s side in the plagiarism dispute.<br />

After a tense showdown Rothbard kicked Reisman out of his apartment.<br />

Angry phone calls fl ew back and forth between Rand, Nathan,<br />

Fore more urdu books visit www.4Urdu.com

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!