Progress Amid Resistance

428 WOMEN’S RIGHTS IN THE MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICAa foreign-born woman’s Saudi citizenship upon divorce if she has retainedher original citizenship. These two amendments benefit women by lettingthem remain in the country to be near their children after being divorcedor widowed, but they also limit their future options for residence in theirhome countries by requiring renunciation of their original citizenship. 7In 2002, women were allowed to apply for their own individual civilstatus (ID) card rather than, as in the past, having a legal identity only as adependent on their guardian’s identity card. The Executive Regulation forthe Travel Documents Law states that at 15 years of age all persons mustob tain a civil status card, with the approval of their guardian. In 2008,according to the Saudi National Society for Human Rights, women forthe first time were allowed to receive their civil status cards without theirguardian’s permission. 8In practice, women in Saudi Arabia lack equal access to courts becausethey must rely on a male relative or lawyer to represent them. Many judgesarbitrarily require that before a woman may represent herself in court,a guardian must be present to verify her identity and grant her permissionto do so. Identification by a guardian is necessary because women’sfaces must be covered and judges do not accept the ID card as proof ofa woman’s identity. This is particularly detrimental in divorce and childcustody cases in which the guardian is also likely to be the husband, whois also the woman’s legal adversary. Women are at a further disadvantage inthe courts in that the testimony of one man is taken to be equal to that oftwo women, and for the purpose of compensation for accidental death orinjury, a woman’s worth is calculated at half that of a man.Access to justice for women, however, may soon improve. In 2004,a National Dialogue Conference on Women, initiated by then-CrownPrince Abdullah, recommended that women be allowed to sit as judges infamily court and that family law be standardized so that decisions are notleft to the arbitrary opinions of individual male judges. 9 That conferencehas sparked change in the judicial system, and as of 2007, three SaudiArabian educational institutions now permit women to study law. Whilewomen are currently not allowed to be judges or act as lawyers on behalfof clients in court, the Ministry of Justice announced in 2007 that it willallow women to act as legal consultants to other women. 10 The justiceminister, Dr. Abdullah bin Muhammad al-Ash-Shaikh, declared in March2008 that courts would soon have reception centers for women staffed byfemale law graduates. 11