EVALUATION

4. To what extent and under what conditions have PPPs contributed to EAFM outcomes?
Evaluability: MAYBE. No evidence-based to show achievement or measurement of indicator, i.e. sustainable livelihood. Conservation, however,
emerging results were successful, e.g. FishR. It looks like this question is being mixed up with enterprise development. While generically speaking, PPP
is targeted for both conservation and economic objectives, it may be better to evaluate it focusing on PPP strictly for conservation, for reasons
earlier cited under enterprise development (EQ5-EQ6). The recommendation is focus on conservation.
Result area: Intervention: Facilitate strategic partnerships that support EAFM
Indicator/unit Appropriateness Data Availability Data Quality Analyses Overall Remarks
Partnership
facilitated
Number
Yes
Yes
Yes. Legal partnerships
are in the form of MOAs
or any agreement mutual
to both parties. The
types of partnerships
recognized by Ecofish
may or may not have
MOA. MOAs are with
the POs.
Yes. All partnership
engagements are
recorded and analyzed
by Ecofish.
The more of these
indicators achieved by
the LGUs, the better it
is in the position of
attaining EAFM level.
Result area: Public-private partnerships support the objectives of the ECOFISH project
Indicator/unit
Appropriatenes
s
Data Availability Data Quality Analyses Overall Remarks
Evidence of
strategic
partnerships
actively engaged
and mobilized
Yes
Yes. These are forms of
partnership leading to
EAFM particularly in
reducing fishing effort.
This is well accounted
Yes. The partnerships
are identified and
included in the regular
reporting by Ecofish.
The more of these
indicators achieved by
the LGUs, the better it
is in the position of
attaining EAFM level.
Number
Yes
for by Ecofish.
Result area: Increased enforcement
Indicator/unit Appropriateness Data Availability Data Quality Analyses Overall Remarks
Number of
violations
reported
Yes
Yes. Actual numbers of
violations are not
reported by Ecofish. It
Yes. The types of
violations are considered
and are reflected in the
The more of these
indicators achieved by
the LGUs, the better
Annex 4 - 14