(SAWS) and His progeny - Islamic Books, Islamic Movies, Islamic ...
(SAWS) and His progeny - Islamic Books, Islamic Movies, Islamic ...
(SAWS) and His progeny - Islamic Books, Islamic Movies, Islamic ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
The very first reason to reject the tradition(s) of Ikrima is based on the fact that he<br />
was Kharijite. Secondly his being a Kharijite, he even justified the killings of the fellow<br />
Muslim(s).<br />
Moreover, on the authority of Ibn al-Musayyab (RA) that he said to his slave in reply:<br />
Do not fabricate the story on anyone, <strong>and</strong> do not lie the way Ikrima lied on Ibn Abbas<br />
(RA). And Ikrima also narrated from Ibn Umar (RA), about that said to Nafa: Nothing<br />
was authentic.<br />
1) Meezan al-Aitdaal V5, P.119<br />
2) Tahzib al-Tahzib, V7, P.267<br />
Yahya said about Ikrama that he was a liar. Upon being asked about Hadrat Ikrima,<br />
Hadrat Muhammed ibn Sireen (RA) said: He was a liar.<br />
� Meezan al-Aitdaal V5, P.117<br />
Hadrat Ikrima is even reported to have been punished by Hadrat Ali Ibn Abdullah Ibn<br />
Abbas (RAA) as it has been reported from Jarir <strong>and</strong> he from Yezid bin Abi Ziyad that<br />
Abdullah Ibn Harith narrated:<br />
I once went to Ali Ibn Abdullah Ibn Abbas (RA), <strong>and</strong> I got stunned to have seen that<br />
Ikrama had been tied to the rest room. Having seen this I said to 'Ali bin Abdullah (RA):<br />
Is this how you treat your slaves, thereupon he replied: Ikrama associates many lies to my<br />
father i.e Ibn Abbas (RA).<br />
62<br />
1) Tahdhib al-Tahdhib, by Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani, V7, P.268<br />
2) Meezan al-Aitdaal V5, P.117<br />
Finally,as reported by Hafiz Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani (RA) that "Ikrima even criticized<br />
<strong>and</strong> blamed the Holy Prophet (<strong>SAWS</strong>) that He (<strong>SAWS</strong>) married Hadrat Maimoona (RA)<br />
despite the fact that He (<strong>SAWS</strong>) was a mahram to her".<br />
� Tahdhib al-Tahdhib, by Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani, V7, P.268<br />
At this point, it would be nice to quote another report which is also falsely attributed to<br />
Ibn Abbas (RA):<br />
Second chain of the narrators, who related that this verse (33:33) had been<br />
revealed for the wives of the Holy Messenger of Allah (<strong>SAWS</strong>) i.e. Ummhat ul-<br />
Momineen (RAA)<br />
Reported by traditionalists on the authority of Abul Qasim Abdurrahman Bin<br />
Muhammad al-Siraj through Muhammad Ibn Yaqub, through Hasan Ibn Ali Ibn<br />
Affan through Abu Yahya al-Hamani through Saleh Ibn Musa al-Qurshi through
Change language